Transcript 0:00 This episode is sponsored by ClimateFirst. ClimateFirst is solving climate resiliency for commercial real estate. 0:06 Developed by RWDI Ventures, the startup arm for RWDI, ClimateFirst provides climate risk analysis software that quantifies the financial impacts of physical hazards at the building systems level. 0:18 Its bottom-up methodology applies climate value at risk assessments to reveal the added cost of climate exposure and to model how targeted resiliency measures can mitigate those risks. 0:28 The result is transparent, building specific insights and resiliency plans backed by climate science to empower owners and operators to make data-driven decisions. Thank you, ClimateFirst, for sponsoring this episode. 0:41 [upbeat music] Hi everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of adaptation finance tech and policy. 0:52 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at www.climateproof.news. Here's a question we return to again and again here on Climate Proofers. What is the financial case for adaptation? 1:06 Or put slightly differently, how do you measure the positive impact of adaptation investments? ClimateFirst, a climate risk analysis software company, is trying to answer exactly that. 1:16 In a new case study with BMO Climate Institute and the Investment Management Corporation of Ontario, the team quantifies the potential physical climate losses for a typical residential building across several US locations and shows how specific resilience upgrades can meaningfully reduce those risks. 1:32 You can find a link to this report in the show notes. 1:35 In this episode, you'll hear my conversation with Mike Williams, the president of ClimateFirst, as together we unpack the findings of the case study and dig into the knotty technical challenges involved with quantifying climate risk and resilience. 1:47 We get into why identical buildings can face wildly different climate related financial risks depending on where they're located, and unpack the various awareness and behavior hurdles that still hold many real estate players back from investing in resilience early. 2:00 It's a can't miss conversation for all you investment professionals out there struggling valiantly to make the case for adaptation to your higher-ups, and indeed for everyone curious about the real dollar impacts of unmitigated climate risks. 2:10 We'll get to the conversation with Mike in just a moment, but first, a roundup of last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 2:17 [whooshing sound] In finance, a survey of over nine hundred financial institutions suggests that global investors are prioritizing climate resilient assets and increasing their interest in adaptation-focused investments. 2:28 The survey, conducted by Morgan Stanley, shows more than half of institutional investors say climate resilience is now a core part of how they evaluate risk and return in infrastructure and real estate. 2:39 Nearly three quarters expect extreme weather and climate shifts to move asset prices within the next five years, and over one-third think those impacts will be market-wide. 2:48 On the opportunity side of the equation, adaptation now ranks as the third highest global sustainability investment focus, trailing only renewable energy and energy efficiency. 2:57 As for the top adaptation solutions investors say they are interested in, almost half say data and analytics tools, while forty-four percent say water infrastructure, forty-four percent grid modernization, and thirty-eight percent cooling and urban heat resilience. 3:11 However, many barriers still stand in the way of investor engagement with the adaptation and resilience theme. For example, a large share of North American investors say regulatory or policy uncertainty are a challenge. 3:22 Among European and Asia Pacific investors, the lack of a common market language, standard definitions or classification frameworks is cited as an obstacle. 3:29 [whooshing sound] In policy, the European Commission opened its proposed EU-wide climate resilience and risk management initiative for public consultation, with the aim of creating an integrated framework that hardens member states against worsening floods, fires and other climate hazards. 3:43 Running from December the first through February twenty-third, twenty twenty-six, the consultation is meant to shape a legislative package that would embed climate risk and resilience across public policy and promote investment in climate proofing priorities. 3:55 [whooshing sound] Feedback from an earlier call for evidence shows strong support for tougher, more coordinated resilience policy. 4:01 Individuals, research institutions, businesses and nonprofits called for mandatory resilience by design in public spending and procurement, as well as harmonized climate risk assessment standards and more stable long-term funding for adaptation. 4:14 [whooshing sound] And in tech, Zillow, the largest US online real estate platform, has quietly removed climate risk ratings from property listings after pressure from real estate agents and a major California data provider. 4:25 The ratings, launched last year and powered by climate intelligence company First Street, scored individual properties for multiple climate risks, including flood, wildfire and wind. 4:34 However, The New York Times reports that the California Regional Multiple Listing Service, one of the nation's largest listing databases, complained to Zillow about the accuracy of the flood ratings. 4:45 Zillow now links to First Street's data rather than embedding climate risk scores directly on their listings and argues it still supports informed consumer decisions. 4:53 [whooshing sound] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now onto my conversation with Mike. [upbeat music] Hi, Mike. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hey, Louis. Thanks so much for having me. 5:04 I am calling in from near Guelph, Ontario, Canada, which is just outside Toronto. I am the president of ClimateFirst, which is a climate tech spin-off company that was born out of RWDI. 5:18 And you just told me there's been a snowmageddon up where you are, so I hope you're not barricaded into the office right now and can't get home later. 5:24 [laughs] I, I, uh, working remotely today to avoid that potential snow in. But, yeah, you never know what the climate's gonna do. Okay. 5:32 First of all, Mike, I'd like to start by learning a little more about you and how ClimateFirst came to be. So can you take us through your work with RWDI and the steps that led up to ClimateFirst's founding? Yeah. 5:44 Fantastic, Louis. 5:44 I'll try not to spend too much time wandering down memory lane, but maybe just a, a quick refresh through my career might help set the stage for, for why I'm here and why we're focusing on what we are at ClimateFirst. 5:56 I'm an engineer by training. 5:58 Started my career almost twenty years ago, which feels hard to believe.But early in my career, I took a real interest in the notion of sustainability and thinking about both the positive and negative impacts that the built environment has on nature, and really started to focus my career on how we could create a built environment that was more sustainable. 6:19 That, uh, led me to starting a company early in my career, which I ran for six years with a business partner. 6:26 We had a certain amount of success, which was wonderful, and then we were acquired by the global climate and performance engineering firm RWDI. 6:34 I worked as an engineer at RWDI for the last twelve plus years of my career, and then two years ago, I was presented an opportunity to lead the spin-off company out of RWDI. 6:47 The inspiration for the spin-off company came from some of the work that we were doing in the consulting business, looking at climate resilience on buildings and helping those that are responsible for those buildings come up with resiliency plans. 7:02 We were doing hundreds of projects a year through a consultant-led journey, but really had the epiphany that this is a problem across the literal tens of millions of buildings that are found globally, and if we keep chipping away at it one hundred buildings at a time, we're not gonna make a dent in the scale of this challenge. 7:22 And so I sat down with a group of really bright individuals at, at RWDI and thought about how we might put a software solution around this problem, which would allow us to scale the approaches that we were taking through a consultant-led journey to the level that we felt like we could really start to have a meaningful impact. 7:41 Uh, that was the initial thought spark for Climate First. That's now two and a half, three years ago. 7:47 We've been now an operational company for two years, and we've helped support the identification of physical climate risks and the, the creation of resiliency plans across thousands of built assets, which feels really rewarding, to be honest. 8:01 So the journey was you were receiving all this inbound, and then there was a recognition that we could scale this for a much broader audience set, and I think that's an interesting journey that we've seen a lot from consultancy to software and especially in climate, right, when you're noticing patterns, you're noticing sort of set things that can be done to enhance the resilience of the building, a business, whatever it is. 8:23 So that journey, I think, is not unusual in this space. Can I ask Climate First who your client base is right now, just so listeners get a sense of who you're, who you're selling to, who you're, who you're supporting? 8:34 Yeah. We're working with people that are responsible for portfolios of buildings. 8:39 And so some of our customers on the Climate First platform, they have a responsibility to own a portfolio of building assets on behalf of some form of financial institution. 8:52 Some of our customers have a responsibility to solely operate buildings on behalf of those that own them. And then some of our customers have a, a dual responsibility. They both own and operate the assets. 9:05 It's really people that have a responsibility over a portfolio of buildings. Some of our customers have a dozen buildings under their purview. Some have approaching a thousand. 9:17 So, like, the scale of assets under management varies significantly across those that we're engaged with, and, you know, I find that a very fascinating challenge and opportunity to figure out ways to work with all those different types of customers. 9:32 And I believe we're still in this phase, whether it is building owners, property portfolio managers, there's still some work to be done on educating them on the risks of climate change and then the benefits of resilience. 9:44 And this takes us to the new report that Climate First released, which revolves on an analysis of the benefits of resilience investments in commercial real estate. Can you set the scene for us? 9:55 What was the purpose of this analysis, and what was in scope? Yeah. 9:58 Really exciting analysis, and it was wonderful to work with the Bank of Montreal, BMO, as well as IMCO, and they were wonderful partners on this work alongside Climate First. 10:10 What we wanted to do was to show that across a portfolio of buildings, we could leverage glo-global climate data to identify is there a physical climate risk at a given location? If so, what are those risks? 10:24 And could we quantify the magnitude of those risks to the specific building assets? 10:29 That work has been done pretty extensively, and you can look at a, a number of different sources for research papers that have done similar work. 10:38 Where we really wanted to take it further was to be able to quantify the magnitude of that risk to the specific building assets. And what we really wanted to show was the final magnitude of that risk. 10:52 And so if we could start to show the materiality of that risk, the, the quantification of that risk in financial terms, we felt like we'd be able to show very clearly where one would need to begin or should begin to take action as a result of those climatic exposures. 11:09 And then lastly, where significant risks were found, what would be the best resiliency measures to start to deploy at those specific buildings to start to reduce that risk? 11:21 Could we show a, a, a financial business case for making that resiliency investment? 11:27 And I think we were really able to achieve all of that through this case study paper, and I'm, I'm really pleased with the way that it came together. 11:34 This multi-stage analysis is so important, I think, when it comes to converting skeptics into believers on adaptation resilience, right? 11:42 I feel like the first wave of climate intelligence services, thinking even before twenty-twenty, was all focused on understanding how climate risks can affect businesses or assets and quantifying the risk, but not going into much on the, okay, what can you do about it? 11:58 What's the cost benefits of taking adaptation actions versus doing nothing or versus removing yourself from an, a certain area or-Retreating from certain assets. 12:07 So I really think this sort of analysis is what we really need to see in order to spark that aha moment within businesses, governments, whatever, into taking action. 12:16 So can you take us through the findings of the analysis, and were there any surprises to you when you looked at the, the buildings that you were, you were ana- analyzing and the adaptation benefits that could be used to enhance their resilience? 12:26 Yeah. I, I agree with what you're saying in terms of... Well, we're still in early days of all this. 12:30 Like, 2020's not that long ago, but I think the, the state of the art has evolved rapidly, and I think we're gonna continue to see advancements in the way that we're approaching this. 12:40 But with respect to the specific analysis and some of the surprises that, uh, we perhaps found, and then what I think were some of the real key findings, one of the things that maybe wasn't surprising to me, in that I've had my sleeves rolled up on this problem for a while, but the scope of the analysis was to take a multi-unit residential building, so an apartment building, that was give or take 100,000 square feet, 15 stories tall, and we placed it in nine geographically diverse locations across the USA. 13:12 We then looked at do all of those nine locations have an elevated physical climate risk? Are they exposed to a changing climate parameter that might put additional pressure on this building? 13:23 The answer was yes across the board. Uh, these physical climate risks exist everywhere, whether it be extreme heat, whether it be exposure to extreme winds, elevated levels of precipitation. 13:35 The climate is changing everywhere. Every building is exposed. So that was a key finding. 13:40 As I said, with my sleeves rolled up on this problem for quite a while, maybe not surprising to me, but also shows the magnitude and the challenge of this problem. 13:48 And I also think that level of analysis is where a lot of these portfolio scale resiliency assessments stop, the identification of that risk. 13:57 And when you're responsible for a portfolio of building assets, to learn that you've got a problem off across the board, you need to know where do you begin to focus effort from there. 14:09 And that's where this study really starts to differentiate. What we were able to then do was what we call a climate value at risk assessment across that full nine-building portfolio. 14:21 This was all run through the Climate First platform. 14:24 I highlight that not only because I, I'm really proud with what we've done with Climate First, but it really exemplifies the power of bringing a software solution to a problem like this. 14:34 We were able to do all of that very rapidly, I'm talking about in days, to do this detailed analysis, and we were then able to quantify in dollars the level of risk exposure to each of these nine different properties. 14:48 What I think was the first interesting finding, and was even a surprise to me as someone that's been in this for quite a while, same building, nine different locations, the level of risk at the individual buildings range from $70,000 on a 10-year time horizon all the way up to just shy of $5 million 10-year time horizon. 15:09 We estimated the value of this archetypical residential building at around $50 million. So that $70,000 risk on a 10-year time horizon, very manageable level of risk. 15:21 $5 million of risk on a $50 million asset, that's a yellow to red flag where you really need to dig in, understand how that risk is manifesting, and what you should begin to do to address that risk. 15:34 So I think that range of risk was surprising to everyone that participated in this study, and I think those that dig in and read it, I think they're gonna be interested to see that variability of the financial exposure when you get to that next level of resolution on this problem. 15:51 And the drivers of the difference in financial exposure, is that largely because of the type of hazard that was manifested in each of these nine locations? 15:58 Because as you said, the buildings were identical, so you can't put it down to variations in structure, maintenance routine, whatever. 16:05 So it is purely the driver was different types of climate hazard, the intensity of them, the frequency of them. Yeah. Short answer is yes, Louis. 16:13 That was sort of the idea of this study, and I think what's interesting to be able to do it somewhat theoretically, that you can isolate that variable of every building being unique. 16:22 So in this case, we were able to isolate that variable and have every building be the same so that we could then quantify, well, how does the financial impact vary as a result of the different hazards that each of these buildings was exposed to, as well as the magnitude of those hazards. 16:41 The, the building with a, a relatively low r- level of climate value at risk, its primary risk exposure was extreme heat. 16:49 When you think about how extreme heat really manifests itself onto a, a building asset, it's gonna begin to expose that the cooling system may be undersized. 16:58 That's an addressable risk that those that are responsible for that building could think about upsizing that cooling system the next time it comes up for a replacement cycle. I, I would argue a very manageable risk. 17:10 The property with a, a very elevated level of risk was exposed to both fluvial and fluvial flooding, as well as extreme wind. 17:20 This property is located down in the Miami Beach area, where they've been hit with some very extreme weather events in the recent past, and those buildings need to start to think quite differently about the way that they're preparing themselves for the future. 17:34 Now, for those who may not be familiar with climate value at risk as a concept, can you explain how investment professionals typically interpret these numbers? 17:42 And what should be kept in mind when looking at CBAR outputs, and, and what should be... how, how should they inform behavior? How should they inform decision-making? 17:52 Because there has been some concern in the past about climate risk metrics to kind of give you one number and kind of say, "This is the number. This is the risk over 10 years. This is the risk over five years." 18:01 And there's been understandable pushback to that because, of course, weather is variable, climate change is undeniable, and we are gonna see greater frequency intensity of climate shocks. 18:11 But actually, how that results in financial-Impact is, is hazy. So can you talk a little bit about CVAR as a concept and how you communicate that to your clients? Yeah. Great question, Louis, and really good point. 18:22 I think the notion of climate value at risk is, is an evolving science, and there are a number of different ways to approach it. 18:28 And so I think as you're looking at a climate value at risk metric, I think you really need to ask how will-- how was it approached in this specific instance. 18:38 Our approach to the development of a climate value at risk metric is really an engineering-led model. 18:44 And so what we look at is a building has a set of systems, and our model then looks at each of those systems and how they're gonna respond differently as a result of these climatic exposures the forward-looking climate models suggest they are gonna have to begin to deal with as they head into the future. 19:03 Um, because our model, um, builds its risk profile from a building system level on up, it gives you an incredible level of transparency that you can then look at the very specific building systems the model is suggesting are, are, are at risk, uh, to these changing climate parameters. 19:22 Uh, that level of transparency allows you to really question and query the model. What is it saying? Why is it showing an elevated level of risk? 19:31 Well, it's because you have your primary air handling system, your primary cooling system located at grade. The future-looking climate models are suggesting that flooding is a major risk here. 19:42 That system is therefore at risk itself. 19:45 And when you can see that level of transparency, you can get buy-in and confidence in the analysis from those that are responsible for the building from a financial management perspective, all the way down to those that are responsible for that building with o-ongoing operation and maintenance, boots on the ground. 20:04 And so I think it's really that transparency in the model that you really wanna see so that you can understand how it's working and question and query the inputs, and therefore the outputs. Exactly. 20:16 And there are varying levels of sophistication in different industries, different companies, but there is, seems to me, an overall drive to, yes, as a user of climate risk tools like yours, to be able to understand what goes in and therefore integrate what comes out. 20:29 And I feel like that's actually a better way to drive action because if a user can say, "Okay, my CVAR is related to these drivers here, here, and here," and I can see within the system, as you put it, like what tweaks need to be made, what alterations need to be made, what new connections need to be made, that can really help drive action. 20:47 So I wanna turn to the resilience part of the equation now. What did your analysis show about the benefits of resilience, and how can investors use the sort of outputs you came up with to choose adaptation measures? 21:01 Yeah. 21:02 I think the engineering system-based CVAR model that we utilized allowed those assets that were determined to have a high level of climate value at risk for us to then focus in on those, identify the specific systems that were at risk, and then select a suite of adaptation measures to create a very logical resiliency plan. 21:23 For the asset that was found to have significant risk, the proposed intervention was also significant, and it found that having a flood protection device or a flood barrier that could be deployed in advance of one of these anticipated flooding events could have a significant impact on that climate value at risk, reducing it by over fifty percent if that mitigant was procured and deployed. 21:52 That presents an incredible opportunity for value preservation. 21:57 And you think about these building assets and them being exposed to these climatic risks, if we can begin to invest in their resilience, we can really preserve their forward value for the investors that are holding these assets. 22:12 One of the things I'll, I'll, I'll now point to as a, a challenge in the re-resiliency conversation is that when we talk about these metrics, when we talk about these dollar values, we're talking about dollars of avoided loss. 22:29 And so we have anticipated that this event may occur in the future. By deploying this resiliency measure, you've greatly reduced your risk of having that future event occurred. 22:40 So we can quantify that in dollars and say that you, you've reduced your risk exposure to that future event by this much. That's incredibly powerful and allows you to prioritize where you're gonna make those investments. 22:52 What continues to be a challenge is that in the pro formas of typical commercial real estate, you don't carry a future loss value. You don't have a future loss value carried on your profit and loss statement. 23:05 So there's no way to really create a simple ROI equation by saying like, "Well, we've now invested in reducing this future loss, we can therefore reduce that in our forward-looking pro forma for this asset and drive a very simple return on investment equation." 23:22 So to drive that return on investment, we do have to look to other levers. We can look to insurers. 23:29 We can make arguments and create relationships with lenders who can begin to understand why one might want to make these investments to really preserve the value of this asset into the future. 23:41 But I do think that's one of the key challenges in really enabling investments in resiliency to go mainstream. Yes. There's agreed upon accountancy principles, right? 23:51 And there is a danger in a lot of companies that you want to optimize for that accounting standard rather than actually what might be most useful in the real world. 24:00 I do wonder with-- when it comes to fixed assets like buildings, you have depreciation, you have wear and tear, but one concern I have is that when it comes to adaptive measures, you referenced that with the example of the building with a five million dollar CVAR, you can reduce that by half, fifty percent, right? 24:15 So that's just two point five million still of exposure over ten years. 24:19 You discount that back to today, maybe-An investor says, "Okay, so we could spend a bunch of money now on the flood barrier, and we'll avoid this loss." 24:26 But actually looking at the accounting books today, it's better us to kind of save the money on the flood risk mitigation and take our chances and also be like, "Okay, we can deal with two point five percent... 24:37 Sorry, five percent loss in value over ten years of this asset." Because also we might sell out of it within eight years before the flood happens. 24:43 So I still think there are lots of different factors that can sort of disincentivize adaptive actions. 24:48 Which is why I think there's been a lot of effort on the policy side, regulatory side, to say, "Okay, yes, you need to disclose climate risks, you need to consider climate risk in your capital allocation and your portfolio management if you're an investor." 25:00 I understand that's kind of the missing link there. Is, is that your finding when you're talking to clients and, and showing the analysis that you do? But what messages are you finding are getting through? 25:09 With resiliency and maybe with, with climate related conversations in general, the bad news story often takes the headline, and we can quickly miss what the good news story is. And we look at this- That's true... 25:21 very small portfolio of nine buildings, over ninety percent of the risk was concentrated in three buildings. 25:27 And so we've just finished talking about the risk in one of those buildings and what needs to be done as a result of those exposures. 25:34 But I don't think it should be lost that six of the buildings, very manageable, uh, level of risk was identified. And so I think for many building assets, yes, they're... 25:45 everybody's exposed to climate and a changing climate, but for many buildings this is a manageable risk. Yeah. 25:52 And I think if we can start to quantify it and understand some of the interventions that we can take, it, it doesn't always have to be a major flood wall that's procured or divestment strategies that are considered. 26:06 It can often be relatively small things and, and we're seeing some of the customers on our climate first platform ta-take small steps, doing things like pruning trees so that the building is less prone to a window breaking during an elevated wind event. 26:21 We're seeing simple things like making sure that exterior patio furniture is tied down so it doesn't cause an issue during an extreme wind event. 26:29 Other good news stories that I'll point to is I find sometimes when these climate models miss their prediction, that also grabs the headline. 26:38 Um, but we are seeing many, many cases where the climate models are actually doing quite a good job of anticipating and predicting the way that these climatic events are unfolding. 26:50 We had one customer on our platform who experienced a one in one hundred year flood event in the vicinity of where their building was, and the way that that flood manifested actually mapped really closely to the flood mapping that had been provided. 27:04 And they called us to give us some kudos, which is really great. And I... sometimes I think that these, these positive stories don't catch the headlines, but I think that they're important. 27:13 I think we're doing a better job with respect to understanding the risks. And I think, uh, the ability to start to suggest what should be done about it has improved tremendously as well. Yes. 27:24 I think as we, as we have more examples of forecasts coming true, as, as tragic as they may be in terms of climate risk, I think we can start changing behavior amongst decision makers, right? 27:35 Because I still feel there is this sense that, okay, what happens in the future is unknowable, force majeure, acts of God. 27:41 But actually our technology now and our understanding of the climate and the environment is such that we can provide very accurate forecasts in the near term and medium term as well. 27:50 So I do wonder if we'll start to see a real change in attitude by institutions and by individuals actually about how they, how they react to promised climate risks, and that would also help with this resilience investment case that you're making. 28:04 Okay. I want to ask a little bit beyond just looking at kind of purely financial calculations of, okay, if I invest in X, then I will reduce my search by Y. 28:12 What other considerations should investors, commercial real estate operatives keep in mind when it comes to building resilience? And two factors come to mind. One is insurance, insurance availability and affordability. 28:24 Very important for all sorts of assets, particularly fixed assets like CRE assets. And then the other one is building codes, right? 28:31 Because we were talking about standards in the context of accounting principles, but also standards by how buildings are created can be changed so that the resulting product is more resilient to climate risks, right? 28:42 But that is very variable. Building codes differ in the US not even by state, but by locality. 28:47 And in other regions of the world, yes, building standards, building codes can be very localized, but that also has big implications for the resilience of current and future buildings in an area. 28:57 So those are two factors. I wonder if you want to opine on those two, and what other factors should CRE investors keep in mind when it comes to doing these calculations of physical risk and resilience. Yeah. 29:08 Fantastic, Louis. I agree with your line of questioning here for sure. And maybe hitting on insurance to start. 29:15 I think insurance provides the immediate opportunity to drive some simple return on investment through the investment in resiliency. And we are seeing some insurers start to provide performance-based insurance packages. 29:28 And so they are saying, "Hey, if you make these investments in resiliency measures at your building asset, we're gonna reduce your insurance premiums." 29:36 And that's a simple way to drive a return on investment equation, and I think we're gonna see more of that. So I think insurance and continued innovation in the insurance sector is very exciting. 29:49 Building codes, I agree with you. We are starting to see future climate being considered in next iterations of the building code. 29:56 I think that's tremendously important that the built environment continues to be built, and we are gonna have more buildings in the future, and for them to be resilient to the changing climate future, very important. 30:09 Unfortunately, the building code doesn't do too much for the buildings that already exist, which are tens of millions of buildings. 30:16 So the building codes, yes, important, but it won't provide a lot of guidance and jurisdiction over the existing built environment.I think over that existing built environment, other drivers that we are beginning to see are different voluntary programs at this time. 30:32 Various different types of green building rating systems can often be a great nudge to start to move the sector along. But then we are starting to see efforts towards regulatory requirements. 30:43 We saw the push towards SB two six one in California, which went beyond the requirement of just disclosure, but proving that you're beginning to take action at specific assets. Fortunately, that's been paused. 30:58 I don't think it'll be canceled. I think we will see some evolution of that, but I think those are the types of things that we're gonna begin to see. 31:05 I think your question went further to say, well, beyond just financial implications, what other things do you need to consider? There's reputational risk. 31:13 If your building goes down for an extended period of time, even if that's covered by insurance, and you can recover from the financial losses, the reputational losses can be significant. 31:24 I think the interruption for certain types of tenants of these assets, you know, on the extreme end, you think of healthcare facilities, like any interruption is not acceptable. 31:36 But even for commercial and residential tenants where we're not talking about mission-critical facilities per se, being put out of house and home, I've got a couple young kids at home, imagining having to deal with that even for a few weeks would be quite traumatic, to say the least. 31:51 Yes. 31:52 It's important to think of buildings not just in isolation, but what services, what public goods and private goods are actually they are supporting by being in operation, and what does disruption to those assets mean for the kind of network of services and goods around them. 32:07 Yes, I do wonder whether beyond just disclosure requirements and building codes, whether it is gonna be more of this reputational risk, but also even when it comes to, like, building developers, whether this kind of duty of care kicks in, right? 32:19 If you've got a team of engineers who are well-versed in the kind of the current practices and understand how buildings could be affected by growing physical risks, and a client says, "Yeah, I want you to build a building at this spec, and I want it to cost this much. 32:32 Go with it." Are you as an engineer, are you as a contractor, as a professional being like, "Okay. 32:36 Yeah, we'll just do what the client says," or do you have a duty to say, "Hey, look, just to let you know, flooding is a big deal here. 32:41 You could build it like this, but we think this could be your risk, and actually you should talk to Climate First or someone else before you actually sign off on a certain plan." 32:48 And that was an interesting discussion I had this year about whether actually, yes, the professions involved in real estate gonna have to change the relationship with clients because they understand, look, we could build it as the client wants, but if we do it like this, then they're gonna be in trouble, store up trouble for the future that will rebound on us, on our reputations, if we don't actually say something. 33:06 So I do wonder beyond just regulatory, beyond just market, there is gonna be some interesting dynamics around professional courtesy or professional relationships generally. Yeah, I totally agree, Louis. 33:16 Occasionally, I'll be talking to somebody about helping them understand these future climate risks and how that may expose some challenges to the building assets that they either own or they're contemplating purchasing. 33:30 Occasionally, I'll get the pushback, "You know what? Like why, why do I want to know this? 33:34 Like, am I not just from a business perspective better off to just allow this unknown to remain unknown, which would allow me to push ahead my b- business decisions faster?" 33:44 I think that's a dangerous [chuckles] position to take. If you're contemplating purchasing an asset, I think you're better to go in eyes wide open. 33:52 This data is starting to become widely accessible, and I think it's a bit naive to think that whoever's on the other side of the deal doesn't have this information and will be using it to negotiate with you. 34:03 And so maybe it's my background as an engineer, but I think the more information, the better as you're trying to drive towards a decision. 34:10 I think whether or not there becomes some fiduciary duty to make sure that you understand that information and that you're held accountable to future scenarios, that's very interesting, and I do think it could start to become an interesting driver. 34:24 Yes. Historically, information asymmetries between market participants allow for winners and losers, right? 34:30 And over time, though, those asymmetries are kind of ar- arbitraged away because providers come in, provide data to all, all parties. 34:36 So I feel like the influx of climate intelligence data, consulting services is gonna help to kind of equalize information asymmetries over time, which is, yeah, I think important for the, the markets involved, but also for our overall resilience as, as a society. 34:50 Okay. Now I just wanna finish by asking a little bit about the trajectory of Climate First itself. You've released the report. 34:57 What are you hoping generates in terms of, of discussion, in terms of engagement with Climate First, and what's the plan for 2026? How do you see yourself building the business and expanding? Yeah. 35:05 No, that's great, Louis. Thanks. 35:07 I think what we've done to date with Climate First, and I think maybe where the broader conversation around resiliency has got to, is really around this notion of value preservation, where we can identify risks using tools like Climate First. 35:21 We can begin to quantify the climate value at risk, so we can begin to prioritize, and then we can zoom in and identify the specific assets where investment should be made and start to think about what would be the adaptations or resiliency measures to deploy at those specific assets to protect their value. 35:41 And we wanna protect that value for a number of different reasons that we've talked about throughout this session. 35:46 Where we want to take Climate First next and where I think the industry as a whole is gonna go is around the notion of value creation. 35:54 So not just value protection, but how can we systematically invest in resiliency so that we can create new returns on investment across the real estate sector? 36:06 This is gonna require us to think about these metrics, like avoided loss, has a key piece of a return on investment equation. 36:15 I think we're gonna see insurers start to respond to this and provide enhanced opportunities for premium reductions as a result of understanding that potential for avoided loss. 36:26 We're also having conversations with leading lending institutions-Who are also seeing this as an opportunity to create value and want to create financing products that will enable those responsible for buildings to invest in resiliency. 36:42 And so to me, that's the big opportunity, to move not just from value preservation to value creation through investment in resiliency. 36:50 And if we can do that, and I think we're not far off, we'll really see resiliency start to tip into the mainstream. I agree wholeheartedly. 36:59 We're seeing this across different verticals of adaptation investment, adaptation innovation. 37:04 Like, avoided loss is one thing, but value creation is what really can drive new participants into a market and create new products and services that really help support the climate proofing of different industries. 37:14 And I think we are gonna start seeing, we have already seen, especially large corporations start to be more discerning about where they're putting their assets, where they're putting their supply chains based on the climate physical risk they could face. 37:25 And you can see a world where people are willing to pay more in rents for a certain office space, a certain building that is protected, that is resilient vis-a-vis its neighbors, and I think that could also be revenue generating as well for CRE investors. 37:38 Okay. Finally, Mike, where can folks get in touch with you if they want to digitally? Digitally, yeah. I'm very active on LinkedIn, so please look at my profile. Send me a connection request. 37:49 So again, Mike Williams, climatefirst.net. So we're always posting new information. We've got some webinars that are gonna be kicking off shortly, highlighting some of the work from this case study. 38:01 You can download that case study from our website. I think you'll really enjoy it. 38:05 I think the way that we get into the financial KPIs of physical climate risk and resiliency, I think you'll find to be really interesting and engaging. Please keep an eye out for me and come and say hello. 38:18 I'd love to engage in conversations around resiliency. I think it's a tremendously exciting time in this space, and it's gonna take many hands to make the advancements that we need to. 38:30 Once again for listeners, the link to the case study, the report, is in the show notes, and I'll also be putting Mike's, uh, LinkedIn profile in the show notes and in the email that goes out with this ep- episode, so do reach out to him. 38:44 Uh, Mike, I hope to be able to bump into you, uh, on the conference circuit in the near future as well, and hope we can keep the conversation going with Climate First going forward. 38:51 But for now, thank you so much for your time. Have a great rest of your week. Thank you, Louis. This was wonderful. [upbeat music] Climate Proovers is a Climate Proof Media production. 39:02 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 39:10 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]