Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of adaptation finance, tech, and policy. 0:12 My name's Louis Woodhill, and I'm the editor of Climate Proof, which you can read at www.climateproof.news. This summer, Europe got a preview of its climate future. 0:22 Heat waves pushed temperatures above 40 degrees Celsius across the center of the continent. Low water on the Danube forced nuclear plants offline, and shipping on the Rhine nearly stopped. 0:32 By some estimates, between 35,000 and 50,000 additional people died from the heat. 0:38 The European Commission called it the summer of truth, and at the end of October, it responded with the EU's first dedicated climate resilience framework. 0:46 The package has three parts: a non-binding blueprint for EU member states on building resilience, a set of risk tools, including an interactive European climate viewer, and at its center, a proposed climate resilience law. 0:59 That law would require every member state to assess its climate risks against common warming scenarios, assign ownership of those risks, and draw up plans to manage them. 1:08 My guest today is Paolo Caridi, head of the Unit for Resilience and Adaptation to Climate Change at the European Commission's Directorate-General for Climate Action. 1:17 We discuss why Europe needs a resilience law when it already has a climate law and an adaptation strategy. 1:23 We also cover why the commission chose to plan for three degrees of warming by the end of this century while staying committed to the Paris goals, and where an estimated 70 billion euros a year in adaptation investment will come from when the law creates no new funding stream. 1:37 We then get into the role of insurers and banks in a block where only a quarter of assets are insured against climate hazards, and what happens next as the proposal moves to the European Parliament and Council. 1:46 Before we get to the interview, your weekly reminder to become a Climate Proof member. We're on a mission to win over 40 odd new paying members to get us to our year-end target of 350. 1:57 If you value Climate Proof and want to see it survive and thrive, then please consider becoming a member by heading to www.climateproof.news/upgrade. 2:06 Also, if you're listening on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, why not give us a star rating and drop a review too if you have the time? It really helps with getting the pod in front of new people. 2:16 Right, in a moment my conversation with Paolo, but first a rundown of last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 2:22 [whooshing] In finance, a draft decision out of the UN Climate Conference, COP31, would set the tripling of adaptation finance from rich to poor countries at a minimum of $120 billion annually by 2035. 2:35 It would also ask developed countries for a roadmap showing how they will scale up their contributions to poor nations by that year. 2:41 The draft text, published on Monday, is a launching-off point for negotiations and is likely to change significantly before being adopted by the conference. 2:49 Still, it shows that climate negotiators are keen to clarify the adaptation finance commitment first agreed to at COP30 last year. 2:56 [whooshing] In policy, a federal appeals court blocked California's climate-related financial risk disclosure law, ruling that forcing companies to judge how climate change threatens their businesses amounts to compelled speech, which is unconstitutional in most cases. 3:10 The Ninth Circuit Appeals Court ordered a preliminary injunction against the disclosure law, known as SB 261, on November the 9th. 3:17 The law would have required about 2,675 companies doing business in California to report every two years on their physical and transition climate risks. 3:26 They would also have had to report the steps taken to reduce and adapt to those risks using the guidance set out by the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures. 3:34 [whooshing] And in tech, AI forecasting tools are letting poor nations' weather agencies run advanced models without supercomputers, improving the quality and accuracy of early warning systems. 3:44 That's according to a new UN report, The Global Status of Multi-Hazard Early Warning Systems. 3:49 However, the report warns that internet connectivity issues and a dearth of technical staff could widen the divide between countries with strong early warning infrastructure and those without. 3:59 Only 15% of World Meteorological Organization members report having enough technical staff to maintain observing networks, while 29 national weather services operate on unstable internet connections. 4:09 [whooshing] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now onto my conversation with Paolo. [upbeat music] Hi, Paolo. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hello. I'm calling from Brussels. 4:22 I'm the head of a unit dealing with resilience and adaptation to climate change in the Directorate-General for Climate Action in the European Commission. Thank you for being here today, Paolo. 4:31 I have you on the pod to talk about the new climate resilience framework that the EU released at the end of October. 4:39 This has been many years in the making and is something that I've been covering at Climate Proof, and I know a lot of our listeners and readers are interested in learning more about. 4:47 So perhaps we can start [chuckles] at the very beginning. What problem is the EU framework for climate resilience designed to solve? 4:54 I've been in climate change for many years, and I'm quite new to resilience, but I still remember distinctly when I start working on this that resilience adaptation was considered something which was not a big concern for developed country, let's say 20 years ago. 5:10 It was seen something for developing country and also something maybe for next generation. 5:15 And in the meantime, little by little, we came to realize that no, it's not for future generation, neither is only for developing countries. So it's a problem which we need to tackle in Europe as much as everywhere else. 5:28 So this is really the, the foundation. Why a framework? 5:32 Uh, for a number of reason, but I would say the key reason is that, uh, as of now, the, there are many countries, many member state of the European Union who have already some sort of climate risk assessment or climate adaptation plans, but it's very patchy. 5:49 Uh, the risk assessments are sometime only sectoral, or they use also different kind of reference scenario in term of what to expect in the next decade. 6:01 So we felt that there was a need At European Union level, so as a continent basically, to have a framework which was much more uniform. 6:11 And this could only be done, in our view, by a legislative proposal, and that's why we decided to move into that direction to really try to have something which, as I said, is uniform, but it's also... 6:23 so really forward-looking because very often the mindset when it comes to resilience is basically trying to sort out problem after crisis be striking, and in reality we really want to be as much as possible anticipatory, uh, and structured in preparing ahead. 6:40 So yes, the idea of the framework is to fix what has been a fragmented piecemeal system for addressing climate risks and building resilience across the EU. 6:51 It's called a framework, and I think if we could just take a step back, what does that framework actually entail? There are some legislative measures, yes, but there's also some non-statutory measures too. 7:00 Can you talk a little bit about what the package looks like? Absolutely. Now, indeed, I move directly into the legislation, but indeed this is a framework and there are three main components in that package. 7:10 So for one side, there is what we call a communication, which in new lingo means basically a plan for the future at EU level, and this is something we as the European Commission, which you can say we are the executive of EU, have been putting out autonomously. 7:28 It's not legally binding. It's more of a roadmap or a plan if you want. 7:32 It contains a number of components, and it's pretty broad in its design because it includes the reason is indeed why we think we need to tackle climate resilience. 7:44 It explain also what is already there and how we do see basically the future moving. Then there is a legislative proposal, so it's a regulation, which means it's directly applicable for, to member state. 7:54 It's a proposal of course, because in our legislative system, basically the European Commission makes a proposal and then we need the European Parliament and the European Council, which are the legislative powers basically to approve our proposal and amend it if needed. 8:09 So that part is legally binding, but at this stage it's, it's a proposal. 8:14 And then there is a third part which is about tools because as we want this to be tackled in a much more uniform way across Europe, we felt it was also necessary in parallel to create an obligation to facilitate the work of the, the, the addressee of this legislation, which are basically our member states, our European countries. 8:36 So that's why we have these tools, and among these tools there are three of them. One is what we could call a, a repository, so it's a really a list of existing tools at a level of member state which can be useful. 8:52 The second one is a sort of collection of best cases, and then the third, which in reality is the most important, it's a European climate viewer, which is basically an interactive map which allow you to see depending on climate scenario, and this climate scenario are basically 1.5 degree increase by 2030, 2 degrees by the 2050, and then 3 degrees by the end of the century. 9:17 And you can then decide which sector you want to look at, which kind of phenomenon, so can be heat waves, can be drought, can be on the contrary precipitations, and then you can have a view at a 12-kilometer definition. 9:32 So it's not very granular, but still it gives you pretty good indications for people who need to just take decision or have a view for planning future investment or future public authority decision at a, at a level which is not local, but which is, has a bigger scale. 9:50 And one example we often use is, for instance, if you are a railway company and y- which goes across different member state and you want to know what the temperature will look like in 2050 and whether there are area which are prone to be flooded so that you can start designing, well, this tool is, could be quite useful in fact. 10:08 These are the three, three key components o- of a package as it, it is defined now. That's very helpful. Yes. 10:14 So the tools are meant to empower member states and subnational governments to see their client risks, understand some of the trade-offs with investing in resilience. So I see the value there. 10:25 The communication is, as you said, sort of indications of where the commission wants to go in terms of engaging other entities, including the private sector in the hard work of resilience. 10:36 And then we do have the centerpiece climate resilience law, and I would like to get into that law in particular because from my understanding, the EU's not really starting from scratch here. 10:45 There is an adaptation strategy in the EU, and there is a climate law that was passed. So my question is, why do we now need a dedicated climate resilience law if there were these other building blocks in place already? 10:56 Yeah, that's a very good question. For, in fact, indeed, we have already climate law. We have also have a European Union climate risk assessment, which are already in place. 11:05 So indeed there are some, some good foundations. However, none of them was specifically looking at resilience. 11:14 Even climate law, which is not so old, it's only three year old, the new version of, of a climate law, but the part dedicated to resilience I tend to consider still relatively weak, and this is probably the reflection of the fact that mitigation is traditionally being considered a priority and it still is a priority. 11:34 I mean, we can discuss it maybe later, but it's obvious that the fact that we want to deal with building resilience doesn't mean we want to do less effort on reducing emissions. 11:45 Also, there was, for instance, an obligation on member states to do climate risk assessment, so many of them, I think 16 of them have one, but as I said before, it's a bit patchy and references are different. 11:58 So uniformity was a key, and also making sure that at EU level, of course, we will continue and improve this, but at member state l- level as well, that we'll have basically Good risk assessment, good attribution of risk, which was not in previous legislation, making sure that Xante government decide who is in charge of different risk and tackle, uh, tackling them. 12:26 So this is something which was absolutely not there yet. And also the having plans is something relatively new. 12:33 Again, member state do have plans, but they are made a bit on an ad hoc base, while we felt that for all risk which is considered critical or serious in, in the risk assessments, there is a need to elaborate a plan, and that plan needs then to, to go down to local authority and then ultimately to businesses, households as well, obviously. 12:58 Hearing you speak, it does sound like the law is more about standardization than imposing burdensome new requirements, and I think this comes back to a common complaint amongst those who are trying to push for resilience, is that we don't have standardized data. 13:13 There are plenty of gaps in our view on risks at the national and supranational level. 13:18 And so is one of the objectives of the climate resilience law to create the standardization that allows the EU, commission, parliament, council, et cetera, to have better information over time to then make maybe more targeted interventions in the future? 13:33 Well, the short reply is yes, absolutely. 13:36 Because what we have been observing is that there is a need to have not only better information, but also to have a, a more uniform way of dealing with data and to using them in building national or local plans. 13:50 And in fact, it's true that, uh, the third article, well, the second article, is about definition. 13:55 And when we drafted the definition, we realized that for many topics there was not even a commonly agreed definition of things as banal or as tolerable level risk. 14:08 Even climate resilience was not defined, at least not defined in EU law. So we felt this was... And that's why it's the first article basically of the law. It, it deals with a long list of definition. 14:19 Some existed already, some we have to basically make them up. And also the, the ultimate objective. So i- it's really about... 14:26 It's a bit process-oriented, if you want, because we are not putting a lot of things like precise KPI or what we want to be done. 14:35 It's how you should build a system which allows you basically to have better resilience in the future. 14:42 And it's really a lot about processes, about using reliable data, using common reference scenarios, and through that, getting ultimately to have your, your future policy. 14:56 And this is not only about climate policies, about a- all policies, to make sure that they are designed in a way which makes basically the country and the local community resilient to climate change ultimately. Yes. 15:09 There's this component of the framework about resilience by design and embedding resilience into infrastructure. 15:16 So yes, this is, goes beyond just pure climate policy into how future and upgrades to existing infrastructure, how they look like, how they're conducted across the EU. So we know that resilience is not really a goal. 15:29 You have to keep adapting [chuckles] and to keep build resilience and adapt your resilience. But I am wondering, like, what's the, the hope here? 15:36 Let's say the climate resilience law is rushed into effect and the framework is all put together. What do you think will be different about how Europe prepares for climate impacts in 10 years' time? 15:48 I'm glad you ask about 10 years' time, because this obviously is something which will not have an impact on next summer. I mean, this summer has been an eye-opener for many people. 15:58 Maybe not for the people who have been working on climate change or who are, are very active about it, but for many people, we have heat waves in places like, like England or the Netherlands, where this was not very common, I would say, to say the least. 16:12 We had droughts, again, in places where this never happened before. Temperature above 40 degrees Celsius basically all over the center of Europe. 16:22 We had nuclear power plant who need to be shut down because there was not enough water to cool down in a river as big as the Danube. 16:30 The Rhine River basically almost stopping maritime navigation there because there was not enough water. So it has been, I would say, an eye-opener i- in term of showing what the situation was. 16:42 Now, this has been helping us because it came in, in a moment where we are finalizing basically a- the design of our legislation, and this became very politically important. 16:52 However, there is a risk with that because obviously people and politicians want a solution for next summer, and our law is not designed with that view. Our law has been in the making for a long time. 17:04 It came out in a moment of, perceived as a moment of truth across the European Union. 17:09 I think the, our president call it the, the summer of truth, and I think it's very true, but that it's also important that we make clear this is about having long-term impact. And what... How do I expect to be different? 17:22 Well, first, I expect across Europe in all member state and at the European level to have risk assessment to be done in a very uniform manner and to identify the critical area of risk. 17:34 And obviously, critical area risk are going to be completely different from one member state to another. 17:40 In the Nordic, probably it's going to be about coastal erosion and flooding, and in the south it's going to be more droughts and heat waves. 17:48 But that's left, and it should be left to every individual member state to assess. So once people and countries identify where the vulnerability are, then the plan will be made. 18:00 And the plan, if you know what your future is in term of temperature increase and you have been identify the, the critical risks, then any government is somehow obliged, at least politically obliged, to make sure they also tackle with the risk and they give the attribution, and with attribution comes obviously powers and budget to local authority or to other public body who need to tackle it. 18:23 So my hope is that in 10 years' time We'll have first a much clearer vision of where the risks are. 18:30 Second, a clear plan, and this will take less than 10 years I hope, and by 10 years I would say we'll be in the first cycle of building infrastructures which are more resilience to making sure we build houses, business, et cetera, in places which are less prone to be affected by climate change. 18:49 Ultimately making sure that the assets in, in the EU are not stranded, basically. 18:54 And I'm not talking about, of course, reducing loss of life because this summer, depending on the estimate, there have been something between 35,000 and 50,000 people who died because of... 19:04 Well, additional people died because of heat wave, and this is a very big number we hope not to see in the future anymore. 19:12 Yes, the toll in lives and economic activity lost in assets damaged is going to be high and could still increase in the years to come. 19:21 But it sounds to me like we're kind of hoping that EU member states won't be caught by surprise by certain climate risks going forward. 19:28 If they are doing these assessments in a standardized manner, if they are aware of the kind of priority of impacts of hazards that they face, then they can kind of prioritize interventions to deal with those. 19:39 And while we may, we are definitely going to see more extreme heat waves, more extreme storms, and sea level rise accelerating, et cetera, the idea is that each member state will be aware of those risks coming down the pipe and, and be able to invest in preparations appropriately. 19:54 I wanted to turn now to this point on the climate scenarios, right? The baseline set by the Climate Resilience Law is 1.5 degrees of warming by 2030, 2 degrees by 2050, and 3 degrees by 2100. 20:08 These to me seem pretty sensible given that we already have evidence that we are overshooting the 1.5 degree warming threshold. 20:17 Current trajectories looking at current policies suggest that somewhere between 2.5 and 3 degrees of warming by the end of the century makes sense. 20:25 However, the EU remains committed to the Paris goals, [laughs] which is keeping warming below two degrees. 20:30 So there is some discrepancy there, and I'm wondering why did this law, why did the commission want the planning around 3 degrees, and how do you answer those who might see this as conceding defeat on mitigation? 20:42 Yeah, that's a very good question. I started mention it already before that adaptation is not an alternative to mitigation. 20:49 It's very clear that if you go in a world with unconstrained growth of greenhouse gases, we'll end up to something which is probably much worse than 3 degrees, and where the cost of adaptation, and sometime even the very possibility of the adaptation, will become so daunting that it's going to be almost impossible to tackle and it will imply enormous financial efforts. 21:13 But yes, in a way you can say there is an inconsistency because of course the European Union remains totally committed to the Paris Agreement goals of the, the two degrees and, if possible, also below 1.5 degrees. 21:26 This remain our, I would say, North Star in term of policy making, and this has been also the references we have been using in all our emission reduction policy. 21:37 And as you know, we, we have our 55% reduction by 2030, which we think we are basically on track to achieve. But then there is a much more ambitious target of 90% reduction by 2040 and climate neutrality by 2050. 21:52 This for us remain important. They are in law. They will happen. So it's quite clear we are not abandoning mitigation, so I think this is very important that, that everybody understand it very clearly. 22:04 But as you rightly said, at the same time we also see 1.5 degree being either al- already overachieved or certainly within this decade we will have, I think, let's say even a scientific measurement to tell us, yes, we have been going above 1.5 degrees. 22:21 So why we choose these scenarios? We did because these are basically sort of the more... most realistic scenario under IPCC. I would like to add these numbers are the global numbers we have been using because in... 22:34 we have... 22:35 What we have been experiencing is that for the time being, Europe is heating up more or less twice as fast as global, so the 1.5 global is more or less something around 3 degrees we have been experiencing in Europe with peaks around the Mediterranean Sea even higher than that. 22:53 So by the end of the century we expect climate change to be a bit more uniform a- across countries and continents, but for the time being we know we are heating much more than that. 23:02 So for us that was an absolute necessity. It's a... In a way it's a call of reality. The 1.5 degree is no longer within reach. 23:10 We still think we should go back to that, so it's not only that we want to absolutely stay below two degrees, but we also want in the long term to go even below 1.5. 23:20 So you can say that maybe our objective to, to the end of the century is something we hope it will not happen, and maybe we might have over invested in resilience if this happens. But at the same time we are not alone. 23:33 Other, other part of the world are not as committed as us or are not invested as much as us on mitigation, hence we cannot control alone basically what, what the global temperature increase will be as much as we are trying even now in COP. 23:48 But it's something we cannot control alone, and resilience is something which we cannot afford anymore to be considered as, as a secondary policy. So that's why we decided to, to really use this scenario, which are... 24:02 We are not over-pessimistic, I would say. We are just realistic. With the present projection, this is more or less where we are going to get basically according to IPCC, according to United Nation Environment Program. 24:16 I think they recently raised to 2.8 degrees by the end of the century, which is very, very close to our 3 degrees. 24:23 Yes, so it's a realistic set of scenarios, and the argument is, like, prepare for The likely reality while still working to, to mitigate lower emissions as much as possible. 24:34 So you're hoping that actually that three degrees is never reached. But then at the other end of the spectrum, you do have certain parties, certain member states even preparing for even greater degrees of warming. 24:45 I believe the French National Adaptation Strategy asks local governments to prepare for four degrees of warming by the end of this century. So what do you say to those who might say, "Actually- Yes... 24:54 you're not being realistic enough, or you're being too conservative," and does that mean that there could be, like, tail risks that European nations don't see because they're planning for a three-degree world, when in reality a four-degree world is actually going to happen? 25:06 That's, that's a pol- a policy choice, and when we will prepare our own climate risk assessment and plans, of course, we will look at what is realistically happening in Europe. 25:18 As I said, we are already now basically at close plus three degrees in Europe. 25:23 So when the European Environment Agency will do the next risk assessment, we will take into account, of course, the global reality, but at the same time also what we believe will happen in Europe because at the end of the day, the plan will be about policies and investment to be done within the European Union. 25:40 Hence, we are probably go to develop our plans based on something which is in fact worse than this. Now, whether globally it's going to be more than three degree, I really hope not. 25:52 So we believe our assumption are not only based on science, but of course there is a, there is a policy choice as well to be, again, to something which we believe has a very high likelihood of happening without being neither optimistic but not too pessimistic either. 26:09 Also for economic reason because of course, if you plan for four or five degrees, you are probably over-invested in resilience in places and in investment where it's not necessary. So you say this term policy choice. 26:23 Does that mean that given the future progression of the scientific reality of climate change, there could be changes to the law to say, "Okay, actually we're gonna want a four-degree scenario as well"? Yes, absolutely. 26:35 Now, there is a provision explicit in the law which says that this scenario, I mean, the, the reference trajectory in the law might be amended if or when there are new, new scientific evidences. 26:47 So it can go both ways, in fact. All right. I wanna turn to the communication part of the framework now. So we mentioned earlier climate resilience by design, which is a big plank of this communication. 26:59 However, the law only requires member states to encourage public authorities to use climate risk trajectories and assessments. 27:06 So I'm wondering, is encouragement enough to alter the course of budgets and change planning decisions by member states? 27:14 What sort of carrots and sticks can the commission, can the EU as a whole provide to actually make climate resilience by design happen? Well, encouragement per se obviously is not sufficient. 27:26 However, the resilience by design is really about a number of things. 27:31 It's, for us, it's the result of its overall framework, so the reference trajectory, the different risk management, which are what I, I mentioned, so the risk assessment, the strategic plan, and then the risk ownership. 27:46 So all these three component are what you can call resilience by design. 27:51 Now, the article you mentioned which speak about encouraging public authority to use trajectory and risk assessment, uh, it's across the entire economy, obviously. It means that it being an encouragement not... 28:04 Member state are not obliged to use that, but at the same time, the fact that it's clearly spelled out, it gives as a minimum, I would say, political responsibility. 28:16 So if you are a local administration or even in a ministry or a secretary in a, in a member state and you just disregard the trajectory when making your planning and investment decision in area which are not directly climate, can be transport, can be energy, can be even defense, certainly territorial planning, well, probably you're doing something which is backward-looking because there are assumptions in any event, and those assumption can be based on the past as unfortunately it has been the case very often until now, and you'll end up with stranded assets and bad investments. 28:54 Or you can use this, this reference which is now there, and it's the same for everybody, and use it. 29:00 You might decide to, to disregard the result, but making your investment based only on past data is certainly a very bad choice for, for any administration. 29:10 I think it's, it's, it's against any good administrative practices. Again, is enough. 29:16 Well, of course, if we could have prepared something m- more binding saying that o- in all investment or planning you must or you should use the reference scenario. 29:28 This was, was probably going a step too far in the sense that would have been probably criticized as a tick the box exercise where in any possible public decision you need basically to say, "Yes, this has been considered," and in reality the, the concrete impact might not have been so much. 29:47 While with the system we have now, with at least for critical risk identified in the risk assessment, there will be the need to do a plan, and all this based on the common trajectory, we believe the impact will be there still. 30:00 As always, with European Union level legislation or framework building, there is a need to build consensus, and I understand that. 30:08 But I suppose the question I have is, do you don't know in advance whether you struck the right balance between consensus and making sure that member states are doing enough to ensure that they're protecting their own citizens and their own governments essentially from, from climate risks? 30:22 But can you talk a little about why you chose encourage rather than should or must? 30:26 Is, is it a political and policy choice or is it because you want to give member states the flexibility they might need given their own data, their own understanding of their risks? 30:34 Well, first, we are not at the end of the road. 30:36 This is a commission proposal, and it might well be that in the parliament or even in the council some member state might Want to do more, and some might consider that maybe encouraging is already too much. 30:48 So a-as always, we try as a European Commission to strike the right balance as much as possible with our proposal to somehow make it easier the life of co-legislators. 31:00 Now, whether we, in this case, this is the balance which will be the one retained at the end of a legislative process, honestly, it's very difficult to anticipate. 31:10 Why we decided to take this balance point is because overall, the European Union now is rather in a phase of simplification rather than in a, in a moment of strong regulatory activity, so that was, I would say, a general framing in which we are, we are operating now, especially when it comes to environment and climate. 31:30 We still keep a very high level of ambitions, but we try to achieve it with a minimum administrative burden and cost. 31:37 So this was part of a philosophy which is, as I said, behind all our legislative processes now and commission proposals, and we need that to take that into account as well. 31:50 As I said, an exercise where you oblige all decision at all level of government and in all economic sector to take into account would probably have been considered, like, too intrusive into, into all level of governance and very difficultly being accepted by, by member states. 32:09 So with a system we created now, despite not having an obligation of climate resilience by design, we believe a combination of a different element brings you pretty close to that, at least in the area where risk are very high. 32:25 It's true in area where risk are less high, government might decide to, to use or, well, or not to tackle basically resilience or, or not to use a reference scenario. 32:37 But again, this is a conscious choice we need to make, and we need to take the responsibilities ultimately. 32:43 Yes, and I take your point about this not being the finished article, so to say, because there is going to be negotiations between the different organizations of the European Union. 32:53 But I did wanna turn to the question now of financing. So a recent report, I believe it was from the European Environment Agency, estimates adaptation needs across the bloc at around seventy billion euros a year. 33:06 But to my understanding, the law itself, the Climate Resilience law and the framework, creates no new dedicated funding streams for the EU, for member states to fill that gap. 33:16 So where will the money come from for implementing the Climate Resilience law for making member states hardened against climate risks? 33:23 The, the seventy billion a year of additional investment needed is also what we have been retaining in our communication, and this is, is probably still a relatively underestimation of the real needs over the next decade, but that's what we-- is, is being estimated now. 33:42 We didn't create dedicated funding streams, I would say, for a number of reasons. First, because we are in the middle of negotiating our next budget. The European Union doesn't work only with annual budget. 33:54 We have a multi-annual budgeting system which runs over seven years, and in fact, we are in the middle of negotiating the next multi-annual fra- financial framework. 34:04 That means that the moment was not right to making a proposal for a new fund or a new facility. Does that mean that there will be no money at European level? 34:17 I don't think so, because at the same time, there is already earmarking for green policies. Now, this is not specific indeed to adaptation. 34:27 It's more across mitigation, adaptation, and also other environmental policies, but it's a sizable part of it will certainly go into adaptation, and there is a lot of appetite by member state and by also policymakers to improve the resilience in a number of sectors. 34:44 So some of that money will come from that. 34:47 At the same time, for instance, the European Investment Bank has been also earmarking thirty billion to be invested in climate resilience in the next years, so that's also something which will certainly help, especially because this not typically come as a co-financing, so it's not... 35:05 It-it's also something which has a multiplier effect, obviously. 35:08 Having said all this, there will be some money at European level, but it's quite clear that most of the money will come not even at national, but at local level because resilience, building resilience to climate change is very much done at regional level. 35:23 There could be big nationwide project or, you know, even European-wide project, if you think about, for instance, strategic energy grids or railway or even road systems, this can be tackled at a larger scale. 35:39 But the bulk of investment will be about houses, companies, local infrastructures, hospitals, you name it. So this is something which will have to be basically paid at, at national level or at local level. 35:56 You have to compare it with how much money y- it will cost to do nothing. 36:00 Now, if you look at how much we estimated, well, the European environmental changes, so the same body who estimated the seventy billion the investment need, they also estimate, in fact, economic pure losses or asset lost in the region of fifty billion per year. 36:17 If you take this summer, we have a very recent study by an insurance that only because of a heat wave between June and August in Europe, we lost something like under the ten billion. 36:30 And this is not only actual losses of assets which were destroyed, but it's about productivity losses, it's about the disruption in supply chain, it's about lower energy output. 36:43 So it's, in a way, doing nothing will mean losing between fifty, let's say, and at least one hundred billion. On the other side, you do investment, and this investment has a return. 36:54 I mean, depending on what you invest on, there are a number of studies But depending on where you are and which kind of activity it is, because it can be building a dam, it can be nature-based solution, but the return is between one to two and one to seven. 37:11 So it's something which is, in fact, bringing returns. It's not money lost like repairing something which has been destroyed by the extremely weather event. 37:20 There does seem to be an effort to engage private investors and insurers in particular in the hard work of funding adaptation, and European Commission president spoke at the State of the Union about a climate insurance alliance. 37:32 This is also referenced in, in the framework. 37:35 And I have contacts with the Insurance Europe Trade Group who talk about how they've been involved in discussions that have been taking place on how can we encourage [chuckles] the insurance industry to finance some of this resilient infrastructure. 37:47 So how are you thinking about involving the private sector, private investors in particular? 37:52 And I know your focus is here on the climate resilience law and adaptation resilience, but what thought has there gone into maybe changing other existing regulations that currently control or at least influence how private investors allocate capital to make it easier for them to support resilience by design, to make it easier for them to invest in large infrastructure projects that are needed to climate-proof different member states? 38:15 This is a very important topic, and yes, uh, involving the financial sector is crucial. Let's say I think bank and insurance play can play a completely different role in a way because insurance is... 38:28 and as you rightly said, the president has been launching this initiative to have a European Insurance Alliance, which is supposed indeed to look basically at the insurance gap. 38:40 I mean, overall, at as a European Union, only 25% of assets are insured against climate change. This is extreme, extremely low, with huge variability also between member states. 38:53 So you have countries which has systems of public reassurance or of a mutualization of risk like France and, and Spain respectively, who have almost 100% insurance covers, country like Italy, my own country, which is below 5%. 39:12 So there is a huge variation. So these are the two basically issues, on one side, making sure this gap is reduced overall and also even places where it's needed most to, to, to, to, to lift it up. 39:25 Now, insurance can play a huge role as well in helping financing better resilience because what we see now, and I think in that respect, the, in the US, the insurance sector is more advanced than in Europe, your premium is not necessarily properly reflecting how much your house or your company or your asset, whatever it is, is, let's say, well-protected or resilient to climate change. 39:51 And I think in that respect, insurance need also to do quite an effort, and the effort can be on the one side in adjusting premiums obviously, but also in making sure or helping basically household to finance what they need to do, for instance, to protect against flooding or to protect against heat waves, and then that could be compensated by premium over long term. 40:15 So this is also something we, we really want to explore. 40:18 It's not only about making sure that everybody is insured, but also making sure that the insurance plays a role in, in as an incentive basically to build better resilience. 40:28 And the last point is, of course, there is also the issue of overall, this is not typical to Europe, I think it's everywhere because obviously if a place is flooded every year or if you have a heatwave every year, well, then it's g- becoming almost impossible to be insured. 40:43 So that's also a key point which we need to tackle. 40:46 Now, how this will happen through the alliance, I don't know exactly, but it's clear that the intention is to have something more than a talk show, to have a real proposal coming out of this, whether this proposal will be commitment by the industry or whether ultimately we will move into a regulatory initiative at EU level, obviously it's difficult to say. 41:07 If I say one word about banks, banks are not doing much now on building resilience. Again, huge divergence across Europe, but overall, in most of European country, when you get your mortgage, you... 41:24 whether the house you're buying is resilient to climate change is, is, is not a key factor in deciding whether or not you'll get, you'll get your mortgage. 41:33 And this is something which we believe should also change, whether it should change through regulation or through better information and better, uh, awareness we're raising, I, I don't know, but it's clear that bank can do much, much more, especially for households, because for companies a bit different, especially big company, typically every managers and they do this assessment themselves, but for households it's much more complicated. 41:57 Yes. There has been a great push to increase the amount of information available on banks' own portfolios, exposure to climate risks, both transition risk and from physical risk. 42:08 So we do have interesting data at the European Banking Authority level and an insurance side at the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority side that there is data on like exposures that insurers and banks have, but there seems to be that missing piece, which is how do you incentivize them to lower those exposures and incentivize them to proactively invest in those projects, those activities that this climate resilience framework wants to encourage. 42:32 And I, I wanna stay on the private sector for, for my last question, which is on how are you going to encourage businesses, small businesses and big businesses throughout Europe to also consider climate resilience in their activities and in their investments? 42:46 You know, we have a whole swath of sustainability laws in the EU that have been implemented, revised, and a lot of them are enforced now. Yes. I'm thinking particularly about the, the disclosure regulations in Europe. 42:56 So again, we have lots of data, but how do you see this resilience framework interacting with the private sector to get them to take climate resilience seriously? 43:05 The law as it is proposed now is only addressing member state. So the obligation, all obligation will be on member state. So there is no direct obligation of a private sector at all. 43:16 But of course, how private sector on the one side tackles climate change, a consequence of climate change and build resilience for their own assets, but also how they contribute in a more systemic way of building resilience across the economy, it, it's absolutely crucial. 43:34 The idea is, again, the same system I, I, I tried to explain, so it's a sort of cascading system. 43:39 So member state will decide which are the sector, which are at high risk, which are the risk which are identified, and then in the plan they will need to decide what should be done by those. 43:51 So the obligation, for instance, on risk ownership, it doesn't go directly to company. It will go to local authorities who should tackle them. 44:01 But it's quite obvious that ultimately local authority, when they make their planning or their investment decision, this will have a huge impact on how companies will react to it. 44:13 So I mean, very banal example, if you want to build a plant and you want to do it in a specific area, if that area has been identified with a local authority being in charge of, say, flooding in that specific place, then you as a company, you, you, you will become indirectly affected for whatever that local authority has been decided in term of what to do to prevent risk, what is the acceptable level of residual risk which, which is there. 44:42 So I think there, there will be an impact, but the impact is again, through this cascading system from government, central government level into local authorities and then into businesses. 44:54 But as I said before, I think businesses do... Are not, but they will be affected as, not as direct addressee of the law, but as indirect addressee of the law. 45:05 But then businesses will also need to invest in, and this is very much in their self-interest, in fact. 45:10 Again, I was, was saying before for, for local authority that when you build a new road, a bridge, any infrastructure, a school, you want to be make sure this will not be stranded in, in a few year or in a few decades. 45:24 Well, obviously the same applies to companies, and company will be able to have access also to the same information, including the tools I mentioned before, which should help them with making better informed choice and hopefully building better resilience over the next decades. 45:39 Thank you for that comprehensive answer. I want to let you go, but just finally, can you tell us what the next steps are in the Client Resilience Framework and the Climate Resilience Law? 45:49 What, what are the next actors and steps involved? The communication, it's already applicable, so we start thinking about how to best implement that across the European Union institutions. 46:01 The tools are already available, so in particular, the European Climate Euro is already there. You can, you can have a look. It's, it's already working. We wanted to improve it, and that's the next step. 46:13 When it comes to the legislative proposal, it starts next week basically, when we'll go for the first time to a working, what we call a working party, so which is a meeting of all expert from all 27 member state, and we start by a presentation of what we are proposing, and then the process will go on this year with additional discussion. 46:36 And then basically next year there will be the parliament and the council will separately first take a position on the law, and then when they both have a agreed position, they will get together also with the commission and end up with a core trialogue, which is the final phase of a legislative process, which then normally leads to an agreed text, which then becomes a law. 47:00 We are have the ambition of finishing all this process next year. I, I don't want to hide that it's, it's, it's one year is extremely ambitious. 47:09 It typically takes something between 18 month and two year to pass a piece of legislation. 47:13 Uh, but we are also very optimistic in a way because everybody acknowledge this is an urgent issue, and we hope we can speed up a little bit compared to normal practices. 47:22 Yes, there's no hiding from the client risks that Europe is facing, and one would hope that would translate to political urgency and the implementation of this framework sooner rather than later. 47:32 Paolo, thank you so much for your time, for taking us through this complicated but very essential piece of legislation, the, and, and the framework. 47:40 I look forward to following its progress, but for now, thank you and have a great rest of your week. And thank you very much for having me. [upbeat music] Climate Proofer is a Climate Proof Media production. 47:50 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 47:58 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]