Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:12 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. Today, I chat with Valkyrie Holmes, CEO and co-founder of the insurtech startup Fora. 0:25 The company uses property and climate risk analytics to help insurers and homeowners reduce their natural disaster risk, and has been racking up awards and commendations on the startup circuit for its mold-breaking approach to capturing and communicating climate resilience data. 0:39 Valkyrie talks to us about shaking up the insurance business, changing the relationship between policy holders and carriers, what tech and policy upgrades could help make the insurance and property industries more climate resilient, and much more. 0:51 Before we get to the conversation, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber supported productions. 0:58 Listeners like you can help support my coverage by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. 1:05 Okay, in a moment my chat with Valkyrie, but first let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:11 [swish] In finance, global finance flows for adaptation and resilience reached seventy-six billion dollars in twenty twenty-two, more than double the amount for twenty eighteen, according to new data from the Climate Policy Initiative. 1:24 However, this amount is barely one-third of that needed each year from twenty twenty-four to twenty thirty for developing countries alone. 1:31 The latest global climate finance report from the well-regarded thinktank also shows that public finance made up the vast majority of adaptation flows, around ninety-two percent in twenty twenty-two. 1:41 It isn't necessarily going where it's most needed. 1:44 The CPI says only around nineteen percent of adaptation finance is going to the least developed countries, a family of nations including Bangladesh, Cambodia, and the Solomon Islands that are the most vulnerable to climate shocks. 1:55 Moreover, just two percent of finance is making its way to small island developing states. 2:00 The CPI admits that tracking adaptation finance remains challenging, claiming that the bulk of public financing cannot be marked as helping with climate adaptation because of how government budget items are labeled. 2:11 [swish] In policy, the UN Biodiversity Summit, COP16, ended on November second with much business left unresolved after the conference lost its quorum. 2:20 While progress was made adopting nature protection and biodiversity conservation plans at the country level, a hundred and fifty-two parties have yet to submit these blueprints. 2:29 The plans could be critical for climate proving efforts since nature-based solutions and ecosystem preservation are important contributors to climate adaptation and resilience. 2:38 On biodiversity finance, the site failed to reach consensus on a fund to support nature protection. 2:43 At the previous COP in Montreal, countries pledged to increase nature protection and restoration finance to two hundred billion dollars a year by twenty thirty. 2:51 However, developing countries' concerns with the global environment facility, which oversees a series of UN-authorized climate and nature funds, led to a deadlock. 3:00 [swish] And in tech, stock exchange operator ICE and data provider Dun & Bradstreet have teamed up to create a climate data offering that promises climate physical and transition risk insights for millions of public and private companies. 3:13 This fuses insights from ICE's geospatial intelligence platform and climate data models with Dun & Bradstreet's private company databank, utility spend info, and shipping and supply chain data sets. 3:24 The offering will be packaged up in ICE Climate, a risk data and analytics hub for investors. [swish] Right, that's it for this week's roundup. Now onto my conversation with Valkyrie. [upbeat music] Hi, Valkyrie. 3:38 Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Yeah. Hi, Louis. I am calling from New York, and I run a company called Fora. 3:46 We help insurance companies place more profitable business in disaster-prone areas and help policyholders reduce their risk in areas that they probably wouldn't have been able to find better or more affordable insurance. 3:57 It's wonderful to have you on the podcast today. I met you at a Boston conference, and you were on a very interesting panel about, uh, insurance innovations and the intersection with climate resilience and adaptation. 4:08 And I think Fora's a really great story, and I think you've got a great story. I was wondering if you could take us through your journey to insurtech and, and how Fora was born. Yeah. Yeah, definitely. 4:17 I more so see insurance as a mode of transportation for a greater solution in climate risk, and when I first started looking at things in the climate space, I come from a data science background, and I started off at NASA and SpaceX doing work on satellite imaging and then commercial rideshare, sending companies into space, what we had to design and manage to make that happen. 4:38 That was really my initial work, and got this grant to pursue something in sustainability and have kind of been in that space ever since. 4:45 But in pursuing that space, realized that a lot of people talk about climate risk as, like, this problem that everyone has to work together, basically. But then in practice, that doesn't really happen. 4:55 [chuckles] Like, like, we end up creating a lot of, like, niche products and targeting specific industries, but there's not really any connecting piece of it all. 5:03 And what we saw from the natural disaster perspective was this idea that properties have this survivability component that we are not leveraging in any real industry as of right now. 5:15 Typically, when you're looking at an address, you're looking from a kind of a community level, like a neighborhood level, and, like, an individual property level. 5:23 And when we look at survivability, we're saying, "What is the likelihood that this... that if a disaster is to impact this property, that the structure will be able to withstand the effects of the next disaster?" 5:33 So it's specifically focused on, based on these property characteristics, what is the chance that this property will still be there after being impacted by a natural disaster in the area? 5:43 So that's, like, the thing that we're leveraging initially, and that sends ripple effects into every adjacent legacy industry. So when we got into insurance, we said, "Hey, insurance is something that everyone relies on. 5:53 We need insurance to have a mortgage, to have a home," and we're going through an insurability crisis right now. 5:59 We know there's a lot of people that are struggling to find insurance at all, let alone affordable insurance, and insurance companies are struggling to place business that is high margin, that's high performing for them.Or just find business at all that's not extreme risk that they're able to gain confidence on and place on their books. 6:14 So that was like essentially like our initial, I guess, like entrance with survivability and insurance and making some kind of wave there. 6:23 And then if we look at survivability from like a general standpoint, in real estate, realtors come to us all the time and say, "Hey, it's really hard. Insurance is a big bottleneck for me. 6:33 It kills so many of my deals because I don't have any insight into whether someone's going to be able to get insurance for this property, so I can't walk them through that during the buying and selling process." 6:42 So survivability of a property and inherently the survi- the insurability of a property is something that we can use and leverage to our advantage to help people close more deals and buy and sell more properties at higher property values. 6:54 And we always give the example as well of like, like Rocket Mortgage. They acquire half a million homes through, like their lending process from another mortgage lender. 7:03 They have no idea if they're just getting like the done properties that won't be there in the next five years because they're all in like hurricane zones. Right? Like, we're not really like measuring that. 7:11 We've never needed to measure that at the same extent. 7:15 So this core survivability information for individual properties is something that we've seen talked about but not really made actionable, and it's something that we really believe in as something in insurance to incentivize people to reduce their risk, but also something we can leverage outside of that. 7:30 Yeah. It's interesting. 7:31 It makes it sound like Fora is this connective tissue or networking apparatus to connect different stakeholders who are all, in one way or other, influenced by climate risks, but might not be sending the messages they need to each other to actually make their own companies more resilient. 7:46 And actually, as you said, allow them to do more business. 7:49 And I think that's an interesting framing because more and more I'm coming across climate tech companies and resilience-focused companies, and they're always talking about, "Okay. 7:58 We want to actually tell clients that we can expand your kind of deal book. We can actually provide opportunities that others might not have because you'll have access to the data analytics you need." 8:08 And it's a shift I've noticed mostly in the US versus Europe, where I think compliance, uh, is a bigger issue. But yeah. Can you tell... 8:14 talk a little bit about that op- opportunity framing and how that kind of helps you to grow momentum? 8:19 It's a big pet peeve of mine when sustainability organizations or advocates for climate will say, big companies need to be more sustainable, and that's it. Like, [chuckles] like that's... 8:30 The, the ROI needs to really be there, the data and the research needs to be something that we can consistently prove out year over year for big companies to act, and there needs to be some kind of like profitability aspect to it. 8:42 So when we thought about like profitability as a function of survivability, that's something that we really harp on in a lot of our conversations with our clients and prospective clients in the s- sense that, hey, no matter where you think climate is coming from, no matter where you think big disaster is, like what the meaning behind it is, they're happening and they're impacting your bottom line. 9:03 So if we are able to manage survivability and use that as a function to incite more people to think about these incentives, then ultimately that helps solve more of the issue. 9:14 So I think like we're starting to see more of that conversation. Even if we're not the startup that ultimately wins, quote unquote, "wins," there has to be a solution in the space. So even if it's not us, the... 9:25 just the fact that people are talking about it and brainstorming and the more people have that, the more people like bring their own ideas and their own networks and, and communities, ultimately, that's where we're going to create more change and then create more meaningful conversations, if that makes sense. 9:41 It does. But as you're speaking, I'm thinking it is disruptive what you at Fora and what some of these other insurtech platforms are trying to do, right? 9:49 Because the way I heard you explain Fora back in Boston, it almost like it sounded like you needed to change the relationship between insurance carrier and policyholder and make sure that data and obligations, I guess, flow in both directions. 10:02 Because my understanding is with Fora, households can analyze their climate risk and resilience and the survivability of, as you said, of their properties, and communicate this to their insurers, and in turn, maybe insurers can offer discounts or incentives to lower their premiums, and this data could also be used for by those other stakeholders you mentioned, like real estate. 10:18 And it just seems like there's a way of doing things right now in insurance world, in real estate world, and these sectors, they all want access to additional data, but the way you're framing it is actually there should be a more dis- equal distribution of, of power and, and data across the ecosystem. 10:32 So yeah. Can you tell us if you think this is... if this is a disruptive model and how you need the market to come to your way of thinking in order to thrive? Yeah. 10:40 We were very intentional with the way that we created our tools in terms of not adding an additional step onto an underwriting workflow. So like when I think about an underwriter and they're... 10:49 what they're typically going through to be able to bind a policy, they get an address. 10:53 First step is typically pinging some kind of third-party climate model to get a general sense of the risk, so they're getting some kind of wildfire, hurricane, flood score, nine out of ten, ten out of ten, whatever it might be. 11:03 And then from there, they move into assessing the property, and that's a lot of like data aggregation right off the bat, where they're looking at things like Google Street View and Zillow and realtor.com listings and building permits, and maybe they're doing an inspection in there, but maybe that happens after. 11:16 So it's all of these different data points that help the underwriter gain confidence about a property that they're putting on their books. 11:23 But ultimately, what we do is we replace a lot of the like effort that needs to be done at that second step. So we're already doing all the data aggregation ourselves. 11:32 We're placing another analytical layer on top of it, so it's less of a subjective decision, and they can measure it across their entire portfolio. 11:38 And I think that's like the biggest piece that we've had to try to convince people of is, you know, we're giving you all the information right off the bat. 11:45 You no longer have to prioritize all these different factors on a property because we're doing it for you. We know that's an efficiency within the majority of underwriting systems. 11:53 But it's more just about like the analytical layering component where we have a survivability score, and this is how all these different items on the property factor into this score. 12:03 And then you can use that to measure, hey, a percentage of your, of your portfolio, we only want to be high-risk properties. 12:11 We can measure that by the survivability score as opposed to a general sense of climate risk.The, the way that we've been doing things in the space previously has worked very well. 12:20 Like, insurance companies have been using these kind of models for decades, and it was great because they help business and disasters are more likely to happen in these areas. 12:30 But now disasters are more likely to happen in way more areas than [chuckles] than they can afford to, to not write. 12:36 And so for us, it's about providing more, like, personalized information to every insurance carrier to help them compete on something other than price, which is now both customer experience and the personalization of, of properties according to their own standards. 12:50 So I, I think, like, the biggest thing and I guess the biggest disruptor is the idea of a survivability score, but less about the actual tools themselves because we're already demonstrating this is more efficient for you. 13:01 You're spending less time, so you can buy more policies, which ultimately adds more premium to your books. 13:06 And the score function, like as we continue to publish more research, has a compounding effect because you're putting properties on your books that are traditionally higher risk properties that actually result in less claims and reduce your loss ratio down the line. 13:19 So you're making more money from lower risk items that you're not competing on with a bunch of other companies because you're spotting them with a different algorithm essentially. 13:28 Whereas before, if you were just relying on typical climate models, that's not very actionable from a structure standpoint. 13:33 It's only giving you things based on weather data and, like, things like temperature, humidity, topography, all those things. It's a coherent message and it's a compelling pitch. 13:41 I'm wondering though, like, when you're talking to certain stakeholders, do they get it? 13:45 What sort of pushback do you get against this survivability score and the way you're providing this kind of personalized data, right? 13:52 I'm wondering if there's been questions about, okay, why should we trust your way of scoring things versus XYZ's way of scoring things, and that. And what sort of answers do you have for those who have those questions? 14:02 Yeah. I think for the most part, we haven't seen any other scores that are like our survivability score on the market. So it's definitely like a newer concept, like looking at properties in this way. 14:12 The biggest thing that we've seen previously is just we publish a lot of research and we've taken almost like thought leadership approach. 14:19 So we publish a lot of both like insightful, kind of like articles and go do debriefs with the industry, host and co-host events about all these different natural disaster topics. 14:30 We're educating people in the space, and that not only establishes ourselves as, like people that know what we're doing and building something that showcases that we know what we're doing, that's smooth and slick, but it's also because we're publishing research and postmortems on different disasters, it helps us prove out, hey, if you were to use our survivability score in all these different scenarios, this is how this would've translated on your book of business. 14:52 So it's less about I don't believe your score, and more about show me why I should believe that this is like the right way to approach this topic, and then we already have all that publicly available for people to be able to go through and test out, and we do a lot of like pilot testing with a lot of our stakeholders, lots of demos. 15:10 So 15:11 overall, it's demonstrating it has value originally, uh, through something that's compelling, and then being able to back that up with research that we publish that we can cross-reference, and then showcasing how the product works in the scope of that research. 15:24 Does that make sense? Yes, it does. It's common with a lot of startups that are kind of trying to almost create a new market category, right? And it sounds like you're going about it the right way. 15:32 We were just talking before recording about the kind of road shows you're doing, talking to... Going to different events, going to different InsurTech pitches, and also going to conferences like where I met you. 15:42 Can you actually tell us like whereabouts you are on this journey then before? So you got the, you got the tech out, you're getting the message out there. What, what's the sort of roadmap for the next year? Yeah. 15:50 I mean, we go to a lot of conferences, but ultimately we're closing up our seed round right now, so hiring a lot of new help to onboard more of these like larger contracts, um, and making sure all those go well. 16:02 We're just like increasing our volume pretty substantially. We've done thousands of assessments all across the US, but moving into Canada, uh, Latin America, and then hopefully Europe at some point. 16:12 So expanding geographies, which expands our data set, but also expanding the tools that we use. 16:17 So just in the last six months, we've expanded into five different perils as opposed to the two that we started with, and that's purely based off of demand, of people wanting to know more insights about their portfolios, being able to cover the broad spectrum of everything that's been working has been something that now we worked on and, and are continuing to push. 16:34 But the rest of the year is really just we're hitting a lot of different conferences. 16:38 We're doing a lot of different events with Insure, which is a nonprofit that we're a part of, uh, at the intersection of climate and insurance. 16:45 Yeah, just having a lot of conversations and, like, wrapping up some pilots that we're doing to convert into commercial contracts in the beginning of the year, as well as starting some pilots in the beginning of the year with larger tier one carriers that we're excited to continue to, to provide value for. 17:00 So that, and I think the last thing is just doing more postmortems on disasters. 17:05 I was hearing about there's another hurricane that's in, like, the Caribbean right now that is like one of the most devastating ones, and I'm sure there's a lot of others that I'm not even privy to. 17:15 It's just so consistently devastating that I've... I'm on calls with people and they're like, "Yeah, we're actually sheltering in place because of the hurricane." 17:21 Like, I got that so much when Milton and Helene were happening and it's just... It is actually just mind-blowing how insane it's become. 17:29 And I, for one, am just, I am excited that insurance is ready to adopt a solution like ours. 17:35 And I think for a long time we doubted the fact that we needed to be more personalized in property insurance, and that's not really our fault. 17:44 I think a lot of people thought, "Hey, this isn't like a pattern we have to, we have to figure out. Like, these disasters are once in 100 years. This is not something that's going to continuously impact our pocketbook." 17:55 But it has, and more people are, are willing to have those conversations. 18:00 So it's interesting what you say about the people you're talking to, and they're realizing slowly maybe that there are going to be changes in the patterns of perils and impacts from climate related risks. 18:10 And sometimes I think about this climate adaptation, climate risk InsurTech market is about improving technology, right? Improving g- data granularity and communication of risks. 18:20 And other times I think it is more behavioral and almost like-... a perception, right, by individuals and businesses in the wake of super storms like Helene, like Milton. 18:29 And I wonder, how do you think about the ways in which society could reach a tipping point where thinking about climate resilience becomes kind of a mass market phenomenon, right? 18:36 That you're trying to do that with these personalized assessments, right? You're trying to put climate risk data in the hands of, of users and trying to make them see there's a benefit from doing this. 18:45 What other ways do you think could d- drive people to embrace climate resilience as something they need to do for their own financial wellbeing and their own individual wellbeing? 18:54 It's all about aligning incentives where, uh, there, right? 18:56 Like, when we first got into climate, I, I touched on this a little bit, but it, just the idea that we were always talking about how we needed to solve climate all together, and we needed to create solutions together, and the fact that everyone that went into climate was creating solutions for one industry that didn't touch other industries, and we're like solving one problem, which granted a lot of them are like real problems that exist, but they don't solve the overall issue of the fact that most of the time the policy holder, the homeowner, they're losing their most valuable asset, and they're the one that is hit the most when a disaster happens to them. 19:32 And yes, that sends ripple effects into all these adjacent industries that we can use, but ultimately it's about incentivizing the policy holder to take that into their own hands because there's millions of properties that are already built. 19:44 Let's forget about the properties that are being built at a different building code to be able to withstand disasters. 19:49 There's all of these properties that are built, that people are living in, that people are buying and selling all the time that are in high-risk disaster zones. 19:56 And we also know that these disaster zones and the data that we have is typically five to 10 years behind in all of these models from where they should be. 20:04 So all of the flood zones that we know today are likely actually supposed to include millions of more homes and people that are living in these areas. 20:13 So when we think about incentives, in my mind, I envision it like someone is living in a wildfire zone in Napa Valley, and March comes around and they get a notification from their insurance company that says, "Hey, uh, we're getting ready to like think about renewing your policy. 20:29 Do these like XYZ things to reduce your risk on your property and keep your insurance or lower your insurance if you qualify." 20:36 And it just becomes a function of, okay, when March hits, I prune my trees and I remove the debris from my roof, and I clear defensible space on my property, and that's just a function of me keeping insurance now. 20:49 And a lot of the thing-- I think a lot of people underestimate the fact that a lot of the things that we could do on our property to reduce our risk are things that you can... 20:57 I always give the example of is like things that you can get done in a couple of hours on a Sunday afternoon. They should not be very daunting tasks. 21:04 That's how we slowly start to create this like incentives network and positive feedback loop that works for us. 21:10 It's like as a function of owning a home, as a function of having insurance in these areas, you perform certain work and that just becomes a part of your process. And that's all about incentive. 21:20 If people know that, hey, I'll keep my insurance in this area, I won't have to shop around if I don't want to, I, I know I'm getting a good rate or I can get a lower rate if I invest this time, that ultimately makes it easier for people to act and actually do this work. 21:33 'Cause the big thing that we saw when we were initially building for like grant organizations to help people track reimbursements, that was like the initial inception of Fora. 21:41 We realized, hey, these grant programs can't-- could or could not exist next year, and then there's also no follow-up. 21:47 So people could get paid $10,000 to replace parts of their roof and siding and upgrade parts of their home. 21:54 But then if there's debris everywhere and they're not maintaining their house, then that defeats the purpose of the entire program, right? 22:00 So it's the consistent maintenance, creating those incentives year over year to something that everyone relies on, like insurance, like real estate, and then being able to monitor that and, and continue to provide those benefits year over year. 22:12 It seems to me like climate resilience can be done at, at different levels, different tiers, let's say. 22:17 And there's the individual actions you can take, and I, I think that's especially important when it does come to properties that are standalone properties and they are at wildfire risk, clearing vegetation, putting in fire breaks, whatever. 22:29 Those are things that individuals can do. But then you have to go above that. 22:32 There's community resilience, which is also important because of course you can do everything to your house, but if you've got a neighbor's house that is basically an ignition risk, then how do you convince them to do that, right? 22:42 I'm wondering how do you see yourself kind of plugging into broader efforts to do like community resilience, state and city-level resilience? 22:49 Because we're seeing increasingly municipalities coming out with like adaptation plans, resilience plans, and insurers too trying to invest in infrastructure that provides resilience at a larger scale. 22:59 So I just wonder how do you see yourself fitting in with those broader, uh, adaptation and resilience efforts? 23:04 I think the, the more that we collect data on individual properties, the more we can gather insights about larger communities and then as a whole, like larger states and at the federal level. 23:13 So we're already collecting thousands of different data points on thousands of properties all across the US and as we continue to develop this data set, it's all in relation to individual property characteristics and how they aid or do not aid in survival. 23:26 And so like when we look at something like Helene or Milton, when we're doing a postmortem on that disaster, we're looking at a couple of different things. We're looking at, okay, here are all the addresses. 23:36 If we run them through a survivability score, which ones survived, which ones did not survive, and how did those fare within the survivability ma- matrix that we've developed? 23:44 And then from that, what were the average property values that would've been lost if an insurance company were like non-incentivizing risk versus incentivizing risk? 23:54 We think a lot about just the fact that like if we're making recommendations, if these properties that didn't survive did X, Y, and Z on their property, what is the percent increase in survivability rate? 24:04 And what we find is a lot of these things are very little, like maybe a couple hundred bucks at higher ends, and they significantly, 20% to 30% increase in survivability from what we're seeing currently. 24:17 So for within like larger communities, there's also a lot of opportunities for not only like us creating more incentives based off of that data, but partnering with companies and solutions in the space that-Make it easier for us to extrapolate and pair that together. 24:31 So for example, community-embedded insurance is something that we've been looking at fairly recently. 24:36 It's not something that's caught on very, uh, very much yet, but it's this idea that communities can buy insurance all together, and that way insurance is part of, like, the community. 24:46 Everyone reduces their risk, which reduces the risk to everyone else, so everyone is incentivized to continuously maintain their property. 24:54 And in some ways it would kind of function like an HOA in a way, where it's like you have specific rules and you pay into a specific pool of money to maintain the property, but it's less about property value and more about, like, the actual insurance cost for everyone. 25:07 And so we think that's a really great opportunity, especially in areas that are wildfire-prone or flood-prone where, you know, reducing the risk on everyone's property has a very inherent benefit to everyone else. 25:18 And then the same thing with parametric insurance. We really love the idea of parametric insurance. 25:23 I know it's catching on specifically in flood and there's a couple of, like, earthquake parametric insurance companies out there. 25:28 But ultimately if we're giving people an easier way to get paid out but that's triggered by something on the property, so you're impacted in this way, you've done this mitigation work, you get this amount of payout, then that's also, like, a very good structure for us as a community to be able to be more sustainable, be more resilient and benefit inherently from that process. 25:48 So I think we fit in pretty nicely with all those different solutions, and I think there's more solutions that will come up down the line, but those are just a few that, that immediately come to mind. 25:57 That's really interesting. I love the idea of that community-embedded insurance. I hadn't heard of that before. 26:02 And it makes me think, again, to my earlier question about is it behavioral shifts or is there market and technological shifts, and it still- it seems like there's... 26:10 it's a combination of both, right, 'cause, like, to do that sort of community-embedded insurance you need to have trust in your, in your neighbors, right? 26:16 And that's possible when you're in these dense networks, the people down the road or who are also in your apartment block or whatever. 26:22 But it's harder when you have communities that are more disparate and don't have those strong social ties. So... 26:27 And then on parametric insurance, I'm glad you mentioned that because I, I wrote an article recently about parametric insurers. 26:32 I spoke to Chris Lol at Insure, who I know you know, and he's very excited about the opportunity to tie insurers up with this broader task of resilience, right? 26:41 Having a really resilience-minded insurer that incentivizes policyholders to take resilience actions. 26:47 Again, it comes back to your idea about changing the relationships between the different stakeholders in this environment. 26:52 One thing I'm wondering is what is necessary though to build this market from a technological and sort of, I suppose, policy point of view. 27:00 So I'm wondering, you're involved in the insurance industry, real estate industry, financial industry, all very heavily regulated, all kind of political as well. 27:08 So I'm wondering what you think in terms of the regulatory space and the policy maker space in terms of making the insurance industry and property markets more climate resilient and more, more, I suppose, open to tools like Fora. 27:18 Yeah. No, absolutely. 27:20 I mean, we think about policy and regulation every single day, and the interesting thing about, like, where we sit with ins-insurance specifically is we are sitting, like, right at this point of risk selection before it goes to pricing. 27:32 So if we were informing pricing through some kind of algorithm that had to be in line with the Department of Insurance, like, regulations and guidelines, we would have to be rated with the Department of Insurance in every single state we did business in. 27:45 But we're technically like a risk... like a selection platform to qualify business in terms of do we even want this property on our books in the first place. 27:54 And that's the first step is, is being able to provide this extra filter on top of the properties that are either going to pricing or not going to pricing, and identifying more profitable business according to that pricing schedule before it actually, like, goes into the algorithm, if that makes sense. 28:08 So because of where we sit in the insurance sector, we don't have to be rated yet by the Department of Insurance. Once we get into pricing, which is on the roadmap, then that's something we have to worry about. 28:18 But something that we do think, uh, a lot about is this idea of compliance for insurance companies. 28:23 For example, in the de- uh, Department of Insurance in California, they are now requiring insurance companies that do business in California to account for mitigation discounts on these properties. 28:32 Typically you can do that through some kind of in-person inspection, but we simply don't have enough of a scalable workforce to be able to account for the heightened amount of risk. 28:40 Not enough, like, property inspectors are trained in wildfire science or hurricane or flood, et cetera, to be able to make those recommendations and spot all those different things. 28:50 We would need to train up a significant amount of workforce that's also exiting the insurance market. 28:55 I think it's like forty to sixty percent of the insurance industry is retiring in the next five years, which is absolutely incredible. 29:02 So from that perspective is we don't have enough of a workforce to be able to account for all those mitigation discounts. 29:07 So how on earth are we going to be able to comply with this re-new regulation if all we have is a top-down view of the property that doesn't show us all the different things that we need to know? 29:17 So that's where a tool like ours comes in, and we pitch it to companies as if you have mitigation discounts that you need to keep track of and you need to be able to qualify whether or not you award these discounts to properties and they maintain that risk year over year, that's also an incentive that aligns with both parties, where property owners maintain their risk and they keep these action items up. 29:36 And then policyholders and, and regulators are able to spot with an insurance company, hey, they're tracking these policyholders and what mitigation activity they've done, and that means they qualify for these discounts. 29:49 That's regulation. That's approved. That's solid. We know that California leads the charge on a lot of these, like, discounts. 29:55 California, Florida and Iowa, so it really is just a function of how long will it take the other states to adopt them. We know they will at some point if they're not already. 30:07 As well as for individual companies, like companies like State Farm and Allstate, Farmers, Chubb, like all these big companies, they have their own discounts that are ingrained in their policies that w- so that when they file, they need to be able to account for those every year. 30:21 So that's not even like a federal regulation. That's just purely part of their company and what they've said that they would do. 30:26 So it, it's really-A lot of it is focused on how do we make that as simple as possible and within regulation, like how long is it going to take other companies to adopt? 30:36 I don't have a great answer for that, unfortunately. Yeah, those are like big things. 30:39 And the last thing I'll say on like regulation and, and just like general policy is the idea that we really need to get people off of these like state plans of last resort, like the California Fair Plan and the Citizens Plan in Florida. 30:52 In the next three years, those two plans are gonna reach over three trillion dollars in premium on our books. 30:58 And California Fair Plan, as of right now, two hundred million in the bank, over three hundred billion on their books. 31:05 So they are completely insolvent, and they would be-- they would need to be bailed out by the government and these insurance companies that are doing business there because that's what they signed on for when they do business in California. 31:15 And so everyone loses. Policyholders don't get paid out. If they do, it's because all these insurance companies are forced to pay, the government is forced to pay, that comes out of our pockets. 31:24 Like, it's a whole, it's a whole thing. 31:26 And we hear about California and Florida all the time, but every single state, for the most part, their fair plans or their insurer of last resort is growing exponentially, and they need more resources to be able to keep up with it because prices are rising and, like, the consumer aspect is not really being taken into account. 31:43 So I think that's like going back to one of your original points about, like, how we're connecting with the policyholder and servicing the policyholder as much as the insurer and, like, being able to get that information. 31:54 That's where we see a lot of value is policyholders don't know that this is happening regulation-wise. 32:00 Like, underwriters know, companies know, but being able to involve that and create a little bit more transparency in the insurance industry, like they have with telematics and auto insurance, like they have with health and life, with the healthier you exercise, you get a lower premium. 32:13 This is following in the same footsteps. It's more just how do we make it as, as actionable as possible for every party involved. Those stats about California are fascinating. 32:24 That makes you think about how as society faces climate risks, there are these kind of unavoidable problems. 32:30 There are also unavoidable opportunities, right, in terms of investment in climate resilience, in decarbonization, but there are these unavoidable problems as well that will have to be dealt with sooner rather than later, which, you know, makes the case for, uh, services like yours. 32:43 It does make me think as well when you talk about the mitigation benefits and the tracking of those mitigation measures and associated benefits at the state level, but also at the company level. 32:52 Yeah, there's a lot of data that needs to be managed, and I'm wondering, like, what are the barriers to entry here? 32:56 Because in InsurTech, there is a lot of innovation going on in, in insurance now and at the intersection of insurance and, and climate. 33:02 But I'm wondering, you know, you're a small outfit, you're in pre-- you're in seed-raising mode, but there are these massive, very wealthy incumbents who are churning out data and, and analysis, and I'm wondering what, what do you think gives startups a, a hope in hell [chuckles] in this busy and expensive space? 33:18 Yeah, no, I mean, that, that's a great question. And I, I think startups in the insurance space, all we really need to do for these larger incumbents is make it easier for them to do what they are already doing. 33:31 A-and so I think the big kind of, like, story that was started when big InsurTech companies like Hippo and Lemonade came on the scene, you know, a decade or so ago, these big companies basically came into insurance and said, "We can underwrite and do things better than you." 33:47 And, like, a lot of those companies fizzled out. Some of them are now public, and they've, you know, been wildly successful. But for the most part, like that was the thing that, like, really rubbed people the wrong way. 33:57 Startups in the insurance space need to be saying, "Hey, we know that what you guys have been doing has worked in the past. 34:03 We're here to help you change with the times and do exactly what you were kind of used to doing, but just tweaking it a little bit so that you actually can stay afloat in harder markets." 34:14 So, like, from us, from our perspective, it's you have step one with climate models, you have step two with evaluating the property, and then you go to bind and you price it, and you do all these other things. 34:23 For step two, you use us and you make it faster. If you use us, this becomes faster and more efficient for you, and that's what we have to do. 34:31 And I think it, it would be wrong of me to say that insurance professionals don't recognize that there's a problem. 34:36 I think for a long time it was like we need to be more sustainable for insurance companies, and that's the biggest thing. But ultimately, we know that we have a climate problem. 34:44 We know that we have a natural disaster, like risk issue that we have to be able to innovate on and, and create more personalized property insurance for. 34:53 But, like, the biggest thing is just this is more efficient for you, and then we continue to prove out as we go along that this actually also reduces your loss ratio, and we could track that over the next couple years. 35:03 And those are really the biggest pieces that we have to convince people on if you're an InsurTech startup. And we also get the question all the time of why don't insurance companies build these things themselves? 35:13 Like, they have all this massive data, they have all this money, they're like wealthy companies, they've been around for so long, all these different things. 35:19 But people are so shocked at how reliant the insurance industry is on third-party vendors because ultimately, insurance companies are risk management companies, they are not data companies. 35:29 So while they have all this information, it would be silly of them to invest into an entire data science team to build these models, get the data, clean the data, train the model, test it, and beta test it over a year, actually file with the regulation, with the Department of Insurance in every state they do business in, and then finally get it to market. 35:47 That's like a three to five-year process for a lot of these, like, larger incumbents. 35:51 So that's out of the picture because, like, they would much rather have a vendor management team that does underwriting on the side or maybe is, like, fully focused on finding these third-party vendors to be able to place more business and, like, actually add the premium that is making the money in the first place. 36:06 And then with the larger data companies, we have a lot of like core systems, aggregators, a lot of people that are making these, like, moves in the space, and they have such a big technical backlog that even if they started today, it would still take a very long time for them to build the same kind of tool that offers the same kind of value. 36:24 So, like, we're partnering with big data companies now because we've built out this ecosystem, we've built out the mitigation discount database and, like, client product services that we can recommend to people based off of their property characteristics.Contractor service referrals, like, like all these different pieces that again, like, it's no question in my mind that they could build it. 36:45 But it's more just about is it more advantageous for them to work with a company that it would be cheaper for them to pay us whatever amounts to be able to get that upfront and be able to all start placing business with this new information, or is it more advantageous for them to go through that whole process? 37:00 And for the most part, it is not. [laughs] Like it's more... It's better for them to work with other, like, third parties to be able to go back to doing what they do best, which is writing policies. 37:10 I think people need to be talking to as many people as they can. 37:13 Like, that's what we did initially, just, like, learning the language, learning what people really want to see in a product, doing a lot of demos, getting a lot of feedback, going to a lot of these events. 37:22 And then eventually, if you're talking about a full, like, mission and then how you achieve that mission, people tend to listen if, if it's something that's important to the industry, and you can kind of read the room on, on a lot of that. 37:33 Yes. It's a less adversarial environment, I suppose. It doesn't need to be startups versus incumbents. Yes, these large companies, they're not monoliths that are behind their own high walls. They are... 37:44 They have more amorphous boundaries. And yes, they're using vendors, dropping vendors, taking on new ones, trying new things all the time. 37:49 So that is a bit more porous and allows companies like Fora and allows some of these other insurtech companies to, to, to gain traction. 37:56 What are the, the things you'd like to see developments in the market that you think could help turbocharge your growth? 38:02 Because going back to talking about parametric insurance, I spoke to a few startups, and they said what's really enabled this climate resilience parametric insurance renaissance is the fact that there are all these satellites now that provide great geospatial data at very high granularity, which enable for the analysis to price each parametric insurance at the right level and to determine triggers to a very high degree. 38:25 So I'm wondering for Fora, what are the sort of technological advances that could really help turbocharge your growth? Yeah. 38:31 I think some of the biggest things is just more transparent data on, like, siting of properties. So, like, we use a lot of inspection data. 38:39 We use, uh, a lot of just, like, aggregation of, like, building permits, but also, like, satellite and aerial imaging to find things about roof characteristics. 38:47 And, like, the biggest problem that we find is, like, from a foundation and siting perspective, it's very hard to get that information, uh, from anything other than some kind of inspection. 38:56 So I think some of the biggest things that we see opportunities in improving is, first off, we're bu- we're building this data set of siting and foundational data, so we'll be able to turn that around and create more actionable tools off of it. 39:07 But just being able to provide more of those insights. Like, maybe it's an inspection company that makes it public. 39:13 Maybe it's more government databases that have this information that they have no idea how useful it would be to someone like us. 39:20 But making that more transparent and just, like, available to more people, I think will really help. So that, that's probably, like, one of the biggest things. 39:28 And then I think, like, the more people just, like, think about the intersection of climate and insurance, the more people will come together and brainstorm and be able to bring their own networks in to provide more incentives. 39:40 So for insurance companies offering more discounts on very specific, like, variable actions, um, you know, like there's companies that have all of these, like, programs for policyholders where if you do all of these things, then you get some kind of insurance discount if we're partnered together. 39:56 But it's a checklist where y- you only qualify for something once you spend a couple thousand dollars. 40:02 And I think we need to realize as an insurance industry, but also just, like, generally across all of these different facets of, of climate risk is cost is the biggest barrier to entry for a policyholder every single time. 40:15 Like, like, it's, like, pretty non-negotiable that is the case, especially for risk mitigation. 40:21 And so if we take this idea of policyholder is the one that's impacted most, so we need to provide a solution for the policyholder as much as these larger incumbents. 40:31 And then because cost is the biggest barrier to entry, how do we provide data and get data from policyholders in a way that's helpful to them but doesn't cost them very much? 40:40 So that's, like, why one of the reasons, uh, that we partner with insurance companies was if they're doing a digital inspection as a part of just getting insurance, then we don't have to directly charge them anything, and we still get this data, we still provide them with a resource, and it still closes the loop. 40:53 Yeah, so that's, it's less techno- technological advantage and more just, like, understanding that whatever we provide to policyholders, we need to make more accessible to more people, not just the people that are, like, high net worth or, or living in, like, more well off territories, because those are not the majority of properties that are getting impacted, right? 41:15 So those are... That's my two cents. Okay. 41:17 So finally, I'm interested to know, after a few years in the insurance world, insurtech world, you probably came into the industry with, with some thoughts about how it operates and, and how people would be when it came to interacting with a company that's trying to disrupt things a little bit. 41:31 I'm wondering, after a few years in this space, what have you learned that kind of surprised you or went against your prior expectations going into, into insurance world? 41:40 Because I think that might be interesting to those people out there who are also thinking of getting into the space. 41:43 And I think we know that the insurance, and especially the cli- climate insurance space, is gonna get very busy in the next few years. 41:50 I think one of my initial, like, assumptions about the industry was because it's a larger legacy industry, people don't care as much about innovation, but that could not be further from the truth. 42:00 Everyone talks about how slow it is, but in the grand scheme of things, when you think about how large these companies are and everything that they're doing within their organization, yes, it might be slow from, like, a team to team perspective, but from, like, a company-wide, like, initiatives perspective, they're used to looking at a lot of things and moving relatively quickly on whether they want to pursue an idea. 42:20 So chances are if it's moving slow for you as opposed to quickly, that's probably a good thing because they're still evaluating your solution. 42:27 They're looking at all these different areas and, like, figuring out where you could potentially work. 42:32 We've done dozens of calls with different carriers and, like, it resulted in some kind of pilot, but from my perspective, I thought-Man, like they're stalling on us. Like, like they don't want this. 42:41 And so I've had to like change up how I've thought about the insurance industry as a whole, and then leveraging that. 42:47 So once you get a couple people talking about you, the, the biggest thing is everyone on, in insurance, the majority of people hang out on LinkedIn. So build in public. 42:56 And this goes for a lot of industries, but especially for insurance. It's all about trust. We took the approach of like, I'm reading something, I repurpose it for content. 43:05 If I can teach someone else about what I just read, then that means I've learned it even better. 43:10 I'm learning the insurance language from reading all of these things, talking to all these people, and then I'm engaging with the community. 43:15 And if more people know who you are and what you're doing, and can validate your solution, and you have happy customers, it, it really all just starts to compound year over year. 43:24 And I think that I attribute a lot of that to our early success, and continued success as we continue to grow, is building that network early on, asking as many questions as you can, and it's more approachable than I think a lot of people would think. 43:37 [laughs] Like, there's a lot of people that are interested in, in creating something new for the space, so it's really just about finding those people. Yeah, that's a good insight. 43:45 I started my career writing about insurance, and I thought it was slow and boring compared to banks and hedge funds that my colleagues were writing about. 43:52 But they have to, especially in, in climate worlds, be innovating at quite a fast pace because they are at the front lines of, of climate risk in particular. Yeah. 44:00 And they need to think about how their business is gonna run for five, 10, 15 years in the future. And every year it seems like our predictions for the last five years are already out of date. 44:09 So you have to be very fast-thinking and, and embracing of, of innovation. 44:13 So that's encouraging to me to hear that, and it must be encouraging for you as a entrepreneur in this space as well, that people are open to, to the new ideas and the new technology that you're bringing. 44:21 Okay, Valkyrie, thank you so much for chatting to me today. I'm really looking forward to seeing how Fora grows, and I do encourage, uh, listeners to check out Valkyrie's LinkedIn page. 44:30 She's always posting some really interesting stuff about what's going on in Fora and what she's seeing in Insurtech world more broadly. Valkyrie, where can people go to find out more about Fora? 44:39 Yeah, I mean, you can go to our website. It's F-O-R-A.us, and we have a lot of resources on there. You can reach out to me on LinkedIn. 44:47 I'm very active, so if you have any questions or want to chat, then hit me up on there and, yeah, I'm looking forward to connecting. Great. Thank you for your time, Valkyrie. Have a great rest of your day. 44:57 Awesome, you too. [upbeat music] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof Media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 45:11 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [upbeat music]