Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. Today, we'll hear from Jay Coe, a pioneer in climate adaptation investing. 0:22 As co-founder of the private equity firm, the Lightsmith Group, Jay Coe and his team invest in tech companies that address adaptation needs, like Source Global, which creates self-contained water systems, and Aidash, which uses satellite technology and AI to improve the climate resilience of infrastructure assets. 0:40 Jay also has years of experience in the private equity sector and in public service, where he worked as chief investment strategist at what is now the US Development Finance Corporation. 0:50 He's also the founder of the Global Adaptation and Resilience Investment Working Group, also known as GARI. 0:56 We talk about how awareness and engagement in adaptation has evolved over his career, learn a little bit about Lightsmith's investment thesis, and chat about what the GARI group is all about. 1:06 Before we get started, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 1:12 Listeners like you can help support my coverage of climate adaptation and resilience by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. 1:22 For the month of August, annual subscriptions are thirty-three percent off, so sign up today. Okay, in a minute, my conversation with Jay, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:33 [whooshing sound] In finance, the think tank Tax Justice Network is urging countries to adopt a wealth tax in order to meet climate finance goals. 1:42 The group says a tax on the top zero point five percent richest households, like the tax introduced in Spain in twenty twenty-two, could raise two point one trillion dollars a year globally, more than double the amount needed to meet the so-called external climate finance requirement set out by the independent high-level expert group on climate finance. 2:01 The Tax Justice Network assumes the tax would apply to only zero point zero zero three percent of the global population, around one quarter of a million people. 2:09 [whooshing sound] In policy, last week, US Democrats approved a new party platform at their national convention. 2:16 While there's little firm policy on adaptation and resilience, there are signs that the climate proofing of America under President Joe Biden is likely to continue under Kamala Harris if she were to succeed him in the Oval Office. 2:27 The platform includes a section on building climate resilient communities, which promises continued investment in cooling centers and refuges for vulnerable populations facing extreme weather events. 2:37 There's also a specific pledge to pass a disaster resilience tax credit to help families and small businesses invest in preparing for and recovering from the impact of storms, heat, floods, and other natural disasters. 2:49 Moreover, Democrats pledge to enforce and advance labor and environmental rules that protect workers from extreme heat, and to combat heat stress in urban environments by planting millions of trees. 3:00 [whooshing sound] And in tech, six US universities are teaming up to find ways to produce cooling tech without the nasty climate pollution that comes along with it. 3:08 They're doing so with the help of a twenty-six million dollar grant from the National Science Foundation. 3:12 The so-called Environmentally Applied Refrigerant technology, or EARTH Hub, has been set up to create tech that boosts the energy efficiency of heating, ventilation, and cooling while reducing their contribution to global warming. 3:24 The hub will be based at the University of Kansas. [whooshing sound] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Jay. [upbeat music] Hi, Jay. 3:35 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? 3:37 Well, Louis, I'm calling you today from the Upper East Side of Manhattan here in New York City, and I invest in climate resilience and adaptation technologies and solutions for the Lightsmith group, which is the sponsor of the first private investment fund for adaptation and climate resilience. 3:53 Wonderful to have you. Just two New Yorkers shooting the breeze on climate adaptation today. Thanks for being on the podcast. You've been banging the climate adaptation drum in the finance space longer than most. 4:03 Everybody I spoke to when I first started Climate Proof told me to get in touch with you. 4:08 And I wanna ask, what first attracted you to this theme, and how have you seen interest in adaptation by investors evolve over your time as an evangelist for adaptation? It's a great question, Louis, 'cause it's a... 4:20 it is an area that's not as well known. Adaptation and climate resilience investing is not as well known as decarbonization or what policy people might call climate mitigation. 4:28 Um, um, and we're at the very beginnings of investment capital being deployed into it. And my journey to it has been sort of unusual as well. 4:36 So I've spent the entirety of my career, um, in and around private equity and private investing. 4:43 And so, uh, you know, the listeners on this podcast might have right now, which is what do you mean by that, and how is that actually investable? 4:51 Back in twenty fourteen, fifteen, we started looking at this question of what do you do when climate change actually happens? Uh, and it was much less obvious then what would happen. 5:00 And we started to take an approach of looking at it in the context of other transitions that we had seen in the risk and in the technology landscape. 5:10 And so that's what sort of began my journey into the adaptation and climate resilience universe, though I'd already been exposed to, obviously, the ongoing challenges of climate change, uh, in the renewable energy space. 5:22 Can I ask, how did your experience in public service shape how you approach adaptation once you entered the private sector? 5:27 I'm interested to know whether adaptation was more well understood in the public sector and less understood in the private sector when you first started. Yeah. In 5:38 both contexts, I don't think adaptation was very well understood at all. 5:41 In fact, the first adaptation gap report back in two thousand and fourteen says something like, "One of the big problems with adaptation is nobody knows what it means." 5:49 And so we spent some time working on that through different approaches like definitions and frameworks and taxonomies that we can talk about in a bit. 5:56 Um, but there was at least the beginnings of an understanding of what adaptation meant in the public sector and virtually no understanding of it all in the private sector. 6:03 My, my experience in the public sector and private sector were led us to this strategy at LightsmithUm, was an understanding of how capital can shape outcomes, right? 6:13 And so if you understand how capital flows, you can actually direct it, uh, towards sets of outcomes I think are both good for investors and good for your policy objectives, if that's what you want. 6:25 And that's what we found in the adaptation landscape. The, the background here really is, if you look at the question of what happens when climate change happens, you're really trying to do two things at the same time. 6:35 One, reduce the trajectory of the problem we've created for ourselves. That's decarbonization or mitigation. 6:42 And two, reduce the risk and impact of the problem we've created for ourselves itself, which is really creating resilience or adaptation to climate change. 6:50 So what was not clear back in twenty fourteen, fifteen were the answers to three questions. When? What's the downside? And what's the upside? 7:00 And so where I think investors have transitioned in looking at adaptation investing or have become, let's call it climate resilience curious, and hopefully eventually climate resilience committed, is to recognize that three things are now happening. 7:16 Number one, climate change is here now. The risk is not to polar bears and coral reefs in twenty one hundred. 7:22 The risk is to your human health and to your supply chain and to your buildings and to your energy and to your healthcare today. And we're seeing that impact unfortunately unfold right now. 7:33 And the second thing is investors understanding that the risk is now here today look at the risk on the downside to all of the assets that they own and the future investments they might make. 7:44 The third transition is looking at the upside. 7:47 Now, once you know that something's happening now, once you understand what the downside is, the next natural question, which I think is going to become increasingly interesting and obvious, is what's the upside? 7:58 What are the opportunities to invest created by the need for resilience to climate change? And has it become easier in recent years to explain those three messages to investors? 8:08 And what factors do you think have made the market writ large more receptive to, to those three points? I think two major things have happened. 8:17 So Lightsmith closed the first private investment fund for climate resilience and adaptation back in two thousand nineteen, and reached final close in two thousand twenty-two. 8:25 We have a hundred and eighty-five million dollars in capital. Uh, we're about to announce our sixth transaction in this fund, and we'll be fully invested by the end of the year. 8:33 Um, and are really excited to demonstrate that you can make interesting market return generating transactional investments in adaptation and climate resilience companies that are, like, all around us, even though they may not necessarily call themselves that. 8:47 The first transition that really happened here was the shift, I think, in administration here in the United States was a bellwether, um, because before two thousand twenty-one January, um, there had been very little capital available for clean tech or climate related investing because of the challenges that everyone had experienced in the first wave of clean tech, uh, back in the two thousands period. 9:10 Um, some of those transactions worked out, some of them did not really work out that well. 9:13 But since, uh, January twenty twenty-one, and with the momentum created in addition to that by the bipartisan insurf- infrastructure law here in the United States and the IRA, I think close to ninety-five billion dollars has been mobilized, uh, in private equity and venture capital for climate. 9:30 So there's been a real understanding that the climate opportunity and challenge is here today and here now, um, certainly in decarbonization, where I think that's become much more of an inevitable trend, and now in the area of adaptation. 9:43 The second thing that's changed is unfortunately the reality of climate change is now all around us. 9:48 And so this question of when will this happen, when is it relevant to me, how does this affect anything that I care about in the investment landscape, is now answered by the fact that we have climate change here now in twenty twenty-four. 10:02 Yes. We're definitely seeing the physical impacts of climate change accelerating market take-up of climate adaptation resilience as a theme for sure. 10:11 And absolutely there's been a, an uptick in groups, uh, alliances, uh, and think pieces on adaptation resilience, and I think it's no coincidence that, that has happened at the same time that the US has experienced multiple billion-dollar disasters in recent years. 10:26 Now, I wanna turn to Lightsmith itself. You list on your website, uh, a number of investments in your current portfolio from agricultural technology to water. 10:35 And I wanna talk about one you recently invested in, Ai-Dash, which is an AI first satellite powered SaaS company that provides remote monitoring of physical assets. 10:44 Now, this is a cool company, but I think to some listeners it may not sound as a traditional adaptation company. So I wanna ask how you see this company and other... 10:53 others like it fitting into the adaptation theme, and ask also what attracted you to Ai-Dash s- specifically. 10:59 So when you ask the question of what's investable in adaptation and climate resilience, the question for us unpacks into about twenty sectors of the economy. 11:08 Those are areas where there are companies that have solutions and technologies that can either, one, help you understand how the path of climate change is going to unfold in specific parts of society and the economy, and two, what you can do to manage or even transcend the risks and impacts that are now gonna be made more complex by climate change. 11:27 So you can either assess on the one hand or manage on the other, or have intelligence on the one hand or solutions on the other, that support resilience and adaptation to climate change. 11:36 So the way we apply that in looking at investments at Lightsmith is we read the science. 11:40 We look at things like the IPCC or GermanWatch or climate literature and identify risks and impacts in specific places and specific timescales. 11:48 And if we find a company that has the technology that can help us either understand that risk better and manage or transcend that risk, then we can describe it as a climate resilience or adaptation company. 11:58 And that's been formalized in something called the CRISP framework, the Climate Resilience Investment Solutions Principles framework that we released after peer reviewing it this year in twenty twenty-four, that sort of formalizes that approach to saying-How do we decide what is and isn't a climate resilience or adaptation company? 12:14 Now, most of the companies we look at still probably don't immediately describe what they do as climate change anything. 12:21 Uh, they do risk management, they do supply chain analytics, they do agricultural analytics, healthcare diagnostics, geospatial imagery, digital mapping, water efficiency. 12:30 Uh, but that's how the real economy and society will really adapt. No one wakes up in the morning and buys a loaf of adaptation or lives in an adaptation. 12:38 You live in a home that's hopefully more resilient to climate change, and you wanna buy food that's gonna be more resilient to climate change. 12:44 Just like you don't fill your tank with decarbonization, uh, or live in decarbonization. You live in a home that's more low carbon, and you drive around with power generated in lower carbon ways. 12:56 So you have to kind of unpack the concept of adaptation and climate resilience in order to identify investments that actually speak to that. 13:02 So AI Dash to us was a fascinating company that we've gotten to know over the last several years with a terrific CEO named Abhishek Singh, and its technology is really focused on the question of vegetation management, where you're looking at satellite imagery and applying machine learning and artificial intelligence to identify where there's encroachment of trees, shrubs, and other vegetation on power transmission and distribution lines for utilities, and this is where all the fires, um, have been starting as a result of the increasing temperature, wind, and other challenges driven by climate change. 13:36 When we look at that company, what we see is identification in the literature of increasing wildfire and extreme weather event risk, wind storms, increasing other types of storms on the East Coast of the United States and all around, uh, Europe, and fires, uh, in the United States and Australia, in the Eastern Cape of Southern Africa, in Australia, other places that are now becoming much more catastrophic as a result of climate change as well. 14:00 And this technology directly helps assess and helps manage the impacts of climate change, and we think, unfortunately, the rate of change is going to accelerate in the amount of wildfire risk we're gonna see going forward. 14:12 We have now... You know, where before we had wildfires every couple of years, we have wildfire tornadoes, we have mega fires, and I think unfortunately it's now a season, not an anomaly. Yes. Vegetation management as 14:26 a industry would probably have had people scratching their heads a few years ago, but in the context of wildfire management, it makes perfect sense. 14:34 I'm wondering what the kinda client base is for these sort of services, though. Is it utilities? Is it government? 14:39 I hear a lot from investors and startups themselves that seem to be focusing first on, on government and public sector rather than commercial interests initially. I was wondering what your experience is. Yeah. 14:51 In this case, AI Dash has over 60 different utility company customers in the United States and, and other international markets. 14:58 We're working to help expand its reach, particularly into developing countries and emerging markets, working with institutional investors and asset owners in the infrastructure space. 15:07 Um, we're about to, on the decarbonization side of things, deploy an unbelievable amount of additional electricity transmission distribution. 15:14 We wanna make sure that all of that is not going to create a tremendous amount of wildfire risk. Uh, otherwise both decarbonization and resilience will fail, uh, as we go through a much more complex transition. 15:24 But they were one of the few companies that we found that has cracked the code on how to engage with and make their technology relevant, um, to utilities and to other sets of, uh, much larger institutions that are really trying to figure out how to incorporate climate risk into a practical effect on their decision-making process and their workflow. 15:44 Now, looking at Lightsmith's portfolio in the round, are you trying to construct a, a series of investments that speak across the adaptation theme, or are you trying to hone into a specific theme? 15:55 I've spoken to other VCs, investors on this podcast and, and, like, one of them focuses very much on the water technology, one of them is focused very much on geospatial, which I suppose AI Dash could fit into. 16:07 How do you see yourself building this fund? Are you trying to cater to all flavors of adaptation? We are focused on six sectors out of 20 that we've already initially identified, um, in this fund. 16:19 So the first of these is agricultural analytics. We also look at, um, risk analytics, starting with catastrophe risk modeling, weather modeling, weather analytics, related things like parametric insurance. 16:31 Uh, geospatial information and digital mapping, both of which are relevant to understanding how risk is going to change over geography and time. And then the area of supply chain analytics. 16:41 The supply chain's being disrupted, uh, by climate related risks, uh, among other things. 16:46 And then on the physical products and services side, water generation and management, and then the broad context of resilient food systems, which could be everything from drip irrigation to drop drought-resistant crops to cold chain storage, et cetera. 16:59 And so we selected those areas because they come out of the literature as we had described. 17:04 You can read through the IPCC and see all of these things being in greater demand as a result of risk and impact generated by climate change. 17:11 And there are also, uh, business models, technology-enabled services, data and analytics that lend themselves to a growth equity strategy, which is what we pursue here at Lightsmith. 17:22 We wanna find companies that already have $10 to $100 million of revenue already growing maybe 15, 25% per year. 17:29 We think that they'll grow even faster and can help them grow even faster as a result of addressing the increased amount of demand they're gonna see from climate change. 17:38 And an observation I've had is that you're quite open about your portfolio, about who you're investing in. Lightsmith is in the news often. 17:45 Do you see yourself partly, like, trying to model behavior for other investors that want to get into the adaptation space? 17:50 Do you see yourself as pioneers who have to be a bit more open and, I don't know, show off what's possible in this theme so you can get other people involved in this market? 17:58 Lightsmith's mission here is to really make great investments, and we define those great investments as ones that generate attractive returns for investors as well as a measurable impact on climate resilience and adaptation and, and other sustainable goals that we have. 18:14 We want both of those things to be priorities, and we don't think that the kinds of investments we're makingActually compromise on either one of them. In fact, they're aligned. 18:23 Uh, if you think about AI Dash, the more that they can help to reduce the risk of wildfire, the larger their growth of revenue and profitability would be. 18:33 And in fact, you want them to be much larger as the challenge of wildfire risk gets much, much larger. So we think those things are aligned. 18:42 Now, as to how we think the space is going, as one of the first investors, or according to the Climate Policy Initiative, the first private investment fund for adaptation and climate resilience, we want many people to join us on that journey. 18:56 In fact, what we've become really focused on is this concept that we have been focused on for a long time of the unavoidable opportunity, right? If you read the IPCC's 2023 synthesis report, 19:11 one line says, "Some changes are now unavoidable and/or irreversible," which means that a certain amount of climate change impact and risk is already baked in as a result of the cumulative emissions that we've had over many decades now. 19:27 So the trajectory of climate impact between now and 2030 is pretty much fixed. There's a limited amount that we can affect the trajectory between 2030 and 2040, and really playing for the world after 2040. 19:39 So there's an unavoidable series of changes that will now unfold, and the question is, with that knowledge, how should we shape investment strategies that take account of that and that can address some of the challenges and overcome some of the issues created by that set of changes in a way that actually generates great investment returns, which we think is certainly possible. 20:01 Now, by making that case and explaining how that turns into a practical investment strategy, we think many sets of investors and many entrepreneurs, and hopefully many of the people listening to this podcast, will consider investing their time, energy, and effort into these kinds of activities, which I think should generate much more attractive returns for everyone, and also a much better return to society, and that will have much more scaled up technologies and solutions as the challenges become more complicated. 20:29 So you have a clear investment thesis, and it's not, if I may say, an impact investor thesis. 20:34 It's about investing in companies you think are on a path to, to be profitable, to be successful, uh, while also providing these societal goods. But it's not like you are seeing a trade-off between these two factors. 20:47 You do see this as a, an investable theme that should be attractive to a whole range of, of capital allocators. Yeah. Let me say two things very clearly off the bat. 20:55 The first is, before we talk about how awesome climate is as an investment theme, we take extremely seriously the fact that this is first and foremost a humanitarian tragedy, right? 21:05 There are people being impacted right now all around the world by the effects of climate change, and the unfolding implications of that will continue to impact lives, livelihoods, nature, everything. 21:17 And we should do as much as we can to address and reduce the potential of that trajectory to impact everyone else. So that is something that we think is extremely serious and should be, uh, treated as such. 21:32 That being said, 21:34 there is also a huge opportunity to take that set of problems and complexity and turn it into the opportunity for technology solutions and the mobilization of capital and the creation of value, uh, that takes account of that complexity. 21:50 And that, I think, is the opportunity side of the equation. The question is what do you do with it, and whether you actually capitalize on it. 21:57 Um, but we do think that this kind of investing that we're doing aligns the tools that we wanna scale up with the returns that we think we can generate as a result of that. 22:07 We're not here to decarbonize steel in this fund. We're here to accelerate the rate of solutions as the rate of problems accelerates. Thanks for that, Jay. 22:19 Moving on, I was hoping you could speak to us about GARI, which is the Global Adaptation Resilience Investment Working Group. 22:26 You were involved in the founding, and I was wondering if you could tell us why it was set up and what the purpose of the group is. 22:33 The Global Adaptation Resilience Investment Working Group was set up at the Paris Global Climate Talks, COP21 as it's called, in 2015. 22:41 And the way that it came about was the UN Secretary General in the run-up to Paris wanted to engage the private sector and investors, both in discussing capital that could be allocated to mitigation... 22:54 Again, decarbonization, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, reducing the scale of the problem. 22:59 And then this area that had been talked about as a policy objective called adaptation or climate resilience, or how do you deal with the effects of climate change. 23:06 And as a result of that, we were invited to present our strategy, which we were developing, on how to invest in adaptation and climate resilience, which as I mentioned before, really is a tool strategy. 23:18 So Lightsmith believes that there are many existing sets of tools and technologies out there that address the risks and impacts that will become much more complicated because of climate change, and that we can invest today in those tools and solutions and scale them up as rapidly as possible as the scale of the problem gets larger. 23:34 So we presented that idea to a convening of the Office of the Secretary General on the run-up to Paris, and they said, "That's a great idea. Can you consider raising a $10 billion fund around it?" 23:45 And we said, "We don't know if that's possible." [laughs] That's quite ambitious. 23:50 We know that would be a great idea, and the Green Climate Fund itself is designed to, again, deploy half of its funding in adaptation, and if you can make that investable, then hundreds of billions or trillions of dollars should be deployed in this area. 24:03 That, I think, is much more obvious now than it was back in 2015. 24:07 Uh, but we said what could be really useful was to pull together experts that came from many different stakeholder groups, so investors, climate experts, government individuals, corporates, technologists, entrepreneurs, scientists, to talk about two questions. 24:27 One-What is the impact on investments of the physical risk and impact of climate change? And two, what are the opportunities that are created to invest by the need for resilience to climate change? 24:41 And so, uh, we agreed with the Secretary General that we would launch a working group called the Global Adaptation and Resilience Investment Working Group to pull together those set of stakeholders to have a series of discussions over the course of 2016 and talk about what might be possible as a result of focusing on these two sets of questions. 25:02 And so that was the origin of the GARI working group. 25:05 It's an official partner of the UN Secretary General's Climate Resilience Initiative, and has then since published, I think, several discussion papers, including one in 2016 which set the landscape out. 25:16 It's been involved in developing taxonomies around this, convened over 900 individuals in about 70 meetings globally to really talk about these two sets of issues, and I think has been a helpful intersection point for a lot of people in discussing how these two things can be faced practically and in a way that's constructive across many different groups of people. 25:37 So to me, GARI seems like a, a thought leader in adaptation investment. You provide great content and data on the state of adaptation finance and investable solutions. 25:47 You bring people all together, but what's the kind of purpose or the or- o- o- organizational imperative of that? Is it to drive towards, uh, investment taxonomy? Is it to try to encourage more likesmith groups to form? 25:58 Is it to try and get a, a group of people engaged in their industries, uh, in, in adaptation? What, what do you see as the purpose of these convenings? 26:07 Yeah, the GARI Working Group's mission is to generate information around adaptation and climate resilience as an investment area, and to disseminate it, and to build a community that can share that information across multiple stakeholder groups. 26:20 So it is, as a center of gravity, focused on investors and trying to provide the investor input and perspective into a discussion around adaptation and, and resilience to climate change. And so that is its core mission. 26:34 The reason why we meet about at least four times a year and always have a site event, uh, during the, uh, Global Climate Talks is to try to present a, a snapshot of where folks thinking about investments in adaptation and climate resilience really are, and what the state of the state is year to year of that. 26:49 Um, the overall mission is to try to inform investors and other stakeholders about the physical risk and impact, uh, created by climate change and how that could affect investments and how they can develop investment strategies around it. 27:01 And to, you know, scale up interest and, um, support the mobilization of investment around this i- in a way that's helpful to that broad range of stakeholder groups. 27:11 Through it, we hope many different types of strategies emerge. 27:13 I mean, one of the reasons we created GARI in the first place is when we were trying to find people to talk to about investment and adaptation back in 2015 in the run-up to the Global Climate Talks in Paris, uh, and the Paris Agreement, we could find lots of places where you could have discussions about mitigation and decarbonization and renewable energy and the energy transition, um, and almost no one that was really focusing on how to invest and what happens to investments as a result of adaptation and climate resilience. 27:41 And so we thought we should pull together a bunch of people. We did that for one year, and then everybody kept asking us to keep doing it, so that's why we do it. And am I right in thinking that GARI is expanding? 27:50 It looks like you're hiring for a program manager. GARI continues to expand its activities and support different sets of research projects. 27:59 It has historically been very much supported, uh, by, um, volunteer efforts, but it's also received support from the Kresge Foundation, State Street Global Advisors Foundation, uh, has worked on projects supported by the Bezos Earth Fund most recently, and ClimateWorks Foundation, and is now working on a project, uh, together with, uh, the Global Environment Facility and UNIDO and Climate-KIC, uh, around expanding, uh, the ecosystem of practitioners in adaptation and climate resilience investment, um, in both developed and developing countries. 28:31 And so the program manager role that you allude to is related to that, um, activity. 28:36 And so we have been pleasantly surprised that the discussions and the knowledge generation coming out of GARI has become increasingly of interest to, I would say, climate resilience curious investors and others, as well as continuing to support climate resilience-committed folks that are active in investing in the field. 28:55 Yes. 28:55 When you think of the plethora of net zero or climate-friendly investor alliances and groups that have sprung up since the Paris Agreement, and then you compare that to what I think is a very sparse space [chuckles] on the adaptation side of things, it is great to see GARI lead the way there. 29:11 I want to look domestically now. 29:12 I want to look into US shores because we have seen in the last year or so this backlash against ESG investing, and I'm wondering if you think these same pressures could negatively affect adaptation as an investment theme. 29:26 Do you think adaptation financing, as it becomes more prominent, do you think there'll be a similar negative reaction, or do you think there are characteristics to adaptation which kind of insulates it from some of the backlash that's been seen towards net zero and green initiatives? 29:40 I think it's an excellent question because I think there's a complex answer to it that comes in two parts. 29:45 The first is the drive and demand for adaptation and climate resilience technologies and solutions is physics and time. The amount of extreme weather events now is just going to increase by frequency and severity. 30:02 The amount of volatility in health impact from different disease vectors is going to increase as a result of global warming. 30:11 The amount of disruption to the supply chain potentially or, or impact on infrastructure, all of these things are now going to unfold because of the cumulative amount of emissions that we already have in place, at least until about 2030And to some large degree to 2040. 30:32 So the government doesn't need to force anything to happen for you to need more solutions and technologies to address the increasingly complicated environment that will unfold because of the path of global warming today, right? 30:47 There will be more flooding, unfortunately, there will be more fires, there will be more weather events, there will be more volatility and disruption if you believe the science, and I do, um, on a trajectory that is not very easy to change between now and 2030, and again, to a limited degree, to 2040. 31:03 Which is well, I think, within the decision-making and investor horizon that we have right now. 31:07 People will demand those solutions, uh, whether they call them climate change adaptation or resilience solutions or flood protection or wildfire management or supply chain, uh, certainty of delivery or business continuity or, um, secure coffee and cocoa supplies, which I certainly hope exist in 2030, 2040 and well beyond then. 31:29 Um, all of those things will be in demand because the challenges are independent of government action in that sense. 31:37 So that's the first part of it, which is you don't have to call it climate change to believe that there's more flooding in Florida. 31:44 You don't have to call it climate change to know that there's gonna be more fires in, uh, many different parts of the world, unfortunately, or to recognize that there is more fire in more parts of the world. 31:55 Um, that demand driver is there. 31:56 In fact, I would argue that you actually have more certainty and conviction if you think about it, about the direction of climate change than you do about the path of interest rates, inflation, artificial intelligence, consumer behavior, Taylor Swift's dating life. 32:17 All of these things are way more variable than whether or not climate change will unfold between now and 2030 and 2040. So Louis, if you're having this podcast in 2030 or 2040, 32:28 I am pretty sure that climate change will have unfolded. 32:33 I don't know where interest rates will be or what the political cycle will look like or, or popular culture will be, but I do know that climate change will have occurred. 32:43 And so that unavoidable set of changes creates this opportunity to make investments around that known trajectory, and that trajectory will not be affected, uh, directly on the demand side by the shape of government policy per se. 32:59 Now that being said, the government can be incredibly helpful and the political environment and the investment environment can be incredibly helpful at accelerating how we assess and address these unavoidable changes, right? 33:12 There are pieces of the, uh, IRA that support smart grid upgrade, right? 33:18 There are pieces of energy forecast demand spending that can accelerate our ability, uh, to deal with the fact that we're gonna ha- have a heck of a lot more, um, heat events and also air quality events driven by wildfire smoke from thousands of miles away. 33:32 So th- there's certainly support that can be driven into these areas that help people deal with the fact that there will be more of these primary, secondary, tertiary impacts from, uh, the unavoidable amount of change from climate change between now and 2030 and now and, uh, 2040 effectively. 33:50 Um, so I'm not saying that government policy can't be helpful, it's just not what will drive the underlying demand for these technologies and solutions. 34:00 Uh, it wouldn't be crazy to me to launch a CHIPS Act for adaptation and climate resilience where we find those technologies we think are gonna be the most important and most useful and create the most advantage and the most return that can help us deal with this increasingly complicated environment that we've created for ourselves. 34:16 In that I think you will fail... Have all the effects of climate change regardless of the political environment. 34:21 It may be labeled differently how you invest in solutions and technologies to assess and manage those complexities, but those complexities will happen regardless of whatever political party is in power. 34:33 Yes, the board is set, the pieces are moving, and you can't defy destiny, a- at least we can't defy the physical impact we've already brought on upon ourselves. And I do see 34:45 certain states, certain government entities talking about climate adaptation, but using different language like natural disaster resilience, et cetera. 34:53 I do think that is helpful, but coming back to something you mentioned earlier, a number of companies you said that you explore, they do speak to the climate adaptation theme, but may not describe themselves as climate companies. 35:04 They might describe themselves, as you said, companies that provide resilience in different areas from cocoa to water to, to agriculture. 35:11 I'm wondering from a company's point of view, does it make sense do you think for them to start to kind of embrace cl- climate as a theme because it may unlock capital from certain funds like your own that are focused on promoting adaptation? 35:23 Yeah, I don't know whether I have a great recommendation for companies on whether they should self-label or not. 35:29 I'm certainly against greenwashing or, you know, obscuring, uh, what's really happening or being generated by a company if it wants to seek particular labeling. 35:37 What I would pose is the opposite question, Louis, which is this. If you agree that if we're sitting here in 2030 or 2040 that climate change has happened, then companies could choose one of two paths. 35:51 You could either make your operations and your products and services resilient, adapted, or transcendent to the changes and impacts and complexity created by climate change, or you could not. 36:06 And I would argue that there's a higher chance that if I can deliver your two-day Amazon package to you, even if there's way more flooding, fire complexity, changes in temperature, changes in 36:20 different types of risk factors, and my competitor can't because I took account of the fact that the world will change now between now and 2030, and you didn'tMy company's gonna be worth a lot more, and should be a lot-- worth a lot more than your company. 36:36 Now, do I need to call it climate resilience or adaptation, or do I simply need to take seriously and practically the fact that the world is now going to change in a specific identifiable direction between now and twenty thirty and twenty forty? 36:51 That's, I think, the question that people should be posing because there will be otherwise lots of unfortunate surprises that will be less surprising over time, um, in the case of people that don't take account of the fact that conditions are changing. 37:04 There are some unavoidable and unfortunately potentially irreversible changes now that will happen between now and twenty thirty and twenty forty. 37:13 It's strong framing, it's convincing framing, and I do think that messaging is attractive to investors and can make sense to potential clients of these businesses that are providing adaptation services, whether they know it or not. 37:25 But this interest with me in labeling comes from the fact that the last few months I've been looking at a lot of investment taxonomies for adaptation resilience. 37:33 So Gary has one, the, the Climate Resilience Investments and Solutions Principles. It's not really a taxonomy, it's more of a, a framework. 37:40 But again, it's focused on trying to kind of sort out what is adaptation, what isn't in an investable sense. And I'm wondering what you think the next step is to get adaptation mainstreamed as an investment theme. 37:50 Do you think these frameworks, these taxonomies will lead to things like investable indexes or more funds like Lightsmith that can move the, the story on? What's, what's your take for what's gonna happen next? Yeah. 38:02 I think that what will happen next is, is two different things, 'cause the purpose for these kinds of approaches to identifying or describing or defining what is resilience and adaptation to climate change depends on who's using the taxonomy, right? 38:20 Why do I wanna have a definition for climate resilience and adaptation? I might want it because as a policy matter, I want to direct capital and activity and investment and funding towards that set of goals, right? 38:34 And so that's the kind of, you should do this stuff. 38:38 And, uh, the other side of it is I just wanna figure out what is going to be more important or more interesting or potentially more valuable, um, when climate change happens. 38:49 Not because I wanna necessarily push people in that direction, not because I... 38:54 someone should do something from a, a moral or, or normative standpoint, but they ought to do something because it'll just be a better outcome from a at a positive standpoint, if that makes any sense. So 39:08 the use of these definitions of taxonomies, I think, is, is the critical point. 39:12 And we think that the CRISP risk framework, um, that Gary produced is to support both sets of folks to say, "Here's what we really mean by adapting and building resilience to climate change," which is reading scientific evidence, figuring out what we are gonna need as a result of the things that are all predicted, um, and now unfolding unfortunately because of climate change, and here are the things that should be supported as a matter of policy on one hand, and that are really interesting opportunities uh, on the other hand because of climate change. 39:39 I think those two sets of interests will continue to expand as more people shift their attention to this question, and I think that's very important. 39:50 So the two things that I am concerned about on the downside and the upside of the problem. 39:55 [chuckles] On the downside, Louis, I'm very worried about what I would call the Esperanto problem, which is a whole bunch of people go out and invent a whole bunch of new languages- Mm.... 40:03 that nobody else wants to speak. Yes. 40:05 And then we end up with several regional Esperanto dialects and it becomes even less intelligible because we don't really have time anymore to be messing about with the, the kind of harmonization process, let's put it that way, right? 40:23 The crisis is upon us and the opportunity is upon us now. 40:27 And so figuring out what we need to have way more of, so technologies that help us understand how agriculture's gonna be affected, how water's gonna be affected, the supply chain, healthcare, infrastructure, energy systems, financial services, everything, biodiversity being impacted, all those things, and then how do we actually address those things? 40:47 How do we manage them? And again, like I said, how do we transcend that set of issues? That is what we should be all about. 40:53 And however we describe that, I would hope that more people would be willing to get on the same page on that rather than spend a lot of time flipping back and forth between other pages, if you will. 41:03 Um, now the upside to that is I think it's great that there's this much energy and focus on identifying things that are out there right now that support adaptation and climate resilience because they are out there right now. 41:15 Now the outcome of this paper that we released at Yuri with the support of the Bezos Earth Fund and Climeworks Foundation, The Unavoidable Opportunity, was a piece that we did together with Lightsmith, um, and with MSCI Sustainability Institute, which looked at the entire universe of publicly listed companies, both in developed and developing countries, and identified over eight hundred companies with these types of solutions for adaptation and climate resilience that are investable right now by people all around the world. 41:45 About nine to 11% of all listed companies, whether in developed or developing countries, have these kinds of technologies. 41:52 Again, they may not call them adaptation and climate resilience, but from the point of view of investors who wanna find those companies and get exposure and support with capital or benefit from the growth in those companies, that's one use for the tool, the CRISP framework in that case, which was applied. 42:09 And from a policy perspective, governments wanna be out there figuring out how to support and amplify those solutions and technologies because they are the ones that are going to address the challenges that they've already id- identified here. 42:23 So the, the thing I wanna really highlight here is this. Louis, we talk about adaptation and climate resilience in these three stages. First, it's right here right now. Climate risk and climate impact is here now. 42:34 Second, climate risk and climate impactIs a downside risk to your investments right now. And that is something I think people are coming to grips with and understanding right now. But that third piece is really critical. 42:48 Sure, it's here now. Sure, it's a downside risk, but the other side of that equation is that it is an enormous opportunity. 42:58 It is an unavoidable opportunity for building technologies and companies and solutions and societies that will be even better in spite of the more chaotic or volatile or complex or climate changed environment, however you wanna describe it, um, if we direct capital and innovation and entrepreneurship at them right now. 43:23 And the prize for that for investors is dramatically higher growth and more value, and for society, substantially more tools and technologies so that we can manage an incredibly complicated environment we've created for ourselves. 43:40 And I think both those things can be accomplished at the same time. So that is the unavoidable opportunity that we have right now. 43:46 Uh, and if we have ways of defining or approaching or understanding or translating what we mean by that into companies and categories and investments that people can then practically look at and do something about, that's great. 44:00 And that's the last point that I'd probably make here, which is climate investing and climate change is not a tale of two islands where you can choose mitigation or decarbonization island, or you can choose adaptation or climate resilience island. 44:14 We are gonna live in one future that's gonna have climate change in it, and the choice is to build that future in spite of the complexity of the environment in a way that is lower carbon, and so reduces the scale of complexity going forward and resilient to climate impact, or one that exacerbates the problem 44:34 or is just damaged over and over because of it. And we can make that choice right now as investors and as entrepreneurs and technologists and citizens and all those things. Yes. 44:46 It seems the one choice is definitely greater than the other, and pursuing that unavoidable opportunity, as you phrase it, certainly seems something worth doing. 44:54 And absolutely, I believe that Lightsmith is in, in the investment space at least, is definitely leading the way here. 45:00 Just finally then, Jay, I wanna ask about your travel schedule and your plans for the next few months as we come up to Climate Week in New York and also to the next COP. What, what are your plans for the next few months? 45:11 What's got you excited? We're very excited about the upcoming, uh, New York Climate Week. 45:16 Uh, I think it's a great chance for folks that are new to investing in climate change and interested in policy or interested in, um, technology entrepreneurship to see a whole range of different folks from all over the world that are focused on both the decarbonization side of things, but also adaptation and climate resilience. 45:33 Uh, Gary itself, we're likely to have several events during the course of Climate Week, and we'll, we'll certainly keep you, Louis, and folks on this podcast posted on that. 45:41 And obviously then there's the run-up to the global climate talks in Baku, in Azerbaijan in the November timeframe, and I think we're seeing continued momentum and expansion of folks interested in investing in adaptation and climate resilience, both here in the US and globally, and hope to ro- report out on some interesting developments that we're seeing in that landscape. 46:02 The one thing I would tease you with, Louis, is we did launch this first private investment fund for climate resilience adaptation here at Lightsmith, and I think the useful thing about that is our hypothesis that there were hundreds or thousands of companies that you could invest in that existed out there today, you could put capital into that could scale, that could generate measurable impact and interesting financial performance, has proven itself out. 46:31 And that's a great first attempt at making this space more concrete and understandable and investible to lots of folks, and we've seen lots of momentum since then. 46:41 What we now have recognized is that there is a clear need, not just for capital at the growth stage for adaptation and climate resilience that we're pursuing right now at Lightsmith and will continue to pursue, but there are hundreds of other companies at much larger scale 46:57 and hundreds of companies that are just starting out and developing new technologies we're gonna need absolutely in the future, and that the overall opportunity set is even larger than we thought it was five or six years ago when we started to deploy capital in this space. 47:12 So that is... What I can also tell you is that there is a concrete attackable opportunity right now for investors in the private markets, and as the unavoidable opportunity paper describes, also in the public markets. 47:25 And that means that there is a tremendous amount that investors can do and entrepreneurs can go after that we see that should give rise to lots of other new strategies and platforms and approaches. 47:41 Uh, and we certainly have a few ideas about that, that we hope to follow up with you on as we unfold them. 47:47 Well, I'll be keeping close tabs on your work with Lightsmith and with Gary Jay, and I look forward to seeing all the cool intellectual capital you produce and also the cool financial products a- and, and data that you might be coming out with soon as well. 48:00 So I do encourage Climate Proof listeners to check out, uh, the garygroup.com and also check out the Lightsmith group to learn more. Jay, thanks so much for your time today. Really appreciate it. 48:11 Have a lovely rest of your week. Thanks so much, Louis. Really appreciate it. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 48:26 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]