Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. 0:19 Multilateral development banks, or MDBs, are the oft-overlooked anchors of the global financial system and key players in the mobilization of climate finance. 0:29 In twenty twenty-three, MDBs provided almost twenty-five billion dollars in adaptation finance to low and middle income nations. 0:36 Last year, a coalition of 11 of these banks pledged to nearly double that amount by twenty thirty to forty-two billion dollars a year. Now, this isn't an amount to be sniffed at, but much more is needed. 0:47 Remember, the UN believes between two hundred and fifteen billion and three hundred and eighty-seven billion dollars is needed annually through the end of this decade to adapt the developing world to climate shocks. 0:58 One MDB pro believes there's a way development banks can do more to close this gap. Avinash Persaud is the Special Advisor on Climate Risks to the President of the Inter-American Development Bank, or IDB. 1:10 He's been instrumental in pushing for MDB reforms, most notably through the Bridgetown Initiative, a comprehensive effort to transform the international financial architecture to better account for climate risks and social inequalities. 1:22 I met Avinash at a conference in Brasilia last month, and he shook up the room with his frank talk on the state of play of adaptation finance. 1:29 He believes that MDBs have to take the lead, as private finance isn't likely to invest in climate proofing at the scale needed, and government grants should be reserved for addressing loss and damage. 1:38 In our conversation, he spells out how MDBs can reorient their lending for adaptation and explores the resource constraints facing both borrowers and lenders on this front, and how they can be overcome. 1:48 Before we get to the conversation, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 1:55 You can back my coverage and help the publication to grow by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. 2:03 If you're feeling really generous, please consider choosing a super proofer membership, which comes with additional goodies like free gift subscriptions, access to monthly roundtables on adaptation technology, and more. 2:13 All right, in a moment, my conversation with Avinash, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 2:19 [whooshing sound] In finance, climate groups are suing the US Environmental Protection Agency and Wall Street lender Citibank, alleging the illegal withholding of billions in grants for climate mitigation and resilience activities. 2:31 The action escalates a dispute which started when EPA head Lee Zeldin moved to claw back some twenty billion dollars in grants obligated from the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund, or GGRF. 2:42 This was a Biden-era initiative aimed at financing projects that cut climate pollution and build resilience against climate shocks. 2:49 Federal dollars for the GGRF were appropriated under the twenty twenty-two Inflation Reduction Act and moved to recipients' accounts at Citibank late last year. 2:58 Grant awardees said they have been unable to access funds from Citibank for weeks, delaying critical projects and threatening payroll. 3:04 They claim to have received no explanation from the EPA or Citibank despite numerous inquiries. 3:10 Climate United, a coalition of three nonprofit groups, which was awarded seven billion dollars under the GGRF, filed a lawsuit this past Saturday against Citibank and the EPA. 3:20 The Coalition for Green Capital, or CGC, a separate group, was awarded five billion dollars by the GGRF and filed suit against Citibank alone on Monday. 3:28 Among the many projects Climate United plans to fund using its award are infrastructure upgrades to harden communities against extreme weather and natural disasters. 3:36 [whooshing sound] In policy, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said that eighty-three percent of projects run by the US Agency for International Development, or USAID, are being canceled following a six-week review of its operations ordered by President Trump. 3:51 USAID was a top provider of overseas adaptation investment in the period twenty twenty-one to twenty twenty-three, according to data gathered by blended finance nonprofit Convergence. 3:59 In a statement on social media website X, Secretary Rubio said the five thousand two hundred contracts being torn up spent tens of billions of dollars in ways that did not serve, and in some cases even harmed, the core national interests of the United States. 4:12 He did not elaborate on how these programs hurt the US, though. Experts say gutting USAID works against US efforts to prevent conflicts overseas, encourage economic growth, and limit migration to North America. 4:23 [whooshing sound] And in tech, Foresight Canada, the country's largest clean tech accelerator, has launched EarthTech Adapt, a nine-month program for startups that shield industries, communities, and ecosystems from climate impacts. 4:35 The program aims to equip early-stage companies with expert membership and access to industry partnerships and help them to acquire capital. 4:42 Areas of focus include wildfire mitigation, flood prevention, and grid resilience. [whooshing sound] All right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Avinash. [upbeat music] Hi, Avinash. 4:54 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? I'm calling from Washington, D.C. I am the president of the Inter-American Development Bank's Special Advisor on Climate Risks. What do I do? 5:08 Well, we spend a fair amount of money on a range of, of climate related things, climate resilience, making sure our region is more resilient to climate impacts. 5:23 Our region, Latin America and the Caribbean, is the most heavily impacted, uh, by a warming climate. 5:32 And, uh, we also work a lot on trying to support the energy, food, transport transition to greater efficiency, greater sustainability, greater security. Wonderful. It's great to have you here today. 5:48 I met you at a conference in Brasilia the other week where you gave a wonderful speech, without notes, may I add, about, uh, multilateral development banks, MDB's role in adaptation finance, and I wanna drill into that a little more today. 6:02 But first, I'd like it if you could define a little bit more what your role is as a special advisor, uh, to the president on climate change at IDB. I wanna get an understanding of what your day-to-day is like. 6:12 Who are you meeting? What deals are you putting together? 6:15 And what strategic efforts are you pushing for at the bank?Well, I'm the bank's first special advisor on climate risks, and so I'm sort of making it up as I go along. 6:25 But the way I see my role is that Latin American and the Caribbean have enormous needs on building climate resilience, enormous investment needs on transitioning energy and agriculture. 6:43 The region is a major food exporter and transport is a major issue. And these are enormous needs, and we can only do a fraction of that. 6:53 And so there's a fraction that we do already, and we have teams of people trying to make those loans as best as they can be. 7:01 And I'm sort of looking at the gap, the gap in, in finance, the gap in resilience that's being unfunded, the gap in investments in, in the transition that's been unfunded, and trying to fill that gap, whether that is a combination of national economic policies 7:23 or finding new instruments to maybe de-risk the investments to make them more attractive to private investors, or understanding what is holding the private sector back and de-risking those instruments, 7:41 or identifying that here's something that can't be funded by the private sector. It is a pure public good, as we say in economics, uh, that they aren't capturable private revenues, and so the government has to fund it. 7:55 And the governments tend to be underinvesting in resilience because it's expensive, and they don't have a lot of ability to borrow. 8:05 So we look at ways of making it less expensive and more affordable, and that they can do more. 8:11 Because what we found is for every dollar they spend on resilience, um, they save, uh, up to $10 in the future from having become more resilient. Yes, it's a very popular way to frame adaptation finance, right? 8:28 A dollar spent today can save 10 in the future. I've seen also $13, $15, depends which study you're looking at. Well, our studies say 13 to 15. I just find that such an unbelievable figure. 8:40 Unbelievable in the sense that the multiple is so fantastic. Uh, that's one of the best, uh, things to... One of the best returns you can get, right? 8:48 I think it's always safer to be even more conservative, but 10 to one is still massive. And can I ask then, who are the stakeholders you're engaging with when you're doing this gap analysis? 8:58 Are we talking here, uh, folks at other MDBs? Are we talking about people in government finance ministries, insurance companies, institutional investors? 9:06 I think people will be interested to know, like, who are the movers and shakers in this space. So we work with all of those people. We are like a cooperative bank, a not-for-profit, uh, focused on development. 9:18 Uh, and our members are governments, so they are borrowers and creditors, shareholders and customers. And so we try to understand their problem. Uh, we- we're trying to provide solution to them. 9:32 So we might speak to them about, um, say, having heat-ready schools 9:39 and ask what's stopping you converting all your schools to be heat-ready schools, uh, given the impacts that you're having, uh, and that you've shown this to have. 9:50 And so we need to understand their problem and try and come up with a solution to their problem. 9:55 And then they often don't have the financial resources, so we speak to institutional investors on what stops you investing in it, um, you the institutional investors. We also speak to local financiers. 10:10 Developing local financial markets is an important part of what we do. So we're speaking to, to all of these people. 10:17 Um, these projects tend to be big and complicated, uh, so you also need to, to be speaking to the engineers about the latest technologies, about the communities that these projects are gonna go into. 10:33 We have to be very careful that these projects don't disrupt the community in a negative way. If you're working on... 10:40 In vulnerable countries, um, and y- often there are vulnerable communities there, indigenous populations or, uh, people, um, in slum dwellings. Um, so these... Th- there's, there's a lot of people to speak to. 10:57 And you seem well positioned to do so, Avinash, 'cause you're a good public speaker yourself. And can I actually ask before we get into the meat of the topic today, how did you get into your position? 11:06 What was your winding journey to, to the IDB? I'm a relatively newcomer to climate. I was, um, an investment banker in London, but I was also born in Barbados in the Caribbean. 11:21 And I went to college at the London School of Economics in the UK and bumped into a fellow Barbadian, 11:28 Mia Amor Mottley, who in later years becomes prime minister [chuckles] and, uh, encourages me to come back to the island of my birth. 11:39 And, um, when I returned, we had the horrendous hurricane season, the horrendous Atlantic hurricane season of 2017, uh, in which an island, uh, of Dominica was flattened by Hurricane Maria. 11:56 It was a Category 5 hurricane, the second Category 5 hurricane that year. Getting two Category 5 hurricanes in the space of two weeks was really unusual. 12:06 One of those once in a thousand year events that seem to be happening every 10 years or so. 12:12 Um, and so Prime Minister Mottley, being the, the, [chuckles] the lady she is, she said, "You've got to go to Dominica, and you've got to go and see how you can help them and support them." 12:22 So off I went in, in a UN plane.To look at this island that had looked like it suffered from a nuclear winter. Uh, and the process of a year of trying to support Dominica, and, and the people there were fantastic. 12:36 They picked themselves up very quickly. I learned a lot about it, and became something of a- an expert on how we finance reconstruction and redevelopment. 12:47 I developed a, an agency called the Climate Resilient Execution Agency of Dominica, and things led to things, and, uh, so I ended up at the Inter-American Development Bank overseeing climate action. 13:00 Thanks for indulging that trip down memory lane. 13:02 I always think it's interesting how people end up in climate finance, and it sounds like you've got the range of experiences from private sector land and also public sector world to, uh, really help create some good ideas and push some good developments in climate finance. 13:16 Now I want to get into the adaptation finance landscape itself, and particularly MDB's position in it. 13:22 I've gone over time and again the figures about the small fraction of finance from the public and private realms that is going towards adaptation, and there are many arguments about why there is not increasing finance going towards adaptation, some of which you spoke to at Brasilia, and some of which you can reiterate now in today's podcast. 13:39 But I wanna actually talk from somebody who's kind of on the inside, what are multilateral development banks actually doing in adaptation finance today, and what do you think they should be doing to really drive the increase in finance we need? 13:51 So when you look at some of the big adaptation and resilience investments, it's things like a, a new sea wall or sea defenses or flood defenses or better drainage systems, and these are big public infrastructures. 14:09 These cost billions of dollars, or hundreds of millions of dollars in small places. 14:15 And so it's very hard for, for governments to fund these themselves, and it's a classic kind of thing that multilateral development banks can help them with. 14:25 So, uh, we lend to governments who invest in this resilient public infrastructure, which will save them even more than the actual investment, and so it's a, it's a sensible investment for them to do. 14:40 And because it's a large investment, we have to, to lend to them fairly cheaply. And multilateral development banks, uh, like the IDB, we, we have very high quality credit because we're very conservative lenders. 14:55 We have triple A credit rating. 14:58 And I actually think this is a thing of beauty in the global financial system, and that may be perverse, but at the heart of the global financial system are a series of not-for-profit development banks with a triple A rating. 15:12 And that means they can go in the marketplace and borrow like a triple A-rated, uh, entity that won't go bust, and then lend to developing countries who don't have a triple A rating, may not even have a triple B rating. 15:26 They may have a triple C rating, and the cost of their borrowing would be double digits or far more. 15:32 And we can lend to them as if they were triple A, and that allows them to invest in things they wouldn't otherwise be able to invest in. 15:39 But it's still a lot of investment, and so we need to still find ways of making it even more affordable. 15:48 And now I want to get into one of the mechanisms by which MDBs can leverage that triple A rating balance sheet to really provide adaptation finance. 15:56 This is the idea of extra long loans for adaptation, and you said in Brasilia that these are attractive instruments for scaling adaptation finance because they can be issued for decades instead of fifteen years, or ten or fifteen years, for forty years or even more. 16:11 There would be predictable repayment schedules for the countries that are the borrowers. 16:16 They could be embedded with climate resilient debt clauses so that they can suspend repayments when necessary, uh, and they could be at very low rates, so actually the debt burden of these loans could be quite low. 16:29 So it was an interesting pitch you made. I wanna get into some of the logistics here. So what kind of entities would be receiving these loans? H-how would the rates be kept low? 16:38 Is it because of that triple A balance sheet? And how could MDBs be made comfortable tying up capital for multiple decades? 16:44 'Cause that's the thing that came to me, to mind when you were speaking the other week, is that, okay, you can make a capital commitment for forty-plus years, and some entities might be comfortable doing that for small amounts of capital, but tying up large amounts of capital for long periods of time may be antithetical to how a lot of banks like to ba- manage their balance sheet. 17:01 So bunch of questions there, but it'd be great if you could unpack that idea in more detail. 17:06 So I think there are three things we need to do to encourage governments, support governments in making their countries more resilient. 17:17 The first one is that we need, uh, a lot more low-cost long-term loans, and that's kind of the business the MDBs are in. They have a triple A rating, so that allows them to borrow, uh, inexpensively. 17:32 And they're not for profit. They have a development mandate, so they can on-lend to the countries at rates that basically just cover their costs. Uh, they don't lose money. 17:43 Multilateral development banks don't lose money, and whatever money that they may end up making because they've more than covered their costs, they plow back in to, uh, lending more. 17:55 So that's how we get, um, low-cost, uh, lending. Long term, as you say, at the moment, multilateral development banks lend around fifteen to twenty-five years. 18:07 But what we found is in doing these studies, that the savings from investing in resilience are really long-term, ultra long-term. 18:16 Uh, these savings are thirty, forty, fifty years.And so if you could match the, the length of the repayment to the, uh, length of the savings, then it becomes much more affordable for the country. 18:33 If they're gonna repay all of the investment in the space of, say, 10 years, when in fact the investment is recouping savings over 30 years, then it's an expensive thing to do. 18:44 If I can match the length of the repayment period, and therefore make the repayments less, uh, over, over this longer period of time, then it will become more affordable. 18:55 But as you said, the longer we lend as a development bank, um, the more capital we, we have and, and it's tied up. 19:05 Now, we can lend longer term than a commercial bank can because we are triple A rated and conservative, which makes us not prone, vulnerable to the economic cycle. 19:20 As you know, economies go up and down on a four, five, six-year basis, and in the down cycle, if you're a commercial bank, ma- many of your loans are going bad at the same time, and people who've lent you money as a commercial bank, uh, want their money back [laughs] at the same time. 19:38 So it's just hard for banks to lend long term. It increases their riskiness. But as a triple A rated institution, if ever we were short of cash, we can borrow very cheaply. 19:51 And in tough times when people are nervous in a down cycle, the place they wanna put their money in is a triple A rated institution. 19:59 It's triple A rated, uh, bonds, for instance, uh, the, the bonds that finance triple A rated institutions. And so we have a capacity to lend longer than others. So we can lend long, and we can lend cheaply. 20:14 Already development banks have a concessional facility. It's called IDA, International Development Association, IDA, and they lend 40 years at IDA money at less than the cost of their borrowing. 20:29 So they've already proven that they can lend long term. Um, so I'm saying, yes, let's lend 40-year money, but let's not make it less than the cost of the bank's borrowing. 20:39 If the development bank is lending to a customer at, at a lower cost than they themselves borrow at, there's gonna be a limit to how much you can do that. 20:49 It, it, it reduces the amount you can do, and one of the things that we know is that we're not doing enough, uh, so we, we need scale. 20:57 So it seems that the way we can make the debt affordable but also scalable is by making it long term, rather than making it even cheaper. 21:08 Uh, I don't know if I'm making sense, but if we make it even cheaper, we can never scale it, um, because w- the banks will be losing money on every loan. 21:15 So here we're not losing money on every loan, but we are lending long term. So we've got low cost, long term loans. The second thing we need to do is make those loans more flexible, adjustable to shocks. 21:30 So the kind of countries we want to be lending resilience loans to are vulnerable to climate impacts. 21:37 And, and we've seen in Latin America and the Caribbean over the last, uh, 12, 18 months, uh, lots of flooding, lots of forest fires. These shocks tend to be big. 21:48 In, in the case of the small islands, that's, that's even more... 21:50 very graphical to see because sometimes you see these satellite pictures of, of the Earth, and there's a, you know, big swirl of a storm that's bigger than the islands itself. 22:01 So you got storms bigger than your countries. You can get wipe-out risks. 22:05 So in those situations, all the people who've lent to you think, "Oh my God, your economy is, is decimated," and they worry that, "You're not gonna be able to afford my debt, and you're gonna default on my debt." 22:18 Uh, and so, you know, as your economy's decimated, you go out there to try to borrow some money to go and do the repairs and, and everyone's saying, "Well, I don't wanna lend to you 'cause I'm not even sure you'll repay the existing stuff I've, uh... 22:31 you, you... I've lent to you." 22:33 Uh, and so the idea of the pause clauses, and, and something that we put in when I was working in Barbados into a- all of our debt during a, a debt exchange, is that when, uh, a disaster happens, and it has to be a major disaster, this can't happen every, every year, uh, so we limit it to twice over 10 years, um, 22:58 then the government has a choice. It can suspend its interest payments and its debt servicing for two years. 23:07 Now, it then adds that back on to the bond, so the, the person who lent the money, the, the, the creditor, is at the end of the day no worse off. They've got all their interest and all their repayments back. 23:20 They've just had a, a bit of a reshuffling of the timing. And to compensate them for that, they've had a, a, a modest increase in their interest rate. 23:29 But they haven't had to lend to a country that's on its knees at emergency rates. It's a much more orderly process. It's predetermined. 23:41 Uh, the liquidity given to the country in the need, uh, is at almost the same cost as they borrowed initially, not at the emergency rates. And the scale is huge. 23:51 So for developing countries, if you can suspend all of your interest payments and your, and your principal repayments of your debt, that can be like a fifth of your national income, 20% of GDP. 24:04 If you had to go out there and go to an insurance company and ask the insurance company, "Insure me against a climate disaster"Uh, the premiums will be very high because the insurance companies know these disasters are happening more frequently, and they're bigger. 24:18 And so there is insurance out there, but companies are able to insure themselves maybe for one or two percent of their GDP. So the scale you get... Now, it's not like an insurance plan, you get cash, right? 24:30 Here, this is effectively a sort of loan at the same rate you were paying before. Um, but it's a massive loan for a couple years. And so we need long... low-cost, long-term debt with added flexibility. 24:46 And the final thing we need is the ability to, to borrow lots of that because that is more affordable, um, it's going to lead to more savings. 24:55 And the current way in which the, uh, authorities calculate debt sustainability isn't discerning about what have you used the money for, what have you used the debt for. 25:07 Have you used it for things that will save you even more money, or have you used for things that you'll never recoup? 25:12 So if we've got a more discernment about debt sustainability, and we have more flexible debt so you don't need to go into default after a disaster, and we have more long-term debt, and we have more low-cost debt, uh, then this is a transformation. 25:28 It'd be wonderful if, uh, you weren't in debt at all, right, and you had grants, and that people gave you money to become more resilient, especially if the changing climate was not a result of something that you did. 25:42 But there isn't a, a trillion dollars stuffed behind a sofa somewhere waiting for someone to find it. 25:48 Uh, so low cost, long-term debt over a long enough period that you can actually pay back the debt with the savings from the investment, I think is, is the way to go and the most realistic and plausible way to go. 26:03 This flexibility point, I think, is key and shows why these sort of loans, adaptation loans, only really make sense if they're issued by a MDB that doesn't have the commercial constraints of a commercial bank. 26:16 I'm interested in this point you made about countries having debt constraints of their own, right? 26:21 So it sounds like you wanna be able to create instruments that borrowers can take advantage of, but that don't prejudice them against raising funds in other markets for general purposes, right, normal sovereign bonds, et cetera. 26:34 So is there... Are you saying there's a constraint on the borrower side to take on more loans because they're not counted, uh, appropriately, like you said? Most definitely. 26:43 Most developing countries are, especially after COVID, where they didn't have this flexibility, and they had a massive disaster which required huge amount of spending. They prin-principally got money at emergency rates. 26:59 They've now ended up being very close to the debt limits as calculated in the old-fashioned way that doesn't care what you spent the money on, whether it was a, an investment that will recoup savings or not. 27:14 And so many developing countries are, are, are near this limit, which means that they can't invest in resilience. 27:20 It, it's a wonderful perversion that, in fact, the prudent thing to do, invest in resilience, is being stopped by rules that were meant to be prudential, that were meant to stop you from having too much debt. 27:37 Sorry, are you talking about IMF rules here? Are you talking about how credit rating agencies look at debt, indebtness of countries? 27:43 So the debt sustainability analysis is, is an analysis that is carried out, uh, most notably by the International Monetary Fund when a country comes to it for support and, and the World Bank too. 27:57 And other agencies, other entities look a-at the results of that debt sustainability analysis, so even if it's not theirs, they still use it, and they still consider it as a factor in, in their calculations because they know that the country can't go to the IMF if it's, you know, not debt sustainable. 28:17 So it has a, a stronger influence beyond just the IMF and the World Bank. But yes, so many people... And, and the IMF, I think, recognizes the issues, but they would say it's complicated to change it. 28:30 I mean, who is to determine whether a debt will lead to greater fiscal savings? If you speak to governments, they would say almost all of their debt will lead [chuckles] to future fiscal savings. 28:40 So you may need to create an, an independent entity that assesses those fiscal savings. And, and so it's not straightforward, but it is an essential thing to do. 28:50 That's really interesting, and it kind of comes back to efforts at the UN level and amongst financial institutions to really kind of quantify the benefits of adaptation, right? And I wonder, from your point of view, 29:02 is there a need to scale up some of this climate risk data and climate risk analysis to justify loans like this? Because I take your point that an MDB with their 29:13 u-unique profile don't have to worry about some of these issues that commercial banks have to. They can lend long-term, they can incorporate these fle- this flexibility, like climate resilient debt clauses. 29:23 But presumably, if you're gonna tie up capital for multiple decades, you also wanna be able to show on ins-inception, on the origination of the loan, that, look, we've done some analysis here. 29:32 We've used XYZ data vendor, XYZ consultancy to kind of go over the numbers, and we are pretty confident that we'll be able to get paid back through the savings that this adaptation loan will produce. 29:45 So is data and climate risk analysis important, an important component of this adaptation loan mechanism you're talking about? 29:52 And, and do you think the climate data world is at a point of maturity where it can provide that sort of surety to investors like, uh, MDBs, like the IDB? It's a, it's a really good question. 30:03 I think the, the, the, the value is as much for the country, the borrower, as it is for the lender. As multilateral development banks, we lend to governments. We know governments well. 30:17 We have preferred creditor status, which means if the government gets into trouble, they, they do have to pay us back first, and that means that the government is a good customerBut development banks. 30:31 But the government needs to worry about whether it can pay back its loans a-as well, uh, as, as the lender. 30:37 Uh, and so this data is very important, will help to maybe direct the government of what are the best things for them to invest in. 30:44 Because, you know, resilience, we, we tend to think about it in terms of individual projects, individual investments, individual bricks almost. But resilience is actually systemic, right? 30:56 Imagine I've made all of my roads resilient, but none of my bridges, it's not gonna be very helpful. Uh, a lot of roads to nowhere. 31:06 And so we need to have a, a national plan to think about systemic resilience and, and the government needs the data to identify what is the best way of spending its dollars, its scarce dollars, on resilience. 31:21 What, what, what combination, what sequence of investments leads to the greatest resilience? So that data is, is needed, that analysis is, is very much needed. 31:31 And the data has been leading to all kinds of interesting thoughts. I remember as a, as an ec- I, I, I often say to people I'm an economist, so I know no actual science. 31:43 It, it took an engineer to explain to me that maybe a resilient bridge is not, as I had in my mind, a heavier and heavier bridge, but a collapsible bridge. Hurricanes don't spontaneously combust. 31:59 You give, uh, you know, a minimum of three, four hours warning, sometimes longer. Maybe you collapse the bridge, hurricane passes over, open back up the bridge. 32:08 And that may be even more resilient than a bridge that's twice the sort of weight, and density, and, uh, of, of what you had before. 32:16 Uh, and so there's lots of scope for new ideas, new technologies to improve resilience, so we need data. Wonderful. 32:24 That's a great idea, the idea of collapsible bridges, and it kind of mirrors what you were saying about the importance of flexibility. We need flexibility in finance. 32:31 We also need flexibility in the hard tech solutions, and the hardware solutions, and the infrastructure solutions we develop to, to respond to climate risks and to prepare for climate risks. 32:41 I think that's really interesting. I think, I think you, you made a nice little theme there. It's all about shock absorbing, and not all shock absorbing is about weight, it's about bending. 32:52 Now I wanna turn from public finance world to private finance. I've got the impression that you're s-sort of bearish on private finance piling in to support climate adaptation. 33:02 And I'm with you when it comes to these large infrastructure projects like roads, bridges, and sea walls, where there isn't the capturable private revenues, as you put it, to really compensate private investors. 33:14 But there's this other kind of realm of climate adaptation that I've been exploring, where you have high tech solutions to agriculture, or to water management, or to flood risk management, and there's a number of companies, large number of companies that are springing up that are attractive targets for venture capital, that are proving attractive targets for institutional investors once they get to the kind of growth equity stage. 33:39 And I'm kind of interested in, in how you see private finance filling a gap in the adaptation landscape. 33:45 Or do you think those solutions that these VC-backed companies are providing are kind of small beer compared to the, the big meaty infrastructure projects that we need and that MDBs are financing? 33:56 So let me frame, uh, this discussion firstly in this way. 34:02 So developing countries, uh, who are, uh, particularly vulnerable to, uh, climate impacts and, and, and the band, uh, around the equator between the tropics of Cancer and Capricorn, so like 15 degrees either side of the equator, this band where about half the world's population live is the most prone to climate impacts, and that tends to be developing. 34:25 It's almost all developing countries. So developing countries have been saying, "Look, you know, our actions have caused this, this shift in the climate, these climate impacts. We need help." 34:36 And the response has been from other countries that, "Oh, you want money? Uh, what about using the private sector instead? What about, uh, insuring yourself instead?" A whole range of things that really don't work. 34:52 Uh, you know, insurance doesn't, doesn't mean you don't pay, [laughs] it just means you're paying installments, uh, with premiums. 34:59 And the private sector, uh, I'm a big believer in the private sector fi-financing the improvements in energy and food security, uh, and a range of investments where there are revenues. 35:14 Uh, and I spend a significant amount of my time thinking about how to mobilize private money into those things. 35:21 But if there's no capturable revenue, take a sea wall for example, I mean, how does the private sector get paid for building the sea wall? 35:29 They can't sort of charge people and say, "Well, if you don't pay, you won't be protected from it." It's a classic public good. 35:37 And the only way they can really deal with that is, like, charging everybody, which is just like general taxation really. 35:43 Um, and indeed the government's a bit better at charging everybody than, than, uh, than the private company would be. Now, you're quite right that there's a whole bunch of investments in technologies. 35:56 So for example, sea walls are made with high carbon intensive reinforced concrete, and there's some interesting technology that came across the other day on, on creating reinforced concrete without being high carbon intensive. 36:12 And so there's a private company doing that. Fantastic. But who is buying their product? It's the government. It is the government who's gonna be using the reinforced concrete in the sea wall. It's... 36:24 So there's all kinds of great tech-tech out there for better water management, for better flood defenses, uh, produced by the private sector. Fantastic. And they're doing it. 36:36 And yes, people can invest in those companies doing it. And yes, those companies want to do it 'cause they know that there, there's gonna be a buyer.Because of the climate increasing climate impacts. 36:46 But that buyer is invariably the government. So it's not... It's kind of privately invested, but it's still publicly funded. 36:56 Uh, and the problem I'm trying to solve is the public funding problem, and so the public funding problem, uh, a problem as in there's so much stuff that needs to be funded and governments don't have enough money, and the public funding problem isn't solved by private investment in this tech because the government ultimately is having to buy the tech. 37:15 What you're making me think is how this all comes back to economic growth actually. Because, yes, you have these private companies that are selling to governments essentially, right? 37:24 They're creating technologies, developing processes and solutions that are ultimately gonna be bought up by governments, local, state, federal governments for climate adaptation purposes, and those governments will need to pay for those technologies, et cetera, with revenue, and that revenue can either be through borrowing, uh, but it all comes back essentially to taxation, right? 37:41 And in order for governments to be able to purchase the adaptation tech they need, they need to have a large, strong economy, and that large, strong economy can be supported and made more stable if there is adaptation measures in place. 37:55 So I've been kind of, uh, I don't know, squeamish about some governments' massive focus on growth, right? 38:04 So the UK government right now is pushing very hard for growth, and there's some concerns that it's going to cut back on certain priorities because of that. 38:12 But actually, if that growth enables the government to get higher tax receipts and purchase the adaptation technologies and adaptation innovations we need, then maybe it's all for the good. 38:21 So I think you make a good point about, yes, this is all coming back to the government, and the government has to pay for it, and the best way for it to pay for it is to, in my view, to grow, grow the economy and make it strong and stable against climate shock. 38:31 So it makes the case that the adaptation and the growth agenda are kind of hand in hand. That's, that's how I see it anyway. 38:38 But let me complete the circle in a, in another way, which is that one of the best growth strategies for developing countries is investing in energy, food, and transport, and investing in the electrification of these things that actually increases productivity, increases efficiency, um, investing in, uh, clean air. 39:05 Uh, many of the cities in Latin America and the Caribbean are heavily polluted, and we are having huge health costs, lost, lost days of work, massive health expenditures because of the pollution in the air and the pollution in the environment. 39:22 And so in fact, investing in the other part of climate risks in the environment and in... and, and not degrading that environment actually is a source of growth. 39:35 We've done some work in Latin America and the Caribbean where for a dollar spent on energy, agriculture, and transport, um, uh, in, in the efficiency, sustainability, uh, transition will generate about $3 of savings if you include some of these health savings as well as the improved productivity from the efficiency of electrification. 40:02 I always find it interesting, financial analysis is all about forward-looking projections, right? 40:06 And then cascading back future cash flows at a certain discount rate, and it feels like adaptation should fit very cleanly into that. 40:12 But I still don't know if we've actually got investment professionals in the public and private sector to get comfortable with the idea of, okay, if we do X today, we will increase revenue or decrease losses X percent in the future, and that is something that we can then bond out against or, or collateralize a loan against and be comfortable doing that. 40:30 It seems like there's still a lack of trust in some of this data, maybe because we're only recently started thinking of natural disasters, extreme weather events as things that are predictable and that we know are getting worse because of the science we have, rather than as force majeure acts of God. 40:45 And it just... I just... 40:46 It, it's funny to me as a former financial journalist when I'd hear about structured products being put together based on cash flows that hadn't even started yet and why, why we can't have a similar financial innovation for adaptation when we're also talking about future-looking projections. 41:01 In my experience, I don't see that being the obstacle to adaptation investment. I don't see government saying, "I don't believe in these fiscal savings numbers." 41:13 I see government saying, "I've only got this much room to borrow this year, and I need to build a school. I need to build a hospital. 41:24 I need to open this road, and you want me to build a sea wall, the benefit of which will come sometime in the future?" 41:31 So I think it's, it's, it's an allocation of scarce resources in a developing country where they've got immediate pressing needs. I think the problem, I, I guess to, to your... 41:44 the way you framed it, it may be the discount rate in developing countries is too high a number, right? 41:51 So if it's a high discount rate, what it means is those future savings, uh, in 10, 20, 30 years don't count for much today, uh, because today I've got these really pressing problems. 42:03 I've got kids who don't have enough food, who can't get to school, and the, uh... and, and these things matter. 42:12 The equation is different in a rich country where the discount rate is much lower because there's greater certainty, and there's greater... the, the money available. The cost of money is, is lower. 42:23 So I think that's part of the problem of development, that the, these savings are there. 42:28 Uh, they can calculate the savings, but the savings long term into the future when you're speaking to a government about pressing needs, that's where, that's where they f- it fail... it fails to cut. 42:40 And so the only way I feel that I can get involved in that debate and shift the trade-offIs by making it, uh, even more affordable. By extending the repayment period, reducing the cost. 42:55 Um, something else, another instrument, Louis, that we've been looking at is something called reward for results, and then we c-call it part of our IDB, uh, clima, IDB climate. 43:06 And basically we, we will lend the money for a, say, a, a sea wall, you know, about a few hundred million dollars, and we'll find a donor who's prepared... Who doesn't have enough money 43:18 to build a sea wall for a country, doesn't have hundreds of millions, but is prepared to maybe pay part of the interest. So I can go to a government and say, "This would've been a, a 5%, uh, loan to build a sea wall. 43:35 And once the sea wall is finished and it's proven to be resilient, this donor's gonna come in and pay half the interest. It's gonna be a two and a half percent loan." 43:46 And so you can get your brand new sea wall with a two and a half percent loan. And I'm hoping that that kind of difference will make them say, "Yeah, okay, let, let, let's do that then." 43:56 So you've created some physical space for me, some room for me to still invest in those pressing needs. 44:02 And that's attractive to the donor because they already have certainty that the investment is providing the crucial function, but they also know they're having a direct impact on the country because they are reducing its repayment rate. 44:14 And so you, you hit the nail on the head, because in fact, that certainty is rare, right? 44:18 There's a lot of things in development, uh, that people put money towards that we're not sure is going to yield the return, uh, or sometimes doesn't. 44:27 So here their money only goes in when the s- they can see the sea wall, they can see it working. But here's the other thing, it's also much cheaper for them. 44:36 The multilateral development bank has put up the hundreds of millions of dollars. They're just paying part of the interest. 44:43 If they paid all of the interest for the entire term, it'd be almost the same as if they put up the money. But they're not putting... They're not paying all of the interest, they're paying part of the interest. 44:52 So the question is whether a government is persuaded to do an investment by you re-reducing the interest rate from 5% to 2.5%. 45:00 If I can persuade governments to do it because I've lowered the interest rate from 5 to 2.5, then we'll get more resilience done, and it doesn't require donors to be spending all of the money which they don't have. 45:12 I like that. That's a interesting spin on blended finance, I suppose, right? It's, it's the kind of the stage at which you inject philanthropic packed capital or other donor-supported capital. 45:23 It's slightly different from how some traditional blended finance funds are put together, but I can see it could be attractive for those who have to be a bit more discerning in today's environment. 45:31 And finally, we've been talking a lot about resource constraints, and one constraint is overseas aid itself, right? 45:37 And I'm wondering, some developing countries, they do rely on aid to a degree for economic development, for climate adaptation, and I'm wondering, with the shrinkage in overseas aid we've seen from the US, the UK, Germany, does that kind of put a spanner in the works for some of these plans for adaptation finance you mentioned? 45:54 Because it might be that developing countries are even more constrained than they were, and MDBs may also have to preserve their own capital, believing that they will potent-potentially lack, uh, future donations from donor governments. 46:07 So what do you think about the aid space in this context? 46:11 Well, one of my controversial ideas is that I don't really want to use aid for adaptation in any significant way, unless it's playing a sort of catalytic role, because aid is so scarce. 46:28 There's limited amounts of aid. And so I think aid should go on those things that can't be funded any other way. So here we've presented a way in which adaptation could be funded by multilateral development banks. 46:43 So don't use your scarce grant money for that. Use your scarce grant money for the thing that you can't borrow money for, and a good example of that is, is loss and damage. So the, the... 46:56 Yes, you need to borrow to build a sea wall. But what happened if you didn't have a sea wall and the, the, the, the village is being wiped out, and there's no homes, no schools, no clinics. 47:08 People are sleeping under blue tarpaulin. Uh, so you need to rebuild their homes. Uh, you can't borrow money to rebuild homes or get wa- that get knocked down every time you've had a disaster. 47:21 You'll be sinking under oceans of debt before the sea levels rise up. So I would say if all of the loss and damage in the world is bigger, i-in poor countries, it's bigger than all of the grants in the world. 47:34 So that should be the focus of the grants. Uh, I'd love grants to be bigger. Uh, even if they were bigger, they still probably wouldn't cover the loss and damage number. 47:43 And let's use the multilateral development banks for adaptation and for being a catalytic force in de-risking private capital investments in the energy, agriculture, and transport transition. 47:56 But could MDBs themselves be limited in terms of what capital they can provide if donor countries are, are pulling back or retrenching on their commitments? 48:05 I think that MDBs are, are the, one of the most effective ways donors can, uh, have impact, right? A dollar they put in an MDB leads to seven or eight dollars of, of, uh, of lending and impact. 48:20 Whilst a dollar that they do outside an MDB often has a dollar of impact. So, uh, it makes sense for them to use their scarce, uh, resources, uh, by putting some capital into MDBs. Now, let's say that they don't do that. 48:37 We still have some room left in the capital adequacy framework agenda. So things like have we got the right loan to equity ratio? 48:48 Could MDBs lend more with the amount of capital they have?Are they using callable capital enough? Uh, special drawing rights. 48:56 We believe that, uh, re-channeled special drawing rights, we can lend about six or seven dollars for every, uh, SDR we have, dollar of SDRs we have. 49:07 Using donors' money to guarantee a portfolio of multilateral development bank loans allows the multilateral development banks to reduce some of their capital behind those loans and then, then redeploy that capital. 49:22 So there's stuff we can do to what's called sweat the balance sheet, right? Also, that's already been done, and the lending room was increased by about $400 billion. 49:33 We could probably get that lending room up by a trillion dollars if we do all of the things recommended in the CAF review. 49:41 Yes, and I know you've been pioneering some of this work on reforming MDBs and helping them sweat those balance sheets even more, right? What is the kind of status of the MDB reform agenda? 49:51 What's next on the horizon there? Well, I think we've, we've done about half, but we've got another half to do. And, uh, I do fear that, uh, it's too early for us to run out of steam on the momentum. 50:03 You know, there, there's things like hybrid capital, right? 50:06 So let's say governments don't wanna put any more money in, but private investors might put some money in as capital if they got a return that was slightly more than a typical triple A-rated bond. 50:20 Um, and although that's paying slightly more than if donors gave them capital, the MDBs can, can leverage this money. And we can, we can re- re-channel more special drawing rights. 50:31 We can be better at defining what callable capital is. 50:35 Governments have put up callable capital, but they've not really made it very clear on what the terms are for which they can be called, and as a resu- uh, that capital can be called. 50:44 And as a result, the rating agencies say, "Well, I don't know how to, how to value this because you've not explained the callable function. You've just said it is callable." And so it... 50:55 We could do work on that, and I think we can double that lending headroom increase, more than double. But at the end of the day, we need the MDBs to be, to be bigger. 51:06 It's fascinating to me how innovative you can be with MDBs. 51:10 Like, I used to think that the Wall Street banks and the hedge funds are where all the smart financial innovation happens, but it sounds like there's lots of potential of MDBs to use their balance sheets in, in inventive ways and, as you said, make each dollar of donor capital go further. 51:24 So I feel people shouldn't underestimate the capability of MDBs to really add to the space and leverage their dollars to really bring about the adaptation outcomes we need. 51:34 Yes, of course, it's not all complete magic, 'cause ultimately we are lending for very boring things. We're building a seawall, not investing in an entirely speculative new cryptocurrency, say. Okay. 51:47 Well, Avinash, I really appreciate your time talking through all these issues with me today. You've been very generous. And I look forward to kind of following, uh, what you're doing next. 51:55 Where, where is your next, uh, trip? Where's your next conference? Where, where can people catch you? 51:59 [laughs] Uh, not sure yet, although we're gonna be in Santiago for the annual meeting of the Inter-American Development Bank at the end of March, and I'm looking forward to being in Chile. Mm-hmm. 52:09 I do recommend people keep track of Avinash on, on LinkedIn, his LinkedIn profile. 52:13 And yeah, I'll be sure to keep track of what you're doing and what the other MDBs are doing in adaptation going forward here at Climate Proof. 52:19 For now, thank you very much for your time, and have a great rest of your week. Thank you. Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 52:29 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]