Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience finance, tech, and policy. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. 0:18 Today I'm joined by Seb Tranaeus, a venture partner at RallyCap VC, a fund that invests in early-stage climate adaptation and resilience startups. 0:28 I've gotten to know Seb in recent months as Climate Proof has grown and have been impressed by his thesis on the emerging climate adaptation technology, or CAT, market. 0:38 We talk about the current state of play in CAT, where the energy and investment is currently focused, and how the startup and policy ecosystems differ on either side of the Atlantic. 0:47 Before we get started, just a note that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 0:53 Listeners like you can help keep the lights on and support even more great content by heading to climateproof.news/upgrade. You'll get two newsletters a week, access to exclusive data dashboards, and special reports. 1:06 Thank you for the support. Okay, in a minute my interview with Seb, but first let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:14 [swoosh] In policy, the UN Climate Change Conference in Bonn, Germany, is into its second week, and negotiations are ongoing over several adaptation-related issues. 1:23 Specifically, on June the 10th, informal consultations were held on national adaptation plans, matters relating to the global goal on adaptation, and on the Nairobi work program, which focuses on impacts, vulnerability, and adaptation to climate change. 1:38 On national adaptation plans, a draft text noted concern that many developing countries are yet to put these plans into place. Negotiations are focused on ways to help nations put these together. 1:48 These include making access to finance, technology transfer, and capacity-building support easier. 1:54 On the global goal on adaptation, discussions focus on fleshing out the UAE Framework for Global Climate Resilience, which is a blueprint for delivering the goal that was approved at COP 28 last year. 2:06 For this framework to actually make progress, there have to be means to support countries in tracking, reporting, and assessing their adaptation measures. 2:14 One focus of discussions has been working out what indicators should be used to gauge progress against the seven adaptation targets featured in the framework. 2:22 These cover water, food systems, health impacts, ecosystems and biodiversity, infrastructure and human settlements, poverty, and cultural heritage. The Bonn conference ends on June 13th. 2:34 The draft negotiating texts made here will then be taken up by UN member states at COP 29 in Baku, Azerbaijan, later this year. 2:42 [swoosh] In finance, the government of Canada rolled out a $530 million adaptation fund for towns, cities, and municipalities. 2:50 The Green Municipal Fund, announced last Monday by Minister of Environment and Climate Change Steven Guilbeault, is one of the largest ever investments in building livable and resilient communities, according to the government. 3:01 The money can be used by cities to draw up adaptation plans, build up expertise, and conduct project feasibility studies. Municipalities can also apply for up to $1 million to get started on shovel-ready projects. 3:15 The government hopes to fund more than 1,400 municipal activities by 2031. 3:21 [swoosh] And in tech, developing countries will be empowered to use space technology, data, and research for their climate proofing efforts thanks to a new Commonwealth space collaboration. 3:30 Through the initiative, which has been set up by the Commonwealth, an association of 56 countries with historic links to the British Empire, a dedicated space data hub will be established to promote the access and exchange of space-based climate risk data, which can be used to help countries enhance their resilience and pursue the UN Sustainable Development Goals. 3:49 [swoosh] Right, that's this week's roundup. Now on to our interview. [upbeat music] Today we're joined by Seb Tranaeus. Seb, where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hey, Louis. Great to be here. 4:04 I am calling in from London. What do I do? So I am a venture partner at RallyCap Ventures. RallyCap has funds that focus on investing in adaptation software. Happy to talk a lot about that in our, in our chat today. 4:15 And then I pay the bills as a senior software engineer at a carbon removal startup here in London called Curate. Yeah, so the tagline is "Mitigating by day, adapting by, by night" for now. [laughs] I love that tagline. 4:26 I think you should get that embossed on a T-shirt somewhere. I want to talk to you about climate adaptation technology, or CAT for short. Mm-hmm. 4:33 This is a hot topic in certain quarters of the venture industry, so I wondered if you could give us your definition of CAT and why it's an attractive niche for venture investors. Okay. Sure. 4:44 I guess there's a, there's a narrow definition and there's a broad definition, and, um, there's a lot around that. The narrow definition is climate adaptation technology is... 4:52 Or any solutions that help us, uh, deal with climate hazards. So that could be from the kind of super cool firefighting robots, uh, to improved air conditioning for heat waves to, I don't know, 3D-printed sea walls. 5:05 Um, that's the kind of very specific narrow definition that some funds are going after. You could broaden that, so the broader definition is anything that makes us more systemically resilient. 5:15 So if you think of, uh, software for managing supply chains or making the grid more dynamic and resilient, all these things help us withstand shocks. 5:25 And those kind of two definitions come from the fact that you can divvy up the adaptation space into hazards, uh, or the adaptation problem space into hazards and risk drivers. 5:35 So some things that are a hazard, like a fire or a flood or a heat wave, or it's a risk driver, so something that contributes to the overall consequences caused by that hazard. 5:43 So an example of risk drivers would be, um, I don't know, h- our firefighting capacity or how many... The size of the vulnerable populations in a certain area exposed to a heat wave. 5:55 So you can kind of look at solutions that go after, uh, hazards or solutions that go after risk drivers.That's how I'd kind of start with the definition. Mm-hmm. 6:02 And I should say, you've done some great work collecting information on cat companies and trying to classify them, and we're both familiar with groups who are coming up with adaptation taxonomies, right, to try and classify different companies by, yes, by either hazard or by how they actually contribute to resilience somewhere. 6:20 Uh, and I think these initiatives are very helpful for the venture funds and other i- institutional investors who are trying to get into this space. Uh, one thing I, I think we are... 6:29 we're both familiar with is this software and hardware debate, right? 6:32 So you can have climate adaptation technology that is hard assets to actually protect the physical risks, and then you have software to help with calculating grid resilience or, or energy usage or early warning systems, et cetera. 6:45 So I wonder from your professional viewpoint, what... where do you see the balance? Is it more on the software side or more on the hardware side or... And, and what's the kind of appetite from venture funds? 6:54 Is it hardware or software? You know, I think from a, an impact perspective, we obviously need hardware. Climate is a real-world problem that needs real-world solutions. 7:03 We need more innovation in the hardware space, be it, you know, again, 3D printing sea walls is just such a great example, um, of, of kind of modern technology used to combat climate change. 7:13 While software is important, do you have software that helps you make decisions, helps you think about decisions? 7:18 Um, do you have software that actions on things in the real world that can influence hardware, or do you have software that processes data and, and kind of provides that data to you? 7:27 Investors tend to love software and software margins, and that's probably where the space is going due to the kind of past 10 years of, of SaaS fever. 7:35 But I think there's a, there's a ton of great investors also putting money into hardware. Yes, it does depend where you are in the capital stack, right? 7:42 Of course, venture funds want to invest in industries or opportunities with high multiples, but then you also have, like, very large pension funds and sovereign wealth funds who want to invest in long-term fixed assets that produce steady revenues over time, right? 7:55 So it depends where you're sitting what sort of climate adaptation technology is attractive. So I, I get that. 8:02 Now, because of your tagline, "Mitigation by day, adaptation by night," I thought you might be well positioned to ask a... 8:08 answer a question about where the kind of cat space sits relative to decarbonization technology, so renewable energy tech, and also carbon removal technology, so DAC technologies that suck carbon from the air. 8:21 That seems to be a very buzzy space right now, uh, but it wasn't anywhere like five years ago, I'd argue. Uh, so I wonder where, where you see adaptation tech in terms of the journey of, of adoption and excitement. 8:31 Where, whereabouts in the hype cycle do you think we are? Yeah, we're definitely at the beginning in the adaptation space or at least in the adaptation technology space. 8:39 There are plenty of players who have been thinking about adaptation and resilience for decades. Within the venture industry, we are in the beginning. 8:45 I'd say there is a sense that things are picking up, especially after conferences like Adapt Unbound in New York, where we saw each other. There were a ton of new funds coming into the space. 8:54 They're interested in adaptation. You saw some late-stage funds, like DBG fund there. So there's a sense it's picking up. Um, still early days in terms of adaptation technology, I would say. 9:07 And when you look at the funds themselves, yes, we were at this great conference, Adapt Unbound, and we did meet a lot of interesting fund founders, uh, and originators. 9:15 I'm wondering, what do you think in terms of their sophistication? Uh, is... 9:19 Are, are they looking for, for the quick wins, or are they realizing that this is a space where you kind of need expertise, you need to look beyond maybe the usual suspects to find the opportunities? Mm-hmm. 9:30 Um, I think different funds bring different values. There, there were some funds there that are specialized in, uh, startups that sell to government. That's gonna be totally critical in the resilience market. 9:40 And so I think they're just trying to get a feel and a sense for the problem. Um, I think the right funds don't wait for a taxonomy to come out. Like, especially in the early stage ventures, you just... 9:49 you don't need a taxonomy. Totally understand for later stage investing, different types of financial assets and vehicles, uh, you need more kind of structured, formalized thinking, let's say. 9:59 But in early stage venture, you should just dive into the space and work on it until you develop an intuition. And then sure, if you want, share that intuition, grow the space, stimulate the ecosystem. 10:09 But we don't need to wait around for, for taxonomies in the early stage investing space. 10:13 That's a, a refreshing perspective because when I speak to, yes, large institutions, it seems to be all about, "Okay, yeah, we need to wait for taxonomy. We need to know what we're investing in." 10:22 But you're absolutely right. 10:23 The whole point of venture, right, is to kind of blaze a trail to clear the path for others, and so you can be a bit more creative and, and identify investments that suit your conception of adaptation and, and resilience. 10:36 Um, I suppose that kind of leads to a follow-on question, which is, is, is it proving effective? 10:41 Like, if you're a venture fund branding yourself as adaptation, is it a way to attract capital, or is it still poorly understood? Sure. I... You know, I guess it, it depends what you're optimizing for in that question. 10:53 I think, you know, investors want returns, and investors want to be today where others wish they were in five or 10 years. And it's about finding those, those pockets of scarcity in the world. 11:04 And I'd say adaptation is still there, although it's getting less scarce. There's more and more attention going into it. 11:09 So I think from a returns perspective and from an impact perspective, we see a lot of funds going into it wanting to kind of fund these solutions that save people's lives and livelihoods. 11:18 It makes a lot of sense in terms of having a thesis that resonates with other investors and especially with limited partners. Um, less clear, I think for a lot of people, adaptation just isn't on their agendas. 11:30 It's not on their mind. We're still very mitigation, carbon, and decarbonization focused, um, for the right reasons. 11:36 But that mentality shift will take some time to set in, and when that happens, it'll be a lot easier to talk about adaptation in the venture space, to be clear. The... 11:43 In the public sector, you know, NGOs, the UN, the UN says half of all climate finance should be spent on adaptation. So where public money goes, private capital tends to follow. Excellent. 11:54 And you kind of touched on this already, but the barriers that the cat market are facing. 12:00 So what are they, and how can they be overcome, both from the side of investors who-Yeah, might be unsure how to fit CAT into their portfolios but also from the side of startups, I, I think you've done some interesting research here, like some startups, especially tech companies, may be providing services that actually do have a climate adaptation play to them, but they might not themselves realize that. 12:19 So I was wondering if that's a barrier that could be overcome and, and how more startups could be made aware that, hey, you're providing a service that could be classified as adaptation and resilience. 12:28 Uh, you could go out and market that and attract capital as a, as a result. So how can we kind of help startups kinda see that they're providing adaptation and resilience benefits? Yeah. No, I think startups... 12:41 Good startups attract the right capital because they're performing and 'cause they show promise, um, not because of what they label themselves as. 12:49 And, uh, cap- startups should focus on the product and the customer and, and obsess over that. And, and if they do a good job, money should flow in principle if the system works. 12:59 But, you know, I think if co- if startups are looking diligently for the right customer and really getting specific on that customer in the early stage, 13:07 if it's a resilience customer, they'll find, um, a kind of resilience stakeholder, be it within government or businesses or elsewhere that fits that. 13:15 On the investor side, at the early stage, yeah, I don't, I don't know what else to say besides don't wait for taxonomy, just dive into it. 13:21 And, you know, like Convective Capital, uh, which is a 35 million fund based in California that invest in fire tech, founded by Bill Clerico. Like, they didn't start because Bill found an amazing taxonomy. 13:31 They started because, uh, he had a lived experience of wildfire caused by, worsened by climate change, and he had the resources and the talent and the network to take action and do that. 13:41 And, and the same goes for his portfolio company. They didn't start because they found taxonomy. They started 'cause they are passionate people with lived experiences of climate change that took action. 13:50 So the best thing, uh, you know, we can do from a regulatory standpoint is just keep improving the startup ecosystem. 13:55 Uh, particularly in Eur- in, in Europe, we need to get our kind of startup equity laws in order and, and just kind of get out the way to let these people work on problems. 14:04 So are you saying that the general startup ecosystem in Europe may not be as amenable to all typ- all types of startup, including climate adaptation technology? 14:14 I think if you think of these things on a kind of evolutionary s- s- cycle, like the startup ecosystem in Europe is just maybe like five years behind or 10 years behind where it was in... where the US is now. 14:25 There are some structural constraints in place. The US is, I don't know, what, 300 million English speakers. You can become a, a unicorn overnight if you scale nationally there. 14:35 While in Europe you have different national legislations, different national languages, um, it's just harder to kinda scale super fast in Europe, and there are still, like, legal constraints on startups here. 14:47 That said, Europe brings its own benefits, and, um, I'm sure there are a lot of startups that have made it big in Europe that might not have made it big had they started in the US. 14:56 Yes, arguably there's a more accommodative policy space, right, in Europe. There is actually public money going towards climate proofing the regions in the European Union. 15:06 There is institutional support for local governments on adaptation. So that should be creating demand for climate adaptation technology products, et cetera. 15:16 Um, and also we talked about the Adaptor Bound conference earlier, but you also went to a climate adaptation tech conference in Germany. There's another one taking place in November in Germany, I believe. 15:27 So there seems to be a lot of energy going on in the adaptation technology space in Europe. But is that translating to dollars? Maybe not yet. Yeah, it's, it's unclear. I, I think, um, 15:38 yeah, climate is just less polarizing in Europe. Adaptation is less polarizing politically, thankfully, in, in both jurisdictions. 15:45 Um, European legislation is in some ways leading the way when it comes to kind of adaptation funding, adaptation taxonomies. The European Climate Adaptation report came out earlier this year. 15:56 Um, climate assessment report, can't remember exactly, but that came out earlier this year, and that had a lot of really valuable detailed information on how the European Union views climate change and European resilience. 16:07 Europe is the fastest warming continent in the world. It's still unclear if that leads to startups being founded in Europe and growing in Europe and, and leading to kind of meaningful impact. 16:18 And, you know, we, we also have Holland, and Holland has been holding back the North Sea for, like, 200 years. Uh, they've been adapting. They've been adapting to a changing climate, uh, for the past centuries. 16:27 So, um, we have a lot of things going for us as well. Mm-hmm. Yes. It's not entirely a new theme for some countries [laughs]- Yeah... 16:35 particularly those under constant threat of inundation from the North Sea, as you said. Totally. 16:40 So the climate adaptation technology and government interface is interesting to, to me, and I know it's interesting to you too because, as I said, in the EU there's a lot of efforts to promote adaptation by local governments. 16:52 There is this EU adaptation mission, uh, that I wrote about recently, which is trying to take a different approach to research and innovation and trying to connect local authorities with solutions that can help them climate-proof their populations and their natural resources. 17:09 So it feels to me that there's a great opportunity for startups to actually get into the, the business to government, the B2G space, right? And I'm wondering if that's... that thesis holds true to you. 17:21 And also is that enough? Is it enough to have, uh, B2G, or do we actually need to build out the B2B and B2C segments of adaptation tech in order to create a thriving ecosystem? Yeah. 17:32 I, I guess it sounds like there's two questions there. One is, um, is B2G kind of the right route for certain startups? A- and, and then is it enough from an impact perspective? 17:41 I think there will definitely be startups that nail selling to government in the resilience, in the adaptation and resilience market, but it's notoriously hard. 17:51 Uh, a lot of investors are turned off by startups that sell to government, and so they just... Yeah, they, they need to be careful. 17:58 They need to manage their, their runway and make sure they really understand the selling to government model. 18:03 Governments are very different from, let's say, commercial and obviously individual consumers.Yeah, government's optimized for stability. 18:10 You need to find ways to satisfy all the stakeholders within the government you're selling to, not to just go in there and say you're gonna disrupt their operations and bring a new technology. 18:19 So, um, yeah, it's hard nut to crack, but there will definitely be startups that ace it in the next 10 years and meaningfully support government with, with their kind of mandate to protect citizens from climate change hazards. 18:32 Some examples of startups that do that, ForeRunner sells floodplain management software, and now they've gone multi-product. They help, uh, with citizen education around floodings, disaster planning. 18:42 But in California there's a ton of fire tech startups selling to governments, be it to predicting how wildfire will spread, uh, or helping with kind of evacuation planning. 18:52 And by the way, I'm not affiliated in any way with these startups. I just think they're awesome companies. There's, there's tons of room for just really solid software to improve government workflows. 19:01 If that's enough from an impact perspective, the answer is no. I think, one, because we can't expect governments alone to solve these challenges. 19:10 Um, when it comes to climate hazards and the climate shocks that we're going to experience, um, they're kind of monumental. We need businesses to think about their supply chains. 19:19 You need businesses to think about which assets are under threat. And unfortunately, at some point, consumers will probably start taking things into their own hand. 19:26 I'd say that's quite down the line, and, um, it's unclear if when that does happen, there are, like, software or startup solutions, uh, for those use cases. 19:34 I mean, there are companies that market themselves as startups that give you, like, um, like a flood barrier to surround your car with when it floods, and it kind of inflates and goes around your car. 19:44 And that's great technology and will provide a lot of value. Unclear if it's a venture backable startup. 19:49 You're seeing a lot of B2B plays, a ton of kind of climate risk analytics for, like, asset managers to figure out how their portfolio is going to be affected. You are seeing some B2B2C plays. 19:59 There's a lot around kind of community resilience, community-based data collection. You know, apps that incentivize citizens to take pictures of coastal areas, and then the... 20:08 you extract as much data as you can from those pictures to monitor, like, sea level change, things like that. I personally, I think those solutions are super cool. 20:16 Uh, municipalities like them 'cause they kind of improve... There's like a two-way relationship with citizens. Citizens feel involved in, in, in the data collection, municipalities benefit from the data. 20:26 Unclear if those are, like, venture backable opportunities or not. Uh, that doesn't mean they shouldn't grow and be supported. Yes. 20:32 I think it's interesting to ask whether there's a certain model of entrepreneur that ensures a adaptation startup will be attractive to a certain market segment, right? 20:45 So you mentioned that you have entrepreneurs who have personal experiences of climate change, and they have a passion to kind of solve these problems, so they have a compelling story. 20:54 But I'm wondering, they might come from backgrounds where actually they don't know about selling to governments, and they're not familiar with the needs of certain sectors. 21:02 So I'm wondering if the adaptation technology space is going to be only attractive to a certain type of entrepreneur and a ty- certain type of investor, or whether it can really expand beyond a kind of narrow model. 21:15 It, it comes down to what is the entrepreneur's, uh, hypothesis about the market- Mm... and how do they think the value they provide is unique, is differentiated, and can scale rapidly. 21:28 I don't think it matters too much, uh, if they have an existing network or experience, for example, with selling to government. 21:34 Obviously that helps, but it also brings in preconceptions and biases that maybe, uh, get in the way. 21:40 Um, I'm sure there are examples of, of entrepreneurs and founders that had no prior experience selling to government and, and nailed it, and they got the right investors who had the experience, or they found the ri- right advisors. 21:51 Um, or they were just, you know, smart and smart enough and capable enough and, and hardworking enough to really, uh, dig into the space and understand it in a short period of time. 22:00 I think it, again, it comes down to what's the problem they're trying to solve, who they're try, who they're trying to sell it to, and, and how are they differentiated. Yes. 22:07 I'm just thinking about this from my perspective as well. Like, my company, Climate Proof, is essentially B2C, right? 22:13 I sell individual subscriptions, but I might want to move into enterprise subscriptions one day, which means trying to market to businesses, and I appreciate that's an area that I have no experience [chuckles] in. 22:21 Mm-hmm. And, uh, and it kind of makes me nervous to get in there. But of course, there are resources available, uh, to help with that. 22:27 And it seems like in the climate space, there is no shortage of efforts by governments, uh, and by nonprofits or, or sort of industry-led groups to try to educate entrepreneurs, uh, get them into ex- accelerators where they actually can get the benefit of institutional knowledge, uh, and scale up their, their solutions that way. 22:45 Uh, do you feel there's enough education going out, out there to kind of tutor entrepreneurs through this, through this cycle, or does it need to be a bit more? 22:53 Uh, within the adaptation space, there should always be more, I think, just because we're, we're in the early stages of this cycle. Um, it's growing. 23:01 For example, My Climate Journey, which is a pretty well-known climate tech community, now has an adaptation channel. The activity there is growing. I'm a kind of big participant and, and, and promoter of it. 23:11 So, um, yeah, you're seeing pockets of interest and enthusiasm and, and therefore support and kind of ecosystem growth, but it's nothing compared to, like, decarbonization. 23:21 There are so many great courses, be it on carbon removals or, I don't know, grid electrification and, and, and all of that. Um, yeah, we have a long way to go when it comes to adaptation. 23:30 I have yet to find a kind of amazing website that captures different climate hazards, uh, the different risk drivers that contribute to them, where technology could be useful. 23:40 Um, yeah, we just need more people and more, more brains in the space. Well, watch this space. I'm trying to produce something like that, and I know there are others [chuckles] who are trying to work on this as well. 23:49 It's a big task though, 'cause there are so many hazards, and there are so many aspects of adaptation, and there's no one-size-fits-all solution, right? 23:57 Like, every business, region, geography, business model has its own adaptation needs, so it's kinda hard to impose one structure onto all of them. Yeah, um, totally. 24:08 I mean, I mean, risk analytics is-A super crowded space right now. There's a ton of, of software startups getting into it, but, uh, it's hard to see how all of them will, will differentiate. 24:20 Okay, one final big picture question from me is what potential inflection points do you see on the horizon that could trigger a massive scale-up in adaptation finance, in adaptation companies, in corporates taking adaptation more seriously? 24:36 We know that politics is a, a big driver. 24:38 We're, we're talking today during the middle of the European election, so we, we, we wait to see what will happen after those votes are counted and what that does to the, the policy landscape in Europe. 24:48 Of course, in the US, we have an upcoming general election as well, which may change the atmosphere for climate technology and climate policy generally. 24:55 But then there are other factors that are non-political, non-geopolitical that might matter, and I keep thinking about how we're probably overdue a massive hurricane or storm here in New York City, which might change the game in terms of investment in adaptation, like what happened after Hurricane Sandy in 2012. 25:11 So from your perspective, like what events, physical, political, technological, could really spark a, a kind of, a massive influx of energy and capital into climate adaptation technology? Yeah. That's a great question. 25:27 In terms of kind of singular events, we should just look at the kind of shining example of adaptation right now, which is fire tech. Fire tech is having its... 25:37 has been having its moment, um, and that comes down to the kind of nexus of Californian talent, tech capital, and unfortunately heat risk. 25:46 And it's after several terrible fire seasons that, uh, founders and investors switched gears and focused on, on building out fire solutions. 25:53 And unfortunately, I think that is how you galvanize, uh, the ecosystem and get it going, is unfortunately catastrophes and, uh, moving people and, and getting people with, with lived experiences. Uh, unclear. 26:06 You know, we still have yet to see if, let's say, something similar panned out in terms of a hurricane in New York. 26:11 Would that get the, the New York tech ecosystem going, focused on adaptation, or is California a, a kind of special example? We have yet to see what happens. I would say yeah, singular climate events are, are critical. 26:24 Um, we need less from an event perspective, but we just need more discussions that, that make adaptation and mitigation seem less zero-sum and more like kind of collaborative, I don't know, cousins. Like it's not... 26:39 Adaptation is an extension of, of the incredible work that's been going on in mitigation. And they ultimately both have the exact same goals. Why are we trying to mitigate climate change? 26:47 So that we can save our world, lives, and livelihoods. That's exactly what adaptation's trying to do. And it's, it's not just, um, I don't know, erecting s- flood barriers. 26:56 It's, it's a lot about understanding nature and understanding how best to interact with it. Like so many of these fire startups in California, they're not just, they're not just suppressing fire. 27:04 They're helping us understand our forests and when we should let fire burn and play a healthy role in the ecosystem. 27:09 So yeah, less zero-sum thinking in, in that debate and, uh, and more just kind of supporting both of them and continuing to up the, the adaptation finance. That's an excellent answer. Yes. 27:21 Getting rid of that false dichotomy between mitigation and adapta- adaptation is a big deal, and I feel like we're, we're making progress there, but there's still plenty to be done. Okay. 27:32 Finally, I'd like to ask all my climate proofers who come on the show what they're focusing on over the next 12 months or so, or what aspirations they have over the next 12 months when it comes to their adaptation focus. 27:44 Uh, yeah, great question. I'm excited about diving into two areas. One is heat tech. Extreme heat is gonna be a huge issue in many parts of the world, and it's gonna lead to a kind of... 27:55 With adaptation more broadly, it's gonna lead to the migration of risk factors. We're gonna see tropical diseases moving northward. 28:00 We're gonna see heat stroke rates skyrocket in, in parts of the world that never had to deal with that kind of issue before. So heat risk, super interesting, super big problem. Definitely room for startups there. 28:11 And more broadly, kind of urban tech and seeing what's the kind of intersection between urban tech and, and adaptation. Um, I'd say that's what, that's what excites me right now. 28:22 Yes, resilient cities is a hot topic that I'm very interested in too as well, and that's where you're gonna see a lot of these risks compounding, right? 28:29 You have heat risk is worse in cities because of, uh, the urban heat island effect. Flooding can be worse because of the kind of bathtub effect that happens 'cause of the concretization of surfaces. 28:40 And you know, I live in a big city. You live in a big city. So I suppose it's quite personal for us how cities are going to become adapted to climate change. Yeah. 28:47 And there seems to be a lot of cool technology involved in that. Totally, and again, it's not just about stopping the hazards. It's about improving our relationship with nature. 28:55 So many of the solutions in the next 10 years will just help us get closer to harmony with nature via technology. Brilliant. Well, I'm glad you're focusing on those areas. 29:05 I look forward to, to reading and, uh, analyzing whatever you come out into the world on, on heat tech, and I look forward to continuing to follow your career, Seb. 29:13 It's been a pleasure to get to know you over the last few months, and I'm really pleased you could come onto the podcast today. So thank you very much, and have a lovely rest of your week. Great, Louis. 29:21 Thanks for having me. Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 29:34 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Tune in next week for another episode. Goodbye. [outro music]