Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation, finance, tech, and policy. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of Climate Proof, the adaptation publication, which you can read at www.climateproof.news. There's no getting around it, the US electricity grid is in trouble. 0:24 Just last week, the North American Electric Reliability Corporation president warned federal regulators of a, quote, "five alarm fire in grid dependability" due to a mounting series of small-scale events and near misses. 0:36 Among these are extreme weather events and other climate-driven physical risks to grid infrastructure. 0:41 Even the Trump administration's Department of Energy is not blind to how these are affecting the grid, having noted the impact of extreme weather events on load loss in its most recent report. 0:50 Meanwhile, data from poweroutage.us shows that the number of severe power outages is increasing from sixty-eight in 2023 to eighty in 2024. 0:59 Given the importance of reliable electricity to the US economy, especially now given the AI boom, it's small wonder that a host of startups have sprung up in recent years to help power utilities improve their reliability. 1:11 One of these startups is Rhizome, co-founded and run by today's guest, Mishal Fedani. 1:16 The company has developed a suite of software products that help utilities assess their climate risks, plan long-term wildfire risk mitigation efforts, and prioritize investments that strengthen reliability and resilience. 1:27 Rhizome is gaining serious traction with utilities and investors alike, having closed a six point five million dollar seed round in May this year with high-profile funds, including Base10 Partners and the wildfire-focused Convective Capital. 1:39 Mish joins to tell the Rhizome story so far, to offer his expert impressions on the resilience of the US grid, and share how utilities are implementing adaptive measures. 1:49 For all you electricity and infrastructure nerds out there, this is the conversation for you. If you're a regular listener and enjoying the show, please consider rating us on Spotify or Apple Podcasts. 1:58 And if you're feeling really generous, why not drop us a review too? Those who want to go the extra mile and support us with their wallets, please head over to www.climateproof.news/upgrade to become a paying member. 2:10 Right, in a minute, my conversation with Mish, but first, a roundup of last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 2:16 [swoosh] In finance, the Climate Financial Risk Forum, a joint initiative of UK financial regulators, released a fresh batch of reports last week on embedding climate adaptation into financial decision-making. 2:28 The headline report, From Risk to Resilience, outlines how financial institutions can operationalize adaptation across asset classes, sectors, and sovereign exposures, and capitalize on opportunities investing in climate resilience. 2:40 And accompanying publication focused on physical climate risk assessment tools, benchmarking those provided by thirteen tech vendors, including ClimateX, Jupiter Intelligence, Fathom, and First Street. 2:51 This revealed wide disparities in risk modeling, a lack of standardized metrics used across providers, and challenges capturing certain systemic climate impacts. 2:59 The forum intends for these publications to help the financial sector better manage climate-related risks and opportunities. 3:05 However, they do not represent binding regulatory guidance or necessarily reflect the views of the UK's financial watchdogs. 3:11 [swoosh] In policy, only half of the low-income parties in the UNFCCC have submitted their national adaptation plans, or NAPs, so far, raising concerns that many may miss the year-end deadline. 3:23 A new report on the global process finds that as of September, sixty-seven developing countries have formally submitted NAPs to the UN. 3:30 Another seventy-seven have started the NAP process but have yet to complete their plans. NAPs are meant to help countries defend against climate shocks and expand their adaptive capacities. 3:39 One stumbling block for countries that have yet to submit their plans is a lack of finance. 3:43 Although the Green Climate Fund has approved six point nine billion dollars for a hundred and sixteen projects aligned with NAPs, access to finance is uneven and slow. 3:52 Capacity constraints and bureaucratic hurdles continue to delay the flow of funds, the report says. 3:57 [swoosh] And in tech, US-based Burnt Island Ventures has closed a fifty million dollar fund to back early-stage water technology startups, doubling down on a popular adaptation investment niche. 4:08 The fund targets innovations that address the intersection of aging water systems and intensifying climate impacts, as well as the surging industrial demand for water amidst the ongoing AI craze. 4:19 Burnt Island Ventures has already fully deployed its first thirty million dollar fund across eighteen companies, including Floodbase, Subica, and SewerAI. 4:28 The firm's second fund will focus on seed-stage technologies for water reuse, digital efficiency, and infrastructure resilience, areas increasingly seen as central to climate adaptation and business continuity. 4:38 [swoosh] Okay, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Mish. [upbeat music] Hi, Mish. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? 4:48 I'm calling from Menlo Park, California, and I am the co-founder and CEO of Rhizome. Thanks for being on the pod today, Mish. 4:56 I got to know you through our mutual contact and friend, Sonam Vallani, who works at Streetlife Ventures. Got to hang out with you briefly at Climate Week New York this September, and we'll get into that a little later. 5:07 So pleased to have this conversation. Rhizome's a company that's come up a lot in discussions and seems to have quite a lot of buzz itself, so we're gonna get into that. 5:15 But first, I'd like to talk about you, your background, and your journey to becoming an adaptation entrepreneur. I'm happy to dive in, and I think it's a pretty non-traditional path going from mitigation to adaptation. 5:27 So, you know, excited to sort of tell you about my journey here. So maybe we can start with your early career. How did you get involved in the grid, energy systems, and mitigation? Yeah. 5:37 And, you know, when I was in school and in coming out of college, there wasn't really a whole lot of buzz around new clean energy technologies. 5:47 If you were interested in environmental activism, it was more so about emissions and how to cap sulfur dioxide emissions or NOx emissions, so on and so forth. 5:56 I actually had the privilege of taking a class from one of my professor, David Cohen, at Rice University in Houston, where he taught a course of what are some of the advanced energy technologies around there, or alternative energy technologies out there, such as wind, solar, geothermal, which as we know today are no longer alternative technologies. 6:13 They are go-to low-cost solutions for decarbonization. 6:17 But it really got me interested in-All of the new frontier of energy that we could start building out to actually transition off of fossil fuels and mitigate the impacts of greenhouse gas emissions. 6:30 So I focused my college career on studying atmospheric sciences within the civil and environmental engineering group, learned quite a bit about the impacts that climate change could have on Earth, and started to think about how we could adapt, but for the most part, I was focused on mitigation. 6:44 So I started my career in none other than, than BP Wind Energy, so a very small effort to decarbonize within BP, so an organization you'll be familiar with. An office located in Houston. 6:57 And we built a bunch of wind projects around the country. It was an exciting time, but I realized I wasn't much of a project developer at the end of the day, at least at the utility scale. 7:07 So I joined a solar startup, um, and the concept and the intersection around distributed energy resources, not only how we can decarbonize the grid with minimal land usage, do it on rooftops, but also increase the resilience of customers that have solar, especially plus storage o-on their units a-as well. 7:25 Resilience was a big motivating factor for wanting to get more distributed. 7:30 I moved to DC and I may have picked up the policy bug, so I started focusing quite a bit on utility regulation and how rules need to change to advance. 7:39 It started by just showing up at public service commission meetings or public utility commission meetings and advocating for grid modernization to advance distributed energy resources. 7:48 One of the major tools that we used in that policy advocacy was the concept of customer resilience for the energy sector. Folks who can provide themselves with power even when the lights go off. 7:59 So that's how I got my start in really focusing in on grid regulatory and policy issues, applied that in the AI space, started working with utility commissions across the country on machine learning-related use cases, partially for decarbonization, partially for resilience, and then ended up launching Rhizome as, you know, we've now been facing a really pivotal moment over the past few years where utilities are needing to really grapple with bankruptcy and other types of devastating impacts from communities from all types of hazards. 8:27 So how do you better invest in the system to create a more resilient outcome? And that's what we're doing here at Rhizome. Yes. 8:33 And can you tell me why you made this shift to focusing on the resiliency of the grid and providing these data services to utilities? What was the kind of market signal you were picking up? 8:45 No, [laughs] it wasn't really an ambition. And I appreciate the question, but it was, wasn't really an ambition to start a company, right? 8:50 The ambition for me has always been to try to solve for the policy goals and then create implementation mechanisms for those policy goals, whether it be on the mitigation side or on the adaptation side. 9:03 And so PG&E caused a major wildfire in twenty nineteen, the Camp wildfire. They ended up going through bankruptcy proceedings thereafter. 9:12 I think the company that I was with at the time, Urbint, was working with utilities, including PG&E, to try to evaluate how those high-risk assets that could cause fires, how to mitigate, identify those assets and those instances of risk. 9:26 And so that's where I was getting a whole bunch of exposure. But the real one that set it off for me in terms of an event was Winter Storm Uri in Texas. 9:34 So I'm, I'm a native Texan from South Texas, and even though I was living in DC at the time, many of my friends and family were affected in terms of multi-day power outages when that winter storm hit Texas and took the entire grid offline. 9:48 For many folks, it was a couple of weeks before they got power back online. And so just that resonated with me quite a bit and wanting to dive deeper into resilience and actually how to solve for better planning. 10:01 Uh, I started doing a bunch of research and investigation, started looking into utility resilience plans that they were filing with the regulators. 10:07 So a whole bunch of additional capital that utilities were starting to file with their regulators, not just PG&E, but also, you know, Entergy in New Orleans to prepare against hurricanes and even in the Northeast, right? 10:19 Con Ed developed their first resilience plan after Hurricane Sandy and have been working on it for years now, right? 10:25 So but what we started seeing broadly is that the CapEx and operational processes started increasing and changing related to specifically resilience and adaptation. 10:36 So it felt like it was a good time to come in and help inform, provide more and better information as those high-level, high-value decisions are being made. 10:44 Now to Rhizome itself and your platform, Aspen, can you explain how you provide useful data to grid operators, uh, power utilities, and what's your moat? I'm always interested in this. 10:55 I know you don't want to give everything away because competitors might be listening. 10:58 But, you know, in this world where AI is enabling the aggregation of data and the exploration of insights that were previously kind of hidden in the mass of big data that was available, like, what is, what is the way that you kind of help provide customers with an edge? 11:13 Yeah, I think over time, most data is going to be commoditized, right? So I can appreciate that question. But maybe I'll start with the first part of that question in terms of what are we trying to provide. 11:23 At the end of the day, right now you have dozens, if not hundreds of people within utilities that are trying to identify 11:30 which investments do I make on the system given large CapEx budgets in order to address the risks that are presented from the system, from floods, from fires, from storms, extreme temperatures, especially with that effect on transformers, for instance. 11:46 And how do I best maximize the value of the investments that are going in to mitigate those risks and also maintain reliability for customers? And oh, wait, we also need to decarbonize in the process, right? 11:55 So it's a really big task for the engineering teams and asset management teams to manage and balance all of these various needs of a system that also happens to be the backbone of society. 12:07 All of our manufacturing, all of our hospitals, none of it would operate in the way that it does today without the energy system, right? So it's a big job, and it's an extremely complex job. 12:16 And so the information that we're trying to provide is in a way to align with the workflows that a utility has internally. 12:24 What we do is we mapReliability information, system GIS information, creating a digital representation of a transmission and distribution system. 12:33 Typically, you know, utilities operate within a state, so it'll be in a service area within a state. 12:38 We're not just creating the current digital representation, but we're also looking historically to see where have the failures occurred, and what were the conditions under which those failures occurred. 12:47 For instance, if you had a forty-mile-an-hour wind event, you might have seen some failures. 12:52 But if you had a different forty-mile an hour wind event, and it also was a precipitation event, otherwise known as a storm or a blizzard, then that'll have a different effect in terms of how the system is affected, because the physical representation of those hazards has a different stress effect on a utility asset. 13:09 And so our job is to recreate historically what has all the conditions that the utility transmission distribution asset's been exposed to, learn from the failure patterns, and we build machine learning algorithms in order to do this, and then provide that insight at a granular basis at the asset level. 13:26 What's the likelihood of failure under various conditions? What does this mean in terms of reliability at the circuit level? What does this mean in terms of resilience at the system level? 13:34 So we're able to summarize this information again on a geospatial tool to allow a utility to easily visualize where the events are going to impact their system the most, where the vulnerabilities are, and then we have an investment planning mechanism built in with the tool where you have a menu of different investments that, again, these asset planners and engineers are accustomed to making and are making decisions on kind of on everyday basis is where should we underground overhead lines? 14:03 Where should we replace aging assets? Where should we trim trees or even, uh, do hazard tree removal, which is we know that this one tree is a problem. Instead of trimming it, let's just rip it out, right? 14:14 But there are so many different decisions that are being made today of that variety, and the challenge for a utility is what is gonna get me the most bang for my buck for each of these activities? 14:25 And so we really just help optimize across all of those different interventions within our tool itself. 14:30 I think providing those two services, both the risk analysis, but then the kind of menu of options is so important because I hear time and again, some software solutions come in saying, "Hey, look, here's your risk, here's your exposure." 14:42 And then it's like, "And what? Then what am I supposed to do with this information?" And providing that insight is, is so helpful. 14:48 And actually, I did wanna ask, like from your client base so far, have there been any trends that you've picked out in terms of what risk mitigations, what physical adaptations have proven either most popular or most needed, right? 15:00 And especially utilities companies, they're talking a lot about their wildfire mitigation plans. They're talking about their rate decisions, their rate proposals to their local regulators. 15:09 There's this back and forth always about investment in mitigation and how much energy companies should charge for that. 15:15 So I understand the cost pressures they're under, but can you talk about what adaptations, what hardenings have been most popular with your client base? Yeah, absolutely. 15:24 So we do work with customers in various geographies, including the Pacific Northwest, Texas, and the Northeast. I can talk generally about the conditions in those environments and what they're going up against. 15:35 In Texas, for instance, one of our utility customers has the ambition to be the most resilient system on the Gulf Coast. They've gotten hit with storms and hurricanes on a regular basis. 15:45 One of the things that they're implementing more and more of is installing steel and composite poles along the coast, as opposed to the wooden poles that most people are familiar with when you drive down your street. 15:58 If it's not an underground system, you're most likely gonna see some wooden poles out there, highly vulnerable to failure under high winds, especially with precipitation. 16:06 That has been the mechanism of choice for this particular utility as a way to overcome the hurricanes. 16:13 The reason why they chose this path was because we do have some evidence of upgrading materials to be working, and, and that is an example in Florida, where Florida Power and Light upgraded their transmission system to be rated against a hundred and fifty mile an hour wind events, and lo and behold, three years ago, they got a hurricane, a category one hurricane come through. 16:36 It was anticipated to take out much of the transmission system, but there was not one single failure on their transmission system during that hurricane. 16:43 And so those types of material-related overhead structure upgrades have been really popular in areas like the Gulf Coast, also the middle of the country, say in Michigan. 16:54 And then in the Northeast, you have a lot of flood mitigation measures, as you might expect. 16:59 So things like raising substations or making sure to insulate the underground infrastructure from potential flooding as well has been a major area of, of concern. 17:10 And then lastly, if we focus more on the Pacific Northwest, um, it's been more about wildfire mitigation, so understanding the interaction between vegetation and trees and the potential for ignition when it's in close proximity to a line. 17:25 And so you see a lot of covered conductors in places where they feel that undergrounding is either due to the topography and the soil type. 17:35 If the topography is extremely rocky, it's mountainous or hilly, it does not become an affordable option to underground that infrastructure. So what are the alternatives? 17:45 You can do the Tokyo approach in terms of i-insulating those conductors using an insulator to cover the overhead conductors and make sure that even if there is contact that's made with vegetation, there isn't the ability to arc with a bare wire. 17:59 So those are the various types of mitigations that we see and we're actively modeling within our platform. What I find interesting is that those are all different examples of different geographies, right? 18:08 And one challenge with utilities, especially in the States, is that highly regulated, very geographic specific in terms of the challenges they're facing, their infrastructure, their regulatory system. 18:19 And one thing I learned from talking to a European, uh, utility was that sometimes the issues with startups in general is that they try to provide a, an all-in-one service and as automated as possible, but actually they kind of still need that kind of high touch-Consultancy or hand-holding through the data that you provide, the solutions that you provide. 18:37 So can you talk a little bit about, you know, your tech startup on one hand, but also these are very people-forward businesses, very physical businesses. How do you kind of bridge that divide? Yeah. 18:46 And not only that, they expect a high degree of relationships to be involved here as well, right? 18:51 So maintaining a good rapport with the folks who are in charge of investment plans in particular, and ensuring that we're providing an adequate service is a critical part to delivering, you know, what we would refer to as customer success at a technology company. 19:05 But there is a high touch approach here in the sense that when we implement a model and deploy our software tool, we do have a team internally that manages the customer success, ensures that they can use the tool appropriately, and then if they do have an area of need, such as filing an investment plan, then we can provide the adequate support in terms of reporting or giving some guidance on how to interpret data. 19:26 The last thing that I'll say about that is that we are a technology company, and so we know that we need to partner with other folks, and this may be commentary on the adaptation space as a whole, where I think you've been part of cultivating a community around how we think about adaptation and how we build solutions for adaptation. 19:45 It's not gonna be investors in a silo, it's not gonna be technologists in a silo, but it's gonna be a broad stakeholder group coming together and developing solutions that can scale. 19:55 It's very similar with utilities, right? We need to bring consulting players that have a lot of experience in the regulatory environment, as well as advising utilities in how to create the change management. 20:06 And so we do have partners. One of our prominent partners is KPMG, for instance, uh, where they're coming in with advisory on the back of our software tool deployment, a-as well as other consulting partners as well. Yes. 20:18 There needs to be a degree of matchmaking in adaptation world, right, between technology providers, kind of hands-on consultants, but then you've also got the public and private sector divide as well to bridge, especially with hi-highly regulated industry. 20:29 So yes, you need to know what you can do well and what you need to kind of outsource or partner with to create a successful company. That's something I've learned as well. 20:37 I wanted to ask about tailwinds and headwinds to your business, but also to the idea of grid adaptation, grid resilience in general. You know, we're coming off of Climate Week. 20:46 There was a lot of discussion at Climate Week about grid reliability, grid resi-resilience, not just in the context of extreme weather, but because of the massive electricity build-out we're seeing in the States here because of AI. 20:56 Also expected to increase because of the demand for AC, demand for industrial processes, the electrification of the economy in general. So I imagine that's a tailwind. 21:05 I'd like you to speak on that, but also headwinds in terms of the fact that you, you do have this balkanized regulatory system in, in the US, but also you can have, as we've seen, like federal policy as well kind of get in the way of certain grid operators and certain utilities plans. 21:19 So tailwinds and headwinds, how, how can you speak to those? Yeah. 21:22 In terms of tailwinds, I think there's probably never been a more exciting time to be in the electricity sector beyond when we were first building out the grid, right? 21:30 And keep in mind that in the US we have the oldest electric grid in the world. It's also the least reliable electric grid in the world, uh, in terms of developing-- developed countries. 21:40 Right now, with all of the trends around load growth, it's causing a lot of excitement in the sector, but it's also putting a lot of pressure in terms of the regulatory framework and compact that we have. 21:53 Which is, utility will build that infrastructure and customers will pay for it. The problem is, is that utilities are having to build out new infrastructure with new customers coming online. 22:02 We have to upgrade our systems to account for new loads, but we also have to harden the system because we do have the worst reliability of any developed country in the world. 22:11 A-and we are getting battered by extreme weather, where if we don't start accounting for providing power and being able to withstand extreme events that are becoming more frequent, customers will defect. 22:24 The electric utility industry is having to grapple with all of this, and it means that they're spending more capital and trying to address this in really meaningful ways that includes innovation. 22:33 So I think the innovation ecosystem in the utility sector has never been better, and I think we're benefiting from that. 22:39 Those are some of the tailwinds that we have that we're riding is, utilities are turning towards solutions that can help do more with less, and Rhizome certainly fits into that category because what we do at the end of the day is we help optimize about thirty billion dollars today is being spent on adaptation and resilience in the utility sector in the US. 22:59 And so getting more with those dollars is what every C-suite has on their mind at the moment, and I think we fit in really well with that. 23:08 Now let's talk about the headwinds a little bit, where utilities are regulated at the state level. I appreciate you calling that out. 23:15 And your regulators are only more interested in terms of building resilience with their kind of local utilities, right, and being able to incentivize them in the right ways. 23:25 You had, through the bipartisan infrastructure law, around eleven billion dollars that was promised to go into the utility sector to in- specifically for resilience adaptation and for smart grid related stuff that obviously is now f- totally canceled. 23:40 And there is no federal support whatsoever when it comes to the ambitions that states and utilities have. So I wouldn't... 23:48 Other than that, you know, it's not like we're dependent on tax credits or anything of that sort in order for our business to thrive, but the lack of federal support certainly leaves a gap in terms of what could have been as we start to approach this challenge. 24:01 Yes. The swings in federal funding, but also R&D in grid resilience obviously kind of provides a whiplash effect to startups like yours. 24:09 WiFi in general, it does seem like there are energy companies and corporations and of course universities, research outfits that are still putting money together, doing grants and doing research efforts on this because there is such an understanding that it's so needed to have a reliable grid, especially again, with all the AI infrastructure that's being built out and the hopes of the electrification of the US economy. 24:30 So I'm, I'm kind of hopeful to-- that that's happening. Like, there is an understanding from the private and philanthropic world that, yes, we need to invest in this. 24:36 But clearly it's a challenge if you are-Yes, there was a world where there was billions of federal dollars coming into resilience, and now there's not. 24:43 And one thing to stress, right, and all of us think about this, and this is reflecting back on Climate Week as well, is sure, we, we know that we need adaptation resilience, but who's going to care, and then who's gonna pay for it, right? 24:55 And there are only so many buckets of money out there for things that people find valuable. 25:02 Keeping federal dollars aside, you can have states pay for adaptation resilience, you can have cities pay for adaptation resilience, or you can have utility rate payers pay for adaptation and resilience. 25:13 And then obviously, there's private sector capital that will come into play for various types of use cases. 25:18 When I think about the three buckets of state, city, and utility, we see the utility space as being extremely successful in being able to address adaptation and resilience head-on. 25:29 Because you're able to make cost-benefit decisions in front of regulators, and the value of resilience is very much a hot topic of conversation that I was observing in Climate Week. 25:40 We are getting to a point where we can actually quantify what that value is for utility regulators, and if so, then you can get rate payer dollars to actually pay for adaptation initiatives. 25:50 And so now we have globally, in the recent McKinsey report that came out on climate resilience and adaptation and how new technologies are gonna succeed, there's a hundred and seventy-five to two hundred billion dollars globally being spent on adaptation and resilience. 26:03 And that's because there is a successful regulatory case being made that this actually matters and there's value to be had here. 26:10 We need to do the exact same thing with states, and we need to do the exact same thing with cities. And then where private investors can make a buck off of it, we need to make the case for them as well. 26:20 And talking about dollars and cents here, it does seem like Rhizome's thesis business case is resonating. So you recently closed your seed round. I think you've raised around ten million altogether. 26:31 A lot of adaptation resilience startups find it difficult to raise money, but it does feel like utilities is such a clear-cut case about where there's added value. 26:40 So can you tell me about how your business case has resonated with investors? And also, you know, your seed round just closed. 26:46 You've got hopefully a bit of runway before Series A, but can you tell me about your hopes for growth down the line? Yeah. A-absolutely. 26:52 And for our pre-seed round, there is quite a bit of hesitancy i-in terms of what we're doing, primarily because we're selling software to utilities. 26:59 And I think most folks are bought in on the concept that resilience is becoming increasingly important, that utilities will want to quantify their climate risks on their systems and assets and actually do something about it. 27:13 I think that thesis has always been well understood, but the real challenge that we have is how do you actually develop a scalable go-to-market where you're a venture backable business? 27:21 And now I've been working with utilities for a long time, and importantly, my background in regulatory I think makes us uniquely positioned to craft the right message on how to improve resilience planning practices within a utility. 27:37 We, in about two and a half years, are working with ten utilities in three countries and are about to open up our fourth country, hopefully followed by a fifth going into the new year. 27:49 The reason being is because the message that we have really resonates with utilities in terms of quantifying risk, being able to manage it, reduce it, and then create that regulatory success. 28:02 Because when affordability is kind of in the balance over here, then creating the right narrative for regulators is, is really where many utilities at the C-suite level, their minds are at. 28:12 So where we were ended up getting folks to, is that we can actually deliver a strong message to the C-suite that allows them to pull the trigger on our solution. Not every solution be that way. 28:23 Overall, figuring out what are the levers you can pull to gain the attention of C-suite or VP levels at large corporations that actually make a decision around adaptation and resilience is gonna be a challenge that everyone has to go to, but we've did figure out what that sweet spot was in terms of product market fit. 28:42 And we're still on the journey, um, as we develop our product. We had really good early signals from large utility customers. 28:49 We were able to successfully make the case to investors that this is a scalable business model. 28:54 One of the best parts about working with utilities is that when you do start working with utilities, they're a very sticky customer. They tend to really lean on their approved vendors as trusted partners. 29:05 We do have the ability to continue to help them as they augment and change their plans, and as their conditions change in the future, we'll be there to support with many of their technology needs. 29:15 And what do you make of the competitive landscape for adaptation technology for your utilities as well? Because there seems to be, on the one hand, lots of different ways to kind of get in this space, right? 29:24 Some providing like digital twin technology, geospatial data. Some are doing more on the ground, like use of drones and visual sensors. 29:32 I've put together a little database of companies for clients, for subscribers, and I see when I kind of look for companies that you're familiar with, there's Buzz Solutions, there's AiDash, there's Overstory, there's TechnoSilver, Repath, TreeSwift. 29:45 Like, there's a lot of companies. They're all... Some of them doing slightly different parts of the utilities world, but it's, it's getting crowded in there. 29:51 What do you make of the competitive landscape, and how do you think you can keep your head above the parapet? Yeah. It, it's certainly growing, and I think every company actually has their own niche. 29:59 From all the companies that you mentioned, there are pots of money for just about each of them that you just mentioned. The other thing that I would say is that not all utilities are created equal, right? 30:09 You have some utilities that, you know, look at Avista in Washington that serves around three hundred, four hundred thousand customers, but off on the entire eastern front of Washington, right? 30:20 So they operate tens of thousands of miles of line, and they're what's known as a more sprawling rural customer. 30:25 Meanwhile, you have utilities that are m-more based in cities, like Con Edison in New York, right, that cover Manhattan, and it's a huge concentration of customers in one area, not a lot of overhead assets, so a more of an underground network to manage. 30:38 I think what you'll find is m-utilities will gravitate to different solutions based off of theirOwn system and characteristics and what they think will provide them with the most value. 30:47 At the end of the day, I see all of the companies that you mentioned having some degree of success in terms of providing value. 30:53 And at the end of the day, if you're not providing ROI, a utility will be rigorous about that. Unfortunately, I don't think those businesses are gonna scale. 31:00 Really, what's gonna distinguish the true success stories versus the others is the ROI metric, right? We'll also see some significant consolidation at some point, is my prediction, in the next few years. 31:11 As the space continues to mature, as technologies start to separate themselves, you will see some significant degree of consolidation. 31:18 Some of these companies are able to grow at the early stages mostly because you have a certain subset of a market that are very willing to buy based off of their existing characteristics. Yes. 31:28 I mean, that's capitalism, right? There'll be consolidation. There'll be some winners, some losers. The space is very large, and there is room for multiple solutions to flourish alongside each other. I do think... 31:37 I see this in lots of areas of adaptation startups. Those companies where there are personnel who understand the industry pretty well, like you've worked with utilities, you understand the pressures they're under. 31:48 You can speak their language quite quickly. Maybe that helps get into the door faster. 31:51 Whereas you also see other companies that are started up by pure tech heads, people with great software experience, who've probably put together a really good tool, but they have no idea how to talk to their potential clients, right? 32:00 [laughs] And so that's harder for them to make those connections. 32:02 And I think there needs to be this blend of innovation and tech side, but also, yeah, look, we're dealing with some industries that may be a bit set in their ways. 32:09 They've got a very complicated system built up around them. You need to be able to kind of cut through the thicket of jargon, regulation, bureaucracy, and really understand what motivates them and how to talk to them. 32:17 You kind of need that balance in order to succeed in this world. 32:20 If you were to ask me a few years ago, I would say that if you were a total tech head, and you think you have a really compelling solution for the utility sector, just hire a full-time BD person who has sold to utilities before, right? 32:32 Or just have someone who has some exposure and knowledge of the sector to really craft your BD, be in the conversation, structure the value prop, so on and so forth, right? 32:40 But now f- fast forward three years, and this is three years into Rhizome's journey. I think there are so many resources that have developed over the last decade around the innovation ecosystem. 32:51 So you have dedicated accelerators. 32:52 We just finished an accelerator in Australia called Energy Lab Scaleup, and their number one mission is to take cool technology companies, get them a lot of exposure to Australian energy companies, and then ultimately try to structure pilot projects, right? 33:06 I think through those types of mechanisms and means where utilities are being increasingly bought into, uh, those types of innovation events and innovation lovers that will start to close the gap where you need a middleman in terms of translator, right? 33:23 I think you can do a whole lot of learning in a short amount of time by gaining some exposure through those innovation types of ecosystems. Oh, that's an interesting perspective. 33:31 That's the role of accelerators and the role of all these kind of supportive infrastructure around startups, right, is to actually help to get to product market fit and help cut through some of the complications and actually get your product out there into the hands of users. 33:44 I still think with some industries it helps to have some background in that world. No doubt about it. Okay. Just finally, I wanted to just ask for your reflections on New York Climate Week. We were both there. 33:54 I spoke to a bunch of people about this, and what I find so funny about the Climate Week sort of wash up posts you see on LinkedIn and the articles is that you can tell how Climate Week is a kind of choose your own adventure, right? 34:04 Like, all the people I was talking to were saying, "Oh, yeah, adaptation resilience is the big thing. Everyone's talking about it." 34:08 Then I read my friends at CTBC, and they were saying, "Oh, it's all about energy and AI," 'cause that's where they're focusing, [laughs] right? 34:14 So you're, of course, not unbiased either because I'm presuming the events you went to, the people you were talking to, are very much in the grid world and adaptation world. 34:21 But can you give me your reflections on Climate Week and where you think the climate tech conversation is going in the US? Yeah. Well, first thing I'd say that, like y- you... 34:30 It was surprising to me how large it was, how many events that were, there were, given the lack of federal support, federal activity. 34:38 What feels like, y- you know, climate is less of an interesting thing for people today versus, you know, three, four years ago. 34:46 I learned a whole lot about new ones in agriculture and new forms of bioenergy, and of course, resilience and adaptation was, was top of mind for me as well. 34:56 And so that space and the number of events and the types of conversations seem to have elevated from even just last year, right? 35:03 And so I think the other thing that I noted is that the investor interest is still quite high. 35:11 I went to, to numerous events that were focused on both venture as well as growth equity investors and then in some cases, just big banks, and those people would not be there for no reason. 35:21 I think the outlook at all levels of the financial stack are still very keen and interested on the climate solutions that are gonna win here. 35:30 And I think everyone's been talking about, okay, now it's about providing customer value and making sure that you can generate a sustainable revenue model. 35:38 If you can generate a sustainable revenue model that stands the test of the political winds, then people are gonna be very interested in investing, and that was one of my key takeaways. 35:48 I find that so funny, though, because on one hand what you're saying is, is so sensible and obvious, but on the other hand, we've got the AI bubble, let's be honest. It's like revenue, revenue, shrevenue. 35:57 We just want growth, you know? So it's like the way to connect with investors, the way to connect with corporates is so different depending on where you are in the cycle. 36:03 It feels like a few years ago, climate tech, it was less about the revenue, more about growth potential, and now it's very much down to the dollars and cents. Yeah. 36:12 And I, I'd say that really has drawn a lot of attention to the grid, right? That intersection of AI and the grid has become super popular. 36:19 It is great for, again, attracting all of this excitement, but there are so many other folks who are not involved in the AI and energy or AI and grid conversation that still deserve attention, right? 36:32 So o- on the one hand, great for bringing folks together, but I hope that folks who are developing solutions in other part of the climate tech ecosystem are getting access to those investors or were able to demonstrate the value that they're creating as well. 36:44 And very finally, where else are you headed for this year in terms of conferences and convenings? I see that you, you... Rhizome's a sponsor of Red Sky Week in San Francisco, which is kind of wildfire-focused. 36:55 Can you tell me about that and tell me about other events that you're looking forward to this year? 36:59 Well, Louis, I just finished up about four or five intense weeks of travel, so I'm looking forward to a little bit of a break. [laughs] You're a startup. You're allowed to rest. 37:08 So Red Sky is, of course, our investor is Convective Capital, I think hosts the best wildfire-specific event of the year. That's happening on November fourth. 37:17 And then I have a couple of utility-specific events that I'll be going to as well. But really, I think the rest of the year is for visiting customers. L- luckily enough, one of our customers is in Prince Edward Island. 37:28 I gotta make sure to read my Anne of Green Gables before I go, but I'll be visiting them in November, which I'm excited about. Oh, beautiful. Yes. Well, I hope the weather treats you well. 37:36 And yeah, I hope you do get some rest. It has been a frantic conference convening season, and there is no rest for the startup founder, I understand. 37:43 But you've always impressed me, Mih, with, with your energy and your engagement. Really appreciate you taking the time with me today. I look forward to keeping track of your career and Rhizome's growth. 37:51 But for now, thanks so much, and have a great rest of your week. This was a pleasure. Thanks so much, Louis. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. 38:02 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodhill. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 38:10 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]