Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. 0:17 COP29 gaveled to a close on Sunday with a new climate finance goal and agreement on a whole bunch of papers touching on adaptation and resilience. 0:26 To help me make sense of it all, I'm joined today by Ana Miljeo Alvarez, a researcher for the international think tank E3G, who was on the ground at Baku for the entire summit and saw firsthand how the sausage was made. 0:38 Ana describes the tug-of-war over the new collective quantified finance goal, or NCQG, and explains why the idea of including special subgoals for adaptation and loss and damage was ultimately scrapped. 0:50 She also unpacks the agreement on the global goal on adaptation, or GGA, which could bring much needed clarity to countries' progress on adaptation and resilience. 0:59 For good measure, we dive into the latest on the UN adaptation fund and discuss the concept of transformational adaptation too. 1:06 Before we get to the conversation, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 1:13 Listeners like you can help support my coverage by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. Now let's get right to my interview with Ana. [gentle music] Hi, Ana. 1:26 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? 1:29 I am calling from Brussels, and I'm a researcher at an independent think tank called E3G, where I lead the work on adaptation and resilience, particularly focused around the UNFCCC. 1:43 Um, a lot of the work that we do is around supporting countries move forward the adaptation and resilience agenda by bringing them together around ambitious coalitions, um, doing a lot of analysis on what needs to happen and where in the system for these transformations to occur, and I'm really excited to be here today. 2:05 I'm very grateful you are here today. You have been talking to us on the ground in Baku for the last two weeks. You've been talking to many media. 2:13 You've been writing up the negotiations, and how many times have you done this, this COP process, Ana? So this is my second year, but I've been around the process for around five years. 2:24 I think there's a lot of people that go to COP and do events and, uh, you know, uh, things like that, write reports that they publish. But I'm one of the lucky people that I actually get to work on COP all year round. 2:36 I really enjoy it, and I love to be in the weeds. So you're really tuned in to the COP process, to the negotiations, particularly on the adaptation and resilience side of things. 2:44 So you're the perfect person to have on the podcast today. And my first question is, how would you rate the success of this COP in terms of strengthening and moving forward the adaptation agenda? Well, it's hard to say. 2:56 If I had to give it a percentage, maybe I would say thirty percent, uh, success out of a hundred. And really, it, it's quite split. I... The outcome was nothing what I expected it to be for two main reasons. 3:10 One, we had the big finance goal that was, um, kind of the centerpiece of this COP, the new collective quantifiable goal, and we really expected developed countries to make an offer in adaptation finance under that new goal. 3:26 There was a lot of momentum, particularly in the UK and the EU, to put that offer forward. I know that there was text developed. 3:33 Uh, the number was around eighty-five billion, and in the last minute, this kind of was withdrawn and, and didn't materialize, and as a result, we have a very weak climate finance goal for adaptation. 3:46 That really leaves a lot of uncertainty for developing countries on how are they going to implement their national adaptation plans? 3:53 How are they going to build resilience if they don't have the finance, um, the means to do so? So that's kind of the big negative outcome of, of this COP. Yes. 4:03 Yeah, you've seen a lot of angry headlines about where the finance goal ended up, and I was particularly surprised that there was no subgoals or floors for adaptation, even for the least developed states. Yeah, exactly. 4:15 You know, on the other side, we had one good outcome, which justifies my, my thirty percent optimism, and that is, uh, we had substantive outcomes on the global goal and adaptation that I don't think we were expecting at all. 4:26 So we have multiple mentions of means of implementation under the global goal and adaptation indicator work program, and that is a good signal. 4:36 But there's no point on having a system to track finance going to adaptation if there's no finance to track, right? 4:43 So I'd say overall, the COP failed at providing the support that vulnerable countries need to adapt to the impacts of climate change. 4:52 Now, this was called the Finance COP, and you've mentioned the anger and reservations at the NCQG. 4:59 And I was just wondering, though, there was some confused responses to that goal, because on the one hand, there's this three hundred billion a year by twenty thirty-five bilateral finance from developed countries, and then you have this one point three trillion dollar aspiration, which is in line with what the independent high-level ex-expert group says is needed and would go a longer way towards closing the adaptation finance gap, which we know is above three hundred billion a year at the moment. 5:26 So I was wondering if you could, like, take us through your take on, on the actual quantum of the goal and the significance of the three hundred billion versus the one point three trillion, because some people think the, the former is more important and some think the latter is. 5:39 Because the three hundred billion has kind of a name on who is responsible to, to materialize it, right? We know it's has to be developed countries or at least leading. 5:50 A lot of people are focusing on that three hundred billion. 5:52 Others think that the private sector, new innovative sources of finance can make up the, the gap between the three hundred billion and the one point three trillion, and therefore they're focusing m-more on the outer layer. 6:07 But I think-What developing countries are saying and what they're focusing... why they're focusing on the three hundred billion is that well, so far we haven't seen the private sector deliver. 6:16 We haven't seen these innovative sources of finance come through and save the day so, sure, it's nice to have that one point three, uh, trillion inspirational goal, but what we really care about is what's actually going to be put on the table, and that was promised to be three hundred billion. 6:34 Um, and that quantum is really small. So we know with inflation, with the promises already made by MDBs, countries are probably, you know, we're already going to be at three hundred in the next ten years. 6:49 So developing countries were asking for that quantum to be bigger and to require transformational change, not a business as usual approach, which is what we've, what we've gotten. So that... 7:01 there's a, a disappointment on the, on the number, which is on, on the three hundred billion, and then there's disappointment also, as you were saying, on kind of the sources, right? 7:09 So the goal just saying, you know, developed countries must lead, and it kind of has a lot of wishy-washy, unclear language on, on other sources. 7:18 And it's funny because we all went into this process of the new climate finance goal saying, "We need something better than the one hundred billion," and what we've gotten is basically the one hundred billion again, but with a three hundred figure. 7:33 You know, we were-- we're likely to have the same issues that we had with the one hundred billion in terms of tracking and figuring out exactly how much money is flowing and where. So that's another big disappointment. 7:44 And then in the outer layer, the one point three trillion, that's likely to be even worse because then you're counting private sector money, and you're counting these innovative sources like international taxations that don't exist yet. 7:57 So that will be even harder to track, and there's also I think a, a question responsibility, where developing countries are saying, "If collectively we fail to meet the one point three trillion, we don't want to get blamed for that." 8:13 We don't want to, you know, we don't want developed countries to say, "Well, 8:17 developing countries didn't have the right enable environment for, for private sector investments," or, you know, "Well, we just haven't made enough progress on innovative sources." 8:26 Developing countries want certainty and more motivation to develop their climate plans, if that makes sense. Yes, absolutely. 8:34 I think it's really important what you say about this three hundred billion finance goal not being additive to what's already happening. 8:41 Once you factor in inflation, once you factor in existing flows, yes, as you said, this three hundred billion dollars today is similar to the hundred billion dollars a day deal struck back in two thousand and nine, which I think is a source of a, a lot of anger. 8:53 However, there was this addition last minute into the NCQG text about this Baku to Belém one point three trillion roadmap, and I was looking at this, and I thought it was just a way to kind of put one point three trillion into the text again, uh, to kind of show developing countries, "Look, we're really serious about getting to this one point three trillion goal." 9:10 But what's your take on that? It seems like another talking shop that will come with a report next COP, and that report will similarly be discounted and ignored. What's your sense here? Well, I think it could be either. 9:22 It could be an opportunity to get more tangible, more detailed like outcomes on what is... how are we going to get to the one point three, um, or it could be a talk shop, and it... that's always up to the parties. 9:37 The reality is that, and I think why so many of us were really hoping to get something better at this COP, is that the geopolitical situation next year is not gonna be any better. It might even be worse. 9:47 We have more elections coming in, uh, Canada and Australia, with Canada holding the G7, Australia perhaps holding COP 31, and there's really no certainty then that parties will negotiate in good faith on living forward. 10:03 So let's see. I, I do think it's an opportunity. 10:06 For an example, we will have the Global Solidarity Task Force, I think that's the name, produce policy recommendations at COP 30 for that international tax that could unlock, you know, billions every year of public finance for adaptation loss and damage. 10:24 So that could be something harnessed by, by the roadmap, but it's still... yeah, it's completely in the air. It will be whatever countries want it to be. 10:32 Okay, and finally on the finance goal, we mentioned the lack of sub-goals or floors for adaptation in that finance goal, and there's only now a reference to balance between adaptation and mitigation. 10:43 So I wonder if you can take us through the sort of insider baseball about why the sub-goal idea fell apart, who was responsible for that, and whether it could be revived in future discussions like in this Baku to Belém roadmap. 10:55 Yeah. Um, I... and I will go public on record to say I will do whatever is in my power to make sure we get a sub-goal next year because [laughs] Yay. [laughs] That's great to hear. 11:07 Um, because I do think that we still can get it. I've already heard from European countries like Ireland, they, they haven't forgotten. It's not over, and they're really keen to keep working on this next year. 11:20 What happened on the sub-goal is tricky and hard to really say, but multiple things were at play. So you had the, the adaptation sub-goal. 11:31 There was also a request, an initial request on a loss and damage sub-goal, and there's a long time kind of trade-off between these two. 11:39 We see that when one, when either loss and damage or adaptation gets more attention, the other one gets neglected. And then we saw a last-minute move from LDCs and SIDS on, I think it was the first day of COP or 11:53 something like that, where they came out and said, "Actually, we want minimum allocation floors for our groups."With, I think, LDC saying they wanted two hundred and twenty billion, something like that and SIDS saying they wanted thirty-eight billion. 12:07 So this kind of changed the tune, and I think I'm, I'm not really sure the motivation from LDCs and SIDS to do this. 12:15 Uh, as, you know, something that I thought that they could be trying to do is say, "We don't want that trade-off between adaptation and mitiga-- and, and loss and damage. 12:23 We just want to receive money and then decide how we want to use it." That could be one option. 12:28 Another option is that they thought, "We're gonna get screwed over anyway, and most adaptation and loss and damage finance is gonna be going to, you know, middle-income countries that already receive a lot of help via, you know, concessional loans, et cetera." 12:41 But anyway, this really changed kind of their request from all these SIDS that are the countries that the Europeans were look, you know, looking to kind of satisfy with this adaptation sub-goal. 12:51 So that really undermined the adaptation sub-goal ask. And then there's another big issue, and that is mitigation. Again, there are constant trade-offs between adaptation and mitigation. 13:02 Developed countries wanted a strong mitigation outcome, and that just wasn't happening. 13:08 And I think that also really turned off the appetite from developed countries to put anything on the table for adaptation, saying, "Why are we going to give grant money for adaptation when we're not going to be lowering emissions? 13:21 That's kind of wasted money." So I'm thinking it was probably a combination of these two things that contributed to the sub-goal dropping off last minute. 13:31 But I do know a lot of LDCs and SIDS were still asking for the sub-goal. 13:35 I, I spoke to them a lot about this, and they were just trying kind of different strategies to get substantial money that they really desperately need. Yes. 13:43 Well, the least developed countries and the SIDS, the Small Island Developing States, they are the ones who are most vulnerable to, to climate shock, so it makes sense why adaptation loss and damage should be a priority for them. 13:54 And of course, having gone through several natural disasters in recent years, including this year, I suppose the need is very pressing for more adaptation and resilience and loss and damage funds. 14:04 I'll be interested to see if this discussion of sub-goals is revived, and I'm s- feel like there's gonna be greater appetite for it as we get better at quantifying adaptation needs, right, through these UN adaptation gap reports, through the initiatives of different private groups like this Climate Policy Initiative. 14:20 They're all putting together the kind of numbers on adaptation, right? And I feel like that will help provide clarity about what's actually needed in order for these countries to, to survive in a climate-adjusted world. 14:30 Yeah. 14:30 I, I also wanted to add that COP30 being held in Brazil, I think also has a lot of potential in itself to make significant progress in adaptation because the Brazilians have said, you know, very clearly in their G20 presidency this year that their focus is poverty reduction, 14:51 and resilience is key to that. 14:53 So I, I know Brazilian NGOs are already working on this framing of COP30 being the COP of adaptation, kind of like this one was the COP of, of finance, so that also gives me hope that we can get a substantial outcome. 15:07 That... COP30 will also mark the end of the work program to operationalize the global goal in adaptation. So all those pieces coming together, topped with a new number for adaptation finance, would be critical. 15:22 Also, particularly because in twenty twenty-five next year is when developed countries are due to have doubled their adaptation finance from twenty nineteen level, from like twenty billion to forty billion. 15:34 So if they meet that, they'll need to also basically say what comes next, right? So we have these kind of three things that I, I think are, are in our favor to get that, that strong outcome. 15:46 So it could be the adaptation COP, just like this one was the finance COP. Interesting. I hope so. So one last thing on finance. 15:53 The adaptation fund, uh, the UN Multilateral Climate Fund, seemed to get very little love this year. 15:58 I looked at the data, and it seems like they only achieved a third of their goal to receive three hundred million dollars in pledges. So they received about a hundred and thirty-three million. 16:07 So what do you think explains the adaptation fund's difficulties here, and is it actually still a relevant entity in the adaptation finance space? 16:13 I used to think it would be the focus of discussions, but nobody really seems to me to talk about the adaptation fund as an integral part of the overall effort to get more finance to adaptation goals. Yeah. 16:23 Thank you for this question. I think it's super, super relevant. So what's the issue with the adaptation fund? How do I put this diplomatically? 16:30 It's the only fund that has a majority developing country board, and it doesn't allow donors to earmark their money. So once the money goes into the adaptation fund, adaptation fund decides what to do with it. 16:47 So a lot of European countries, like the Netherlands or the UK, who are big donors for adaptation, want to pick and choose where their money goes. 16:57 For example, the Netherlands wants to prioritize LDCs in Africa, and the adaptation fund doesn't allow for that, even though they do mostly serve LDCs and SIDS. 17:07 So that's kind of led to developed countries not using the adaptation fund to its full potential. 17:13 Now, does the adaptation fund still serves its purpose, and is it, um, you know, a critical part of, kind of the adaptation finance architecture? I'd say yes, because 17:23 first, it's the only adaptation-specific fund in the UNFC-- the UNFCCC, and it's the only fund that provides direct access to communities, and that is critical for adaptation, which is so context-specific. 17:35 So I'm really, really hoping that the board can figure out a way to attract more donations from developed countries, and they can work together with parties toClose this gap because what, what we hear from developing countries and vulnerable communities as the, is that the Adaptation Fund works, works really well and is delivering a lot of good action on the ground. 17:58 For an example, I know the airport in Jamaica used to get flooded every year, and there was this infrastructure project from the Adaptation Fund to kind of improve the road system and, and build the sea walls, and now the Jamaican airport doesn't flood anymore. 18:14 That's the kind of good work they do. So- That's pretty cool. Yeah. Uh, and the, the director, Mikko, is an absolutely wonderful person that I think is, is very willing to work with countries to, to find a way forward. 18:26 So I'm hoping that they do get together and discuss because I, I hope that the Adaptation Fund starts getting more love. They really deserve it. Yes. 18:34 I just think the numbers are very small in the context of what's needed. 18:36 But as you said, they're prioritizing locally-led adaptation in developing countries, and actually the, the raw amounts of dollars are gonna be lower than adaptation projects in the developed world anyway. 18:48 And so if that money is going exactly where it needs to to produce the resilience and adaptation outcomes necessary, then it is definitely a worthwhile endeavor. 18:56 But I understand also with these multilateral funds, these climate funds, there is an issue just getting money out the door, right? 19:01 So the Adaptation Fund receives these pledges, but then allocating them out to projects takes a long time. So what do you think about reforms to kind of speed up the dispersal of funds from these UN entities? Yeah. 19:14 I think that's, that's key, and it's something that we did get some good signals from the NCQG, is the kind of that calls to reform and to a- you know, to enhance access, and that's a reform that's happening also, for an example, in the GCF, um, because countries are having to wait, like, seven years to access climate finance, and that's just not, not realistic. 19:34 So there's a lot, a lot of, of work to be done. We just have to see the willingness again from parties who sit in the boards of, of these funds to make the, the right calls. Okay. 19:47 Moving on from finance, we mentioned the global goal on adaptation. What I find interesting about the global goal is this focus on targets and progress indicators towards these targets. 19:57 So we have 11 targets, seven thematic targets, four dimension targets, which refer to how adaptation should be implemented. 20:05 And from the final text out of COP, it seems like parties are committed to come up with 100 indicators for measuring adaptation progress. 20:13 And those who've been following this closely know that they had received, uh, this expert group who was working on indicators, over 5,000 indicators. 20:21 [chuckles] So I don't envy the expert group having to go from- [chuckles] Yeah... 5,000 to 100 indicators. That's gonna be a big job. 20:26 But let's, let's go back a few steps and ask, what's the significance of this breakthrough? What's the significance of having these indicators when it comes to supporting adaptation in developing countries? Yeah. 20:37 So adaptation efforts are extremely fragmented and context-specific, as we've already discussed. 20:43 So having a global goal kind of sets the, you know, the first global framework to measure progress in adaptation and to identify gaps and find synergy. 20:54 So it's actually really, really important that this framework has targets that are fit for purpose and indicators that are fit for purpose to feed into those targets. 21:02 In that way, we can kind of assess how are things going, you know, are we getting there, while at the same time we know the climate impacts are going to worsen. 21:11 So indeed, the decision decided that at maximum the experts could produce 100 indicators. Um, I think at the end they had over 10,000 indicators. Wow. Okay. Yeah. [chuckles] That's a lot. Yeah, exac- It's, it's a lot. 21:27 Um, but there are, you know, a lot of repetitions. Not all of the indicators are, you know, relevant to the targets. 21:34 So there is guidance in the text about how to kind of boil down the, the indicators to those that are most relevant. 21:43 But I think that the biggest takeaway there is that experts have been told that they can include indicators of means of implementation, like what is the finance that is flowing to meet these targets? 21:53 And I think that will make our case even stronger for, you know, in order to meet these targets, we need the money, and, and hopefully it serves countries to see, okay, you know, not enough money's going to, for example, water security or food systems or, you know, there's a real gap in the, in this particular level of implementation or technology transfer. 22:14 Um, we're not doing the proper review mechanisms or the proper, you know, planning for adaptation, and then countries can, can enhance their adaptation efforts. 22:24 So one thing I'm interested in with this indicator process is how it could cascade down from the country level to the private sector, right? 22:31 Because I've read a number of reports this year, I'm sure you have too, about financial institutions saying, "Okay. We want to invest in adaptation, but we need a framework under which to do that." 22:40 And you have seen entities like the Climate Bonds Initiative, Tailwind Climate, et cetera, come out with taxonomies of one type or other. 22:48 But it does seem to me like having, like, a UN-approved set of indicators could cascade down and be useful for other entities when it comes to directing capital towards adaptation. 22:57 So what's your thinking of the interrelationship between what happens here within this GGA and what's happening on the ground with financial institutions, both in developed countries and developing countries to, to really get more capital flowing? 23:11 Yeah. That's a, that's a really good question. We've... do, do hear that from the private sector and even from MDBs. 23:17 I know for an example, the EAB has a target of 15% of their portfolio going to, um, adaptation, and they're only at 5%, even though their target is next year. When I ask them, like, "Why are you so behind?" 23:30 They say, "Well, we just don't have the demand," or, "We just don't know how to, you know, leverage the private sector to mobilize it." 23:38 So I do think that having this framework can provide that structure and that foundation for more capital. 23:45 But at the end of the day, I think it comes down to countries getting better at using, you know, blending and guarantees to attract, you know, you know, to de-risk and attract the private sector. 23:57 And it also takes the private sector having a, a new mindset around adaptation, resilience andApproaching projects, you know, thinking more in the longer term rather in the short term because, you know, a lot of adaptation action is around providing like water and sanitation or enhancing roads, and those are things that are not going to be profitable in the shorter term, but they can certainly be in the longer term. 24:25 And if the private sector really take that into consideration, they'll see it's actually in their own interest to, to enhance adaptation so that, you know, we don't see disruption of supply chains and other systems that, that they rely on. 24:38 So I think the GGA is critical, but I think that we still need to see kind of a transformation of, of approach from the private sector in countries on, on how we deal with adaptation. 24:50 But that's really a, a wider challenge, you know, of climate change. We're asking kind of the same thing on mitigation. 24:55 You know, invest in renewables because it's, it's the better thing longer term rather than the short-term finance that you can get from fossil fuels. 25:03 So within the UNCCC, we send the right signals, but then we need the private sector to receive them and act upon them. Yes, the signaling role of COP is, is so important, and it... 25:13 I suppose the idea is to try to promote some long-term thinking. 25:17 But as you kind of referenced earlier, like with the geopolitical situation fragmenting, the idea of investing for the long-term future might be, might be relegated to second-tier issues over the next few, few years. 25:28 Yeah. Hopefully not. One final thing on the GGA then. 25:31 I did wanna mention this reference to transformational adaptation because this is actually an area I've not looked into too much before, but it seems like there was a bit of controversy about getting transformational adaptation mentioned in the context of the GGA. 25:45 And for those who don't know, transformational adaptation refers to changes that are systemic, that are deep, big structural change that can really change how societies and ecosystems deal with climate change, whereas incremental adaptation is small modifications to existing systems. 26:01 So I think we see a lot of incremental adaptation going on around the world, but maybe not lots of transformational adaptation. But it seemed to me like it was quite important that this got into the final GGA text. 26:11 What, what's your take on that, and what is the importance of transformational adaptation? 26:14 I think transformational adaptation is super important, and it align with that kind of other transformational messages I, I've said before about, you know, the, the need to kind of change the financial system, the need for the private sector to change its mindset. 26:28 This is kind of the next step as well s- for adaptation specifically. And you can see that actually a lot of developing countries are on board, like ILAC, LDCs and SIDS. 26:38 They see that we, you know, incremental adaptation will only take us so far, but that we do need to change the systems to become truly resilient. 26:48 The issue with including transformational adaptation in the text is that some developing countries, particularly African countries, were worried that this would become kind of a new requisite for them to access finance. 27:01 So kind of setting the bar even higher of like, well, is your project that you're applying for funding going to have transformational, [chuckles] you know, system impact? 27:11 Um, maybe not, and, you know, maybe countries just don't have the capacity or means to develop those kinds of projects right now, so it's not fair to impose it on them, but it's more about creating the enabling environment so that they can develop that transformational adaptation. 27:28 So I think what we saw in the text finally is we have both mentioned, and I think that hopefully eases developing countries' minds of, "No, we want the benefits of transformational adaptation, but that it is not going to become a barrier for you to access finance." 27:44 Yes, that's one thing I, I noticed throughout the process is that some developing countries, they didn't like the idea that additional complexity will be brought in, additional friction to them getting the resources they need, and I think that can explain a streamlining in a lot of the texts. 27:58 But I suppose it also means that finance and resources can flow to certain types of adaptation that are necessary, but maybe are not all-encompassing or maybe not as protective as they could be. 28:11 So I can understand both sides on this argument, but I think it's interesting that transformational adaptation made it onto the final text, and I do wonder whether we'll be hearing a bit more about this concept, not only in the COP process, but also amongst private players as well because I haven't seen much of that discussed in papers from the kind of Policy Initiative or from IISD, but I'll be interested to see if think tanks start to take this more seriously now. 28:34 Yeah. We also saw the, the decision ask for a new, more reader-friendly report on transformational adaptation from the secretariat. So let's see when that comes out whether it can facilitate further work on this. 28:49 I think it, it has great potential, and I think it gets to the root of, of the problem, and it ha- it does have support of a lot of developing countries. 28:56 Now there's been a lot of think pieces written about the utility of the COP process after this Baku summit, right? There was petitions and papers being circulated even as the conference was going on, right? Yeah. 29:08 About we need to reform COP. It's all crap. We need to throw it out and try something new. And now I hear other people saying, "No, this is the most important multilateral venue for climate discussions." 29:17 So from somebody who's on the ground, from somebody who's been involved in COPs for five years now, what's your take on the efficacy of the COP process, particularly when we think about adaptation resilience? 29:27 Is it worth keeping? Is it worth reforming, or is it worth looking to other forums to really drive action? 29:33 Yeah, listen, if someone tells you they've never doubted the efficacy of the COP process being on the ground, they're probably lying. 29:39 You know, the reality is that there's not another credible proposal on the table about what a similar, more efficient process could look like. 29:50 So not only is the only venue we have to discuss climate change, but it's actually the only space where all countries have the same voice and vote. 30:01 So for the most vulnerable, for LDCs and SIDS, which have very limited capacity and resources, it's key.If we don't have the COP, their voice won't be heard. It's that easy. That's what we see on the G7, on the G20. 30:17 So I'm open to discussing how we improve the COP and being open about some of its issues, but I don't want it to be at the expense of vulnerable countries. 30:29 So, um, I think it would have to come from them, how they want to improve the system. 30:34 But yeah, it's concerning that we are struggling to reach a agreement in this, in this venue, and we definitely saw a lot of sketchy things happen at this COP with the presidency treating parties very differently. 30:48 Aldus Islands, it's walked out of the NCQG, the, you know, one of the last NCQG meetings because it said, "We have not been consulted about this text." 30:56 And at the same time, we saw that Saudi Arabia was getting exclusive access to the mitigation texts, and they were tracking changes on Word and making it whatever they wanted. 31:06 So these are all real issues, but that, you know, fixing those can't be at the expense of, of vulnerable countries. Yes. I'm amazed that 195 countries can get together and agree on anything, really. 31:19 I mean, I've been involved in local politics and in, in membership clubs, and trying to get, you know, 10 people to agree on something can take hours and hours and hours, right? 31:27 So I understand the complexity and the frustration of the process. 31:30 I think what you put your finger on rightly is that if certain parties are being treated differently or have different levels of access to the presidency or to the agenda, that's really problematic. 31:40 But the idea of actually a forum where everybody has a voice and has to be listened to, I think that's worth keeping. 31:45 And yes, it does make for very long-winded, complicated and frustrating negotiations, which is why I can never be a climate negotiator because I like to work quickly. [laughs] Yeah. 31:54 But I understand this is, this is the game you play, and it's better to have a forum where you have all these voices heard rather than a- another bunch of talking shops that don't connect to each other and prioritize the needs of rich countries. 32:07 Yeah, if I could add just one last thing on this, is that not only is the only place where all countries have a voice, but actually it's a bit of a neutral space, or it should be. 32:19 It's actually one of the few places where 32:22 countries are all the same in the sense that no country gets to tell the other, "Oh, I'm, you know, I respect more, you know, this, or I do this other thing better, so I get to tell you what to do." 32:35 Um, so for example, a lot of people wonder why do we have COPs, uh, that deal with climate change on, in oil-producing countries. 32:43 And the response is because everyone's equal in the UNFCCC, and developed countries cannot say to oil-producing countries, "Hey, you can't host a COP because you produce oil." 32:55 Because oil-producing countries will say, "Well, you consume our oil, and you seem to be perfectly fine with it." So there's no moral superiority. 33:03 [laughs] You know, we're all there, and we all depend on, you know, we're all there equally, and we all depend on each other being there in good faith trying to do what's best. So that's also very, very unique. 33:14 And I, I think most people that are outside of the system don't understand this. 33:19 I think especially in Europe, we have this very, like, Eurocentric perspective from, you know, multilateral venues where we are supposed to go and tell them, "Oh, we're amazing at respecting human rights," and all these things, and we should have a bigger say or get to tell where we host COP, and that's just not the reality. 33:36 There's a lot of perspectives about who's best and who's worse, and in the UNFCCC, we're all the same. 33:42 Well, Ana, you know a great deal about this, and your understanding of the process, your closeness to some of the negotiations and your efforts to, to push the adaptation agenda forward have been noted, not just by me, but I know by many other people in, in media world and also in think tank world and policy world. 33:58 You've been there for three weeks, I think you said, in Baku. Yeah. Um, and you just got back, and you came onto a podcast with me, uh, which I'm very grateful for. So thank you for sharing your expertise and your views. 34:08 Um, it's been brilliant, and have a well-deserved rest. Hopefully we'll g- get to talk to you again soon. Oh, thank you so much. 34:14 I really appreciate you guys having me and putting the attention on this really, really critical issue. [upbeat music] Climate Proofer's is a Climate Proof Media production. 34:24 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 34:31 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]