Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to the second episode of Climate Proofers, the show all about climate adaptation and resilience, finance, tech, and policy. 0:11 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read and subscribe to at climateproof.news. 0:17 Today's climate proofer is Eugene Montoya, founder and principal at Sandmont Natural Capital, strategic advisor to the Waterfront Alliance, and member of the Climate Bond Initiative's Resilience Taxonomy Advisory Group. 0:29 We'll get into all those roles later on and explore the burgeoning topic of coastal resiliency, what it is, why it matters, and how to finance it. 0:38 But first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 0:43 [swoosh] In finance, last week, the Federal Reserve published findings from its inaugural climate scenario analysis exercise, which asked Wall Street banks to test the climate resilience of their loan portfolios. 0:54 The six participants were Bank of America, Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, and Wells Fargo. Each had to gauge how their loan books would behave under a series of hypothetical climate shocks. 1:06 All the banks had to test themselves against three hurricane scenarios, which assumed monster storms hit the Northeast US. 1:13 Each bank also had to conjure up three idiosyncratic shocks tailor-made to cause them severe problems. 1:18 Some banks bundled wildfire, flood, storm, and hurricane risks together to come up with these idiosyncratic shocks, while others considered fewer hazards. The results left much to be desired. 1:29 The Fed didn't give much away, and there was no bank-by-bank breakdown of projected loan losses or dollar impacts. 1:35 However, the Fed did reveal that under their most severe hurricane shock, altogether banks estimated that more than 1,000 commercial real estate loans and 238,000 residential home loans would be impacted, around 20% and 50% of their total exposures in the Northeast respectively. 1:53 [swoosh] In policy, a report out of the European Environment Agency exploring urban adaptation found that only half of Europe's cities have dedicated adaptation plans in place. 2:02 Worse, only 55% of plans have metrics that can be used to properly measure adaptation progress. However, the report did find that most cities are adopting some adaptation measures. 2:13 Notably, 91% of local climate action plans on the continent include nature-based solution measures. Still, the report warned that these are not likely to be enough on their own to climate-proof urban centers. 2:26 Cities also have to take steps like reinforcing physical infrastructure to ensure a high level of adaptation. 2:32 [swoosh] And in tech, the European Commission's Destination Earth initiative is out with a beta test-ready version of its climate change adaptation digital twin, or Climate DT. 2:41 As the name suggests, a digital twin is a virtual replica of planet Earth, allowing for in-depth, high-resolution studies into how the real world's climate system is likely to react to global heating. 2:52 Climate DT is able to provide regularly updated climate impact projections that reach decades into the future and resolve at the scale of a few kilometers, the sort of resolution needed to provide governments, companies, and financial institutions with decision-useful information on where to prioritize their adaptation actions. 3:10 Climate DT-generated data and a range of Destination Earth tools are available for beta testers to play around with until May 17th. [swoosh] Right, that's this week's roundup. Now on to our interview with Eugene Montoya. 3:24 [upbeat music] We're joined today by Eugene Montoya of Sandmont Natural Capital. Eugene, where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hey, Louis. Great to be here. 3:33 I am calling in from Miami, Florida, where I work, and I, I work as a climate finance expert in the Miami area, but I serve clients both on the public and private sectors that are focused on both climate finance as well as natural capital. 3:47 So we want to talk a little bit about coastal resiliency and coastal adaptation, and I want to ask, first of all, for our audience may not know, what is coastal resilience, and why should investors, both public and private, care about it? 4:01 That's a great question. Uh, coastal resilience is something that I look at and talk about almost every day. It's really driving a lot of the work that I'm doing both in Florida and beyond. 4:10 To help define this term, I think that we need to really look at the two parts of the equation, so coast- coastal and resilience. 4:18 Coastlines are places that we have built environments, cities, which include dwellings as well as commercial and industrial properties, plants, equipment, a whole suite of different assets to think about. 4:30 And then resilience is really more of a description around the ability or the capability of those assets to withstand shocks. 4:37 Historically, that's how it's been defined, but w- when we bring them together, we start to focus on a body of work that's related to the hazards that are impacting the coastal assets in particular, and those get into both acute weather events as well as chronic longer term physical climate risks. 4:55 Great. And just to expand on that, why has coastal resilience climbed the agenda in recent years? Why is it something that you're focused on now? 5:02 So a lot of people have done studies to understand really why coastal resilience is, is becoming a larger buzzword, if you will, within the larger climate action space, and I think it has a lot to do with the intersections of cities, of water, land use, built environments, energy, transport. 5:19 All these sectors and regions of the world generally have some similarities, despite the fact that the geology, the Earth, as well as the hydrology, the water systems, differ. 5:29 Uh, they all share similar concerns about things like sea level rise, heat stress, flooding, and in, in some cases, natural resource or, um, nonrenewable resource scarcity, which gets into more discussion around, um, energy security, food security, and water security. 5:46 So as the world has really activated on understanding that most people live or work near the water's edge, that we have to really focus on that as a critical linchpin in our plans to respond to the climate hazards that are affecting every day. 6:00 How did you personally get into this space? 6:02 What was your journey for working in coastal resiliency and natural na- nature-based solutions?So I'll start with the fact that I'm born and raised in Miami, Florida, which is a very unique place, in not only in that it's a tropical savanna in terms of the climate system compared to the rest of Florida, but also a place that really has incredible intersections of business and history and culture. 6:24 And as a child growing up in South Florida, I often would notice that we had daylight flooding. 6:29 There wouldn't be any storms, there would be no clouds in the sky, yet cars were still forking and fording through and, and wading through these small puddles and rivers. 6:38 I started to really understand that there's a relationship with water that the built environment has when we've built cities made of cement and steel and glass. 6:46 But even on the beaches, understanding a bit more about that morphology, how beaches come and go, some of the nat-natural features of the land, the shorelines, the reef lines, it's really hard to escape it when you live in a place that's effectively almost below sea level. 7:01 Sixty-five percent of the lands of Florida are submerged, and Florida itself is one of the water richest parts, if not the water richest part of the Earth. 7:10 Uh, it's part of our soil, it's part of our built environment, and as the years have gone on, these hazards have gotten only more amplified and have now been, you know, noticed by the financial community, which is concerned with assets that are exposed to physical climate risks, as I've mes- as I've mentioned, but also what to do about them. 7:28 What's the solution side? How do we actually start to create short-term protection and build more aspirational long-term strategies to make assets truly fulfill their useful lives? 7:39 And so in order to do that, you have to think about engineering, finance, design, policy, communities, hyperlocalization, and it's really hard to escape it. 7:49 If you're in Miami right now, we're having a renaissance on this topic because different stakeholders are experiencing it in different ways, and I think that this is why coastal resilience has become our framework or our play field to actually think about solutions and, and R&D specific to climate response. 8:06 Yes. I think there's something about the immediacy of climate risks in areas like Miami. 8:10 I'm in New York, and we've had some pretty terrible rainstorms in recent months, and I think that immediacy does bring people to the field of adaptation, resilience, and people wanna know how they can improve the resilience of the places that they love. 8:22 And there's also, you said, a great recognition of the financial implications now, which I wanna get into in a little bit. 8:28 But first of all, can you tell us a little bit more about the Waterfront Alliance, which you're involved in? Yes. 8:33 So while I was actually working, um, in the banking sector focused on net zero, primarily on mitigation, I was contacted by this organization that was asking for advice about, um, green bonds, and specifically how to integrate what they do with, um, the financial world with sustainable debt capital. 8:51 So Waterfront Alliance is a nonprofit that was founded in the mid, uh, early two thousands. It really in response in many ways to, to, to nine eleven was really where the first idea gestated. 9:02 It was around the fact that lower Manhattan, this very strategic piece of land surrounded by water, did not have an easy way to evacuate people in an emergency. 9:11 Of course, that was a human-driven or human-induced emergency. 9:14 Fast-forward a couple of years to Superstorm Sandy and the devastation that caused really sprung to life a lot of the urban planners and architects and designers that were part of what's known as the Municipal Art Society, which is an organization in New York, and that's actually where the Waterfront Alliance was incubated. 9:31 Originally, it was called the Municipal Waterfront, uh, Alliance, and it grew into a convening, if you will, a nonprofit that focuses on giving a voice to all of the stakeholders of the waterfront. 9:43 It looks at the waterfront in two ways. 9:45 One way on the working waterfront, thinking about the actual commercial activity that occurs on waterfronts such as shipping and containers, maritime industry, port operators, passenger transport, but also living waterfront, how people build and construct, um, facilities as well as dwellings on, on the water's edge, and have that natural relationship to water. 10:07 So a lot of it really boils back to things like artificiality and nature and the connection between the two and the, the relationship. 10:15 So Waterfront Alliance o-operates various programs, and one of them, the one that I was originally brought in most to focus on, it continues to be the, the main, uh, engagement point for me, is called WEDGE. Um, it's... 10:27 it stands for Waterfront Edge Design Guidelines. 10:31 And you can think about WEDGE as a credential, or you can think of it as a rating system, you can think of it as a scorecard, you can think of it really as a verification similar to what the experience was with creating lead, uh, in the US Green Building Council. 10:46 The difference here is that WEDGE is completely focused on the relationship between the built environment and the natural environment through water. And WEDGE has evolved over the years. 10:56 It started as primarily coastal resilience and coastal adaptation, but now it's expanded into freshwater locations like lakes and rivers. 11:05 So effectively, any built environment structure that has a relationship to water can be, uh, WEDGE verified, and that involves going through a very comprehensive evaluation and verification of its resilience benefits, its ecology benefits, so not just what, you know, the-- what's happening on the land, but also what's happening inside of the water. 11:26 And lastly, what de- to what degree, and most importantly probably, the community dimension, how accessible is the waterfront to its stakeholders, which include asset owners, financial institutions, community organizations. 11:39 It's the economic livelihood of towns. It's also recreational spaces. And so we have what's known as our WEDGE portfolio. 11:47 We've verified about eleven, I believe, but somewhere between ten and fifteen sites, including a large pipeline, and that expands beyond New York, New Jersey and Connecticut. 11:57 We have a site here in Miami, Florida, which is the first in Florida, called Jose Marti Park, and then also a site in Wilmington, North Carolina. 12:05 So WEDGE has quickly expanded into a national standard of excellence in resilient design.That you can take as a project developer into a, into a green field project where you're starting from scratch thinking about an unoccupied piece of land and what you're gonna do with it and how you're gonna make it resilient, or you could also apply it to a brown field property or asset and bring in this excellence in design to, to really demonstrate that this asset will be designed against climate hazards. 12:34 And to be clear then, WEDGE is a voluntary standard. Is it enshrined in statute by any states or municipalities? Yes. 12:40 So WEDGE, WEDGE's mission, if you will, is to have project developers apply its discipline to the way that they build and operate assets that intersect water. But the... 12:51 it's not on a compliance or a regulatory sort of a trajectory. Instead, it's really more, it is coming from a voluntary place. 12:58 It's really demonstrating the, the benefits as well as understanding the costs and the trade-offs of doing this sort of work for sites that previously have not considered these factors around climate resilience, ecology, and access. 13:11 Mm. 13:11 We don't necessarily have a mission to become a compliance protocol or a regulatory function, but there are examples, for example, here in Miami, in the city of Miami, all new public works that have water, water nexus are required to have a WEDGE certified individual, so that means someone who has gone through the training program on that, on that committee or on that, uh, working group. 13:35 So there's ways that WEDGE is starting to be identified as a leading standard and integrated into the way public funds and public finance operates with resilience projects or with anything that's trying to build community-wide adaptation. 13:48 Although I should point out that WEDGE is primarily focused on the, the site itself, so an asset, and that's an important distinction because you've got single assets and then you have networks of assets that we could call a, a community-wide adaptation to protect a much larger coastal area or a much larger inland water environment. 14:09 Thanks for that. And so to me it sounds like there is an alignment of incentives here, right? 14:13 We should encourage take-up of WEDGE, because as you said, there's a focus on community, on the local ecology, and we know people flock to these beautiful cities like Miami and wanna live there because they want that sense of community and sense of oneness with nature. 14:26 So there is, it sounds like there's something to benefit the developer and the asset owner as much as there is something to benefit residents who will be protected and made more resilient from climate risks. 14:35 That's a really fan- fantastic point, um, because the benefits that WEDGE unlocks can be financial or non-financial. 14:42 They can create co- cost savings in terms of building more resilient design avoids a lot of potential loss and damage, so it enhances the insurability of an asset. 14:52 It also improves the operational efficiency of resource use, such as in materials or in, in energy or water. But it also, like you said, it, it appeals to developers in different ways. 15:03 The community integration part, understanding how a community's gonna respond to the reconstitution or refurbishment of a previous factory that was basically a derelict property and is now a thriving multi-family residential place with a public park attached to it. 15:19 That public park is providing recreational opportunities to people in, in low to moderate income communities, but it's also providing storm water protection. It's also providing shade against urban heat island. 15:31 There's so many stacked benefits that you can start to integrate and demonstrate, and that improves not just operations of this particular site, but it also improves the goodwill, the relationship between these companies, the developers, and the communities that they operate in. 15:47 Okay. Now let's turn from principles to practice and into the nitty-gritty of building and financing coastal resilience. 15:54 So I'd be interested to know what coastal defense, coastal resilience projects are in vogue right now, and how are they being financed. Is it largely public funds, municipalities? 16:03 Are you getting private investors involved at all and interested in coastal resiliency? S- what's the state of play here? Yeah, no, this is a very large topic, so I will... I'll just try to break it into some pieces. 16:13 Coastal defenses are site specific. 16:15 Again, because of the geology and the hydrology, there's different factors and nuances to doing this type of work in a place like South Florida versus in New York versus in Michigan versus in, in, in West, West Africa or the Southeast Asia. 16:30 But fundamentally, I think that there are some commonalities to sea level rise, something that's massively influencing not only investment mandates, but also the, the climate reality that's being lived through, especially in the small developing states in what are known as the small island developing state SIDS. 16:46 They have the highest sensitivity to sea level rise, and it's absolutely impacting their ability to maintain their built environments as well as their economies, which are heavily dependent upon a more balanced, healthy, um, ecology with things like sustainable a- aquaculture and seafood and tourism. 17:04 So I think that those lessons have certainly come into the frame of vision when thinking about building and financing coastal resiliency because you are fundamentally working on the relationship of the coastline or the shoreline, or in some cases the reef line, and trying to restore a baseline. 17:19 Very similar to, in many ways, the work we're doing in net zero, we're trying to compare the before and after. We're trying to say, "Here's where we are now in our carbon intensity, and here's where we wanna be." 17:31 With resilience, you're thinking, "Here's where we are now in terms of how much the na- the nature itself has degraded, and here's what we have to restore in order to restore the balance to the economy." 17:42 And so some of the defenses that are used are things that can address that. Sea level rise impacts in different ways. 17:48 It can exacerbate the, you know, coastal risks like storm surge and the ability for these storms to really wreak havoc on coastal properties. 17:56 But it can also intrude below where we don't see in things like salt water intrusion, where it starts to get into fresh water stocks. Those fresh water stocks are connected to things like agriculture. 18:07 They can destroy crops. They can damage livestock health. They can also damage our plumbing systems. 18:12 So there's different vectors of risk to think about with sea level rise, and so the response is really understandingThat we're gonna try to work on, in most cases, accepting the water in a more intelligent way. 18:24 So a lot of the brilliance I've seen in that space on sea level rise relates to sea walls, re- relies on berms, which are when we wrap... 18:33 Fundamentally, we wrap the coastline in nat- in natural islands that can attenuate, they can reduce the wave power so that the onshore attacks are not as bad, or we can think about ways that we can actually try and redirect the storm water or the s- or the sea water during events into benign locations in a way from critical services like power, which is obviously an absolute must-have for things like hospitals, and obviously for vulnerable populations in different respects. 19:00 A lot of the innovation that's happening around sea level rise is, is really thinking about storm water, because that's the most acute manifestation of sea level rise. 19:09 Generally, with flooding, like things like rain bombs, what we just saw in Dubai, that's unusual for this particular geocode of the Earth, but here in Florida, we have smaller, much smaller versions of these, and they do cause issues. 19:22 So there's a lot of interest in creating, really restoring the draining power of nature. If nature is covered in cement, it's becoming a bathtub effect, and it's why cars are floating in Downtown Miami. 19:33 It's thinking about things like that. 19:35 So we have to understand where the rain could come, and if we can think about redirecting it benignly and safely through our oolite system, which is really the aquifer, um, we can find ways to redirect those storm waters. 19:48 And by the way, as we start to, as we start to be able to absorb greater and greater floods, we can also find financial value. 19:57 Th- those things are typically done by the public sector, but if they were done by the private sector through private assets, and we called it coastal adaptation and resilience, it could actually become a payback to an investor who's interested in monetizing and, and preserving their capital with some upside potential. 20:14 But back to your question on who finances it today, primarily this is the work of the public sector, especially, and again, my expertise is more in my home state and my home city. 20:24 But primarily, this is the work of the Department of Environmental Protection, using the science and the engineering, the brilliance of organiz- e- organizations at the federal level like the EPA and NOAA, but fundamentally executing things through, um, organizations that really focus on things like the flood protection level of service and understanding the vulnerability of communities to, to coastal risk and whatever the manifestation might be. 20:49 So thinking about the solutions, a lot of it is gonna be about our ability as a people to really absorb water, redirect water, and really mitigate water's arrival in places that it can't, in, in, in sensitive areas, sensitive assets. 21:05 I think it's interesting the way you're speaking about it. It's not like we're trying to fight water or shut water out. It's more about finding ways of working around water or with water. 21:13 It's less shut it all out, shut it all off at all costs. It's much more, okay, are there ways to redirect water into less damage areas? And I think that's a more sensible approach. 21:23 Because we know water is almost insidious and relentless in how it gets everywhere. So this sounds like a more sensible approach than just trying to shut everything down and turn cities into hermetically sealed entities. 21:34 Yeah. That's a great insight. I, I, I completely agree. I think that's part of the solutions. And again, it, it requires understanding the cost and the benefits of, of taking different strategies for different assets. 21:46 It's also about understanding that we do have, um, some larger connection points, like where the Miami River meets the Biscayne Bay, which is the open Atlantic Ocean, that's a place where you can do a lot of work. 21:57 Actually, our wedge site is on the Miami River, and there's a lot of interest in trying to create natural defense systems out of parks, out of changing the pavements, out of making them quick-draining, out of figuring out the permeability so that we can accept what we know is coming and, like you said, not deal with trying to keep everything watertight. 22:16 But to some degree, if you look at a little smaller scale, now we're going down into individuals' homes, there are individuals who want to raise their homes to bring them above the floodplain or the flood stage or the water table overflows and think about how to actually harden one particular asset, not an entire community. 22:33 But what we realized is that working at the community scale is much more efficient in terms of what you're gonna spend on the investment, and it's also less challenging with the human layer, because you can't get agreement from individuals, for example, to build flood panels on just some houses but not others. 22:50 It makes more sense to create something that everyone's concerned with. 22:53 It neutralizes this topic and depoliticizes it when we think about water quality of the bay and not protecting high-value homes or low-lying floodplain homes. Mm. 23:04 And so I think the redirection towards a larger goal and considering larger implementations and using public and private and blended channels of financing is exactly what we wanna focus on. 23:17 So you mentioned that public finance seems to be the main source of cash for coastal resiliency, but I'm wondering what policy levers could be pulled or what market incentives could be introduced to help encourage more private investors into this space. 23:29 I've been reading that nature-based solutions are, are big. I've... The idea of ecosystem services and the idea that things could be monetized to provide cash flow to private investors. 23:38 But I'm interested to know, like, what you think and what the likely solution is to getting private investors involved. 23:43 So I named my company that I started Natural Capital in the title because I do believe that the recognition of natural capital is essential to the adaptation and resilience work we have yet to do, not just on carbon, but on water, on land use, and on materials. 23:58 And fundamentally, the public sector is raising capital the traditional way, through taxes, which they put into deployable funds. Those funds come in grants. 24:07 They focus on the environmentally sensitive areas, and they direct to create a restoration or a protection.That those are not investable asset classes for private capital to come into. 24:18 They benefit private capital assets, but that line is not drawn. It's not articulated. It's not really part of the incentives. 24:24 I think that policy levers that left to be utilized include really removing the obstacles to do research and development, both in the water and near the water, so that startups can come in and start to solve some of these problems related to water quality, which gets into not just flooding, but also into waste and into connection between the fresh water and the salt, the saline environments. 24:47 There, there is a... There's, of course, a, a very shared interest that everyone has on the asset performance. 24:54 If I'm an asset owner, obviously I want my buildings to be non-disrupted, and I want them to maintain their value over time. 25:02 My insurance company wants the same thing, my bank wants the same thing, my investors want the same thing, my communities want the same thing. 25:09 So again, if we start to zoom out a little bit, we can realize that we have all very shared incentives to do the adaptation and resilience, but the question is really who pays for it? 25:19 If the public funds rely on tax and rely on labor costs and materials costs, and have to take on larger systems than they can operate, then it really does fall into a gap. 25:30 In that gap, the private capital has to come in, but how it actually shapes that, how it creates financial instruments that, that even recognize half of what we're talking about in the natural capital dimensions is still underway. 25:43 And I think that what I'll say about the innovative piece is that some of these new instruments really are trying to recognize the value that nature provides and, and give it a revenue, give it a cost, give it a benefit. 25:55 And if you can do that, then you're starting to get closer to restore-- to re- to repaying debt, which is the primary way that this, these kinds of projects can be funded. 26:05 Equity is not really a direct way to, to participate in this market. 26:08 It's gonna be primarily debt driven, and it's gonna be primarily driven by, by key performance indicators and key risk indicators that make sense for investors of different risk tolerances. 26:20 Patient capital is clearly an insurance, are clearly playing a role in focusing on the de-risking horizon of these investments. 26:27 But once they're de-risked, once they're operational and starting to generate revenue, such as through things like the stormwater fee innovations you're seeing in places like Louisiana or even in parts of Florida, wetland mitigation banking, you start to realize that the private sector has not paid attention to what the public sector's been doing since the creation of the EPA in the 1970s, and the subsequent creation or hyper-development of the local state level EPAs. 26:53 They have a lot of knowledge and knowhow that is not really translating over into private capital activities. 27:00 And I think that this is part of the gap that we have to close, but we have such a strong foundation to start in thinking about directing private capital into actual investable asset classes for adaptation and resilience specific to the coastlines. 27:14 Yeah. I think that's interesting. It makes it sound like there are pockets of opportunity for private capital and private investors if they can sort of navigate local ordinances or understand particular cities. 27:25 I wonder if the issue is that a lot of national and international financial entities, they like to work with commodified investments, right? 27:31 They have to do stuff on the ground, but if they do so, there has to be a massive return involved. 27:35 So it sounds like if those people who are on the ground in Miami and other cities who understand the risks, who understand how to navigate the local government, there are opportunities to create products and potentially make money here. 27:46 Is that your sense? That's just what I'm getting from hearing you. On short to medium priorities are certainly profitability and insurability. 27:54 Those two things are essential that these projects can deliver, that they can stabilize the loss of insure-insurable coverage, and that they can also fundamentally, before we layer in climate and environment and social factors, that they can stand alone, uh, because they have a, a business model that's continuous and sustainable. 28:11 So those things need to be designed and, and, and considered and, and operationalized before you can really attract, incentivize mark- private capital. But private capital is worried about the downside. 28:23 The risk is driving them closer to some of the innovations, but there's still a gap in the funding because of the operational risks required to do novel things. 28:31 Even if we have a strong foundation in how to protect the natural environment and the built environment's relationship to it, we still need, we still need de-risking capital. 28:40 And so this falls upon philanthropies, foundations, these facilities that are created at the super national level, at the United Nations levels. Those are cert... 28:49 Those are certainly ways to get the capacity building going. 28:52 But really when it gets into the, into the O&M, to the operations and maintenance part, that's gonna be the world of engineers, of builders, of real estate managers and property developers. 29:02 They're really the next step in terms of changing the way we design and build and operate, and I think that they fundamentally need to start looking at those, those unique kind of l- squeeze net locations that are creating a lot of risk concentration for them. 29:18 And so that absolutely requires a novel way of thinking. 29:22 We need to create independent, private, public sort of super pools or super funds that can really focus on what w- single institutions or even large ones are incapable of, of, of facing. It's too daunting for them. 29:34 They need help. They won't be the first movers. They'll wait for the public sector, and the public sector will continue to be dominated by the macro and other factors. 29:43 Can I ask a quick follow-up on what you think the role of technology should be here? 29:47 I write occasionally about climate adaptation technology or CAT, and there seems to be a lot of opportunities in the water space for remote sensing, monitoring of water levels, early warning systems for floods, et cetera. 29:59 And that's been seen as a way to help produce the data that might encourage more financial institutions and private investors into the space. 30:06 So if they have a better grasp of the risks, and therefore the opportunities as well, they'll be more likely to invest. Is that your sense as well? 30:12 Do you play around with climate adaptation technology in the water space at all?Yeah, it's, it's definitely part of the larger, of the larger package. 30:20 The transparency push is really helping this work to identify, like you said, those early warning indicators. 30:26 Those quali- those real-time metrics can be used in time series to create strategies, to create actual implementable short-term strategies for short-term calamities. I think that there's a lot of value in that work. 30:40 Beyond that, the innovators are really the people who are going into the oceans and actually working with the natural assets. I'm talking about mangroves, coral, salt marshes, sea grass. 30:51 Again, these are very Florida-specific, but these innovators are figuring out ways to use nature na- and natural, really natural engineering, not only for carbon sinks and to create monetization there in the legitimizing, uh, carbon markets, but also in, in a way to create, uh, insurability, draw a line between protecting and wrapping the coastlines in thriving ecosystems will allow us to deal with the uncertain risks of, of sea level rise, flooding, and heat stress. 31:18 Um, but absolutely, the technology part is, is critical, and I would say even another step further would be material science, understanding how some are really un... are focused on the biogeochemistry of all of this. 31:30 Understanding how we're gonna use new kinds of ethologically sound materials in the construction and operations of our coastal assets is absolutely critical i- in terms of really thinking about cities of the future, how they'll charge themselves, how they'll heat themselves, how they'll cool themselves, how people will transport around, whether it be using water transit or not. 31:52 Uh, this is definitely all part of this, the solutions package. So absolutely, technology is a big piece of it. Startups receiving that early stage capital and confidence and belief, it absolutely- Mm... 32:04 has a lot, a, a really big part to play in, uh, in actually responding to this in a organized and intelligent way. So that's technological innovation. Just one last question on financial innovation. 32:16 So I've heard, and I'm sure some of our audience have heard, about blue bonds as a financial instrument, and I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about them and how they can be used to finance coastal and marine resilience and a- and adaptation. 32:28 So blue bonds are a really interesting instrument class that originated really out of the work of the green bonds taxonomies that have been built. 32:35 I could refer to ICMA or, or Climate Bonds Initiative or the EU Taxonomy, which a- all three of those major standard setters have also been in strong contact with each other over the years to try and calibrate and align themselves to create better, uh, symmetry in the market. 32:50 But blue bonds have grown out of the green bond category with a real emphasis on oceanic environments specific to the ocean and specific to coastal locations in which there's commerce to be had, whether it's tourism or it's fisheries or it's other, or other key industries from native economies. 33:08 So the blue bonds primarily are, are thematic bonds. 33:12 They are use of proceeds focused, so that means that I'm raising capital to complete a said mission statement or a said purpose, as opposed to a general purpose bond, which could be like a sustainability linked bond or sustainability linked loan in the case of a loan. 33:27 So th- this is a really creative way to bring attention to the fact that the oceans are threatened, and the fact that not only are they threatened, they're considerably under more threat because of other capital commitments that we've made, things like the oil and gas exploration production, but also some more significant harm that is on the way from waste and from other commercial industrial downsides. 33:49 So I think that the blue bonds have really hyper-focused our attention to the fact that the oceans are the greatest thermal regulator of the planet. They're where the breathable oxygen comes from. 34:00 The oceans have also absorbed decades of climate change that we've caused as humans without any recognition or credit, and the oceans themselves are starting to collapse in, in many places. 34:10 If we can keep them healthy, we can buy ourselves time to focus on defossilization of our energy system and meet mitigation goals. 34:18 I actually am a big subscriber to the fact that the, that blue finance is really gonna clip on green finance. 34:24 It may have started under, but eventually green will go under blue, and the reason we can get to green through blue is because of the carbon sequestration potential of proven technologies as well as aspirational technologies, and we also have a lot of power, and I'm talking about electrons that can be created through marine renewable energy that we're not utilizing. 34:46 So this asset class, though, is primarily the world of sovereigns and s- maybe sub-sovereigns to some degree, but it's not at all happening for the corporates in the private sector. 34:57 They're not really creating blue bonds. 34:58 And if you look back at the existing blue bond examples we have, the issuances that have been created in places like Ecuador, the Galapagos, Seychelles, most of this took years and grew out of the multilateral world. 35:11 We don't have this kind of time. 35:12 We should take these brilliant examples and start to really apply them in the private sector because they have short-term earnings potential that, that, that will help repay them and make them an investable asset class to really bring people into the space. 35:26 I would also say that we need to expand the definition of blue to fresh water because the relationship between fresh water and oceans is becoming better understood. 35:34 The scientists, the engineers are starting to really bring the corporates and the financials better into that frame of vision, and that will really create an even larger effect of what blue finance can do. 35:45 So don't sleep on blue finance, people. You heard it here from Eugene. I like to ask my interviewee, interviewees at the end what they're working on over the next twelve months. 35:53 So what do you hope to achieve this year in the A&R space? So I work on, I work on all three of the main verticals under climate finance, and I'm supported in that by my interest and my focus in natural capital. 36:06 So on the mitigation side, I'm continuing to work on net zero for financial institutions to understand how they can be empowered to influence the, their products and services, and those products and services can manifest as real healthy decarbonization over time, defossilization, a balanced approach to really getting to a place where we can really move away from non-renewable resources and into renewable, cost stable, price stable resources that also have massive benefits for wealth-Creation potential for previously unfunded, unclassed individuals and, and societies. 36:39 On the adaptation resilience side, I'm working with Climate Bonds Initiative on their resilience taxonomy, as it's a phenomenal group put together of experts to really understand how to take the themes of resilience and define them, and, and put them into context around regions and sectors of the real economy, and link that back to the interest of what issuers can do and what investors can align their mandates to. 37:02 So that's a phenomenal place to, to really exert some thought leadership or some support. 37:07 But more specifically, I'm actually working on a lot of blue finance deals, helping companies raise non-equity grants, early stage startups, helping them get to breakevens, helping them understand their financial propositions. 37:19 But also contributing what I can as a non- as a non-registered broker dealer to the development of blue bonds for the private sector. 37:26 Really bringing the features of these instruments to those audiences, those corporate treasurers who really raise capital all the time, but not with a lot of purpose, at least not purpose that's known to us, and benefits that can be quantified and qualified. 37:39 This is really the area that I'm dedicating myself to, illuminating those benefits so that they can sell themselves, and that we can actually start to see some serious changes to the baselines of deteriorating conditions in natural assets. 37:54 So there's a lot in your inbox then, and we'll let you get back on with it. Thank you so much for contributing today and, and coming up to chat, and we'll speak again soon, I hope. Absolutely. It's been my pleasure. 38:03 Thanks for having me. Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 38:15 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Tune in next week for another episode. Goodbye for now.