Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience, finance, tech, and policy. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. 0:18 Today, I'm joined by Ujala Qadir, Director of Strategy and Programs at the Climate Bonds Initiative, an international nonprofit that works to mobilize global capital for climate action. 0:29 Ujala is currently spearheading the CBI's work to create a resilience taxonomy, a means of classifying climate resilience investments that can help companies structure bonds that clearly support adaptation and resilience goals. 0:41 We talk over this taxonomy, the broader landscape of climate-friendly investments, and whether there needs to be a little rebalancing in the climate investment market to support climate proofing activities. 0:51 Before we get started, just a note that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 0:58 Listeners like you can help keep the lights on and support even more great content by heading to climateproof.news/upgrade. You'll get two newsletters a week, access to exclusive data dashboards, and special reports. 1:10 That's climateproof.news/upgrade. Thanks for your support. Also, after this episode, you'll have to wait until July the 9th for your next installment of Climate Proofers. 1:21 Yours truly is headed out on vacation for a couple of weeks, but rest assured I will be back with plenty more interviews on all things adaptation and resilience. 1:29 Okay, in a minute, my interview with Ujala, but first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:35 [swoosh] In finance, leaders of the Group of Seven nations singled out the importance of adaptation finance at their latest summit in Italy. 1:43 The leaders said that there is a need to continue to scale up action and support, including finance for climate adaptation, as called for in the Glasgow Climate Pact. 1:52 They also promised to help climate-vulnerable countries translate their national adaptation plans and instruments into investment plans that are aligned with their needs and priorities. 2:01 In addition, the leaders said they welcomed the development of climate resilient debt clauses, which are special terms put into loans to governments that allow repayments to be temporarily suspended in the wake of climate shocks. 2:12 More controversially, the G7 also underlined their collective stance toward the new climate finance goal, which is currently being negotiated between developing and developed countries. 2:21 They say that donor countries should include those that are capable of contributing, a clear reference to large growing developing countries like China, Saudi Arabia, and India, to name a few. 2:31 The G7 think they should pay up because of their contribution to current greenhouse gas emissions. 2:35 Climate activists and many developing countries think the G7 and other rich nations should do more themselves to provide climate finance before they go about lecturing other parties. 2:45 [swoosh] In policy this week, ministers signed off on the European Union's Nature Restoration Law, which aims to revive the continent's ecosystems and strengthen its climate resilience. 2:55 The regulation should help mitigate climate change and the effects of natural disasters, according to the European Council, by obliging member states to restore 20% of land and sea ecosystems in the European Union by 2030 and all those in need of revival by 2050. 3:10 The European Environment Agency has previously reported that 80% of Europe's habitats are in poor shape, which is bad news for the continent's climate resiliency. 3:18 [swoosh] And in tech, The New York Times has an interesting little story about the US Environmental Defense Fund. It turns out the advocacy group is investing in research on planet-cooling tech. 3:29 Namely, solar geoengineering, the banner term for a series of techniques designed to reflect more of the sun's energy away from the Earth. 3:37 While such technologies could reduce global temperatures, they may also produce unintended consequences, like changing rainfall patterns or upending ocean circulation. 3:46 EDF hopes its research will shine a light on some of these possible consequences and has made clear it is not funding real-world implementations of the technology. 3:55 Still, the investment underscores the growing interest in solar geoengineering as a radical but plausible climate adaptation strategy. [swoosh] Right, that's this week's roundup. Now on to our interview. 4:06 [upbeat music] We're joined today by Ujala Qadir from the Climate Bonds Initiative. Ujala, where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hi, Louis. I'm calling in from Vancouver, from the beautiful Vancouver. 4:22 I'm a Director of Strategic Pro- Programs at the Climate Bonds Initiative, and I lead the resilience program there, which is really aimed at mobilizing capital for adaptation investments. 4:33 So I'm based in Vancouver now, but I'm originally from the beautiful city of Islamabad in Pakistan, and thanks so much for having me here today. Super honored to be here. 4:42 I was looking at, you know, your past, uh, guests, so again, another reason to be honored, because you've had some incredible people on the podcast so far. 4:50 Uh, and I just wanted to say, Louis, before you jump into questions, congratulations on the success of Climate Proof. I'm a subscriber and a huge fan. I told you this in New York when we met. 5:00 It's really kind of my go-to source for catching up on latest developments on adap- adaptation finance. 5:06 So really from one adaptation nerd to another, I think you've really masterfully filled the void with this much-needed, sort of relevant and up-to-date content. So thanks for creating that fantastic resource. 5:18 Thank you so much. That's really kind of you to say. 5:21 And yes, you are in esteemed company, and I feel very grateful to have the opportunity to talk to you and to others in the adaptation space and really get to grips with the knotty issues in adaptation and finance. 5:33 So with that in mind, I'd like to go into our, our first question, and that is the Climate Bonds Initiative is all about mobilizing investor capital for climate goals. 5:42 But to me, a lot of the focus seems to be on promoting green bonds and investments with a climate mitigation focus. 5:49 So I was wondering if you could talk to us about why green bonds and climate mitigation-focused instruments like them seem to have dominated the sustainable finance landscape so far. Right. 5:59 No, that's a really good question, Louis, and you're right. 6:02 Climate bonds, you know, just starting off from in terms of what Climate Bonds does-We are all about mobilizing capital for climate action, and debt capital markets are a really great place to start with that. 6:14 So why is that? Well, firstly, it's the largest source of capital that we have. 6:19 In fact, today, we have more capital than we've ever had in history with around, I think, a hundred and thirty trillion dollars or so outstanding in fixed in-income markets alone. 6:31 Second, the bulk of this money is managed by institutional inves-investors, such as pension funds and asset managers. 6:39 So these investors have, you know, really a, like, an, a part-- intrinsic part of their fiduciary duty, a vested interest, and an incentive to manage long-term risks. 6:49 And climate change, of course, is, uh, both a short-term and a long-term risk. You know, y-they can't pay back your pension or my pension otherwise, and they can't safeguard long-term value. 7:00 So I think this really gives us a clue as to whose doors we should be knocking on when we're looking for investment in climate solutions. These long-term investors have the deepest pockets. 7:11 They have self-interest to mitigate the impacts of the climate crisis on the financial system. 7:16 So yeah, this is really kind of our strategy at Climate Bonds and, um, you know, one that I think that can really sort of move the needle. So what Climate Bonds has been doing is precisely this. 7:27 We've been knocking on these doors with a pretty simple value proposition, which is green bonds. These often go by different names. You know, sometimes green, they're called sustainable bonds, social bonds, blue bonds. 7:40 We've even heard of orange bonds and gender bonds. But behind all of these labels is a simple concept. 7:46 These are bonds that have the same characteristics as conventional or vanilla bonds, but they have this added bonus feature, um, and that's specifically that the money that is raised through these bonds is going to be invested in activities that are aligned with climate and development goals. 8:03 So I think that's really exciting news that this concept and this instrument is really now proven. It's the largest thematic investment asset class. 8:12 There's huge, exceptionally strong demand for these types of thematically labeled bonds. 8:18 And this morning I checked on our database, which we, where the Climate Bonds has a database where we track this market, um, and at to date, there's three point one six trillion dollars of outstanding green bond issuances to date. 8:31 So I think that's pretty exciting, but it really does represent a pretty small fraction of fixed income markets out of that hundred and thirty trillion. So there's still a lot of room for growth. 8:41 So sorry, Louis, that was a bit of a preamble to get to the answer to your question. Mm-hmm. But I think that context is worth highlighting. 8:49 But to answer your question on why have they been so focused on mitigation, I think there's, uh, probably, like, three key reasons for this. So first, the market is still pretty new. In relative terms, it's nascent. 9:01 It's growing at pace, but it only really took off, like, around twenty twelve. Um, and in the beginning of this market, people thought this was an instrument to finance clean green energy, and that was it. 9:13 Green equals clean energy. But this slowly started to change and low carbon transport like rail started to feature more prominently in these bonds. 9:23 And so over the last ten years as the market's grown and the definition of green has really started to expand, and we're seeing investments in all types of sectors that have emissions associated with them. 9:33 And recently, you may have heard there's much more focus on transition, so looking at high emitting sectors like cement and steel and mining. 9:43 Um, and they now also often contain adaptation and resilience too, but very little, and we can talk maybe more about that a bit later, but they are, you know, it, it does feature as well in these bonds. 9:55 But as you say, they're primarily dominated by mitigation. So another reason I think for that is that the science behind defining what is low carbon has been much more, well, not... 10:08 It's not straightforward, but it's more straightforward than defining what is adaptation. Um, and then there's been a common goal for net zero by twenty fifty, so a common goal for mitigation. 10:18 And that's made it much easier to standardize what can be included in a green bond. Um, you know, an emission reduction here in Vancouver is the same as where you are in New York. 10:28 So that, that makes it just a slightly easier. And then last, lastly, I think one of the reasons why mitigation has been such a priority is really because it's actually most urgent. 10:39 You know, if we don't curb emissions, we can't adapt. You know, there's limits to adaptation. We can't invest in our health and our education. We can't, you know, 10:50 i-invest in adaptation if we're directing all of our efforts in weathering the next big storm, rebuilding after the next big hurricane, you know, et cetera, et cetera. 11:00 So mitigation is an absolute priority, but unfortunately, I think we failed to act fast enough. We already are starting to see the impact. We're edging towards one point five degrees. 11:11 You know, there's nowhere to hide from this. And investors, governments, companies, everyone's kind of feeling it, and this brings adaptation back up the agenda. 11:20 So as adaptation goes up the agenda, I don't think this is defeat or surrender, and we're not saying let's give up on mitigation, but what we're saying is it's time to shore up our defenses, so we can safeguard not only our future, but we also safeguard any chance that we have left at achieving our mitigation goals and our net zero goals. 11:40 So I think we're gonna see rise of adaptation and resilience in these bonds, but those are some of the reasons that we haven't seen them as prominent to date. Wonderful. Thank you, Jaala. 11:52 That's a very comprehensive answer. 11:53 And I agree with most of what you're saying, especially the point about it's easier to understand what an emissions reducing activity is, and therefore what can factor into a green bond. 12:05 And we know there's issues at the UN level and at the investment level, at the corporate level about-... quantifying adaptation and resilience. 12:14 If you don't have those indicators, it's harder to try to create financial products that cater to those themes. 12:21 I do think it's interesting as well what you said about adaptation being maybe deprioritized in the past because the focus was on mitigation, naturally following the Paris Agreement, and the focus has always been on the 1.5 degree and two degree goal. 12:34 And yes, I've been covering climate finance for several years now, and adaptation as a discrete concept seemed to me only to become used in the general lexicon in the last, oh, I don't know, three, four years, at least in my world. 12:47 I'd be interested to know your thoughts of when ad- adaptation started to come up the agenda, uh, in the circles that you move in. Hmm. Yeah, [laughs] that's a great question. So I've been... 12:56 I come from a background looking at adaptation resilience from a practitioner's sort of point of view. You know, I used to work in international development in Pakistan and in Kenya and Somalia. 13:07 And so adaptation was in my world a long time ago because I was involved in a lot of rural development programs, helping communities to build infrastructure and irrigation infrastructure. 13:18 You know, all of these, uh, we would basically be taking two steps forwards and then three steps back with these projects because of landslides and floods and disasters. 13:29 So adaptation started to become very prominent in, in, in that world because we simply were seeing the impacts and, and effects of adaptation very early on. 13:38 But in terms of the finance sort of space, I think it has been relatively new, as you say, but it's, it's accelerating quickly. 13:46 Like, we're seeing so much more action and so many more institutions getting involved and thinking about how do we define adaptation and how do we get, uh, finance to flow. 13:55 It's hard to put, like, a number, like, a, a time in, i- in, in the past when this became more prominent, but I think in the last four or five years is when I've started to see much more happening in terms of adaptation finance and how we bring private sector capital to play. 14:11 Yes, I'm probably telling on myself here because, you know, being a developed world inhabitant and being focused largely on developed world financial system, in that r- realm, mitigation has very much been the number one issue because physical risks from climate change, climate disasters, while they do occur, they're not as existential, uh- Mm-hmm... 14:32 in the US or the UK as they are in developing countries. So there's probably a developed world, developing world bias when it comes to adaptation versus mitigation as well. Yeah, no, absolutely. I think that's right. 14:44 But, you know, at the same time, climate impacts, again, they know no boundaries, right? And we're seeing the impacts everywhere, regardless of if you're in a developed or developing country. 14:55 But, um, absolutely, I think mitigation was probably less high on the agenda for, um, a lot of developing economies in the past. Okay. 15:03 Now, drilling in a little bit into those green bond instruments that you're familiar with, have you seen many that have an explicit or at least partial adaptation or resilience focus? 15:14 Are there such a thing as adaptation bonds out there in the wild right now, or is this not a theme that's been explored yet? Yes. The answer is yes, and I love the adaptation bonds in the wild. 15:24 [laughs] I'll give you a statistic, Louis, and you can decide whether you want to be depressed by it or you want to be excited by it. [laughs] Okay. 15:32 This is from an internal screening that we did at, at CBI at Climate Bonds a couple of years back, so it's probably not most up to date. It's from twenty twenty-two. 15:42 But we analyzed around thirty-five thousand green and thematically labeled bonds that we've recorded in our Climate Bonds database, and we analyzed them to try and identify how many of those might have some adaptation related use of proceeds. 15:57 And we found around six thousand five hundred bonds that did have some adaptation focus. So that's around nineteen percent. So I don't know. Happy? Depressed? How do you feel about that number, nineteen percent? 16:11 [laughs] It's definitely higher than I thought it would be. Mm. However, my interest is in what's the quantum of the- Yeah... proceeds that these green bonds finance. How much of it is gonna- Yeah... 16:21 towards adaptation or is it an afterthought? Do you know what I mean? Absolutely. Exactly. So for me, it's a bit of a mixed bag, right? 16:28 So, like, first of all, it's higher than I also thought when we did the study, but the financing gap for adaptation is massive. 16:36 We need to be raising hundreds of billions of dollars on an annual basis to address adaptation needs. So in that sense, I think nineteen percent is simply just, it's not enough. 16:46 So to, to answer your question, that nineteen percent just represents the number of bonds that mention adaptation, but we don't actually know the details of how much of that money, the volume of that money, is being used for adaptation. 17:00 We also don't know the details of what the nature of that adaptation investment is, and that's because there's very limited guidance out there on what you can include. 17:09 All there really is is a category in the ICMA guidelines, which many green bond issuers turn to, or the climate bonds taxonomy and standards, which also allow for adaptation, but it's all very high level guidance. 17:22 So the disclosure around what this money is being used for is incredibly opaque. 17:27 So all we all really know from that number is that some financing in those bonds is being directed towards adaptation, but we don't know much more beyond that. 17:36 But there is some good news, and that's where the nineteen percent makes me, you know, not feel very depressed, but actually feel very hopeful. 17:43 And that's the fact that there are bonds already doing this, and that means we have a very viable instrument, a green bond that can be used and is being used to channel money to resilience. 17:55 So yes, while there's barriers and we need to overcome some of those to get better disclosure and to understand what those are being used for, it's a proven, demonstrated asset class with high demand from fixed income investors. 18:08 So this means we can really achieve scale, we can achieve it quickly.We don't need to puzzle over new and innovative instruments, though those are helpful too, but we have something to start with that already kind of works. 18:20 So let me go back to your original question about examples, so I can just kind of a-add some more color to this. Out of those bonds, a couple that, you know, that I found particularly interesting. 18:31 So one was the sovereign issuance from the Dutch government. 18:35 There was a series of extreme events and floods around 2018, and I think the government really recognized that they can use their green bond issuance to raise capital. 18:43 So they raised capital for funding their Delta program, and then another bond in 2023, I believe. So all together, around 15 billion to date has been raised through this bond. 18:54 And this Delta program is actually one of the world's most advanced floodplain management systems. 19:00 The use of proceeds are used for things like reinforcing flood defenses, monitoring and management of water levels, improving water treatment distribution, things like that. 19:10 So I think that's a really great example of a sovereign issuance or a sovereign government basically raising money from capital markets. Another example that, um, is interesting is from a commercial bank. 19:22 Uh, it's Access Bank in Nigeria. 19:24 They issued a green bond, and they used this to create a financing pool that would fund coastal flood defenses, um, to protect against sea level rise in this new coastal urban development that they're creating around Lagos. 19:37 So the bank used this funding to basically create a pool of financing. And then the last one that maybe I'll share, Norway, there was a local government funding agency. 19:47 It's a very difficult name for me to pronounce, so I'll use the acronym KBN. They issued a green bond, and they used this to, again, support disaster early warning systems. 19:57 They used the funding to install, I think, like, siren masts in the town to alert people of tsunamis. It was directed towards construction of landslide and flood protection measures. So yeah. 20:09 So there's a lot of different small to large to medium types of projects and, and investments that can go into these bonds. One m-more point I wanted to make, Louis, was that most of these bonds didn't... 20:21 They weren't s-just solely allocated to adaptation. Most of them had mitigation and adaptation both, and I actually think that's a great thing. I don't think we need just adaptation bonds or just mitigation bonds. 20:34 I think we need to see these integrated because these are two sides of the same coin, and we want to see more bonds with these kind of mixed use of proceeds. 20:42 But there are a couple that have been wholly dedicated bonds for adaptation. Only two that I know of. One is from EBRD, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. 20:52 That was back in 2019, and they were actually aligned with the Climate Bond's Resilience Principles, which we had also published around 2019 to help guide issuances, uh, that are, uh, solely focused on adaptation. 21:06 And then more recently, just last year, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank also issued a bond that was labeled as an adaptation bond, which is also really kind of following the Climate Bond's Resilience Principles as well. 21:19 So yes, to answer your question, we see adaptation included out there in the market. It's not nearly enough, but it's a good start. Thank you. 21:28 Those are some great examples, and I take on board what you say about we don't need to start from scratch. 21:34 There is a structure here in green bonds that can be used for adaptation resilience purposes, and there is evidence that certain entities are already doing so, right? 21:47 But the challenge is, as you said, scaling that up and also, I suppose, broadening people's understanding of what adaptation and resilience means. 21:53 And, and to that end, I wanted to ask next about what you're doing over a-at Climate Bond Initiative on this resilience taxonomy that we've, we've talked about before, me and you. 22:03 I was wondering if you could explain what it is, first of all, I guess, and then give us a little update on how that's going a-and how you're using this all-star resilience taxonomy advisory group you've put together. 22:12 I think I've interviewed about half of them by this point. 22:14 [laughs] I think you have, which is amazing, and thank you so much for this question, Louis, and letting me speak a little bit about this topic because it is pretty all-consuming for me right now and for our team right now as we inch closer to finalizing this piece of work and publishing it. 22:31 So in terms of what is the Climate Bond's resilience taxonomy, you know, it's, it's a, a taxonomy classification system and criteria for identifying adaptation and resilience investments, and I can talk a little bit more about that in... 22:43 as I explained. 22:44 But I just want to kind of go back to the point I was making before that I feel like one of the biggest barriers from both a supply and demand perspective is this lack of common definitions and rule sets on what type of adaptation projects you could include in a bond or in an instrument. 23:01 There's really very little out there in terms of very granular level information that can guide issuers and investors. 23:08 So issuers, you know, they want to raise more finance from capital markets to fund their climate priorities, and they want to use thematic bonds, but they often struggle to identify what pipeline of my projects could actually go into this bond. 23:23 And then on the other hand, investors really need liquidity, right? To get liquidity, they need a large and liquid and credible market so that they can buy and sell these bonds readily. That's really important. 23:35 So what the taxonomy is really trying to do is expanding the universe of assets that are eligible to be included in these bonds, so this solves the problem from the issuer's perspective as well as the investor's perspective. 23:49 The resilience taxonomy, we call it the resilience taxonomy, but actually what it is is an expansion and extension of the climate bonds taxonomy, which we had established back in 2013. 24:01 It's been updated and evolving ever since we first put it out there. 24:05 This is a major expansion of the CBI climate bonds taxonomy, and it's aimed at making adaptation resilience now a major objective within that in addition to mitigation. 24:15 And we've been very fortunate to have support from partners like the cooperators. They're a leading fi- Canadian financialServices Cooperative. 24:25 Um, and I find it really interesting that an insurer is supporting the development of the resilience taxonomy. 24:30 They're on the front lines in terms of being directly impacted, but also in the front- on the front lines in terms of having a huge role to play in how we respond, right? And how we build resilience. 24:40 So in order for this sort of expansion of the taxonomy to suc- to be successful, we really need it to be rooted, deeply rooted in science and evidence. 24:49 This isn't about making value judgements about whether this is good or not. We need science, we need evidence, and we need it to be usable by market actors, so it cannot be something where there's no data availability. 25:00 And then finally, it really needs to be dynamic because we need to be able to update this regularly to reflect innovations and new technologies and solutions. 25:09 So this is no small task, creating something like this, and that's where this becomes a bit of a crowdsourcing effort to [laughs] you know, uh, to use that term. 25:19 And so we start this off by building up a community of practice with expert advisors, and that's what the Resilience Taxonomy Advisory Group is. 25:27 It is a superstar group of experts that have, you know, decades of experience under their belt. 25:33 It's around 30 members representing a range of stakeholders from nonprofits and academia, to investors, consulting firms, insurance companies. 25:43 So that's what the RTAG is, but we're also consulting a number of other institutions to keep sense-checking this and providing rigor through peer review groups. We also are talking to investors and banks. 25:54 It is a huge undertaking because we are taking a whole of society and a whole of economy approach because I don't really think anything less will do. 26:02 You know, we need vaccines and biotech to prepare for the next pandemic, which we know there will be more of, driven by climate change. 26:11 We need to house people in low-cost housing that's resilient and protected to climate risks. We need more and bet- better and bigger drainage in our transport systems, in our cities. 26:22 We need buildings to be using materials that can reduce ambient temperatures. We need drip irrigation. So I mean, I could go on and on. Please, sorry. [laughs] You may have to stop me. 26:32 [laughs] But there's a lot we need, right? There is a lot. Yeah. Adaptation is more than just sea walls and irrigation. I think that's what- Exactly... I've learned. That's right. 26:39 But my point here is that coming up with a, a taxonomy for adaptation solutions needs to be holistic. 26:46 It needs to be kind of broad, and for that, there's only one way to do that, and that's to bring many experts and practitioners to the table. It cannot be done by one institution or one group alone. 26:58 So, so we have this Resilience Taxonomy Advisory Group right now helping us, and then in the next phase of development of the taxonomy, we're actually be- going to be putting technical working groups together that will even be deeper diving into some of the areas in the taxonomy. 27:12 And just as a reminder, uh, to anyone who doesn't know, which I'm sure [laughs] there's several people who aren't super familiar with, um, the sort of breadth of the taxonomy, I just mentioned that we're looking at seven key themes. 27:24 Um, and that includes infrastructure, industry and commerce, cities and settlements, natural systems, health systems, social systems, and agri-food systems. 27:35 And so for each of these, we want to put together technical working groups. 27:39 So, um, just the last thing I'd mention here, that this Resilience Taxonomy Advisory Group, which we call RTAG for short, less of a mouthful, has been meeting for the past six months. 27:50 We've been working together to create the underpinning rule sets, definitions, principles, and approaches of the taxonomy. We're supported by a consulting group called Cadlas. 28:02 I believe Craig Davies was on your podcast a couple weeks ago as well. He was indeed. Although we didn't have time to talk about his ro- role with RTAG, so I'm glad you get to shout him out now. Absolutely. 28:12 Big shout-out to them because they're our technical partners in supporting this work. And yeah, we've got this really great group. There's an incredible spirit of collaboration. It's really kind of amazing. 28:22 People are willing to give their time, you know, their knowledge, their expertise, and I'm super grateful to be a part of that. And yeah, it gets me a little bit... 28:30 Yeah, it gives me the feels a little bit, I have to say. [laughs] Yes, you're very passionate about this and all the members I've spoken to are really pleased that this is taking place under the CBI banner. 28:41 I think as an established group in the climate finance space for so long, you impart that credibility to this effort that might, might, might be lacking otherwise. So yes, I know they appreciate being part of this. 28:53 I do want to know if you could talk a little bit more about the timelines then, about when you're expecting this taxonomy to be rolled out. Absolutely. Sure. So we are planning to publish the taxonomy in September. 29:04 We don't have an exact date yet. 29:06 We're calling it a prototype taxonomy, and the reason for that is, as I mentioned, there is still work to be done to, uh, develop the more detailed criteria through the technical working groups that will be subsequently, uh, formed. 29:18 But in September, yes, we will be releasing and publishing a methodology document that explains the entire process and approach and, and rule sets, along with the types of investments, um, that would be eligible under the taxonomy. 29:34 And can you speak a little bit about the linkages beyond just the RTAG? 29:38 Because you can correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't the genesis of this taxonomy a white paper that CBI did with a UNDRR, um, a UN agency on disaster risk reduction? 29:49 Uh, and can you talk about how they f- fed into this if, if at all? Absolutely. Fundamental. So you, with UNDRR, we developed the white paper, which was basically the starting point for where we're at now. 30:02 What we'll be publishing in September is basically the next evolution of that work. 30:07 So that work set the basic approach, and now we've taken that basic approach and we've further refined it, really thought through some of the nuances with the help of the RTAG. 30:18 And then in addition to that, we've now translated those principles and approaches into sector-specific investmentMeasures and activities. So we have a, basically a database, a list of investments. 30:30 Think we have about over 1,500 l- in that list. Wow. Uh, so that's kind of the next, yeah, iteration of that, of that foundational work with the UNDRR. Wonderful. 30:42 Uh, this just came to mind because I've been following the climate change meetings that the UN hosts in Germany, and a number of the work streams were focused on adaptation and adaptation indicators. 30:53 The idea is that countries need to know how to measure adaptation progress, and I thought, okay, those adaptation indicators can also be useful from a financing perspective and to integrate into financial instruments. 31:03 So it does make sense to me that your work with the RTAC should have some interlinkages with the UN and with international and national efforts so that more finance can be promoted towards adaptation goals. 31:18 So I, I do hope those linkages continue because it d- it does seem like there needs to be a real connection between finance and a- adaptation in the developing world especially. Yeah, absolutely. 31:27 So, you know, that's why I like to use the word crowdsourcing when I talk about the taxonomy, because the taxonomy that we're working on is all about pulling together what already exists. 31:40 It's not about creating new indicators or new tools. 31:43 It's, I would say, taking what's out there, but curating it and packaging it and putting it within a common set of principles that really speak to the finance, to the investors. 31:55 It's almost like an interface between the needs and the, and the investments, and making it easy for investors to understand, right? Because if, if it's too complicated, then we're not going to see investment flow. 32:08 And to me, that's the f- one of the main purposes of a taxonomy. The main purpose of a taxonomy is making it easy. [laughs] It, it, it's as simple as that. 32:18 Making it easier to understand, you know, without needing a PhD in climate science [laughs] and without needing a team of people in each and every investment firm or corporation or business, um, that is specialized in understanding climate risk. 32:35 It's creating standardized, scalable, easy-to-use indicators and metrics that kinda shortcut that longer process that isn't always needed and isn't helpful to replicate over and over again. 32:48 Yes, I get that, and I think that's a good way to define a taxonomy. And I've been a bit catty in the past, a bit snarky in the past about the mushrooming of taxonomies for adaptation and resilience finance that 33:01 seems to have happened over the last six months, right? So- Mm-hmm... 33:04 CBI came out with this taxonomy proposal, and then there was a number from private sector entities approaching it from different ways, and it does seem like there are different initiatives kind of overlapping, competing maybe on this adaptation resilience taxonomy space. 33:20 So first of all, I'd like to know what you think about this sudden mushrooming of different taxonomies, and then it'd be nice to understand how you think the CBI taxonomy differs or is complimentary, as you said, to, to these other ones that are out there. 33:32 I think the first thing I wanna say, I think it's really important to note that not all the goui- guidance and framework that's out there or that's being released, those are not all taxonomies, right? 33:42 So, so sometimes we talk about them as taxonomies, but they're not. They're actually doing other things. So that's, I think, uh, maybe not that important of a distinction, but a distinction we should be aware of. 33:53 So in the world of sustainable finance, taxonomies are basically classification systems, and they serve the purpose of establishing criteria or rule sets that qualify which type of, of, of an investment is sustainable or climate mitigation or adaptation, whatever the goal of the taxonomy is. 34:10 So that's really important. That's what a taxonomy is, a classification system that the end goal is to get criteria that helps you qualify what is green or not. 34:19 So one of the first examples of this, just to go back a little bit to how this all started, the first example of this was the China Green Bond Catalog, as well as the Climate Bonds Taxonomy, which were kind of published n- uh, around the same time, and we were working very closely in supporting that China Green Bond Catalog as well. 34:36 So that was- Sorry, that's surprising to me that China was one of the first out of the gates. Isn't it? Yeah. It's funny because a lot of people don't know that, but yes, they were, back in 2013. 34:46 And since then, there's been, like, widespread spread adoption of this idea, this idea of a taxonomy, and I think the most prominent one is the EU taxonomy, and that was published in 2020. And since then... 34:57 So that was 2020, and now we're at 2024, right? Since then, in this very short period of time, we've seen countries all over the world developing taxonomies. 35:07 I believe that now there's around 40, uh, around 40 countries that either have taxonomies in place or they're in the process of developing them. 35:15 So in addition to those government-led taxonomies, then there's the ones that you've kind of mentioned as well. 35:20 There's the Standard Chartered guidelines, which again, they're not a taxonomy, but guidelines, but then there's the Tailwind Taxonomy. 35:26 There's investors, you know, that are putting together their own taxonomies for internal purposes. There's banks working on this, and then other international organizations. 35:35 So everyone's starting to think, okay, how do taxonomies support decision-making? And the question I ask myself is why? Why is everyone trying to come up with a taxonomy? And I think it's because they're powerful. 35:45 They're powerful ways for people to look at, at ways of scaling, right? So the answer to why there's a mushrooming or a ballooning is really this fundamental sort of role that they play in what they do, right? 35:59 They provide a common language and rule set. So think about how important standardization is for so many things in our lives or in the world, right? Like, I think about sports. 36:09 Uh, you know, we couldn't have international sports without common rules. Like, imagine a FIFA World Cup game where every team was playing with a different set of rules, right? 36:18 [laughs] Or a different interpretat- interpretation of, I don't know, what an offside is. It would get very messy. It would be com- [laughs] Right. It would be, it would be chaotic. It would be messy. 36:28 So I think taxonomies are super key, right? To, to bring scale, to bring cooperation, and to function within a system that's connected. Our economic system is connected. 36:39 So in sustainable finance, we need these overarching rules to be the same though. So that's where I think there is risks with mushr- mushrooming or a plethora of taxonomies, right? 36:50 So we need to be flexible, but we also need to have common rule sets.But the flexibility is also really important, and I think that's important because we need them to be fit for purposes, for purpose, and not every taxonomy is for the same end use or for the same purpose, and I think that's why we're seeing multiple taxonomies. 37:10 So at the country level, we're seeing, you know, everyone's not just saying, "Okay, I'll just take the EU taxonomy and use it," they're saying, "No, I need a taxonomy for my country because there are specific nuances in my country that this taxonomy needs to reflect." 37:24 Also, the process of taxonomy development itself is proven to be very valuable at the country level, where min- various ministries and actors have to come together, um, in the process of developing it, and that in itself creates common ground for investment planning, et cetera, et cetera. 37:42 So that's a side benefit I just wanted to mention. 37:45 And, and in these 40-odd countries that are developing these taxonomies, Climate Bonds is advising many of these, so we have, you know, insight onto, uh, what these look like. 37:55 And I'll tell you that many of them are very similar to the EU taxonomy, um, but they do have some differences and some tweaks, again, to meet the context of the country. 38:04 But let me just really quickly talk about these other taxonomies that aren't being, you know, nationally driven. 38:09 So I think Standard Chartered's, like, main use case or goal is to help banks to develop and structure new financial products, right? Like loans, lines of credits, et cetera, that focus on adaptation. 38:21 I think that's, you know, a very positive thing to, uh, basically take what we have and adapt it to u- to use it for a different use case. And then I, I don't know if you mentioned Tailwind, but I'll mention Tailwind. 38:32 They also have, uh, recently released a taxonomy. 38:36 Climate Policy Initiative, um, also has developed a taxonomy, but their use case is very much on tracking finance, so they needed to have slightly different tweaks in order to implement it for that specific purpose. 38:49 So all in all, I'm really happy to say, and even es- especially in these two examples, we've all been collaborating very closely, and all of our approaches are highly compatible, they're interoperable, and they're s- using the same overarching principles and guidelines. 39:04 So Louis, I hope that gives you a little bit of, um, comfort that there is coordination happening, but I think it's very valid to ask this question. It's like, what, what does this all look like, right? 39:13 And how does it kind of come together? Um, and it's happening really fast. Like, it's been, like, over the last six months we've seen, like, four, five, or six of these come out. 39:22 Um, so if I may, sorry, I know I've, I've answered your question in a bit of a long-winded way, but I just want to add a couple more points. 39:29 [laughs] My view is that in, in the adaptation s- standard space, we need, like, two key ingredients or two key, key things. 39:36 So we need innovation and we need collaboration, and I think that without these two ingredients, we risk two sort of risks. Either we land with, like, one unified taxonomy to rule them all, right? 39:48 But that can be very inflexible if we have something like that because it may not be fit for purpose for multiple use cases. So having one unified set taxonomy is probably not the end goal we want either. 40:02 But at the same time, we also don't want to end up with a multitude of approaches that fragment and confuse investors and end users, and then in the end we don't see any capital flowing, right? 40:14 So in order to sort of address these risks of too inflexible of approach or too many divergent approaches, we really need to nurture innovation, and we really need to bring in people from different perspectives that bring different use cases in, different clients and end users in mind, and they're thinking through how to make this easier to invest for that particular use case. 40:38 Absolutely, and I think it's interesting, as you kind of intimated, that lots of smart people have had similar ideas around the same time. 40:46 Like, we all got the sense that adaptation and resilience is under-invested in, is very important to this next phase of the climate fight, and I do think it's interesting. 40:55 Some people have been involved in the game for a while, some people are new on the scene. 40:58 Like, like myself, I'm pretty new on the scene, but I've noticed a lot of very smart people who I respect getting into this space, and that makes me think that this is primed for growth. This is important to the world. 41:09 But there is a danger, in my mind, of analysis paralysis, right? Like, you have big institutional investors who are naturally conservative in many ways. 41:16 They're like, "Okay, we need to wait for a taxonomy before we start investing." 41:20 And the urgency by- with which adaptation finance needs are expressed at the UN level, at the national level, is such that I worry that if we take too long to get these taxonomies together or to build consensus around them, we're just kind of delaying the release of capital that we need- Sure... 41:35 into these areas. So I think that first of all, the fact that you've got your taxonomy coming out [laughs] very soon is, is a positive, but what do you think about that, this danger of analysis paralysis? 41:44 Is, is it a- Mm. Is it a fair complaint? That's a really, really good point, Louis, and yeah, absolutely. I think that we should be very aware of that. But I'll say one thing. 41:55 What my, my first thought when you, when you asked this question is, look, there is guidance in the EU taxonomy on how to bring adaptation resilience into, um, your, into frameworks, right? 42:06 So it's not that it's not there. Like, the EU taxonomy and then all these taxonomies that are hap- uh, being developed at a national level often do have adaptation. 42:15 It's just that it's so high level that it's not, like, the risk isn't analysis paralysis. I think the bigger risk is that investors won't come to market because they're afraid of greenwashing concerns, right? 42:28 So that's why a lot of times we think that people aren't using the existing guidelines in the EU taxonomy and in other... 42:35 You know, we have the Climate Bonds Resilience Principles that we put out, and we were very hopeful that we would see a lot of transactions off of the back of that, but we didn't. 42:44 And the reason is because, again, it's not granular enough to provide investors confidence that if they buy a bond or issuers if they, uh, issue a bond, that they will be seen as credible because there isn't enough guidance. 42:56 So I actually think it's a bit of the opposite. I think that-There, we're not seeing action because of a lack of guidance that, that can provide assurance of the credibility of, of the underlying investments. Yes. 43:09 I've learned through getting to know the adaptation space a little bit more, like, the difference between, okay, there's an ad- adaptation finance gap and we need to fill it, uh, and actually having projects and systems in place to actually get capital to where it needs to go, right? 43:23 And that taxonomy is a very important part of that sort of intellectual infrastructure. Mm-hmm. 43:28 Uh, it's not like there are 1,001 investments just perfectly created, ready for capital, desperate for capital, calling out for it. 43:36 We need to actually help create the intellectual underpinnings for creating these businesses and services in the first place. Mm-hmm. And a taxonomy can help with that. 43:44 I have one last weird question for you, and again, this is kind of half-formed thought of mine and I wonder if you'd agree or disagree. And that's... 43:52 This, this is how, how I think about adaptation finance in the round, is you seem to either have lots of very small scale venture investments that are taking place in the developed world. 44:01 A lot of, like, community-based resilience investments taking place in the developing world. 44:06 You hear about sort of, uh, small family farms being provided with certain low-tech solutions to help them become more adapted to climate change. 44:14 So you've got the kind of small penny packet stuff going on on one end, and then you've got these massive investors, some of them are insurers, some of them are big institutional investors like AXA, like Allianz, et cetera, who are trying to allocate large chunks of capital towards infrastructure projects, basically, or very long-term projects that have a resilience and adaptation component to them. 44:35 And I'm just wondering, is there a missing middle here? Yeah. Is there a missing middle? Interesting question. So I would say no. [laughs] Okay. Sorry. Let me think about- Okay. We've got some controversy. I like it. 44:49 [laughs] No, but let me think about that a little bit. Um, first of all, I just wanna, I wanna reflect on this idea that is there enough capital, right? 44:57 Like, just going back to what we were talking or what I mentioned when we started this conversation, like, there is no shortage of capital, and I just want to just kind of start my answer with just that thought, right? 45:09 We have enough capital, it's just that the capital isn't working for us. It's not working for people, it's not working for the planet, and it's often working for nar- very narrow interests. 45:20 There's trillions of dollars being invested and planning to be invested in infrastructure in the next decade. 45:27 The added cost of making that infrastructure resilient is tiny compared to, like, the cost of not doing that, right? 45:33 So just one thing, sorry, I know this is a bit of an aside, but I think it's important to just recognize that we do have the money, it's just that we need to figure out how to make the money flow to the right types of things. 45:42 Now, in terms of corporates and in terms of a missing middle, 45:47 I perso- the reason why I said no, Louis, and I, I, I could be completely wrong, but my thinking is that many companies are already actually thinking about climate and climate risks, but they just don't call it that. 45:59 They don't call it climate proofing or climate adaptation. They call it weatherizing, or they call it hardening, or they call it supply chain risk, or they just call it risk, right? 46:09 So, so I think that what we need to really think about is what are the existing decision making processes and risk management processes that companies, corporates, even small businesses, what are... 46:20 how do they think about risks? And how are they already intrinsically thinking about climate risk? 46:26 And then think about how we kind of expand that in- information or that thinking to be more forward-looking, because I think the problem that we're seeing is that while corporates and businesses and companies look at risk, sometimes they don't have access to the forward-looking or the future risk, right? 46:42 They're basing a lot of their information on past risk, and as we know, past risk is no longer a good signal of future risk because of the sort of nonlinear changes of climate change. 46:53 So I think that's one, one piece of the puzzle, is, uh, you know, looking at risks. 46:57 But I do think there's a lot of people working on this, and that there's a lot of, like, movement on understanding risk, and there continues to need to be. 47:04 But what we're not seeing a lot of is, okay, once you've figured out what your risk is, once you've quantified that and you've done your TCFD reports or whatever, you know, these requirements are, or whatever the processes you might be undertaking as a business, now what? 47:19 What do we do now, right? 47:20 [laughs] And that's where I think the taxonomy comes in again because that provides you a kind of guide post or a blueprint for what you can do to address these risks, and that's why we're taking such a broad approach in the taxonomy as well. 47:35 It's not just about building flood walls or drought-resistant or heat-tolerant seeds, but it's about shopping malls. It's about warehouses and ports and financial services. It's about education. 47:46 You know, there's so much more that we need to look at. It's a broad range, and a lot of these companies and corporates are looking at these particular types of assets and how they're affected by climate. 47:57 But again, maybe not thinking about it in terms of climate, but thinking about it in terms of weather, right? So in our taxonomy I, I mentioned that we have seven themes, but we're also including 27 sectors. 48:08 We've got around 70 sub-sectors and, as I mentioned, around 1,500 investment measures and activities. 48:14 So these can be picked up by corporates, they can be picked up by governments, they can be picked up by what you're s- you know, calling the missing middle. 48:21 These are just measures and activities that if you're able to create a portfolio or a pipeline that identifies these measures and activities, you can go to capital markets and try to raise financing through bond instruments or through other green loans. 48:35 The use of proceed bonds is not the only application of this taxonomy that the climate bonds is developing, but you can also use it for planning and, as I mentioned, green loans and other types of instruments. 48:48 So I think corporates that are directly impacted by climate are going to see the value in implementing adaptation, not because of regulatory risk drivers, but simply because of supply chain disruptions, loss of assets to disasters, loss of labor force productivity. 49:05 So these are going to become real sort of impacts on their financial considerations. 49:12 So if they can put forward a credible adaptation plan that aligns with a framework like the climate bonds taxonomy-That addresses risks that they've identified, I think they can attract investments, and it becomes a much more viable prospect. 49:24 So a long answer to your question, I think that the missing middle or corporations, and I think small scale ventures, large... 49:32 All of these can basically benefit from a more standardized understanding of what adaptation investments are. That's a very fair answer, and it aligns with some of my observations of the corporate space. 49:45 I've been looking at how executives at S&P 500 companies talk about climate risk and adaptation, and a lot of them don't use the words adaptation resilience. 49:53 They use words like hardening, reliability, responsiveness, readiness, all these terms that, a lot of which actually feature in, in your white paper, uh, with UNDRR, and words I'm sure which will feature a lot in your taxonomy. 50:07 Uh, but because it's not flagged as adaptation resilience explicitly, sometimes it might go over my head, it might go over people's heads. 50:15 But there is absolutely investment going on here, and the supply chain issue is really salient even in the developed world, right? 50:21 I said that there are maybe some biases towards adaptation in the developing world versus developed world, but we're already seeing a series of heat waves in the US causing disruptions, in India causing disruptions. 50:35 So this, these supply chain risks are already manifesting, and I think that will spur increased interest in investing in adaptation resilience. 50:42 And for sure, some guidelines and taxonomies will definitely help direct that capital more efficiently, I think. Yeah, absolutely. Yep. 50:50 I mean, I'm sitting here in, [clears throat] in, in Vancouver, and I'm having to replan my summer because of the wildfires. And I think, I think everybody's basically impacted now. 51:01 There's really nowhere to kind of hide from this, whether you're a corporate or an individual person or a farmer. But it doesn't matter where you are. 51:09 You know, we're gonna have to start thinking about these things and thinking about them in a very joined up and systematic way. 51:14 So we hope that some of the work we're doing and the work that a lot of the, yeah, amazing individuals in our RTAG and others in this space are, are going to help sort of move us forward. Yes. 51:26 As I said, you've got an all-star team to help you out here, and I'm really looking forward to seeing the finished taxonomy and writing about it, and maybe we'll have you on Climate Proofers again, maybe with some of your RTAG members to talk about it in more detail when September rolls around. 51:39 But for now, Ujala, thank you so much for your time. Really appreciate you sharing so many of your thoughts on adaptation resilience and explaining so well what's going on with the CBI's resilience work stream. 51:49 Thank you so much. Have a lovely rest of your week. Thanks, Louis. You too. Appreciate it. [outro music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 52:02 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [outro music]