Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. Today I'm joined by Kit England, a senior climate adaptation specialist at Paul Watkiss Associates. 0:24 Kit has developed and implemented adaptation policies and projects at the local, national, and supranational scale. 0:30 One of his most recent contributions being Pathways to Resilience, an EU program focused on preparing and supporting regions when drafting their climate resilience plans. 0:40 We talk about the EU's mission-based approach to adaptation and resilience planning, his history working on building resilience at the city level, and what lessons companies and other organizations can learn from adaptation initiatives in the public sector. 0:52 Before we get started, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 0:58 Listeners like you can help support my coverage of adaptation and resilience by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade. 1:05 You'll get two newsletters a week, access to exclusive data dashboards and special reports, including the new Adaptation 10 series, a collaboration with the adaptation consultancy DSR and partners. 1:15 Thank you for the support. Okay, in a minute my interview with Kit, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:23 [swoosh] In finance, the fallout from Hurricane Beryl has led Caribbean leaders to call for increased climate finance to help them rebuild and increase resilience against future climate shocks. 1:32 Beryl, the first storm of the Atlantic hurricane season, and the earliest on record to strengthen to a category five, swept through Grenada and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines on July the 1st before advancing in a weakened state to the Gulf of Mexico and Texas. 1:46 Catastrophe risk modeling firm Karen Clark & Co. estimates that privately insured losses from Hurricane Beryl will be close to $510 million in the Caribbean, though uninsured losses are likely to be much greater. 1:57 Dickon Mitchell, Prime Minister of Grenada, said, "There is no economy in those parts of the islands hit by the storm," and that the government would have to feed the population for the next six months. 2:07 The United Nations initiated a $9 million response to the disaster, however, Mitchell said the payouts represented just a drop of what is needed. 2:16 [swoosh] In policy, the US Federal Emergency Management Agency, FEMA, has put in place a new rule ensuring that climate-driven flood risks are taken into account when it comes to rebuilding schools, hospitals, and other public infrastructure following natural catastrophes. 2:30 The federal Flood Risk Management Standard requires construction projects paid for out of FEMA funds to either withstand or avoid flood risks. 2:38 The rule expands the definition of floodplain to account for the increased height and width of floods expected in the near future, with the hope being that fewer taxpayer-financed buildings will be washed away once rebuilt. 2:50 The rule enters into effect on September the 9th. 2:53 [swoosh] And in tech, investment firm Climate Adaptive Infrastructure announced $100 million equity commitment to Upwell Water, a tech-powered water resource and infrastructure company based in San Francisco. 3:05 Upwell Water is a developer, owner, and operator of water supply, treatment, and utility assets around the world, using technology to inform system upgrades and to ensure they have the expertise and capital needed to thrive. 3:17 CAI's equity injection will support Upwell with the sustainable management of water resources in structurally water deficient or under-resourced areas. 3:26 CAI raised $1 billion in 2022 to invest in large scale, low carbon real assets in the clean water, energy, and urban infrastructure sector. [swoosh] Right, that's this week's roundup. Now on to our interview. 3:38 [upbeat music] Hi, Kit. Thanks for joining us today. Where are you calling from, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. Really great to be with you. 3:47 I'm joining you from sunny Carlisle in the northwest of England, and I am a senior climate adaptation specialist at the research consultancy Paul Watkiss Associates. I've been here for about a year. 3:58 We're a small little firm that advises clients on climate risk assessment, adaptation planning, decision-making, and finance and economics. The firm's been going for about sort of over 20 years now. 4:09 I joined last year, but prior to that, I've worked in a range of different roles in the public sector on climate change and particularly on adaptation planning as well. Thanks, Kit. 4:18 Yes, great that you could be here today. 4:20 I found you via LinkedIn, like I've found many of my climate proofers, and you have very much been at the heart of a lot of the policy-making process, it seems, and devising ideas to bring adaptation and resilience to local governments and communities, which is what we're here to talk about today. 4:36 So my first question for you is, because you have this rich history working with local governments and cities to create and implement adaptation plans, I was wondering if you could tell us a little bit about your work in the area and any lessons that could help with scaling adaptation planning across localities. 4:52 Absolutely. There are three maybe takeaways that I would, I would bring, and I guess the first is that too often we're still seeing adaptation framed as an environmental issue, and it really shouldn't be. 5:02 So quite a lot of people, if you think about the sort of hierarchy of things to care about if you work in sustainability, you've sort of got, at the top you've got carbon and emissions and things, and then you've got a range of other sort of sustainability issues. 5:15 And then everybody used to get to adaptation last 'cause it used to be the sort of Cinderella. 5:20 And I think partly that's a reflection of where people used to be, I guess, and the amount of different responsibilities they had. 5:28 I think it's partly because it's in the Paris Agreement, and it's been framed as the, the sort of sister to mitigation. 5:34 And mitigation, although you can argue now it's very much a mainstream corporate issue, it, you know, it used to be in the environmental box rather than in the heart of, of what companies did and governments did. 5:46 I think framing that as an economic issue rather than an environmental one is really, really important. Extreme weather and climate change are, is much broader. 5:54 It's, you know, it's not just about hitting a single number on emissions and you... some technology options, but it's much more fundamental, like where are our places? You know, how are they set out? 6:04 Are they gonna still be in that space given the changing climate? How do we plan our land allocations? How do we look after one another in society? 6:11 You know, some very, very big-Big questions within that and too often climate change and extreme weather now is stopping us, or it's making it harder to hit our policy goals. 6:22 If economic growth matters to you, climate change and extreme weather disrupts productivity, it disrupts supply chains. 6:29 The things that we work really hard, and you think governments put so much effort into generating growth. 6:35 Think of all the news headlines you see on BBC News or whatever about the growth numbers and the attention that we give to it. You know, climate change has the potential to hit those. 6:43 If you try to deliver health policy and you've got waiting lists and poor health outcomes, then again, overheating hospitals makes that harder. Hospitals flooding makes that harder. 6:54 So we're seeing all these kinds of these issues, and I think the penny's starting to finally drop, but that was the first thing. 7:01 I think the second is that we shouldn't just be limited by thinking about what risks are and then addressing those. 7:08 So that's what the sort of traditional planning cycle says is think about what risks climate change poses to your organization and then take some action to mitigate those risks. 7:17 And that's all great, but it sort of closes off a lot of options about a better future and what the world could look like. That's the second and then the third is around building on what's gone before. 7:27 So we have a huge knowledge around how to do this well. 7:32 The recent influx of standards and focuses on climate risks from the financial sector is great, but it sort of missed all of the capacity building, the knowledge that's happened in all of the adaptation space by the IPCC and others beforehand. 7:46 And, you know, we really need to build on that. And here in the UK, we used to have, um, something called the UK Climate Impact Program. 7:52 We used to have regional climate change partnerships and a sort of advice service for businesses as well. And all of that has gone and we've sort of seen it... 8:00 I, I'm not gonna sort of stand on my soapbox and complain, but what you start to see with that is that's a strategic capability for countries. 8:08 And once you start to lose that, the structure of the process, um, falls down a little bit and it's very inefficient. There's a lot to be said for learning on what's gone before. 8:17 And Scotland and Wales and Northern Ireland have those kinds of programs. 8:20 You know, they fund capacity building programs which support public sector decision makers and the private sector to kind of help build their capabilities and then kind of deliver on adaptation planning. 8:30 So I guess those are my three takeaways. It's not an environmental issue, it's an economic one. 8:35 Don't limit yourself to thinking about what the problems are, but think about what the future could be and then build on what's gone before and use the best of it and evolve things. Fantastic. 8:45 Thank you for that rundown, Kit. I appreciate it. And what just has struck me over the last few months of doing this podcast is just how cross-cutting and wide-ranging adaptation is. 8:54 As you said, it has to be thought of beyond environment, even beyond disaster management. 8:58 And there's so much more possibility when you think about adaptation as a way to enhance economic opportunity, health outcomes, social cohesion, and I know that you've been involved in projects big and small that focus on those areas. 9:11 And in fact, I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about your experience with Climate Ready Clyde and how that experience has kind of informed how you think about adaptation today. 9:20 Yeah, I mean, so Climate Ready Clyde was a project, um, and well still is, still a project run by a little sustainability charity based in Scotland called Sniffer. 9:29 Um, and what it has sought to do was bring together a range of different partners from the public sector and the private sector and the third sector to collaborate on producing a regional adaptation strategy and action plan. 9:42 And I, I joined Sniffer. I was there for about five years. Great organization. They run the capability program for Scottish Government, so that capacity building program we talked about. 9:52 But they also have these stream of regional climate change partnerships, and they had started with Edinburgh and with Glasgow, and now they're sort of starting to expand over Scotland. 10:02 We sort of made the case for a set of organizations, and it became about 15 in the end to co-fund a regional climate change partnership, which kind of s- looked at assessing the risks, but then also developed this transformational adaptation strategy and action plan. 10:17 And it came from a couple of realizations, which is that no man's an island when it comes to adaptation, right? 10:22 And when it comes to climate risks, because if you're in a corporate, your ability to manage your risks really depends on how resilient your local infrastructure is. 10:30 Or if you're in a local government, then it's also about what the transport sector's doing or the public transport bodies are doing because it's about whether your employees can get to work or not. 10:39 And so if you're a householder or you're a parent, it's really about whether your childcare is open or your kid's school is open and they can get to school. 10:46 So, you know, all of those risks that come from climate change are really interdependent, cross-cutting, and there's a really strong role for local government not to just be thought of in the service delivery kind of space, but also as that kind of steward of local places. 11:01 So, you know, re- local authorities and regions and things have those dual roles. You know, one is about, okay, yes, they deliver services, but then the other is about a stewarding role. 11:10 And so they co-funded in Glasgow, the partners co-funded a couple of sort of, uh, posts and to run this partnership, and we had this process together where we assessed the risks of climate change, and then we sort of developed an adaptation strategy and action plan. 11:24 But we were really fortunate that sort of about halfway through the process, we secured a fairly large grant from EIT Climate-KIC, who is sort of Europe's innovation organization, to look at developing something more ambitious. 11:37 So they had this Forging Resilient Regions program, and Glasgow joined along with the Dolomites in Italy and Nouvelle-Aquitaine in France and, um, Andalusia in Spain. 11:48 Climate-KIC co-funded the region to develop a range of more ambitious methods for adaptation planning. 11:54 There's a lot of debate in the literature about what's incremental adaptation and what's transformational adaptation, but fundamentally, incremental is that bit one we were talking about before about, well, what are your risks and how do we keep the system the same? 12:07 And transformational is more about, okay, how do we change land use systems? How do we change transport systems that produce more resilient outcomes? 12:15 So Climate-KIC was really, really forward-thinking and funded us to, to pilot a range of different tools and methods. 12:21 So we piloted this kind of process for visioning of what a, a region that flourished in its future climate would look like, and what are the changes we would need to make to get there.We also piloted things like a social impact assessment. 12:35 We looked at the role of innovation and what a portfolio of innovation might look like for the region to help us reach that goal, and we also did a financing plan. 12:43 And then the strategy itself was very much more ambitious than your typical adaptation strategy as well. So we were really fortunate there to, to do that. 12:51 And I guess in a lot of ways, that set the precedent, although we were building on things that others had done as well. But that's kind of what we were doing in, in Glasgow. 12:59 So I really encourage people to go and have a look online. There's the website there with all the resources on as well, so, uh, worth checking out anyway. 13:06 Yes, I do encourage people to check out that project, and I think some of the things you said there are, are indicative of how the adaptation debate has moved on somewhat, and I particularly like this distinction you make between incremental and transformative change. 13:22 And my next question I wanna ask about essentially these different approaches to integrating adaptation in local governments and local regions. 13:30 There's this mission-based approach we've heard a lot about in the European context, and now I believe also in the UK context now with the new labor government. 13:39 So I was wondering if you could talk to us a little bit about this EU mission on climate adaptation, what it actually means, and what your work has been with that mission through the Pathways to Resilience project you spearhead. 13:51 So can you talk a little bit more about that, please? Yeah. Ab- absolutely. 13:55 So the EU mission on adaptation is really a, a kind of initiative by the commission to try and scale up this amount and the ambition of adaptation planning in Europe, with a particular focus on 150 regions. 14:10 So it's funded through the European, uh, Research Innovation Program, Horizon, and it's funding a whole range of different projects. 14:18 So Pathways to Resilience, um, i- which is one of the flagship projects for the mission, is the one that I'm involved in. But there are a wide range of others. 14:26 So on finance, there's also one called ClimateFIT, Climate Financing and Investment Task Forces. But there's also a range of, of, of others that are focusing on different elements of adaptation. 14:36 The mission has these three objectives. One is about sort of a baseline level of capability for all regions in Europe. The second is the kind of the advancing the ambition of 150 to be climate resilient by 2030. 14:48 And then the other is kind of demonstrating new solutions. So there's kind of... It goes deeper. 14:53 You know, as the, as the ambition gets greater, there's a deeper focus, but it's also slightly narrow, so the number of regions are slightly less. 15:00 And the idea around the sort of mission-based approach is that you set this bold societal goal, and then you use your sort of research and innovation money, um, to catalyze wider investment and to bring together new solutions and new approaches. 15:14 We're encouraging people to be bold and to try things. 15:17 And Pathways to Resilience, the big thing that we're trying to do, we're supporting 100 regions to develop a climate resilient strategy and an investment plan as well. 15:27 And so it's building on the model that we had in Glasgow and in the demonstration project. So we're trying to make sure that those strategies are transformative. 15:36 We, we're setting out like a common method for str- planning your adaptation strategy and also developing your investment plan. 15:45 But more importantly as well, we're providing regions with grants, so most of the money for Pathways to Resilience is not being kept by the technical partners. It's being given away. 15:54 Each region gets 200,000 euros to participate in the program and to carry out the development of a strategy and an investment plan, and it also receives a range of, uh, training and capability building and tools and support to help them do it. 16:09 And there aren't conditions attached to that 200,000? You're not dictating how they should come up with an adaptation plan. It's more like, "Here's the money. This is the objective. You find your way to get there." 16:19 We've got a method. So we are, you know, we're trying to, um... It's called the Regional Resilience Journey, and it maps out the key stages, and the same with the investment plan. We have an adaptation investment cycle. 16:30 We're advocating for regions to follow that, but we're not being prescriptive about exactly what they do with their finance because actually each region will be at a different starting point with a different level of knowledge and experience and context and will have different capabilities and, and competencies too. 16:44 So, you know, the money is there to supplement that and make sure that it goes towards the, the kind of, the most effective way to get them to the outcome, rather than to be very prescriptive about you have to spend it on this and this and the other. 16:58 Obviously, within the EU rules. I'm intrigued by this mission-based approach to, to policymaking and to adaptation in particular because, on the one hand, it seems kind of diametrically opposed to the 17:11 sort of corporate smart targets approach where everything is very discrete, incremental, measured, targeted, up the yin yang. 17:19 And the mission-based approach is more aspirational and more accepting of the fact that there are multiple ways to build resilience and a- to adaptation. 17:27 But then my worry is that by leaving it open-ended, you could have regions without proper guidance kind of going down dead ends, coming up with ideas that won't actually work, [chuckles] uh, or letting too many cooks spoil the broth, so to say, right, by bringing in too many outside consultants or stakeholders. 17:43 So I'm wondering how you think of that, that tension and whether it's right to think of mission approaches opposed to smart target approach, or whether the two are actually more compatible than I've made it out to be. 17:54 So I think they're probably more compatible than you made it out to be. Having a mission-based approach doesn't mean you don't manage it. In fact, it's probably the opposite actually. 18:02 You've got to do more management to look at the range of different projects that you're funding, and then how well we're delivering and where there's promise and where there's not. 18:11 Across the suite of projects, there's two levels. 18:13 One is that the European Commission is funding a suite of different research and innovation projects all aimed at the same outcome but all trying different ways to get there. 18:22 But in funding that set of programs, there are a set of calls, and there's a set of criteria that you have to hit, and... Do you know what I mean? So there- there's... 18:31 The innovationI guess the way of thinking about it is like bounded innovation, right? You know, there are some rules of the game, there are some criteria, there's some, some clear targets around what you have to achieve. 18:41 But the thing is, you have to then watch how the projects do and try and pick winners. And I guess that's the same with any company, right? 18:48 Once you get through to delivery side of things, everything is, is kind of, um, very well managed. 18:53 But in the early days of developing a product or a service, if you don't do the primary research, if you don't have people to give space to try new things, then nothing new ever happens. 19:02 So there's a tension there, but you have to manage that as a process. 19:05 So the kind of the challenge, I guess, around this, not for the projects, but for the commission, is around looking at that portfolio of projects and stewarding it in a way that actually picks the best of what's achieved in some projects and take the learning from those things where you fail, and then use that to take you further. 19:24 The sort of analogy that's often banded around is around the moon landings. You know, we went from not knowing how to land on the moon to land on the moon in ten years flat, right? 19:32 And that's a massive, massive challenge. But it... we wouldn't have got there if we just kept trying the things that we already knew, you know? 19:39 So everyone has to have a sort of license to operate a little bit, but also ma- carefully managed so that you're still getting good value for public money, and you're still focused on delivering what the ul-ultimate goal is, right? 19:53 So I guess that's the challenge for anyone who's working on a mission project is to, on the one hand, you have the ambition of the mission, and on the other hand is you have a legally negotiated contract about what your objectives have to be and what you have to deliver. 20:07 And so there's always a bit of a tension there, but I think it's a healthy one that, you know, as long as you're alive to, it's not too bad. Yes. 20:15 Governments are sometimes reluctant to give away too much control and to allow other actors to kind of innovate. 20:21 But when you have a challenge like climate change, and we know the goal is to adapt and strengthen our societies, that's, that's the goal, that's the moon landing, so to say. 20:31 But actually, there are so many different ways to get there because there are so many different aspects of climate risks that need to be protected against, and we're not entirely sure maybe yet how we can bring synergies in terms of different solutions, what the best approach is to building resilience, uh, against floods, against storms, et cetera, what those will be. 20:49 So it does make sense to have this more innovative, almost entrepreneurial approach, which I think is why adaptation is, is an attractive area for, for people who want to get involved in policy, but also who want to get involved in, in business and, and technology, because there's so many different problems to be solved, and there's actually no real consensus yet about how the best way to, to achieve, uh, adaptation resilience is. 21:11 I mean, if you think about going back 20 years when we were arguing about renewables, there was a lot of discussion about are wind turbines gonna really work, and are we gonna be able to scale them? 21:20 You know, on solar panels, are, you know, are we ever gonna get the cost down quickly enough, and are they ever gonna be viable? That's sort of where I feel we are on the adaptation side. 21:29 You know, there's been a lot of work and there's been lots of research. We need adaptation now, but the big risks only really occur post 2050s. 21:37 We're really at the sort of foothills of what we're gonna need to do rather than at the summit, you know? So I think that's okay, but I think we have to... it's useful to draw that context of where we are. 21:48 And I guess one of the things that hopefully the mission will do is pull us forward a little bit to be nearer to mainstream, nearer to, yeah, nearer to the st- you know, status quo of, of, of things. 21:59 And talking about management and coordination, you were at this EU Mission on Climate Adaptation forum in May, I believe, and there was plenty of discussion there about the importance of collaboration across and between different levels of government. 22:12 And I do think one of the big issues that was raised by delegates in a poll at that forum was that, yes, getting the different levels of government, local, regional, national, European to coordinate is, is a challenge. 22:25 So I'm wondering from your experience so far, like is coordination a problem, and what actions or policies could solve this issue? So I mean, it's... 22:33 I was thinking about this one a little bit, and I guess coordination's not really the problem when it comes to what's happening, right? Everybody knows each other. 22:42 You know, the coordination between different people is fairly okay. I think what's interesting is there is a need for more collaboration across sectors and also at different levels of government. 22:55 So we have a horrible phrase for it called multi-level governance. But there is a need for, for more of that. 23:01 And I think it's more important for adaptation because the responsibilities for managing those risks sit with different levels of government. 23:07 So if you think about a place, you know, you might have a local set of flood risk, but actually the standards for buildings on flooding are set at a national level. 23:16 You know, so if you wanna change things, then you need action at, at different levels. And the problem is that that risk is distributed differentially across places. 23:25 If you take the UK, for example, what's important to Glasgow might not be important to London. And if you think about London, London's, you know, got a very big heat risk, whereas Glasgow's got a very big water risk. 23:36 And so if you're in government, you're gonna hear two different messages from two, from two different people, and you've got to think about how do you manage that. So it is very challenging. 23:45 But I guess the, the thing where I would say coordination is a problem is not so much about what's happening, it's about what needs to happen. 23:52 So everyone is, I suppose, clear that there's probably not enough money in the system to adapt to climate change, right? And that's gonna need more public money, and it's also going to need private money as well. 24:04 And the challenge with that is that, well, we're still in our infancy of working out what we need to do, but once we start to get clear about what it is we need to do, you then start to have to intervene. 24:16 If you really want the private sector to do things on adapting to climate change, if governments want that to happen, then they're going to have to be much clearer about what the goals are and how they get the private sector to do those things, which inevitably means either some kinds of incentives to make it make financial sense, or it means policy and regulation. 24:35 That-I think is challenging because-- and that's where the coordination really becomes a problem. 24:40 Because, for example, if you wanted to do a green roof subsidy in a city, most of the time the kind of subsidies and incentives aren't controlled by cities, they're controlled by national governments. 24:50 And so you either have to give powers down to the city level to let them do that and then pay for it out of their own budgets, or you have to run it as a national program and then that becomes a budget line in a government program. 25:03 So that's where the tensions start to come out, because if governments' budgets are already tight, they don't want to allocate new money. 25:10 But actually, at the same time, they want to achieve these policy ambitions, increasing resilience. 25:14 And the kind of the barriers mean that that's not gonna happen just autonomously, until the risk level gets far too high anyway. 25:21 So I think the coordination point is everyone is pretty well coordinated, but when you start talking about the big steps that we need to make, the coordination... 25:31 It's not that there's no coordination, it's that there's a very, there's a sort of general disagreement about what ought to happen and how we ought to pay for it and things like that. 25:39 What's so interesting about what you just said is that it kind of aligns with some of my thoughts I've been having recently about how climate change could alter political economy in a certain way. 25:49 And, and in Europe and in the UK, there's been this trend towards devolution, right, over the last twenty, thirty years, let's say. 25:56 But with climate risks, they're so vast and all-encompassing, it's like you do need central government to dole out the money, right? 26:03 But in terms of, like, how different areas are going to respond to those climate risks and what their needs are gonna be, they are kind of local devolved issues. 26:10 But it feels to me there's this tension because the central government's got the resources, the money, and the regulatory power, but the local governments are the ones who know best what needs to happen in their area. 26:19 And I'm wondering if that is gonna create a tension and whether we're actually gonna see more centralization over the next twenty, thirty years because federal governments and national governments are gonna be the only ones with the budgets able to sort of bail out towns and cities when they get hit by extreme weather events. 26:34 So I'm wondering if you've thought anything about that. Oh, I think about it all the time. That's, that's- Good. I'm not crazy. [laughs] But no, no, no, not, not at all. 26:42 I th-- but I think what I would say is, I think there's actually multiple ways that you can do it. I think you have to be willing to have the conversation. 26:49 There's a really important role for national government because it's fairly reasonable to have an expectation that you have a standard of protection that's pretty similar across all parts of a country, right? 26:59 And as you say, government set the rules of the game and the standards and things on that. But equally, local places know what needs to happen, and we do it quite well on flooding in the current arrangements. 27:09 Where in the UK, for example, there's a national budget for flood risk management, but then it gets managed through the Environment Agency and then distributed out to local government as they develop their projects and their plans, right? 27:22 So, you know, that arrangement works quite well now. And through Pathways to Resilience and what we did in Glasgow, you are developing a pipeline of bankable projects. 27:32 So you, you know, as a region, you work out what you need to pay for for adaptation, and then that gives you a bit of a, not a shopping list to go to government, because government doesn't need to fund everything, but it gives you a clear, considered view about what you need to pay for and the best potential ways to pay for it to allow you to be informed in that debate with government about what you want. 27:53 And then that gives government a general picture as well about what's gonna happen. And I guess this is where the link is through to disclosures and the work that the private sector's doing as well. 28:03 You also need a sense of what the private sector is doing and is going to do, and at the moment, we don't have that. 28:08 So, you know, this, what the private sector will do is different to what the societal goals need to be and what governments set in their sort of societal goals, but you also need that picture as well. 28:18 And that's also why government has a big role too, right? It's around setting the rules of the game to make sure that there's good flows of information and things too. 28:26 That leads really well to my next question, actually, which is whether there are any lessons from the local government adaptation planning world that can be translated to corporate and financial institution context, right? 28:39 'Cause I write a lot about companies and, and banks who are trying to get their head, heads around adaptation. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Absolutely. 28:47 There's quite a few, and I appreciate the contexts are different, but I guess the point is that the adaptation planning process is quite transferable. 28:54 So there's a sort of normal cycle that says, "Get ready to do some adaptation planning, engage your, you know, the people, and get some permission to do it. 29:03 Assess your climate change risks, assess some options, you know, develop a strategy and a plan, and implement them and learn." 29:11 So there's a sort of traditional cycle, and that's just as true for a corporate or a, for a, for a business as it is for a, for a public sector, but what they do is very different. 29:20 So, you know, you go through in a corporate setting, you look at what your risks are to different bits of the business and the different functions that you have. 29:28 I wrote a guide, actually, myself and Ellie Murtagh, um, from the British Red Cross, wrote a guide for the Institute for Environmental Management and Assessment on how to do that for businesses, actually. 29:37 So that, that process is, is common. And I guess the other thing that's quite transferable are the sort of rules of thumb around what makes sense to do now. 29:46 So when we talk about adaptation, this, the, is plagued by something called deep uncertainty, which there's a lot of literature out there on it, but in, in essence, what it boils down to is that there's no way you're ever gonna be able to predict what the future is in terms of climate change. 30:01 You've got some knowledge, and it can help you, but you need to have lots of discussions in your organization and come to a potential view on what the right options to take are in the context of where you are, and you focus on being robust. 30:15 And there's some learning from that, which is that you need to think about not just the timing of the climate risk, but also the timing of the decision and the type of decision that you're taking. 30:24 So, um, from this, there's a little framework and we put it in the... We adapted it and put it in the primer that we wrote for the Transition Plan Task Force on preparing for your disclosures on adaptation. 30:36 Um, but it sort of says there's three buckets of types of options that you want to think about. So there's sort of no and low regret options, which are things that deliver benefits under the current climate. 30:46 So if your factory gets flooded now, then it's only gonna get bigger in future, so you might as well start preparing for it now, and that's gonna deliver you benefits now and in the future climate. 30:55 There's things where you've got very long-term decisions which potentially locks in risk, and you ought to think about those. 31:00 So, like, when you're investing in new facilities or premises or those kinds of things-Think decisions that are very hard to then undo, right? 31:08 So if you move a head office somewhere, and you've moved there because you've got the right workforce or you've got the right capabilities, then actually that's a very big, difficult decision to move once you've done it. 31:18 Or if you're in the steel industry and you've invested in electric arc furnaces, it's not a decision you're gonna wanna walk away from very lightly. 31:25 And then the last is around the value of knowledge and starting to kind of think about where you've got long-term risks to the business, but you don't need to act yet. 31:32 So thinking about what research, what evidence do I need to help us to be a bit more adaptive in future and, and adjust as the risks kind of come through. So those are very transferable. 31:43 I think the other thing that's really important, we've seen a bit of a rush to focus on physical risk and global warming levels in risk assessments. 31:52 And global warming levels are great for policy decisions like in the IPCC where they... and, and the Paris Agreement, where they're saying, "Well, how bad is it if we get to two degrees? Do we really... 32:02 Are we gonna let that happen, or are we gonna go for one and a half degrees?" But for practical adaptation planning, it's really challenging because they don't have any sense of time. 32:13 So they start with what does the impact at two degrees mean, and then you have to work out when that's going to be. The logic is the slightly the wrong way around. 32:21 The climate models tell you, "This is what happens at two degrees," and then you read off what time period that is. 32:27 The RCPs, this is a bit technical, but the RCPs, the, the kind of climate scenarios the IPCC uses, are really helpful for adaptation planning 'cause they give you a time and a range of uncertainty. 32:38 So if you're in a organization, you've got to make decisions today or you've got a corpor- a business plan for the next five years. 32:44 You need to know, what do I invest in today over the next five-year period that takes me to be well prepared for a possible future? 32:53 And so that's the kind of benefit is that if you link the kind of the risk assessment and the thinking about the urgency of those risks to the sort of building blocks for adaptation, then that could be really, really powerful and lets businesses get off really, really quickly. 33:08 Excellent. Yes, there's been a lot of focus on exactly when certain climate impacts are gonna manifest and, and how severe they will be. 33:16 And of course, businesses want that certainty, and the scientists say, "Well, it's not that simple. Uh, we don't have that crystal ball." 33:22 But there is this desire for, for metrics and targets, right, that businesses can kind of align themselves to, and the IPCC has obviously kind of looked to for, for some of that. 33:32 But I also believe that the UN is also looked at to provide some of these adaptation metrics and indicators. 33:39 So there is this body of work going on under the global goal of adaptation to develop adaptation indicators and metrics, and I'm following that quite closely 'cause I think it could help direct financing at a country level, at least, to, to important adaptation priorities. 33:53 But I'm wondering, at a local level, are there similar common indicators that could be used to compare and contrast adaptation across regions? 33:59 And who's coming up with these and, and what do you think their progress should be? Yeah, I mean, I think... So this is a really great question. It's interesting. 34:08 So the global goal on adaptation is great, and it's got seven or eight goals that countries are aiming at. And I guess there's a challenge for governments to think about which ones are most relevant, right? 34:18 So it, it's a bit like on mitigation, you've got the concept of common but differentiated responsibilities. 34:24 So, you know, there's a question about everyone needs to reduce emissions, but how much do you reduce your emissions by, and by when? 34:31 And sort of on resilience, you know, there's a lot of wiggle room in the global goal because it specifies what you want by 2030, but it doesn't say sort of what standards and where. 34:43 So everyone can agree on the, the words that ended up in the, in the global goal around things like, you know, increasing the resilience of infrastructure and human settlements to climate change impacts. 34:52 You know, nobody would disagree with that. But are, are we talking about a one in a 200-year flood, or are we talking about a one in 50-year flood? Those are, those are very big differences. 35:02 And I think it's a challenge n-not just for, for the UNFCCC and for kind of the UN processes, but it's a challenge for everyone, right? 35:09 And it's not a easy one for policymakers because inevitably, once you start being more specific, it can be really helpful because everyone knows what you're aiming at, but it also creates winners and losers, right? 35:22 The moment that you say, "We're going to make sure everyone is resilient to a one in 200-year flood event," the person with a one in 201 year flood will say, "Well, what about me?" 35:33 You know, so those people who are at a high level of risk will lose out. So understandably, people are very reluctant to say that. 35:41 But it, it's sort of you need that level of definition to then think about, okay, what do we actually need to achieve, and then who pays for that and who does it? 35:51 So I think that's the sort of r- next level down of the global goal, and it's also for cities and regions to do as well. And if we're being honest, they haven't really thought about that. 36:02 So the way that lots of the public sector thinks about things is through outcomes and outputs. They recognize that they have an influence on, but don't completely deliver outcomes. 36:14 So if you think about an outcome being a healthy population, you know, local government or local health services aren't completely in control of that. 36:21 You know, what people choose to buy at the supermarket, whether exposed to secondhand smoke, all those kinds of things play into it. 36:28 But what they can d- focus on is the outputs, which is how many s-stop smoking workshops have we delivered or how many dental treatments have we done or whatever. I don't know. I'm sorry, I'm not... 36:37 I've perhaps picked a bad example. But I think that's kind of also what we have to do in the adaptation space. 36:44 The outcomes piece is much harder, as I say, 'cause it creates winners and losers, but we also don't have huge amounts of scrutiny and delivery on the outputs yet. 36:53 You know, so y-you know, programs about, well, how many hectares of nature-based solutions have you delivered in your city or region, or how many buildings have you retrofitted to withstand a 40-degree heat wave, those kinds of things. 37:06 Um, we're not quite there yet. We'll get there. I think we'll definitely, we'll definitely get there. And I think the societal goals debate can only really happen, I think, when disclosures kick in. 37:16 Because once disclosures kick in, you'll really start to get a measure ofWhat will the private sector deliver and how far does that take you to what you want to achieve as a society? 37:26 We haven't really done that bit yet or tried, so I think it's... I, I feel a bit harsh saying, "Well, there's a big challenge that we're shying away from on the outcomes." 37:34 I think you sort of, you do need to get a sense of what the private sector might be prepared to do or is planning to do as well before you can have that discussion. Mm. Absolutely. 37:42 I think it's another source of tension, right? 37:45 You have the desire to create standards and to have metrics and targets, but then there's also the danger that once you put those out in the world, that all solutions as well sort of migrate to that, right? 37:56 And I think about the mitigation space once net zero became a corporate priority. Net zero was kind of at the corporate level quickly construed to be, "Okay, we need to reduce our emissions X amount." 38:07 And then all the solutions became about how do you measure your emissions, how to reduce your emissions, and I feel we lost out a little bit in terms of, like, nature-based solutions and thinking more broadly about the just transition because everything got very focused on just that one metric. 38:21 So I see the danger of it also happening in the adaptation space. But also, again, coming back to the mission approach, you also don't want things to be so loose that people just go down blind alleys. Yeah. 38:33 No, absolutely, and I think that's the line that everyone has to walk now over the next sort of 5 to 10 years is how do you be specific enough that it directs activity but how do you avoid being so specific that it closes off potential other solutions or pathways or... 38:49 You know, there's a, there's a risk, for example, that we just focus on things the market will pay for and then the problem with that is that, you know, it won't pay for things like capacity building or more transformational adaptation. 39:00 That's not something that's got a revenue stream and there's no business in that. But it could be really, really fundamental. 39:06 This is kind of where the disclosures will help the conversation, um, and then there's a kind of big conversation to be had about what the goals are and how we get there and then who pays for that as well. 39:18 You know, that's the, that's the other side of that. Wonderful. Well, thanks for answering those questions, Kit. 39:23 My last one to you is one I ask all my climate proofers and that is what are you working on over the next 12 months? What's got you excited? 39:30 I mean, I g- I guess the thing that's really exciting at the moment is the, um, support to our 100 regions for Pathways to Resilience. 39:38 So we have closed our first call for regions, and we have just selected our first 40, and we're in the process of finalizing those. 39:45 So we can't say anything more about that, but that will be announced in the autumn, which is very exciting. The plan is for them to all come together in the autumn in October. That's gonna be really exciting. 39:54 Starting the training, starting training them and starting working on their investment plans is gonna be really exciting, so we're really looking forward to that. Um- [laughs]... 40:02 I guess the other one is, um, in a personal capacity, I sit on, um, the UK Green Taxonomy Advisory Group for adaptation. Oh, cool. 40:10 So been working on kind of defining some of that, so I think that will be really exciting. And then I, I guess PWA also is heavily involved in the UNEP Adaptation Gap Report as well. So we do the finance chapter on that. 40:25 Paul really leads it, but I'm d- involved a little bit this year, so it's really exciting to be involved in that too, and that will be in release in the run-up to COP as well. So those are all keeping us busy anyway. 40:35 Those are heavyweight initiatives, and Climate Proof will surely be covering those, so yes, expect me to be bothering you a lot in the future, Kit, via email, text, and call, and maybe we'll have another podcast later in the year to kind of go over what you've been working on. 40:48 Thanks so much for joining, Kit. Have a great rest of your week. No worries. Thank you ever so much for having me. Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 40:59 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now.