Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. Today marks the 30th episode of Climate Proofers and the last episode of this year. 0:23 The pod will be going on hiatus for two weeks, but will come roaring back on January the 7th for a brand new season featuring more special guests on the bleeding edge of adaptation and resilience. 0:33 For the final episode of this season, I'm pleased to share my recent interview with Emily Mascarotti, the co-founder of Tailwind Climate and a longtime innovator in the climate space. 0:43 Last week, Tailwind published an adaptation and resilience innovation playbook, a comprehensive overview of the adaptation tech and financing landscape. 0:51 Its purpose is to help investors and entrepreneurs navigate the market for adaptation and resilient solutions, and hopefully increase the amount of capital flowing towards them. 1:00 Emily joins today to take us through the new report and to share her impressions of the current state of play of adaptation tech and financing. 1:07 It's a conversation rich in data and insight, a proper feast of content for you to chew over through these holiday weeks. 1:13 Before we get to the conversation, though, a reminder that Climate Proof and the Climate Proofers podcast are fully subscriber supported productions. 1:20 Listeners like you can help support my coverage by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. 1:27 And if you're feeling really generous, consider choosing a super proofer membership, which gives you additional goodies like free gift subscriptions and access to monthly roundtables. 1:36 Okay, in a minute my chat with Emily, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:42 In finance, a new report from the World Economic Forum estimates that extreme heat will inflict annual losses of $404 to $448 billion on publicly traded companies by 2035. 1:54 The forum counted up the expected yearly dollar impact on listed corporations from seven climate hazards, coastal flooding, pluvial flooding, also known as river flooding, tropical cyclone, drought, water stress, wildfire, and extreme heat. 2:08 Altogether, these hazards are projected to cause $560 to $610 billion in damages per year by 2035 to companies' fixed assets. This means their plants, factories, stores, and other physical properties. 2:22 Out of this total, extreme heat could be responsible for up to 73% of these losses. 2:27 In policy, the UN Convention to Combat Desertification, known as COP6, ended last week without agreement on a new global framework for responding to drought. 2:36 The summit, held in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, saw representatives from almost 200 countries gather to discuss ways to bolster drought resilience and slow desertification worldwide. 2:46 Today, around 40% of the world's land is degraded, according to UN figures. 2:51 However, the gathered delegates did not finalize a legally binding agreement on a new global drought framework, which could force states to take action on water scarcity, a key climate adaptation issue. 3:01 This effort will next be taken up at COP17 in Mongolia two years from now. 3:06 And in tech, data analysis by consultancy PwC finds that climate tech financing dropped to $56 billion over the four quarters to end September 2024, down 29% on the period Q4 2022 to Q3 2023. 3:21 However, adaptation tech was a rare bright spot. According to PwC, over the first nine months of 2024, around 28% of climate tech deals covered adaptation and resilience plays, a higher proportion than is often reported. 3:34 10% were pure play adaptation deals and 18% dual benefit transactions covering adaptation and mitigation together. Still, adaptation deals accounted for just 12% of climate tech investment value. Right. 3:47 That's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Emily. [upbeat music] Hi, Emily. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. Thanks for having me. 3:59 I am calling from Berkeley, California, and I am co-founder and managing partner of Tailwind. Tell us a little bit more about your journey in climate, Emily. I've worked on climate all my life. 4:10 I was founder and CEO of a climate risk analytics company called 427 that I sold to Moody's in 2019 and co-founded Tailwind a couple of years ago with Katie McDonald. 4:20 So I've been working on climate risk and adaptation for over 12 years now. 4:25 And I have known you for about six years when you were back in 427, and I've kind of followed you into the a-adaptation space, to be honest, because I found it very interesting that you were getting involved in this area. 4:36 And I thought, "Okay, there's some smart people getting involved here. I should start following what's going on in this space." 4:41 So I do have you to thank in part for me having this podcast and, and doing the Climate Proof newsletter, so. Oh, thank you. So I want to set the scene for our listeners. 4:50 Can you tell us what Tailwind Climate is and why you and Katie co-founded the company? 4:54 Tailwind is an advisory and investment firm focused on accelerating the development and the deployment of climate adaptation and resilience solutions. So, so that's a mouthful. 5:05 [laughs] So let's start with the, with the end. 5:08 Climate adaptation and resilience solutions are products and services that we can use to predict, prevent, mitigate, and recover from climate impacts like floods and wildfires and, you know, extreme heat. 5:23 And so as a company, we are focused on making sure that there are innovative climate adaptation and resilience solutions on the market that allow us to adapt to the impacts of climate change faster, cheaper, better. 5:39 And how we do that, we provide research and consulting services to corporate, uh, clients and investors. 5:48 We, uh, conduct research, typically funded by philanthropy grants, and, and that's the report we're gonna talk about today. And then we invest in early stage climate adaptation startups. Yes. So let's get to it. 6:01 Last week, Tailwind published the Adaptation and Resilience Innovation Playbook.And the big question is who is it a playbook for? 'Cause playbooks are usually for teams in sports or for certain entities to, to use. 6:15 And how do you hope it will be put into effect or operationalized in the coming weeks and months? 6:20 Just for context, when we started Tailwind, we looked at the market, there was a lot of innovation going on in mitigation technologies to reduce greenhouse gas emission or remove them from the atmosphere, and almost nothing that we could find on adaptation. 6:34 And so our initial analysis of the market was that we saw three gaps. There was a capital gap, not enough investment. A demand gap, not enough demand from people who should be buying adaptation and resilient solutions. 6:48 And then an ecosystem gap, like not enough support from incubators, from universities, from accelerators. And so with a playbook, we set out to do two things. 6:57 One is to research and confirm and validate and inform those three gaps and really understand what was going on. And second, to provide owners and recommendations for people as to how to fill in those gaps. 7:12 So the folks that we hope will read the reports are investors, venture investors, as well as other funders, so government and philanthropic funders, but also innovators, entrepreneurs, startup operators who may or may not be working on adaptation today, but might be really interested in seeing some of the gaps that we point to, some of the demand signals that we point to. 7:36 We also hope it will be read by folks who are working on adaptation inside government, inside corporations, and that it might inspire them to look a little more broadly at adaptation solutions beyond the things that we already do and see if there can be innovative technologies and products and services that help them do things better. 7:59 Yes, I can see how the playbook could be very useful for a myriad of actors. 8:03 There's a lot of data in there, and you really set out the kinda landscape of adaptation, resilience, demand, as you say, current investment, and then some great ideas on how to, uh, expand this market and expand the supply of, of capital for A&R solutions. 8:20 And I wanna get into to some of those findings you had. The playbook has lots of data on government, corporate, and consumer spend on adaptation and resilience needs. 8:30 Um, I wanted to know what stands out to you when it comes to who's doing the spending, where that money's going to, and where else you think governments, corporates, and consumers have to spend in order to climate-proof themselves for the future. 8:41 All right. So you're, you're speaking to my deep, uh, data nerd nature here, Louis. Indeed. Yeah. And I'm excited to share the numbers with you [laughs]. Go for it. All right. 8:49 So headline numbers, we found $729 billion of public money being spent on programs and activities and investments from governments, and that is pri- a lot of money in developed, industrialized countries, so that's the US and Europe and Japan and, uh, other industrialized countries. 9:14 And then about half of that comes from or goes into emerging markets and developing countries. 9:22 Um, second headline is we estimate the market, uh, for consumer adaptation and resilience products at $647 billion globally. 9:34 That is way, way larger than we anticipated, and at the same time, it makes a lot of sense if you think about the fact that people's houses are getting trashed [laughs] by floods, by storms, it's, it's not funny, and that smallholder farmers in developing countries are losing their crops. 9:54 And people need a home to live, and they need to make money and have crops to eat and to, and to feed their, their own families. And so nobody's waiting for governments to set standards or spend that money. 10:06 Individuals, consumers are spending the money directly themselves to protect their assets, and so that's, that's a really key finding for us. 10:15 And then the third headline, corporate spend is a very hard to estimate because corporations do not disclose this data, but for what we found, it's way, way lower than we would expect and what it should be. 10:29 So we found $58 billion of corporate spend. It is a gross underestimate of how much money is really going on. That's a small sample. We looked at about... We looked at 75 companies. 10:43 We looked at a few key mark, and out of 75 companies, 38 disclosed some kind of number, and so that's how we got to this $58 billion overall. So that's extrapolated from across all corporates- No... 10:57 or just for that subset? That's just for that subset and then added some numbers from, uh, other third party trusted sources, like the Climate Policy Initiative looking at private sector spend in developing markets. 11:09 Um, it's extremely low, and what we find is that utilities do spend money on grid resilience, and so that's usually to the tune of billions of dollars that's driving most of that number. 11:22 Uh, railroads are spending a lot of money on resilience right now. Um, and then other companies are, are spending smaller, uh, tickets. It's usually less than $100 million per company. 11:35 And again, that's on a small sample. So 75 companies, half of them disclose numbers, so that's 38 companies. 11:40 So on average, we found corporations, uh, spend $200 million annually on adaptation and resilience for the ones who do spend money and talk about it [laughs]. Um, there are 10,000 large publicly listed companies. 11:56 There are hundreds of thousands, millions of small businesses around the world. We don't have numbers for these. We know the risks are tremendous. 12:06 There is, uh, a large, large set of sources, uh, about climate risk for corporations and how much it's gonna cost and how much it's already costing corporations, and that is not matched by a commensurate level of investment, uh, from the corporate sector.So one of the challenges on the corporate side then, it sounds like transparency, right? 12:27 Understanding if they are putting dollars in and where those dollars are going. 12:31 Uh, do you think there may be an increase in this spending, or at least an increase in your discovery of this spending as corporates are affected more by climate risks and decide to tell investors, "Okay. 12:43 Yes, we know hurricanes are more a risk to us, or water scarcity is a risk to us, so we're investing more." So do you see this as actually a trend that we might reveal more corporate spending going forward? 12:53 Because that's what the current policy initiative has found while it's been doing a bit more careful investigation on what's going on in the corporate sector. 12:59 So you, you and I both love corporate disclosures, but it is not the answer to everything. 13:04 So yes and yes, better disclosures of the types that would be mandated by the SEC if they ever come to light, of the CSRD in Europe, the California, um, climate disclosures regulation, those will help bring a lot of data to light in terms of things that are already happening. 13:23 However, we also see there was a very interesting survey released by the European Investment Bank a couple of months ago that surveyed both European and American companies, and they found that 60% of companies have already experienced climate impact, and that 35% say they've already spent money on reducing the risk. 13:46 But 20% of them actually have a plan for how they're gonna deal with those risks, and wait, wait for it, 10% have done a quantitative physical risk assessment. So you see how the market's working on its head, right? 13:59 Like, people are responsive, are responding tactically and reactively to impact, but they're not even yet really doing the risk assessments and the planning and the long-term investments that should lead to being much better prepared for those impacts. 14:17 That's why I'm saying, on the one hand, of course, we're gonna see more investments come to light with disclosures because, again, 35% of companies are doing something. 14:26 We don't have that data, but also it's 35% doing probably a very partial type of response to the actual risks, and that also means that there's a remaining 65% of the market that hasn't done anything yet. 14:41 Yes, those shrinking numbers as you go up the ladder of kind of engagement of adaptation are, are quite stark. 14:47 I do wonder if we will see quite a quick acceleration, though, if more large corporates get, uh, negatively affected by climate shocks that we are be-becoming all too familiar with. Yeah. 14:57 Well, I'll share one more stat with you on that front- Sure. Sure... is Verdantix estimates the climate risk analytics market was $468 million, so that's million with an M, in 2022 and will grow to $2 billion in 2030. 15:13 That is really the tip of the iceberg. 15:16 When you talk to people who do the adaptation and resilience work in the trenches, they estimate that the risk analytics spend is 1% of the final bill in terms of spending to actually make assets resilient. 15:31 So the stuff where we're seeing a lot of activity right now [laughs] is 10% of the co- of the companies, and it's 1% of what they will spend eventually. So that gives you a sense of how big the market really will be. 15:43 Like, it's really worth shaving ice on top of the iceberg right now. 15:47 Yes, it's nothing but potential, but it seems like venture capital companies, early stage investors aren't really taking hold of that potential and really, really seeing where it can take them because you have some great information in the playbook as well on the VC space, right? 16:04 And you s- found that pure-play adaptation resilience companies account for just 3% of climate tech funding, so it's a drop in the ocean. 16:14 And I'm wondering, why is this so low, and how can the gap with mitigation startups be closed because they seem to be taking on the lion's share of the funding right now? 16:23 Yes, all very good question, and I will say that was also one of the surprises for us when we crunched and got to those final numbers is that 3%, we knew it was small, but that's really, really small. 16:34 And, uh, let me provide a little more context here. First, just how we got those numbers. 16:38 We did work in partnership with Vibrant Data Labs, who is behind the Climate Finance Tracker, and we took crunch-based data, filtered, mapped using AI model to identify which companies were either pure-play adaptation or dual benefits in that they have products and services that both reduce greenhouse gas emissions and have adaptation and resilience benefits. 17:06 And so the pure-play adaptation is where the biggest gap is. 17:10 That's 3% of total funding, and if you look at the number of startups that are out there tries to raise money, there's 12% of the startups that are in adaptation and 3% of the money, right? That's a big gap. 17:24 And then you have a second category that's much bigger, and those are the, the startups that have those dual benefit products and services. And so they represent 30% of the startup in count and 18% of the funding. 17:42 So about a third of the startups that are currently funded as climate tech mitigation also have adaptation features. That's important. 17:51 If you add the total of startups on the market, so that is 42% of climate tech startups are actually doing adaptation one way or another, but they're getting 21% of the money. And so why that is? 18:05 [laughs] To your question, sorry. [laughs] Yeah. Yeah. Why, why is this happening? Especially considering, you know, I, I know there's been a mania for, like, carbon removal tech. 18:14 It was a very attractive investment a year or so ago, and there's a lot of interest in, in platforms for trading carbon credits, et cetera. But-ANR doesn't seem to have caught the imagination the same way, right? 18:25 [laughs] That's a good way to put it. Yeah, so there's a lot of reasons, and they're all fixable, I think. So on the private sector side, I will say venture investors, a lot of them are resilience curious. 18:38 And by that, I mean they understand the potential of adaptation and resilience. They understand the overlap with maybe some of their existing portfolio companies. 18:47 They maybe would like to formally expand their investment thesis to include adaptation and resilience, but they're not quite sure how to do it. What's in scope? How do you define? How do you know what's good? 18:59 How big is the market? Is this corporate market really gonna materialize? So that's-- those are the people that we're, we're writing for and we're speaking to, right? It's like, here's a taxonomy, here's a playbook. 19:10 Go and spe- [laughs] go and invest. Um, another one is that, uh, people still believe it's only a government market. It's only B2G. 19:20 And while B2G is of course very important, we just talked about how much government money [laughs] being spent on adaptation, it's not the only one, and you, you don't need to sell it all directly to government. 19:31 There's other ways to get to market. But I think we just showed very compelling [laughs] fashion. I hope that it's a big consumer market, and it's gonna be a really big corporate market. 19:41 The other reason why it's not as active as the, the climate tech mitigation space is that the government isn't pouring billions of dollars into it, so that actually makes a big difference. 19:51 If you think about the massive take to market investments and R&D investments from the federal governments, from states into mitigation tech, that's a really big gap. Yes. 20:02 I think it's one of the dirty little secrets of a lot of the EV and renewable energy success stories, right, is that they did get a lot of initial funding from, from government or the concessionary financing from government agencies, and we need the same sort of energy and, and resources to come into adaptation resilience as well. 20:21 That's exactly right, yeah. And what's interesting is that we're starting to see some of those programs expand their purview. 20:27 So California, for example, and Massachusetts in their latest rounds of funding for startups and climate tech startups are now explicitly including adaptation and resilience, which wasn't the case just even a year or two ago. 20:39 This is a thing that I've explored in other contexts as well, the idea that if there's a federal retrenchment of spending under the incoming administration, states might level up to kind of help fill the gap. 20:49 And of course, states that are threatened by climate risks, a lot of them on the, on the eastern or western seaboard or indeed, uh, in the center of the coun-country where wildfire risks and drought are a big problem, maybe they can help provide some of the seed financing to, to kickstart some of these ANR companies as well. 21:05 Very much so, and, and that brings me back a little bit to government spend. 21:09 For the United States, we looked at both federal and a few select local government, and eighty-five percent of the money we found was federal government, and, and some of that might be revisited under the new administration. 21:24 And some of that is not gonna go away because it's money going to the agricultural sector and to industry, and nobody wants their power to go out. Resilience is, is pretty cross-sector. 21:34 At the local level, so we looked at states and cities, and again, it was not exhaustive. There's a lot more going on than what we included. We found some very large budget, right? 21:44 California just passed a ten billion dollar bond for adaptation and resilience and then climate more generally. That's not gonna all be spent in a year, but there's some real money going on there. 21:55 Um, and that is very much not just gonna continue, but probably gonna increase, uh, because it needs to. 22:02 It's not gonna completely make up for, for the lack of federal engagement on some of those topics, but it's not like all public funding is gonna go away overnight either. 22:10 Okay, now moving on from the pure quantity of finances. What I also find interesting is where the financing is going, right? 22:17 Because the way you spit it out in the playbook, it seems like funding for pure play ANR startups is going overwhelmingly to software and data companies and not enough going into the hardware, the physical stuff that we need to build protection and preparation against climate risk, so the stuff we actually need on the ground. 22:35 So I was wondering if you could explain why there is this focus on software and data and how we could potentially unskew the distribution of finance so it goes-- there's a more equitable distribution across sectors in need. 22:45 And, and that is one of my pet peeves, so thank you for bringing it up. So I think some of that is... I mean, there's a bit of a chicken and egg, right? 22:53 Some of that is the fact that this is where corporations are buying right now. [laughs] They're buying climate risk analytics, and so it's a big market. It's also a market where there has been exit, if I say so myself. 23:04 And so for investors, that's attractive because they know there are acquirers out there who might buy the corporation, [laughs] the startups that they invest in. There's even an adaptation and resilience unicorn. 23:15 It's, it's Planet Labs. They went public with two point eight billion dollar IPO, so that's attractive for an investor. 23:22 And investor, the VC model, and that's true for all climate tech, the VC model is much better suited to software because of the time duration of funds and the return expectations. 23:34 Like, it's just easier to make money on software than on hard tech. 23:39 Uh, however, there are ways to address that, and I think folks who work on climate mitigation have spent a lot of time working on how you address those valley of death by bringing more public funding for research, bringing analytic investment for early stage, making sure that you help nurture those companies in the very early stage so that they eventually become very attractive investment for venture capital when they're a little bit further along. 24:05 Yes, and innovative financing structures, right, can also help. 24:09 I think that's why there's a lot of interest in how to innovate financing.Through blended finance structures, through guarantees, et cetera, not just in the developing world, but I think also in the developed world or the richer world as well, there is a desire to try and do some more burden-sharing across different stakeholders and allow some of these capital intensive, heavy infrastructure type solutions kind of get off the ground. 24:31 That's, that's true, but what I'll add is that I think for startups it can be simple. It doesn't need to be blended or, or anything. 24:38 You can think of it as in public and maybe philanthropic foundation type investments can help support those early years where you're iterating on a product, you're not ready to sell, and it takes a year to actually go from a prototype to a product that's ready to sell. 24:54 And then once you get to that commercialization stage and really scaling, this is where the private sector can come in. 25:01 And so you don't even necessarily need to blend them in that complex, innovative financing structure. Sometimes simple is, [laughs] is better and beautiful, and the sequencing is what matters. 25:13 And so we have a section in the playbook that speaks to this, uh, capital stack and what it looks like right now and what we think it should look like. Wonderful. I wanna move on from financing. 25:23 We could talk about the financing aspects of the playbook until the cows come home, but I wanna talk about the innovation side now, and you kind of split up ANR innovations into these categories, bright spots, hidden gems, and blind spots. 25:37 So can you expand on what you mean by these, and to you personally, what category excites you most as an investor, a- and what category do you think needs the most attention right now? It might be the same. 25:46 [laughs] Uh, yes and no. Okay. So let's talk about our finding. 25:51 What we did is we looked at not just how much money is being spent, but where is it being spent, both in terms of consumers, customers buying adaptation and resilience solutions, and investors and startups developing new adaptation resilience solutions by, by sector, by hazard. 26:08 And so we found that there are parts of the market where there's a really good alignment between those two in a good way. 26:14 Like, there's a lot of money, a lot of demand, and there's a lot of investments, and so those are primarily three sectors. One is ag. Ag and food and forestry. 26:23 Generally, most of the things you do in that sectors are gonna be beneficial, both in terms of greenhouse gas emissions and in terms of resilience, and they're very active sectors with a lot of investment, and again, that's where a lot of the public money is going. 26:39 Second is water. Everybody needs water. Everybody loves water. 26:42 And again, with the water energy nexus, you find that a lot of water investments are also really good from mitigation standpoint, but of course we are gonna run out of water in a lot of places before climate change, so there's a lot of, um, synergies here. 26:57 And again, it's a big priority in terms of the public spend. It's also one of the most active sector in terms of investments. 27:05 And then the third one is everything having to do with electricity infrastructure and grid resilience. 27:11 And again, it's one of those dual benefit investments where there's a lot of public money, a lot of private investments. 27:18 The second category, which we call hidden gems, is where we're seeing growing demand from customers in all segment, government, consumers, and corporates, but not as much [laughs] innovation and certainly not as much investments. 27:36 And so to your question, this is the category that excites most because this kind of gap to me screams opportunity to invest in some really good businesses and to fill a big gap in terms of societal and economic needs. 27:51 And so floods, flood tech, which isn't even a category right now, that should be huge because that's what everybody worries about. We've all read the news. Everybody's read the news, right? 28:01 I mean, floods are devastating everywhere around the world. Governments are really starting to spend some real money. 28:07 That's what a lot of things that consumer products are focused on right now, that we're seeing increase in, in sales of consumer products around flood mitigation, and that's one of the biggest concerns for corporates as well. 28:19 And there are very few startups, and we need some hard tech solutions for floods. 28:24 Just on that, on hidden gems, 'cause I was gonna say, yes, there is a lot of interest in terms of kind of the data and monitoring side for flood risk, right? 28:31 You mentioned in the playbook, you talk about flood base, future proof. Go ahead. 28:35 So there does seem to be a lot of innovation in flood risk analytics, but you're saying, like, the hard tech for flood mitigation, flood risk management is not there. Yeah. 28:43 I think there is, there is innovation on the flood risk analytics. I think there's more, and if you ask, uh, those folks that we just mentioned privately or, or publicly how much... 28:53 how fun is it to fundraise, you might find that that doesn't mean the funding comes easily, right? So there are startups, but they're not getting funded. 29:00 And then what we're not seeing as much of, though we are seeing a little bit, is hard tech solutions that will help the physical environment deal with the excess water better. 29:12 And so here I'm thinking of startups like NatureX that have novel material for sea level rise and coastal flooding, for example. There should be a lot more, and that's near impossible to get funded in that category. 29:28 I didn't realize that, but I suppose I'm, I'm on the outside looking in, right? 29:31 It seems like some of these flood risk companies are doing, doing very well, but [laughs] maybe it's the, uh, fake it till you make it sort of mentality. You know, they are doing very well, but it's really, really hard. 29:40 That's what I want to mention. [laughs] Okay. Third category, really important, is what we call the blind spots, and this is where we see very large climate impact. 29:50 We see surveys where people express a lot of concerns over those issues, and we are not seeing either money being spent to address the issue, nor are we seeing a lot of startups and, and certainly not a lot of funding. 30:03 So in that category, primarily there's everything having to do with climate and health and heat and health specifically. And then second category is, uh, everything having to do with social systems. 30:16 And in social systems we put things like, uh, early warning systems, disaster risk and recovery, um, as well as ecosystem, nature-based solutions where there's a lot we can do there. But those are... 30:29 can be harder to fund on a purely private sector model, and they're also-Just not where people's mind goes first. 30:37 But going back to the, the first piece of blind spots, the nexus between climate and health, the fact that we're not yet seeing the health tech ecosystem really engage on this topic and health tech investors yet really speak to climate, to me, that has huge potential, and that's one of the places where we very much need more attention, more public money, more catalytic investments, because it's gonna take, uh, a little extra effort to spur innovation and help those early-stage startups make it until they can become more commercially viable. 31:12 Yes, I like that categorization. It also feels to me like blind spots is almost like just beyond the horizon, right? 31:18 You say what makes a blind spot is, uh, somewhere where there's demand that's high but latent because we know it's coming, but it might not be manifesting now, and unfortunately, our short-term focus means that maybe we're not putting the, uh, investment research that's needed right now. 31:34 So I... yeah, that's the area I'm most interested in as a observer, I suppose, as a writer. 31:39 I think there's some really interesting solutions in this space that needs to be built up because you can see how these issues are starting to pick up in terms of degrees of, of damage and hazard, and also in terms of attention from the general public and from governments, but not quite there yet. 31:55 Y-yes, and, uh, let me nuance that a little bit because sometimes I think it's a little bit of theater of imagination from the customers, and I don't think that market is necessarily very far away because it's such an acute pain point for cities, for corporations who are losing people. 32:11 I mean, it's been covered extensively, but it's, it's brutal. People die on the job. People die in the street. And so- Right... 32:18 what I'm noticing is that when I talk to folks about some of the startups that are out there and the cool technologies that are, that they're developing, their eyes just really brighten, and that as soon as those technologies 32:34 become ready to be commercially deployed, there will be a lot of interest. It's just that the buyers don't know yet that those technologies could be created, and then let me give you a couple of examples here. 32:45 Um, one is a startup called Cryogenics that has developed a medical device to treat heat stroke, so they can cool core body temperature very rapidly without water, without power. It can be in the field. 32:57 It can be in the back of your ambulance. You strap it on the person. You save their lives without having to bring them back to the hospital for an ice bath. That product just does not exist on the market right now. 33:09 Another product is staying with heat is a, a startup called Thermoshade, and they have inductive cooling where they can cool people outdoors, so it's like you have AC outdoors, but you don't because it's not cooling down the air, it's cooling down you, your body personally. 33:26 So those are very novel technologies. 33:28 They're products that just don't exist anywhere, and I think when they become available commercially, with their going through the last stage of whatever regulatory approval and, and testing, that people will be very eager to buy them and test them and deploy them because they're gonna save lives right away. 33:46 So I don't think it's five years out. I think it's-- I think we're gonna see a lot of movement in the next couple of years. 33:53 There is in the US I suppose more of an inclination to invest in, to buy solutions that can help you personally or to your family personally. So I do wonder if there will be greater take-up for these. 34:02 I think social acceptability or social comfort with some of these measures if they're being used like by day-to-day folks, obviously for like construction crews and outdoor workers, these like cooling solutions you mentioned are a no-brainer. 34:17 But I do wonder whether in order to get a large take-up there needs to be taken up by people who are living in environments which are pretty hot, but... 34:25 or, or that have extreme temperature fluctuations, but they themselves are not working in outdoor activities. 34:31 I'm kind of interested to see if there'll be a mass market, I suppose, in some of these solutions going down the line. Yeah. I think, I think there will. Uh, I'm thinking... 34:40 I, I don't think necessarily for what I just described, those are more at scale, sort of industrial, corporate or societal solutions. Like you don't have a defibrillator in your apartment, [laughs] right? 34:50 That's not how it works. 34:51 But in terms of consumer product, uh, of course, there are a bunch of startups developing cooling wearables, so garments or patches or otherwise that you can wear and that we can keep you cool significantly more, uh, effectively than, than regular, uh, clothing. 35:09 Um, and, and those are typically also gonna sell into the corporate and the government market if you think of firefighter uniforms and, uh, construction tech workers', uh, outfits. 35:20 But I think there will be a mass market because it's getting really hot. We all experience it, and we're all ready to do anything to get out of that heat sometimes [laughs]. 35:28 So I, I think there will absolutely be consumer product, and those are not even captured in our estimates of the consumer market, our estimates of the consumer markets, which, um, we're, uh, very much informed by data from the Climate Policy Initiative. 35:41 I wanna give them credit here. It doesn't look at other consumer products like wearables and garments. Yes. I'll be very interested to see how that market evolves. 35:50 So at the latter part of the playbook, you talk about enablers of change, and you also provide some recommendations for policymakers, corporations and entrepreneurs to kind of help break down some of these barriers that might be preventing broader take-up, uh, by VCs into, to ANR or broader innovation in ANR. 36:10 And I'm wondering, looking at those recommendations, if you could stack rank them, what are the most impactful actions that could be taken, especially in light of where we are in the business cycle, given the political backdrop, for example? 36:22 Like we know climate tech funding is, is still quite down from its peak a few years ago. Of course, that might ramp up again for, for ANR. 36:29 And we also know the political backdrop in the US at least may be less favorable towards climate-related investment. 36:35 So looking at your recommendations, what do you think could have the most impact given the real world we're in right now?Yeah. 36:41 Well, let's de-entangle a little bit because I wanna be clear that I think there's two very different trends at play for climate tech generally. One is the change in, uh, the administration in the US. 36:54 That means some of the funding that's currently available from the federal government for climate tech is gonna go away. Not all of it, but I think we can expect that some of it will go away. 37:03 On the other hand, climate tech investments have gone down over the past couple of years because of what happened with Silicon Valley Bank and because of the economic environment and financial markets. 37:14 There's been very, very few IPOs in the past two years, and so investors have not [chuckles] received money back, and they're not ready to reinvest. 37:22 That, I think, is gonna change for the better looking forward because generally financial markets have been doing extremely well, especially in the US, and that we're gonna start seeing more IPO again, and that's gonna free up a lot of cash to get reinvested. 37:36 Like, right now that loop is broken on the exit side. Um, now to go back to our recommendations, I would say two big things. 37:45 One is that we really need public money both on research and development and on tech to market programs and investments. So research and development, that can be public, that can also be private. 37:59 Philanthropy plays, uh, a meaningful role in funding a lot of research in, in academy, uh, institutions in the US. Uh, we need people to focus their attention on the problems at hand. 38:10 Like, no offense, but we don't need another battery technology. [laughs] We need a flood technology. We need a heat technology, and right now 38:19 I think students, uh, and researchers maybe haven't yet grasped the importance of that, and a great way to get them to pay attention is to have fellowship and specific targeted funding available, so that's one of the things that we need. 38:33 We need, as I was mentioning earlier, that early stage either non-dilutive funding, like grants, or catalytic investments like patient capital, where it's money that a lot of fun- a lot of... 38:47 Some foundations [laughs] some very smart foundations out there do catalytic funding, and so they invest in startups knowing that they're not gonna see a return on their investment probably for twelve to fifteen years, which is far longer than the standard venture investment. 39:01 And so, yes, it would be nice to have more money from the federal government on those two accounts. 39:07 Um, probably not gonna be a priority for the new administration, but states are playing a really big role in that regard, and, and again, I'll call out, uh, California, New York, uh, Massachusetts, Florida are h- as having a lot of great programs to support startups and increasingly, uh, for startups in adaptation and resilience. 39:27 The other big gap, I think you guess what I'm gonna say [laughs] is that we need corporations to actually get to work on adaptation and not just on doing a risk assessment and talking about it in their disclosures and then putting sandbags around their building. 39:41 Like, we need corporations to seriously up their game in terms of how they think about their own adaptation and resilience plans and what kind of technology they think would help and coming to the table with money to buy and to invest, and that's gonna help them, and that's gonna help society at large because once we have a real corporate markets, we're gonna be able to scale some of those technologies much more rapidly, lower those costs for other buyers. 40:13 We can see corporations invest in early warning system for their facilities, but that also serve the local communities. They can do investments in local infrastructure, again, that's help them and help local communities. 40:25 So we need corporations to really step up and come to the table and [laughs] and, you know, put up their big boy pants and, [laughs] and invest in adaptation. Yes. 40:36 My interest on the corporate front is whether if adaptation resilience is spun as an opportunity to, to grow revenue rather than just defend existing assets, that might be a way forward. 40:46 One company I keep coming back to is Generac in the US, which sells these gasoline backup generators, and they've seen their earnings go up and their forecasts go up following Hurricane Beryl in Texas, following Hurricane Helene. 40:59 Mm-hmm. So this is a company that kind of countercyclically benefits when there are climate risks, and I wonder there's probably opportunities for other companies to, to take advantage of that. 41:09 Companies that create, like, construction materials or windows, and they sell them to storm or very heat-prone regions of the States or, or you can see those companies doing well and actually seeing, sadly, rising temperatures and rising risks as, as a revenue generator for them. 41:26 But that's the corporate mentality, uh, is more opportunity-focused and revenue generating rather than revenue protecting. 41:33 Do you see that, or do you see companies, uh, investing in adaptation as a pure, like, revenue protection measure rather than a revenue growing measure? 41:41 I see both, and oddly enough, I see less, uh, of the investment on the opportunity side. 41:47 But to your point, I think it's gonna be key in actually getting corporations more interested because everybody prefers talking about saving money than not losing money. 41:56 I think there's some great examples of corporates who are investing in this space. And so if you look at, uh, uh, 3M who developed, uh, cool roof materials, it's been several years ago now. 42:07 If you look at Bayer investing in gene editing crop startups, John Deere buying an autonomous tractor, robotic tractor, that to me is adaptation and resilience because it's gonna prevent some farmers from getting exposed to extreme heat from some of the hardest tasks out there. 42:28 So I think there are-- there's very much a business case, uh, for, for corporations, and then, uh, we have some materials to that extent in the, in the playbook as well. 42:37 And, and there should be a lot more, and there's a little bit of movement on theInvestor side in terms of large public asset, asset managers who invest in public equities, there's a conversation about how there should be maybe adaptation in, you know, ETFs or specialized funds. 42:59 There's very little on the market right now. 43:02 I think you, you had guests who have spoken to that, but I do wanna mention, uh, GARI, the Global Adaptation and Resilience Investor Group, and MSCI and their great report looking at the unavoidable opportunity. 43:12 I would say from where I sit, I see the public equity market even more of a laggard than the startup market, which is to be expected, right? 43:22 You would expect VCs and startups to be on the bleeding edge [laughs] of new developments, and I think we're on the cusp of that wave that's gonna, uh, change the entire market across the board from private to public markets. 43:36 Well, I look forward to that wave of innovation and wave of financing that will hopefully be unleashed in part because of your playbook. As I said, it's chock-full of really useful data and information. 43:47 I can see it being useful to a broad range of, of stakeholders. And I suppose in closing, what are you gonna be doing over the next weeks and months to try to show off the playbook to its best extent and, and what... 43:58 yeah, what's the plan for Tailwind going into 2025? 44:01 We're gonna spend a lot of time on the road in 2025 talking to the very folks that we hope will read this report and will benefit from our- the findings and from our research, so lots of time talking to investors, lots of time talking to startups and helping them understand that, building our investment portfolio. 44:20 And then we have a busy research agenda. In the recommendation, we talk about enablers of change. 44:27 We talk about our concerns over maladaptation, the need for clear metrics, the need to better understand co-benefits between adaptation and mitigation. 44:37 And so there's a number of projects we have in the wings where we hope to dig deeper on each of those issues and, uh, continue to support the market and all the good work that we hope everybody else is gonna do as well, not just us. 44:52 So there's plenty to do. I suppose I can allow a week of sleep and rest before you get into... [laughs] Thank you, Louis. Thank you. 45:00 But I'm really looking forward to, to seeing the playbook, uh, get picked up and used by all these different actors. 45:05 I'm really looking forward to keeping tabs on what you and Katie are up to in the new year with Tailwind. 45:11 I think you've really helped to pioneer, uh, a space that I'm covering now, and I know lots of interesting people and companies are getting involved in. 45:19 Even though that's starting small, I'm, I'm seeing the growth and, and you'll def be part of that. So thank you for, for chatting to me today, Emilie. 45:25 Thank you for, uh, the playbook, and I hope to have you on the podcast again soon. Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. This was great. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. 45:38 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 45:46 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]