Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation finance, tech, and policy. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at www.climateproof.news. 0:20 Today, I chat with Ben Andrews, the founder and climate resilience lead at Adapt40, a bespoke consultancy that helps governments and organizations identify their climate risks, build local capacity to deal with them, and plan adaptation solutions. 0:34 Why Adapt40? It turns out the name may be a little out of date. It was chosen to reflect how scientists initially believed 2040 would be the year the world exceeded 1.5 degrees of human-induced global warming. 0:46 Now, it looks like that threshold could be reached within the next five years. That's a big challenge for humanity, but means a lot of work and a lot of opportunity for companies like Ben's. 0:56 We talk about his journey to founding Adapt40, unpack the consultancy's philosophy when it comes to planning and implementing adaptation solutions, and get into the value of a, quote, "participatory approach" to building resilience. 1:08 Ben also lets us know what he really thinks about generative AI in the adaptation planning context. 1:13 Those listeners who work in adaptation consultancy and are familiar with the challenges dealing with government organizations are sure to hear plenty to get them nodding along. 1:21 For everyone else, it's a window into the hard but vital work that's being done to prepare regions and entire countries from worsening climate shocks. Before we get to the conversation, two quick housekeeping notes. 1:32 One, I'm pleased to announce that Climate Proof hit an important milestone last week. We bagged our 200th paid member. 1:38 That means we're two-thirds of the way to our 300-member target by September 30, a date that's no longer that very far away. 1:45 If you're a regular listener who hasn't yet made the leap to becoming a member, there's no time like the present. Head to climateproof.news/upgrade today. 1:53 The other note is that the Climate Proofers podcast will be taking a break in August. I'm planning on getting another episode out on July 29th, scheduling permitting, and then I'm off for a few weeks. 2:03 Rest assured, though, I'll return in September with lots more guests and fun convos on all things adaptation finance, tech, and policy. 2:09 Right, in a minute, my conversation with Ben, but first, a roundup of last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 2:15 [swoosh] In finance, global regulators plan to investigate how extreme weather events and poor insurance coverage may affect the financial system, even as countries diverge on the significance of climate threats to banks and insurers. 2:26 In a status update on addressing climate risks, the Financial Stability Board claimed that members are, quote, "starting to focus more on enhancing resilience" and are continuing to evaluate how analysis of physical risks and gaps in insurance coverage may affect financial stability. 2:40 The report follows an acrimonious meeting of the global regulatory panel in June when a US Treasury official argued that climate change should only be considered if there is proof of an imminent financial stability risk, according to Bloomberg reporting. 2:52 The official was opposed by representatives from France, the Netherlands, and Canada, among others. [swoosh] In policy, the US Environmental Protection Agency is shuttering its Office of Research and Development. 3:02 The move is part of a broader reduction in force announced last Friday that will cut the agency's headcount by 23% relative to January levels and save an alleged $749 million. 3:12 The ORD is the cornerstone of the EPA's scientific infrastructure, responsible for conducting in-house research and supplying grants to universities and private firms to further understanding of climate and environmental risks. 3:24 In its place, the agency is launching a new Office of Applied Science and Environmental Solutions, which it says will strengthen the connection between science and policy. 3:31 [swoosh] And in tech, Fugro and Esri are joining forces to craft geospatial tools that will inform climate-threatening countries on their resilience and adaptation plans. 3:41 The collaboration will bring together Fugro's high-resolution Earth observation surveys and predictive modeling with Esri's mapping and location intelligence software. 3:49 The initial idea is to produce easy-to-use data sets for small island developing states. [swoosh] Okay, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Ben. [upbeat music] Hi, Ben. 4:00 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. I am calling from Bermondsey in London, and I am the climate resilience lead at Adapt40. Thanks for joining us today, Ben. 4:12 I actually got to know you through one of our other podcast guests who came on recently, Sarah Farrell. Can you tell us a little bit about your relationship? Yeah, sure. I can go on all day. 4:21 Um, we met at Durham University back in 2009. 4:28 So yeah, we've been, um, going out and for a long time, married for about, God knows, about eight years now, and we're slowly but surely gravitated to the, um, climate space together. 4:39 This is actually our second couple who've been on the Climate Proofers podcast, so I think I'll, like, make a series of couples in climate adaptation. 4:46 For now, let's get into your personal journey into climate adaptation. 4:50 So going through your resume, you've had experiences at the UN, with development charities, and with engineering and infrastructure giant AECOM before founding Adapt40. 4:59 So can you tell us a little bit about your career history and how it led to this founding of your own bespoke adaptation consultancy? Yeah. When you put it like that, it's been a bit of a rollercoaster, actually. 5:09 Um, yeah, as you mentioned, I kind of spent most of my time in the development sector. 5:13 Back in 2010, I did a kind of first internship with, uh, the UN Development Program in Kosovo, working for community-based organization and charity, the Ideas Partnership. Big shout-out to them. 5:25 Still doing, um, a little bit of voluntary work for them. They're a wonderful Kosovo-based charity. 5:30 But yeah, since then, kind of I did some postings kind of out in Cambodia, Uganda, Myanmar, and it was kind of there where I saw a lot of the impacts of climate change and realizing that it's really impacting kind of development gains across the world. 5:46 So I applied for a master's in disasters, development, and adaptation at KCL under brilliant academics Mark Pelling and Helen Adams. Shortly after, I joined AECOM, um, had a great time there. 6:03 Spent a lot of that time with what was Mike Henderson's Resilient Cities team.And did a lot of work with a close-knit, wonderful team doing work with the likes of the World Bank, EBRD, 6:19 doing climate risk assessments, kind of adaptation work, infrastructure work, and green city action plans. There you go. 6:28 It was a really lovely experience working in cities such as Dushanbe, various cities in Turkey, Oman, the UK. 6:37 And it was at that time that I kind of thought there's, you know, a good space for kind of more specialist niche operators providing more targeted specialist advice on adaptation. 6:50 The big organizations are doing some great work, but I think you do need a good mix, some more agile, responsive organizations that can kind of meet maybe community and local needs a little bit better. 7:01 So that was kind of the reason why I thought, "I'll have a go at setting my own thing up and see how we go." Yes, a twisty, turny road. 7:10 I do wanna, before getting to Adapt40, just wanna double-click on AECOM there, because it seems to be a incubator for a wide number of folks who have then gone off to do their own thing in adaptation, whether working in the public sector, philanthropy sec- sector, or starting their own startup. 7:25 So can you tell us a little bit about AECOM and how it kind of fits into this adaptation resilience ecosystem? Yeah. They're a great organization. 7:33 They've got a wide range of service offerings from climate mitigation, sustainability, ESG, and climate adaptation as well, and they've got a wide reach. They've got offices dotted a- around the world. 7:46 So yeah, a, a lot of people go there, get some good experiences, especially with the big multilateral development banks and the World Banks of this world. And yeah, I'd like to think go off and do some great things. 7:58 I know a team that I was working with, some of them are working, uh, with the UN, some are working in different organizations and doing great work. So yeah, definitely an incubator. 8:09 And I definitely think these kind of bigger organizations with kind of grad schemes, you know, you kind of go there, and if you're fairly junior, you can get a range of experiences, which is always good. 8:19 Yes, I see a lot of job openings for graduates in climate resilience engineering at AECOM over here in the States, so it does definitely feel like a growth area for them. Yeah. But enough about the past. 8:28 Let's talk now about Adapt40. Can you tell us about how it started and how you brought the team together, and what projects are in your sweet spot? Yeah. 8:36 So we're a, a small and quite young, but, um, hugely passionate and, dare I say, talented kind of adaptation specialists. We only work in adaptation and loss and damage, so we don't try and do everything. 8:51 We stay in our lane, shall we say, and we do three things. We utilize and work with data, and working with stakeholders to identify climate and disaster risks at the local, municipal, national, and regional levels. 9:08 Secondly, we develop plans and strategies to build resilience to those risks and vulnerabilities which we identify, and we then spend quite a lot of time building capacity, developing tools, developing methodologies and guidelines to make sure that some of the work that we do sticks and the impact is sustainable. 9:28 The team kind of got together very organically back in 2021. 9:32 I got the ball rolling, shall we say, and shortly after brought in Jess Tinkler and Anastasia Chow to help with some of the national adaptation program work that I'd been doing in Moldova and Montenegro. 9:47 Jess was an old colleague from AECOM, so she took a bit of a risk, but she bought into the vision that we had. And yeah, we picked up kind of more projects, did some great work, got a good kind of track record. 9:59 And here we are, nearly four years later, about to celebrate our four-year anniversary. It's been a great process. A lot of hard work. Hasn't been plain sailing, as you can imagine. 10:10 But, you know, we've got people in New York, Glasgow, and Sri Lanka, but the team is mostly based in London. 10:17 Yes, I think it's remarkable that with a small team you have projects that are scattered across the globe and seem to have expertise that's relevant to many different jurisdictions and contexts. 10:27 Can I ask actually what the business model of Adapt40 is like? How do you go about finding these projects? Is it you scan around for request for proposal? 10:36 Do you have pre-existing relationships that have helped you get started? 10:39 'Cause I think there are a number of folks who listen in to Climate Proofers who themselves part of consultancies or trying to start up their own shops, and they might be interested to learn about how the business works. 10:48 Yeah, Louis, I'd say all of the above. We look at tenders, and we kind of win those. Of course, in the early days, the barriers to entry is quite high. 10:57 You know, lots of these bigger projects require three to five years of accounts and lots of track record. So it's... it was quite hard to kind of break into that a little bit. 11:07 I mean, a lot of time went into that, but, um, we won a few good bids, and then our kind of track record kind of, I'd like to say, spoke for itself a little bit, and we managed to get follow-on work. 11:18 But we're still a very young and small organization, so it's not the easiest of spaces to be, you know, bidding for. 11:25 But we do think of the climate sector as a community, and so we reach out to organizations such as the big infrastructure companies, some of the smaller ones, some of the specialist ones, and we team up. 11:38 So we don't really see it as competitors, but kind of partners and collaborators, and we've brought people onto our bids and our projects, and they do the same. 11:48 And that's kind of how we need to tackle climate change, in a collaborative fashion rather than trying to compete for different projects. 11:54 Yes, so you're, you're right size for the projects you take on, so you have to start small and keep to your knitting, I think the phrase is. So let's get into some of those projects. 12:02 You've got initiatives running from Dartmoor in the UK to the ASEAN Centre for Climate Change. 12:08 Can you talk about the common threads and familiar gaps that you found in adaptation capacity across these different geographies? Everywhere we work there is...Great people doing great work. 12:18 There's a wide range of knowledge and expertise everywhere you go, and that's the kind of brilliant thing about this role, is we get to work with different stakeholders in different contexts, and we keep on learning, keep on developing our, our knowledge. 12:33 And there can be a little bit of a kind of overlap, like what's the purpose of a international-based consultancy when there is loads of expertise and there's loads of knowledge? 12:43 I think what we try and do, and I think the purposes of a lot of consultancy, is to bridge that gap between local knowledge and expertise and what some of the donors and the multilateral development banks are looking for. 13:01 So in terms of converting some of that information, and, you know, we know all the international recognized tools and methodologies, and so we work with that data and build it into these methodologies so that we can... 13:15 Yeah, we're doing a bit of a translation kind of task there. I think that's sometimes what's lacking because the local organizations are, um, are... is where the money needs to be really. 13:25 They understand their risk and vulnerability and how best to build resilience. 13:29 So there is a little bit of a gap though, and to get the money to those organizations at that kind of local level, you need to have a good, strong evidence base. You need to be able to detail that very clearly. 13:41 So that's kind of what we do in a nutshell. Yes. I was just trying to summarize that in my head. 13:46 So it sounds like you provide extra expertise, capacity to kind of take what is known at the ground level in terms of climate risks, what adaptive measures may make sense, and then you kind of connect that with your knowledge of all the institutions and tools and techniques that are out there to really measure these climate risks and put together tried and tested plans to address them. 14:08 Exactly. Exactly. Essentially, it's data, and utilizing that data in a way that's kind of... 14:14 people can understand it from the kind of more local context to the decision makers who are financing a lot of these programs as well. Yeah. 14:23 So you mentioned cooperation and working with partners, and your approach is characterized by the use of, quote, "participatory methods and co-creation with local partners." 14:33 So can you tell us what this looks like in practice? Maybe there's a particular project you can talk us through about how you join together with the folks on the ground to create holistic adaptation plans. 14:43 Yeah, and it's a great question. 14:44 I think what's particularly powerful about kind of community-led projects is that the community understand their own vulnerabilities and strengths, and as the primary bearers of climate vulnerability and their impacts, they have a vested interest in reducing their vulnerability. 15:03 They also understand how best to build resilience to those climate risks as well, so they have that specific kind of local knowledge. 15:13 So when you put it like that, it's kind of mad that not all programming is either led or co-led by kind of community-based or organizations. 15:21 And we see lots of examples of where adaptation goes wrong, you know, what we call maladaptation. 15:29 And there's lots of great academics, Lisa Schipper and others, who have done lots of great papers on, on this, and it's, it really shows that, like, a shallow understanding of the vulnerability context and inexorable stakeholder engagement really inhibits adaptation, design, and implementation. 15:49 So that's kind of what we try and do at Adapt40, is we take stock of our positionality as international consultants, and we seek to engage local experts in our projects, and where possible, partner up with local organizations. 16:05 So there's work in Saint Lucia at the moment. 16:07 We're partnering up with a local organization to provide their expertise and knowledge of how climate change has impacted Saint Lucia and looking at some of the loss and damages and things like that that we need to factor in. 16:21 Um- That's a small island developing state. Yeah, in the Caribbean. So they're... Okay. So they're... What sort of climate risks are they facing and constraints on adaptation capacity? Yeah. 16:30 Well, a lot of the Caribbean states, of course, um, facing intensified, um, hurricane seasons, hurricane seasons be- beginning sooner, it's going longer and, and the intensity of the hurricanes is growing by the day, which is fairly horrific if you live in those pathways. 16:47 Of course, flooding is a big issue. Sea level rise is also an issue as well. In terms of constraints, I wouldn't like to fathom too much of an answer. 16:56 We just started working [laughs] with them, so I don't wanna stick my nose out too much. But of course, data is always a tricky one. We're doing a loss and damage needs assessment and action plan. 17:06 We need to make sure that the evidence base for that is absolutely concrete, so we use a lot of quantitative data and qualitative where it's not available. 17:16 Fortunately, we have our wonderful GIS team led by Janelle Johnston, who spent many years at the Ministry of Environment in Antigua. 17:25 She has a great understanding of data, GIS mapping and the Caribbean states, so I'm, I'm sure and con- I'm confident we're in good hands. Excellent. 17:34 That's an example of you having this technical expertise that can be readily applied to an in-flight project and really add value to a context which may be constrained because of issues with data, et cetera. 17:45 So I do seem to come across a lot of philanthropies, consultants, et cetera, that talk about participatory approaches and the importance of community-based resilience, et cetera. 17:55 But then you also see occasions where it looks like adaptation strategies are being imposed from the top down. 18:00 And I know this is a concern when it comes to national adaptation plans, the NAPs, that are being developed by countries under the UN process. 18:09 And you look just at the UK, for example, their national adaptation plan, it gets criticized for being a bit too top-heavy and also not actually having a, a clear thread from, like, the promised actions to actually delivery on the ground and engagement with folks on the ground. 18:21 So I was just wondering, what's your analysis of this space been? Do you feel like adaptation is, uh, primarily understood as something that has to come from the bottom up? And how do you think we can fix-... 18:31 areas where governments and maybe big philanthropies who think they know best coming in and imposing things from the top down. 18:38 It's a bit of a tricky one because a lot of the financing is coming from GCF adaptation funds channeled through some of the UN partners as well, and I'm sure all of the intentions are very good and honorable is to try and get the money and the impact down at the local level. 18:55 It takes a considerable amount of time and effort to do that. 18:58 And so you've got programs that are set for a certain amount of time, and to set a really participatory and inclusive process, uh, you might need a program which takes a number of years. 19:11 So I think the timelines for these sometimes are a struggle to make sure that we're getting all of the right people to the table. 19:18 But that being said, you know, I've been heavily involved in the Montenegro National Adaptation Plan process, and it's recently been adopted by the government, which we're all delighted about. 19:30 We involved lots of different non-governmental and governmental stakeholders in that process. 19:36 We did quite a lot of different, hopefully, engaging exercises where we brought people in to help us prioritize the different adaptation actions that we had drafted up, and we've had quite a, you know, one of those sessions where you get all the sticky notes and get different people in discussing these in a really holistic way, which is great to see. 19:57 That being said, there is always space to do more, including marginalized groups, women's groups, people with disabilities, things like that. There is always more to do on that space. 20:08 So I don't think it's ever done intentionally. 20:10 People are just in a rush to try and get this adaptation funding as quickly as possible 'cause people want to make sure that these projects are implemented quickly because of the climate change that's already impacting millions of people across the world. 20:22 But there needs to be a balance between kind of getting those projects up and running and doing it right because what you don't wanna do, as I mentioned earlier, is do the wrong projects which perpetuate inequalities, the structural inequalities that then increase vulnerability of those that you're trying to support. 20:39 So you do need to be very careful. And the best way of doing that is bringing in diverse voices because, like you say, they know their context better than anyone. One thing I hear... 20:49 a common complaint I hear is that getting money from the supernational level, from the UN, multilateral funds can take a long time, and some of that money, a lot of that money sometimes goes towards technical assistance, right? 21:01 That phrase means kind of building up the capacity on the ground in the first place so that these communities, so that local professionals can kind of get involved in the process of building adaptation. 21:10 And that does seem to create some frustration, uh, in some corners of the philanthropic but also in the private finance world 'cause it's like we wanna put money to work here, we wanna put our experts to work, but we are having to wait to kind of build up the local capacity to do so. 21:24 So is that an observation you've had, and do you think there are reforms in development that might help speed up the transmission of finance, but also of expertise? Yeah. 21:33 I mean, I've got an opinion because, like I said, I typically work at that level where we're trying to identify progress and develop these strategies. 21:40 So, you know, we work with GCFs and GEFs and all these big vertical funds. 21:46 I would say that there is a balance that needs to be struck because there is a lot of scrutiny on where climate money, especially now in our kind of Trump days and the climate that we're in now, to make sure that we can demonstrate the benefits of every penny that's been spent. 22:04 And there is a good reason for that as well. You know, there was a bit more trust maybe, but I think now there's any opportunity to kind of color funding, people will take it. 22:13 So I think people are very cognizant of that. Therefore, when you kind of request proposals and things like that, you're requesting a lot of information, a lot of data. 22:23 Where's the evidence base coming that says that this is a vulnerability hotspot? Okay, where's the evidence base that says that that adaptation plan or that measure is gonna have that impact? 22:32 How are you then gonna measure it through the... 22:34 And so to provide all of that information is, of course, a big task, and it does require, on many occasions, kind of technical assistance from, from the likes of myself and, and my team to say, "Okay, this is how you can measure it. 22:47 This is the kind of indicators you can put in place. We have this data. We can measure this." So, yeah, I think it's, it's a bit of a balancing act. 22:57 I don't know if they're getting it right or they're getting it wrong, but yeah, I think I can see it from both ways there. So that answer is right on the fence. Very political, Louis. I haven't jumped on either side. 23:08 [laughs] Oh, yes. Yes. Straddling the divide like a colossus there. [laughs] But I will say there has been recognition within these funds themselves, right? 23:15 The Green Climate Fund has been talking about speeding up implementation. I know this is a focus at GEF as well, Global Environment Facility. 23:23 So there is recognition of the challenge, but because these are organizations that are built on consensus, right, amongst stakeholders from across the world in very different 23:32 political, social, and climate context, it can be hard to get agreement on needed reforms and, and get those reforms actually implemented. Absolutely. 23:39 But it's interesting to hear how this could affect the kind of value chain of adaptation consultancies and implementing experts down the line. Yeah. 23:47 And onto that sort of like the value of Adapt40 and adaptation consultancies writ, writ large, I'm wondering where you think the, I suppose opportunities is the word, uh, are for you over the next five years in terms of the challenges or the countries, maybe the regions in which you can add the most value. 24:03 And, and what do you think about the competitive landscape for the kind of professional services that you provide, right? 24:08 So as I said, there seem to be a number of consultancies, small bespoke adaptation consultancies cropping up. 24:13 One imagines that with the cutbacks in overseas development assistance, the mass firings here in the US and elsewhere of, of very talented professionals who are very well-versed in adaptation resilience and have good connections in developing countries, they might start their own firms, right? 24:30 There might be a whole mushrooming of adaptation consultancies. But then you're also seeing some of the, some of the big boys kind of getting into adaptation as well. 24:37 Just wondering how you see the competitive landscape and where you think the most value can be added by an Adapt40 over the next five years.We, um, the, the team actually, we, we got together last Tuesday and we had a bit of a strategy session, kind of answering this question, so it's very timely. 24:52 There are a lot of people doing great work. There are a lot of people who see adaptation as an opportunity area who aren't doing as great work. 24:59 So I think our kind of main focus is making sure that the work we deliver is as high quality, as useful, as kind of value for money as, as possible, really, and then hopefully that puts us in good stead. 25:12 If it doesn't, it's kind of out of our hands a, a little bit, but we can be a bit savvy, and we stick to our, our channel, and we work with the clients that we have very closely. 25:23 So what we don't try and do is, is kind of expand too much, look at all different projects, and get, get a bit kind of touchy. 25:31 We just stick to what we know, stick to know what we're good at, and hopefully that will, will carry us through. 25:36 Adapt40's focus is on our ability to work with data, work with stakeholders, and to do so in a very effective way. And so we'll just carry on in, in that regard. 25:47 Um, we have a lot of experience working in data-limited contexts, supporting local teams with quantitative, qualitative, and data collection management, visualization, and GIS mapping. 25:59 As mentioned, we've got a great GIS team. And I think going back to this strong evidence base to persuade these decision-makers to invest in climate adaptation is where our value is. 26:13 We can help with developing strong project proposals, and we work with community-based organizations all the way through to the big UN organizations in trying to convert that data into really useful, visually appealing data and reports so they can take that and hopefully leverage more, more funding and deliver the impact that they want to see. 26:33 We need to be very persuasive, especially with regards to the cost and benefits of acting now. You know, that really needs to be fundamentally clear, the difference between acting now and acting in five years' time. 26:44 'Cause, you know, money speaks, and if you can say that this is gonna have impacts, economic impacts, non-economic impacts over the next five, 10 years, and this is what will happen if you don't act, that's very compelling if you're provided that, and that's the kind of work we strive to do. 27:00 In terms of the competitive landscape, if you're doing great work in this space, feel free to reach out to us. We'll see how we can collaborate. We work with lots of different organizations. 27:10 A- as I said earlier, partners, not competitors. And if you're not doing great work, we'll probably kind of stay away from you [chuckles] as well. So I'm not too concerned about the future landscape. 27:20 I'm more concerned about the lack of, of funding. That is a big, big issue. Funding isn't cut at the local level and being as efficient with it as possible. 27:28 So yeah, spend less money on technical advisors and consultancies if you're gonna get that money down to a local level. That's why we're all doing it. 27:36 One way to reduce costs is to ramp up the use of efficient tech, right? 27:40 And you mentioned your expertise in data, in GIS, and I've written a lot about geospatial and remote Earth observation technologies and companies that are springing up to provide data analytics at a lower price than ever before to private companies and to governments even, and government agencies. 28:02 I was just wondering if you could speak to any of the developments in GIS, in geospatial that may help 28:09 you and your team going forwards in terms of providing more comprehensive coverage and also at a cost-competitive level. Yeah. 28:16 I think, you know, there's, there's been great developments for GIS and mapping, and there's a space for AI in that. 28:24 I'm a technical advisor for Tajikistan's National Adaptation Plan and work on different national adaptation plans as well, and I have seen the use of AI being put into effect not very effectively at all. 28:37 And I think when you're talking about kind of climate adaptation, everything needs to be absolutely concrete. 28:43 I am a little bit concerned about the use of AI and organizations using it, um, as a bill of a kind of means to say, "Look, we can churn out all of this kind of reports and stuff like that." But when you kind of 28:55 dig into the detail a little bit, it becomes a little bit fuzzy. So I am a little bit concerned that AI is gonna be used as shortcuts. 29:02 I think there's definitely a use for it, and it can be used effectively in the right people's hands. But I think there's also a big concern around AI in, in the industry, um, people receiving reports and you go, 29:15 "That's gobbledygook." So it's being used to populate reports, and the reports are showing evidence of AI hallucinations or just the- Mm-hmm... making connections that aren't there, et cetera? Yeah. 29:29 Speaking to people in the, the sector, you know, people have seen reports produced by AI or supported by AI, but not really verified very well, and I, I think that's a big concern for an industry such as climate adaptation. 29:43 So I think I, I'm not an AI person. Still getting to grips with how it can be utilized. 29:48 My data and GIS team are a lot more familiar with that, and it's something we'll explore and see how we can do things more efficiently. But yeah, lots of caveats around that. 29:59 But, you know, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts in that you see more kind of closer detail there. 30:03 I do think there's an attempt to use AI to fill in modeling gaps or to affect downscaling or to take course data at the geographic level and make it more granular, right? Mm-hmm. 30:15 Because there's this big concern in private and public circles to have asset-level data or very specific locational data. 30:23 Because we know climate risks, although we know in the round that they're increasing in frequency and intensity, we know that their impact will not be evenly distributed around the globe or around regions. 30:34 And indeed, the very topography of the land, the built environment can determine how devastating those climate impacts can be. 30:41 So there's a real need for very granular data, and y- actually, a, a large number of these new satellite-powered-Geospatial companies can provide very granular data like that, but I do know a lot of folks are trying to use AI to fill in modeling gaps in climate risk analysis, but also to provide that sort of translation layer, right? 30:58 Which is like, okay, GIS data, GIS methods of working are... 31:03 They're a bit archaic, and there is kind of secret knowledge held by, by a few, and it's not the most easily accessible to folks who work in a bank or folks who- Sure... 31:11 you know, are working in a consultancy and haven't got this experience. So there's a lot of attempts to use AI to kind of translate some of this complex data into something more tangible for frontline users. 31:22 But then again, in that translation, what do you lose, right? There's a danger that there is misinterpretation or you think the data's telling you one thing, and actually it's doing another. 31:31 And oversimplification, right? I think I see that in my use of AI, right? When I'm trying to summarize things, and it just oversimplifies and smushes things together in a way that makes no sense. 31:39 And when it comes to adaptation, if you make those sort of simplifications, you can really cause trouble for yourself down the line. 31:45 Yeah, no, I completely agree with everything you're saying really, but, uh, you know, as long as the work is kind of ground truth at a local level and validated by various stakeholders, then it's, it's, it's great to use. 31:56 And, and you know, we should be doing that all the time with data, whether it's kind of AI supported or not really. Yes, ground truthing's come up a few times actually in recent conversations. 32:05 One with Garrett Kephart of Earth Finance. He was talking about the importance of ground truth verification. 32:11 So it feels like adaptation's this interesting space where there is great capacity to use this high tech AI-powered tools and geospatial data, but a real understanding as well, at least amongst those more sophisticated in this world, that you also still need the boots on the ground. 32:26 You kind of need two different types of workforces and two different mentalities, not just the sort of high tech, we can do everything from behind a computer, and also not just, okay, we need to spend thousands and thousands of pounds or dollars on workforces on the ground. 32:38 It's this interesting synthesis that is needed. Yeah. Yeah, definitely. We're working on this very interesting project with the UN-Habitat. It's called the Rise Up program. 32:47 We work with 10 different countries, 12 different cities, so from South America to Jordan to Laos to Sri Lanka to Ethiopia to South Africa and Madagascar, amongst others. 33:00 And we're working with the country offices at UN-Habitat and the headquarters team into s- basically supporting that process. So we help develop this methodology where you can utilize open source data. 33:11 So we don't want data to be a big limitation. So, you know, it takes kind of six months or something to try. We want it to be able to kind of help provide some indications of where the vulnerability hotspots are. 33:23 And so yeah, my team have been working with the different country offices at, at UN-Habitat to kind of help them through that process. 33:30 And then that country offices goes and kind of ground truths and kind of works with the different stakeholders to say, you know, "Is this data that we've found, which is open source, which isn't really high spec kind of data, you know, anyone can access it, is this telling, you know, the, the truth really? 33:45 What's your lived experience? Does that reflect it?" So I think that's a great, great way that you say we kind of need the, the two to work together. Okay. 33:52 Now, one aspect about Adapt40 that I really admire is that you pledge to channel a portion of your revenue towards pro bono work and climate justice work. 33:59 So can you tell us a little about that, and, and where are you seeing the most need for this kind of pro bono work? 34:04 It is a real honor to kind of work with community-based organizations, and as I kind of mentioned throughout this discussion, it's something which we're kind of really passionate about. 34:13 When I was doing my master's, I, I did, uh, my dissertation thesis on how social capital affects vulnerability to climate change in Madagascar, and I looked at two different communities. 34:23 One was quite interlinked, one was very remote. And I was supported by YMCA Madagascar, a great guy called Harry Miaina and his team out there. 34:32 And they gave me so much support when I was struggling with my various research questions and having logistical challenges and needed to get a better idea of the cultural aspects of these communities. 34:43 And so when we set up Adapt40, we, we really wanted to kind of not just give back to those types of organizations, but carry on learning from them. 34:52 There's so much that we need, um, to, to kind of work with in terms of those community-based organizations. And so it was a simple choice for us to say, "Look, how can we separate ourselves? 35:03 You know, we can do things great, but w- what else can we do?" And so we wanted to commit a certain amount of our revenue to s- providing technical advisory services to community-based organizations. 35:14 And so it's been a joy to work with YMCA Madagascar over the last few years. We have a couple of French speakers in our team, so that's helped. 35:22 And we've been helping them when the cyclone season comes with kind of disaster risk reduction and disaster preparedness activities, supporting with community early warning systems as well. 35:34 And we've tried to carry on that, that model, and so we're also working with a wonderful organization called Nuestra Genesis in Cali in Colombia on very kind of similar things as well, so doing lots of vulnerability mapping, early warning systems, and hopefully we're gonna do a kind of multi-layered vulnerability assessment so they can feed that into the local plans and advocate for some of those local communities. 36:00 So yeah, it's been a real privilege to be able to do that, and we want to do more. So if there's any community-based organizations in the UK or globally that would like some advisory services or just a chat, let us know. 36:13 We've got an open door policy, and we'd love to, uh, speak to you because we feel that local level work is where change happens, and we want to support that as much as possible really. Yes. 36:23 I can't help but feel you'll get a lot of people take you up on that offer, given the cutbacks in spending on the UK and globally and the ODA spending. 36:32 So I think there's gonna be a greater need for free or near free services on adaptation, and I think it's great that you're providing the model here, providing an example of how you can do this. 36:42 You can make money on certain projects and use that money to help support other ones as well. So I think you're really embedding the idea of climate justice. 36:48 And we hear about the importance of just transition, but we need a just adaptation and just resilience as well.Absolutely. Okay, Ben. 36:56 Well, to finish off, just give us a little rundown of what's coming up for you over the next six months or so. What other projects do you have in the pipeline? What things are you looking forward to? Yeah. 37:05 Lots going on, which is, which is great to see. We are working with Dartmoor National Park Authority on developing their climate vulnerability assessment, and so that's gonna feed into their adaptation planning. 37:19 So this week we've got loads of workshops. We're trying to get an idea of the different priorities that the different stakeholders in Dartmoor have, and so we can factor that into the assessment. 37:29 Lots of interesting maps. There's a, a wealth of kind of data that Dartmoor has available, so we can do some interesting kind of mapping and visualizations, which will be really cool. 37:40 We are hopefully finishing up on the establishment of the, um, ASEAN Centre for Climate Change, and we've been helping operationalize that since last December. 37:52 So I've been working with the different member states of ASEAN, which has been a great process, and we're doing kind of needs assessment, stakeholder engagement piece, and oper- operational framework out there. 38:03 So we were in Brunei last month, and yeah, hopefully kind of bring that to, to, to an end shortly as well. 38:12 Carrying on all the interesting work we do with Australia funded programs such as Partnerships for Infrastructure, where we're looking at how we can integrate climate change and disaster resilience at the infrastructure level. 38:23 So it's a great range, and it's nice to have a bit of both as well. 38:27 We have civil engineers in the team, Upashika, who lives out in Sri Lanka, who works a lot on the Partnerships for Infrastructure projects, so it's great to have that as well. 38:36 But yeah, hopefully, um, winning some more interesting projects, developing the team, doing more pro bono pieces, and supporting and working with local organizations is the name of the game, hopefully. 38:49 There's a lot of variety there. 38:51 You obviously got a lot of irons in the fire, and I think it really reflects how adaptation it does, as I've said time and again, it cuts across sectors, it cuts across geographies, it cut across disciplines as well, right? 39:00 So you need to have a multidiscipline team, a flexible team. And I think actually that's why adaptation's quite an exciting place to be if you're a, a young professional, a mid-career professional, a later professional. 39:10 I think lots of folks are coming in from all stages of their career, from all different disciplines because there is such a need for this expertise. 39:16 And it sounds like at Adapt40 you've got a, a crack squad put together to really deliver on these projects and to meet various needs from various stakeholders in all sorts of places, from Dartmoor to ASEAN. 39:26 So great work you're doing, Ben. Great work that you and the Adapt40 team are up to. I look forward to keeping tabs on your progress, and perhaps we'll speak again soon. I, I certainly hope so. 39:36 And yeah, thank you very much for having me on, on the show, and keep up the fantastic work you're doing. Kind of adaptation communications is, is absolutely vital, and you're doing a s- a smashing job. 39:47 Love the newsletter, love the episode, so yeah, look forward to hearing many more. Cheers, Ben. Have a good rest of your week. Thank you very much indeed. 39:57 [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 40:09 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]