Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of adaptation, finance, tech, and policy. 0:13 My name's Louis Woodhill, editor of Climate Proof, which you can read at www.climateproof.news. Welcome to the 100th episode of Climate Proofers. 0:22 For a milestone like this, I wanted a guest who could cover adaptation from every angle: the science, the policy, and what it means for people on the ground. Dr. Adele Thomas is the expert who ticks every box. 0:34 She serves as senior director of adaptation at the Natural Resources Defense Council, and vice chair of Working Group II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the group that assesses climate impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability. 0:46 She's been an IPCC author since the fifth assessment cycle way back in the early 2010s, and contributed to the special report on 1.5 degrees, which is very much in the spotlight now that the UN is saying an overshoot of this target is imminent and unavoidable. 1:01 Now, she's helping to steer the seventh assessment, which will include a dedicated chapter on responding to loss and damage for the first time, another of her areas of expertise. 1:09 We get into the soft and hard limits to adaptation and why the Global North still resists the idea that some risks can't be engineered away. 1:17 We also discuss how data-hungry attribution science can skew our picture of where climate change hits hardest, and why roughly 90% of climate finance still goes to mitigation. 1:26 We also look at what overshooting 1.5 degrees means for adaptation and for loss and damage, and get Adele's preview of COP31, which kicks off next month. 1:35 Thanks to all you listeners out there for tuning in almost every week for the past two years now and helping us get to this 100-episode landmark. 1:42 If you want to help us get to 200 episodes, please consider becoming a paying Climate Proof member by heading over to www.climateproof.news/upgrade. 1:51 Right, in a moment, my conversation with Adele, but first, a rundown of last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 1:57 [swoosh] In finance, the European Investment Bank Group has pledged to deploy at least 30 billion euros in adaptation finance through 2030, but warns that a shortage of investable projects remains an obstacle to resilience spending. 2:09 The bank's adaptation plan, launched last Thursday, says that critical infrastructure would be first in line for investment, led by water systems and by energy, transport, and communications networks. 2:18 The EIB says it will also make more use of blended finance, guarantees, and risk-sharing instruments to strengthen projects with uncertain revenues and make them more attractive to private capital, an approach that an EU expert group urged Brussels to adopt last year. 2:32 [swoosh] In policy, Cameron Hamilton, administrator of the Federal Emergency Management Agency, told state officials they must build the financial reserves and capabilities to handle most disasters without federal help, according to a recording of his remarks acquired by Politico. 2:46 Speaking at the National Emergency Management Association's annual conference, Hamilton said he hoped states would become resilient enough so that the number of federal disaster declarations would go down. 2:56 His remarks flesh out the Trump administration's stated aim to shift disaster responsibilities onto states, and follow a September memo in which Hamilton called on FEMA to, quote, "return to the basics of emergency management." 3:07 [swoosh] And in tech, ICEYE has partnered with thermal satellite firm Aurora Tech to expand and enhance its wildfire intelligence product, allowing it to track blazes from ignition through to recovery. 3:17 Germany-based Aurora Tech maintains satellite-hosted thermal sensors that can detect hotspots early and follow an active fire front day and night. 3:25 ICEYE synthetic aperture radar satellites then see through smoke, cloud, and darkness to gauge building-level damage while an event unfolds. 3:33 Until now, ICEYE customers could evaluate structural damage only after a fire was already well underway. [swoosh] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Adele. [upbeat music] Hi, Adele. 3:46 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, there. I am Dr. Adele Thomas. I am calling in from Washington, DC. 3:54 Here, I am the senior director of adaptation at the Natural Resources Defense Council, the NRDC, and I am also vice chair of Working Group II for the IPCC, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. 4:08 Thank you so much for being on the podcast today as the guest for our 100th episode. 4:14 I'm really thrilled to have somebody of your experience, expertise to talk about the current state of play of adaptation and some of the issues that have come up in your research and your day job, for want of a better phrase. 4:25 So I'd like to start with your work with the IPCC. 4:29 You co-authored part of 2022's chapters on impact, adaptation, and vulnerability and are currently working on the update to this assessment, which is slated for release [laughs] in 2028 or 2029. 4:41 Although, we know there are some conflicts over when that report will actually come out. 4:46 So how have you seen the, the discussion, the debate, and the science on impact, adaptation, and vulnerability change over the course of the two reports? 4:55 So I've actually been involved in the IPCC way back since the fifth [laughs] assessment report, which was in 2012, and so since then and since AR6, um, which came out in 2021, the awareness and engagement with adaptation has really increased quite a lot. 5:13 In AR6, we were still having to advocate for the importance of adaptation, for why we should pay attention to adaptation, and I think that that message has come through pretty clear. 5:25 We're seeing adaptation, um, moving sort of from the margins of climate policy to people and policymakers more recognizing that adaptation is important. 5:36 So I think one of the clearest shifts has been that adaptation is no longer viewed as something that's optional or that's something that, um, needs to happen in developing countries only, but that it needs to happen everywhere and that it needs to complement mitigation. 5:50 Uh, I think in the scientific community, we've also seen a significant increase in research on adaptation, particularly on the effectiveness of adaptation, on adaptation limits, on climate resilience development, which incorporates adaptation along with mitigation. 6:07 And a focus on equity. 6:09 So I think, you know, research is expanding and exponentially, which creates quite a challenge for us now in the seventh assessment report to actually look at all the literature that has been out there, and also in the political and governance space in that people are paying more attention to the importance of adaptation. 6:27 I remember covering the AR6 report and looking at some of the wonderful breakdowns on how climate risks are going to escalate and compound over time if current warming trajectories aren't changed and if adaptation doesn't take hold. 6:41 And it seems to me like from AR6, that was when we first had this idea of... first time I was seeing ideas of climate change being attributed to the increasing severity and frequency of certain types of disaster. 6:55 And we've seen this take up of attribution science in the scientific world, and being increasingly used as a lever by policy makers. 7:03 So this might be a little bit outside your, your circle, but I am interested in how you've seen the... 7:07 in how you see the, uh, impact of attribution science and truly relating climate change to individual hazards, changing the tenor of the debate on adapting to climate risks. Yeah. 7:19 There's definitely been a lot of improvement in attribution science, and I think a lot more people are paying attention to attribution science. 7:28 And I definitely think that there is a role and a space for the attribution science, particularly when we get into sort of the legal approaches to dealing with climate impacts. 7:38 If you want to sue a particular company or you sue a particular country, then that attribution becomes incredibly important in that context. However, I have, um, some challenges with the attribution science as well. 7:50 It's very well documented that the attribution science requires levels of data, levels of processing power, and levels of expertise that are often not in place in developing countries, in places where there isn't that data available, in places where we don't have scientists that can do these rapid attribution studies. 8:11 And so that's sort of where attribution, I think, meets some of its limits, and we shouldn't just rely on attribution science to be able to say that something has been caused by climate change. 8:24 We know the trends in heat. We know the trends in hurricanes. We know the trends in all of this. 8:29 And so if we only rely on, on very, you know, data-intensive attribution science in order to link particular impacts with climate change, then we end up in a situation where we will find more impacts of climate change happening in the developed world, and it looking like climate change has more of an impact in places that are actually better equipped to deal with those impacts than in places that don't. 8:54 And this has been a finding that the IPCC has had since the fifth assessment report, where there are just so many more studies on impacts that are happening in more wealthy places that have data and expertise and scientists that can do these studies, and less that's coming out of more remote places, less developed places. 9:14 And it pre- presents this imbalance in understanding how climate change is affecting people and places around the world. 9:21 That's a very good point on the data intensity of attribution science, and yes, how it can kind of tilt our view of climate change having perversely greater impacts in the Global North when we know actually the reality is the greater impacts in terms of lives and livelihoods is actually in the, in the Global South. 9:37 So in the course of my podcast, I've talked to a number of people around the measuring the effectiveness of adaptation, which you said has advanced in recent years. 9:45 I've also been talking to folks about how to put in place financing and government structures to implement adaptation and what the return on investment looks like for adaptation. 9:53 But one area I've not looked into as much is the idea of limits on adaptation, and this is a, a major plank of your research. 10:00 So I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about the soft and hard limits to adaptation, and to what extent do you think awareness of these limits are being factored in to national and, I suppose, international discussions on adaptation. 10:11 I really got into the limits to adaptation work in AR6. 10:16 No, actually ba- back in AR5 when it was the first time when we were, um, talking about this concept of adaptation limits and recognizing that adaptation is really critical, but it cannot do everything, and there are limits to what adaptation can do. 10:31 So we sort of conceptualized adaptation limits into two different categor- categories. 10:37 A soft limit is when adaptation is technically possible, but it is constrained by things like lack of finances, institutions that aren't set up to actually put in place adaptation measures, governance that isn't there that understands how important adaptation is, or even lack of political will in, in not pushing forward adaptation. 10:59 So that would be a soft limit to adaptation, where adaptation is possible, but there are things that are stopping adaptation from happening. 11:06 So an example of that may be a city could reduce flood risk if it put into place more infrastructure investments, but they don't have the resources available in order to do that. 11:17 So that would be a soft limit to adaptation. Then we have hard limits to adaptation, and a hard limit is when there is no further adaptation. 11:26 All of the money, all of the governance, all of the political will, there is simply nothing else that we can do to adapt. The risk is just too high. 11:33 And coral reefs are, like, one of the best examples of hard limits to adaptation because beyond a certain temperature, they will die, and there is nothing that you can do about it. 11:44 Hard limits are also, um, used in the context where we have, like, coastal communities, low-lying communities. 11:50 If we have rates of sea level rise that are so high, combined with storms and coastal erosion, there really is nothing that you can do, and that island is just going to... 12:00 or that coastal community is just going to be subsumed by water. 12:03 So that was our understanding of soft and hard limits, and we really wanted to show that, number one, we need to put more resources into adaptation in order to overcome those soft limits so that adaptation can actually occur, and also to bring attention to hard limits and to show that as we increase temperatures, there are just things that we cannot adapt to, and we will have to deal with the consequences of climate change there. 12:29 From my perspective, there has been a lot of focus on, on soft limits, e-especially in terms of how developing countries are asking for increased adaptation finance, technical assistance, you know, modalities for monitoring and verifying adaptation investments. 12:44 That seems to be an area where there's a lot of c- understanding consensus. 12:48 One thing I'm worried about is if hard limits to adaptation are actually having a place in the, in the dialogue, because you made the point about coastal communities and, like, you know, I'm in [laughs] New York City, we're building this massive resilience project around the island. 12:58 But again, yes, that could be overwhelmed. Those billions of dollars of defenses could be overwhelmed if sea level rise accelerates beyond current projections. 13:06 And the choices we have, if hard limits are reached, are very hard decisions to make politically and to be... on an individual basis. 13:14 And I, I feel like we're s- at least in here in the Global North, kind of avoiding that discussion about how, h-how these hard limits, we're gonna come up against them and, and how do we react to them. 13:22 What's your sense of, of how hard limits are engaged or not engaged in the conversation right now? I think a lot of the more general understanding about hard limits is that it applies to the biophysical world, right? 13:35 So it applies to coral reefs, or it applies to species, and species may be extinct. So, like, it doesn't apply to us as societies and humans. It's something that happens to nature. 13:47 But I think particularly as we're having this conversation about overshooting 1.5, and there's been so much research on irreversible risks, I think that's where the hard limits is going to become more of a concept that people can grapple with, because we're not going to be able to just adapt our way out of all of the risks that are coming. 14:08 I think generally [laughs] the Global North, you know, it, it... climate change is seen as something that's not that big of a deal. It's something that we can deal with. 14:16 And so there is no limit to what we can do to address these issues. 14:20 I mean, even down in Florida and in Miami, where they're having actual buildings that are falling, in North Carolina, there still isn't the recognition that we may not be able to adapt our way out of all of these impacts. 14:34 But I think that as the impacts escalates, I think there'll be more of a recognition that there are just some things that we can't adapt to, and that's where the hard limits are. 14:42 I'm wondering whether small island developing states have a greater awareness and appreciation of things that can't be adapted to, right? 14:49 There's been a great deal of discussion about the risks of sea level rise to island states, and in fact, the UN agreed on a, a resolution recently to ensure that the sovereignty of island states is maintained even if they are massively impacted by sea level rise. 15:03 So it does seem that actually that some of these states that really are on the front lines of the worst types of climate risks that can't be adapted to are really trying to think long term about how actually their governing structures, their whole economic modes will continue. 15:18 You have some expertise in this area. Can you talk, talk a little bit about the perspective from the SIDS? Yeah. 15:24 The SIDS have really been, um, strong advocates for climate action since even before the creation of the UNFCCC back in 1992. 15:32 Because the SIDS recognized that climate change really posed what they called an existential threat to their countries, and that they would no longer, you know, physically be on the map if sea level rise, in particular, were to come up to levels that would subsume those islands. 15:49 And so I think that has lent the SIDS a particular urgency in, in recognizing that, that the impacts of climate change could be catastrophic. 15:59 And it's not just catastrophic physically, but also fiscally, because the small islands have such small GDPs. And so one hurricane can come through, and it can be multiple times the size of their GDP. 16:12 So they're going further and further into debt trying to respond to these climate impacts, while at the same time the climate impacts are getting worse. 16:21 So SIDS have really been very vocal in not just wanting to limit temperatures. 16:26 They were the one who- ones who came up with the 1.5 to stay alive slogan, which was wanting to limit temperatures to 1.5, and were really instrumental in getting that 1.5 limit in the Paris Agreement, actually. 16:39 But they are doing more thinking around, um, transformational adaptation and how may they need to change because of climate change impacts. Particularly the Pacific SIDS have been really innovative in their approaches. 16:52 So they have the Tuvalu and Australia Pact, which is providing a path to citizenship and residency for Tuvaluans to move to Australia, just recognizing that their islands are at high risk of being submerged. 17:05 Yes, that's long-term thinking, and also changes the relationship between states, right? 17:09 If you're trying to basically say, "We want citizenship to be fungible to a degree because you have to recognize you're a major emitter who got us in this mess, and you can give us all the money in the world, but we can't fortify our islands to protect ourselves en masse. 17:21 So we need to have this kind of transfer of population." Uh, yeah, I think that's a very interesting example of transformation of societies because of climate change. 17:29 Something connected to the concept of limits to adaptation is this idea of adaptive capacity. 17:34 Again, an area you've written about a lot, and also, again, something I think we are kind of underappreciating in the current dialogue. 17:40 So can you talk about what adaptive capacity means and, uh, whether you think it's been properly, uh, surfaced in the policy debates at the UN level, national level, et cetera? 17:50 So adaptive capacity is really about the ability of people and institutions to respond to climate change. And climate change actually erodes adaptive capacity unless we actively strengthen it. 18:04 So adaptive capacity is about can people, can communities, can institutions, can they anticipate for climate impacts? Can they prepare for them? Can they respond to them, and can they recover from them? 18:16 And we see that that is not equal everywhere, right? 18:20 So even at the individual level, if you have a low income person that is not aware of how climate change affects them, is not aware of the risks that are facing them, doesn't have in place, you know, contingency funds or savings to be able to recover from a disaster, doesn't have in place insurance that would help them if something were to happen, they are in-- have a much lower adaptive capacity than a wealthier family, you know, that is aware that they may be in a flood zone, that may seek extra flood insurance protection, that may be aware of programs that can help them. 18:54 They have a much higher adaptive capacity. And so we see that play out not just at the individual level, but at, you know, between different states, um, between different countries. 19:04 There are different levels of adaptive capacity, and that really then influences who was able to adapt, how much they are affected by climate impacts, which then is a circle that influences how better prepared they are to respond to the next set of impacts that come through. 19:21 And so we've really been seeing a definite divide between Global Sout- South and Global North in terms of institutions and resources that are available to be devoted to adaptation. 19:32 I think now having worked in the US, a lot of the developing countries, I think, are paying more attention to adaptation than we are here [laughs] in the US, actually, and have more of the understanding of the importance of adaptation and, like, how different sectors need to be combined and how they need to think about it in a systems way than what I'm finding here in the US. 19:58 So that speaks to different parts of adaptive capacity. 20:01 In the US or developed countries, they may have more financial resources and stronger institutions, but I think in the developing worlds where they're having to think more about adaptation, they're having more of, like, the knowledge and the importance of adaptation, which I think is really equally important. 20:18 And do you have any examples of measures or programs that proactively improve adaptive capacity? Cou- could be anywhere in the world, 'cause I think that's a policy lever we're gonna have to pull more often. 20:30 As you said, you know, lower income folks who may also have not access to, to data information, their adaptive capacity is lower, but that could be improved if, for example, there's cash transfers or also, like, the extension of low-cost early warning systems, for example, which is something the UN's pioneering. 20:48 I think there are measures like the early warning systems which help people to be aware of when there's, like, an immediate risk to them. 20:55 There are pilots that I've seen happening in Jamaica, for example, that, like, aim to train farmers so that they're aware of changes to the weather that are coming, how they may need to change their crops, and, and how they manage their farming practices. 21:12 There have been some pilot programs. 21:14 I've done a lot of work in the Caribbean, in Saint Lucia, where there is, like, this micro insurance, parametric insurance that would pay out if a storm hits a certain level of miles per hour. 21:25 Just things that are trying to equip individuals and households with more awareness of climate impacts and provide them with tools that will e- enable them to be more prepared. Wonderful. 21:37 Now I'd like to move to your role with the NRDC. What does your work as senior director climate adaptation entail? Yeah. So this has been a really interesting shift for me. 21:48 A lot of my career has been spent, um, focused internationally and really working with SIDS and least developed countries and in the UNCCC and the IPCC. 21:58 And now here at NRDC, NRDC is an advocacy organization, and so really it's, it's translating that science into action, into policy, into how is it that we can actually make a difference in people's lives. 22:12 And so I lead our climate adaptation division, which is a division of about seven senior advocates, and we are really framing adaptation around how is it that we can help people in their homes and in their communities to understand the impacts of climate change and to be able to respond to them. 22:31 And so we center our work around people, which I think is incredibly [laughs] important because a lot of the conversation around adaptation that I found here in the States immediately goes to infrastructure, and it's like, how are we hardening our infrastructure and not thinking about how are we helping people and communities? 22:49 So our areas that we work on here are around homeowner insurance, which we know is getting more expensive and less available as climate impacts rise. 22:58 We do work around disaster resilience, and so really using disasters as an entry point to help state and local government understand the importance of climate adaptation. 23:08 We do work around occupational heat and looking at how extreme heat affects both indoor and outdoor workers, and pushing for policies that will protect those workers from that extreme heat. 23:19 And then finally, we do work on climate mobility and looking at planned relocation in particular, and how do we need to start thinking about moving entire communities away from places that are at risk. 23:31 I completely agree with your assessment that when it comes to adaptation in, in the US, the conversation quite quickly goes to, yeah, infrastructure, spending. 23:39 Also technology, like what technological interventions can be used to help workers who are out in the heat. You know, what sort of new wearables can we have? Yep. Insurance is a big part of it. 23:49 What new insurance solutions are available, parametric insurance, microinsurance, et cetera. 23:54 But I'm interested that you, you make that point about people, and I feel sometimes, A, it's hard to invest in just, like, growing networks of people or strengthening communities. 24:06 But I do know that social capital, building up social capital, building up bonds between people can be a very effective way to build adaptation. 24:14 So I'm interested in your views on, on whether we need to put more effort into kind of, like, building social capital as an adaptation mechanism, and it feels like one of the sources or exacerbators of many of our ills [laughs] in, in the, the Global North at least, seems to be the fraying of, of social cohesion and community. 24:32 And I'm wondering, it's a big question, but how do you kind of help to reve- reverse that in the face of climate change? Yeah. 24:38 So a lot of our work, we try to work with community-based organizations who may not even understand that climate adaptation is an issue for their communities. 24:48 But we try to educate on how climate risks are affecting these different communities and how they can be engaged in educating their members about these risks, but also galvanizing their members and galvanizing- Broad public supports to then push political action. 25:07 'Cause we're seeing that, you know, state and local government, federal government at the moment is not wanting to pay attention to adaptation, is not wanting to put into... 25:17 put money into how do we protect people, communities, households from climate change. And as a scientist, you know, I have... 25:24 The more reports that we have and the more evidence we have, it doesn't seem that it's pushing the needle that much. 25:29 And so we also need that, you know, that incentive and that push that's coming from regular people to be like, "This is something that is affecting me. I need government to pay attention to this. 25:39 I need to know what you're doing to protect me from climate impacts." 25:42 So that's sort of the approach that we're taking, is to increase people's awareness in order to mobilize broad policies and broad action that would help as many people as possible. 25:53 But speaking to the social cohesion and the, you know, the networks of communities, that is so important, I think, for, um, for all climate hazards. 26:02 You know, coming from hurricane impacts in The Bahamas, which is where I'm from, the first responders are your neighbors. That's who's gonna help you. If your house gets washed away, then you run to who's closest to you. 26:15 And so having that community, just knowing who your neighbors are, I think is something that we have moved away from, unfortunately, in this day and age. 26:24 But it's something that we need to build up, particularly as we face escalating climate risks. Something I'm aware of from research out there in the world is that humans are reactive creatures rather than proactive. 26:36 So here in the States you see that people are more likely to buy flood insurance after they've been flooded [laughs] rather than before they've been flooded, no matter how much good data they're shown, how many simulations, how many people knock on their door and say, "Hey, you should get flood insurance." 26:49 And similar things with extreme heat or wildfires, like I think everybody in Altadena and the Palisades and Los Angeles knows the signs of wildfires 10 times better than they did this time two years ago. 27:00 So I'm wondering if... it's an impossible question maybe, what kind of proactive messages work? So you're in the area of the country which is at climate risk. 27:09 It's not seen a big disaster yet, but all the signs, all the projections show it's gonna happen next year, two years, five years from now, it's gonna happen, it's gonna be bad. 27:17 How do you tell a community, how do you get community ready for that risk when there are always gonna be those saying, "Eh, it's never... I've lived here for 10 years, it's never happened"? 27:23 How do you kinda get past that blocker? What I've found most effective is, like, finding, finding a similar community or something that people can relate to and, like, show how this has happened to them. 27:37 So, you know, it... 27:39 this other community that's, that's near you, or this other community that has characteristics that are very similar to yours, this is what happened to them, and this is what could happen to you, right? 27:50 So something that's really tangible that they can then grasp onto, and it not just be a hypothetical for their particular community, but they can see how it has affected a community that is similar to them, I think is something that helps people to understand that this is a possibility. 28:08 I have people in my own family that are climate change deniers, um, even after going through terrible hurricanes, they're still climate change deniers. So some people you're just not going to convince. 28:18 But I think others that are open and that you can make a case and, and show them in tangible ways how this could affect them and what are some simple, we like to say win-win strategies that they can do to prepare themselves, I think that's the way to go. 28:34 Yes, that point in finding comparators is, is a good one, yes. 28:37 It's like your community looks like this community, which did have this struggle, this suffering because they weren't adapted, and you can avoid their fate if you take these actions. 28:45 To go on a tangent a little bit, but something I've been curious about is how the UN's been framing adaptation, the adaptation gap, for example, and it's [laughs] these bar charts, how much finance is going to adaptation, and then, like, the total modeled needs, which is billions and billions and billions of dollars per year. 29:01 And I'm wondering if that is counterproductive in a degree, first of all because it gives you an i- a sense, an illusion that, oh, if we only had this much money, we'd be fine. Yeah. We, we'd be adapted. 29:12 So that's the target. We reach it, we're, we're fine. But also it creates the idea that, oh God, it's gonna be so expensive. It's gonna be so hard to do this. We... there's no point taking the incremental steps. 29:22 So wondering about how you see the framing of adaptation as a financial goal, uh, at the international level. 29:28 I think at the international level, the framing of the goal and the gap, I think is important because it brings attention to how little climate finance goes to adaptation versus what goes to mitigation. 29:44 So it's like 90% of climate finance goes to mitigation, and we're not putting as much into adaptation. And so I think the adaptation gap report helps to, like, highlight that discrepancy. 29:55 On the other hand, it can be very daunting to, like, see these big numbers in the billions and hundreds of billions of dollars as to how much money we need to adapt. 30:06 But then you see how much money we spend on other things, right? Like how much money do we spend on war? How much money do we spend- Debt repayments now. Exactly. 30:14 The whole US debt repayments every year is more than the adaptation gap. Right. So I think we need those figures just to show, like, what... 30:21 ultimately what we need to get to, but it shouldn't preclude people, governments doing some of the incremental things along the way. 30:29 So I hope it's not, like, paralyzing to governments to be like, "I can, I can do some of these basic things without having all of my adaptation needs met, but I can do some of these basic measures." Yes. 30:41 I'm wondering about the incentives that could create where it's like, okay, we need X billion dollars. 30:45 We can't get that much, then we'll be like, "Oh, we tried and we failed," and the incremental steps, the cheaper steps aren't taken. 30:50 I'm sure there's plenty of efforts underway to make sure that [laughs] doesn't happen though. 30:54 You wrote recently for NRDC an article titled Overshoot Demands a New Era of Adaptation, Loss and Damage and Climate Justice, and here you talked about the need to consider, quote, "transformational adaptation." 31:06 So that's a concept that folks may not be familiar with. Love it if you could explain that, and then I'll get into the article itself. So transformational adaptation is a tricky topic. 31:15 Transformational adaptation means changing underlying systems rather than just protecting the status quo. So we sort of differentiate transformational adaptation from incremental adaptation. 31:27 Incremental adaptation helps to maintain existing systems. Transformational adaptation asks whether those systems are going to remain viable under future climate conditions. 31:39 Transformational adaptation, you know, it involves rethinking how development occurs, where are we gonna build, how is our, how are economies going to function, where are we placing communities. 31:52 It's really like a really big picture thinking for transformational adaptation. It can get very difficult to understand because transformational adaptation is really context specific. 32:04 What's transformational in one place may just seem incremental somewhere else. 32:08 So for example, in the Global South, transformational adaptation could be something like redesigning agricultural systems, putting in place climate resilient crops, or changing the crops that are grown in particular places, diversifying livelihoods or diversifying economies. 32:26 So I come, you know, from a very tourism-dependent country. If tourism is not going to be an attractive industry, what other industries could we look to rely on or to invest in rather than solely focusing on tourism? 32:41 So that's what transformational could look like. 32:43 In other places, transformational adaptation could be relocating entire communities, deciding that, you know, this city isn't one that we're gonna be able to protect and let's move further inland, and what does that look like for, for homeowners, for infrastructure. 32:59 So it can get, it can get very, very complicated, and I think transformational adaptation is something that's still really in the scientific space. 33:09 I haven't seen too much in moving into actual practical, um, action, but I think with overshoot we're gonna really have to start grappling with, with how are we gonna transform. Yes. 33:20 I want to get into how overshoot changes the dynamic somewhat, but transformational adaptation, it was relatively new to me, but it was raised, I believe at the last two COPs, the two UN climate summits that just went, and I'm sure it's gonna be on the agenda in some form this year. 33:34 And I feel like with many aspects [laughs] of climate policy, disagreements between developed countries and developing countries, one aspect is that transformational adaptation can sound, as you said, big and scary, and it could mean a lot more money has to flow from Global North to, to Global South, and maybe also transformation of a current system. 33:54 When you're currently benefiting from the system, [laughs] like a lot of developed countries are, you don't really wanna change that dynamic 'cause then you, you, you come off your perch somewhat. 34:01 So I think those are two of the friction points that may be preventing action here for sure. 34:06 So why is the fact that we are overshooting 1.5 degrees, in the short term it seems, hopefully, [laughs] maybe we'll come back down again, we'll see. 34:15 But why does the overshoot then make transformational adaptation something more important, something to take more seriously and, and really try and put some intellectual and policy heft behind that? Yeah. 34:26 So, and I grapple with overshoot, right? 'Cause overshoot means that you're coming back down, and with all of the [laughs] action that we've seen, I don't think it's a guarantee that we will. 34:37 So breaching 1.5, we know 1.5, you know, is a major threshold beyond which points, you know, we, we start having irreversible impacts, higher levels of risk, higher levels of heat waves, more intense precipitation, like all of this. 34:53 When the IPCC special report on 1.5, which I was also an author on, came out and really like scientifically articulated the difference between 1.5 degrees of warming and two degrees, and showing just how much worse climate impacts get at 1.5 versus sub 1.5. 35:12 So overshoot means we're going past 1.5, we're gonna have all of these impacts. That includes, you know, the higher levels of sea level rise, which means that islands may, and coastal communities may be submerged. 35:24 Species extinction. Higher, you know, more intense disasters, meaning even more deaths and destruction than we see now. So we're really going to be moving into a much more tumultuous state of the climate than we are now. 35:40 And so that's why overshooting 1.5 means that we need to think more about how do we really take adaptation seriously. 35:49 Right now I think we're beginning to be like, "Oh, yes, adaptation is important," and more people are paying attention. But as we pass 1.5, the impacts is really gonna be so severe that we... 36:00 it has to be a central component of climate action and we have to be adapting. 36:06 I remember looking at that overshoot report and understanding how gnarly things can get at 1.5 degrees, and I do also wonder whether overshoot world we're going to be living in, or we, we are living in, means that some of the preconceptions of adaptation, which are if we do these measures that we can continue business as usual, they sort of break down. 36:24 And in the private sector, in the technology realms, there a lot of the focus is on, okay, if you use our solution, if you use these financing mechanisms, do X, Y, and Z, you continue living like it's 1990 [laughs] in a world where the climate change is, is plus 1.5 degrees, and I don't think that's true the longer we stay in a 1.5 plus world. 36:42 Yeah, absolutely. 36:44 I think what we've even seen to date is like the science can predict one thing, but what, what happens often is worse than what the science has predicted when it comes to impacts, when it comes to, to how people experience climate change. 36:58 Um, so like the levels and the cost of climate impacts that we're seeing now are exceeding what we predicted back in AR5. I think 1.5 worlds is gonna be very wild. 37:10 In AR6 we talked about compounding and cascading risks, which is when one, you know, hazard happens and then another one happens right after that, and this makes the impacts escalate. 37:22 So you have a heatwave on top of a drought, and what does that mean in terms of escalating deaths or water insecurity or food insecurity? 37:31 What does this mean for global food security if we have places that we rely on for food and they're no longer able? How is this gonna interact with conflict? 37:40 We see that interacting with conflict now, what is that gonna be like? 37:44 So I think we're moving into really uncharted territory as we have these increasing climate risks, and it interacts with whatever else is going on in society at the same time. 37:55 Now, another theme of that article you wrote was the importance of foregrounding loss and damage in the climate policy and financing space. 38:03 So can you talk a little bit about how loss and damage should be incorporated, or the relationship between adaptation made stronger over time, and how can financing for adaptation and loss and damage complement one another? 38:16 So adaptation and, and responding to loss and damage really exists on a continuum. They are super interconnected. So adaptation is how can we reduce climate risks. 38:26 Loss and damage is how do we respond once those impacts occur. 38:30 And we're seeing the impacts of climate change that are just escalating, and so there's more and more of a need to respond to those impacts to help people to recover. 38:40 And they need to recover in a way that takes into consideration adaptation. You don't wanna be recovering and going right back to business as usual. 38:49 You need to recover in a way that considers future climate risks and prepares for those, which is adaptation. So I really see loss and damage as existing on a continuum. 38:59 I think that there has been this unfortunate divide between the adaptation community and between the loss and damage community, and it's sort of been like a fight for resources. 39:10 And if we pay attention to loss and damage, then that means there's gonna be less money for adaptation. But I think the overall money that we spend on climate action should be increased. 39:21 Climate action should include mitigation, adaptation, and loss and damage, and we need to figure out how the three of them work together and not just try to do them in silos. 39:33 And yes, we saw that sort of contested resources play out at recent COPs, where we had the adaptation fund one year got a load of contributions, and then the following year, the fund for loss and damage was stood up at the UN, and that got a bunch of contributions. 39:47 But [laughs] contributions for the adaptation fund went down. So yes, it seems like it matters how these different concepts are kind of... How prominent they are in, in the discourse. 39:58 One of my concerns is that understandably, developing nations might be like, "Okay, it's very hard to kind of get money out of developed countries anyway, climate finance from developed countries anyway, and adaptation finance should help reduce the actual quantum of losses we experience, but we'd rather actually have the funds after a disaster strikes to rebuild. 40:18 We definitely need that." And maybe it's easier to kind of get developed countries to pay for that 'cause that's already kind of part of the aid programs. Whereas adaptation is slightly... 40:27 'Cause it's preventative, right? It might be a little bit harder to grease the wheels to make those contributions happen. 40:32 I mean, that's the way I see it a little bit, but then we have seen also the complications with the fund for loss and damage actually raising contributions anyway beyond its initial burst of popularity a couple of years ago. 40:41 Yeah. And the fact is, like the humanitarian aid that, that developed countries provide to developing countries doesn't cover the rebuilding costs. 40:49 Those costs then end up being borne by the developing countries, which is why they go further and further into debt. 40:56 So I think the loss and damage funding is really to recognize that these are climate costs, and that the countries need assistance in recovering from those impacts. 41:05 And a lot of my work has been like trying to bridge the adaptation [laughs] and loss and damage communities, because I think we need to work much closer together. I started out in adaptation. I ended... 41:15 I've been in loss and damage. So I s- I sort of straddle both because I see the importance of both. 41:21 And I think in the upcoming AR7 report out of IPCC, we actually have for the first time a new chapter on responding to loss and damage. 41:30 And so we're making those connections between adaptation and responding to loss and damage. Now, finally, we have COP31 taking place in November. 41:40 I'm wondering what your hopes and expectations are for the adaptation agenda at this COP. There are specific agenda items that I think we need to make progress on. 41:51 One is on the global goal on adaptation, and really moving past the stalled progress on discussions around the indicators and how is it that we measure progress on adaptation. 42:02 I really hope that we move beyond those disagreements and come to some sort of agreement during this COP because it's so essential for us to be able to measure progress on adaptation. 42:12 That's one of the things that's used against us. You know, you can't tell what's happening, if we're making a difference with the money that's spent on adaptation. So I hope that we come to some conclusion on that. 42:22 I hope that we get more, um, financing for adaptation. There are, you know, wanting to come up with a roadmap as to how do we meet that tripling adaptation finance goal that, um, came out of the last COP. 42:36 But more broadly, I really hope that this overshoot report that came out from UNEP like spurs a greater conversation, a greater sense of urgency within the COP, that we are acting too slowly. This is the 31st COP. 42:51 We are now heading past 1.5. Like, the processes, the bureaucracy, the deliberate blocking of progress is not serving the world. 43:03 And I hope that at this COP there's a recognition that we need to start doing some things differently. 43:09 You know, Greta Thunberg with her famous, "COP is a bunch of blah, blah, blah," I think more and more people are feeling like that. 43:16 And now that we're, like, blowing past 1.5, I think there's a need for us to really rethink how are we gonna use the UN system to actually spur action. 43:26 One thing I think may help is that you are seeing developed nations on the adaptation in their own policy agendas. 43:32 So later this month, we're expecting the European Union to come out with their framework for climate resilience and risk management. New Zealand has their own plan they're putting out. 43:40 So a lot of developed nations, they're trying to build the adaptation of their own societies. 43:46 But as we've seen because of the geopolitical conflicts that have been raging in recent years, how dependent so much [laughs] of the developed world is on supply chains that run through developing countries and run through areas of climate risk. 43:57 And I'm wondering, I'm hoping that some of the policy arguments that convince developed countries to take adaptation more seriously in the round and internationally will be this argument that, hey, in order to be adapt ourselves, we need to make sure that we're building adaptation resilience in the developing world as well, where we get so much of our fuel, where we get so much of our food stuff, where we get so much of our raw materials. 44:17 So that's my hope. Although [laughs] I will see if it's borne out down the line. Okay, and very finally, what are your plans with the NRDC over the next 12 months? 44:26 We are really focusing on states and local government action, really trying to get some policies, some laws on the books that will make sure that, you know, that the issues that we care about, homeowner insurance, disaster resilience, occupational heat, and climate mobility, have the, the support of policymakers, and that we're actually putting in place measures that will help people and communities to be protected from the impacts of climate change. 44:56 That's a full docket. The best of luck to you and the team implementing that ambitious agenda. For now, Dr. Thomas Adele, thank you so much for your time, and have a great rest of your week. Great. 45:05 Thank you for having me. [upbeat music] Climate Proovers is a Climate Proof media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodhill. 45:13 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]