Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of adaptation finance, tech, and policy. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, the editor of Climate Proof, which you can read at www.climateproof.news. 0:18 Today is the second in our double feature on the Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety, the research and communications outfit working to create science-based resilient solutions for American homes. 0:29 I'm joined by Rachel Penton Gauthier, meteorologist and science content creator at the IBHS, to talk about the art and science of communicating extreme weather risk and resilience to the public. 0:40 We get into what messages work, the role of storytelling in describing potential risk impacts, and why it's so hard to move folks from knowing about climate and weather risks to doing something about them. 0:51 Along the way, Rachel shares stories from her 10-plus years as a broadcast meteorologist for local TV, and what extreme weather event transformed her perspective on the destructive power of climate change. 1:01 Before we get started, a reminder that if you're a fan of this pod, to give us a star rating on Apple Podcast or Spotify, and to type up a review if you really want to make my day. 1:10 And remember, there's lots more climate adaptation news, insights, and content available to Climate Proof members. So why not join the cool kids and sign up at www.climateproof.news/upgrade. 1:21 Right, in a moment my conversation with Rachel, but first a rundown of last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 1:28 [whooshing sound] In finance, the Inter-American Development Bank arranged its first catastrophe swap, shifting a slice of Belize's hurricane risk to private reinsurance capital providers via Swiss Re. 1:38 The deal gives Belize fast access to emergency funds after major storms without adding to its debt load. 1:44 The deal marks IDB's first swap under its Financial Instruments for Resilience program and offers a template that other Latin American and Caribbean nations could use to transfer disaster risk to global markets. 1:54 [whooshing sound] In policy, Canada's first national adaptation strategy progress report shows the country is falling behind on its climate proofing efforts, the Canadian Climate Institute has said. 2:04 While the federal government has committed over 2.1 billion Canadian dollars since 2022 to adaptation programs spanning disaster resilience, infrastructure, and health systems, the return on investment appears limited so far. 2:16 Municipal adaptation costs are estimated at $5.3 billion per year, with current funding described as inadequate to the scale of need. 2:23 [whooshing sound] And in tech, WatchDuty, the nonprofit wildfire and flood alert platform, is layering satellite imagery from Planet Labs into a new range of enterprise tools for utilities and infrastructure operators. 2:35 Pacific Gas and Electric Company has become the first customer to deploy the feature, gaining weekly satellite source insights to evaluate vegetation conditions, gauge changes to terrain, and support incident response. 2:46 [whooshing sound] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now onto my conversation with Rachel. [upbeat music] Hi, Rachel. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? 2:56 Hi, I'm calling from the Charlotte, North Carolina area. I work at IBHS. We're located down in Richburg, South Carolina, just a little bit south of the Charlotte area. 3:04 And I'm a meteorologist and a science content producer for IBHS. Thank you for joining today, Rachel. Very much appreciate it. 3:12 I want to get into your role at the IBHS, but first, let's take a step back and talk about your over one decade's experience as a meteorologist for television. 3:21 Over that time, obviously, extreme weather events have become more frequent and severe. 3:25 They've become headline news across the country, and I was wondering if you could tell us a little about the science of communication on extreme weather. 3:33 For example, what messages work when it comes to prompting people to take preparatory action, and how has the messaging of these events changed over the course of your career? Yeah. Thanks for having me, Louis. 3:42 And that's a really interesting question because when I went to school, I just studied science. I actually did not study communications at all. 3:49 But I got into a business that was all about communication, which was broadcast meteorology. So, um, in school, some people learn a little bit about communication. 3:59 For me, I learned a lot of it on the job, finding out what works and what doesn't work, being out in the community, talking to different people. 4:06 And, uh, w- what I learned is that the science really doesn't mean much if it's not making an impact with people, if you're not effectively communicating that. 4:14 What I've learned, uh, first and foremost is that information alone really doesn't do much for people. They need to know how specifically it will impact their lives. 4:23 For example, I worked in Louisiana for a very long time, and in Louisiana, they have a pretty good idea when you say that the forecast calls for a half inch of rain. 4:32 Um, but when it comes to winter weather, for example, a type of weather that they don't commonly see, they have no idea what a half inch of ice accumulation means. 4:41 So telling people how that will impact them, "Hey, power lines could go down. Trees could go down. You could have tree branches covered in ice landing on your roof." 4:50 Really letting people know, giving them that information and letting them know how that weather hazard may impact them, and that's how you really get people to understand what the forecast means and help drive them to, to take preparation, to take action that will strengthen, uh, their homes, uh, ag- against severe weather. 5:08 So less about the metrics, about the inches accumulation or the wind speed, for example, and more about what the impacts could be. That makes sense to me. 5:15 I'm wondering if you could tell us a little bit behind the scenes, the sort of formulation of, like, communication policy, if you want to call it, in TV stations, right? 5:23 I mean, to what extent do you kind of have to evolve your approach based on what you're hearing from your audience, what you're hearing from your station manager, et cetera? 5:29 I'm wondering how much you are adapting to the needs of your audience in real time. Yeah. I would say a lot of it is really trial and error. 5:37 Um, in broadcast meteorology, one thing that really helps tell your story is weather graphics. And as a broadcast meteorologist, we build all our own graphics. 5:46 So we decide what it looks like, what words will or won't be on the graphic, what colors to use. And you'd be surprised what different people's interpretation of a weather graphic is. 5:57 For radar, for example, I would assume that, that a red or darker purples and reds means heavier rain, but a lot of people think that greens mean heavier rain, when in fact on certain radar sort of color scales, green actually indicates lighter rain. 6:12 So really, you can't assume that people interpret the information the same way that you do because everyone has an entirely different interpretation when it comes to science information. 6:23 So I would say I was always big on showing what I'm talking about. 6:27 So if I'm talking about a certain message, make sure that's illustrated correctly on the graphic behind me, and then don't assume that the people are interpreting it the same way that I designed and built the graphic for. 6:38 So explain- Why it looks the way that it does. Explain the information that people are seeing behind you. Never assume that people are, again, interpreting it in the same way that you build it. 6:48 Anytime you have numbers, you put those numbers on the screen so that people can, can listen to it, and they can read it. Not everyone learns the same way or interprets information in the same way. 6:58 Some people learn by hearing, some people learn by seeing, and then there, there are people that need to see the words on the screen for various reasons. Maybe they have a, a hearing disability. 7:07 So there's lots of different ways to present the information, but a lot of it is kind of trial and error, finding out what messages resonate with people. 7:15 When I was a broadcast meteorologist, I would have people come up to me at the grocery store and say, "Hey, I really liked the way that you explained this concept or that concept. 7:23 The way that you explained it to me made it really relatable." So just kind of figuring out what works, talking to people, figuring out how that information resonates with the different audiences. 7:34 Yes, that's key, and it comes back to this idea of how extreme weather warnings can be communicated to populations that aren't used to them. 7:43 And there's a lot of efforts underway at startups and in policy shops to try and make weather forecasts more personable and more accessible, and it sounds like this is something that you've been doing for, for some time now. 7:54 So Rachel, over your career, can you talk about a particular event or sequence of events that really changed your view on the severity of extreme weather events, and made you start thinking about resilience more? 8:04 Any particular storms, any particular floods, et cetera? As a reporting meteorologist, I covered a lot of different events in a lot of different places. 8:11 One of those was in Ohio, and I think back to, I think it was in somewhere in central Ohio. I want to say the town was West Lafayette, Ohio. It was a really small sort of v- I think it was classified as a village. 8:24 And there was an extreme rainfall event that developed. I can't remember what the atmospheric setup w- at the time was, but it was a rainfall event, right? 8:33 So this water that flooded the town came from the sky, and not a river or a lake or anything like that. And this little town received an extreme amount of rainfall over a short period of time. 8:45 Believe it was in the summer, and it just, it was catastrophic for a small number of houses. I want to say it was several dozen houses. 8:52 But Ohio is not the place where you think of extreme rainfall events, and you think of flooding events. And in this case, pretty much n- no one in the town had flood insurance. 9:02 Everyone's home was destroyed from this flooding. 9:05 And I remember seeing some kind of nonprofits, and I want to say there were some Mennonite Amish groups that came in to volunteer their time and resources to help rebuild because so many of the people in this community, again, they didn't have flood insurance because they didn't think that they needed it. 9:19 Because who would think that in central Ohio you could experience this extreme rainfall event that led to catastrophic flooding? But it happens. It's happening in all different places. 9:29 And one thing that we know, y- you have this higher moisture content, you have this atmosphere that's extremely juiced up, for lack of a better word, and we are seeing more extreme rainfall events, and in different places that maybe haven't seen them before, places like Ohio. 9:44 So that was one of those events where I really thought, yeah, there's definitely something going on here, and this is an example of what we're seeing more of and what we're likely going to see more of. 9:54 It's always the risk you haven't prepared for that gets you, right? And when it comes to climate change and worse than extreme weather, we have to be prepared for everything everywhere. 10:01 I was wondering what you thought of efforts to elevate the narrative of extreme weather events, not just in the US, but around the world. 10:07 So I'm from the UK, and in the last few years there's been this habit of actually naming windstorms, right? We don't have hurricanes in the UK. We did once [laughs] in the '80s. 10:15 But the idea is that if you give a storm a name and a kind of a, a narrative focus, you help to kind of elevate it in people's minds, and they really get to prepare. 10:23 And I'm wondering from your experience, do you feel that's something we should adopt, not just for in the US and for hurricanes, but also maybe for heat waves and severe convective storms and major flood events? Yeah. 10:32 That's an interesting question as well. We've been naming hurricanes in the United States since, I think, around the '50s, and those were named by The National Hurricane Center. 10:42 World Meteorological Organization has evolved in choosing those names. And other entities, such as private cable TV news channels, have taken it upon themselves to name other types of hazards, such as winter storms. 10:56 So on one hand you have the National Weather Service and NOAA in the US. They do not name winter storms. But then you have private entities that have chosen to name them. 11:05 At the end of the day, I do think that it can lead to confusion, especially when different entities do different things. Um, you know, who is the official source? Is it the government organization? 11:15 Is it the private entity? I don't know. I, I think the main thing that we need to focus on is making sure that we properly communicate the hazard or the effects of whatever that hazard is, whether it has a name or not. 11:28 How will this heat wave impact you? How will this winter storm impact you? 11:33 I do think on one hand it's good for helping people remember things, but I'm more interested in just making sure that the hazard itself, what you may or may not see, is communicating properly. 11:43 And our, our forecasts have come such a long way over the last few decades, that are... In general, our forecasts are, are pretty good. 11:50 One thing we've been able to do over the last decade or so is really communicate the range of possible outcomes. 11:56 Because we have so many different models available to us, and so much information, we can communicate kind of the range of the possible forecast outcomes. 12:04 "This is what it could look like for you if the worst-case scenario does play out for your area. But we're a few days out. There's still some uncertainty. 12:13 The worst-case scenario is not always going to play out, so here's what the lower end could look like." Our job as broadcasters historically has been to prepare people for the worst-case scenario. 12:23 We tend to get a lot of feedback from forecasts when that worst case scenario doesn't play out. They say, "Hey, you said it was going to be this, it was going to be that, and that didn't happen." 12:32 Um, our job is to prepare you for the worst that you could see, not the best that you could see. That's so important, yes. 12:38 It's describing the range of possible outcomes can actually help strengthen trust in information services like weather stations, like meteorologists, because time and again you'll see people say, "Oh, they said it was gonna be 100 degrees, and it's 95." 12:50 And it's like, well, actually, there's only five degrees, and if the- if you'd said, "Oh, the range will be between 90 and 105," people wouldn't be able to use that as stick to hit professionals and say, "Hey, look, you guys don't know what you're talking about." 13:01 So I think you're absolutely right there. One last thing on kind of s- science of communication here. So I'm a climate journalist. Climate Proof is my publication. Climate Proof is my podcast. 13:09 And I like to try and talk about how climate change is driving extreme weather events, their frequency and severity. 13:15 I'm wondering, as a professional communicator, i- in your previous career but also at the IBHS, how useful it is to talk about climate as a kind of exacerbating factor here, or do you prefer to keep that separate and just focus on the immediate impact of these disasters and what you can do to prepare for them? 13:30 Yeah, we get a lot of questions at IBHS about climate change. Is there a change in climate driving, you know, worse disasters, more widespread disasters? 13:38 We're fo- we're focused on solving the hazard regardless of whether climate change is exacerbating or not. 13:44 We know generally that climate change can lead to things like we have warmer base state temperatures, and that leads to the available ingredients that you need to get severe thunderstorms. 13:53 And sometimes we're now seeing those ingredients in unusual places at unusual times. A, a couple of years ago, there was a, a tornado outbreak during the winter months in the upper Midwest. That's unusual. 14:04 That's something that typically wouldn't happen until the spring months. But at the same time, we have a lot more people living in those areas that are impacted by the hazards. 14:13 We call that the bullseye effect, and, uh, that's something that we're studying a lot at IBHS, is not necessarily the hazard itself, but who is in the path of this hazard. 14:22 And we're seeing a lot more people living in the paths of these hazards. As they become more widespread, their geography is evolving and changing. We're seeing simply a lot more people impacted, a lot more houses. 14:35 Another great example is shifting Tornado Alley, right? We've always seen a lot of tornadoes in places like Oklahoma and Kansas, and we still are. 14:44 That's that traditional Tornado Alley that I learned about all the way back in elementary school. 14:49 But over the last couple of decades, we've al- we've also seen an increasing number of tornadoes and tornado outbreaks in the southeastern US. 14:56 So we're communicating that we now have a secondary Tornado Alley, Deep South Alley, from that kind of Texas over through Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia. 15:06 So we are seeing some shifts in our patterns, but we're also seeing big shifts in where people live and the type of housing that people live in. 15:13 So it certainly all ties together, uh, but we're really focused on really making those homes and those, those businesses stronger. We know we're not going to see fewer hazards in the future. 15:22 We're probably not going to see less intense hazards in the future. So we have to do something, and we have to get out ahead of the way that we build our houses, our businesses. 15:32 We've got to change what the built environment looks like to prepare for whatever it is that, that's ahead. Yes, that bullseye effect is very much dominant in the media as well. 15:42 If something happens to New York, LA, London, or Paris that's unusual, then suddenly this is a change in paradigm. But if it happens somewhere else, [laughs] it might not be as, as highlighted. 15:50 And interesting what you say about this shifting Tornado Alley. I wrote an article recently about hail risk in the US and how actually it's very hard to measure hail if there's nobody there. 16:00 But as people are building into more hail zones, we're learning a lot more about how damaging hail can be. So it is like these hazards are getting worse. 16:06 But also, as you said, people are moving to areas where actually we didn't actually know how bad things could get in terms of the impact of these hazards, and now we are. 16:13 I've observed over the last couple of years actually meteorologists like yourself being employed not just by institutions like the IBHS, but more banks and, like, financial institutions are hiring meteorologists. 16:24 You're getting them used in consultancies and in stream-facing service companies as well because more and more businesses, more and more organizations are realizing that understanding the weather, understanding the impacts of extreme events can have a real impact on their P&L and on their investment plans going forward. 16:39 So I was wondering what you make of that, and do you feel actually meteorology is now a, a profession that doesn't just mean you're gonna be a scientist or you're gonna be on TV, and it can mean many more things? Yeah. 16:48 No, that's an interesting question. I think one thing we can say for certain is that meteorology and climate impacts every single thing, right? 16:55 And that's one thing that I thought was really interesting about choosing meteorology as a major because there are very few subjects where every single person on the face of the planet is impacted by this every single day, right? 17:08 There is no break from weather anywhere, anytime. Uh, you know, even if the weather is good, you're being impacted, right? Because you're enjoying that nice weather. 17:16 And if it's extreme weather, you're being impacted by that as well. So I think it's really smart for companies to take weather for- weather forecasting and meteorology, put that kind of center stage. 17:27 We can look to all of the events that have happened where we had negative outcomes to see just how important that is. Um, you know, something as simple as concerts and baseball games. 17:36 We've heard of these different events where there was no meteorologist on duty. 17:40 They just wanted to go with the luck of the draw, and in some cases, people were hurt, killed, injured, property was destroyed because meteorology was not at the forefront of the decision-making. 17:51 So I do think it's smart for people to bring in weather, especially as we see extreme events become more extreme. 17:58 I think it's really important, and there's been a lot of discussion, it, within the meteorology community about this, and that's it's not just about the science, right? It is about being able to communicate the science. 18:09 At the American Meteorological Association conference this year, we had Ken Graham, the, the head of the National Weather Service, and he gave a, a whole discussion on how they're looking for not just the latest, greatest meteorologist, but people who can effectively communicate that, right? 18:26 Because when you're in a room with some of the top government officials or whether it's a private organization and you're in the room with the CEO, uh, you have to be able to effectively communicate not just the forecast, but how it may or may not impact people. 18:39 So that is just as important as the science itself, especially- As we work to solve all these different science communication challenges that are out there. Okay. I wanna turn to your role now at the IBHS. 18:50 Tell us why you wanted to jump in and join the institute, and then tell us how you use your expertise to help inform resilient strategies for homeowners. Yeah. 18:57 Well, after a decade-plus as a broadcast meteorologist, I was often on the ground, um, after a disaster. 19:04 So I'd be in the studio kinda helping people prepare as storms are on the way, and then the disaster would strike, and I would turn to being the reporting meteorologist. 19:12 So I'd be out in the field the day after a tornado or a fire or whatever it was, and I saw the destruction. I saw the... I talked with the homeowners who, you know, in many cases had lost everything. 19:25 So I wanted to do something that made a bigger impact before the disaster strikes. 19:29 And when I came across IBHS and I read the job description, I said, "This is exactly what I'm already doing, but in a different environment." 19:37 And then when I got the chance to come and tour the facility and see the six-story wind tunnel, it was pretty much the coolest thing I had ever seen, and I knew I could put my skills to the, to use doing something kinda for the greater good. 19:51 So what I do at IBHS is I'm primarily a science communicator. 19:55 As I said, my background is in meteorology, but I spent a decade-plus developing stories, doing a lot of science storytelling, interviewing people on a range of subjects. 20:05 And so now I get to do that for IBHS, so I help communicate the research into different products that really help spread our message to a variety of audiences. 20:15 Could be homeowners, it could be builders in the construction industry, it could be in the public policy space. 20:22 And what we're really trying to do is influence people to move from inaction to action, where we want to lay the science out, explain how it could impact their lives, and put it into resilient strategies that, uh, people can put into action really quickly. 20:39 Uh, one really interesting thing about IBHS is we do the research, we look at the findings, and then we can pretty quickly implement it into our programs that can move into the market pretty quickly. 20:50 We did that with the FORTIFIED program, the Wildfire Prepared Home program, so we're able to put it into really tangible things that people can do to improve their homes and build better. 21:03 So I think one of the challenges with climate adaptation, resilience more generally, is actually being able to tell people, "Look, this might cost a little bit of money up front. 21:11 You might have to t- do some work to and invest some money to make your property more secure against a, a climate-driven disaster, a storm, a flood, whatever, but you will reap the dividends later on," right? 21:21 This idea of the resilience dividend. But that... s- I always find it doesn't quite gel with human nature. 21:26 Like, we want to see returns straight away, or if we're gonna invest in something, we wanna see a 10X return in terms of money coming to us rather than, "Oh, okay. Maybe my insurance premiums will go down in the future. 21:34 Maybe I won't have to worry about repairs in the future." But that's less tangible than having money in your hand. 21:40 So can you tell a little bit how you try and communicate that, like the, the resilience dividend benefits of doing these interventions? Yeah. 21:46 That, that's an interesting question, and that's something that actually we're still working on. 21:49 We're trying to figure out what combination of incentives or benefits can drive people to choose resilience, because resilience is not always the cheapest upfront cost, right? 22:01 As you mentioned, sometimes that return on investment is much, much later, or maybe the return on investment isn't to the homeowner itself. Maybe it's someone else who's actually paying for that upgrade. 22:10 So maybe the return on the investment is more towards the insurer or s- or someone else who paid for that upfront. So I think one thing we're trying to do is make resilience the default. 22:20 Typically, when you're making decisions about your home, choosing the resilient option is not really the standard practice in the United States. That's something that's still kind of newer. 22:29 Um, all these different resilient choices have, have been out there for a little while, but it's still not the default way that people think. 22:36 When th- people think about putting a new roof on, most people are just thinking, "Give me the cheapest," and in most cases that's going to be asphalt shingles. 22:44 And in some areas of the country, choosing an asphalt shingle roof might be an okay choice. 22:48 But in other areas of the country that experience frequent hail, maybe there's a different emerging material besides asphalt shingles, or maybe it's an impact-resistant asphalt shingle that could be the better choice. 23:00 So I think educating people, homeowners in particular, about the different choices that are available and that there are more resilient choices that can bring them a return on the investment. Maybe it's not... 23:11 Maybe it is in year one, and you're getting a discount from your insurer. If so, that's great. But in some cases it may not be in year one. 23:17 It might be on year 10 when you've chosen a different roof type, and one material may be starting to gr- degrade after year 10, but another type of roof material may still be just as fine as the day that you installed it. 23:31 So educating people on those differences and getting them to think about the lifetime return on investment. 23:38 Um, if you're getting a 30-year mortgage and you plan to stay in your home for 30 years, what choices can you make now and upfront that will pay dividends later on at year 15, 20, or even 30? 23:51 'Cause there are choices that you can make that bring that return on investment. And also, return on investment does not always mean financial. 23:57 Uh, we often hear that term, and we think it means money, and in many cases it does. But y- you can see the, the videos that we produce out of IBHS that shows the resilient home and the standard construction home. 24:10 Uh, often that resilient home looks just fine when we turn the wind chamber on, and the traditional construction, you know, is blowing out the back door. 24:18 Putting that return on investment into something that's tangible that people can see. Nobody wants to be living in the home that, that blows out the back door, right? You don't have to deal with that. 24:27 You don't have to deal with the displacement, the disruption, things like water entering into your home. 24:32 Maybe it causes a certain amount of financial devastation, but, you know, if you have family heirlooms, wedding photos, baby photos, things like that stored in your attic and they're all wet, some things are irreplaceable, and some things you just can't put a price tag on. 24:46 That's wonderful. I'm glad you gave that example at the end there, 'cause I was gonna ask how do you actually communicate what can seem kind of academic, science-y, technical building standards, blah, blah, blah. 24:54 How do you make that resonate with homeowners and- I was going to ask, the tools you're using as a communicator, plus I've seen some of the videos you've put out on the IBHS, these examples of not just the wind tunnel, but I know that IBHS has literally set fire to houses to show the benefits of Wildfire Plus Standard. 25:11 So can you tell us a little bit about the little tricks of the trade that you're using to try and get the word out further? Yeah. We do use a lot of, um, you know, capturing content in the form of videos. 25:22 As a member of the product design team, I get to be up front and center during these experiments, all these different types of experience, experiments capturing that video, and we like to show examples of what good and bad look like. 25:36 So for example, we often will show photos, what does a bad zone zero look like? 25:41 Zone zero is the first five feet surrounding your home, and that's what must be cleared to make your home the most resilient to wildfire, in addition to a lot, some other actions. 25:50 But we'll show bad examples, right, with thick vegetation in the first five feet that could catch the embers and lead to your home setting on fire. But then people say, "What does good look like? 25:59 Does that mean that it's just bare and gravel, that there's nothing there?" Not necessarily. 26:04 We went out and we, we filmed houses and took pictures of houses out in California that have beautifully landscaped their yards. 26:11 They've made really aesthetic landscapes with the different hardscaping, native plants, and they space them properly. They have the right amount. They have them in a way that looks really nice, but that's also resilient. 26:22 So when we show a bad example, we also try to show a good example as well, and vice versa. 26:28 And we like to show people what does it look like when your house is not resilient and when it's resilient, because it's easy to see the difference when they're side by side. 26:37 We try to do as much as we can with the side-by-side demos. 26:40 You've often seen those wildfire videos where half the home is burning down because it's built with combustible materials, and then the other half is built with more resilient materials, a metal gate, non-combustible siding, a Class A roof, things like that. 26:55 And when you can see the visible difference, it's, it's hard to argue with that. 26:59 And I wanted to ask a little bit about how we could maybe combine the drive to resilience with, I think, a uniquely American desire to have houses that are kind of cutting edge, that look good, that feel secure. 27:13 And I was taken by the story about this, this first wildfire-prepared neighborhood that IBHS put together in, I think it was Southern California with KB Homes. Is that right? Yes. 27:21 And I think those houses are cool, modern, high-tech. 27:24 They look aspirational to me, and I feel like there's some concerns about resiliency work upgrades can kind of look ugly, kind of people think, "Oh, it's gonna- you're gonna make my neighborhood look lame. 27:34 We can't have trees. We can't have vegetation." 27:37 And I've heard firsthand from former firefighters that they had issues trying to get homeowners in fire-prone areas to actually cut back their vegetation just because of the aesthetic reasons. 27:46 So I'm wondering, how do you think a little bit about how can you actually speak to this, the, the American homeowner who might be proud of a certain look and feel of a house. 27:53 How do you kind of try to combine that with what you're doing on resilience? Yeah. 27:56 That's an interesting concept as well, 'cause when people think sometimes when they hear the word you need to fortify your house, or you need to make your house more resilient, people often think about that we're talking about these, like, concrete bunkers that it can't look attractive. 28:10 It's not going to look nice. But if you are thinking about resilience as you're... 28:15 You know, if it's a new build, as you're designing your home, if you're incorporating that resilience into the design of your home, it can look really great. 28:22 Those homes that are being built in wildfire-prepared neighborhoods, they have really aesthetic-looking front yards and backyards. 28:29 And, um, in many cases, you had, whether it's an engineer or a landscape architect, you have these different people designing the look and feel of the home side by side. 28:39 So they're incorporating the science into it while also making it look aesthetically pleasing as well. So just kind of getting people to think about resilience as they're designing their homes. 28:50 Retrofitting is another option as well. We have people retrofit their roofs to the Fortified Roof standard. There's a lot of different options out there. 28:58 Um, we have a whole list of shingles that you can choose when it comes to your Fortified roof. So in many cases, there are multiple options for people to choose from. 29:06 So it's not this kind of one prescriptive thing, like this is your only choice, and it's not gonna look good, and it's one and done. There's usually a variety of different materials and things to choose from. 29:18 I was just out in Paradise, California, looking at wildfire resilient homes, and the Wildfire Prepared Home Standard is now in the local Paradise building code. So they've adopted it for all new build homes. 29:29 They will just automatically be built to this higher standard that mimics the IBHS standard. And one thing I noticed is all the different metal gates out there. 29:39 I was so surprised to see in many cases, not only was the last five feet non-combustible and made of metal, but so many people had incorporated these really cool, like, metal designs into their gates with trees and bears and different animals and things incorporated into, to the metal design of the gate. 29:57 So there are cool materials out there. There are different materials. 30:00 There are materials that look good, and that was one thing that really surprised me, is just how awesome something as simple as a metal gate could look when you are intentional about it. 30:10 Yes, they can be canvases for human creativity. We find a way to personalize our homes, right? 30:15 And I'm glad you mentioned about, like, kind of the spectrum of interventions you could do, 'cause I think that's important going back to the affordability question. 30:21 Some people might be able to shell out a little bit more to do a full retrofit, get, like, ember-resistant vents, for example, do the zero, zero vegetation, and do everything you need to do to make your house fireproof. 30:32 But then some folks might be like, "Okay, actually, a bit too much. I want to make sure my house is secure, but I can't really do that right now." 30:37 And I know there are efforts underway at the state level, and some insurers as well are trying to provide financial help for that. 30:42 But can you talk a little bit about maybe, like, quicker fixes, less expensive fixes that people can do to secure their homes? Yeah. We, we do realize that it's, it's a lot. 30:50 Um, and our, our science shows that in the case of most hazards, it is... We kind of use this term, it's a system of mitigation. And- The hazard will find the weak link. 31:00 A great example that was given to me by a researcher recently, you know, let's say that you do the whole set of actions to prepare your home about wildfire, but on the day that there's a wildfire threat, you leave your garbage can up against your home. 31:14 An ember can land on that garbage can, and because it's made of a combustible material, and then perhaps there's garbage in the garbage can, which we've seen on a lot of damage surveys in the field, that garbage can still light on fire, and it can lead to damage on your home. 31:29 So that's what I mean when we say it's a whole system. Even if there's one weak link, like a garbage can, that could lead to damage or destruction of your home. But what we tell people is start where you can, right? 31:40 So if your roof is 15 or 20 years old and it's time for a new roof, look into upgrading your roof to a fortified roof. Look at the incentives available. 31:48 Maybe they're right for you, and it's a good time for you to upgrade to something more resilient. If, when it comes to wildfire, start by clearing your, the first five feet around your home. 31:58 That's gonna make a big difference. 31:59 That's where embers land and accumulate, and that's the area of your home that is very likely to ignite during a wildfire situation when you have millions and millions of embers being driven by the wind. 32:11 So start with what you can do on a weekend. Do one project on a weekend, complete it, and then move on to the next thing. Maybe the next thing is retrofitting your vents against the ember intrusion for a wildfire. 32:23 And then over... I- even if it takes you a year's time, at the end of that year, if you've incrementally taken all the different steps, then after a year you may have the entire system in place and not even realize it. 32:34 So just start with what you think is tangible and doable for you, and work your way up from there. 32:39 But just know that it's kind of a layered approach, so for every extra layer of resilience that you add on to your home, becomes increasingly more resilient against the hazard. 32:49 And having that full kind of system or set of actions in place is what's going to protect you the most. Yes, resilience is a state. It's not really like a destination. 32:58 It's not like I do X, Y, and Z, and I'm gonna be resilient forever [laughs]. It's like, no, you have to keep doing mitigations. 33:04 Yeah, mixing and matching as your budget and your time depends, and hopefully over time you continue to do that, you will stay one step ahead of extreme weather disasters. Yeah, no. That's a good point. 33:12 You do always have to stay one step ahead. Even if you do all the actions, you still have to do things like making sure your non-combustible gutters are free of leaf and tree debris and pine straw. 33:23 I have to make sure that you keep the tr- the plants and things trimmed back that are in your zone one, because even having an abundance of vegetation in, in zone one, so five feet out, in s- in certain cases, that can, that can lead to, to damage as well. 33:36 So just kind of maintaining that resilience. You do have to continue to take smaller actions, but there's maintenance involved, regular maintenance. Okay, finally, I wanna broaden the scope here, right? 33:47 'Cause the IBHS, you work with insurers, you work with policy makers, you work with, uh, homeowners and those involved in, in, in home building. 33:55 And I wanted to get your sense of where we are in the US in terms of the state of publicly accessible, publicly available information on extreme weather risk and on resilience and on early warning systems as well. 34:07 There's been some concern with cutbacks to NOAA, that we've lost a lot of capacity to provide early warning. We have private sector entities coming in. I've interviewed a few of them. 34:15 There's multiple firms who are trying to provide personalized extreme weather guidance and alerts to people via their phones. Uh, if you look... 34:22 taking a step back, look at the, kind of the whole network of private and public services out there, what, what do you... where do you think we're at in terms of extreme weather resilience and preparedness? 34:31 And then what do you think needs to be done to, to improve it? Yeah, I think going back to what we've talked a, a little bit about, our forecasting is great. 34:37 We have more technology than ever to, to deliver the data, and now we have AI that's come on board over the last couple of years. We have pretty much unlimited access to all the information that we need. 34:49 I think at the end of the day, um, it's still a matter of getting people to act on that information, right? We have to find out what motivates people at this point. It's less about... 34:59 There's still science questions we have to answer, but for the most part we have the basic answers that we need surrounding what you need to do for the various hazards, what steps you need to take. 35:08 So at this point it seems like it's more of a behavioral, kind of behavioral science problem. 35:14 What are these products and technologies that can motivate people to action, whether that's motivating someone to take cover during a tornado warning, uh, which you know now has a great lead time, right? 35:25 Back in the '70s or so, i- if the tornadoes were warned at all, it was just a few minutes notice. Today we have 15 minutes or more lead time on tornado warnings. 35:34 We have these underground tornado shelters that people can install in their garages and underground. 35:39 So all the tools we need to protect our lives and our property are all the information that we have is out there, we just have to figure out kind of the right combinations and incentives that, A, help people understand the information that we're presenting, and then B, motivate them to act on that information, whether it's installing a more resilient roof or whether it's purchasing flood insurance even though they don't live in a flood zone, but they understand that extreme rainfall could lead to flooding in their neighborhood and, and cause damage. 36:08 So I think it's just finding new and better ways to present the information, make sure people understand it, and reaching all of the, the different audiences that, that need to know the information. 36:19 Because this, the way a homeowner interprets one piece of information is going to be different than how a contractor needs to know about, uh, another piece of information when it comes to resilient construction or something like that. 36:30 We have all these different audiences, and everyone has different motivators. So finding out what motivates each audience and then kind of helping educate them. 36:39 And finally, I wanted to ask what your priorities are at the IBHS for the rest of this year. We're in- getting into the peak wildfire season. We're in hurricane season now. 36:48 But what's in your inbox and what do you hope to achieve by the end of this year with the IBHS? That's a good question. 36:53 We're working on all sorts of things, and actually I'm part of the strategy team developing the strategy for the next three years at IBHS. 37:01 And through the end of this year we're trying to bring, send everything to the finish line. 37:05 Uh, one big project we're working on is damage amplifier, so, uh, kind of I- uh, putting buildings in our wind shaver, trying to blow them apart and find out which small components can lead to bigger failures on the rest of the building. 37:18 So that's a project that we're gonna be finishing up this year, the damage amplifiers project. 37:22 We're doing a lot of work on vegetation when it comes to wildfire, looking at how different types of vegetation can spread or not spread wildfire to a building. 37:33 So that's a big project that's on par for the rest of this year. Looking ahead to the next few years, we've done a lot of work on really big wildfire experiments, like burning entire houses down. 37:44 We've developed our ember generator to figure out how all the different components of a home fail when it comes to wildfire, but there's a lot of medium-scale research that needs to be done, so more work on the vegetation, more work on things like mulch for example, and how it can spread wildfire to different types of like wall cladding, things like that. 38:03 That doesn't look quite as exciting as the rest of the video 'cause it's kind of like a slow smoldering fire that maybe takes an hour or two to ignite a wall if it ignites. 38:13 But there are a lot of questions like that that we still need to answer when it comes to wildfire. And then hail, we've identified lots of different damage modes when it comes to hail. 38:22 We've put out our list of impact-resistant kind of shingle ratings, but kind of helping people understand those damage modes. 38:29 For example, granule loss has been something that has historically been considered kind of a cosmetic type of damage, but at, at IBHS over the last few years we've identified that it's actually what we believe is functional damage. 38:41 Like those granules actually serve a purpose, so when they're knocked off they can be degraded by UV and things like that. 38:48 So- And these are granules, for those don't know like myself, granules on the roof or on the tarmac outside the house or- Yeah, sorry. 38:53 So on a, on an asphalt shingle roof you have the little sort of like pebble-looking things that maybe fall off the asphalt shingle. 39:00 They're very rough when you touch them, and so they are protecting that kind of asphalt shingle mat. 39:05 And they naturally fall off over time due to natural weathering, but a lot of our research over the last couple of years with hail has found that when the hailstones hit the roof a, a large number of those granules can be knocked off. 39:18 And when you have large numbers of them getting knocked off your roof, that can degrade the performance of your roof because that U- UV in the sun then degrades that mat that's underneath the granule loss. 39:28 So communicating the different types of damage modes that we've discovered and how they can impact your regular roof performance, your roof performance over time, things like that. 39:37 So still a lot of questions to be answered, but really we've answered a lot of the questions we need to know. Now it's how do we implement it at scale? How do we make these everyday decisions become the default? 39:48 Um, kind of our go-to tagline at IBHS is how do we make resilience the default, not the exception? We want people to think of resilience as something that they should just do. It's like designing your home. 39:59 You pick out the kitchen cabinets and you pick out what your bathroom's gonna look like. 40:04 What are the resilient features of your home that you should pick out and think about as you're building a home, as you're buying a home, things like that. Big jobs ahead of you then. 40:13 And it sounds like you're covering all the hazards and all aspects of resilience. And I think it's wonderful that IBHS is investing more in this communication side as well, 'cause I think that is a missing piece. 40:23 I think we have the science, we know it works, but just getting people to adopt it, and also in convincing other stakeholders to help stump up the money for some of this is important, and communications, good communication can go a long way to, to unlocking that. 40:33 So appreciate what you're doing at the IBHS, Rachel, and thank you so much for being on the pod. Yeah, thanks for having me. Really appreciate it. [upbeat music] Climate Proofer's is a Climate Proof Media production. 40:44 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 40:51 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]