Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation, finance, tech, and policy. 0:11 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. 0:17 I'm back from a Europe-hopping vacation and raring to go with a bunch more interviews with top adaptation and resilience talent. Today I'm joined by Dr. 0:24 Paul Munday, a director at S&P Global Ratings, where he serves as a global climate adaptation and resilience specialist. 0:31 We discuss his team's recent research on companies' climate adaptation planning and lots, lots more. 0:36 Before we get started, just a note that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 0:43 Listeners like you can keep the lights on and support even more great content by heading to climateproof.news/upgrade. 0:50 You'll get two newsletters a week, access to exclusive data dashboards, and special reports, including the new Adaptation 10 series, a collaboration with the adaptation consultancy DSR and Partners. 1:01 Thank you for the support. Okay, in a minute my interview with Paul, but first let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:09 [swoosh] In finance, California lawmakers succeeded in putting a first of its kind climate adaptation bond on the ballot this November. 1:16 If approved by voters, it would authorize California to borrow $10 billion to finance projects for safe drinking water, drought, flood, water, and wildfire resilience, extreme heat mitigation, and much more. 1:27 In a nod to the importance of climate justice, the bill authorizing the bond says that at least 40% of the proceeds must provide meaningful and direct benefits to vulnerable populations or disadvantaged communities. 1:38 The vote on the bond will take place on November the 5th. 1:41 [swoosh] In policy, a new left of center labor government was swept into power in the UK, a political sea change that could have profound ramifications for the country's climate policy. 1:50 On adaptation and resilience specifically, labor's manifesto is short of details, but does commit the party to improve resilience and preparation across central government, local authorities, local communities, and emergency services. 2:03 This includes working with all stakeholders in the fire and rescue services to inform policy and establish national standards. 2:10 Elsewhere in the manifesto, the party talks about creating homes and places that increase climate resilience and promote nature recovery. 2:17 Planning reform and expanding house building are central planks of the party's program for government, and it's certainly welcome that climate proofing hasn't been forgotten in this context. 2:26 When it comes to business, labor says it will mandate financial institutions and large listed companies to implement credible transition plans, which are likely to include adaptation and resilience components given recent efforts by groups organized by the UK Transition Plan Task Force. 2:41 The party also wants to make the UK the green finance capital of the world, which surely bodes well for efforts to unlock private investment for adaptation and resilience. 2:50 [swoosh] And in tech, the Biden administration announced $504 million in financing for 12 tech hubs throughout the US. 2:58 One of these, the South Florida Climate Ready Tech Hub, is receiving $90 million to spin up solutions for sustainable and resilient infrastructure. 3:06 These include advanced concrete technologies that can protect communities in the path of extreme weather events. 3:12 Some of the money will also go toward financing workforce development programs and efforts to break down barriers within the climate and capital ecosystem. [swoosh] Right, that's this week's roundup. 3:22 Now on to our interview. [upbeat music] We're joined today by Paul Munday from S&P Global Ratings. Paul, where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. So, um, I'm calling from London. 3:35 Um, it's actually sunny here today, which is, uh, quite unusual. Um, and my role is the, the global adaptation resilience specialist at S&P Global Ratings. 3:44 So what that means is that I support my colleagues in, in, in ratings, um, and also in sustainable finance to try and help them improve the, the clarity of the credit and other impacts of physical climate risks. 3:57 Wonderful. Thanks for taking the time. So I've been interested in your work for, for many years now, and recently you and your team have been pumping out great content on physical risk and, uh, climate adaptation. 4:08 And there was a particularly interesting piece released, uh, a few weeks ago on adaptation plans produced by corporates and the content or lack of content thereof in these plans. 4:19 So I was wondering if you could speak a little bit about this, this body of work and talk about what was surprising or counter to your expectations in that analysis. 4:27 Yeah, good question, and I'm, I'm pleased you, you, you read it. Um, it was a bit of a labor of love [chuckles] in... It was a bit of a labor of love in many ways. 4:34 So I think that the genesis of that piece really was that, you know, a, a lot of my kind of work, um, since joining S&P has, has been to try and leverage some of the kind of climate data that we've got to understand how different entities may be exposed to, to physical risks, and through a credit lens, understand what the, the kind of outcomes may be. 4:53 But frequently, what I've not been able to do is just to try and dive a bit deeper into that kind of other side of the coin, so the kind of the, the, the this kind of adaptation and resilience component. 5:03 So understanding how, uh, companies are able to adapt to and cope with the physical impacts of climate change. We leveraged two types of, uh, assessments in, in doing the work. 5:12 So one was about 6,800 or so, um, responses from companies to the S&P Global Sustainable One, um, Corporate Sustainability Assessment. 5:23 Um, and then the second component was a, a kind of a deep dive, if you like, of about 130, uh, companies', um, adaptation plans. 5:31 And yeah, I mean, we, we revealed quite a lot of interesting findings, some of which, of course, were, were surprising I'd say. 5:38 That said, I would say that many of us in this kind of adaptation and resilience space perhaps are of the opinion that efforts to adapt are generally behind what the science is, is telling us and what's needed, and also in terms of the kind of impacts that we're seeing kind of play out globally across many different regions. 5:54 So in some ways there, there, there were some surprises. In many ways it was kind of par for the course. 6:00 But of, of those surprises, I think the-When we looked at the proportion of companies that had adaptation plans, so of that six thousand eight hundred or so responses, only about a fift-- about twenty-one percent, so about fifteen hundred or so companies reported that they had an adaptation plan. 6:16 So, and, and also I should say to be clear, like, what is an adaptation plan? That could be quite an obscure thing for some people. 6:24 So in the context of this work, that was defined as any plan to, to adapt, adapt to any climate risk across a company's value chain that a company's identified through a climate risk assessment. 6:37 So it could be a specific climate-related plan that, that is part of a wider risk assessment, or in, in some cases, we see this a, a lot more now, it could be a bespoke adaptation plan. So a s- a specific report. 6:51 Um, but suffice to say, not many companies reported that they had an adaptation plan in, in, in our sample. 6:59 I was gonna ask, because I haven't seen many examples of self-contained adaptation plans in glossy brochures or PDFs, right? 7:05 So adaptation plan, in your definition, is also, like, segments on adaptation within a company's task force for climate-related financial disclosure report or climate action report or annual report. 7:16 Are you counting those as part of the adaptation plan universe? Yeah, exactly. So, um, it, it can come in many different forms. 7:22 And actually for some, for, for some companies, this theme, I guess, falls under that kind of wider business continuity management type bucket. 7:30 So, um, we tended to see those-- that, that information in, in different locations. I would say on average, we saw fewer kind of bespoke adaptation plans, so specific reports on adaptation. 7:41 But they were certainly more frequent in certain sectors than others, um, like utilities, for example. Yes, that makes sense. 7:47 From my understanding, utilities have to be wary of water risks, and in the US over here, wildfire risks, of course, are a big, big deal. So which sectors do you believe need to ramp up their adaptation planning? 8:00 So yeah, we certainly saw kind of varying responses across sectors, and w- we know we pull out in the report a few examples. 8:07 In terms of the responses to companies that state that they have an adaptation plan, companies in the kind of energy sector, utility sector generally were quite, w-were quite high and, and it was relatively kind of low in many others. 8:19 So particularly those sectors that we'd probably argue were more kind of indirectly impacted by or exposed to physical risks so through their value chains, industrials, kind of consumer discretionary and, and others besides, telecoms, et cetera. 8:34 So there was definitely a, a, a different level of response, um, based upon the, the kind of sector that the companies found themselves in. And, and I also I would say that 8:44 one other, I guess, surprising thing was just the kind of implementation timelines of those plans where they were available. 8:50 And we found, although I mentioned about fifteen hundred companies have adaptation plans in our analysis, less than half of companies indicated that they were gonna implement their plans within the next ten years or, or less. 9:04 So a long timeframe to implement those plans. Yes, that implies to me that they have an idea of how they could be affected, but it's kind of still a piece of paper, the plan, right? 9:14 It's not something to be integrated into their actual business as usual. Otherwise, there would be timescales, there would be capital allocated to implementing these plans. 9:24 So when we're talking about how companies should put together adaptation plans, my understanding is that you need to start with a physical risk assessment, right? 9:32 How are wildfires, floods, storms going to affect, uh, my physical assets, disrupt my operations? 9:38 Can you tell us a little bit about the makeup of physical risk assessments in the adaptation plans you surveyed, and what can explain the seeming paucity of climate risk analysis on the physical side among these companies? 9:51 Typically, that kind of first step is, is some sort of a physical climate risk assessment. 9:57 So looking at your, your assets, your portfolio, and kind of understanding how they may be exposed to different types of climate hazards over time and usually under different, um, climate scenarios or shared socioeconomic pathways. 10:09 So that's usually what we see, and it's probably fair to say that many companies are, are in that part of the maturity curve. 10:15 So having undertaken some sort of kind of physical risk assessment and then tried to understand how do we interpret this information, what can we do with it? 10:23 And by that, I mean, okay, how do the outputs of that assessment, how could they be used in terms of understanding the, the types of measures that may be needed to try and adapt to and cope with those exposures? 10:34 And, and indeed, what are the sorts of costs that could be or should be associated with those? So I think that's sort of where a lot of companies, um, tended to be. 10:42 In the review of those a hundred and thirty adaptation plans, um, w-we certainly found the, the, the, I guess, the level of, um, progress or sophistication, if you like, of plans to, to vary quite considerably. 10:54 So both in a kind of a qualitative sense and also in a, a quantitative sense. 10:58 So looking at individual, just single assets and restricting risk assessments to single assets or a handful of assets versus a bottom-up assessment based on kind of quantitative climate data, there tended to be quite a difference in terms of the approaches that we use. 11:14 And, and that was for a number of reasons, I'd say as well, and, and some of which we've touched on already in, in terms of kind of companies maybe not being directly impacted. 11:23 They may be indirectly impacted, perhaps through their, through their value chains. 11:26 So if they're not seeing those, those sorts of impacts already, then they may have lower awareness, and therefore they may not have started to kind of take action and make progress. 11:35 And then also kind of overarching all of this, of course, this big umbrella of uncertainty, and I think that's probably a key challenge for, for many companies. 11:42 And that's both in terms of the uncertainty associated with when those types of hazards may play out, but also in terms of where and what could the impacts be if they do play out, and also the success of any measures that they do ultimately put in place as well. 11:58 So that for companies can be a bit of a challenge. It can be a bit of a stumbling block in terms of prioritizing adaptation resilience against a, a myriad of other-Competing objectives. 12:10 Also, I would say one of the reasons we perhaps see this differing levels of assessment and gaps as well was around awareness, and the, the climate literature and adaptation is, is pretty clear that where companies are more aware of physical risks and climate hazards, they tend to have made more progress. 12:28 That seems to make sense, right? If you're, you're seeing these- Mm. 12:31 -impacts on your doorstep within your operating footprints, then you're probably gonna have taken more action, and if you haven't, you may be slightly slower to, to make progress. 12:41 The other thing as well is around the intensity of ex-exposure. 12:44 So if you're more intensely exposed to these hazards, then and more severely-- likely to be more severely hit, then also you're probably more likely to have made, made, made progress. 12:54 And alongside that, a few other things around regulation, legislation that's driving companies to make changes as well. So there are companies that we know are on the front lines of climate risk. 13:05 We mentioned utilities, agriculture, arguably, of course, 'cause their operations take place in, in the open air and are subject to these extreme weather risks. 13:13 But there seem to be some companies that think they're, they are insulated or shielded from the worst of climate physical risks. 13:19 And in your analysis, you find that like communications and IT companies are less likely to have put together adaptation plans. 13:26 Now, we all know that different sectors of the economy are all interconnected, and that what happens to the one sector will rebound to impact some other sectors, uh, over time. 13:34 So I was just wondering how we can get companies to think of themselves as subject to climate risks or what factors should or could drive companies that are on the front lines of climate risk to consider adaptation. 13:46 No, that's a good question, and I think that the answer is a little bit kind of circular in a way, in the sense that y- there's value in undertaking a climate risk assessment. 13:56 Until you've done that process, it can be very difficult to understand where those potential exposures can come from. 14:02 And for many companies and the examples that you've used in telecom services and IT and those, those sorts of companies, 14:09 m-many of those exposures are likely to come through on an indirect basis, so through their-- through the value chains and, and equally kind of cascade into other sectors and, and, and what have you. 14:17 So I think the, I think the value is in the doing, so undertaking that assessment- Mm. -understanding all those kind of potential kind of pinch points, and that's not... 14:27 I've mentioned before, it's not necessarily an easy process to prioritize against many other competing objectives, um, for those types of companies. 14:34 But I'd argue that if you're in that, that bucket, that bracket of being kind of indirectly exposed, like those examples that we've, that we've mentioned, then maybe kind of understanding the, you know, the depths and the breadth of your potential exposures is probably should be a priority and, you know, carries a lot of potential value. 14:51 Yes. I personally wonder whether we're gonna see adaptation planning become incorporated into some of these regulatory mandates, uh, that are present in some jurisdictions. 15:00 I mean, you have in Europe, the, the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive that requires companies to report a lot of information on their climate physical and, and transition risks, which might spur adaptation planning. 15:12 We recently in the UK had the Transition Plan Task Force come out with guidance on incorporating adaptation into net zero transition plans, so that kind of is like a quasi regulatory nudge to companies. 15:25 So I'm wondering if we'll see regulation kind of nudge companies or the threat of regulation nudge companies into producing adaptation plans. Uh, that's my personal view. I'm not sure if you can comment on that. 15:35 It certainly could be. I mean, we certainly found in our analysis that there were a greater proportion of companies in Europe, for example, that were... 15:44 that, that reporting that they had an adaptation plan and with better implementation timelines, and that's arguably because of the, the, the stronger disclosure requirements in, in Europe and more stringent environmental legislation that's perhaps kind of prompting those companies to take action. 16:02 Okay. Now I wanna turn to the investor perspective. 16:05 We have a lot of institutional investor and finance adjacent listeners to Climate Proofers, and they're always talking to me about the need for data, data, data, data on physical risks, but also on how to kind of measure adaptation as a product or service that's used to protect a company's revenues or enhance their revenues. 16:25 So I was wondering what sort of data do good adaptation plans need to include to be decision useful for investors? 16:32 I can't speak for investors in, in terms of kind of what they're, what they find most useful, but I think generally speaking, most financial market participants are probably quite similar. 16:40 So quantitative information like information on kind of projected losses under different climate scenarios should an event occur, the, the anticipated or estimated costs of adaptation resilience measures that could be needed, they're probably the most important. 16:56 But then also in, in the context of those types of disclosures, it's the kind of qualitative data that provides the narrative as to how companies have, have kind of got to that decision point, got to that answer, is also equally important. 17:09 What are some of the assumptions? What are the climate scenarios that have been used, and, and why have particular scenarios been used? What are the timelines that have been used in any of those climate risk assessments? 17:19 So that sort of information taken together can help provide a relatively good picture about how companies may be expected to kind of cope with worsening climate hazards. 17:29 And indeed, in the report, I think it's table one, we provide a, an overview of, of eight different components of companies' plans that we were looking for. 17:38 And that they really kind of summarize the types of measures that we think help demonstrate companies that are likely to be kind of better placed to, to cope with and adapt to physical climate risks. 17:51 I guess the point is also sharing some of that information in those components that we list in the table, i.e. 17:57 the types of scenarios you're using, the timelines, whether you're inputting the outputs of your physical risk assessments into your financial planning. What are the cost of the measures? 18:06 Have you got metrics and targets? 18:08 All that information wrapped up into a narrative explaining how you've kind of gone through the process is likely to be extremely interesting and useful to financial market participants.So there are two things there that I think is interesting. 18:20 One is the focus on, yes, sort of the audit trail of data, right? If you have done a scenario analysis, what scenario did you use? What were the assumptions therein? 18:28 And I think this kind of goes back to some of the concerns investors have had in the past with transition plans and climate reports that they don't show they're working, right? Yeah. 18:37 So it's interesting that investors, and I feel other stakeholders are, with the adaptation side, also going, "Right, yes, okay, so you're giving me this number, or you're giving me this spiel, but what's the data to underpin it? 18:46 What's the assumptions you're using?" So I think that's a healthy development, and I'm glad to see it taking root here in the adaptation space. It is. 18:51 Although, otherwise, I'd say, I'd, I'd say that one of the challenges here, and this is maybe not, not a new point to your audience, but one of the challenges we always say around kind of adaptation resilience projects is that it, it matters what the asset is and it matters where the asset is. 19:06 So it's kind of both context and location specific. 19:08 And by, by that it means that ultimately the, the measures that are taken and employed on projects can be quite different, even if they could be located in relatively close proximity to one another. 19:20 And, and therefore, it's also quite hard to compare the success of those measures on a relative basis, even if those metrics and those targets, the KPIs actually exist, which is another challenge in this space more, more generally. 19:32 So it, it, it comes with its challenges to try and measure the success of these types of measures. 19:38 And, and indeed, even if that information were to be available, to, to also try and put that into a format that can be of use to people, um, working with financial data. 19:50 And yes, that brings me to the, the second thought that came up from when you were speaking earlier is that, so you and your team came up with these eight components to assess adaptation plans. 19:59 I'm aware of other entities that are trying to deconstruct adaptation plans in different ways, and there's been a spate of adaptation and resilience taxonomies to kind of guide investors on where to put their money if they want to further adaptation and resilience objectives. 20:13 So it feels like there's a great upswing of energy, a upswelling of energy on adaptation planning and adaptation analysis, uh, but there's no standardization yet, right? Yeah. 20:23 And I'm wondering whether we will see a greater kind of convergence towards standardization like we saw on the climate transition side as regulators and standard-setting bodies kind of pick up the pace. Yeah. 20:34 I think that's a, it's a, it's a great point, and I think that's probably where what we're kind of eventually coalescing around. We've, we've seen some, some good work and some reports released in the last month or two. 20:43 The UNFFI have done something, and there's the CBI also, um, presented some work on their resilience taxonomy. 20:50 And, and this is all off the back of stakeholders wanting more information about how they can compare projects and how they can understand better adaptation and resilience interventions. 21:01 And that's, I guess, where we've been, been lacking is having data allows that, that comparison, and that is something that has sorely been missed for s- for some time. 21:12 And I think we're, we're making some, some really strong progress over the last, over the last year or so. 21:17 What lessons do you think can be drawn from the climate transition plan process, the net zero plan process that can be applied to drafting adaptation plans? I suppose we've touched on a few, right? 21:27 Providing your workings, right, so providing the assumptions- Yeah... and the data auditing beneath your, the numbers that you come out with. 21:35 But are there any other thoughts on, on how the transition plan process can be used to inform the adaptation plan process and whether there are any new skills and disciplines needed by corporates to actually create effective adaptation plans? 21:47 Yeah. So I mean, there are a lot of transition plans available. Mm-hmm. The quality- That's true... I would say also varies quite considerably, and that's for good reason. 21:58 Whilst we've seen lots of guidance, lots of disclosure frameworks in that space, ultimately companies can choose to interpret that guidance and those disclosure frameworks as they, as they like, and the result is that there's a range of approaches and inherent, inherently outcomes and quality of those outcomes. 22:16 And, and I think we, we see the same for adaptation resilience plans as well, and, and this is linked to the point that we just, just made. 22:22 There's, there is guidance available as to how information should come together and could come together, the types of tools that you may, you may need. 22:30 But it, it can be a challenge to, to do that in a comparable way, and I think we've, we also see that in the transition space. 22:37 I'd say i- in terms of some of the lessons learned, as I alluded to ear- earlier, more detail is, is often always better, I'd say. 22:45 Some transition plans are bespoke with lots of kind of detailed information on specific, um, actions, while others could be the, the, the polar opposite, and one arguably has kind of more utility, um, than that, than the other. 22:59 And, and I used the point earlier about providing that narrative about the work that you've done and how it's all kind of come together. 23:05 I think that's, um, an extremely important point in, in, in this sense, helping people kind of understand that, that journey that you've been on, um, and the assumptions that you've made is incredibly, incredibly important. 23:15 Um- There's a real storytelling aspect involved, huh? I think so. Yeah, I think so, and for anyone that's kind of been through this process, I'm sure they'd, they'd, they'd agree with that. 23:24 Also, it's not straightforward. It's not straightforward. It takes a lot of time and effort to produce an adaptation plan, and the same for transition plans. 23:34 It's not something that can be done really, really quickly, and I think it's fairly obvious in the instances where that, that has been the case. So taking time to do things properly is also really important. 23:44 It's probably a lesson that we can kind of take more, more generally. Also, one thing I would say is that I think the value in these, these plans is i- i- it's really the, the plan itself rather than in the planning. 23:55 So how is that plan integrated into companies? If it's part of the, the kind of sideshow, if you like, then, um, it becomes less of a priority. 24:05 So a good plan needs input from across the company's functions and, and to... 24:11 in order to be most effective, and it needs to be something that the company has really, um, really kind of embedded and ingrained within their, um, within their kind of DNA. 24:19 Lastly as well, you said about the kind of skills and, and what have you that might be needed.I think the skills are probably already there. 24:27 It's kind of how they come together and how effectively that, that plan is, is ultimately implemented, kept up to date, monitored, that's likely to lead to companies being able to adapt to and cope with physical climate risks going forward. 24:41 Well, I was wondering whether we're gonna see more large companies hire chief meteorologists, right? 24:45 I know a number of insurance companies and banks have chief meteorologists, uh, but I'm wondering if you'll see more companies, uh, embrace that sort of profession and climatologists. Uh, but- Maybe... 24:56 I don't have any data to support that. [laughs] Yeah. May-maybe. 24:59 I think there's certainly you'll be aware of the, uh, the kind of wave of interest in, in, in folk with kinda sustainability credentials in the, in the last few years since, I guess, since kind of COVID, really, and that- Absolutely... 25:11 that, that wave, I think, continues to, to be quite strong. So, yeah, whether we'll see more hires, uh, in that space, I'm not sure. 25:17 But certainly it, it, it would be fair to say I'd, I would argue that companies, particularly in the kind of in financial markets are, are starting to understand the, the, the benefits of that, that type of experience and how it can be useful in their understanding and interpreting of, of, of the risks. 25:34 Now zooming out from the corporate level, S&P, your team also produced recently information on physical risks to municipalities in the US and you've also created great work on physical risk at the country level, like effects- Yeah... 25:49 of GDP. 25:50 So I was wondering if you could speak to, to that, those work streams and also, again, I suppose, to what level of readiness are you seeing from, from sovereigns and municipalities vis-a-vis corporates on adaptation? 26:02 Yeah. Good questions. Yeah, you're right. 26:04 So we-- I, I produced a, a study, uh, late last year, I think it was in November, called Lost GDP, and that was looking at the potential economic losses from physical risk to, to countries. 26:14 And we found on average about 4.4%, um, of global GDP, um, per year could be, could be at risk from, from kind of worsening climate hazards and that was to, that was to 2050 under SSP3 7.0, so like a slow transition scenario. 26:31 And, and I think to put that into context, 4.4% doesn't sound that much, but- Mm... when we think about, say, COVID in, in 2020 and the kind of im-impacts on global GDP there, that's about 3.4%. 26:44 So we're talking about kind of a cl- a COVID plus event each year without adaptation. Um, and- That's the key, isn't it, though? Without adaptation. Yeah. 26:53 So you're kind of showing what the worst case would be if, if governments and corporates did nothing beyond what they're doing today. Yeah. So it, it's quite a, it's quite a stark finding. 27:01 And, and more so with that particular piece, of course, it was those countries that were kind of more vulnerable to the physical impacts of climate change, so low, low-middle income countries, they're expected to be the most exposed and, and see the greater losses from, from physical risks. 27:16 And that, that was-- There's a bit of an irony there in the sense that it's those, those countries that have arguably kinda contributed much less to the, the kind of climate, climate crisis. 27:27 Um, equally, one, one thing we did in that piece as well, um, and that kinda links back to, to kind of adaptation, I guess, is that we try to understand how countries may be more, more or less ready to adapt to and cope with physical risk. 27:40 So we produced this kind of readiness component, this readiness, um, assessment. Mm. And, and really that was leveraging our institutional and economic assessments from our sovereign credit rating. 27:50 So it, it's really saying if you've got a stronger economy and you've got strong institutions, all things being equal, you're probably more likely to be able to cope with and adapt to, uh, worsening climate hazards. 28:01 And we, we see that in many economies. 28:03 So countries like, you know, Singapore, for example, battered by storms and, and heat waves and those sorts of things, but actually the, the realized losses in terms of, you know, GDP impacts are actually relatively small one, and that's because of, that's because of adaptation. 28:17 So we tried to pick up those sorts of kind of nuances in, in that piece. And then more recently you mentioned this research that we did called Navigating Uncertainty based on kind of- Mm... US local governments. 28:27 That was another, that was another bit of work that was trying to understand within the US, um, how are US counties likely to see change in exposures to climate hazards, um, over, over time. 28:39 And we've worked with our, our colleagues in S&P Global Sustainable1 to produce a, 28:45 a data set that, that tries to, um, help us kind of understand those types of trends that, that may ultimately be kind of useful in our, in our, um, credit analysis as well. 28:56 So i-in, in the round, I think that, those research pieces try and tell this story about how different actors, be it kind of countries or corporates or US local governments, could be, could potentially be exposed, but also how those, um, potential kind of impacts may play out over time given efforts to, to adapt and build resilience. 29:16 It's fascinating how physical risks and adaptation can manifest on different levels and this idea at all levels of ada-adaptive capacity I find really interesting, like the flexibility, the resources, uh, the expertise necessary to adapt to, to changing climate conditions is, is different amongst different companies within sectors, across sectors, and of course within and across countries as well. 29:39 So a, a country that has essentially a, a monoculture agricultural economy, their adaptive capacity might be very, very low. 29:46 But then developed world nations that have diversified services sectors may be able to, to adapt more quickly, uh, and more profitably to climate impacts. 29:56 You know, and it, it's probably no surprise that in the, the work that we did there on lost GDP, it's those kind of lower, lower middle-income countries whose economies are, are, are more likely to rely upon agriculture, for example. 30:10 And in our, in our modeling, the, the kind of heat-related impacts on agriculture were, was something that kind of ultimately drove those kind of losses. 30:18 So that's one of the reasons that we kind of saw more heat-related impacts in kind of lower and lower middle-income countries because of that kind of agricultural component of, of kind of countries' economies. 30:27 My last question is one I ask all my climate proofer interviewees. It's what are you focusing on over the next 12 months, and what, what are you kind of looking forward to studying as part of your, your work?Yeah. 30:38 So, um, a number of things. I feel like in many ways I've kind of scratched the surface in terms of the, the research that, that I've been doing. So expect more of the same. 30:48 I'd like to kind of dive a bit deeper into certain sectors to understand how companies in different sectors may be kind of exposed, but also crucially this kind of adaptation component. 30:58 So understanding more about some of the bespoke actions that those types of companies in certain sectors are, are undertaking and employing and, and those that aren't, and equally kind of doing that through a credit lens. 31:09 What ultimately could be the impacts on, on our view of credit worthiness in those, those types of cases. So that, that's gonna take up quite a large proportion of my time, um, over the next, the next 12 months or so. 31:21 And, and equally, it's fair to say that there's, in the work that I've done so far, there's, there are always a number of kind of next steps and things that we'd like to do to try and improve those analyses. 31:30 So in the, the risky business piece, looking at corporates, trying to maybe expand that analysis out to more companies in the component where we looked at 130 plans, it'll be... 31:40 I think it'd be fascinating to kind of expand that analysis out to many more companies in, in different geographies and different sectors and so on and so forth. 31:47 So there's a lot to keep me busy, and I think the challenge in my role is trying to prioritize what's, uh, what's gonna be most useful because when I'm producing research as a core part of my role, it, it's got to be helping us answer or get greater clarity to a question that, that's come through either from my colleagues in credit or through my colleagues in sustainable finance. 32:11 So yeah, it can be a challenge to prioritize. Plenty to do over, over the next 12 months. Well, I always look forward to your research, and I encourage all listeners to, to follow Paul on LinkedIn. It's Paul Munday. 32:23 M-U-N-D-A-Y, correct? Correct. And you can also sign up to S&P's myriad newsletters and Sustainable1 content as well, which has some great stuff in it, which I follow a lot as, as a Climate Proof editor. 32:35 We always look forward to seeing what you've got coming out, Paul. Thank you for your time today. Really enjoyed it. Have a lovely rest of your week. Thanks so much, and thanks for having me. 32:44 Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 32:54 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]