Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone. Welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about climate adaptation and resilience, finance, tech, and policy. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter and long-term climate risk and finance nerd. You can check out Climate Proof today at climateproof.news. 0:21 Today's climate proofer is Sabrina Nagel, global policy and finance advisor at the Atlantic Council's Resilience Center and adaptation and resilience finance lead with the UN High-Level Climate Champions team. 0:33 We talk about changing the financial industry's perceptions of adaptation and resilience investments, what policy and regulatory levers can be pulled to get more private capital into climate proofing activities, and efforts to create adaptation investment taxonomies. 0:47 But before that, a quick whip around some of the main adaptation and resilience stories. [swoosh] Framework fever has taken hold of the financial industry. 0:55 A bundle of overlapping adaptation and resilience financing guides, taxonomies, and frameworks have been published in recent weeks, all of which promise to unlock private capital for climate proofing projects. 1:06 The latest was published by the United Nations Environment Program Finance Initiative and Adaptation and Resilience Investors Collaborative. 1:13 This focuses on ANR impact and was drafted by and for development finance institutions. 1:18 The framework proposes a conceptual model for judging investments based on their ANR impact and recommends a series of metrics for tracking their, well, impactfulness. 1:27 As I said, there's been lots of ANR financing frameworks of late. 1:31 The UNEP ARIC contribution follows a guide to ANR financing out of Standard Chartered, KPMG, and the UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction, the Climate Bonds Initiative's forthcoming resilience taxonomy, and the Global Adaptation and Resilience Investment Working Group's so-called CRISP framework. 1:49 Now, I'm all for the industry brainstorming away on how best to classify ANR investments, but there seems to be a lot of duplication going on. I look forward to some order being brought to the chaos. 1:57 [swoosh] In adaptation tech, partners at Mazarin Ventures, a Chicago-based fund, provided a snapshot of how early-stage investors are thinking about the climate adaptation technology market. 2:07 An open survey put out by the company was responded to by over 100 VCs, PEs, and angel investors, who ranked their investment priorities by type of climate risk. 2:17 Leading the field, two-thirds of respondents said their top priority are cat investments that tackle climate induced water risks. 17% said solutions that address fire risks are top priority. 2:28 Few said the same of wind or heat risks, though heat was the leading second priority response. 2:34 When it comes to sector priorities, 70% said they want to invest in adaptation for the utility sector, while 65% put agriculture in their top three. 45% said the same about the finance, insurance, and real estate sector. 2:47 Interestingly, despite the buzz around artificial intelligence solutions for climate adaptation and resilience, of total survey respondents, only 13% said they were solely focused on software offerings, while 43% wanted to jump on hardware-oriented investments. 3:02 [swoosh] Let's round things off by summing up the Biden administration's recent big spending commitments for adaptation and resilience. 3:08 Earlier this month, feds made available $830 million to climate proof America's transport infrastructure. The cash will be spent to harden roads, bridges, and more against climate shocks. 3:19 37 states, Washington DC, and the Virgin Islands will all get a piece of the pie. 3:24 This came hot on the heels of Biden's budget proposal for fiscal year 2025, which earmarks billions for the climate fight, including $7.5 billion to stimulate the development of climate resilient, affordable housing and $23 billion to address flood, wildfire, drought, and other extreme weather risks. 3:41 There's also a proposed $500 billion contribution to the Green Climate Fund, a UN-backed entity that invests 50% of all its resources in adaptation. 3:49 Few, if any, of the climate tax and spending ideas are likely to be adopted by the Republican-controlled House this year, given red state lawmakers' hostility towards such initiatives. 3:58 Still, the proposal offers a blueprint for how a reelected Biden, backed by a Democratic Congress, would seek to advance his climate priorities. [swoosh] Right, that's this week's roundup. 4:07 Now on to our interview with Sabrina Nagel. [upbeat music] Sabrina, where are you joining us from, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. 4:17 I'm, um, joining you from, um, close to Munich in Bavaria in Germany, and I'm the global policy and finance advisor of the Atlantic Council's Resilience Center. That is one of the hats I'm wearing. 4:31 The second hat is that I'm the adaptation and resilience finance lead at the Climate Champions team, and these positions actually give me the privilege to stay on top of the developments in the private sector on what is happening in financing and adaptation resilience, and really looking into how we convene actors from the public sector, from the private sector to create solutions to scale adaptation resilience. 5:00 And then the second component, apart from developing this, uh, thought leadership, is looking into designing suitable policies for... that we actually need to scale up financing for adaptation resilience. Thank you. 5:14 So what does that mean on a day-to-day basis? It sounds like a lot of stakeholder management to me. Yeah, absolutely. So I'm in touch with a lot of partners. 5:23 I'm reading a lot of reports, and I think, honestly, one thing that I appreciate is that I can reach out to whoever I want to in the financial industry and speak with them about adaptation resilience. 5:37 So one thing that is an integral part of my everyday job is listening, so I'm listening a lot. What is happening? What are your issues, your needs? Where would you need more support? 5:48 And then thinking about how we can support with our network. And today I'm the one who's gonna be doing most of the listening, and I want to hear your answers to some of the questions we've been discussing. 5:58 Uh, and first of all, the question I have is there's a common perception that investments in adaptation and resilience, ANR-That they lack attractiveness from a financial standpoint. 6:08 So my question to you is, how can financial professionals counter this narrative, and can you provide any data or case studies that showcase the economic value of investing in A&R? Yeah. 6:19 So I think I could spend this entire episode about... speaking about this question and bringing arguments why we should invest into adaptation resilience and why it's actually attractive in the short and long term. 6:33 And I also think it's fair to say that financial institutions and professional who say it's not attractive enough actually already have adaptation resilience in their portfolios without knowing it. 6:45 I think, in general, what I see is that there is an increasing institutional realization that the impacts of climate change are not going to go anywhere. 6:54 They're a macroeconomic issue and risk, and with risk always comes opportunity. So I think adaptation resilience is oftentimes not framed as an opportunity. 7:07 And one thing that I've been doing in my free time is really looking into company market valuations that offer adaptation tech solutions such as drip irrigation systems and water management, flood management systems. 7:21 And they are going through the roof, especially during the past year. So I think that is one of the really strong arguments that innovation is rising and there is demand, and company values are increasing. 7:35 So yeah, I think if VCs should do one thing, it's investing into early stage adaptation tech startups. So that's one layer of the argument, um, that I can bring. And then there are also, um, more macroeconomic studies. 7:50 For example, from the Global Commission on Adaptation that found out that investing 1.8 trillion globally in five priority areas could generate total net benefits of 7.1 trillion. 8:04 The, the language of adaptation and resilience financing is often, if you invest in this today, you'll get X amount of net benefits tomorrow. 8:12 I think the challenge is from a financial standpoint is that these net benefits can be seen not just to come to the investor, but they're coming to society, they're coming to the public good. 8:22 And actually maybe investors are like, "Okay, how much of that net benefit am I actually gonna receive?" 8:26 And this language that investing, let's say, $3 a day means you avoid $7 of loss tomorrow still doesn't really work to kind of get investors excited about spending money on adaptation projects. 8:37 Is, is that what you're seeing as well, or have I got that wrong? Yeah, totally. So I mean, where you actually see relatively, um, short-term benefits is in agriculture. 8:47 If a client has implemented crop resilience or whatever adaptation solution. But then when it comes to infrastructure, the benefit sometimes unfolds after 30 years, and that is an issue. And I think 9:02 that is actually the sweet spot where public finance should support to bridge that to actually even if the benefits come in at a later stage. So how can we actually make it attractive for investors now? 9:17 And one thing that is... that I find quite interesting is to also think about how can pension funds that actually have a much longer time period could invest into long-term solutions. So I think 9:30 this is exactly the discussion that we need to have. How can public finance support so it becomes attractive for investors now and not in 10 years when it already hurts too much? 9:43 I found something that I found quite interesting and that could be of immediate interest. Different. 9:48 I found an, uh, a study from the International Labor Organization, and they have analyzed how rising temperatures impact productivity of workers. 9:59 So even a temperature rise of 1.5, um, degrees is projected to reduce global working hours by 2.2, um, percent worldwide by 2030. Doesn't sound a lot, but that would cost the economy 1, uh, 2.4 trillion US dollars. Ouch. 10:16 So I think investing, like for a company to invest into creating cool working environments is pretty straightforward argument. Mm-hmm. Yes. 10:27 When you put the financial implications of all these kind of cutaways from global productivity, it can add up to a great deal, and I think that sort of language does speak to investors who want to avoid those sort of losses in, in the future. 10:41 Looking at the risk side of things now, could you speak about efforts to make adaptation resilience a part of credit assessments by financial institutions, right? Because that's the other thing they're looking at. 10:51 Okay, is this investment, is it likely to become more risky? Is it more likely that the borrower is gonna default on their loan because of, uh, climate risks? So what are you seeing in that space? 11:02 So I think when it comes to only looking at integrating physical risk assessments, insurers are pretty much at the forefront of analyzing that and integrating that into their risk models. 11:16 So I think the insurer side is much more advanced. 11:19 And then when we look at financial institutions such as banks or microfinance institutions, how they integrate, um, adaptation resilience into the credit assessment is not mainstreamed yet. 11:32 So of the financial institutions I know of, it's not many, but from the ones I know that they're doing it, they're based in emerging markets. 11:43 So they are most vulnerable to the impact of climate change, so they started actually integrating it because they know it makes sense for us as a financial institution. And as said, for some, they're piloting it. 11:57 For others, it's a standard procedure. 11:59 For clients of a certain size, especially for most vulnerable sectors such as infrastructure and agriculture, to always look at what is the exposure of the given asset or company-What is the sensitivity of the economic activity, and how is the adaptive capacity of the client, and how can that be increased by an adaptation solution? 12:23 When you request a loan, you have to go through a variety of questions that determine the risk and performance indicators, and adaptation resilience and integrated it into the credit assessment is nothing other than that. 12:38 It's breaking down adaptation resilience into a battery of questions that then create an indicator, and then the financial institution that I'm aware of, they use this knowledge to inform their clients about, "Oh, okay, I can actually see you're quite exposed to drought," for example, when they're producing cotton. 12:58 You should really think about drip irrigation systems. 13:02 It's an extra layer of, of due diligence then that some financial institutions are using, and it does seem to me that there are those who are at the front lines, and it does seem to be emerging markets, uh, entities with lots of, like, coastal properties that are subject to, like, storm surge and are worried about sea level rise. 13:18 They're the ones who are really taking this to heart and, and trying to ensure that client physical risks are incorporated in their credit assessments. 13:24 But it still seems like a niche thing, at least on the bank side, but obviously you're dealing with, uh, investors and stakeholders who are more on the front lines and, and it's good to know that this is happening in the most vulnerable regions. 13:35 Absolutely. And I think the future, it's going to move away from a niche. 13:39 I think adaptation resilience metrics should and will become part of every financial decision-making in the future, 'cause we have to because climate change is not going to go away. 13:51 And also, what I find really interesting and important is from the experience of our partners that are doing this, they are quite successful with it, and even if they're looking at portfolio level physical climate risk assessments, they can see, okay, we should really speak with this and that client and recommend, uh, maybe a loan that supports them to implement an adaptation solution that reduces their vulnerability. 14:18 If you integrate these indicators, it opens, again, opportunities, creates data insights, and the data insights that we see is that clients with adaptation solutions in place have lower credit risks and lower loan defaults. 14:35 Okay, let's spin it to, uh, the other side of the equation to the, like, the government and public sector side of things. 14:40 And I wanted to ask from your experience, what levels of government, at local, regional, national, are leading innovative approaches to climate adaptation financing? A- and what can we learn from those models? 14:51 I think that the frontline communities are the ones innovating today how they can support each other and invest into adaptation resilience, for example, through community-based lendings because oftentimes the local governments just don't have the money to support them or financial institutions, or they are not in- integrated into financial institutions. 15:15 They don't have access to finance. So I think- You're talking even below the level, sorry, of, like, a, a regional government. You're talking about actual communities, individual villages, towns or, or counties. Exactly. 15:26 And what I've just heard now in discussions with partners again is the governments would really like to support with money. 15:33 They just don't have it, and even if they have projects and program funding for two years, it's gonna run out. So I think that is what we generally see in local governments. 15:45 Of course, there's big differences between developing countries and developed countries as well. And I mean on paper, it's multinational funds and DFIs that are financing adaptation resilience. 15:59 In fact, it's 98% of tracked global adaptation finance that comes from governments and public resources, but not only. 16:08 And I think the magic happens when these multilateral funds are actually used to reach the most vulnerable to climate change and forefront communities. 16:21 And there is an example that I'd like to share, and it's a blended finance mechanism, which I'm in general a big fan of. 16:29 And blended finance can be many things, but it basically means to combine different risk layers, so combining public finance and to use it to attract institutional investors, for example. Mm-hmm. 16:43 And there is a fund that is called the Quali Fund from the Spanish impact investor Gava Capital, 16:50 um, and they are currently fundraising quite successfully from institutional investors targeting, um, smallholder farmers in developing countries. 17:00 And in this case, funding from the Green Climate Fund has been used for a first loss tranche, and then the Spanish Development Finance Institution, COFIDES, has supported with further guarantee layers. 17:14 And that actually created a sweet spot for institutional investors to make this an attractive commercial investment to invest into this fund. 17:22 And then Gava is going to place the investments into microfinance institutions and small and medium enterprises in developing countries. 17:32 And I think that's a pretty good example how multinational funds on the global level can be used to reach forefront communities with finance for adaptation resilience. 17:44 Yes, I often think of blended finance as being a way to kind of multiply or amplify the effects of, of public capital, right? Yeah. 17:50 For a smaller outlay, uh, and for assuming the first risk of loss of an investment, uh, uh, a public financial institution can actually crowd in a lot of, of private capital, right? So that's the benefit. 18:02 I mean, one thing I sometimes think about though, especially when I read about very big commercial banks, uh, getting into this space, like they want to invest in projects that might actually be very beneficial to them.But they kind of don't want to take, you know, that first loss of risk, and it's like, okay, so we're subsidizing private investors in a way? 18:18 Yeah. And there's kind of a tension that I find a bit awkward, a bit icky. 18:21 Uh, so I wonder what you kind of think about that, and whether actually th- the benefit of crowding in private finance is worth the kind of, the pain of having essentially public money, uh, bail them out if things go wrong. 18:33 I agree with you, and it's a good argument, and we should definitely not forget about that. At the same time, what I see sometimes is in countries where there's also not a lot of public funding, 18:47 the big commercial banks even sometimes come in where the, the government should come in. 18:52 For example, during, um, the COVID crisis, the financial institutions themselves helped to support local communities and supported them with, with their loan defaults and stepped in. 19:06 At the same time, you could argue, well, that's actually the operational risk that every commercial bank actually has, and it's, it's an important discussion. 19:15 We could also argue private finance institutions should take much higher risk, and I think they should, and they could, and they will if the impact of climate change force them to do so. Mm. 19:31 Keeping on blended finance then, I have a question for you about scaling that up, right? 'Cause I keep hearing like- Mm-hmm... to scale adaptation finance and blended finance is the key. 19:40 Uh, and so I'm wondering, like, where's the blocker? Is it on the private finance side? Do, uh, multilateral development banks and public financial institutions, do they need to scale things up? 19:48 Is there an issue with like lack of taxonomies or, or kind of regulation? What do you see is something that could scale this massively? Yeah. 19:56 It's such an important question because wherever I look, everyone says, "We need more blended finance." 20:03 But when you look at what the practitioners are actually doing and gather capital in designing this, so it's a meticulous design, it's a multi-year process, and the hurdles are oftentimes that it just takes a very long time to sign all the contracts with the multilateral development funds. 20:23 So this is really something that I know is repetitive and has been said so many times, and I know that multilateral development funds are working on speeding that up, but it's still not fast enough. 20:37 So if you still need two to three years to develop an adaptation fund, that's just too slow. So I think this is really a point where we need to make de-risking instruments much easier accessible. 20:51 The same time there's a tension, again, you need to due diligence to really make sure that public funding is spent in a meaningful way. But this is something I hear repeatedly. 21:02 There's a lot of bureaucracy, you're saying, so we need to cut, kind of cut through some of the red tape. 21:05 And I do believe at the G20 level there has been discussions about making it easier for like the World Bank and the IL- IMF to get money out the door. So is that the sort of initiatives you're talking about? Absolutely. 21:16 I think it really means that we need to look into the international financial architecture and how capital is, public capital is made available for countries, but also for asset managers in general that want to design these kind of funds. 21:31 And then I really don't let the argument count that adaptation resilience is too complex or that we don't have the taxonomies. Mm. 21:39 I think it's all there, and we as humans are so smart in finding innovative ways if we want something to really get done. So I think it's a matter of willingness really. 21:54 I think it's also a matter of willingness and, and leadership to really get the forces behind scaling blended finance up. 22:05 I, I often compare, like, where we are with the A&R space with the kind of net zero decarbonization space, right? 22:10 There was a massive upswelling of climate activism that put this on the agenda, and then there was kind of formal take up by public institutions, and then private institutions followed. 22:20 And I still feel, yeah, we're still almost in the advocacy and activism phase of, of the A&R debate, right? 22:24 Because, uh, most of it is, is public money still, and there's still a kind of lack of education or uncertainty about how to implement A&R amongst public and private financial institutions. 22:35 So I still think we're a bit early on in that journey than we are with- Yeah... decarbonization and net zero. 22:41 But still, beyond blended finance though, what other policy levers could be pulled to help free up private finance and that could be like securities regulation or bank capital requirements or insurance rules. 22:52 Anything come to mind? I think mandatory physical risk assessments is really important. And I know there is backlash in these discussions as well. 23:04 I think these kind of regulations need to come with safeguards that ensure that it doesn't really lead to financial exclusion of really exposed assets, companies, individuals. So that is one point. 23:19 And because what's happening right now is some institutions are doing it, but they don't really want to mainstream it in their institution because they think if we do, it's gonna put us in a, in a market disadvantage. 23:33 So it needs to happen for everyone. 23:35 Then the next step is to integrate adaptation resilience metrics, so not only physical climate risk assessments, but also thinking about how do we create adaptation resilience and integrating these into financial decision-making processes will be really important. 23:54 The next one is binding taxonomies, regulatory taxonomies. We see that with the EU taxonomies that has adaptation in it as well. It's a binding taxonomy. 24:06 And a lot of taxonomies that are being developed are not regulatory, for example, in Mexico or other countries. And the next part is- Or they're principles based and they're su- they're too kind of like- Yeah... 24:18 fluffy, and they can be interpreted in different ways. Yeah.Absolutely. 24:21 And I think, you know, I'm happy about every national taxonomy that is coming out because it provides orientation for the ones who want to get started, but it just doesn't have the power that it could actually have. 24:35 And the other point is mandatory adaptation planning for companies of a certain size. Mm-hmm. There has been reports recently how little companies actually have adaptation plans. 24:47 I think 20% of the companies that have been surveyed, and it has been a couple of thousands, don't have an adaptation plan, and only half of them plan to implement them in the next 10 years. 25:01 So I think mandatory adaptation planning and implementation will be key. And then the next step is to think about additional incentivizing policies, and that's where we oftentimes don't have the answers. 25:16 We don't understand what's the macroeconomic effect if we, if we have tax credits for companies that have an adaptation solution in place. Just an idea. Yeah. 25:27 I think of policy as providing carrots, sticks or data, right? Yeah. 25:30 And so, like the stick is, okay, if you're a bank, we're gonna increase your capital requirements if you're not taking into account climate risk a certain way, or if you're an insurer, you're gonna be subject to greater, like, scrutiny by the regulator. 25:41 The carrot side of the debate, I think, has been really empowered by the Inflation Reduction Act over here in the US- Yeah... and the Green New Deal in Europe, right? 25:50 You know, tax credits are attractive for, for companies that want to grow, and we've seen like a big, you know, pull forward in terms of renewable capacity and, and clean energy development in the US because of that. 26:01 But then it's also controversial 'cause it's like the government giving money away to private companies essentially [laughs] to do something beneficial, but it's still, like, sometimes doesn't look so good in, in the public, public eye. 26:12 And then the data side of it though, I think, is where you're coming into it when it- when you talk about adaptation plans and kind of like physical risk assessments and taxonomies, right? 26:20 Because then if you kind of mandate certain data, then you kind of hope the market will see that data and react accordingly, right? 26:26 And that's why there's been such a push behind climate-related financial disclosures and transition plans. Yeah. 26:32 And it is interesting that you've mentioned adaptation plans, 'cause that hasn't been into the conversation until pretty recently. And I do know that the UK's Transition Plan Taskforce came out recently- Mm-hmm... 26:42 with guidance on adaptation plans, but it's still one of many other topics that are covered within a transition plan umbrella. 26:49 Uh, and so that kind of leads me to my next question, which is, what are the insights and strategies from the kind of climate mitigation, climate transition side that you think can be used to boost adaptation finance? 26:59 And you mentioned a- adaptation plans, we'll take that as one, but any examples from the, kind of the fight for net zero that you think could be applied to the fight for climate resilience and a- adaptation? Yeah. 27:09 I think it's a really important and interesting question, and unfortunately, I'm not old enough to analyze how it developed in the past [laughs] 13 years. Mm-hmm. 27:21 But, you know, oftentimes I hear that adaptation resilience is just too complex and mitigation isn't, because you can break it down into one metric, and I think there might be some truth to that. 27:36 Because one point that I see as a almost psychological aspect to it, when you think about mitigation, you do have immediate solutions in mind that are actually bankable, because there has been this leadership of really putting emphasis on solar power plants and windmills, and also even reforestation. 28:01 So I think the leadership aspect, then the emphasis and efforts that have been happening to make solutions bankable. 28:10 Because to be honest, solar power pla- plans haven't been bankable when they were first invented, and I think the same way we need to think about adaptation resilience when we hear the argument of, yeah, but you know, they're aren't bankable projects yet. 28:25 There's so much adaptation tech out there that will, as said, grow and be more attractive. Well, yeah. 28:32 I was just thinking while you were speaking about what, why are certain renewable energy or clean tech investments so much more attractive, I think it's because we see today how lucrative the fossil fuel- Yes... 28:41 industry is, right? So I think from an investor point of view, it's like, okay, if something's gonna replace this industry, the energy industry, uh, then it's probably gonna be very lucrative. 28:49 It's attractive to investors to be like, "Oh, we could take a few percentage points of that by creating renewable energy." Whereas with adaptation resilience, it's less like replacing existing markets. 28:57 More like, yes, kind of adding on to every single sector, a little bit extra activity or extra technology to kind of make it more, uh, economically viable. 29:06 So maybe it's more hard to kind of conceptualize in people's heads, uh, what the benefits are. Yeah. You're absolutely right. 29:12 It's, it's a different kind of logic that applies to adaptation resilience, because ultimately it's a multi-year transformation through every aspect through society, and that makes it really hard to understand and grasp because it means everything and nothing at the same time. 29:31 But there is another really specific point that I think was or is a bit different when it comes to mitigation that can be applied to adaptation resilience as well, which is basically the creation of multipurpose financial mechanisms. 29:48 So basically you have a VC structure, an equity structure, a debt structure, and they're all connected to sup- support bankable or then to-be-bankable solutions for mitigation and for the energy sector, for example. 30:03 And I think we don't really have that yet for adaptation resilience. We sometimes have singular funds or an equity investment fund, but then the companies are actually in demand for debt as well. 30:19 But there isn't the specific structure that could immediately respond to that yet. 30:24 And I think that is something that we can also learn from the mitigation side.And I've mentioned it before, but I also think the leadership, political willingness, and political leadership part is not yet really developed when it comes to adaptation resilience. 30:41 That happened in med- mitigation, also with significant backlash sometimes from the markets. But 30:48 I do think that we need more political leaders really putting an emphasis on adaptation resilience and not having it as an afterthought. Mm-hmm. 30:59 And like with a lot of climate efforts, I think attention goes first to, to the UN and the various COP meetings that take place each year. And we know, like last year at COP twenty... 31:10 COP28, there was a lot more talk about adaptation and loss and damage as well. 31:15 And there was progress of a sort on adaptation, and there was an agreement to focus more on adaptation metrics and targets to kind of help develop some coherency and, and collaboration on financing around these se- set metrics. 31:31 So I'm kind of wondering from you, like, for a, for a unders- your understanding of, of that effort and what it could actually do to help promote adaptation metrics and targets that could be used by investors and the private sector. 31:42 Yeah. It's a good question. And I also think going a step back and asking, can the global goal in adaptation be a place that creates market signals for private investments into adaptation resilience? 31:57 And I do think the global goal in adaptation can do that. 32:02 So what happened at COP, as you said, last year was the parties really looked into what are target areas and systems, so they came to an agreement that you need to look at systems, so food and agriculture, health, infrastructure, et cetera. 32:21 So pretty much in line also with the Sharm El-Sheikh Adaptation Agenda for the private sector. But the good thing is, what I want to say here is there is unified voice that we need sector or system-specific metrics. 32:35 What happened though is that the language around metrics and indicators for finance wasn't strong enough, so it's pretty weak, and they need to strengthen this this year. And the issue is a bit 32:49 when it comes to UN processes, the private sector can actually input into this process and say, "Okay, we do need a goal on taxonomies. 32:59 We do need indications around adaptation re- resilience metrics for the private sector, et cetera." 33:06 So these submissions can happen, and I also recommend for private finance institutions and organizations, um, who want to do a submission that they get in touch with us, for example, or other bodies that are already working on the global goal in adaptation because the private sector expertise and perspective in the global goal in adaptation is still very superficial. 33:34 There seems to be some private entities that are doing a wait and see approach, want to get guidance from the UN or from their governments before doing anything, and then there are those entities which, again, may be on the front lines of climate risk and are kind of taking matters into their own hands. 33:49 So on the taxonomy question, yes, we have the EU taxonomy. 33:54 We have different central banks and regulators in certain jurisdictions putting together taxonomies, but there's also a lot of effort being done on adaptation resilience taxonomies in the private sector. 34:04 I want to know, like, how you see these efforts kind of slotted in with, like, the UN efforts and n- government efforts to kind of create this financing infrastructure for A&R. Yeah. 34:15 I think it's really important to find a central body that can house a global framework for taxonomies. 34:23 Until this is going to happen, I think it's amazing that the private sector's actually innovating on them and not waiting for policies to come around the corner. 34:33 And I've actually been thinking about where can it be housed? Where is a good place to really put the development of taxonomies, um, in, into text? 34:44 And I think that the global goal in adaptation could be a place where there could be negotiated text around, um, taxonomies. But then also the new collective quantified goal on climate finance that will be decided- Mm... 34:57 this year, long name, from the negotiating parties could also be a place where language around taxonomy for adaptation resilience could be integrated. 35:08 And I think there's no doubt that whoever is taking the lead, it has to happen. We need the centralization, otherwise there are going to be 35 taxonomies until next year at least. 35:21 I do think there is a desire to see what's decided upon by a democratic gathering, like the UN, on what adaptation resilience finance should look like, and then cascade that down to different levels of activity, right? 35:35 To private investors, to retail investors even, et cetera. Uh, so I feel like that is the way we should be going towards 35:44 s- you know, to one source of truth, one golden source of truth, and that can be interpreted in different ways in different jurisdictions. 35:49 But the danger is that everybody just kind of comes out with their own taxonomy, follows their own ideas, and then actually there's lots of gaps that develop as a result of that. 35:57 There's a lot of desperate communities or even s- economic sectors that aren't getting the attention they deserve because they've fallen between the cracks of these different taxonomies. Yeah. I agree with that. 36:08 And I also think, in a way, it's also an opportunity for national governments or governing bodies as the UNFCCC to use what is already out there to see what is it that the private sector is actually prioritizing, and how are they making sense of integrating adaptation resilience into their, uh, financial institutions. 36:31 So I think there's a lot of value on taking these effortsInto the global policy processes, and not always the other way around. Excellent. 36:41 Well, Sabrina, those are all my main questions, and I thank you for giving such great answers. 36:44 I suppose as like a last kind of like palate cleanser, I'd like to ask what you are working on for the rest of this year, what sort of goals you have. 36:52 You can go into as much or as little detail as you want, but it's always interesting to know what interviewees are gonna be working on after they, they log off this podcast. Yes. So there are a couple of things. 37:01 One is really to further develop, um, leadership of, um, financial institutions and to really use their voices as an inspiration for others in, in the sector. 37:12 So we're working with a couple of insurers that have, um, shown exceptional leadership in financing adaptation resilience. So that's what we always do throughout the year and until COP. 37:26 We are also looking much more into the nexus of finance for adaptation nature, especially on nature-based solutions. 37:34 So really looking into how this cost-efficient solution can be more mainstreamed and how investments can be attracted for nature-based solutions for adaptation. 37:45 And then most importantly, we are convening private finance, public finance, and civil society in working groups, and come out with very specific policy recommendations on financing adaptation resilience for COP29 and the processes that will happen there for the G20, potentially even for the Biodiversity COP16 in Colombia. 38:13 Mm-hmm. And I'm really curious about how the policy recommendations will evolve, because it's a really solid and inclusive group. 38:24 I think it will sometimes not be easy to come to, um, conclusions, but I think the value really lays in collaboration, bringing 38:34 the important actors together in a room and speak with each other instead of finger-pointing. [laughs] That's a lot on your desk then. And- Yeah... 38:42 I'm really interested, as you said, about the interactions between adaptation and, and nature. I think that's really something that's kicking off this year. Yes, I agree. I will keep you posted. [laughs] Excellent. 38:53 Sabrina, thank you for joining Climate Proofers. Thank you, Louis. It was a pleasure. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 39:07 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Tune in next week for another episode. 39:19 Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]