Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. 0:19 Today, we're joined by Bill Green, the managing director of Climate Adaptive Infrastructure, a unique investment fund that finances projects that address the risks and opportunities of climate change. 0:30 Their belief statement is, "Our society is building infrastructure for a planet that no longer exists." 0:35 This summarizes very well the trouble with storing up for the future if we don't properly account for climate shocks. 0:41 CAI invests in North American infrastructure with a focus on energy systems, water, and low carbon projects. 0:48 Bill himself is an old hand when it comes to infrastructure as an asset class, which we'll get to in the interview. 0:53 But first, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber supported productions. 0:59 Listeners like you can help support my coverage by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. 1:07 Okay, in a moment, my chat with Bill, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:13 [swoosh] In finance, researchers have developed a methodology for creating adaptation smart credit ratings for government debt. 1:20 Institutional investors from pension funds to insurance companies buy and hold government debt, also known as sovereign debt, as a core part of their investment strategies. 1:29 Often, they rely on credit ratings provided by S&P Global, Moody's, and Fitch to help choose which bonds to buy and which to leave alone. 1:37 The researchers say these ratings may be underestimating countries' exposure to climate shocks and disregarding the adaptation measures they are taking to protect their economies. 1:46 To fix these blind spots, the researchers present a way to create adaptation smart ratings that incorporate the impacts of extreme weather shocks and climate adaptation efforts. 1:55 Applying this methodology, they found that physical risk effects on sovereigns could be much greater than previously estimated, but also that they could be offset through smart adaptation investments. 2:04 [swoosh] In policy, the UK government set up a floods resilience task force with a mission to identify and protect flood risk areas, promote effective flood defenses, and support community-based flood management schemes. 2:17 At its meeting last Thursday, the group discussed improving the coordination of flooding preparation and resilience across different levels of government and finding ways to speed up development of the UK's flood defenses. 2:28 The task force is part of the Department for Environment, Food, and Rural Affairs, with members drawn from across government departments, as well as the Environmental Agency, Met Office, National Farmers Union, and community level stakeholders. 2:41 The task force is chaired by floods minister, Emma Hardy. 2:45 [swoosh] And in tech, last week saw the release of the Resilient Planet Finance Lab's annual report, which includes information on an array of initiatives at the intersection of climate resilience, AI, geospatial data, and the investment and insurance industries. 2:58 The lab was set up last November as part of the Resilient Planet Initiative, a research and innovation partnership launched at COP28. 3:06 Its purpose is to produce data and analytics that unlock finance for adaptation, resilience, and nature goals. 3:11 Over the last year, the lab has racked up a slate of achievements, chief among them the Resilient Planet Data Hub, an open resource that collates information on climate hazards, infrastructure networks, and land use. 3:22 It can be used by public and private investors to make climate informed capital allocation decisions. [swoosh] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Bill. [upbeat music] Hi, Bill. 3:35 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. My name is Bill Green. I'm the managing partner of Climate Adaptive Infrastructure, a firm we founded now almost five years ago. 3:45 Our headquarters is in beautiful downtown Mill Valley, California, right over the Golden Gate Bridge. Well, thanks for joining us, Bill. Pleased that you could be here. 3:53 My first question is, would you describe how Climate Adaptive Infrastructure came about? And while you're at it, can you define what adaptive means for your firm? Yeah, great. 4:02 So my partners and I have been doing something or other relative to the climate or sustainability space for decades. 4:10 And what we realized was that infrastructure, uh, an asset class that many investors like and, and invest in historically, is also the single most vulnerable asset class in the face of the climate crisis. 4:26 So the firm, Climate Adaptive Infrastructure, was founded to address both the risks and opportunities of the climate crisis when it comes to real asset investing. 4:38 And we intentionally chose the name not to indicate, uh, adaptation as in get ready, the climate crisis is upon us, but more around being adaptive to the way we think about and deploy capital when we invest in infrastructure. 4:57 And just set, to set the table, I'll say one more thing. 5:01 You know, infrastructure as an asset class, if some of our listeners today are, are allocators of capital, um, they think of infrastructure as real estate, they think of it as, as ports or toll roads, and it's all of those things. 5:13 But to zoom out, we will spend and have historically spent about two trillion dollars a year on this planet on new and renewed infrastructure. 5:24 So this is a tremendous asset class and a tremendous opportunity if we go about it correctly. 5:31 Now, I'm right in thinking this isn't your first rodeo when it comes to infrastructure investment, and I was hoping you could give me a little background to, to your career and, and how you kinda found your way into climate adaptive infrastructure as, as an asset class. 5:43 I, I, I, I got a kick out of Elon Musk's hat in a, in a, in a post the other day, which said, "This is actually my second rodeo," so I'll steal that line. I'm an operating guy by background. 5:53 I founded four companies in what we would broadly call this space, including Ecolink, which was the first company that produced alternatives to chlorofluorocarbons in the late '80s, early '90s. 6:04 These are the ozone depleting solvents.And chemicals that we've all heard so much about back in the day. So I sort of began my career by doing well, by doing good, and building this business. 6:16 And then I found my way to Silicon Valley and sort of stumbled into the venture capital or private equity industry, where we began a fund we called a clean tech fund at that time. 6:27 So this was one of the very early iterations of that. We were one of the first institutional investors in a small electric car company called Tesla Motors. 6:35 We did a number of very interesting and innovative things in the venture asset class. 6:40 But what I realized after about a decade working with my partners in that context is that early-stage capital is not the most effective when it comes to moving the needle on the climate crisis, and that it would be infrastructure, the things we build around us as a society, that really would matter more. 7:01 And I found my way to Macquarie, the world's largest owner of infrastructure, where I spent a decade sort of learning the trade and working in renewables in North America. Learned quite a bit during that period of time, 7:15 including some of the things that we now do at CAI, which were conspicuously absent from the larger investment firms at that time. And here I mean notably the climate screens. 7:30 So what we realized during that period was that infrastructure can't and doesn't change its business model in the course of its life, but many other businesses do. 7:43 Just as a quick example before we end on this point, if you think of Uber, well, Uber can decide to sell food, and they put up a new webpage, and ta-da, they're Uber Eats. 7:53 But a toll road, metaphorically speaking, that you buy or build along the coast below sea level that experiences a hundred days of sunny day flooding, you can't move the toll road. It doesn't change its business model. 8:07 It doesn't become a port. The toll road is what you've bought or built, and you're stuck with it. 8:13 So what we learned over that long period of time at Macquarie in looking at all of the various infrastructure, including renewables and some of the things that we were doing during that period, is that infrastructure has to be thought about, has to be treated differently, and that's why CAI was born, and that's just what we do. 8:33 Yes, there's this inflexibility inherent in infrastructure because it is supposed to be so long-lasting, because it has a set mission, right? 8:40 And that kind of puts the onus on investors and project developers to really think decades into the future about how this infrastructure will perform. 8:48 And on that point, I'd like to ask a little bit about your investment and due diligence process at Climate Adaptive Infrastructure. 8:55 Because when we've spoken before, Bill, it became clear that you have an innovative approach to sizing up potential investments. So can you talk to us a little bit more about that? Yeah, for sure, Louis. Thanks. 9:05 So the climate screens that we developed at CAI are our economic North Star. 9:11 We coined a, a term, phrase here called the triple threat risk of the climate crisis to sort of help people see that the risks we are talking about relative to infrastructure are not only the physical risks that we often think about first when we think about the climate crisis. 9:29 As we speak, I was just looking at the news, a thousand people in Africa have been killed in flooding, so we all sort of deal with these disasters, uh, around us every day, wildfires and, and hailstorms and flooding and so on, but that's only one of the three risks as we see it. 9:47 The other two that make up the triple threat risk are regulatory risk and political risk. And we can get into that more in a moment, but we call that the triple threat risk. 9:57 So what we do here is we use our bespoke climate screens to consider the risks and the opportunities, because there are opportunities at the same time, and we do that starting from initially looking at any investment. 10:14 These screens consider a number of things, carbon impact, the ability to get the project built and so on. And when investors look at those screens, they often think, "Wow, this is an impact fund." 10:25 And indeed, we do have considerable impact. 10:28 But make no mistake, we consider the climate screens as important an economic set of considerations as leverage, geography, currency risk, interest rates, and, and all the rest. 10:41 So that is, as I said, our economic North Star. Wonderful. And can you also talk us through the actual kind of nuts and bolts of how you as, as a firm go about approving investments based on these screens? 10:53 'Cause it sounds like it's a very collaborative approach which requires almost unanimity amongst the different participants. Is that correct? Yeah, you know, it's interesting. 11:02 Over the decades of, of our collective careers, my partners and I learned a lot of things not to do as well as things to do, and one of the things we learned not to do is outsource this sort of work. 11:13 There are firms, some of them quite good, that will sort of look at these risks for you. We said, "No, no, if we are really serious about this, which we are, we're going to do it in-house." 11:23 The other thing that we learned is that unanimous decision-making by the investment committee is quite critical. So we call this the I'm hungry and would like to get to lunch, so let's just take a vote phenomena. 11:36 So really what we do is we say, "Look, the five members of our investment committee need to all be unanimous when we consider how to score." It's a numerical scoring system, our, our climate screening program. 11:49 So we have to all agree, and it isn't like we get in a room and say, "Okay, everybody write your answer down on a sheet of paper and throw them in the box." 11:57 It, it really isn't like that, and in five years it's never played out like that. What is more likely to happen is one of the five or more will say, "You know, I'm not quite ready to score yet. 12:07 I think we should talk more about whatever thing next." And of course, that engenders the additional conversation.So those are some simple learnings and some things we've built in to the practice. 12:19 But, but I'd go a step further. You know, when we built the climate screens, we built them, as I said, bespoke when we founded the firm. 12:26 What we've gone on to do is think about how to enhance and strengthen the overall practice group here around the climate screening, and the most recent innovation of that was to take the time to learn how the EU taxonomy works in something called SFDR. 12:45 Uh, we won't get too far into that today, but anyone who, who wants to geek out on that can certainly hit me up offline and we'll... [laughs] We can give show there's plenty. [laughs] Yeah. 12:56 In the US, less so, in Europe, certainly a considerable number because it's- it is the EU taxonomy. 13:01 But my point in raising that is that the EU taxonomy is a very, very rigorous, defined set of criteria, questions, and considerations. 13:10 When we first looked at it, we thought, "Wow, this is really quite onerous and burdensome." The more we studied it, the more we realized that the work we do today actually feeds directly into much of this SFDR work. 13:23 So we are, I think, one of the only US-based mid-market managers that now reports to the SFDR 9 standard of the EU taxonomy. 13:33 So that's just an example of how we're continuously enhancing and revisiting this screening to make sure it doesn't become a stagnant sort of part of the practice group. Excellent. 13:44 Now, looking at the, the triple threat, as you call it, I'm interested to know how you think about interactions between them, right? 13:49 Because there is this body of research and evidence indeed to show that, uh, increased physical risks from climate change do spur certain adaptive behaviors by individuals, businesses, and governments. 14:01 Of course, it can spur political risks. So I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about how you see the interactions between those, those three threats. Yeah. 14:08 Let me begin with a curveball, one of my favorites, 'cause when we have these discussions, we often sort of think about how this threat contributes to that threat and sort of how we won't make our goals of one and a half or two degrees. 14:20 When we think about political risk, one of the, the three sort of quadrants, we also take into account, believe it or not, the possibility that climate regulation can accelerate. 14:34 In other words, one of the things that we find few others consider is what we lovingly call the handbrake effect. 14:42 Um, imagine you're in a stick shift car, yes, there was such a thing in my day, and you're rolling down the hill in neutral, and the person driving the car pulls the handbrake, and all the passengers in the car sort of whipsawed, right? 14:54 You've, you've, you've got the word picture now. 14:56 So what we consider, among so many other things, is what happens if, in a certain geography or in a certain sub-sector, the regulatory regime actually accelerates unexpectedly? 15:09 This is the opposite of the business as usual scenario, and we think about, well, that could be good or it could be challenging or it could be both and, and we wanna understand that as well. 15:20 So we look at all of these scenarios. You asked about the interplay between them. 15:26 I mean, I, I think that's very interesting and, and provocative, Louis, in that what we find is that the sectors in which so many people are active today, in fact, there's a relatively new term called the energy transition. 15:40 These are actually more siloed intellectually than what is actually taking place on the ground. 15:48 My point here is that our firm invests in energy and water and urban infrastructure, again, through the lens of triple threat risks and opportunities, but we don't see them as separate or siloed. 16:03 We see this as a matrix, and let me just give you a couple of examples. If you have a wastewater treatment plant and you have sludge, I know not a cocktail party conversation, but hang with me on this. 16:15 So you've got this sludge, it's got methane gas in it, it's wet, you can no longer land spread it because it contains all sorts of toxins, so you've got to do something with it. 16:25 Well, if you extract the biogas to create renewable natural gas, you are now basically creating energy, but it's a wastewater plant. So is it a water deal? Is it an energy deal? We don't care. It doesn't matter. 16:39 But it's important, we think, very important to understand that energy water nexus. Because we actually use a tremendous amount of energy, fossil energy, CO2 emitting energy, to deal with water in all its forms. 16:56 Back to my sludge example. Drying that sludge using natural gas heat would be sort of the nineteen fifties more or less obvious answer. That is no longer an acceptable answer. So we have to think differently about that. 17:10 Here's another example. You'll hear a lot of people talk about, quote, "green hydrogen." What is that? 17:16 That is electrons of solar and wind, probably in the desert, which is where you get a lot of solar and wind, an electrolyzer into which you put water to split apart the H2 and the O. But wait, you're in the desert. 17:31 Where do you get all this clean water? Once again, water deal, energy deal, at CAI we say doesn't matter as long as you look at the investment thesis holistically and understand you need expertise in both. 17:47 So the energy water nexus is something you don't hear talked about a lot, we feel is a very, very important part of addressing the climate crisis. Yes. 17:57 When you speak to investment analysts, they like to talk about investments in silos, right? 18:02 And I think we're learning in the climate space that actually there are these interactions between mitigation and adaptation between the energy and sanitation and all these different sectors, uh, that are kind of shaking up how people think about investments in a climate adjusted world. 18:19 Okay.Moving on, I'd like you to speak to some of your recent investments, because I first became aware of CA-CAI in relation to its investment in Upwell, a water resource and infrastructure company. 18:31 You were just talking about wastewater treatment. 18:33 So I want to ask a little bit more about why water is a key theme under this climate adaptive infrastructure umbrella, and if there's any other investments that really speak to this theme of adaptation and mitigation, that would be great too. 18:46 Yeah. 18:46 Well, one of the things that we tend to forget when we get all excited about the energy transition and all the things that we're now electrifying and so forth, is no matter how much renewable energy we generate, you can't drink green electrons. 19:00 So we would suggest that at the end of the day, we may find that while all of this energy transition work is of course critical, that there is more work to be done in the energy water nexus, and that's where we spend a great deal of time. 19:16 Uh, two of our partners were senior executives at Suez, one of the world's largest water and waste companies here in North America. So we have a lot of DNA in the sector. 19:27 One of the things we see as an emerging trend is this idea of water as a service. And this is a huge opportunity for us, and I think others are also aware of it. 19:37 And, and what it means simply is this: there are a number of, of large firms who use water, and it is a critical part of what they do, but it is not the core of what they do. Think about a semiconductor fab, right? 19:51 The core of what they do is etch very small lines on pieces of silicon, over simplification, but the water is of course, critical to the operation from washing to cleaning, et cetera, et cetera, and then disposing of water or reusing water that's full of a large number of potentially quite toxic metals and, and materials. 20:10 But operating that water treatment facility is not core to the semiconductor company. 20:17 So what we do is we work with these industrial customers to take over the ownership or to build if n-if necessary, from scratch, the water infrastructure, have it operated by a third party company like Veolia, for example, the world's largest waste and water management company, and then provide the water to the host company as a service. 20:43 This effectively shifts the burden from the, let's use the semiconductor example. 20:49 Again, the semiconductor company to own and operate their own wastewater or zero liquid discharge facility shifts that to us and our partner, for example, at Veolia, and then changes the cost of that from a CapEx OpEx for the host to simply an OpEx. 21:08 In other words, all they do is write us a contract to take that clean water that we provide to them on a daily basis and pay us just like paying off of an electric meter. 21:20 So water as a service, I think is something you're gonna see, uh, a lot more attention, especially as water demands increase. Uh, yes. 21:30 I can see that really picking up steam, especially when you consider the massive growth in data centers we're seeing as a result of tech companies investing in AI, right? 21:39 And I'm noticing a lot of startups are focused on cooling solutions for data centers and for, yes, these factories that are creating semiconductors and then chips and so on. 21:48 So I can really see that, uh, picking up steam and also, of course, the water needs of other sectors aren't gonna diminish for sure. So that does make sense. 21:56 I'm wondering to what extent could that business also be subject to market risk, I suppose, as water needs kind of fluctuate throughout the States and throughout the world as a result of these different pressures. 22:08 Yeah, look, I mean, 22:10 w-when you consider the screening program and one or both of the non-physical risk items we spoke about, regulatory and political risk, that is a clear recognition of the truth of the point that you've just made. 22:27 There are always fluctuations, and we always have to be thinking ahead as to who will buy that facility from us in five years, or seven years or, or what have you. 22:39 We operate closed-end investment funds, so it is not our mission to own these things forever and ever. So what might the regulatory regime look like? What is the political landscape? However, two things are inescapable. 22:53 If you are providing to society the cleanest, least expensive form of any societal need, here I'm thinking about electrons. 23:04 Solar power today in the right geographies is the single cheapest way to produce electricity, and one of the cleanest at net. So if you do that, you can sidestep the need for subsidies. 23:19 You can ensure that someone will always buy that product. 23:24 And, and I think this is the key when we think about infrastructure coming back to the beginning of our conversation, why is infrastructure as an asset class so desirable? 23:36 Because, as you said, the assets are permanent, number one, but also the contracts that underlie them coming back to water as a service. 23:44 Those hosts sign fifteen or twenty-year take or pay contracts that say, "Hey, as long as you give me the water, I will pay you for it. 23:53 Whether I make a lot of chips or a few chips, we'll pay for the water that you produce." So we are not subject to the market risks and vagaries about how many semiconductors they sell. 24:04 We are a contracted provider of a service with a floor underneath what those economics look like. That's a very important part of the structure of those investments. Yes. 24:14 And underscores the importance of the, the triple threat analysis, I suppose, because climate risks, and climate policy, and climate technology are gonna create volatility for some sectors and change business models, and having the ability to kinda look a few steps ahead as to how these could impact an investment that you make today, I think is gonna become, uh, increasingly important.Now, on the investor side, I feel like there has been some momentum toward climate resilient infrastructure, climate adaptive infrastructure in recent months. 24:46 I note the Insurance Development Forum, uh, recently came up with this climate resilient blueprint for investing in infrastructure in the developing world. 24:55 And so that seems to be a few large institutional investors, mainly in Europe, who are getting into this space. 25:00 Um, I'm wondering, though, from your end, what other investors are you seeing getting involved in climate resilient infrastructure? And do you think... 25:08 Are you seeing, like, a momentum picking up, or do you think you're, you're one of a, of a small breed at the moment? Yeah. I want to do some frame condition setting before we dive into, uh, some observations on that. 25:20 So Climate Adaptive Infrastructure invests in North America, so we are a North American-focused entity. 25:27 There is clearly a gigantic unmet demand in other parts of the world that are less developed than the EU and the US and parts of Asia, for sure. We are not involved in that sort of investing yet. 25:41 Being a citizen of planet Earth, I mean, I'm acutely aware of how countries in dire need of additional infrastructure are, are, are struggling to finance that, certainly in a climate adaptive framework, right? 25:54 So I'm not gonna talk about, about that. However, in the more developed parts of the world, we actually see a significant, uh, amount of new capital over the last couple of three years that's been formed. 26:11 Uh, I would like to egotistically say following in our footsteps, but that, that wouldn't be true. But a lot of new capital has been formed around this thing which we call the energy transition, around decarbonization. 26:23 So I think it has really affected the entire capital value chain from my old world of sort of early stage, good idea investing venture capital to the private equity space, through to the infrastructure space. 26:39 We tallied on the back of an envelope something like three hundred billion dollars of capital raised and allocated to the real assets portion of that value chain. 26:49 These are some very, very large funds at places like Brookfield, uh, Stonepeak, TPG, and others. We're talking in excess of tens of billions of dollars. 26:59 Now, this is a considerable amount of money looking for good investments. We are different. We are a mid-market manager, so our funds are sub two billion dollars. 27:11 We actually see this as a really interesting new sort of exit opportunity path for the investments that we've made. 27:18 But we, we actually see quite a bit of capital available in the space and, and I think that's a trend that will continue. Look, I- I'll pivot slightly and, and offer you another observation here. 27:28 As you may or may not have noticed, we are in an election, uh, right now, but, but what we've seen over the decades that we've been doing this is elections are important. 27:39 This one matters a lot for a whole bunch of reasons, uh, but certainly in the issue we're talking about today on the climate front. 27:46 But what we see is that the political risks that we consider and study matter on a deal-by-deal basis, matter geographically in many cases, depending where you site a real asset, but the trend line here has been directionally up and to the right for many, many years. 28:05 Yes, it has wavered. No, it has not gone fast enough, and we certainly would much prefer a tailwind to a headwind. 28:13 But this is not an investment sector that is, uh, closely tied to the whims of, of specific politicians any more than the growth in data and the demand for more energy and water around the data center world, as you pointed out before, is tied to political whims where people do and don't want to site data centers. 28:36 'Cause fundamentally, at the end of the day, people aren't gonna put down their phones. That demand will continue to increase. 28:42 The people who use that service increasingly want renewable power to support the lifestyle they've adopted with that phone in hand. 28:50 So these are trends that are, that are going to continue to, to grow around us as reflected also by the ever-worsening climate crisis, and those two things go hand in hand. Yes. 29:01 I take your meaning that political whims can't derail a transition that is underway, can't stop the fact that, as you said earlier, people want the cleanest electron, the cleanest possible molecule of whatever it is they're sourcing, right? 29:15 So I understand that, but I do wonder about regulation changes, and I do wonder about things like tariffs, for example, which could change the calculus for certain climate technologies. 29:27 I suppose when you think about infrastructure, though, maybe you're insulated from some of these, but maybe you could just dig in a little bit about what you mean about political winds not derailing your investment thesis. 29:39 Yeah. It, it, it's important to understand that when I say those things, in our day-to-day lives here at the firm, we are looking at specific investments. I'll come back to that in just a second and give you an example. 29:53 So we have to separate the macro question, would tariffs on any materials coming into the continental United States make a difference in the work we do with the renewables? 30:04 Yes, of course, and it would cause a certain level of chaos and et cetera, et cetera. But what we did, uh, on the deal-by-deal level, it can actually be both separate from and different to the macro question. 30:17 Example, so our investment in Intersect Power when the, the CEO, who I, I know for quite some time, a brilliant guy called Sheldon Kimber, and I first talked about the current set of very, very large projects that the firm built, two point two gigawatts across only six sites, some of the largest projects in California and Texas. 30:38 We decided that we would not take the risk of usingSolar modules made in China where we could not well trace the chain of custody of the silicon. This goes back to the Xinjiang forced labor issues and so on. 30:52 We said, "You know what? Let's just use domestic modules," and just sidestep the question. And we've done that. We are now one of perhaps the largest single buyer and owner of domestically produced solar modules. 31:05 That has proven really to work well for us as events have unfolded since that conversation back in twenty twenty-two. 31:12 But it is an example of how you have to think differently about a specific investment or strategy than the macro question. 31:21 So yes, there were embargoes of Chinese modules that followed, but at our investment, we were not impacted because of the correct decision we made, um, at the outset of, of that program. 31:34 So that's, I think, to bring it back to the top of our time together, why the climate screenings are so important. 31:42 They force us into these conversations from the outset of the consideration of any investment, and they help us to, to be as certain as we possibly can that we've considered these issues from their various sides and angles, and finally mitigated any risks that we may have found along the way. 32:03 Yes. 32:04 The way you put it, it sounds more like a bottom-up analysis, a deal specific analysis, which I suppose allows you to navigate some of these macro trends and find ways to avoid potential losses or potential frictions down the line from, from forces at the federal government level or geopolitical level. 32:20 So that makes sense to me. 32:22 Okay, and finally, speaking of governments and, and politics, I was wondering what things do you think the public sector could do to spur more investment in climate resilient infrastructure, in, in providing data and insight that could be useful for siting infrastructure to account for changing weather conditions, changing environmental conditions? 32:44 I'm just interested to know from your point of view, like how the public and private sector could work better together to create the growing conditions for the sorts of projects you're invested in. Yeah. 32:53 So look, it, it's a great question, and one we've asked ourselves at every political cycle. Anyone who's been in this business for any length of time has done the same. 33:01 The answer is always, first and foremost, certainty. So the misconception that the clean energy industry, clean water industry depends on government subsidies, that is not any longer entirely the case. 33:17 Was twenty years ago when solar was six dollars a watt, now it's below thirty cents a watt. Things have changed dramatically. 33:24 However, in this country and in every other developed country, we have historically subsidized things we want more of. That is the whole raison d'être of subsidies. We'd like more of this, let's support it. 33:38 Or we want less of that, let's support the other alternative. So what we would say is that 33:46 when we have certainty that a certain set of policies, that a certain approach to our industry can be certain, at least for some foreseeable period of time, that allows capital to move. 33:59 When politicians say, "We won't permit any offshore wind," using a current example of what they're kicking around, so to speak, then if you're in the offshore wind business, that would really give you some pause, right? 34:11 Will my permits be denied? Will they be delayed? What will I face? 34:14 So this idea of policy certainty and subsidy certainty, and the subsidy levels, thank God, no longer have to be at a point where people would reject the idea that one industry is being favored over another. 34:29 But simply putting renewables on the same level of playing field as the subsidies received by the oil and gas industry, more than sufficient. 34:37 So th-this first point overall is consistency and visibility into future policy is always the key. 34:45 So beyond that, look, once you have the government sector, the, the, the state and federal government speaking in a unified voice around the climate crisis, what tends then to happen and what is critically important is that individuals then start to move in the way they think about it as well. 35:04 In the Bay Area, for example, where I live, the adoption of electric cars has really been phenomenal. I think, I don't have a statistic, but well ahead of the national average for sure. 35:14 And you see entire cultural shifts around how people have supported the deployment of electric car charging and made the electric infrastructure simply more of the, the day-to-day environment. 35:26 So that was an example of a partnership, if you will, between state and local governments, as well as what people then say, "I'd like to lean into that as well." So it's not a government will save us question. 35:38 I think this is more about a unified approach, uh, a long-term plan and consistency in implementing that, and that's what gives individuals who are the key to this at the end of the day, we think, that's what gives individuals the certainty, uh, to then act as well. 35:55 I like that. Certainty of policy, certainty of subsidy, a stable environment in which individuals and businesses can kind of pursue the products and services that they want. 36:04 Okay, Bill, I appreciate we're coming up to the end of our time. Thank you so much for speaking with us today. 36:09 You provided a refreshing perspective on how to go about investing with climate change in mind, and I look forward to seeing what climate adaptive infrastructure gets up to in the future, and maybe we'll have you on the pod again sometime soon. 36:21 I hope we do it again soon. I appreciate your insightful questions. Thanks, Louis. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 36:32 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]