Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. The New York Climate Exchange is redefining the idea of what a climate hub is all about. 0:24 The cross-sector nonprofit group, founded in 2023, offers a new paradigm for research and development on climate solutions in the Big Apple, not only on the tech front, but as it relates to policy, environmental justice, and public education too. 0:37 In around 2029, the hub will settle into a new purpose-built campus on Governors Island, a small parcel of land in New York Harbor, and a place where the climate risks facing the city simply can't be ignored. 0:49 The campus will host research, workforce development, policy development, and public programming delivered by a broad range of partners from the public and private sector alike. 0:58 Today, I speak with Steven Hammer, CEO of the Exchange, to discuss his vision for the new center and understand his theory of change when it comes to mobilizing talent and capital in service of climate adaptation. 1:09 We also dig into the potential of AI as a driver of climate solutions, and as a way of attracting top flight talent to the climate field. We also explore the knotty problem of climate finance. 1:20 First off, apologies for the sound quality of this intro. I'm on the road this week, so recorded without all the fancy tools that usually make me sound clear as a bell. 1:28 Because of this, I'll also be skipping the usual news roundup, but you can catch up by checking out Monday's edition of the newsletter over at climateproof.news. 1:36 Okay, without any further ado, let's get into my conversation with Steven. [upbeat music] Hi, Steven. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? 1:45 Uh, New York City, and I'm the CEO of the New York Climate Exchange. First of all, what is the New York Climate Exchange? Who originated it? How did it get started, and what's its purpose? 1:56 So the Exchange actually came from an idea that the city of New York had to create a globally renowned center for climate solutions that would really capitalize on what New York City has, thought leadership, access to Wall Street, home of the UN. 2:14 And when, when they invited groups to, uh, respond to the tender, they asked universities... 2:22 The, the lead university of the Exchange, State University of, of New York at Stony Brook, they brought together these world-class academic partners, brought in some, uh, amazing corporate partners, IBM, Moody's, and BCG, 2:36 and then 33 community organizations representing the labor community, the environmental justice community, local chambers of commerce, 2:45 all with the goal of saying that we need these very different perspectives and capacities if we're really gonna tackle climate change in a meaningful way. 2:53 So I've been on the job for about a year, and now we're in the process of building out our programming, and eventually we're gonna have a big home on an island, Governors Island, in the middle of New York Harbor, which will be where we'll host university students for academic courses on climate. 3:08 We'll have research l- facilities. We'll have a tech incubator, and we're gonna have world-class conference facilities. All of this together, all climate, all the time. That's wonderful. 3:19 And as a New Yorker myself and someone who enjoys visiting Governors Island, I look forward to when the final center is, is ready, and I'm sure to attend plenty of events and exciting, uh, conferences that will take place there. 3:29 So this sounds like a real success from a public-private partnership point of view, and I'm wondering what factors kind of helped put all the pieces together for this, because we hear about difficulty sometimes of getting private sectors involved in, in climate action, and state, local, federal government agencies all work on their own timelines [chuckles] and all have their own bureaucracies. 3:48 So what, what made the New York Climate Exchange come together? You identified what some of the challenges are right now. Folks are operating in silos. They're not always communicating. 3:58 They're not inviting all the right people to the conversation. And so when the partners came together to put the vision together for what is going to be the Exchange, they really said, "It matters who's at the table. 4:10 It matters that we're hearing these different voices." And so we're now building out the programming. 4:15 The, the, the campus will be the physical manifestation of that idea, all of these things sitting right next to each other, cross-fertilizing ideas. 4:24 What we're trying to do is build out the programming right now that actually lives up to those ideals as well. Excellent. 4:32 And I want to get into that programming because here at Climate Proofers, we're focused on adaptation. I imagine your climate exchange will be looking at adaptation and mitigation. So I'm wondering when you... 4:43 as you build out your program, how are you thinking about the balance of projects and programs, and how does adaptation feature in your inaugural se- uh, semester? 4:51 The way we, we frame it is we're actually building a campus on an island, and so all of the vulnerabilities that any islands anywhere has to sea level rise. This is an island. 5:02 It was actually very heavily hit by Hurricane Sandy 12 years ago. And, and so we are having to take that account into our design. 5:09 We, we are capitalizing on, on that in terms of the research that we wanna host on the island that'll really say we wanna understand both what's going on in the atmosphere and in the ocean, and how could all of that inform how cities are engaging, the impact that cities have on the climate, and how cities need to adapt to the climate. 5:28 A- an even more immediate and prominent near-term impact in New York, and many other cities, is the extreme weather events, the heavy storms that are really leading to a lot of street flooding. 5:41 You're seeing what has been a engineering design decision from decades, if not 100 years ago, in terms of the size of the pipes and the amount of water that they can move off of the streets quickly. 5:52 But when you live in a city, much of which is paved, all of that stormwater runoff is now becoming an increasing problem.And so helping the city think through how to navigate that, helping communities even understand the challenges at their doorstep, these are the some of the things that we're building into the programming right now. 6:12 There is one model in New York, I'm not sure if you've heard about it, it's called Flood Net, and it's an effort by New York University and the City University of New York, it's a collaboration, to install these low-cost sensors in, in key intersections around the city. 6:26 And it provides real-time monitoring data on where there is flooding that's occurring. 6:31 We're s- looking at that as a model for a, a, a low-cost sensor that could be deployed more widely, that could lead to really interesting information that can help guide investment decisions in terms of infrastructure upgrades. 6:45 It can help, uh, property owners in, in certain neighborhoods understand the frequency and the severity of the events and what they're now n- going to need to invest in to upgrade their own properties. 6:55 So New York has become this climate tech hub. Of course, it's the financial capital of America, if not the world. 7:02 Uh, but I'm interested in also how you're thinking some of these tech advancements and finance can be leveraged to kind of drive new modes of, of governance and, and inform better policy as well. 7:11 You made a point about Flood Net there, but I'm also interested, uh, to what extent is the Exchange gonna look at the intersection of tech and governance? 7:17 'Cause my understanding is that when it comes to adaptation in cities, uh, you do have to think a lot about the various levels of bureaucracies involved and of course the needs, uh, of the community that lives there. 7:29 So are you thinking about policy as well in the context of the New York, uh, Climate Exchange? Yeah. So first off, I, I'd make the point that we're gonna be based in New York, but our... 7:39 the issues we're gonna work on and the impacts we hope to have are gonna be global. 7:43 And then so there's gonna be a lot of learning that comes from New York, but there's also ideas that we're th- we anticipate bringing from other cities around the world to New York City. 7:53 In, in terms of the tech sector, you're absolutely right, this is an, a growing space. It's something the city of New York is very focused on. 8:00 They wanna build out the green economy over the next 10 years very dramatically. They're positioning us as an important player there. We're talking to our partners. 8:08 Again, if you think of who we have as our academic partners, whether it's Stony Brook or Brookhaven National Laboratory or NYU or RIT or University of Washington, Georgia Tech, Duke, Oxford, these are players who are, are active in the tech space. 8:26 And, and so they have facilities on their campuses. We're trying to figure out how we can leverage that ecosystem, some of which is in New York, some of which is elsewhere. 8:34 Add to that the tech ecosystem that exists in and around New York City. How can we put those things together? How can we build on that? A lot of what we're very focused on is value add. 8:44 So how do we make sure that we're building connections, we're turning... 8:47 using the Exchange and our, our access to really top quality talent and ideas, how can we bring that to New York to, to leverage, as you said, the access to, to Wall Street, the investment resources that are here? 9:01 But we're also building out the network internationally of other cities, the city networks like the C40, like ICLEI, like the Global Covenant of Mayors. 9:11 That is an audience that is gonna be very interested in what we're turning out in terms of information, ideas, and access to, to new technology. 9:18 We want to make sure that we're hoping to find the cities that are interested in learning more about this technology and help that tech transfer, so that if you're an entrepreneur and you may be dealing with regulatory issues that are challenging in New York City or in another city in the US, that perhaps there's a city that has a problem and they're willing to accelerate deployment. 9:40 And, and we wanna make sure that we can help people, you know, find those solutions, find those opportunities as well. Yes. 9:45 There has been an upspringing of climate resilience centers or hubs partly financed by National Science Foundation, partly through other federal initiatives like the Inflation Reduction Act and the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. 9:59 Uh, and I'm wondering, do you see yourself replicating this model in other cities, or do you se- see yourselves more as a, as a kind of facilitator connecting with these other accelerators and hubs throughout the US and the world? 10:10 I, I think we're... it's still early day and the final answer is yet to be determined, but I... we are... 10:17 we've been, through our travels internationally, we've been talking to some of the tech sectors and the incubators in other parts of the world about how can we build relationships. 10:27 I, I was at the World Bank before I came back to New York to join the Exchange, and I've been trying to leverage those contacts that I had working on climate finance issues for many decades, where we're trying to figure out how can we build bridges to find the entrepreneurs or to find the needs in those countries in the Global South, and how can we bring some of those entrepreneurs to New York, help them access what may be available here that is not available at home, so that they can then go home and live out the, the vision they have for their new technology. 10:59 Or how can we identify the problems and then turn the folks we have access to through our large tech network and say, "Here are problems. Here are a willing audience, consumers for your technology. 11:12 What would you do to help solve those problems?" We wanna be that bridge, taking ideas elsewhere and bringing entrepreneurs here. 11:19 From what you're saying, it seems to me there's a economic growth component to the Exchange, right? This is one of the benefits it could bring to New York and to the green economy writ large. 11:29 I think that's one of the arguments that's been used since [laughs] day zero of the cl- energy transition and of climate change being a real political and economic issue. 11:37 And I'm wondering n- now we've had years of inflation, we have a change of administration in the US. Mm-hmm. 11:42 We also have pressures, growth pressures in Europe, uh, and the UK, and there's this pivoting away from climate being seen as the, uh, the growth driver to, to AI and other technologies. 11:52 I'm wondering how you think the thesis of climate change as an economic driver, uh, will evolve and if it, and if it's still convincing in, in this day and age. 11:59 So I'm from California originally.I have family in the LA area. I've had friends who have been affected by the fires there. 12:08 You know, sometimes climate and the transition that's needed is positioned as this opportunity that we can capitalize on, and there's... This is the, the green growth idea. 12:19 Other folks are very focused on preventing the losses that are anticipated, addressing the, the likely impacts, and so it's much more of a defensive posture. 12:29 If you put those two together, fires and, and the, the size of the impact they're having on LA, given where some of those losses have oc- have occurred, 12:40 could have a dramatic transformation on the economic foundation of the LA region. If there are people in the entertainment industry who have now been chased out of their homes, where are they gonna go? 12:51 They're not gonna necessarily be able to do their job tomorrow or in two months or in six months. They may start thinking very quickly, "Where else can I go to set up shop so I can keep doing my job?" 13:03 Is adaptation or is resilience an investment to capitalize on growth opportunities, or is it to, to retain the economic engine that you have? I think different cities are gonna land in different places on this. 13:18 I don't think anybody anticipated the impact of this scale. We haven't seen fires have impacts like this in other parts of the world, even where the fires have been quite dramatic. 13:28 This was just so close to a very large, heavily populated area, and it's gonna dramatically affect a few key industries or a few, few key sectors, and that may change the way we begin to think about how and why we need to think about climate change. 13:43 And you saw this, again, what was it, 10, 15 years ago in Thailand, when you had the impact on the tech sector in and around Thailand when the floods hit so heavily. 13:54 You know, big storms came through, and I think it was a third to 50% of the hard drive industry was concentrated in a particular geographic region. And as a result of that, they dispersed. 14:08 They said, "We can't rely on the fact that this won't happen again in one year or 10 years. We want to hedge our bets and, and begin to build plants elsewhere." 14:18 So those economies of scale that some economies were, were factoring into the growth and prioritization of a particular sector, you may now see people trying to hedge their bets and saying, "I actually wanna, uh, decentralize some of what I'm doing so that I'm, I'm less vulnerable." 14:34 Now, what's interesting to me is this notion of looking at supply chain as something that we wanna take account of climate. 14:43 That's something that we've been talking about now for more than 10, 15 years, and yet it c- it's gotten caught up in certain three-letter acronyms that people take great offense at. But these risks are real. 14:57 The impacts are real. And I think people are gonna wanna take account of that from a, a pure financial risk management perspective, whether they want to put climate in that, in the name. 15:08 I'm less concerned about people being smart about what are the risks that they face and how are they gonna deal with those in the most appropriate way. 15:16 And the impetus among cities and states here in the US that can kind of compete with each other for, uh, human capital, right, for, for professionals and for finance means that if they, yes, they want to maintain a competitive advantage, whether you, you're New York or Los Angeles, then you have to prove yourself resilient to these climate impacts so that business can go on, if not as usual, but at least still functioning, uh, after these disasters. 15:41 Yeah. And, and again, the Los Angeles example is, I think, the extreme example. 15:46 But if, if you were a New Yorker, if you're a climate person in New York, and you had a bingo card of all the things you expect to happen related to climate change, 15:59 having fires in several of the parks around the city as we did three months ago, was probably not on that bingo card. 16:06 We were all surprised a few years ago when we got smoke from fifteen hundred miles away in Canada, and again, that wasn't on our climate impacts bingo card. 16:14 What is beginning to happen is that we're seeing that a lot of places that thought they were safe or places that thought the, the impacts may not be as great as they, they would in other parts of the world were being surprised. 16:27 And whether you're a coastal community and you're anticipating only to face sea level rise, 16:33 but now you may see that the, the loss of fisheries right off the coast is gonna drive away an important part of your economic engine. 16:40 Or if you're in the southern-- southeastern United States and you're beginning to see different types of sargassum flood the beaches, create this odorous condition that is now driving away your tourism base. 16:52 These are things that people have not been taking into account, and we need to be more comprehensive, understand the science, understand the local relevance of that science, and then take action. 17:02 I want to focus in now on coastal resiliency. 17:05 This is of course a priority for New York City, a priority for the New York Climate Exchange, and your location on Governors Island is clearly vulnerable to storm surge and coastal flooding, so it's obviously something dear to your heart too. 17:20 I'm wondering what are your reflections on how New York has been dealing with coastal risks so far, and what else needs to be done to ensure New York can survive against a barrage from the coast? I... 17:31 What you're saying is that this is a city that has the access to science. 17:36 They have access to the engineering expertise that says, "Let's figure out what is the right solution in this particular neighborhood versus that particular neighborhood." 17:45 They've made a political commitment now for twenty years that they wanna take climate seriously, 17:51 and they're slowly building what is within the city's financial resources to build out those barriers, to build out resilience in different ways, whether it's through the hard infrastructure or through some kind of berm right along the river. 18:04 Go across the river to New Jersey.Go up to Connecticut. Are you seeing the same type of investment, the same type of policy commitment in those coastal communities? And the answer is no. 18:17 And so I think we're very fortunate that we are both in a city that is taking this very seriously, that says we do want to take the actions that are gonna protect lives and livelihoods. 18:29 We do wanna make sure that New York is still New York in 50 years, and it's not some hollowed out economy because it got washed away. 18:36 That's a serious political and financial commitment, and it's really commendable that now we've had admi- you know, since the Bloomberg team was one of the first to really come in and put climate square on the table, that we've had subsequent administrations that have had that same level of commitment. 18:52 And now with the idea emerged under the de Blasio administration, and now the Adams administration, to build this center for climate solutions. 19:01 Again, taking it even one step further, not just the physical, but the intellectual, hopefully bringing in the financial resources that will be put to bear at scale on these issues. 19:11 Again, I think it shows a lot of forethought. I think other cities around the world, other parts of the world are gonna wanna follow suit. 19:18 It's interesting what you say about New York taking a proactive approach to coastal resilience, but other states not doing so. 19:26 And that makes me think about how important it is to have a joined up approach at a national level, at a regional level to ensure that climate resilience actions can be the most effective, right? 19:36 Because yes, there are lots of things that individual municipalities and states can do, but those efforts will be multiplied, become more effective if there is, uh, supporting initiatives taking place in other states as well. 19:48 So I'm wondering, again, from your view, like what's the importance of joining up adaptation efforts and governance, and how can the exchange help with that? 19:55 The interesting timing of our conversation is that we're now, what? A week or two into congestion pricing in New York City, which is the mitigation example of, you know, hopefully people would act in a joined up manner. 20:08 And, and what we're seeing is instead lawsuits and opposition from folks in New Jersey, folks up the Hudson River, folks in Connecticut who are concerned about their, their very parochial financial impacts if they were to drive into New York City. 20:24 And, and so how do you take these kinds of conversations and say that this is gonna benefit everybody equally? It's really hard because the resources will tend to flow. 20:36 And, and, and I'm gonna go back to, if you look at where some of these, uh, resilience investments along the river are being made, is that happening in the South Bronx? Is that happening in northern Manhattan? 20:49 Is it happening on Staten Island or out in Brooklyn? They're focusing very heavily on where there is a very strong economic engine that they're trying to maintain. 20:59 Again, I do not challenge that, but I think that there will be questions raised over time about who wins and who is not winning as much by some of these types of decisions. 21:11 That's why for us, and one of the important elements of the exchange model is making sure that we're getting these different perspectives at the table. Who is going to win, who might not win? 21:22 We need to hear and see how we can help them. 21:25 If we can't make the same decision, what can we do that would help provide some benefit, some value to them, even if they're not gonna have their idea carry the day in all cases. 21:37 So it sounds like environmental justice, climate justice will be part of the curriculum, for want of a better term, at the exchange as well. 21:43 Absolutely, and it's why, you know, environmental justice groups are part of the community partners alongside the chambers of commerce, alongside the workforce development organizations who are really trying to say there are equity issues. 21:58 Equity can be in terms of participation. Equity can be in terms of whether there is investment flowing to certain, certain neighborhoods. But in... 22:06 It can also be opportunities created by capitalizing on that green economy. Can we make sure that the winners, in terms of who gets these new higher paying jobs, are spread equitably around the city? Absolutely. 22:20 I wonder to what extent you see a tension though between the importance of engagement in climate policy at a city level, a community level, neighborhood level, and the need to get stuff done quickly, right? 22:31 There's been a number of opinion pieces and research articles about California, cities in California, cities in, on the East Coast as well, about how long it takes to disperse money or for money to be authorized and put to work. 22:42 Even here, I understand that some of the money that was put aside after Hurricane Sandy has only recently been deployed. Some of those defenses planned 10 years ago have only just been put in place. 22:51 We know that there's a lot of underlying reasons why it's slow to get infrastructure done in New York, slow to get policies done in New York. Mm-hmm. 22:57 But I'm wondering, is there a tension between we need to take into account all stakeholders and need to get stuff done quickly so that New Yorkers will be spared the worst of extreme weather events? 23:07 Look, we've just had a, a year or more of a conversation about the city of yes here in New York, about how to change some of the permitting rules so that you can do things faster, and I think that's a very important part of the conversation. 23:21 Part of our narrative on, on climate and how we're trying to think about things is help move solutions at both speed and scale. 23:29 We know we need to do more, but we need to do them faster because we, we have these deadlines that science has telling us if we get past a certain timeframe, we're hitting tipping points or it's gonna be too hard to make up or the, the cost of repair will be too great if we delay and delay. 23:45 So figuring out how to deal with this, how do we move forward faster on some of this, again, this is part of what we think we are going to be able to help on by bringing these communities together, saying, "The goal, let's agree on the goal and let's agree on how we can actually move this forward faster." 24:03 And see if we can by collaborating with government, by getting communities to the table, help themBecome part of the solutions about what can we do today, what can we do tomorrow? What... 24:13 If we can't wait, if we can't get everything done in five years, what can we be doing right now that will actually help all of us? 24:22 Those are the kinds of conversations we think we're going to have on a range of different issues, whether it's resilience or on mitigation issues. 24:30 Now, one facilitator of faster action, increased productivity is artificial intelligence. Big theme, of course, the last few years. 24:37 I understand that AI is a big part of the climate tech scene in New York, uh, and elsewhere as well. 24:42 There's a lot about opportunity for AI to help with data gathering, data analysis, and I'm wondering how you're thinking about AI as an enabler of climate action, and how will the Exchange be involved in trying to promote, uh, AI and climate res- resilience and adapt- resilience and adaptation. 24:58 I wish you had joined us a couple months ago when we had these student teams participating in what we call the AI challenge. 25:06 Um, they brought their knowledge and expertise to bear on local storm water management issues in New York City. 25:12 And this is not just New York City college students from Pace or, or from NYU or other schools, but we had teams from Georgia Tech, from other parts of the country participating as well. 25:23 And what I found really fascinating was, again, the creativity in terms of how do we collect information and how can we use that information in a way that was not originally anticipated. 25:34 So some of the teams were coming up with things like the use of traffic cameras as a way to begin to gauge. So you use AI to begin to interpret what is showing up on the screen and say, "Hey, there's flooding. 25:46 Hey, there's flooding at two inches. Hey, there's flooding at 12 inches." 25:50 And so use the technology that already exists, but link that together in a way that you can begin to make it more publicly available to help individuals, property owners make decisions about, do I wanna drive in this direction, or do I wanna put up some type of barrier to protect flooding from affecting my home? 26:09 We think we're gonna keep doing that kind of thing because part of our mission, again, is to engage the next generation, help build capacity, whether you're a teenager, whether you're a smaller child, or whether you're a, a university student. 26:23 Our goal is to figure out what kind of information would be helpful to you in terms of your life. 26:28 It's not just about turning people onto a green career, but think about, again, those homeowners who are buying a property but are unaware that it sits in a, a floodplain, or they're unaware about the fire risk if you're out in LA. 26:43 Those are the kinds of information that you want people to just be smart consumers. And so can we help build knowledge and awareness that way? 26:52 And then there are those who are all in, and we want to help them figure out what is a good green career path for them. 26:58 We want to engage them so that they might say that I'm inspired to work on marine science issues or atmospheric science issues or engineering, and they can become part of the solution. 27:08 So the, the type of programming we're gonna be engaging on at the Exchange is really looking across the entirety of the community who we think will be coming to Governors Island or participating in our programming locally or, or internationally, and figuring out how do we help meet their needs in a way that is very helpful. 27:26 That's wonderful. This kind of links back to the economic conversation, right? 27:30 By giving climate policy, climate action, climate investment, this pattern of tech, of AI, you may be able to attract other generations in, people from different backgrounds in to get involved in, in, in the great fight of our time. 27:44 Uh, so that makes sense to me. But I do wonder also whether AI, because it's the new shiny object, and not just shiny, there is genuine useful purposes for AI already being used. Mm-hmm. 27:56 But I'm also wondering, like, is there a danger that some of the lower tech or no tech solutions, especially when it comes to, like, climate resilience, uh, which does require sort of like manual dirty labor, hardware, that sort of thing, is there a danger of that being overshadowed? 28:08 And again, how are you thinking about not just the high tech side, but also the low tech and the kind of like the easy wins, uh, that can be done on climate resilience and mitigation? 28:16 Yeah, no, it's a, it's a great question, and it is something that we're trying to think through. 28:22 A- again, if you think about there are certain communities who are more likely to have easier access to AI as a, a helpful decision-making tool or something that can inform them in some meaningful way. 28:41 But there... 28:41 We still have a tech divide i- in society, and so are we excluding certain communities just from the very start because we're saying, "You gotta have access to high-speed computing, you gotta have access to certain other kinds of, of, of data resources." 28:58 And some folks are, are simply not gonna be part of the, the conversation as a result of that. 29:02 We're trying to think through, again, how do we make AI accessible or useful to people in, at all different economic strata, at different levels of education, so that we can make sure that people can capitalize on it as appropriate. 29:18 Um, but you're right, there is gonna be some need to balance the programming from ensuring that AI isn't gonna help me dig up my front yard and make for a more permeable surface. 29:29 But there are things that AI might help us do to identify which neighborhoods are really at great at risk based on certain parameters that we don't easily identify by looking at a map or looking at certain types of data. 29:45 So I think that we, we're very fortunate that we have access to world-class researchers, but we also have to communities, access to communities. 29:54 And, and our goal is to put the communities in the driver's seat in terms of saying, "Here's the question that we're facing or the challenge we're facing. 30:03 Give us some of the options so that we can make informed decisions about how to proceed," knowing that institutions may not respondTo our particular needs in a timely manner, but are there things that we can be doing right now to take action to protect ourselves or to capitalize on these opportunities ahead? 30:22 AI is coming up repeatedly, and to go back to that, that AI challenge, people are gonna be-- students are gonna be thinking about the use of AI on all types of questions. 30:33 If we can continue to try and rally interest and engagement on climate related issues so that folks who wanna work on AI, 'cause it is that cool new shiny object, but we make sure they're focusing on climate questions, I think we'll also be succeeding in an important way to ensure that the-- we're getting the best and brightest focused on these questions. 30:53 Yes. You can see how AI's been applied to lots of different industries already, that yes, there could be a, an arms race for talent and just attention between climate and, like, advertising and business operations. 31:04 There's so many different ways that climate, uh, AI can be used, so we need to make sure that climate gets, uh, its, its share of folks as well, for sure. I'm interested also then on this investment side, right? 31:14 Like, how do we spur capital into adaptation and mitigation? Now, over here in the States, we had the inflation reduction act. 31:21 We have had some supportive policies at the state level as well that has been channeling finance towards net zero goals, right? And we're near Wall Street. 31:28 There was until recently, the banks in Wall Street area were part of the Net Zero Banking Alliance and helping to fund renewable technologies. 31:37 My understanding is that it's harder to funnel capital into adaptation projects because there's less clear business models or revenue streams related to them. 31:45 And I'm wondering if that's gonna be part of your work at the ch- exchange, is trying to think about interesting business models for climate companies as well that can attract investment and create the sort of growth that's needed to, to scale. 31:57 Yes. I think the innovation in terms of financing instruments, that's something that we clearly wanna work on. 32:03 You're really familiar, again, with where the conversation has gone, what people are trying to do, but the fact that it's still pretty small scale in terms of level of deployment or level of money flowing towards these issues. 32:18 One of the challenges from my perspective is that I think we may be defining the question in an inappropriate way because we're saying adaptation or resilience for everything. Let's break it down. 32:35 Con Edison learned a lot after Hurricane Sandy. Why? 32:40 Because they had these underground electric vaults all around Manhattan that had been dating back to eighteen eighty-eight when there was a big snowstorm in New York City, and the above ground wires all came down, and they said, "We need to underground this stuff." 32:55 But now, a hundred and some odd years later, we were learning that, oh, there's another type of natural risk that we need to deal with. 33:03 And so they needed to move towards saltwater resistant transformers in those underground vaults so that they didn't burn out and, and be completely unusable. 33:13 So there was a tech change that they had to start investing in, but that's resilience of a particular sector where the revenue model is very clear, right? 33:24 There is a tariff that's charged for every amount of electricity that you use, whether you're a residential or commercial, um, customer. 33:32 So there are opportunities to begin to invest in resilience and charge the users of that service accordingly. Now, are there parallels? 33:42 Can we do the same thing in terms of upgrading our storm water management or protecting our water system upstate as droughts become more severe and there's increased siltation into the upstate reservoirs, and now that requires new filtration before the water gets to New York City? 33:57 Again, those are infrastructure systems where the revenue model exists. It's very clear, and the only question is what's affordable. 34:06 Cases like what you talked about earlier, the barriers being built over by Battery Park or on the Lower East Side, that's to address flooding for which the beneficiary, the customer, the person who can pay for that is less easily identified. 34:23 If we begin to say there are needs that we need to address going forward, some of them linked to infrastructure systems where there is a clear revenue structure or, or a, a tariff model and, and the question then is more political. 34:39 What can we afford to do and how quickly? There are other issues related to flooding where it's more of a public good, and we're gonna have to think about those financing questions differently. 34:50 Staying on the topic of financing, I'm interested in what sort of revenue streams could be tapped to fund resilience. 34:58 At a conference last year, the New York City Chief Resilience Officer spoke about maybe introducing a climate resilience tax or surcharge to pay for some coastal resiliency efforts. 35:07 And of course, we've seen congestion pricing, which is helping to finance MTA upgrades, including adaptation upgrades. 35:13 So I'm wondering what you think about different revenue models that the public sector can use to pay for adaptation. 35:20 Look, I, I, I think that I, I-- when I was at the World Bank and some of the things, conversations I've been involved in over the past year, it's on this notion of innovative sources of finance. 35:30 What they often meant was a new tax on someone. It was just a question of who was getting hit with that additional surcharge. In the case of an adaptation charge, yes, that's basically saying we need a dedicated fund. 35:45 We need to keep it at a level that's manageable. We need to ensure that it can't be used for other purposes. So we need to put it in a lockbox and make sure that, that it stays available for the intended purpose. 35:57 A-and so I, I, I think we need to have those kinds of hard conversations. They are a political conversation about what's affordable and, and how do we prioritize where those funds are going. 36:07 But there are also other things that folks are gonna have to take account of. 36:11 Let's talk about insurance.If because of the exit from the industry in certain parts of the country, like you just saw in LA with one of the insurers pulling out ironically just before the fires hit, canceling coverage, you can imagine the property owners are saying, "If I can't get coverage, I'm either gonna have to make that investment and, and take, take what I would've been paying for insurance and start investing in those resilience initiatives to protect my building." 36:42 Is that the alternative? Is that where we're moving? Or are we saying that if the private sector's out of the game entirely, then it's a public insurance responsibility. 36:50 And again, that's gonna be a very difficult public conversation. Why? Because as we've just seen in LA or when you see after some of these big storms, the, the, the price tag is high. 37:01 And so is that part of what the public is gonna need to pay for? And again, where does that money come from? Taxes from someone. 37:09 So we either raise the existing taxes or we identify some of those new ones that may actually help anticipate and address and ensure that we minimize that, that loss or prevent it all together, so the money can be made available in an anticipatory way and prevent the after the fact loss remediation. 37:27 Yes, that's interesting. 37:28 This pre-position of resources has come up in a number of conversations I've been having because it's the speed of deployment of finance is important as well, and a lot of it seems to be post-event there is raising the money, raising the rates, and actually that wouldn't be needed if there had been this pre-positioning. 37:42 So that's a very good point. And, and again, this is part of the conversation. 37:47 Imagine you're that utility and now you're talking about how much is the investment to underground the, the high tension lines that may now be linked to some of these fires. 37:57 It turns out that the economic impact at a regional level is far greater than what it would've cost to ensure, uh, you know, that, that the lines are, can operate in a way that will not trigger these wildfire events or be, be more vulnerable to flooding by undergrounding some of the above ground lines. 38:16 These are the conversations that in our new world we're gonna have to take more seriously and we're gonna have to make some hard decisions on. Okay. 38:23 I'm sure we could speak for many more hours on all things climate change, climate risk, climate policy, but I appreciate you've got lots to get on with, the exchange, uh, getting underway. 38:33 Maybe you could finish by telling us what the timelines are for the exchange itself, when it's gonna be formally open, and when the, the program events and program of, uh, projects is gonna be starting. 38:45 So the campus is anticipated to open late 2028, early 2029 on Governors Island, but we already have space on the island. That's where we hosted our Climate Week programming this past September. 38:55 It's where we'll be doing more events over the course of this year, um, and on into the future. 39:00 Again, we also benefit from the fact that we've got local partners, so I can bring activities to NYU or CUNY campuses or Pace or Pratt in and around New York City because they have great auditorium space or classroom space that we might be able to borrow. 39:15 So we're already rolling out our events. We're already beginning the programming, trying to find the partners, trying to find the research questions. 39:22 Folks should, should come to the nyclimateexchange.org website, sign up for our updates. We're happy to share information on a monthly basis about what we have going on. 39:31 We're gonna be launching much more frequent programming for the public over the course of this year. 39:36 There's gonna be things for everybody related to arts and culture related events, r- to science conversation, to debates, to uncomfortable conversations, we call them taboo talks, where we're really trying to get people to, to think through some of these very hard questions about trade-offs. 39:53 Are we willing to say yes to this when in the past we wouldn't have been able to or wanted to? 39:59 Look for that kind of programming, but also look for us as a solutions resource that can be helping businesses, that can be helping community organizations around the city. 40:09 That's why we were created, and that's what we wanna do well at. I'll be keeping an eye on your website, on the programs page. You said taboo topics. As a journalist, that really gets my senses going. 40:19 So I'll be looking forward to what comes out under that heading, and I do encourage all my listeners to check out, uh, the exchange as well. 40:25 And, and Steven, maybe we'll have you on in a couple years' time as Governors Island starts to really ramp up. But for now, thank you very much for your time. Appreciate it, and have a great rest of your week. 40:35 Thank you, Louis. Really appreciate it. Bye-bye. Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 40:43 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]