Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. How are asset managers thinking about adaptation as an investment theme? 0:22 What information do these kinds of investors need to know from companies in order to judge whether they'll sink or swim in a climate-adjusted world? 0:29 And what climate risk blind spots should they watch out for as they build their portfolios? These are important questions, and not all investors are asking them. 0:37 One big exception is Impacts Asset Management, an investment company specializing in opportunities arising out of the climate transition. 0:44 In today's episode, Julie Gort, senior vice president for sustainable investing at Impacts, explains how her firm approaches climate physical risk and reward. 0:54 Julie recently authored a paper on Impact's innovative physical climate risk engagement process with portfolio companies, which is intended to unearth otherwise hidden risks in their value chains and gauge their resilience to climate shocks and disruptions. 1:06 We also talk about investment opportunities in the adaptation space and how climate risks could evolve in the US following the election of Donald Trump. 1:15 Before we get to the conversation, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 1:21 Listeners like you can help support my coverage by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers for the low price of $5 a month or 50 bucks a year. 1:31 Okay, in a moment my chat with Julie, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:37 In finance, it's the second week of COP29, and time is running out for countries to agree on a new collective quantified goal on climate finance, though their efforts may have been given a boost by G20 leaders. 1:47 In Baku, parties are continuing to finesse ideas on how the new goal should be structured, who should pay in, and perhaps most importantly, how large the goal should be. 1:56 A new 25-page draft text circulated on Saturday, while shorter and simpler than Wednesday's 33-page version, still contains a wide range of options and vast amounts of contested language. 2:07 One question over which countries should contribute to the NCQG may have been resolved thousands of miles away from Baku. 2:13 Reuters reports that G20 leaders gathering in Brazil have tentatively agreed to a joint statement that says developing countries may make voluntary contributions to climate finance goals. 2:23 At COP29, one of the fiercest divisions is between rich countries and relatively well-off developing states like China and Saudi Arabia over whether the latter should pay into the NCQG. 2:33 A G20 agreement could end the conflict over this issue and speed up negotiations. 2:38 In policy, efforts to define adaptation progress indicators are advancing at COP29, although parties admit completing the task on time will be challenging. 2:46 Experts have been asked to significantly cut down a list of proposed indicators on the way to producing a, quote, "streamlined and manageable set" by next year's COP in a draft text published on Saturday. 2:57 These indicators are for measuring progress toward the global goal on adaptation, a part of the Paris Agreement aimed at strengthening countries' climate resilience and boosting their adaptive capacity. 3:07 They relate to 11 specific targets defined at last year's COP and include the themes water, food systems, health impacts, and ecosystems and biodiversity, among others. 3:17 The latest draft text on the indicators recognizes that further guidance is required for experts engaged in the technical work of refining and agreeing them. 3:24 And in tech, over 1,000 national governments, tech companies, and NGOs pledged to advance digital technologies for combating climate risks and strengthening disaster preparedness. 3:33 The COP29 declaration on green digital action encourages collective action on high-tech solutions for climate adaptation and mitigation. 3:41 Among the eight objectives included, signatories commit to nurture tech that supports climate resilient communities and enhance climate monitoring and forecasting. Right, that's it for this week's roundup. 3:51 Now on to my conversation with Julie. [upbeat music] Hi, Julie. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. 3:59 I am calling from Arvada, Colorado, which is a suburb of Denver, but in spirit it's more of a suburb of Boulder, Colorado. Uh, I work for Impacts Asset Management. 4:09 I'm senior vice president for sustainable investing, and what I mostly do is connect the dots between sustainability and investment performance or economic performance. Thank you. 4:20 And I've orbited Impacts Asset Management for several years now as a financial journalist, and I'm grateful to you and the Impacts team for speaking to me when I first started Climate Proof earlier this year. 4:30 Uh, your insights have been very helpful, and I'm very happy we can have you on the pod. Happy to be had. You always ask good questions. Well, let's get into those. 4:38 My first one is about Impacts itself and how you incorporate the concepts of adaptation and resilience into your investment approach. So we have always seen climate as a sort of a big bag of risks and opportunities. 4:51 Part of that is transition risks and opportunities, and part of that is adaptation risks and opportunities or sort of physical risk as we think about it. 4:59 So we've been incorporating the concepts into our investment funds for quite some time. 5:04 We regard both adaptation and resilience as part of the transition to a sustainable economy, so we treat physical risk as a real risk even in cases where full manifestation of that risk may not happen immediately. Why? 5:16 Because building resilience is something that can often take years, so it may take several years before this sort of full picture of things like severe convective weather becomes more predictable in the climate models. 5:28 But we know that it's happening and we may not be able to pinpoint where and when, you know, but we see that risk as something that you probably need to p- pay attention to if you're in the Midwest of the United States, and building resilience isn't... 5:40 You can't wait until you start seeing the impacts to start building resilience. That often takes years, and in some cases, decades. 5:46 So as a follow-up from that, I am interested to know what are the kind of metrics or indicators do you look for when it comes to analyzing a portfolio to discern its adaptation-ness, its climate proof-ness? 5:58 So we rank every industry, every sub-industry on several measures of sustainability-related risk and several measures of sustainability-related opportunity.And sometimes those are, you know, it's really easy to do quantitatively. 6:12 I mean, you have more transition risk if you're a big remitter and if you do more operations in countries that have caps or limits or taxes on carbon emissions. I mean, that's relatively straightforward. 6:24 When it comes to physical risk and adaptation, it's more of a judgment call. 6:28 Now, there's a lot of, um, quantitative work that goes into that, so we can, using the climate models, which are in the public domain, figure out what the value at risk is if we know where all your operations are as a company, right? 6:41 That's just one part of the equation. It's... The next part of the equation is, okay, what are you doing about it? Or do you recognize that these risks are-- could affect you? What are you doing to build resilience? 6:51 We have to, you know, depend on companies for that kind of disclosure, and in the end, we just have to make a judgment call on whether we think the company is responding appropriately or is still asleep at the wheel. 7:01 Yes. So like in most areas of financial analysis, there is the quantitative, the hard data, but also like the judgment- Right. -the thesis. You do have to have some imagination- Yep. 7:10 -and some conviction, I suppose, to make bets in this area. Exactly. This is-- It's no different from anything else in finance. 7:16 I mean, even if you're a quant's quant, and you don't even-- you can't even spell the names of the companies you're invested in because you're only looking at the quantitative data, you still have to make choices about how much weight you put on any quantitative variable, and that reflects a judgment call on how important you think that is. 7:32 I'm also interested in how Impacts has come to the theme of adaptation. You are a fund that's focused on these climate factors, but has adaptation kind of risen up the agenda in recent years? 7:43 Have you seen a ramp-up in energy internally? Yeah, well, so with adaptation, I mean, the concern has ramped up quite a lot, and we had a COP that focused pretty much solely on that a f- a couple years ago. 7:54 So the world is getting more conscious of these things. Whether or not something-- Just because it's a good idea to do adaptation doesn't mean that it's always a good investment idea, right? 8:03 So we need to make sure that, you know, we're not making bets that are going counter, that are countervailing the market forces that are pushing things. 8:12 It's kind of like where solar and wind have been for the past two years in the United States. They've been stalled by a number of things, including high interest rates and, and permitting problems. 8:22 So while we believe that we do need to transition to renewables, we don't necessarily see those as being great, all of those companies as being great financial be-bets all the time, right? 8:32 So you have to look not just at do we need to do this, but under what circumstances will this perform well in my por-portfolio and add to value? 8:40 Sorry, I know that sounds like a very sort of technical financial gobbledygook answer, but I mean, the concern over adaptation is doing nothing but going up. 8:49 Whether or not it's a good investment depends on the company, the location, the timing, the market forces, and everything else. 8:55 Yes, that's absolutely fair, and I think it comes to one of the challenges, mobilizing adaptation finance for the private sector, which we'll get into later, is how do you get return on investment for investing in adaptation? 9:06 And in certain sectors of the economy, in certain companies, it's very obvious, and in others it's much less so, and therefore the impetus for private capital is much reduced. Right. 9:15 I suppose the way you find out whether adaptation makes sense is by understanding individual companies- Yeah. -or understanding your portfolio. Yeah. 9:22 And I know that you've been focused on this physical climate risk engagement process with your portfolio companies. Can you share with us the key findings from these engagements? Yes. Any surprises you can speak to? 9:33 Yeah, absolutely. Um, we've been doing this sur-- for nearly five years now. 9:37 So we started engaging with the S&P five hundred companies on physical risk in twenty twenty after we petitioned the SEC to make physical risk information or at least geolocation information mandatory reporting. 9:49 We partnered with two institutional investors or three actually in that process so that we could sort of gain a better understanding. And at first we just started out asking companies, "Well, where are you?" 9:59 Because your physical risk, your value at risk depends at least as much on where you are as what you're doing there, right? 10:05 So if you, you have a distribution center in Raleigh, North Carolina, it's gonna be a whole lot different than if you have one in Tampa, Florida, because you're much more vulnerable to coastal storms and sea level rise and stuff in Tampa. 10:18 So we started with that. 10:20 Then recently we have turned to focusing more on what are you doing to build resilience to these physical risks because companies are becoming more aware of these things, you know, and it's not just about like, where are you, but it's where are all the assets that you depend on that you don't own, right? 10:36 So if you depend on one single port for your entire supply of coffee coming into the United States, if that port is on the Gulf Coast, it's gonna be vulnerable to sea level rise and hurricanes. So it's... 10:47 You may not own it, but it is still a thing, right? So the main thing we found this year, we engaged with electric utilities, and we asked all of them, "Okay, you're... 10:56 every company on Earth is potentially vulnerable to physical risk," 'cause there's no place on Earth that's sheltered from all of them. And what are you doing to prepare? 11:05 Because the infrastructure these companies have is often, especially the transmission and distribution, is spread out over a large area and so could be vulnerable to several things that could happen at once or sequentially or whatever. 11:18 Main thing we found was that companies that haven't lived through an actual climate catastrophe generally have trouble envisioning what it really would look like to have one. 11:27 When we engaged with semiconductor companies on the same issue last year and electric utilities this year, the only companies that we thought had a really good grasp of what those risks look like and are taking concrete steps to build resilience are companies that have already had a climate catastrophe. 11:44 Specifically, in this case, it meant the electric utilities that have already had tens or hundreds of, uh, millions of dollars worth of liabilities added to their books because of a climate-related event are doing really well in preparing for future climate-related events. 11:59 We found some other utilities that didn't really seem to have a clue what was coming at them, right? 12:05 So it's kind of dispiriting in a way for that to be a finding because we don't wanna have to live through these things in order to figure out how to prepare for them because it takes a lot of money to re-- just to recover, not to mention building resilience.So overall, we found very few companies were really at an advanced level of understanding, and even m-among those, e-- the fewer companies were really investing in adaptation at levels that are sufficient to actually create some resilience. 12:31 So it's a little bit of a, what do I wanna call it? A flashing red warning sign, but we still, you know, there's hope springs eternal. You know, there's... 12:40 as we have more of these things, as we have more Helenes and Miltons and wildfires and things like that, or in the Midwest, derechos and tornadoes and things like that, then I think we... 12:50 more and more companies will get the message. It doesn't take... It didn't have to have a billion-dollar disaster in order to be vulnerable. 12:56 It could be a small and moderate event, but if it's in your area, it's gonna affect you. So awareness is growing. That's the positive thing. 13:04 When we first started doing this, there were a lot of companies that went, "Physical risk?" Um, and that was kind of the extent of the conversation. 13:11 Now, you know, at least they've heard of it, so we're making progress, which is not like everything else in climate, we're not making it as fast as we need to. 13:19 But you saying that makes me think that climate resilience is still a reactive process rather than a proactive process. Were there any examples of companies that were taking a proactive approach, though? Well, okay. 13:28 When we did the initial, uh, engagement where we were just asking for geolocation, we found three companies that had really thought about it and had, you know, sort of at least disaster recovery plans. 13:38 I don't remember all three of them, but they were... it was like Walmart and AT&T and somebody else. You know, it wasn't... 13:44 There wasn't an industry theme or any sort of predictive thing that you could say, "Oh, okay, th-this industry is really ready." It was just companies that had people that thought about it back then. 13:54 So yeah, it's a little bit of a, what do I wanna call it? You know, we're, we're catching up to reality. We're not ahead of it yet. Yeah, that sounds right. 14:02 And when I've been analyzing earnings calls from the S&P five hundred, it has been the utilities companies that have been sued into oblivion because of wildfire liability that talk about- Right... 14:13 climate resilience, wildfire mitigation the most, you know. And everyone else seems to give it, uh, lip service unless they've been directly impacted by hurricanes, you know? Yeah. 14:22 That seems to be the one that does get people to pay attention is when a hurricane hits their customer base or hits their actual operations. Yeah, exactly. And we have... 14:29 There are a lot of big box stores that, you know, they're not big emitters. They don't have big, you know, transition risk or anything. 14:35 But a lot of times, even if they, their facilities withstand a big storm or something, maybe their customers can't get to them, or their customers have had an impact, and it's thinking through that. 14:45 And what you do is we're not finding a whole lot of companies that have really given it a ton of thought. Um, but there are some... 14:52 There's also another facet to this physical risk thing that I think we, that we wanna focus on more in the coming years as we continue to engage on this, and that is there are some sort of unique facilities in the world that a lot of capacity depends on, and nobody knows about it. 15:08 So here's an example. 15:10 In Hurricane Helene, there was a high purity quartz mine in a place called Spruce Pine, South Carolina, that was damaged by the storm, and that's like seventy percent of the world's supply of high purity quartz. Right? 15:24 Now, they fixed that. They corrected the damage relatively quickly. But we've seen several examples. COVID was one. That ship that got stuck in the Suez Canal and stopped shipping for several days was another. You... 15:37 We've seen how even short disruptions in supply for a key industry like semiconductors that depend on these materials can really disrupt the industry. So let me just extend that for a second. 15:49 Every port, every seaport in the world is at sea level. They are all gonna be affected by sea level rise. When Hurricane Katrina struck New Orleans, that... the Port of New Orleans had to close for several days. 16:00 That raised U-US food prices by several percent, even just for a few days, right? So what, what are those facilities that everybody's dependent on? 16:09 And we sort of tend not to think about them because we assume they will continue to work. That's another facet of physical risk that I think we need to start really devoting some attention to. 16:19 And a lot of focus has been on getting the data about these weak points or these commonalities that are vulnerable to climate risks, and so I'm interested in your data sources for this because obviously you're doing engagement with your portfolio companies. 16:32 But there has been this big push for more climate risk information to be disclosed by public companies- Right... via the, uh, Task Force for Climate-Related Financial Disclosures. The ISSB- Yep... is another. 16:43 So I'm wondering, like, yeah, where are you getting your data, and what needs to be done so that you actually have a more comprehensive picture of physical climate risk? Yeah. So you can... The... 16:50 As far as getting the value at risk data, all you have to be able to do is run the climate models, and those are in the public sector. So you can run CMIP6. You can get a consultant. You need the asset locations and a... 17:01 In... We have a lot of that information. It's not complete. It would be nice if everybody disclosed the locations of all their key assets. You can get a lot of information on that. That's not a crippling flaw. 17:14 In terms of what the companies are doing to build resilience, that can... really only comes from the company. Okay, so here's what you can do. 17:20 You can look up, you know, the grants programs at DOE's grid program, which is for grid resilience, and see who they've given grants to and for what, right? 17:30 And then you can contact those utilities and saying, "And what are you doing to build resilience with this five hundred million dollars?" That was a real example. That was Hawaiian Electric, right? 17:39 But outside of that, it comes from the company, so we have to rely on them. Would it be nice if that was required reporting? Yes. 17:46 One of the reasons that we got good information from one California utility, PG&E, in case you were wondering, was because California now requires their utilities to do an adaptation plan and disclose it publicly. 17:59 It's called CAVA, and I forget what that stands for. So that was this California PC's action. So the state authorities are making, you know, that information available, and it... 18:11 they're available to everyone and which is useful for investors. But that is California. There are forty-nine other states. So we're still in kind of a bind when it comes to a lot of this information. 18:23 There is more required reporting in things like ISSB and-CSRD and CEE and all of that. For physical risk reporting, none of it is exactly everything we wanna see. 18:34 I'm reminded again how similar the job of a journalist and a investment manager is, or a portfolio manager is, right, when it comes to finding that information, scurrying through the archives, but also like, yes, having to ring up these companies directly and say, "Hey, [chuckles] how, how exactly are you hardening yourself against- Right. 18:50 -wildfires? How are you protecting your supply chains from storm disruptions," et cetera. Right. 18:54 I mean, this is one of those places where, you know, let's say you get a company that isn't interested in talking to you, or doesn't pick up the phone, or doesn't answer your emails or whatever. 19:03 I mean, then now we have AI, right? So if there is anything public, you can probably find it on AI. So there's a lot more assistance that you can get with data gathering these days. 19:12 The problem is that AI doesn't necessarily distinguish speculation from fact, right? 19:18 So I did a search a few weeks ago because I wanted to see how good it was, the AI, just the Copilot thing in Microsoft Edge, and I said, "Is FEMA running out of money for hurricane response?" 19:29 And the AI basically came up and said, "Yes." It's not. 19:33 That's not true, but there was so much rumor and speculation about that that it picked that up, and it couldn't sort of compare that with the federal budget and expenditures and say, "Oh, no. This is not true." 19:46 At least not yet. Yes. Yes. That's a good point. Signal to noise, that ratio's gonna change probably for the adverse, right, with the outpouring of AI. AI is wonderful at gathering information and disseminating it. 20:00 It is also equally wonderful at gathering and disseminating misinformation. Absolutely. Okay. That's for another podcast probably. 20:08 I wanna keep on investor engagements, though, because one thing I've noticed is that it seems like the high watermark of investing, investment engagements on climate issues is kind of behind us. 20:18 There was a big upswing in, uh, proxy votes, uh, shareholder resolutions on mitigation, on disclosure, on also physical risk planning, and that seems to have dropped down a little bit. 20:30 And I know the sort of engagement you're doing is slightly different, but I am interested to know about your thoughts on the kind of shareholder activism that we saw in previous years, if that will apply, uh, again in the context of physical risk, especially as, uh, perils like hurricanes, like wildfires continue to escalate to the US. 20:47 Yes. We have dropped back in terms of shareholder resolutions and in support for shareholder resolutions on proxies in terms of climate change and a lot of other social and environmental issues. 20:57 In part that's because of the sort of backlash to sustainable investing in the last few years. But that's not the sum total of engagement. I would... 21:06 You know, I don't know what the numbers are because you can't ever get them, but a lot of huge investors... You know, what BlackRock will tell you, we try to engage with every company in our portfolio. 21:15 That's thousands of portfolios. They don't file resolutions. So it's, there are a lot of investors, and this is, uh, like all of our investments, with one exception, two actually. 21:25 We only filed two shareholder resolutions in the entire course of our physical risk engagements with companies, but we've engaged with a couple hundred companies. So the engagement goes on. 21:37 It just isn't always gonna be in a way that you can see it or count it. It's gonna be phone calls, mano a mano, right? 21:44 Now, it does-- If you can't file a shareholder resolution, which is a possibility in the future, it's become significantly more difficult. 21:50 It could be more, more difficult as we see, you know, what happens with the SEC in the Trump administration. 21:56 It may be harder to get the attention of companies and engage with them, especially for, you know, small and medium-sized investors. 22:03 For the big ones, they're always gonna be able to pick up the phone and get somebody from investor relations to answer their call. Um, and I think that will probably continue. 22:10 So yes, I c- see that logic there, but I suppose it also means that the companies that I'll be engaged with, there has to be a financial materiality aspect to these engagements, right? 22:19 It can't be, "Okay, we want you to look at resilience just because we want you to look at resilience because we do believe this is financially material to you." 22:27 So there's nothing that prevents an investor from engaging with a company on an issue that may not be material to that company. There's no bar against it. There's nothing that says you can't. 22:38 You know, it's just y- whether you can do it or not depends on the company's willingness to engage with you on that topic. Other things that are material, you know, that's the same story. 22:49 You know, essentially, it's always gonna be about is the company willing to talk to me about this? Even if it's material, they may not want to. That happens. 22:55 There are some big companies that are notorious for not engaging with investors. Yes. Yeah. I forget, like corporations are as varied as, as people. 23:03 Some are gonna be more open, some are gonna be more cloistered, and hard to paint generalities here. 23:08 Okay, I wanna get back to this idea about the kind of investor perspective on adaptation resilience because there's a lot of focus on loss avoidance, the idea that, okay, if you as a company invest in a new supply chain or you invest in hardening your infrastructure, then yes, you might reduce your losses in the event of an extreme weather event. 23:28 However, that's a kind of a less sexy investment thesis, I feel. 23:32 And there's another kind of school of thought that is we need to start investing in companies that are adaptation companies that pro- that provide goods and services, and those goods and services will be in demand to a great degree as climate risk steps up, and those are the companies we should focus on. 23:46 So there seems to be this, like, bifurcation between adaptation as a theme, right? Between, like, loss avoidance and then investing in companies that provide services that can help companies become adaptable. 23:57 Uh, and I'm wondering like, yo, how do you see that space? 23:59 Do you, do you find lots of opportunities in this kind of new concept of adaptation in terms of startups and data companies that providing the services to help other companies adapt? The, the... 24:09 So the flip side of any risk is opportunity, right? So if, when you invest in resilience, you're not gonna create it out of thin air. You're gonna have to buy something in order to make it happen, right? 24:19 So there may be equipment, there may be consulting services, there may be whatever you need. It depends on who you are and what you need to adapt to and what the technologies are for doing that. 24:28 So there's always an opportunity in creating these adaptation solutions. I'll just give you an example that isn't a very good one, butYou know, there are construction companies around the world. 24:38 If you are Miami and you say, "Hey, we're vulnerable to sea level rise, and we're getting flooding at high tides." 24:44 It's not just king tides anymore because the oceans, the thermal expansion of the oceans and sea level rise together mean that we're underwater more often than we used to be. So they wanna build sea walls. We won't... 24:57 We'll skip the discussion of whether-- of how effective sea walls are. Somebody's gotta build that sea wall, right? And somebody's gonna have a business opportunity from that. 25:05 So there's a lot of opportunities in things that you wouldn't necessarily think of. 25:10 So there are opportunities in things like creating crop or seed varieties that are more resistant to drought or salt as the salt line creeps up along the coastlines or to drought as we get-- as the world's gonna be drier. 25:23 There may be opportunities for insurance companies that are willing to work with property managers to create resilience to wildfire, for example, and maybe you can get a lower premium if you do that, or maybe you can get insurance if you do that as opposed to not being able to get insurance. 25:39 We need hardened infrastructure in ports to withstand both severe storms, wind, and mostly water, um, but also to, you know, sort of do things like, you know, find workarounds in the cases where we have flooding and we need to actually still keep a supply chain moving, right? 25:58 So there are companies that can help you do that, logistics companies and so forth, building more resilient infrastructures like roads, electricity, water infrastructure, stuff like that. Lots of opportunities there. 26:09 So it's everything from financials to construction to you name it. You know, if there's a need for adaptation, somebody is gonna find an opportunity in creating the equipment and the knowledge that you need to do it. 26:23 So I take your point there, but one of my concerns is that climate adaptation becomes too broad or fuzzy a theme, and capital wants to go where it can get the best return- Yeah. 26:32 -where there's less friction to get return. 26:34 And one theme I've, I've picked up on this year is that there's a lot of tech software companies that are providing data services to companies to show their physical risk exposure, et cetera. 26:45 And these are all very important, but I'm wondering, do you see maybe an imbalance where a lot of money goes towards the kind of high multiple companies that are providing software services and not enough private money is going towards this kind of like hard tech, hardware, uh, capital intensive stuff- Yeah. 27:00 -which is very important, but might not have a sexy return profile. Well, that's always a risk. I mean, it's... I'll give you another example. 27:06 So physical climate risk, actually the losses are much higher in low and lower middle income count-countries. I'm talking about sovereign risk at this point. 27:16 They tend to experience something like many multiples of the losses that developed countries do, but they have less money to do it, less money to... They have no money to spend on adaptation. 27:27 And at the COPs, we have basically failed to create a global fund that would be sufficient to build adaptation in-- for a lot of these poorer economies. 27:35 So yeah, there may be a lot more capital going to adaptation, but it's, you know, it's going where it goes for the same reason that Willie Horton robbed banks, right? That's where the money is. 27:44 And that's always a risk in finance, always. The people who need something most are not necessarily the people who can afford to pay for it. 27:52 And I think that's why the climate finance discussions going on at COP twenty-nine, the focus is on making sure there's a big public commitment- Right. -to adaptation finance- Yeah. 28:00 -to make sure that this, this blind spot in the private sector is, is covered. Okay. Keeping on the topic of financial markets, actually, I'm wondering where you think the climate adaptation theme can be best captured. 28:11 Is it in developed market equities? Is it sovereign credit? Project finance is a big topic at the moment in the developing world when it comes to climate resilient infrastructure. 28:20 Uh, where do you think this can be best expressed, climate adaptation? I'm not sure I could pick a best. I think there are opportunities in all the asset classes. 28:27 I mean, we've seen them for us, it's mostly in public equities. We also do publicly listed debt. So here's an example, right? 28:34 If a municipality issues a bond in the muni market to create defenses against coastal flooding, you know, that's-- there's an opportunity in the muni market, right? 28:45 So there's sovereign debt that needs to be addressed, private. It's all in play. I don't think there's any best asset class. I think there are good and bad ideas in all asset classes. Yes. 28:57 I think it's interesting when I read the academic papers on this, there's a lot of focus on sovereign at the moment and sovereign credit and sovereign finance for adaptation. 29:05 Obviously a big deal in the concept of COP twenty-nine. But there is, I feel, some more investors in the developed world who are trying to find equity instruments that can express the adaptation opportunity. 29:17 So companies, midcap companies that are providing, uh, you know, reinforced glass, reinforced roofing for communities in Florida or in the hurricane paths on the, on the East Coast of the US, companies that are providing insurance services that can speak to climate, climate risk. 29:33 So there does seem to be some thought leadership in different asset classes taking place right now, which I think is... We didn't see a few years ago. Yes, true. 29:40 I think this is a developing market, and so we would see more ideas coming up in project finance and private finance, private equity, which is great. You know, that's not what we do primarily. 29:51 Um, so we're more familiar with publicly listed debt and equity, but we know that there are opportunities in those markets. 29:57 I think there's the need out there where right now there it's tough to find an asset class that will address it. 30:02 So we just had this one call with an insurance company, and they were talking about their view of wildfire risk, which they think is actually the sort of the big, the hundred pound gorilla, you know, in the sort of current adaptation landscape. 30:15 So one of the entities that could actually do the most to create resilience are communities. So these little towns in California or big cities in California can do a lot to improve resilience of structures and buildings. 30:29 But, you know, it's what makes you do that as a community? You always have more things to spend money on than you have money to spend, right? That's a characteristic of community finance. 30:41 You need someone who is aware of the risk and is prepared to sort of spend money proactively on something that hasn't happened yet, which is, there are some voters with whom that will never be popular if you're doing a bond issue and floating that as a proposition on your ballot.And some of the things that you have to do in a community to create resilience are things like keeping vegetation from being close to buildings because that's the fuel ladder that fires use to get to buildings, right? 31:08 So if you have a lot of trees in your city, then you basically have a lot of fuel that you can ignite, and that will burn down the structures in your city. 31:15 So getting rid of all the trees in a city is not a popular option, right? So a lot of the things that you have to do to create resilience are, you know, things that don't come with sort of unmitigated good. 31:25 They are trade-offs. And, and right now, there's no real mechanism at the community level to sort of build awareness of the measures that they can take for resilience depending on what physical risk they face. 31:38 So there's a gap, and we need finance to try to... You know, we need ways to bring in private finance if we want to address that gap in a systematic and sufficient way to really make more communities resilient. 31:50 Right now, nobody's coming into those markets that we can see. Might be happening- Mm-hmm. And we might just not be seeing it, but we're not seeing a big movement. The trade-offs aspect is important, right? 32:01 I was speaking to Nikita Devlin, who founded a parametric insurance startup, and she was talking about community-based resilience, just what you're saying. 32:10 And there's-- they're in communications with municipalities about having a community-wide, a town-wide, a city-wide parametric insurance product, and then that's being paid out of like taxation. 32:22 But that also means that the utility bills for local residents may be lower because they will have to spend less on recovery because the parametric insurance will come and help out. 32:31 So there are-- I think there are ways to kind of finesse it so that there are incentives for communities to want- Yeah. investments in resilience. 32:38 Uh, but that is a lot of bureaucracy, a lot of structuring, and yeah, how that actually feeds into then investable products I think is a bit challenging. And I... You know, I would just... 32:48 A little thought experiment, you know, call any town manager in the United States and ask them about parametric insurance, and I would bet my house that ninety percent of them will say, "What?" 32:57 We need awareness building. Okay. Last question then. We are speaking on the thirteenth of November. It's over a week since the el-election in the US. 33:07 I was wondering, have you thought much about how climate risks could evolve over the medium to long term in the, in the wake of the US election, and I suppose the other elections that have happened this year? 33:16 There was a lot of elections this year. How are you thinking about the path of climate risk in, in the near future? Yeah. 33:21 So policy is one of the factors that plays into the investment attractiveness of sustainability writ large or adaptation, but it's not the only one. 33:33 So yes, we know that Trump is probably gonna pull out of COP sixteen, and we know that they will-- they're-- he'll probably try to roll back a lot of Biden's, uh, rules on environment. Um, he may want to either 33:48 spend less money through IRA on certain of the provisions in the IRA. There's not dedicated funding for tax credits, but you can write the rules so that nobody can qualify for the tax credit. 33:58 So he can do that witha-with nothing from Congress. It's unlikely that he'll actually do a... Try to repeal it, we don't think. 34:04 There's a lot of things that Republicans actually like about the IRA, but I think it's gonna get smaller. So a lot of those things, you know, we can anticipate, but we also need to understand that the US is one country. 34:18 There are a hundred and ninety-five others in the world, most of whom are interested in doing something positive to mitigate climate risk. So there's a lot of other policy drivers in the world. 34:30 So for US companies that are thinking, "Okay, I don't have to worry about mitigation and adaptation anymore," if you're doing business in France, you probably should worry about those things, right? 34:38 Or the UK or Europe or even Hong Kong, anywhere else. And then policy isn't the only thing that drives investment performance. Technology also does. 34:47 So if we keep increasing the efficiency of solar panels, they will get more and more affordable no matter how high the tariffs are that we put on solar panels from China, right? 34:57 So there are-- We can anticipate certain sort of more headwinds for a lot of renewables and sustainability ideas under Trump, but none of it is gonna paralyze progress. 35:08 We do think that there are still strong drivers for sustainability, and that will manifest itself in portfolios in a lot of different ways, depending on what your portfolio is about. So we have a water fund, for example. 35:20 You know, there's gonna continue to be... In a drier world, everybody's gonna wanna have a lower water footprint, manage water more efficiently, pay less for moving it around, um, stuff like that. 35:31 So companies that do better water processing or better pumps, pipes, and filtration, they're still gonna be attractive, even if we see setbacks to certain rules under the Clean Water Act in the US. Yes. 35:44 Demand, supply factors won't be completely overhauled because of a change in who's in the White House. I do wonder, in fact, whether the adaptation and resilience theme may be more insulated from policy shifts. 35:57 I noticed last time Trump was in office, uh, the Treasury put out a report on risks to financial stability, and they spoke about natural disaster risk. Right. 36:05 And the language was exactly the same as the language used in connection with physical climate risk. It was just called something different. 36:10 And I think natural disaster mitigation, recovery, they can be sort of depoliticized because it's not linked to emissions reduction. It's not linked to the idea of anthropogenic warming. 36:20 It's linked to the idea of there was a disaster, we need to be resilient to these disasters. Yeah. So do you think there might be less pressure on the adaptation economy under a Trump administration? 36:27 No, I think it's gonna go up. I mean, we're-- So what was it? We used to have, like, three billion dollar climate disasters a year on average in the nineteen eighties, and now it's over twenty. 36:38 And that's just in the US, and those were deflated dollars, so it's... You know, the basis of comparison isn't-- The inflation doesn't account for any of that. 36:46 So anytime one of these disasters happens, it's gonna be in the news for a while, and if you don't have the capacity to respond adequately to that, at least for recovery, that's gonna be a political issue for everybody, right?The other thing we're seeing is that a lot of... 37:02 in a lot of states, they have these fair plans because there are certain kinds of property and casualty insurance that are becoming too expensive for people to afford. So Florida is the poster child for that. 37:15 So the Florida Fair Plan, homeowners that could get the subsidized insurance, they can still buy insurance. It's, uh, for property and casualty. 37:23 It's costs a lot more than it used to, even in Florida, but it's still subsidized. If they had to pay market prices for it, it would be far more expensive than it is. 37:31 The contingent liabilities of Florida's fair plan exceed the size of the state budget of Florida. 37:38 So let's say that Florida gets four hurricanes in a year or a fire and a bunch of hurricanes or a bunch of whatever it is, right? If they go bust, if that sort of bankrupts the state fair plan, the payouts from that, 37:52 is the federal government really prepared to let the state of Florida default on its debt? I would say that's a big no. So it's gonna affect everybody in the end. And I... 38:04 You know, the more we put into the atmosphere, the more of these things we're gonna have, period, end of report. We already know that. 38:11 So I don't think it's gonna get any less prevalent, and it gets political very fast, and it can in any administration. 38:19 So Biden administration probably got tarred with the brush that said FEMA has run out of funds for, you know, hurri- responding to hurricane disasters. 38:28 That was because of a lot of misinformation put out in the w- in the wake of Hurricane Helene. 38:33 But that myth took hold, and FEMA workers were actually being attacked, you know, when they went to communities because there's a lot of misinformation about what they would do. That can then... 38:44 Did that play a part in the election? I don't know. Right? Could it, if it happened more frequently and in more places? Yeah, it could. So I don't see it... I mean, yes, it is less political in a sense than mitigation. 38:56 We already know that that's not gonna be in favor in the next administration. Adaptation depends on how good the recovery systems are, but recovery and adaptation are not the same. 39:08 So you may be able to afford to help people recover and rebuild their houses right in the floodplain where they just got flooded, right? 39:17 It's smarter to do, you know, something that either makes those houses more resilient to flooding or puts them somewhere else. Um, will that happen? I don't know. Yeah. 39:26 Thinking about it, I do think there is some interesting intersections between conservative political ideology and adaptation, right? 39:33 Because if, for example, the federal government retreats somewhat from disaster recovery and adaptation, if FEMA, for example, rolls back, if the DOE doesn't do more of these kind of grid resilience grants, there's more pressure on state and local governments. 39:46 Maybe they'll start investing more proactively in adaptation because they know they won't get the same sort of recovery funds they used to get from FEMA. 39:52 Maybe politicians will also kind of push individuals to take more adaptation measures themselves. The, the doctrine of individual responsibility might, might take hold. 40:00 And I, I still believe that that's a problem because no matter all the adaptation you do, you know that certain tail events can just wipe out all your adaptation measures, and you'll still be screwed. 40:10 So I, I don't think that's brilliant, but I do think interestingly, the incentives might switch so that local and municipal governments in, in, in certain states might be more incentivized to invest in adaptation economy. 40:20 That is a very possible outcome. We'll have to see. 40:22 I don't know, you know, what that's gonna look like, but I also know, and we all know this from just looking at any election, when people are unhappy, they tend to blame the people who have power now, whether that's corporate power or political power. 40:36 So a lot of the sort of the pain of COVID, you know, which didn't start in the Biden administration, was in fact came to roost. 40:44 And Biden, a lot of people, the unhappiness over COVID and the responses to it and everything also came home to sort of sit in the Biden administration. 40:52 We saw that, you know, the, what was it, the two thousand eight or '09 recession, which actually started in the Bush administration, that haunted Obama's first administration for all [chuckles] five years. 41:02 You know, that was a long recovery period. You know, yes, I think there would be more pressure on, you know, politicians at every level, local, national, regional, you name it, village, whatever. I think that could... 41:13 that's a very possible outcome. Will that result in positive things like more funding for adaptation or more interest in adaptation, or will it, you know... I mean, it could really easily get ugly too and not be helpful. 41:27 Just evolve into a blame game. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, let's say you throw out, you know, the town manager because you just had a disaster, and the town didn't have enough funds to respond to it. 41:35 That town manager might have been much more interested in adaptation than the person you voted into office. Very true. I hadn't thought about it that way. 41:42 Yes, there's the intersection of political, economic, and yeah, I suppose just very emotional responses- Yeah... to disasters- It's like I'm not happy... 41:50 that can go against- I'm voting against this guy 'cause this happened in his, on his watch. Well, I'd love to be able to sit with you and go over this crystal ball on prognosticating the future, Julie, for, for hours. 42:02 I'm sure we should do that one day when I come to see you in person. Uh, but I feel like we've come to the end of our interview time here. 42:07 You've been great providing insights on how it impacts things about adaptation and resilience, uh, providing the perspective on engaging with companies and building portfolios. So thank you very much for your time. 42:18 Lovely having you on the pod, and I hope we speak soon. It is always fun talking with you. Thanks for asking me. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. 42:27 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodhill. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 42:35 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]