Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation, finance, tech, and policy. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodhill, editor of Climate Proof, the adaptation publication, which you can read at www.climateproof.news. 0:21 The UN Climate Change Summit, COP30, is underway in the Amazonian city of Belém, Brazil, with adaptation set to be the headline star. 0:29 The host nation's president, Lula da Silva, said he wanted the conference to, quote, "Elevate adaptation to the same level of political and financial ambition as mitigation," end quote, while country leaders from across the Global South are calling for parties to agree on doubling or even tripling current levels of adaptation finance. 0:47 However, whatever comes out of COP30 will, by its very nature, be high level and hard to translate into actionable economic and financial policy at the scale of individual countries. 0:57 Policy makers need help on this front, and one new startup, Morphosis Solutions, hopes to provide it. 1:03 Last week, ahead of COP, the Swiss-based investment business launched its debut report called The Rise of the Adaptation Economy. 1:10 It contains a framework countries can draw on to design policies and incentives that support adaptation by attracting investment, spurring innovation, and reordering the regulatory system. 1:20 Here on the pod to talk about it is Simon Zadek, co-managing partner at Morphosis. 1:25 He takes us through the new framework and why he thinks it's necessary while giving us the lowdown on Morphosis itself, which he sees as part private equity investor, part merchant banking outfit, and part knowledge provider for a whole new adaptation-focused economy. 1:40 If you want a deep dive into how countries can be reshaped to support climate adaptation, this is the episode for you. 1:46 Before we get started, a reminder to regular listeners that if you enjoy and value this pod, please drop us a rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts and go ahead and write us a review if you're feeling generous. 1:56 Also, this podcast may be free, but making it sure isn't. 1:59 We need more paying members to help us keep the lights on, so do head over to www.climateproof.news/upgrade to become a paying member and give us a much-needed helping hand. Right. 2:10 In a minute, my conversation with Simon, but first, a roundup of last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 2:16 [whooshing noise] In finance, climate leaders published a long-awaited blueprint for scaling finance in support of Paris Agreement goals with adaptation at its center. 2:24 But absent strong support from wealthy nations at the COP30 conference, the plan may struggle to deliver meaningful new funding. 2:31 The Baku to Belém Roadmap to one point three trillion comes at the end of a year-long round of talks following the twenty twenty-four climate summit in Azerbaijan, where countries agreed to work on increasing climate finance for developing countries to at least one point three trillion dollars a year by twenty twenty-five. 2:47 The final roadmap outlines a broad range of potential sources for achieving this goal, from traditional development assistance and multilateral climate funds to new taxes on aviation, wealth, and financial transactions. 2:58 On adaptation, the roadmap explains that current flows are not nearly enough and are failing to reach frontline communities that are most vulnerable to climate shocks. 3:05 Citing data from the recent UN Adaptation Gap Report, the authors claim that less than seventeen percent of international public finance delivered between twenty seventeen and twenty twenty-one reached those communities in need. 3:17 It also stresses how shortcomings in adaptation finance are leading to systemic challenges for poor countries in the form of higher sovereign debt costs and heightened economic volatility. 3:26 However, the roadmap status as a guiding framework rather than a prelude to new binding financing mechanisms could make it little more than a paper tiger. Climate groups knocked its perceived weaknesses. 3:36 Carolina Pasquali, the executive director of Greenpeace Brazil, said, quote, "It does not go far enough in holding developed countries accountable." 3:44 [whooshing noise] In policy, climate diplomats could make important progress on tracking global adaptation efforts at COP30, though much depends on whether they can agree on a common set of indicators that some parties appear opposed to. 3:55 Ahead of the conference, a UN-convened expert group published a final batch of a hundred potential indicators for measuring countries' alignment with the Global Goal on Adaptation, or GGA. 4:05 This is the Paris Agreement objective that commits nations to strengthening their resilience and reducing their vulnerability to climate shocks. 4:11 The indicators are slated for discussion over the next two weeks of talks and could be formally adopted by the whole conference by the summit's conclusion. 4:18 This outcome could help accelerate adaptation action worldwide and put climate proofing targets on a par with the Paris Agreement's emissions reduction goals. 4:26 However, experts reached by Climate Proof suggest the path to adoption could be bumpy and may even be blocked entirely. 4:33 Imani Saidi, diplomacy and cooperation researcher at the IMAR Initiative for Climate and Development, told me that, quote, "From a Global South perspective, the list of indicators has too many disadvantages, lacks policy coherency, is too prescriptive, and at times is contradictory with the Paris Agreement's provisions." 4:49 [whooshing noise] And in tech, the Gates Foundation will pour at least one point four billion dollars into climate adaptation technologies for farmers in sub-Saharan Africa and Asia over the next four years, aiming to bolster regional food security and prevent communities from slipping into poverty as extreme weather intensifies. 5:05 Innovations targeted by the new investment include biofertilizers, soil health mapping tools, climate-resilient crop varieties that can withstand heat and drought, and digital advisory services. 5:16 The announcement follows an October memo from Bill Gates, the foundation's billionaire founder, urging climate advocates to prioritize building resilience and improving human welfare. 5:25 Last week, he pushed back against right-wing arguments that this message was an admission that action on global warming had gone too far. 5:31 In an interview with Axios, he said President Donald Trump's claim that his message marked a retreat from clean energy and decarbonization was wrong, calling such interpretations a, quote, "gigantic misreading." 5:42 He also reiterated that funding for climate and health initiatives by his foundations is rising. [whooshing noise] Okay, that's it for this week's roundup. Now on to my conversation with Simon. [upbeat music] Hi, Simon. 5:54 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. I am calling from Geneva in Switzerland, and I am the co-founder and co-managing partner of Morphosis.Thanks for joining us today, Simon. 6:08 I've got to know you and the Morphosis team a little over the last few months, and you're one of these interesting crop of companies that are springing up in the climate adaptation space. 6:18 But before we get into Morphosis and before we get into this new report you've launched, can you talk a little bit about yourself, your career to date, and why at this juncture, you and the Morphosis team are focusing on climate adaptation? 6:31 Sure. Happy to. 6:32 So I'm not even sure if I can describe my journey as a career rather than just a series of faltering steps, but I started working on sustainability and business issues as early as the late nineteen eighties. 6:46 And I've moved through various aspects of that agenda. 6:51 Spent almost ten years working on workers' rights and labor rights as the sweatshop campaigns begin to emerge, through to a lot of focus on the emerging, what at that time was called social auditing profession. 7:06 And I was the first social auditor of the Body Shop and the Ben and Jerry's, and many of the companies that sort of began the journey that has now landed with the ISSB and other international reporting standards. 7:18 And then in the early noughties, I pivoted towards finance, and I've spent the last ten, fifteen years working on how private finance and the financial system as a whole can take different aspects of sustainability into account. 7:33 I spent quite a lot of time living in China, working with the Chinese financial regulators, then running their green finance workstream under their G20 presidency, and then ran for the UN a large-scale inquiry on financial markets and sustainable development. 7:51 Worked for a couple of years for the UN Secretary General, working on the same topic, and founded Nature Finance, a Swiss-based NGO, in two thousand and nineteen, and for five years ran that and contributed to what has been a hockey stick, if you like, of work in that field. 8:10 Uh, and gradually just felt increasingly that as we were clearly heading beyond one point five and probably north of two degrees within a painfully short period of time, we needed to bring together these different social and climate and, uh, other agendas into an adaptation-focused approach to how we're actually gonna live in that world we're facing in. 8:37 So last year, I left Nature Finance after five years successfully building it and co-founded Morphosis, which we can come back to in a second. 8:48 So you've been involved in various different aspects of the sustainability fight, let's say, from the Rio Principles, from sweatshops, through to nature finance. 8:57 And are you saying that your pivot to adaptation is because of your realization of the trajectory of the science, the trajectory of our s-social policies towards decarbonization not being enough to get us below two degrees? 9:10 Is this a scientific reason that you're, you're ch-- looking at adaptation, or is there other factors at play here? 9:16 So just before COP twenty-eight, which was Dubai two years ago, when I was still at Nature Finance, we published a piece that I authored called Time to Plan for a World Beyond one point five Degrees. 9:30 And the essence of the message, as the title implies, is that we needed to bite the bullet, if you like, given the science, to your first point, but also recognize that the extent of change that is coming requires long-term planning and phase shift levels of innovation. 9:51 If today, as I said in the paper, we had about then a hundred and thirty, a hundred and forty million refugees, but the UN IOM, the migration organization, predicts a billion plus within twenty years. 10:06 It wasn't just about accommodating more people in trying to deal with the refugee crisis. 10:11 It was rethinking, reframing a world where perhaps a fifth, a sixth of its global population was permanently on the move, and the same for food and the same for water and other topics. 10:26 And so I guess to your point, partly the science, but also partly, if you like, a kind of new generation of climate denialism, not so much the one that we've been accustomed to in the past where climate change doesn't exist or something of that kind. 10:41 But actually, much of the climate community itself and many of what we would consider to be progressive actors, whether they're in the business field, the policy field, or civil society, not willing to go, "This is where we're heading. 10:55 Get with the plan and create one to act." And, and so I felt, you know, that was a sort of large scale behavioral problem. It was a, an identity problem within the climate community. 11:08 It was a political problem as we could see more broadly. And it was a market problem, which is of course, where I've placed most of my assets that we'll come back to. 11:17 That's really interesting what you say about a new phase of climate denialism almost. 11:21 And I think that has impelled a number of projects by think tanks, by market participants, by climate diplomats even to pivot to adaptation. So let's turn to Morphosis. 11:33 What's your elevator pitch for the organization, and what gap in the market would you say you're filling? So the elevator pitch is that we are a hybrid adaptation solutions business. What does that mean? 11:46 It means that on the one hand, we have a private investment window, so effectively a private equity shop, and we're looking to invest in businesses that are at their Series A, Series B stage and are companies that will be able to scale in delivering adaptation solutions in a world well north of one point five degrees. 12:13 As well as that investment windowWe need what we might think of as a merchant banking window. 12:18 How do we identify and work with businesses that will be profitable in the future, but that have to cross, if you like, a different valley of death, a period of time where markets are simply not rewarding adaptation solution businesses in the way they need to? 12:36 Their strategy, their product mix, their market entry, all of those elements of how those growth businesses will need to bridge, if you like, that short to medium term period where the quote-unquote adaptation markets are not present or functioning effectively. 12:54 That's the second part of our business. So think of it as a merchant banking business as well as a private equity business. And then the third part of our business is more on the knowledge policy demand side. 13:07 So how do we help governments understand policy frameworks and levers that can create markets that reward those adaptation solution businesses sufficiently to attract vanilla commercial capital that drives them into that virtuous cycle of being able to scale and innovate and bring down costs and make their products widely affordable. 13:32 Yeah. And what is it that we need to help those governments do, not just we Morphosis, but others in trying to figure that out. 13:43 And so there's a knowledge policy solution side to the business that if you like, one might think of as the demand side of the adaptation solution space, whereas our merchant banking and investment work is, if you like, the supply side of the adaptation solution space. 14:04 That's interesting. So having an effect on both sides is the dynamic there. Yes. I think that's right. 14:10 And I guess to some extent it reflects and is reflected by our top leadership team that I won't go through in any detail, but my co-founder, Niall Murphy, is a serial technology entrepreneur, so he's a build and operate guy, you know, that has built and operate multiple technology companies, raised capital to make them work, and then exited them. 14:34 Whereas I've tended to work more on the policy market shaping side, so still very market oriented, but working with policy and broader public institutions in order to shape markets that make labor standards work, carbon being taken into account, you know, across that range of sustainability issues that I was mentioning a little bit earlier. 14:57 And then bringing in a wider team of actors that are able to cross over from the demand side, the market shaping side through the supporting business strategies through to investment side. 15:12 And I wanna get onto the knowledge side of the business in a moment, but just to drill down on the investment window concept you mentioned. So are you attracting limited partners and institutional investors? 15:24 Are you managing money that you've already got from your own general partners? Who are you trying to attract to invest in adaptation solutions, and where's the money coming from? 15:32 I think it would be right to say that we are funneling down the runway as we are, um, a startup ourselves. We only came into existence in the early part of this year. 15:45 Our approach is not in the first instance to set up a fund, but to identify a pipeline of individual businesses that we work with and then take to market through SPVs, allowing investors not to contribute to general funds over which they have relatively little line of sight and decision making, and allowing them to invest in individual businesses that we're working with with a direct line of sight and working with us to ensure that effective oversight is executed. 16:22 And similarly, we would say those investors, particularly in the early stages, since we're talking series A, so we're talking, you know, one to five to ten million US dollars, say, um, will tend to be in the early stages family offices or high net worth individuals. 16:40 And I think it will be an open question as to whether in order to attract larger scale funding from institutional investors, we can continue the same model or whether we will need in our second stage of growth to open a fund of some kind. 16:58 And then because we're not simply a private equity shop, but we have this cross-cutting set of business functions that all have their own business models that interlock, Morphosis itself is investable in. 17:12 And so we're in the process of raising equity into Morphosis, you know, which gives... 17:20 Again, we suspect in the first instance family offices and high net wealth players an opportunity to put a stake in the ground in the growing adaptation economy, not just to be successful and earn returns from the work that we do as Morphosis, but for them to get a line of sight on the broader emergence of this area, which would in turn enable them to look at their own portfolios and to deploy assets more broadly in the adaptation investment space as it emerges. 17:56 It's an interesting structure, an innovative structure. I think it's one that works really well when you have an emergent market like climate adaptation. 18:03 I am familiar with other so-called venture studios like Tailwind Futures. They kind of started off by providing the intellectual underpinnings for venture investment in climate adaptation. 18:14 They issued a lot of intellectual capital into the world, and now they're building their fund off of it. 18:18 So when you have an early stage market like this, it is very helpful to have these organizations that areFostering, educating in investors, and also kind of creating the policy environment in which investments can flourish. 18:33 So, so I think that's right. I don't think there's anything entirely unique that we're doing in terms of the structure of our approach, but I think it allows growth in some interesting and diverse ways. 18:46 You know, if you're a, a pure play private equity fund, the way you grow is just getting a bigger and bigger balance sheet. Yeah. Raising more and more capital into your own balance sheet and deploying it more. 18:59 And, and that, you know, it's a way to grow and it's a way to be successful and hopefully profitable, but it's not really our preferred approach. 19:07 We think that our model allows for a Morphosis ecosystem to emerge where many partners, often with their own balance sheets, can become part of a co-investment strategy and indeed a co-development strategy on the knowledge side as well. 19:26 So, so we're hoping not that we're not gonna raise more money to our balance sheet, but that our overall growth structure and approach allows for, I won't say a more inclusive approach, because that sounds like a purely normative desire, but allows for growth that is more distributed. 19:45 For example, distributed by having relationships with funds in sub-Saharan Africa or other parts of the world. 19:52 Distributed in terms of having relationships with other knowledge partners that are using some of our IP that we've developed as part of our insights platform. 20:02 So, so I'm not sure that this is only for the early stage of our growth, and then at some point we become a vanilla balance sheet. 20:11 I think this offers ways of growing and being successful financially and in other ways that are much more interesting in a more sort of chaotic network world. Yes, the fun of being a startup, right? 20:24 All the potential, all the future paths you could go down, and I think it's important to have a initial vision which you have, and then see where it takes you. Okay. 20:33 I'd like to turn to your debut report at Morphosis, The Rise of the Adaptation Economy. 20:39 Now, this is a combination of a review of adaptation finance, country-based research with deep dives on Brazil and China, a technical paper on the adaptation economy, and a, a bundle of guidance and tools that make up what you're calling the adaptation economy policy framework. 20:58 It was released the other day at COP, and I'd like to start by asking, what were you hoping to achieve with this publication, and what audience are you trying to reach with it? Thanks very much, Louis. Yeah. 21:08 So if I can start by analogy and then come back to the core of the question. 21:15 So today we have an almost two trillion dollar a year investment market in renewables and clean tech from, frankly, an almost standing start a decade or so ago. 21:30 And it's worth just remembering one or two of the characteristics of how we got here. Yeah. 21:36 We often think and tend to say that it's all to do with the dramatic fall in the cost of solar and the interesting, but perhaps slightly less dramatic fall in the cost of wind. 21:48 And clearly, those technology cost curves are an important part of the story. But the reality is that the beginning was quite different. 21:56 The beginning was, was that Germany created the demand architecture that allowed China to scale. 22:03 So in the first instance, it was an energy and in fact a sort of ecological strategy linked to German culture with a bit of industrial policy thrown in, and then it became an industrial policy for China. Yeah. 22:20 Uh, and that's followed by the history that we all know. And so the market for renewables was largely created by policies as well as technology. 22:32 And then the next thing happened, which was as renewables needed more and more private investment across the world in order to grow as an energy source, the policy framework for enabling that to happen began to become standardized into really a fairly small number of levers, feed-in tariffs and offtake agreements and, you know, all, all kinds of pieces of the puzzle from capital markets through to the end use of kilowatt hours. 23:04 And today, and I'll exaggerate slightly to make the point, there's a turnkey policy package that one would recognize in Sudan and Switzerland as being broadly the same. 23:17 I exaggerate slightly to make the point, but not a lot in fact. The elements would be very similar. Now, let's turn back to adaptation. That standardized policy playbook doesn't exist. Yeah. 23:30 And obviously, the answer in the first instance is adaptation is more heterogeneous, it's more context specific. 23:38 You know, solar panels in Sudan look the same as solar panels in Switzerland, easier to standardize the policy framework, and in part, that's true. 23:47 Then the second part of the story is there are, you know, fairly common approaches to water or common approaches to food security. 23:54 So we begin to see standardized verticals across different parts of the adaptation agenda. 24:00 How, how will financial regulation shape the nexus between private investment, financial markets, and investment in adaptation solutions? 24:11 How will trade policy and investment policy, how do we think about R&D strategies, national innovation plans, economic and industrial strategies, these cross-cutting or transversal aspects of policies for which...We will need to standardize in order to enable roadmaps to be developed, in order to enable us to understand which governments are really doing what to create what markets, and ultimately, in order for investors to decide where to, uh, deploy their assets and solution providers to figure out which markets they want to prioritize as they think about access strategies. 24:59 So I think the, the thinking behind the work is how can we collectively, not just Morphosis and not just the partners that we've been working with, but how can we move quickly towards a standardized policy framework for making adaptation markets and more broadly for shaping adaptation economies that can make adaptation solutions more profitable, attract private capital, allow innovation and scale, bring down costs, and enable availability and affordability. 25:32 That's the virtuous circle that we're all interested in getting to. 25:36 And of course, technology innovation will help and entrepreneurial energy will be terribly important, but most important markets in the world are shaped by policies, and we haven't got our heads around how to do that most effectively. 25:52 So I think first and foremost, this piece is a contribution to that agenda at a moment where there's more money looking to invest in adaptation solutions, but the concern is that those markets are not delivering adequate financial returns. 26:09 So the core thesis, very clear, we need enabling policies to foster the market for adaptation solutions. Can you provide a few examples maybe of what these policies could look like? 26:21 We have examples from the renewable energy space in terms of subsidies, feed-in tariffs, et cetera. 26:26 For the adaptation side of the equation, what sort of policies do you think could be real catalysts for adaptation investment and innovation? 26:33 I mean, think of some of the things that you've been writing in Climate Proof, if I might kind of throw it back at you slightly, Louis. 26:40 You know, there's interesting work at the moment going on amongst the central banks and financial regulators that have broadly been trying to figure out how to play an effective role in the climate space. 26:55 And historically, their work through the network for central banks for greening the financial system have focused on the carbon side of the story. But they're now beginning to move on the adaptation side too. 27:09 And as you know, the UK regulators and central bank, you know, are looking at what are the levers that they have, you know, quite effective capital weighting requirements through to, you know, bond repurchasing and refinancing and all sorts of other pieces of regulatory armory, you know, in ways that can make those investments more profitable, not because those are policy institutions, but because adaptation solutions are likely to be less risky and therefore should be duly rewarded, for example, in terms of capital weighting as the world heats up more quickly. 27:54 So I think that's spotty at the moment. There are very few central banks that are acting in the area, although there is the beginning of a collective process in trying to figure it out. 28:07 But it's a really good example of it's not about water, and it's not about food, and it's not about sewage, and it's not about buildings. 28:17 You know, it's about how a transversal, in this case, financial regulation, more broadly central banking, can support, you know, the growth of an adaptation economy. 28:28 So that would be an example you've reported on briefly, I know, in Climate Proof, but I think that work is really at a fairly early stage internationally. 28:39 The second example, again, one that is in a sense obvious but is worth saying, many adaptation solution businesses are not profitable because climate is not being priced into the markets in which they're operating. 28:54 Yeah, it's completely clear. And, and that's happening both at the consumer end, through the supply chain, and at the investor end. 29:03 And so obviously we know there are and have been many initiatives over the past five to ten years, some of which I've been closely involved in, you know, seeking to push climate risk pricing into markets more effectively, either through a finance supply side push or through imposing obligations on the broader business community. 29:27 Now notwithstanding the pushback that we see coming from the US, we're seeing some important developments that won't simply result in companies disclosing reports in statutory requirements in some format defined by the ISSB and others. 29:42 But will begin to drive that risk pricing into markets which will advantage adaptation solution businesses, both because of their resilience in the context of climate change and the adaptation products that they're trying to sell, which will become more desirable over time. 30:02 You know, low energy air conditioning and the many other examples that we would think of at a sort of spot level, all these different adaptation solutions, their markets are all being affected by the way climate is being priced, financial regulation is operating, and, and many other of these transversals. 30:22 Think about R&D. 30:24 You know, find me a country that has an R&D strategy, and, you know, many countries do, and where adaptation is reallyBuried in that R&D strategy in terms of the allocation of research funds, the focus priorities within important technology and other institutions. 30:44 You know, we begin again to see a spottiness of interesting examples emerging in that area. But if you ask, "Where are the really interesting strategies in bioeconomy?" You may get some answers investing. 30:58 But if you ask, "Is there a transversal lens being placed on the way in which the public sector is allocating research funds in relation to adaptation?" The answer is not at all. Not at all. 31:10 I can't think of a single country where that's happening in the slightest. So those would be the cross-cutting examples I would give. And then obviously there are the verticals. 31:20 You know, desalination in countries that have weak environmental regulations tends to be large scale plants that have severe polluting outlets. 31:38 Whereas what we really want is to incentivize desalination technologies that don't have that kind of polluting outlets. 31:50 And that speaks not to a rule about desalination and in my example, not even necessarily a way of thinking about the pricing of water. 31:59 You know, in this case, it becomes what are the cross-cutting environmental standards that will tend to advantage desalination technology that has less polluting outlets. 32:13 I'm with you on the point that policies can trigger cascading changes in how markets price climate risk and how they behave in relation to their own customers and partners, right? 32:25 But I do wonder whether policy also can move quite slowly, and a number of people I speak to as part of my work are on the kind of pure play investor side, pure play kind of catalyst side, and they think, "Look, policy is moving too slowly. 32:38 What actually is driving investment and driving activity now is businesses who are faced with floods, fires, storms. They need to protect their assets. They need to make their supply chains more resilient." 32:49 They're not waiting for policy. They're reacting to very specific needs, I suppose, rather than kind of cross-cutting needs, but very specific needs to their own businesses. And I, I'd like to get your thoughts on that. 32:59 Like, what do you say to those who think it's not policy actually, it's market signals that are gonna drive this, pure play market signals? 33:05 Well, we wouldn't be having this conversation if there weren't a set of standards, you know, governing the signals that are running between you and me right now. And some of those emerged through the technology itself. 33:20 Some of them emerged through associations of businesses putting together industry level standards. But actually, a lot of them emerged through policy development. 33:31 And as we know, the Internet was funded by the US military as a kicker just to get going. 33:37 And similarly, without really digging in too far, if we look at many of the highly valued tech businesses in the world today, and not just all in China, but on the West Coast of the US as well, obviously we see that many of them have benefited enormously from policy measures, technologies that were funded by governments and standards that were developed and advanced sometimes for competitive advantage of national champions. 34:07 That may be good or bad over really every sector that we can think of. 34:14 You know, what really is going to deliver climate-proof food security for low and middle income households in the future in the context of a two, two point one, two and a half degree world? 34:28 You know, it's probably going to be the result of scaled technology, whether it be vertical farming or the next generation of lab-grown protein underpinned by China's industrial strategy. 34:46 Not by what's happening in the US or Europe or anywhere else. 34:50 So I think before we get to the problems of Brussels, which I will turn to in a second, I think it's important for people to kind of embrace how most major markets are actually developed. 35:03 Yeah, not purely by policy, but governments often play a really critical role along the way. 35:11 Now, let me turn just for a second to Brussels, because I think, I think we have to ask what kind of policy institutions are likely to move the bar fast enough and in the right direction. 35:25 Is it likely to be an institution such as the European Commission, or is it more likely to be governments more focused on supporting intensive developments of industrial and economic strategies? 35:40 Or is it more likely to be governments that are more focused on fiscal tax exemption models in order to incentivize investment? So we're talking, you know, Europe as a standards organization. 35:54 You know, China as a policy-driven industrial strategy organization. The US, you know, more market-based with multiple industrial subsidies in highly distributed ways. 36:06 You know, these are very different policy development environments. And, you know, do we ask the question going perhaps to smaller countries or less visible countries? 36:19 You know, how does a Brazil maintain the power of its agribusiness economy in the context of climate change? 36:28 Is that a pure play business response or are there some broader-Policy measures, certainly the Brazilian business community thinks so, that need to be taken. 36:40 How do we distinguish if we're an investor between taking insect protein companies to Kenya rather than Uganda or rather than Peru? Well, I can guarantee you it will be availability of capital. 36:57 I can guarantee you it will be the right policy environment regarding the product. 37:02 You know, there will be many policy measures that will be important for making those very specific asset level investment decisions as well. Is there a disconnect between speed and need? 37:15 Yes, I think you're right, but I think only to look at what I would see as a very slothful Brussels process as the only case in point is really unfortunate today. So you've laid out this adaptation economy framework. 37:33 Can you tell us a little bit about why you think it's needed, how it could be implemented, and also how you think it differs from other efforts that have been made in the recent past to try to formalize a structure around adaptation, right? 37:47 The OECD has its climate adaptation investment framework, uh, that it released last year. They've been trying to build upon that. 37:53 You have a number of entities trying to kind of own this space in terms of providing the intellectual superstructure for investment. 38:02 So why does your approach differ, and how do you think it could be best implemented by readers? So you asked me at the beginning of this interview, you know, "You're an old man, Simon. 38:12 What have you been doing all your life?" And I gave you sort of by way of an answer. 38:17 What I perhaps didn't say was that each stage of my journey, I've been fortunate enough to be at the hockey stick moment of the topic that I've addressed. 38:32 You know, whether it was labor standards or carbon, whether it was financial regulation and sustainability, whether it was nature, uh, and now adaptation. 38:41 So what happens at those hockey stick moments is that you get a kind of blossoming of innovations, you get a surge of experimentation, you get a mass of duplication, you get intense competition, much of which is zero-sum, and you come out at the other end, if you're lucky, with most of that noise disappearing and a convergence of a set of approaches that are not low ball. 39:16 Right. That one's actually raised the overall game towards whatever agenda one's approaching. So the first thing is, don't worry about the noise and the replication. 39:27 That, that's just inherent to the moment we are on the innovation curve. You know, I wouldn't worry about it if you like. 39:35 And competition and duplication and personality fights and who's got the best club and all of this stuff is just par for the course. 39:45 One has to really focus on not how to get the best social media onto LinkedIn so that more people read it than read somebody's mate over in the other corner. But what's the core of what one's trying to achieve? 39:59 Because Morphosis might not succeed. Who knows? Yeah. But the question is, what's the core that one's really trying to advance? Okay, so that-that's a contextual point, I think, Louis, that's worth it. 40:11 Otherwise, we're all just distracted by noise. Who said what, when, how, who, and was it a better color? 40:17 So our focus is on the policy frameworks that shape markets that can attract private investment into what are today undercapitalized and therefore underscaled adaptation solution business and assets. 40:36 If I compare it, for example, to the OECD, the World Bank, the IFC, and other finance supply frameworks, 40:46 I think those investment frameworks are really helpful, but there's only so far you can go in looking through a finance supply side lens. You will not find in those documents anything about R&D strategy. 41:01 You will not find in those documents anything about trade and investment policies. Yeah. 'Cause that's not what they're focusing on. And so I think they play a really useful role, yeah, but they're one side of the story. 41:15 And that's why in our report, without again getting into a sort of who said what show, you know, we have challenged our broader community that is, in our view, overly focused on the lens of adaptation finance, saying, "Yes, ultimately finance is important, but we have to take a whole economy approach and not only focus on the finance supply side." 41:41 The risk of looking exclusively through a finance supply side is that because markets are not working, which is our argument, you always end up with a blended finance solution, you know, which is effectively a subsidized solution by another name. 41:58 Yeah. Because the market's not working, so the company's not profitable enough, so the private capital won't flow. So where's the tax dollars that are gonna help? 42:05 And although I have no principled objection to subsidy, you know, if you look for a moment at what's happening to public finances, you know, nobody believes that lending public finance into commercial capital is a scalable route to go. 42:26 You know, last year, international development assistance fell by seven point one percent. 42:31 The OECD reckons it might fall by fifteen percent this year.Debt to GDP ratios of all OECD countries have almost doubled over the past ten years. 42:42 So this isn't just a fiscal crisis in a group of poorer countries, this is a fiscal crisis across the board with almost no exceptions. 42:53 So we can't solve this problem through a blended finance model, even though blended finance options need to be part of the mix. 43:03 Which is why we're arguing one needs to take a whole economy model is what every normal government does when they're thinking about economic and industrial strategy, how one negotiates new trade agreements, and so on and so forth. 43:16 And so adaptation mustn't become a labeled vertical alongside the main game. Adaptation needs to be understood as integrated into those activities. 43:28 Now, if you look at national adaptation plans, in theory, NAPs are meant to be what I just described to you. But they're not in practice. 43:40 Even if you look at what I would consider to be a pretty sophisticated one, which is the recent French national adaptation plan, which as you know, headlines that they are planning for a world of four degrees increase over pre-industrial levels by the end of the century. 43:58 So it's a extraordinary thing for the French government to say, to be perfectly honest. 44:02 But actually, if you read what is a hugely voluminous document with many technical papers attached to it, you will find almost nothing about how to attract private capital into these adaptation solutions. 44:15 They just don't have a game plan. Yeah. 44:18 Or if you look at Brazil's new economic and industrial strategy, you know, that is shepherded by the Minister of Finance and the Ministry of Finance on behalf of the overall government. 44:30 It's a really sophisticated strategy and has many environmental ecological aspects to it, given the nature of Brazil's economy, except that it's not framed by a two to three and a half degree world. 44:46 And so actually there is no adaptation play in it. I know it sounds obvious what we're saying we're trying to do, but when one looks at practice, that's not actually what's happening. 44:59 The solution is not to get Brazil to do a little bit more and to get France to do it a bit different and Kenya to do it a bit different again, and so on. 45:07 That, that although we need to take account of differences between these different countries and their different contexts and their different priorities and interests, we also need to think early on about at what level and in what way one can begin to standardize those policy plays and to be able to measure progress as a result. 45:29 Yes. I think you've touched on another tension perhaps in the adaptation debate, which is should it be siloed? 45:36 Should there be a dedicated focus on adaptation in exclusion of other climate and sustainability goals, or should it be integrated, embedded throughout our entire kind of policy effort on climate, right? 45:49 And I'm seeing conversations about, oh, enhanced national determined contributions, the carbon emission reduction plans that countries put together. 45:57 They should be enhanced and actually kind of tied in with NAPs more closely. So actually there is on one side a push to harmonize, coordinate these efforts more. But then again, from my... 46:06 A-another perspective is that if you have adaptation as its own standalone topic, then it's easier to kind of create investment taxonomies around, uh, and attract investors who have s-only so much limited brain space into focusing on solutions within this area. 46:21 So I understand kind of both sides, the need to kind of like cross-cut and also the need to kind of like focus in so that you can kind of create a really strong investment thesis and policy thesis for adaptation itself. 46:33 Uh, can I get to questions that some people might have, which is, okay, let's say we're a country and we put this framework in place, your framework in place. We follow it to the letter. We are now climate proofed. 46:42 We are now protected. 46:44 [chuckles] I don't think anybody will believe that in this changing, wilder, warmer world we're facing that any degree of policy measures and any combination of investment measures will guard a country against climate shocks. 46:56 So can you talk a little bit about the limits, I suppose, of adaptation and what the realistic outcome of implementation of your framework would be for a country like, let's say, Jamaica, which is facing this terrible hurricane, Cuba, which is facing this terrible hurricane as well? 47:09 I will restate the point that we're not measuring adaptation. 47:15 We're measuring the extent to which the national, for now, economy is made up of markets that effectively awa- reward investment in commercial adaptation solutions. Yeah. 47:30 So that is, for us, a huge part of the story, not least because of the limits of public finance, but it's not measuring adaptation per se. And I just wanna make that clear. 47:44 So, so, you know, let, let's come back to the Jamaica conundrum. 47:49 Having lived in the Caribbean for a number of years, I'm reasonably well aware, having also lived through a major hurricane during my time there, that some things are not just uninsurable, but almost unadaptable to. 48:02 Yeah. And so I'm not the right person to ask this question or to answer it, but I would say with a fairly somber face that there will be many parts of the world that can't adapt, just can't adapt. 48:18 There'll come points where there is no soil to regenerate because the nature of climate has made it so. That there'll come a point where there isn't really enough water to drink. 48:30 In fact, there already are many places of that kind. So I think maybe, Louis, it's a different podcast, but there are clearlyGoing to be more and more places that become unlivable. 48:42 And many people, even in the pro-adaptation space, have said quite rightly, there are limits to what we can adapt to. Yeah. Particularly with limited resources. That goes without saying. 48:55 So, so with that in mind, one keeps coming back to, okay, so for an island in the Caribbean, such as Jamaica, which is a large island, sophisticated, certainly compared to many other islands in the world, you know, lots of capabilities, you know, which parts of the economy can one stabilize in the face of those sorts of climate events, knowing that frankly, there are just gonna be more and more of them. 49:28 I remember when Puerto Rico was very severely damaged a number of years ago, there was an initiative put into play saying, "We don't wanna fix the current energy infrastructure. 49:41 You know, this is the opportunity to replace it with distributed infrastructure." 49:45 So distributed solar infrastructure with no large centralized infrastructure at all, not just because that's good for carbon, but because it's a far more resilient system because it's a highly distributed system. Yeah. 49:59 And I remember there was much discussion about it, and then eventually the discussion ran out and almost nothing happened. But the example is well-placed. 50:09 Obviously, one's trying to imagine which parts of the economy, energy, water, food, tourism, are resilient to those sorts of crises as they happen more and more and, and some of them just won't be. 50:24 The work that we're doing along with many others, you know, may be good at identifying pieces of that economy, yeah, that can be not just made more robust, but can adapt to the changing climate conditions that it faces, you know, particularly through technology developments, but with many others not. 50:45 You know, that there is no magic to markets or technology that solves to some of the problems that we're going to face. So comes a little bit back to the climate denialism issue. 50:56 Again, you know, for us to get away from the sort of the, the sort of toxic axis of pessimism and optimism, yeah, which stops us talking and stops us thinking, and to go, you know, which bits are really fixable where, and which bits aren't, and how's that gonna play out going forward? 51:18 You know, if I'm a purchaser of cocoa from West Africa, I may well be investing in regenerative agriculture in West Africa to improve quality, productivity, and weather resilience. Yeah. 51:34 But, but I'm also investing in synthetic cocoa startups. So I don't really believe that that West African play has a long game to it. 51:43 I only really think it's got a short game, and at, at the very minimum, I'm hedging my bets. 51:49 So we need to understand what's going on here and what can be fixed and what can't be fixed, and how businesses are increasingly creating hedge bets in the adaptation space. 52:00 We need to get our heads around the implications of that, not just for those businesses, not just for the investors in those businesses, but for all the actors down their existing supply chains. 52:10 Many of which those supply chains just won't be there in the future. 52:15 Yes, and I think bringing it back to what I said earlier about market signals versus policy frameworks, it is interesting that you are seeing large corporates, taking the cocoa example, the chocolate example, that are investing in synthetics or investing in hardier varieties that can withstand climate shocks, but these are massive corporations that have the, the budgets of large governments, you know. 52:36 So I'm thinking about the rest of the market, the rest of the global economy that doesn't have access to those resources, that science, and having a framework of, of policies that help to enable this kind of more holistic thinking, this more thinking about, okay, let's not have one focus, let's look at potential climate futures and hedge for different outcomes, I think would be very valuable. 52:56 Okay, I wanna finish now by asking about what you hope to achieve off the springboard of the report, and what are your hopes for Morphosis over the next, let's say, six to twelve months. 53:06 Where do you hope to be this time next year? Great. Thanks, David. So, so we're launching a report or a set of reports, to be more precise, amidst, as we've discussed, a blizzard of other reports. 53:18 And so how do we make this a useful contribution? So it has to be practical. 53:26 We or others have to be able to use it, not to be a standardized template for creating a roadmap, but to inform adaptation economy roadmaps. 53:39 And actually, that would be helpful if in a year's time, a few wealthier countries, a few middle income countries, a few perhaps lower income countries have begun to try this out to see how this adaptation economy lens, this whole economy lens can help them with their adaptation and broader economic development and industrial strategy plans going forward. 54:05 Yeah, so I think where does this fit in to things that are already going on and improve the outcome? So that would be a big step forward, not just for us at Morphosis, but I think would be a useful contribution to make. 54:19 Now, we believe strongly that roadmaps of this kind and frameworks of this kind need to be measurable and comparable. 54:29 And so we are already engaged in turning the framework into an index, and that index, in the first instance, will only be at the sovereign level. 54:40 That's a challenge enough in itself.And we'll seek to measure progress made by governments in implementing policies that create the adaptation markets, dot, dot, dot, dot, dot, as I've described before. 54:55 And we will put out an initial version of that early next year. 55:00 It will be using both standardized available data, so not proprietary data, and will have an AI engine sitting inside it that allows novel approaches to using existing data, but also text-based data to create new datasets. 55:20 And will, over the course of next year, become increasingly functional, i.e., will be something that governments and others can use, not simply observe to see which country has done better than another country. 55:37 We think that framework that we're starting with at a national level can usefully come down to a sub-national level and, and ultimately can come down to an asset level. 55:51 And we're already in discussions with data providers to the financial community to see how we might get more quickly down to an asset level analysis. 56:03 So for example, a single company, which at the moment, yeah, if you look at the way in which we think about resilience and adaptation, it doesn't figure particularly strongly in the way in which we price public equities, for example. 56:20 So I think there's a sort of Russian doll sack, if you like, running from the sovereign level down to sub-sovereign and city sector specific, and also ultimately down to d- down to asset level. 56:32 Now, Morphosis doesn't have to do all of that, but we think having a golden thread that connects from the macro analysis down to the micro analysis is going to be really important to have some consistency in the way that analytics is actually functioning. 56:51 Morphosis, um, in a year's time, you know, if we're successful, I would modestly say in the first instance we've survived, which is always a good starting point. 57:03 I think we will have made a number of investments, so our private investment side will be evolving quite nicely. 57:14 Um, I think we will have a portfolio of businesses that we're working with, some of which we invest in, some of which we don't invest in, more in that merchant banking side of what I just described at the beginning. 57:26 And I think the knowledge side exemplified by this framework can play a useful role along with others for convening actors that are trying to figure where to go. 57:40 And so that I think will translate from pure research products into advisory and other ways in which the knowledge side of our work can generate resources that we need in order to function effectively. 57:54 So it's not a nonprofit part of a private equity business. It's an integrated business, which is what I said in the first place. 58:03 If it was really successful, then, then I would say it would not be only a question of how much won-- money we raised or deployed, or how many people are fascinated by the knowledge products that we're building or are fiddling with the index. 58:17 But it would be whether, despite your raised eyebrows when I said it earlier on, you know, we've begun to create an ecosystem of actors that are working with similar tools and instruments. 58:29 Now, we're not the first people to think of that. 58:32 I think of Gary, for example, and Lightsmith and others who, you know, were really early movers, not just in the adaptation investment space, but also in trying to create coalitions and encourage dialogue. 58:43 So we're not alone in that space, but I think our particular focus gives us a basis on which to contribute alongside Gary and others to bringing actors together, not only to learn and share experiences, but also to form different kinds of effective and profitable alliances. 59:08 I think in the next year, externally, what's going to happen, and I think we're already seeing that as we run into Brazil, and you and I talked about that when we met the first time. 59:20 You know, I think rooms that until now have had twenty, thirty people in it talking about adaptation that all know each other far too well, these rooms are gonna be five times the size, and they're gonna be sold out with people waiting outside the door. 59:34 In other words, there's going to be a huge surge in actors working in this space. 59:39 I think governments, and particularly governments in the Global South, particularly for example, in Sub-Saharan Africa, are going to increasingly, frankly, shun the mitigation agenda and insist on a much greater focus on the adaptation agenda. 59:56 So I think the context in a year's time won't just be more, it'll be more, more intense, many different actors and a lot of focus on what we and you in your work are referring to as the adaptation economy. 1:00:12 And we hope that Morphosis can make a contribution in that area, but there'll be many other actors as well trying to make a difference. Yes. 1:00:20 And your thesis of being at a hockey stick moment kind of shines through there, right? 1:00:24 As you said, rooms that used to be sparsely populated are likely to become blockbuster events, uh, because of this focus on adaptation, this realization that we need to kind of get to grips with this side of the climate equation. 1:00:36 So I'm excited Morphosis is in this space. I do encourage my listeners to read the report and the accompanying papers. 1:00:42 I'll put a link in the show notes, and I look forward to seeing what Morphosis gets up to post-COP as well. For now, Simon, thank you so much for your time, and have a great rest of your day. 1:00:50 Louis, thanks very much indeed and look forward to more. Climate Proofer is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 1:00:59 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]