Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. This week, I interview John Robinson, a technology investor with Mazarin Ventures. 0:24 He's laser-focused on identifying and investing in climate adaptation technologies, or CAT, particularly those that address climate-related water risks. 0:33 As you'll find out, this means more than dealing with floods and droughts. 0:37 It turns out there's a whole investable universe out there for those willing to expand their understanding of what counts as climate adaptation tech. 0:44 Before we get started, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 0:50 Listeners like you can help support my coverage by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. For the month of August, annual subscriptions are 33% off, so sign up today. 1:04 In a minute, my conversation with John, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:10 [whooshing sound] In finance, the Biden administration is investing $10 million in climate resilience centers across 10 US states. 1:18 These centers will bring scientists, engineers, and other experts together to conduct research on climate shocks and develop climate proofing strategies. 1:25 Each center will use climate data, models, and research capabilities made available by the Department of Energy and work on everything from addressing urban heat island risks to developing early warning systems for local communities. 1:37 The funds are being made available as part of the administration's Justice40 Initiative, which requires 40% of the benefits of certain federal projects to go to under-invested and over-polluted communities. 1:49 [whooshing sound] In policy, federal agencies launched a national heat strategy for the US. This aims to protect the health of Americans and promote economic and social well-being in the face of escalating temperatures. 2:00 The strategy features 118 recommended actions for hardening the US against heat-related risks. 2:07 They are organized across four goals: one, enhancing communication of heat risks; two, advancing heat science; three, improving access to heat information services and solutions; and four, supporting inter-agency networks focused on heat. 2:22 Some agencies are already taking action. 2:25 Last week, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration announced that $200,000 would be shared by up to 10 communities to develop heat tabletop exercises, which are simulated emergency drills designed to test emergency heat response efforts. 2:39 [whooshing sound] And in tech, the research network Climate Change AI is offering grants of up to $150,000 for projects that use AI and machine learning to help solve knotty climate issues. 2:50 Projects have to be one year in duration and led by a principal investigator at an accredited university. 2:55 Part of the deal is that grantees publish a dataset or simulator created by collating, labeling, or annotating existing data. The deadline for proposals is September 15th. 3:04 [whooshing sound] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with John. [upbeat music] Hi, John. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. 3:17 I live in London, but I'm originally from the US. My wife is English, and we're raising our family here. I'm a partner in a Chicago-based VC called Mazarin. 3:26 Our thesis is pretty straightforward, backing early-stage technology companies that help industry and society deal with water risk. 3:37 We have an incubator called Mazarin Labs, where we're skunkworking some really early-stage stuff, think university research, spin-outs. Our Fund I has 12 companies now complete. Our Fund II is in motion. 3:49 We're making investments out of that now. And we're planning a launch of our Fund III, which is hyper-focused on what we call the water risk vertical of climate adaptation technology. 4:03 On the side, we do some stuff with some private equity houses, helping them find things to buy. And a big part of our impact mandate is catalyzing, sharing, and learning opportunities. 4:14 So to whatever degree we've developed some wisdom on something or some experience, we welcome opportunities to share with others so they can build off that and pursue their own needs and objectives relating to, to water and wastewater. 4:27 So thanks for the opportunity to be on here and, and looking forward to the conversation. Absolutely. 4:31 I'm very grateful to you, John, because I think you're one of these people who've been trying to educate the wider market about climate adaptation technology, or CAT, and making people realize that it's more than what they may have traditionally thought of it as. 4:44 Mm-hmm. And you've produced some great content with Mazarin. 4:47 You, you're a prolific poster on, on LinkedIn highlighting brilliant technologies and innovations that really do have a climate adaptation purpose but may not have traditionally been seen as that. 4:57 My first question is on this work you've been doing, because you've conducted a number of interesting surveys on the CAT investment space, and I want to know what prompted you to do those surveys and what were the key findings from your perspective. 5:09 When we were planning our Fund III, which is our fund that's hyper-focused on the water risk vertical of CAT, we wanted to understand the, the landscape of, of checkbooks out there that had some focus on adaptation. 5:24 We wanted to find some room where we could spread our wings and lend a hand to the adaptation community in, in a way that was unique, so we didn't wanna be... duplicate existing efforts. 5:35 And we found that through SurveyMonkey, so we've done two and we're gonna do one more, we were able to refine our thesis, which helped us cultivate and improve the deal flow, 5:49 higher quality deals, deals that we could understand, and then lastly, understanding what the exits could be for those deals. 5:58 So in, in short, the conclusion was we, through the SurveyMonkey, is we found that the landscape wasMissing a fund entirely focused on the water risk vertical of cat. So that, that puts us in SDG 13. 6:11 SDG 13 is climate action. I mean, the SDG goals are imperfect, but it's a pretty good chassis for understanding the problems of humanity, from poverty and hunger and health and education. 6:22 A lot of the climate-induced water problems belong in, in 13, and so we decided to create... W- after our SurveyMonkey, we decided that we belonged more in 13. 6:33 So that's why we did it is self-serving, but also as impact investors, we wanted to contribute a verse to the, the global conversation on adaptation by being a subject matter expert in this one space. 6:46 I'm not gonna go through all the questions, but in our first survey of the 101 respondees, 80% were VC, 10% angel, and 10% private equity, something like that. Mm-hmm. 6:59 The first question was, how do you view decarb versus adaptation? And there was four, four answers. The first one was, we're at war and decarbonization is should be our only focus. 7:10 We're at war against carbon, and we should focus 100% of our times on beating carbon. Forget about adaptation. 1% of people are just carbon warriors, and they think adaptation is defeatist. 7:21 7% of people said, the war against carbon has been lost. We need to focus 100% of our efforts on dealing with our new cl- climate reality, 7%. The third one was 82% said they're of equal importance. 7:36 Yes, we need to stop smoking, but we already have cancer and we need chemotherapy now. [chuckles] Uh, pardon the metaphor, but I get it. And then 10% of people said other, 7:46 and a lot of those other ones were like, "You're creating a false dichotomy. We need systemic change." [chuckles] Like, it was a little bit like, "You're framing this wrong. It's not decarb reverse adaptation. 7:57 It's all one big problem and we need to solve it systemically." It was a lot of academia and policy people like, "The whole thing needs to be solved." 8:03 As VC, we have to focus on one thing and do it really well, otherwise we'll probably get a poor deal flow and then a portfolio of also-ran companies. 8:13 Because if you're looking at solar panels and wind and batteries, and then you jump the fence and you're looking at like flood modeling tools and like drip irrigation, 8:24 like you're not gonna be able to play in all those verticals and be successful as a VC. So you've gotta pick a realm where you can go 10 miles deep. 8:31 And so I get it that academia and government wants to think systemically about solving all the world's problems, but as a VC, you gotta pick something and you gotta go deep in it. 8:39 The second question was, have you made any de- have you done any investing on the adaptation side? 8:45 The, the most common answer was, so only 10% of those interviews had done investing on the adaptation side, and the, the feedback from the audience was, "We just don't understand the deal flow on the adaptation side." 8:58 So they go back to electric scooters and e-bikes and solar and wind, and like winning the war on carbon, which is great. 9:04 We're not against that, but there's very defined verticals within the decarb net zero side, and it's tangible, and like even little kids understand, like we need to emit less carbon. 9:15 The adaptation side is a bit more abstract. I would say much more abstract, actually. But over the course of the last year or so, Mazarin has sharpened our pencils up and we've developed a taxonomy and we've generated... 9:27 We've built a, a robust deal flow and, and we've figured out a framing of this, and now we see a lot more interest in jumping the fence and putting money to work, um, on the adaptation side. 9:40 Another conclusion from our survey number one was which problems or which risks, which climate change-induced risks do you think are the most investable for a VC or PE? 9:52 Like- And by investable, sorry, could you lay out what you mean by investable? Yeah. So let's think about, uh, so just on the adaptation side. 9:58 Forget about solar and wind and energy efficiency and s- carbon sequestration. Just on the adaptation side. 10:03 So as the planet warms, hurricanes are getting worse, drought is intensifying some places and floods in other places. Water quality is deteriorating because of harmful algal blooms. Fires are destroying forests. 10:16 Windstorms are taking down lives and livelihoods, and heat is killing people. So pick your devil. 10:24 All of them are problematic, but our audience pointed to 91% of the 101 said climate change-induced water quality and quantity are our biggest headache, humanity's biggest headache going forward, and it seems like there's enough deal flow within that vertical to support a fund that wants to build a portfolio and generate superior returns for their LPs a- a- and most importantly, generate social and environmental impact. 10:55 So it was seen as a vertical that is both very important because climate-induced water risks are serious threats to, to societal and economic security, but also because there is a pipeline of- Deals... 11:08 companies- Deals... and deals, uh, that make sense for you to, to get involved in. No, we're, we're VCs, so we think, yeah, companies, so we just think in terms of deals. 11:14 So here are the four as we frame it, the four horsemen of the apocalypse, let's call it. Fire, water, heat, and wind. So they're all, they're all problematic, but there's not that many deals in wind damage. 11:29 You're getting into weather and climate forecasting, so there's tons there, but like, there's not... We, we don't see that many pure play deals in wind. Y- your weather. 11:40 So there's 20 or 30 companies that are weather forecasting, climate forecasting, so that would count as win- the wind vertical deal flow. 11:46 I'm not saying there's none, but it's hard, it's hard to find enough deals in wind. Heat is a big killer and gets a lot of airtime. 11:55 Yes, there's deals to keeping people cool and keeping food and, and medical supplies cool, and air conditioning and efficiencies. There are deals out there. It's hard to understand how a fund could live on-... 12:07 fire, and then what are the exits? There's tons of public sector involvement in fire risk mitigation and fire management and warnings. 12:18 Now we're biased, or maybe just subjective, 'cause my business partners and I come out of the world of water, so we just naturally have more deal flow, and I'm sure if somebody wakes up and they're thinking about fire every day, they're gonna see way more than we see. 12:30 So we come out of the water world, but it just coincidentally, there's more hardware so- and software to help industry and society. 12:39 There's so many deals, investors like the water risk vertical, and that gets into biodiversity, and that gets into insurance, and that gets into natural resource management, 'cause water cuts across all those ones. 12:50 So our second survey, we had a few questions in there that were interesting around more specifically how are you planning to frame it, and one just to highlight there was, the effects of a warming planet will in- impact all industries, but click on the three industry sectors you plan your adaptation focused investing ar- around. 13:12 Which three o- of them? 13:13 There's agriculture, aquaculture, building owners and, and operators, finance, insurance, real estate, heavy and light industry, logistics, transportation, like ports, harbors, marinas, power utilities, water and wastewater utilities, and other. 13:25 The top three answers on the board from these 101 tech books was agriculture. And this is all relating to... So this is not water s- focused. This is just on the adaptation side, where do you wanna put your money? 13:36 Agriculture was number one. Finance, insurance, real estate was number two, and utilities, power and water utilities were number three. That surprised us. 13:46 I thought that logistics and transportation would score higher, and I thought aquaculture and fisheries would score higher, and I thought industry would score higher, but they didn't. 13:56 But the clear winner there is agriculture is the most effed, pardon my French. 14:01 [chuckles] And people understand that, and they say for humanity to survive we need food, and food doesn't live, if there, it doesn't happen if there's drought or fields are underwater for two-thirds of the year. 14:13 That- that's what the, the people are saying, and so we're building our fund around that, so we're looking for syndication. 65% of the respondees say agriculture is the number one focus of their money. 14:24 Or the farmers will have the biggest headaches. That doesn't always come to the surface though, 'cause AgTech has not done well as a category. It's a graveyard of money and deals, unfortunately. 14:34 The technologies work and they're well intentioned and smart people working on helping farmers survive, but it's been a bit of a graveyard, unfortunately. 14:41 So what we're planning to do as a fund is grab the AgTech deals and bring them into climate and position them as climate adaptation tech. And someone might say, "Well, that's just drip irrigation." 14:52 It's like, yeah, that's climate tech. "No, it's AgTech." It's like, no, it's climate tech. And all of a sudden it gets people excited, it's climate tech, it's more interesting, this is helping climate. 15:02 Ag just has a, unfortunately, has a unfortunate reputation. Can you expand on that? What do you mean an unfortunate- It's slow. It's slow to get farmers to buy innovations. 15:13 Farmers are traditionally very conservative, don't have big budgets. It's hard to plan for future needs. It's hard to reach all of them. There's tons of small farmers around the world. It's a s- a hard to scale industry. 15:24 If you have a good solution 15:26 relating to water on the farm, the big farms are gonna hire an agronomist or consultant to help them figure out what they need to do, and there's a business there obviously for consultants a- and agronomists. 15:36 But like you get to like family-owned farms and small farms, which is most of farming in the world, it's really hard to scale and reach those people. So it's been a lot of graveyard. 15:42 A lot of money's gone into AgTech and, and very few winners. So we did the surv- two survey markets. We're gonna do one more. Um, that's what they've told us. 15:52 One other interesting thing, the last question in the last one was, what are you planning to invest in? So a lot of them said ag and utilities and finance, insurance, real estate related problems. 16:02 We said, "What are you likely to focus on? What kind of companies are you likely to invest in?" We thought most of the investors [chuckles] would say digital only, software, digital data related, broadly defined, 16:12 and very few would say hardware. But 43% of the respondents [chuckles] said, "We wanna primarily invest in companies offering physical solutions, hardware, consumables, but some software digital data," they said. 16:25 So h- almost half said they mostly wanna do hardware with a little bit of sprinkling of software digital data. I... That surprised me. I thought it would be r- the reverse. 16:33 Only 20% said, "We're pure play software digital data." That surprised me. I don't... These investors, we don't know all these guys. 16:39 We're, we know some of them, but people filled that out and they're like, they wanna put money into hardware and consumables that enable industry and society to deal with, to, to survive. That surprised us. 16:50 So those were our, our two surveys. We're gonna do another one that's gonna go deeper into adaptation. In fact, I think our third one will probably just go into the water risk vertical of climate adaptation tech. 17:01 Why do we do it? To inform our fund thesis. 17:03 Conclusions pointed to some salient points that we wanna build strategies around and deal flow around, and we wanna syndicate these with some of these other respondees who said, "We wanna focus on X, Y, and Z." 17:20 It's great. Here's a deal. We're putting money in. You guys wanna put money next to us. So we're building out a syndicate of checkbooks that have an appetite for adaptation. 17:29 Can I ask, slapping the climate adaptation tech brand onto the sort of investments you're talking about, water related investments or fire related investments, et cetera, what do you think it really adds in terms of your ability to go out and raise money and also to, to, uh, you know, find deals? 17:46 Like what is the actual tangible benefit to you having this climate adaptation tech branding? Um, three things. Number one, founders that we come across in our 300 plus deals a year, some of them really... 18:01 It really resonates with them that they're, they might be in-- they've traditionally have found themselves in the water industry or the water space or ag... 18:10 tech or proptech, like water in property and helping building owners in Arizona be more efficient with water. They welcome the re- repositioning or the reframing of their company as climate. 18:24 It gives them more clarity as m- many of these founders will be like, "Wow, this... Yeah, we are really more climate than the water industry." 18:31 And they struggle in the water industry because it's so heavy, like utilities and like a bit of industrial water and wastewater. They struggle to get traction. 18:39 They struggle to explain to their friends and family, neighbors what they do. 18:44 The second they say climate, people sit up in their chair straighter, and it gives them clarity and focus and purpose and mission and being part of something that everyone's concerned about. 18:53 I don't know why more people don't think about water problems, but, like, they just don't. People think about climate. It's top of list. 18:59 Which would be number two, this framing around climate adaptation tech has enabled us to draw polygons around technology verticals, tools that we otherwise wouldn't necessarily see. So I'll give you some examples. 19:15 Um, so the first one is about founders liking this and wanting to partner with us. Second one is it's enabling us to see innovations that we previously wouldn't see just as water. 19:26 There's some nerdy machine learning guys out there who have figured out that essentially our inability to forecast tides accurately because of climate change is basically a data problem, which is, like, cliché nowadays. 19:39 Everything's a data problem, but it's true. And they... 19:42 There's a few, four or five different individuals out there who are nerdy on tides and coastal storm surges and hurricane trends, and I don't think checkbooks that are in the water industry or in climate tech focused on decarb would really find themselves looking at tides. 20:04 So that's one example of an area that we're, we're excited to go deeper into, and there's a whole genre of deals that are, like, coastal marine related, water related challenges and coastal marine that fall outside of the so-called water industry. 20:18 The second area that we're pretty nerdy in is impaired lakes. As the planet warms and, and ag runoff and a municipal runoff, nutrient pollution becomes just so bad, that's a policy problem. 20:31 But the combination of warmer temperatures, warmer ambient temperatures and, and therefore warmer water and nutrient runoff is creating perfect conditions for cyanobacteria, which will kill you. 20:44 Um, and then blooms themselves are pr- highly problematic for drinking water supplies and people's land values that live next to lakes or recreation on lakes. 20:54 The lake industry in the next decade is facing massive problems relating to harmful algal blooms. Depends who you ask in water, but like a... That lake management generally falls outside of the, the water industry. 21:07 It's more climate. It feels almost more utility or ecosystem management rather than technology. 21:14 A lake is just a lake, a lake, but there's so many technologies that are involved in the testing and monitoring of lakes, buoys and sensors and probes. 21:24 There's just tons of companies doing that, and then on the remediation side, you've got chemistry, you've got biology, you've got probiotics, you've got earthworks, you've got dredging, you've got mechanical solutions like aeration and oxygenation, and you've got ultrasonic. 21:38 There's just, there's hundreds of deals out there a year helping manage lakes. And then you've got wetlands and mangroves and coastal marine and intercoastal waterways. 21:49 It's a massive industry that is on the forefront right up there with agriculture of a changing climate, and the economic hardship that will come from impaired lakes, the h- public health and safety problems will come from impaired lakes. 22:01 There's economic development problems. A lot of businesses are tied to the lake, whether it's recreation or fishing or whatever. So those are just two examples, so tides and lake management. 22:12 With our framing of water problems through SDG 13 and climate adaptation technology, it enables us to go deep into Earth observation and satellite and geospatial stuff. 22:24 It enables us to go into things, technologies that are traditionally outside of what most of your audience would think of as the water industry. 22:31 So that's enabled us to see more deals and be more creative in our architec- fund architecture, which allows some balance and some diversification across markets and industries and geographies. 22:43 Is there a sense that these sub-sectors of the water vertical have been under-invested in, and having this climate lens applied to them may actually mean that they get the resources and attention they need to really provide the solutions that will head off these harmful algal blooms and other climate-induced disasters- Yep... 22:58 that are on the way? Excellent question, and I would point towards desalination being the poster child for exactly what you're asking about. Desal has not received enough money. 23:06 The membrane industry generates pretty darn good membranes, and the construction and building of, of, of desal plants are... 23:13 It will continue to move at a good clip, but it's not nearly enough, and it's still too expensive to build a desal plant because it's the water industry. 23:20 And climate checkbooks are like, "We're not investing in water, John. We're investing in electric lawnmowers and scooters and e-bikes because we've got to solve the climate problem. We're not doing water." 23:32 And so we're like, "Yeah, but assuming that we don't win the war on carbon and the Earth or the pla- planet warms, we're, we're gonna need to address water scarcity in certain parts of the world, and that very much is a climate problem. 23:42 It's, it's water within climate." And they're like, "Oh, I never thought about it that way before. So where's my checkbook?" 23:49 So by putting water scarcity solutions, so it could be desal, it could be water reuse and recycling, could be atmospheric water generation, even fog harvesting to get water. We've seen some stuff. 24:01 Now, with our framing of, of those within climate should be easier for climate checkbooks to participate in 'cause they're climate tech. 24:11 The money behind climate funds is for climate.And if you say decel, they're like, "We can't do water, we can only do climate." Yeah, but decel is climate, just not on the decarb side. It's on the adaptation- Mm-hmm... 24:21 side. They're like, "Oh, then we can do it." It's unlocking checkbooks that otherwise would stay away from water. 24:26 When they hear about water problems, their minds go towards infrastructure investments, public-private partnerships, and the government needs to do something, and project finance, climate finance. 24:36 That's where traditionally adaptations leaders have come from. We need to build more infrastructure. And you mention climate adaptation technology, and they scratch their heads. They're like, "What do you mean? 24:47 We just need to build more seawalls. We need to build more infrastructure. We need the government to fund more projects." 24:52 But, but anyways, get- getting back to your question, our framing of this has, has unlocked climate tech money to get into water scarcity and water flooding problems in a way that they wouldn't have done if it was just seen as the water industry. 25:04 I think this reframing of investments as climate adaptation technology investments is very important, and I, I think it's what's been driving a lot of this work on taxonomies that I've seen this year. 25:15 You've seen the Climate Bonds Initiative come out with a taxonomy. Yeah. You have Tailwind Climate coming out with their own. 25:20 What do you make from your corner of VC world about these efforts, and do you think they're going about the challenge the right way? Yeah. 25:28 I think all, all contributions to the global conversation on adaptation are helpful. We see all of these other, uh, frameworks and taxonomies and guidelines, and we, we can pull something from all of them. 25:38 But ultimately, if you're a, a general partner in a fund, whether you're private equity or, or VC or angel or whatever, y- you've gotta slice and dice your deal flow in a way that makes sense for you, and the money behind you, 25:52 um, we're just focusing the water risk vertical in there. And people can challenge- Mm-hmm... us on that to begin with. But within water risk, we slice it into three buckets. 26:02 Technologies that produce data, so it's earth observation, and it's s- s- field, in situ sensing and monitoring, anything that is producing data, 26:12 high spatially and temporal data on water as it relates to an asset, farm, a city, or whatever. That's the first bucket. And we calculate... So the whole... 26:21 The global market for water risk CAT, we calculate $150 billion a year globally spent on technologies that help industry and society deal with water risk, climate change-induced water risk, 150 billion a year. 26:35 It's a p- pretty crude number. Like, we just came up with it by looking through all these sub-markets and, and putting this together. 26:42 But I'd welcome conversations with anybody who's sizing markets to come up with a different number, but 150 feels about right. 26:50 The first bucket in there is technologies that produce data, raw data, which in and of itself doesn't solve any problems, but, like, the more data you get, better for training algorithms and just high spatial and temporal data, we'll understand what's going on with this side of the asset or that side of this. 27:03 The second bucket is the data science toolbox of analytics, so it's turning data into insights. 27:10 So y- that gets a little bit into consulting, where they're getting data, and they're turning it into insights for the customers, but these are sort of data consumers. 27:18 They're consuming data, and then they're translating it in- into something that... So that's the second bucket. 27:22 And then the third and final one is innovations that actually address the problem physically, so acting on the data and insights to physically do something. 27:30 So it's could be engineering, it could be process, it could be consumables. 27:33 It's earthworks, and it's seawalls, and it's dredging, and it's membranes and filtration and biolog- biological tools and natural infrastructure and constructed wetlands and stuff like that. 27:43 It's physically, uh, uh, doing something to mitigate the, the risk. 27:47 Of the $150 billion spending, most of the money goes on to address that third one, 90 billion a year is on physically protecting myself and my asset against what water quantity and quality problems. 28:01 It's also the hardest to make money in [chuckles] because it's physical with a lot of hardware and consumables, you need the earthworks, like bulldozers and stuff like that. 28:08 The m- uh, our thesis of backing early-stage technology companies that address water risks for industry and society, about 75% of our dry powder will go into what we call see and think, observe and analyze, so data producing and data consuming. 28:23 If you can't measure it, you can't approve it kind of thing. And then 25% will go into physical IP that helps customers deal with whatever's coming. So that's sort of how we see the market. 28:35 And I guess other people can slice and dice it with their own taxonomies, but that's how we see it. And, uh, one final thing on taxonomies is the way we've arrived at this taxonomy is starting with the exits in mind. 28:45 People ask, "What markets are you in?" We're in exit markets. We're VC. Everything we do comes down to a liquidity event in three to five years, exclamation point. 28:54 So when thinking about taxonomies, you gotta figure out where the corporates live and where they're gonna be looking to buy over build 29:04 in their M&A and their inorganic growth strategy, and then private equity guys with all their creative goals, looking to acquire stuff. 29:12 And then let's work our way backwards, and let's figure out a smart way to slice and dice this, so we're right in front of the corporates and the PE guys when they're looking to buy stuff. And the... 29:24 I, I just wanna welcome a conversation with anybody in your audience who wants to get nerdy on exit markets because that's like our North Star for everything we do as a fund. 29:31 We gotta get out of these things at some point. 29:32 [chuckles] I think you've hit on a, a real good point here, which is that taxonomies are designed for different purposes, and everybody has to have a system that works for them, right? 29:42 And ex- I think your exit-focused taxonomy makes great sense for the VC industry. 29:46 It may make less sense for institutional investors trying to package together a series of assets to produce an adaptation bond on, for example, or policymakers trying to allocate funds from the taxpayer. I, I don't... 29:58 Like, I'm not holding my breath for government. We... Actually, my business partner and I are not holding our breath for government to really do anything to unlock more money. 30:05 The private sector will spend money regardless of compliance and regs and you gotta do this, you gotta do that. The private sector will spend money on tools to manage operational and financial and brand risk. 30:21 So of the 150 billion a year-I, I should say the biggest spender is government, 21%, but the second biggest spender is the fire sector, finance, insurance, real estate. 30:30 They're gonna invest in whatever software or hardware, whatever they do, to give them eyes and ears and the ability to see and understand what risks they face as lenders, as policy writers, and then the real estate owners, REITs. 30:44 They're just gonna go out and buy stuff that protects their interest financially. Boom, that's 18% of spending. Second big one is power gen. 30:51 Power gen, 15% of that 150 billion a year, including thermoelectric power and hydro spent on covering their asses, pardon my French. 30:58 Then you get into logistics and transportation, 11% of the 150 billion per our calculations that are, we admittedly or admittedly crude. 11% of the 150 billion is spent by ports, harbors, marinas, anybody managing roads, 31:13 um, and airlines and Amazon for trucks, like they wanna understand how our new climate reality, especially relating to precipitation when it comes to transportation and sea level rise for ports, harbors and marinas, will constrain them in the next decade. 31:28 So they're getting, producing more data, more analytics, more modeling. Another big one is heavy and light industry, 14% of the 150 billion. 31:35 Mineral processing, manufacturing, refining, all face water risks going forward, and they're all opening up the checkbook to buy tools that help them see and understand how their assets are changing li- with water related problems, analytics around it, and then physically doing something to cover their own ass. 31:53 And agriculture's in there, and who else? Corporate consumers, like 2% of that. A small category for water risk in the 150 billion is actually water and wastewater utilities. 32:03 We calculate that water and wastewater utilities are only 2% of the 150 billion. It surprises the heck out of everybody. They're like, "It's water risk, isn't that all water industry?" 32:10 Water and wastewater utilities will struggle in the, in, with water scarcity and harmful algal blooms and floods. 32:17 Storm surges for coastal utilities are gonna be in big problems, but they don't have the money unfortunately, to really spend on preparing and adjusting and dealing with, unfortunately for them. 32:29 The money's in finance, insurance, real estate, fire sector, power gen, logistics industry. 32:35 So if you're looking at this as a capitalist, you're gonna have a tough time realizing your performance, your, your fund performance by targeting innovations that help water and wastewater utilities. You shouldn't do it. 32:46 If, if your thesis takes you there, then do it, but... So, uh, to answer your question, I, I, I, I don't know what policy, 'cause this is all physical risk we're talking about here. 32:56 It's not compliance and filling out reports and checking the boxes. This is covering your own ass in the next 10 years, and I- instead of sustainability, we just call it survivability. Survive. 33:05 Yeah, we're not holding our breath for government to do anything in the space. People will look after their own behinds, and they will spend money. 33:12 The private sector does a pretty darn good job of getting in front of who they wanna sell to. 33:17 So, uh, for the government to catalyze more solutions around like flood modeling, whatever, if you're a private sector company, you're a founder of a company that wants to make money on selling your climate adaptation technology, whether it's generating data or analyzing data or like physically protecting, you will find your customer and you will get your product in front of them, and you will make money on that or not. 33:38 Yes, o- of course there, it would be good if the government would catalyze things. They should allocate money to more startups. 33:46 But I don't know, it's, it's, it's a two-sided coin because we see a lot of startups that get non-dilutive money from government, and that money kind of perpetuates a bad idea or a company that's not gonna make it, but they get half a million rounds from the government and they're like, "Ah, I'm gonna go after this for two, three more years." 34:02 Some of them do make it, so that grant money does help them get going, and you can point to a lot of successful companies, they'll point to the government m- money they got from the government early on as core to their success. 34:12 But a lot of companies just perpetuate the e- eventual demise of the going out of business. So I don't know, like friend or enemy, government money, grant money. From a VC perspective, it's such a meritocracy. 34:26 The founder either has the vision or they don't. And if they're, if they have a compelling vision, where's my checkbook? 34:32 Even if they're just pure startup and they don't even have a pr- prototype or a product or even a website. Our next check from Mazarin Fund Two is in a company that does not even have a website. 34:41 The founder, she's just rockstar. Within two minutes of talking to her, I was reaching for our checkbook. Her vision of the future was so compelling. 34:53 We're smart enough to know that climate adaptation technology is an investable thesis, but we're not quite smart enough to figure out all the plays. 35:02 There's just loads of nooks and crannies and corners of this that we haven't quite figured out yet, and that's where collaboration and syndication and partnership between checkbooks, it's like, "Hey, we're looking at this. 35:14 What do you think about this? What about that?" Trading notes and generating rapport and camaraderie amongst the climate adaptation checkbooks makes a lot of sense. One last, one last question for you actually. 35:24 I wanna get into the kind of distribution of adaptation opportunities across like the income spectrum, right? 35:29 Because I think it was you who, who turned me onto a, a story about a company that is trying to help ski resorts ensure there's enough snow to service their customers during periods where there's not enough snow, right, which we're seeing more and more because of climate change. 35:44 And that seemed like a very high-end luxury issue, a first world problem as they say. Mm-hmm. 35:49 So at the far end of the income scale for the wealthy, there seems to be a lot of opportunities to invest in adaptation tech for them. 35:55 But then of course, those people who are really grappling with climate impacts are in the developing world and need maybe lower tech solutions, but need help with drought resilient crops. 36:05 They need help with desalination, as we spoke about earlier. So there seems to be like these kind of two extremes, like there's lots of opportunities and probably lucrative opportunities at the very high income end. 36:15 So I'm just wondering what you think about that, 'cause I think it's quite interesting. 36:18 I think the p- the narrative there is that industries or communities in the Global North that have a little bit more financial wherewithal to pay for solutions that give them visibility and control over climate change willBe the first adopters of some of these tools, like for snowpack forecasting or snow forecasting and for ski resorts. 36:38 And by buying that and pulling it through, the companies doing that get a little bit more confidence, and they refine their product more, and the price comes down to the point where now they can do snowpack forecasting in mountain ranges around communities that are down- or for communities that are downstream from the mountains that rely on that spring snowpack for agriculture. 36:58 Had those ski resorts not paid for these tools, the cost would still be prohibitively expensive. But now that the ski resorts, the wealthiest sort of like de-risked it a little bit, now the cost can come down. 37:11 It unlocks that genius solution to be available for more of humanity, which is a good thing. So another area is that, uh, uh, that's similar to this is dese- the saltwater desalination. 37:20 A lot of five-star resorts in, in drier climates have, have been the first adopters of desal 'cause they just want like self-reliance, and they've spent a lot of money on desal solutions. 37:31 Now the cost of desal's coming down thanks to that, yeah, like you said, the luxury, the affluent are, are making things cheaper so that the rest of us can afford them. We like founders 37:42 that have some genius IP around seeing or understanding or doing something around water risk, and they have intentionality around making it more affordable and less complicated for more of humanity to be able to use their genius solution. 37:57 There has to be a QuickBooks-ing of these things. Absolutely has to. Whether it's on the sensing and, and analytics side, or whether it's on the water reuse and recycling, or new to water generation, or flood protection. 38:10 One of the companies we really like in, is in erosion control. The, the founder is in the US, and he's got a better, cheaper, faster way to keep shorelines in place, and that... 38:23 I don't know if that saves lives necessarily if the beach erodes, but it saves livelihoods, 'cause a lot of economies are tied to a beach or tied to a coastline, and if it all flows away because the storm surge is like, that's bad for business, and then people are out of work. 38:39 So when I met him, I was like, "Man, you're in climate adaptation tech." And now he's got the company positioned as he's in climate adaptation, climate action, SDG 13. 38:48 He's helping coastal communities manage their erosion risk, and those communities get it right away. Reaching for their checkbooks like, "We'll take two of them. We'll buy this all day long." 38:58 And the demand is for this kind of QuickBooks-ization, which I li- I like that. I'm gonna steal that phrase for myself. 39:03 He's coming in and being like, "You can use Earth observation satellite," which is f- more or less democratized now. You can really get high-resolution insights on anything for pretty cheap. 39:15 It's like a fraction of what erosion control used to cost 10 or even five years ago. So that's a VC-able company that will exit at high multiples, 39:25 'cause they understand the customer, they understand the need, and because they're better, cheaper, faster, scalable, any community in the world can afford it. 39:32 So that's like really compelling for checkbooks that wanna get into climate adaptation tech to see stuff like that. 39:38 And we'll hope to hear many more stories of s- of similar companies and similar innovations, 'cause I think that's how we'll actually see the adaptation economy grow to, to a scale where many more funds get involved and institutional investors get involved, and we actually get the mobilized investment we need in this space. 39:53 John, you've been very generous with your time. I just wanna finish with a question about what you're focused on over the next six to 12 months, what's got you excited. Yeah. 40:01 We took a break from fundraising for our Fund III, 40:06 but actually that's been a blessing because we've refined things more and we've cultivated some new relationships that will help that Fund III be a high performer, we think. 40:17 So we're planning to restart that sometime in the next few months with some more tailwinds and some more clarity around what we're gonna do, so that's busy with that. 40:27 One interesting area that we didn't see a year ago, and it's, we're seeing now is [clears throat] the amount of woman founders in climate adaptation tech. 40:38 We, and we didn't think of it, and we started going through deal flow, and we were like, "Whoa. Another woman. Whoa, another woman, another woman." Like it's... I, I don't know what it is. 40:46 We can't quite figure out why, but there's a disproportionate amount, number of women who are running companies, startups, early-stage companies, that have some sort of hardware, software innovation that helps their customer deal with whatever's coming, and we didn't see that. 41:01 It's, uh, it's still too low. I think around 25% are woman founders, and that's still too low. 41:08 It, it should be 50/50, but it's higher than we found in the traditional water industry, utilities and industrial water, which is like single digit woman founders. 41:18 And so there's a lot of women who are passionate or dedicated towards leveraging technologies, whether it's chemistry or biology or data science or process engineering or material science, to help humanity deal with our new climate reality. 41:35 That was an interesting trend, so we're gonna be consolidating that focus more. Our, our third and final survey will be focused on the water risk vertical of climate adaptation tech, and it will be focused mostly on 41:47 area we wanna get nerdier into, and we wanna see what everyone thinks about it is the too much water problem. Flooding kills. 41:55 Somewhere around in the order of 150,000 people lose their lives every year because there's like a wall of water coming at them. So when people say water is life, I think those people would probably disagree. 42:08 Water is death. 42:09 And in terms of like taking out real estate and destroying farmland, like too much water, there is no wall big enough to prevent that flood that's coming down the hillside or the landslide that's water induced landslide. 42:23 There's nothing that... All you can do is just understand when and where a wall of water is coming towards this village or this community. You can give some warning. 42:32 Get out of harm's way.And, and that's the really all you... 42:35 I, I, I, I guess you can build some wetlands, and you can build some resiliency in, in the basins to, like, slow storm surges and slow rivers But as an acute risk, it is difficult to, to mitigate against it. 42:47 It's difficult to stop it once it's coming. So all you can really do is, like, leverage the data science toolbox to see and understand where and how water is gonna be coming, and then you can... 42:57 That will inform you where to build some wetlands, where to build some seawalls. But once that water's coming, there's, like, very little you can do to save anybody. 43:04 So we wanna understand from our investor what, what is your appetite for various kinds of solutions, and we wanna park some money in that realm because of financial motivation, but also because it'll save lives. 43:17 And when will that survey drop? Probably within the next month we'll get that one out to our network, and we're, we'd welcome the opportunity to share it. 43:24 And going forward, we'd welcome the opportunity to share insights, um, to whatever degree we're able to develop them, uh, with your audience in this one word of c- in this one c- of, of water risk within climate adaptation tech or just the climate adaptation tech realm itself. 43:38 Like- Mm... fire and heat and wind are super interesting, and we'd welcome an opportunity to find our counterpart, uh, within those worlds and make some, some syndication or some collaboration opportunities. 43:49 I'm sure they're out there. Yes, I feel like there's a number of funds that are focusing on climate tech and are now starting to build out that adaptation focus. 43:57 But yes, whether they'll be focusing on s- specific hazards or specific ecosystems or specific sectors that need climate adaptation, I think you're seeing a real mix. 44:07 But I don't doubt that there'll be more f- people focused on going very deep on particular verticals like you've been doing at Mazarin. 44:13 And yeah, I do encourage my listeners to, to reach out and get in touch, and I'm sure, John, you'd be very thrilled to talk to them. Thank you so much for your time. Have a great weekend. Thanks, Louis. Take care. 44:26 Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 44:36 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]