Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodhill, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. 0:18 Today, we're joined by Michael Berkowitz, the executive director of the Climate Resilience Academy, a unit of the University of Miami. 0:25 It's focused on interdisciplinary research and education that addresses climate change impacts. Michael has been working at the forefront of building resilience for years. 0:33 Notably, he helped shape and oversee the 100 Resilient Cities initiative with The Rockefeller Foundation, an effort to harden cities against physical, social, and economic challenges, including those related to climate change. 0:44 Today, he describes the concept of the, quote, "resilience dividend" and how it could help climate proofing policy and financing. 0:51 We also talk about Miami itself as a hub of climate resilience innovation and the ongoing challenge of personalizing climate risk information. 0:59 Before we get started, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber supported productions. 1:04 Listeners like you can help support my coverage of climate adaptation and resilience by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. 1:13 Okay, in a moment, my conversation with Michael, but first let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:20 [whooshing sound] In finance, UN member states remain deadlocked on a new global climate finance target. 1:25 An update on the new collective quantified goal on climate finance negotiations, published on August twenty-ninth, highlights seven competing options for a deal. 1:34 They differ on the quantum of finance to be provided, the makeup of contributors, and the division of finance across climate mitigation, adaptation, and loss and damage objectives. 1:44 While some options float dedicated targets for adaptation finance, others do not. Arab, Latin American, African, and Caribbean countries are in favor of a balance between mitigation and adaptation objectives. 1:55 African countries also support grant and concessional finance for adaptation and loss and damage. 2:00 [whooshing sound] In policy, UN Secretary General António Guterres has warned about the dangers of rising seas to island communities and coastal cities. 2:09 While at the Pacific Islands Forum in Tonga, he said surging seas are coming for us all and called on global leaders to, quote, "massively boost climate adaptation investments to protect people from present and future risks." 2:21 The speech came against the backdrop of two separate UN supports, one on the state of the climate in Southwest Pacific and another summarizing the latest science on sea level rise risks. 2:30 [whooshing sound] And in tech, the UK has set up a new floods and droughts research infrastructure that will leverage advanced river monitoring sensors and enhanced computer models to improve the country's understanding of extreme weather events and help craft resilience and adaptation responses. 2:45 The forty million pound effort should also produce insights that help local authorities and the UK Environment Agency in developing effective protections, early warning systems, and damage mitigation measures. 2:56 [whooshing sound] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Michael. [upbeat music] Hi, Michael, where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Yeah. 3:06 So, uh, Michael Berkowitz, and I'm calling from Coral Gables, Florida. It's in Miami-Dade County in South Florida, where the University of Miami is. 3:17 I am the executive director of the university's Climate Resilience Academy, which is a university-wide institute devoted to connecting all of the work the university does around climate resilience in interdisciplinary ways and to the communities on the front lines of climate change that need that innovation the most. 3:35 Thanks for joining us today, Michael. I really appreciate your time. So I wanna get into this topic of the resilience dividend. 3:42 It's a concept that you actually introduced me to, and I was wondering if you could explain this for our listeners and provide maybe some examples of resilience actions that provide this kind of dividend. Yeah. 3:52 So the resilience dividend as a term, I think, was coined by Judy Rodin in her book of the same name, I don't know, maybe about 10 years ago now. 4:03 And it's the concept that you might take actions for one primary purpose but also build resilience, community resilience or urban resilience across a couple of other areas. 4:19 It's very similar to, you might hear the term multi-use infrastructure or triple bottom line. It's very similar to those things, but it's obviously framed around resilience. 4:32 And examples of that, the easiest examples, uh, to cite around that are around nature-based solutions. So just think about street trees. 4:41 You might plant street trees, and we're seeing this effort all over the world and aggressively in the US to plant more trees, and largely that's around reducing the urban heat island. 4:53 But trees also capture storm water, so they reduce flooding. They improve chronic health, and we're seeing more and more evidence of that. They improve mental health. 5:04 There's evidence to suggest they improve cognition with children who have access to greenery learning better. 5:11 There are all these other benefits, and all those other things make communities more sustainable, equitable, healthy, resilient, and better able to survive the next disaster, whatever that is, and that's the dividend. 5:26 You do it for one reason, heat, but you make communities stronger across all these other areas, and that makes them more resilient. 5:35 I like the concept a lot, and I imagine policymakers and businesses like it as well because the idea of multiple benefits from one stream of actions, of course, is attractive. 5:45 So I'm actually wondering whether this resilience dividend language, has it been useful in your experience engaging communities, power brokers, policy makers in the idea of resilience? Is it... 5:56 Does it open more doors than, uh, otherwise would have been closed if you'd said, "Oh, I just need to talk about climate with you today"?I- in some ways it is, in other ways it's not. 6:05 In, in the ways that it is, as a concept, high level, it's pithy, and everyone likes dividends. Like, it, it's [laughs] I've never heard dividends... We, we could talk about this maybe. 6:17 Has dividend ever been used in a negative way? It's just uniformly positive. And so in that way, people get it. 6:24 But what makes it hard is that those dividends accrue across a number of different sectors and silos, and it becomes like all things to all people. It's just too spread out. 6:40 It's easier if you have someone who's responsible for urban heat, like a chief heat officer or s- or something like that, and their targets are reducing daytime and nighttime temperatures in the urban heat island. 6:53 And that's like an easy thing. But then trying to bring in all these other functions, all of those things are handled by different departments. And so capturing that dividend, I think has been more challenging than it... 7:08 you, you might think, given how it resonates in many ways with folks. Yes. 7:13 I suppose if the benefits spill across multiple areas, but also the responsibility for enacting resilience spills across areas, then you have turf war instincts kicking in, and you want to be able to, as chief heat officer, take credit or, or take responsibility for these cooling technologies or these street trees projects. 7:31 But some of the other benefits that accrue to that might want to be taken by other, other departments. So I understand- Yeah... that's a, that's a tension. 7:38 And also there's this question about how can you actually monetize this? Dividend is usually talked about in terms of financial dividend, right? And we're talking here about societal and public goods as a dividend. 7:49 But I'm wondering, in order to build proper support for, for these resilience actions, maybe you need to find ways to, to monetize them. 7:55 So can you talk about how you're trying to intersect the resilience dividend with actual financial dividends? Let me come back to monetizing in a second. 8:02 But, but the other thought about just the reason why we think about primary outcomes and outputs from interventions is also driven by funders. 8:14 Funders have targets for the things that they want their funding to accomplish, and very rarely does it span all of those things, reduced heat, reduced flooding, improved health, improved mental health, improved cognition. 8:29 Funders rarely care about all those targets. And so partly it's how we're architected at the community or city level, and partly it's about how we're architected at the funder level. 8:42 And so there's very rarely funding for something so broad. So that is one reason why this problem continues to exist. 8:50 How we're thinking about monetizing the dividend, a lot of my thinking has to do right now with innovative financing mechanisms, something like a social impact bond. 9:01 A sort of basic example is we have researchers at the University of Miami working with others who have found that street trees in Miami reduce diabetes and hypertension by 15% and 14% respectively. 9:15 That's a massive benefit to society, and that should provide more than enough money to have a tree in front of every single house in the entire county and do maintenance on it [laughs] and, and replant if, if and when they, uh, die or, you know, knocked over or whatever. 9:35 It's hard to capture that because of what we privatize and what we sh- socialize in society. 9:40 But one way you could think about a structure that might do this is you have investors put up money to plant trees in communities. 9:49 You have a community-based organization work with the community to actually do the planting, and there's probably a dividend in there too, because you're building community bonds, empowering community leaders, strengthening community cohesion. 10:04 You have the trees that reduce disease. You need an independent monitoring organization to confirm that these trees have been planted. 10:14 And you work with health insurers that receive a reduction in cost because of the benefits of this to then repay investors. 10:23 And you have the benefits of getting private capital into something that has been traditionally either philanthropically funded or publicly funded, and you start to create an ongoing revenue source to d- continue to do more street improvements that lead to these kind of outcomes. 10:39 And we really haven't seen that at that level now. We've seen other kinds of social impact bonds, but we haven't seen it at the community resilience level that I'm aware of. 10:49 That's a exciting structure, but just hearing you talk about it, one thing I'm worried about is how do you do the attribution? 10:56 As you said, there are these studies that show the beneficial effects on diabetes and hypertension, but how can you actually segment out that benefit and say, "This is because of the trees," rather than, "This is because of another health initiative that the city of Miami has been doing"? 11:09 How can we better attribute climate resilience efforts to health outcomes, social outcomes, like the ones you mentioned? 11:16 So there are a bunch of organizations that are trying to better capture the, the value of urban greenery, and one way that researchers are thinking about it is retroactive studies that use large data sets from insurers 11:32 and look at the, uh, planting of large scale urban greenery initiatives like New York City's Million Trees campaign. And so when you can correlate those two and look at over some years... 11:49 Now, New York's Million Trees campaign started in the Bloomberg administration, so it's, I don't know, um, 15, 20 years old now. 11:56 You can start to s- you, you start to see the impact, and you can correlate that with healthData from insurers and other providers. And that's the way you do that correlation. And there's an emerging... 12:09 like, it's not just one isolated study. I mentioned the University of Miami study because those are colleagues and they're here. 12:16 But, um, there's a, a, a great wave of new evidence of the benefit of greenery, and I think that's... we- we'll keep trying to better attribute it in ways that will make this kind of financing possible. 12:32 And could you see this model being extended to non-nature-based solutions? We've been reading a lot, uh, in the press about cooling centers, the need for shaded areas in urban spaces. 12:43 Talking about New York, I believe New York is trying to roll out increased shaded bus stops so that people who are waiting to commute are, are sheltered from the heat. 12:51 Could you see this model being applied to climate tech or artificial solutions rather than nature-made solutions? Yeah. I think... So a- an example is if you think about something like the Rotterdam water parks. 13:05 So the Rotterdam water parks are structures that look like sunken soccer, five-a-side soccer pitch. 13:13 But what they do is collect rainwater, reduce the pressure on the w- drainage and storm water systems during flooding times. 13:22 And they hold that rainwater, thousands of gallons of rainwater, until the system has the capacity and then it gets released. But the Dutch have also built in all these other aspects of it. It's community theater. 13:37 There's some programming there. There's the five-a-side soccer pitch, as we talked about, a basketball court. So you get healthier, more engaged, more comm- con- cohesive communities. 13:47 And you could think about that in that way as well. The other thing to say is that I said at the top that I've never heard dividend used in a negative way. 13:56 But you could think about if you can better price these kind of externalities, negative externalities of infrastructure, you might be able to discourage ill-advised projects. 14:09 So think about the Cross Bronx Expressway in New York. In some ways, its primary purpose was to transport cars from one side of the Bronx to the other side of the Bronx. 14:19 And by all accounts, for the last, I don't know, 80 years or something, it's done that pretty well. 14:25 Through snowstorms and terrorist attack and heat waves, blackouts, riots, the Cross Bronx has keep ferrying cars back and forth. But what it did is it created areas of isolation and downward mobility. 14:41 There's huge numbers of respiratory disease on either side and lots of other negative dividends, if you use that terminology. And the Cross Bronx is just one example. 14:54 You could go around the country, in fact, around the world, and see a- aspects of this in, in cities all over the world. 15:01 And so if we have a better understanding of what those impacts are going to be, we'll be able to make better decisions and maybe even monetize them, either the positive benefits or the negative benefits. 15:14 And that's somewhere where big data, AI, VR also may all play a role if in our planning process, if we're better able to understand all of these externalities. If... 15:27 In VR, we're thinking about how we might visualize these externalities, right? 15:31 And when you start to put the two together, is it possible that we will lear- have a sort of better, more informed, more visualized, uh, more engaged with community kind of urban planning that gets us to build more things like street trees and Rotterdam water parks and less things like the Cross Bronx Expressway. 15:51 And that's really the struggle that we're in right now. 15:54 I'm always interested in ways in which tech, and especially AI, could be used to promote resilience, and you mentioning virtual reality there, that's a first for me. 16:02 Are you thinking about maybe putting virtual reality headsets on, on the heads of city council members and policymakers and asking them to see what a potential project would actually look like and what the actual negative impacts could be? 16:14 Is, is that what you're thinking? Yeah. We, we actually... we've been working with a couple of researchers here who are already working, uh, at, at University of Miami, who are also are already in the VR, AR space. 16:26 And they're putting together a grant proposal right now for something like that. 16:30 The, the, the way they've been framing it has been around giving community members the power to play around with different kinds of interventions and, and, and using it as a kind of community engagement tool. 16:44 But Louis, you're right. 16:45 You could flip that around and make it a tool for city council and decision-makers, business people, nonprofit leaders, all of these folks to say, "Oh, what would happen if we put a green belt here or have some sort of bike trail?" 17:01 We have this amazing piece of infrastructure in Miami called The Underline, which is just now starting to connect communities in, in, in different ways. 17:10 I think the ability to really imagine what a future is hopefully will be made much more real by new kinds of technology like VR and AR. 17:19 Yes, I like the idea of it being a community tool, but I s- feel as a way to hammer home the potential consequences of infrastructure projects that are approved by city council members, by politicians at other levels of government. 17:32 It could also be very effective. So I look forward to following that s- train of research and seeing where it takes us. Okay. 17:39 You've mentioned Miami a number of times now, and of course you are at the Climate Resilience Academy at the University of Miami. 17:46 I was hoping you could tell us a little bit more about that academy and how it started, and then also other initiatives that are centered in Miami that are focused on adaptation and resilience. 17:56 I've actually spoken to a number of people who are based in that part of the world, and it does seem to be a hotbed of climate resilience and adaptation tech research and investment. 18:04 So maybe you could talk to why that is. Yeah. The university got a grant, an endowment actually from an entrepreneur here named Eric Levin, and he... his endowment helped catalyze this new unit at the university. 18:21 It will be an institute, um, so it's the Climate Resilience Academy, an institute at the University of Miami. 18:26 And as I said at the top, its mission is to connect the university in interdisciplinary ways around climate resilience. 18:33 So think about architecture, engineering, marine a- and biologists working on coastalInfrastructure and new kinds of nature-based solutions, and business folks trying to think about capturing the dividend. 18:49 Traditionally, all of those activities would largely happen in disciplinary silos. Universities are incredibly siloed. At that... 18:58 Some of that's changing, and actually because their research funders, like the NSF, and NOAA, and others, are demanding more integrated proposals. 19:07 And so there-- I think there was a thought that w-we could really make ourselves much more competitive if we're actively working in these integrated communities of practice. 19:18 And so they went on a national search and found me, and here I am. The other mission of the Climate Resilience Academy is also to make this much more applied kind of research and education. 19:32 And so to connect that to the communities on the front lines of climate change that need this innovation the most, and to help the researchers understand what the needs of the communities are. 19:43 It's a two-way kind of cycle. It's, uh, hopefully our vision, and this is h- easier said than done, is to create a kind of virtuous cycle, uh, where innovation scales into communities. Communities also give... 19:55 have a feedback loop to researchers, and we begin to create that. And our vision is to do that really more broadly. If you look at a map of where Miami is, it in some ways is on the periphery of the US. 20:12 But if you look at it in the Western Hemisphere, [chuckles] it's right in the middle of Latin America and the Caribbean, and it is an incredible hub. 20:22 And so our ability to be more influential and integrated and in-involved with the work that's going on, not just in the US, but across Latin America and the Caribbean, is something that we also aspire to. 20:34 And there are lots of examples at the university where this is actually happening. 20:37 And on the needs side, we often think because Miami's at, you know, quote unquote, "ground zero of the climate crisis," it gets, you know, hurricanes and storms, it has sunny day flooding, it has torrential rains, and it's a place where we're getting more and more heat. 20:54 In fact, this is a place where, as the saying goes, heat doesn't come in waves. We get three months of it straight through. 21:02 So there's all of that climate hazard, but there's also lots of other resilience challenges that are here, where the, you know, a city of a d-diaspora populations with many different immigrant groups having settled here over the years who create the culture of this city, thinking about how integration happens. 21:22 We are going to be both a leaver and a receiver kind of ci- uh, city in terms of climate migration. 21:31 People will need to leave dangerous areas of this, of this county, and yet we continue to receive folks who are migrating from Latin America and other places across the world for some, for climate reasons. 21:46 So there's that. And then there's incredible diversity in terms of economics and in terms of political ideology. 21:55 We're both red and blue and purple, and so understanding how climate plays in that environment is all really interesting. So those are all the kind of resilience challenges and opportunities. 22:09 There is a lot of work that's already being done. You mentioned... 22:13 I mentioned, and I think you might have as well, Resilient 305, which is the resilience initiative between the county, the city of Miami Beach, and the city of Miami. 22:23 But there are so many other jurisdictions across the area, including Broward County, who has an incredible CRO. The village of Key Biscayne who has existential challenges that they're working on really seriously. 22:36 Like, there's lots of folks. And the Resilient 305's framing and strategy has really survived over the six or seven years since it was released. 22:48 It's not one of those things that was there because Rockefeller was funding it and then quickly went away. 22:54 It's been something that has been reinvested in by a variety of stakeholders across the county and across the region. 23:01 And the mayor, Daniella Levine Cava, of the county, who was just reelected, has been a, a strong champion. She was a champion when she was the county commissioner, and then she has continued to support it as a mayor. 23:16 And she's one of the... She's my mayor now, so I can say this, but she's one of the really excellent climate leaders of, in may-- of any mayor I've ever seen. 23:26 She has a kind of patience and determination that makes for very good policy and very good outcomes. 23:35 Um, and then of course, when you have consistent impacts from storms and other events, and heat waves, and flooding, and other kinds of events, it... 23:45 You, you just consistently refreshed on the reasons why you're doing this work. And so that helps, I, I think, also build support and momentum. 23:55 That's fascinating, the idea that Miami is a Petri dish of climate hazards, but also it is this hub or this nexus of different cultures and global populations, and therefore it's a crossroads for knowledge transfer and innovation as well. 24:10 And on the economic side, Miami also has great tech companies, it has expertise in advanced manufacturing. Tourism, of course, is a massive industry, and these are all things that could also be affected by climate risks. 24:22 So I was wondering, you talked about the political and the, the research side. 24:25 I wonder on the commercial side, what adaptation and resilience-themed companies or companies that provide these services, even if they don't call themselves climate companies, are you aware of and think are worthy of being, uh, promoted? 24:37 Yeah. We also were awarded a, uh, status as a tech hub by the US Economic Development Agency.And then the EDA followed up with $20 million of a first tranche of funding for some of this work. 24:54 And that tech hub is the one that's called the Climate Ready Tech Hub. It's the only one in the EDA's network of 36 tech hubs across the country that is focused on climate resilience. 25:07 Our goal, both in this hub and at the university, and I think speaking for South Florida more broadly, is that in 10, 15, 20 years, that when you think about climate resilience tech, one of the first places, if not the first place you think about, is Miami. 25:25 That we should, by solving some of the existential issues, the wicked problems that we have here in Miami, should be able to begin to lead the world in climate resilience tech in particular. So you asked about companies. 25:42 So there's l- a bunch of interesting work that's going on in the cement space here in South Florida. 25:50 So Titan America and Titan Florida, and a bunch of startups are working on low carbon negative and high performance kinds of concrete and cement. 26:06 There's a startup called Carbon Limit working on low carbon and carbon negative cement, and as cement's one of the largest emitters of greenhouse gases that the whole... that whole supply chain. 26:18 So being able to change that is, is very important. 26:21 And then from the resilience side, having cement, uh, that holds up better during storms and adverse events and has a longer lifespan are also incredibly important for a region that's situated on a coast that gets lots of storms and coastal hazards. 26:40 Uh, so that's one thing. The second is I, I would say that we are starting to see a new class of coastal protective infrastructure emerging. 26:52 The simplest way to describe that is a sort of hybrid green-gray solutions. 26:59 So in nature-based solutions, which we're getting more and more evidence of how they work to protect coasts, and there's a great Santa Cruz researcher named Mike Beck who's really leading on this, if your listeners are interested in more detail there. 27:16 But the problem with nature-based solutions is that they are effective after a period of time. 27:24 You plant the mangroves or the corals or the seagrass or, or whatever, and over time, those things grow and provide more and more protection, whereas gray infrastructure, like concrete, you put it in the water, [laughs] 27:40 and it, it pr- provides protection immediately. And so the hybrid solutions both give you immediate protection, but also all the ecosystem benefits of nature-based solutions. 27:52 And so there's a, a thing that came from the University of Miami called Seahive. It's a kind of Lego-looking structure, octagonal structure. It can either be casted or 3D printed, and then gets dropped in the water. 28:10 It's very good for holding corals and mangroves depending on where it is, and when you put the two together, you get the benefit. You get... kinda get to your cake and eat it too. 28:21 The other thing that we're seeing, and that this region is really an epicenter for, unsurprisingly, is research around corals. 28:31 And you know that marine heat waves have decimated corals over years, as have dredging operations and other more manmade events. 28:41 And we're being able to grow heat tolerant, even heat resilient corals in a way that is very promising. 28:49 A lot of the progress has been made by a very bespoke kind of nurturing of individual corals, and then you go out and plant them. 29:00 And where the innovation it needs to happen and is beginning to happen, is how do you do that? How can you plant a million corals over the course of a month or something? 29:09 Because that's really what the situation is gonna require. 29:13 And so all of that and some of the tech that's out there, I would say the coral stuff has been led by a researcher at University of Miami, a guy named Andrew Baker. 29:24 Some of the gray-green w- work that I've mentioned before, there is one print is a 3D printer that has licensed Seahive, and they've been most active on helping 3D print and then, you know, deploy some of the Seahive technology. 29:42 There's a, a startup that's gotten a bunch of venture funding, including from Mark Cuban, named Kind Designs. Their product is Living Seawall, and that's for... 29:53 I think it's largely for individual properties, so when property owners need to replace the seawall. This Living Seawall is a sort of biophilic design that then also grows nature-based solutions. 30:06 There's a company called Dune Defender. There's more designs from a outfit called Michael Singler, Singer Studios that's up in Broward. 30:13 So we're starting to see a bunch of different entrants into this, this space, this innovative space of new c- class of infrastructure. 30:23 And I hope that this continues because I think it's something that we can really lead the country, if not the world on, and it's something that will certainly improve resilience both in the water and on land. 30:36 Yes, I like this conception of gray-green structures or innovations, the idea of biophilic design, which is where you have man-made artificial constructs, but try to connect people to their natural spaces or somehow mimic the characteristics of natural... 30:53 products or natural configurations like coral. 30:56 And I'm wondering, yes, that kind of makes resilience and adaptation a little bit more agreeable than vast concrete sea walls or ugly ditches or, yes, big holes dug in the ground to take over storm overflow. 31:08 So there does seem to be almost like a, a branding spin as well that could be attractive to investors and also to, to policymakers. 31:14 It's easier to promote the overhaul of a coastal landscape if you can promise it's not gonna be ugly, man-made brutalist. 31:22 [chuckles] I'm thinking about some of the seaside resorts I used to go to in England, and also the, uh, renovation here in New York of the East River waterfront, which is... 31:30 It's been contentious, but they have created a lovely kind of biophilic space there as well, and I think that's a way to promote adaptation resilience- Yeah... 31:37 without causing the sort of political aggro, the community aggro that could otherwise happen. Yeah. 31:41 And actually on that point, I did wanna ask about what the political, bureaucratic, administrative challenges you see when it comes to embedding adaptation resilience in urban spaces, particularly thinking about coastal and, and ocean projects since you're in Miami. 31:56 Yeah. I- i- in general, I do think that the bureaucracy and the governance challenges are some of the most important issues that we give the least amount of time to in the adaptation and resilience space. 32:11 Because if you think about the most significant projects, the East Side Coastal Resilience project that you just mentioned, that started in Bloomberg, went all the way through the Mayor Bloomberg [chuckles] after Hurricane Sandy, and went all the way through de Blasio, and now is in the administration of Mayor Eric Adams. 32:35 And that kind of timeline across three different administrations really makes it risky to do big, important transformational projects. And that's just one. So that's the temporal element of governance. 32:52 We change political leaders. There's lots of opportunities for a leader to kill that or revise it or send it back to the drawing board or whatever those things are. 33:01 And if we're gonna make the fundamental transformations that our communities need, it... that makes it very hard. And then, of course, there's the spatial heterogeneousness. 33:13 Miami-Dade County has a number of municipalities and a bunch of unincorporated areas, and all of those come with different issues in terms of permitting and zoning and objectives for w- what kinds of resilience and adaptation measures they want to implement. 33:35 And that makes it hard because the things that make South Florida more fragile or more resilient to the next climate shock do not stop at the boundaries of any particular municipality or, for that matter, county. 33:49 And so there are... those governance issues are huge and really important. 33:55 And I- i- in general, I think resilience practitioners and people who are thinking about adaptation would do well to focus more ar- around the governance and try to fix some of those governance systems, but those are hard because they're built into how we govern ourselves generally. 34:10 And they're different not just across the country. 34:13 You know, you think you, you're in a city that has one mayor, five counties, and I'm in a city that has one county with 20-something municipalities, and those are just radically different kinds of environments that you operate in. 34:28 But then you think across the world, even in England, in, in Great Britain, the different kinds of authorities that the mayor of London and Bradford have are totally different. 34:42 And so it just makes doing big transformational things harder because of all these local things. 34:50 So that's the mo- I know you're asking about coastal, and I'll get there, but that's, that's my take on governance more generally, is that it is one of the most important issues. 35:00 Coming to the local context and to the coastal, it is incredibly hard to build novel structures in our waterways, and that makes this innovation around things like gray green biophilic structures all that harder. 35:17 We should start by acknowledging that there are good reasons why we don't just allow people to build whatever the hell they want to in the Biscayne Bay or off the coast of Miami Beach. 35:29 Those things are regulated and w- well-regulated for a reason. Having said that, it does really make it hard for a startup who might be living quarter to quarter in terms of revenue [chuckles] 35:44 to survive in that context. 35:48 And so we've been thinking about ways that we could begin to help this class of innovators and entrepreneurs that are working on new kinds of coastal resilience infrastructure, how we can help them survive and flourish. 36:06 And so this is very early days, so I caveat it with that, but we are thinking about ways that we may do some, like, tactical stuff around helping fund more timely reviews with regulators or identify common data sources that can be used as part of regulatory applications, permitting applications and so on, but there might be larger strategic things. 36:33 One of the big issues is around ownership and liability, uh, and who's gonna take that ownership and liability for some of this big infrastructure, um, that we, you know, are building, uh, to protect the coastline. 36:45 And you might think about a green bank model, a new legal entity that gets capitalized that can both provide funding but also take some of the liability and ownership issues. 36:59 I hesitate to mention this because it is, as I said, very early days, but I, I also think we need to start to think really outside the boxIf we're gonna be able to address some of these issues in ways that lead to the kinds of outcomes that we want, which is innovative infrastructure that provides ecosystem benefits and coastal protection off the South Florida and really a-a-across the country and around the world. 37:25 It always seems to come back to de-risking in one way or the other, right? Financial de-risking or liability de-risking or at least burden-sharing, right? 37:33 And this is why the intersection of government and the private sector is so important, right? 37:37 Because governments can provide the capital and the, the legal protections for innovations to flourish, but there also has to be a sense that if the public sector's doing something, it can't be for nothing, right? 37:48 The private sector also has to weigh in and actually invest and provide those solutions that this public sector infrastructure creates. 37:55 So I think it is an interesting dance that we see between the public and private sectors, but there does need to be some unity of purpose if we are to get these big things done, I feel. Okay. 38:05 Finally, Michael, I wanted to talk about the gap between people's understanding of climate risk writ large and the understanding of how climate risk will affect them individually. 38:15 And indeed, closing that gap may actually help promote public support for adaptation resilience measures that might otherwise be disruptive or seem to be upsetting a neighborhood or, or a waterfront, et cetera. 38:29 But I think it's interesting that we have a large part of the population who understands climate risks are affecting populations elsewhere. 38:36 They are aware of how heat waves are a pain in the ass if you're over here in, in New York or the Eastern Coast, and how floods are a pain in the ass. 38:43 But it seems that sometimes there's this disassociation between these climate risks in the abstract and actually climate risks to individuals and to your own property. 38:50 So I was wondering, do you have some thoughts about maybe bridging that understanding gap and maybe explaining why it's so important to driving adaptation and resilience going forward? Yeah. I think this is... 39:00 Just to put my cards on the table, I think this is one place where climate community broadly probably has something to learn from the public health community broadly. 39:11 And I say that four years on from COVID, and knowing that public health did not go through COVID being unscathed. 39:21 [chuckles] That the risk communication, uh, that public health, uh, did during COVID was uneven and not always well-received. 39:30 But I do think that going back over the years, there's some real opportunities to learn from public health. 39:36 I would say that if you look at the data about how people understand the climate crisis, it is becoming more and more universally recognized. And Edelman puts out a trust barometer every year. In twenty twenty-three, 39:53 they did a special survey on climate, and it's found very high understanding that climate change poses a serious and imminent threat to the planet. 40:06 Across countries, including in the US, who is at the low side of [chuckles] large countries with only eighty-three percent, uh, believing that, but it's still... 40:19 that's still incredibly high and pretty good data from a large sample size from Edelman. 40:25 And yet, and now I'm switching a little bit to some of the stuff that's coming out of the Yale Center for Climate Communications run by Tony Leiserowitz. 40:34 If you look at when people are surveyed and they ask, "Global warming will harm me personally," that number is still well below fifty percent. 40:43 So people have come to understand that climate change is out there and it's getting worse and it's important, and yet there is very little understanding. 40:54 Even in a place that's so exposed as Florida, it's under fifty percent. There's only, according to this Yale study, only three states, Hawaii, California, and New York, and the Washington DC, 41:10 uh, where that's even over fifty percent, and that's only in the low fifties in those three states. And so the question is, how do you make this more real to people? 41:21 And one analog might be the effort to change behavior around cigarettes. In nineteen sixty-three, the surgeon general, the scientist, said cigarettes cause cancer. 41:36 And then over time, we engaged society. We took the cigarettes out of actors' hands. We put crazy pictures on cigarette cartons. We ran emotive anti-smoking ads. 41:49 We taxed, sued, and regulated, and over time, we have changed behavior around smoking. In fact, the university campus where I am sitting has no smoking anywhere. Anywhere. Not outside, not in designated smoking areas. 42:04 Nowhere are you allowed to smoke on the University of Miami campuses, which is a incredible change. 42:10 It wasn't so long ago, in the eighties really, when it was not uncommon to have a professor walk up to the front of a, a lecture hall, take out a pack of smokes and a ashtray and smoke his or her way through the lecture. 42:27 And, and now we're at a totally different place. And what's the similar kind of effort we need to get people to understand that they are personally more exposed and have a different risk footprint related to climate? 42:43 And I think this effort for us, we're just talking about how we at the University of Miami might contribute to understanding that. 42:52 I think Yale has done, and, and some others, George Mason and, and others, have done some interesting work around that, and I think it's capturing what are the best techniques to get people to begin to understand that their risks, their risk profile is changing.We're also living through this incredible disaggregation of formal authority sources, government, media, science, [laughs] and new kinds of information sources, new media stars, TikTokers, influencers and so on, and VR and AR, where technology may also help us better understand and process that risk. 43:32 And so between all of that, I think there's this incredible opportunity to begin to learn about h-how we might better communicate that. I don't think it's one size fits all. 43:42 I think traditional Cuban community lives in Little Havana is going to process things one way, and the older Jewish community on Miami Beach is gonna think about things another way. And I think that's okay. 43:59 We just have to begin to understand which messages resonate and which messengers r-resonate. And the other thing, last thought, is there... this is also a temporal thing. 44:10 When the hurricane just misses us, when the hurricane hits us, right after the hurricane hits us, a month after, a year after, when the hurricane decimates another city like Houston or New Orleans or somewhere else that we relate to but is not us, there are all these moments where different kinds of messages will r-resonate with different communities. 44:33 And so we should just be ready when that happens in order to communicate that. 44:38 And I feel like right now a lot of the climate risk communication is being handled by climate scientists, which is important, but we should expand that in ways that are inspired by public health. 44:52 Yes, the idea of more targeted messaging, it reflects what happens in politics as well, like microtargeting of messages from a political party to the local or even neighborhood level can help to persuade a voter to vote one way or the other. 45:06 You can see certain messages working with one group that don't work for another. But it's, again, a data task, but also, as you said, a messenger task, find the right messengers. 45:13 And maybe it's tech, maybe it's more VR style immersive environments. Maybe it is TikTok videos, influencers getting out onto the field. 45:20 But I think that's a really interesting point because I think the, the singular message of climate change is terrible, we're all gonna suffer terribly- Right... is effective to some communities. 45:29 But actually, in terms of actually getting people to adapt and build resilience, I think it might be less effective. And I do think recent surveys has borne, borne that out. Yeah. 45:38 And I have this great picture of a Rotterdam building that has marked the flood levels from the 1775 flood, the 1808, the 1916, and the big one, which was hugely destructive and killed, I think, close to 2,000 people, the 1953 flood. 45:57 And the Dutch, like, they retell that story over and over when you're young and as you go through school, and so there's a very good understanding of the threats that they're living with. 46:09 And so they've built a lot of political will in order to make the changes that they need to. 46:14 And I think we need something like that, although just marking the side of the building is probably not the way we're gonna do it in the 21st century. 46:23 That's one of the many adventures that we could all take part in together actually, cli-climate communication. It's something I enjoy doing. 46:29 It's, it's a part of Climate Proof and Climate Proofers, and I think, Michael, you're doing a great job as well engaging your communities in, in pressing the case for adaptation resilience. 46:38 So thank you so much for talking us through those topics and answering my questions. I look forward to seeing what you get up to next. For now, thanks for your time and have a great rest of your week. Thanks, Louis. 46:48 It was great talking to you. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 46:57 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]