Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation finance, tech, and policy. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. Today I'm joined by Washington State's newly minted insurance commissioner, Patty Kudera. 0:22 Kudera was sworn in this January as the state's ninth elected insurance commissioner, and is the first new commissioner to enter the office for a whopping 24 years. 0:31 Before winning the office, Kudera served for almost a decade in the Washington State Legislature, becoming the 48th legislative district's first female state senator in 2017. 0:40 Now she's had plenty to do in her first months in her new role, including on the critical issue facing insurance regulators up and down the country. That is ever worsening climate risk. 0:50 We talk about her efforts to improve the climate resilience of the Washington insurance market and her lobbying of state government to pass meaningful climate risk data and hazard mitigation laws. 0:59 The commissioner also sounds off on the federal government's anti-resilience agenda and shares her thoughts on what can be done at the intersection of home building and insurance to harden families and communities against climate shocks. 1:09 Before we get to the conversation, a note to say that Climate Proof will be at the upcoming Adapt Unbound Conference in New York City on May 14th and 15th. 1:17 I'll be moderating a fireside chat with Jonathan Cook, former Senior Resilience and Adaptation Advisor for USAID, and Janie Bovisi, former Deputy Administrator at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. 1:29 It's a conversation I'm really looking forward to. So if you're in town, do consider coming along. You can get tickets at adaptunboundusa.com. 1:37 Also, if you're not yet a premium member of Climate Proof, you're missing out. 1:41 We've recently published the latest edition of the S&P 500 Climate Physical Risk Signals Dashboard, which tracks references to climate risks and resilience made by S&P 500 executives in their earnings calls. 1:52 It's a great way to get a sense of how big companies are thinking about climate risks and to better understand the dollar impacts of events like the LA wildfires and last year's hurricanes. 2:00 To get access, become a premium member today at www.climateproof.news/upgrade. Right. In a moment, my conversation with Commissioner Kudera, but first, let's round up last week's top adaptation and resilience stories. 2:13 [whooshing] In finance, US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent criticized the International Monetary Fund and World Bank for focusing on climate finance in a speech last week at the institution's annual spring meetings. 2:25 Bessent accused the IMF of, quote, "mission creep," claiming it devotes disproportionate time and resources to work on climate change, gender, and social issues. 2:33 He said instead it should work on trade and payment imbalances and hold countries accountable for economic reforms. 2:39 As for the World Bank, Bessent said it should stop trying to achieve, quote, "distortionary climate finance targets and instead prioritize affordability in energy access, including by investing in fossil fuel production." 2:50 The World Bank wants 45% of its annual financing to go toward climate-related projects this year, though President Ajay Banga said earlier this month that many of these would be smart development investments that have knock-on climate benefits. 3:02 Half of the bank's climate finance target for this year would be earmarked for adaptation and resilience, he added. 3:07 [whooshing] In policy, climate laws that would force big polluters to pay for adaptation and resilience may get a boost from new research that quantifies how much specific fossil fuel companies have contributed to climate-related economic losses. 3:19 The research, published last week in the journal Nature, estimates that from 1991 to 2020, emissions from just 111 companies were linked to $28 trillion in global economic losses from extreme heat alone, with five top emitters responsible for nearly a third of that total. 3:35 The findings could reinforce the nascent field of attribution science, which shows how likely climate shocks are linked to fossil fuel-induced global warming. 3:42 Attribution science is being used to justify a wave of climate super fund laws across US states that aim to make oil and gas majors pay for adaptation measures. 3:51 Vermont was the first state to implement such a law, followed by New York. Other states, including California, are exploring their own versions. 3:57 [whooshing] And in tech, participants at the just wrapped San Francisco Climate Week made a strong case for adaptation solutions, particularly tech addressing wildfire risk, water scarcity, and declining crop yields. 4:08 Climate Proof wasn't in attendance this year, but according to the newsletter CTVC, conversations at the week-long jamboree made it clear that adaptation is moving from a nice-to-have to a must-have, with founders and investors talking more about resilience and energy security than climate tech per se. 4:23 CTVC added that grid reliability and capacity were particularly hot topics given the growing demand on US energy supply from data centers and AI. [whooshing] All right, that's it for this week's roundup. 4:33 Now on to my conversation with Commissioner Kudera. [upbeat music] Hi, Commissioner. Where are you calling from today, and what do you do? Hello, Louis. 4:42 I am actually coming to you from beautiful sunny Olympia, Washington, which is the capital of Washington, and I am the Washington State Insurance Commissioner, newly elected. Thanks for being here, Commissioner. 4:55 My first question is, what efforts are you making to improve the climate resilience of both the insurance industry in Washington State and for policyholders, particularly homeowners facing more frequent and severe climate hazards? 5:06 Yeah, excellent question. 5:07 And I can tell you that, you know, last year and a half I traveled around the state of Washington talking to people and, you know, healthcare and property casualty insurance were the top issues on everyone's mind. 5:19 And with respect to property casualty in particular, you know, the risk of, um, wildfires and flooding was very, very prominent. 5:29 And also I will tell you that people are concerned about non-renewal notices that they're getting. They're not getting an explanation as to why they're getting non-renewed. 5:39 They really are afraid that they're not going to have access to insurance, and if they do have access, they're concerned that they're not gonna be able to afford it. So what we're doing here, there's actually... 5:50 We're doing it on multi layers. So we have the international level that we're working on when it comes to climate change, we have the national level that we're working on, and then we have the state level. 6:00 You know, uh, internationally, we are part of the Sustainable Insurance ForumWhich is a global group of like-minded insurance regulators who exchange ideas on practices and policies that are working in our areas, and the OIC was a founding member of that. 6:17 We also are part of the Forum for Insurance Transition to Net Zero, and that's a UN-led multi-stakeholder forum that supports the acceleration of voluntary climate action by the insurance industry. 6:29 That's both in terms of their operations and their investments. Nationally, Washington State has been a leader on encouraging insurers to think about and report on their climate change impacts to their business. 6:43 Climate change is already having a direct impact on property casualty. 6:47 And, uh, you know, we started the, uh, the NAIC started the Climate Risk Disclosure Survey in twenty ten to require insurers to report on that risk and make it public. 6:58 So that's what we're doing internationally and nationally. 7:01 Locally, what we're doing is we are working right now, and there's a bill going through the legislature that will, uh, establish a study on wildfire risk mitigation and the potential for creating a grant program to help communities harden against natural catastrophes, wildfires in particular. 7:20 So that's what we're doing. We're collecting non-renewal and cancellation data because I think that that will help give us an idea of where we need to focus those efforts, uh, right out of the gate. 7:30 And we're working with other agencies and governments on improving awareness of flood risk and new flood insurance products that are coming out on the market. 7:37 I just had a conversation just a few hours before speaking with you with a legislator whose district is, is number one for flood risk. 7:46 And we are gonna be working collaboratively, not just within the state and amongst the legislature and this office, but also with our federal delegation on how we address flood, um, flooded issues as well. 7:59 Thank you for that. There's obviously multiple layers of government where insurance is relevant and where changes can be made. And I'm interested though, from your point of view, there are two concerns, right? 8:11 There's one that insurers themselves may not capitalize themselves appropriately against growing climate risks, and there's also the threat that insurers will pull out of certain areas and leave parts of the country, parts of Washington State uninsured, right? 8:24 And I'm wondering what levers you can pull as a state commissioner to try and remedy those challenges and how you engage with legislators to kind of deal with those challenges that aren't under your power. Yeah. 8:36 Well, I can tell you for-- to start, you know, we do have the fair plan here in Washington state, which is the insurer of last resort. I wanna keep it that way. 8:45 The goal here is to reduce the risk exposure, uh, for the insurance companies in order to maintain insurability for the consumers of the state. 8:56 That is looking at how do we prevent things that cause claims to be made in the first place. So we're doing... 9:04 One thing we did this last session that, that is, uh, making its way through the legislature right now is a bill to transfer, um, fire loss data reporting back to the office of the insurance commissioner. 9:15 So way back in the day, the insurance commissioner used to be the fire chief and collected that data. 9:21 Then it was farmed out decades ago, and now we've asked to have it come back because that data really hasn't been collected and analyzed like I think it should be. 9:29 And we have the capacity here at the OIC to be able to analyze that data and look for trends that we can then warn consumers around the state so that we can prevent claims from happening in the first place. 9:42 So my orientation, my personal philosophy is to be preventative based, which I think matches the insurance industry's approach to insurance to begin with. 9:52 And the goal here is to keep the fair plan transitory because we have roughly three, four hundred policies on that fair plan right now, which is really quite low, and folks that come onto it typically don't stay very long. 10:08 We wanna keep that way in Washington state. We wanna be able to have a strong, healthy insurance market that is competitive. 10:16 And in order to do that, we do have to look at how do we reduce risk exposure when it comes to climate change in particular. 10:23 And let's be real, I mean, that can has been kicked down the road a long time, and this isn't just Washington State doing this on our own. 10:32 You know, I mean, climate change is a world phenomena, and it will take a global effort to really address it. 10:38 But we can't have people with their heads in the sand who are in power, who don't believe in climate change, who can't even utter the words climate change. 10:46 You know, we need to, to get serious because this is an existential threat to us, and it certainly is going to have continuing impacts on the insurance industry, which is why I think, you know, when I would meet someone who didn't wanna talk about climate change and, you know, that-that's either not happening or they don't like the words, I just tell them to go talk to their insurance agent. 11:08 Ask them what they think about climate change because they have some of the best climate scientists around, and they're doing that catastrophic modeling already. 11:16 And I think we need to be paying attention to that so that when we focus our efforts on mitigation, we're focusing where there is the most vulnerability out of the gate, and hopefully we get there before a catastrophe does. 11:31 Yes, climate change is an existential threat to humanity, but before that, it's an existential business threat to the insurance industry. 11:37 So that's why I'm seeing so much innovation and focus on solutions to climate risk management mitigation amongst insurance industry, and that's why there's also so many startups who have kind of pro-- popping up in the Insurtech space to support insurers with their data needs and et cetera. 11:54 Okay, I wanted to ask briefly about how you kind of fit in with other state level climate resilience plans. 12:01 So Washington State itself has a climate resilience strategy.And your legislators, your governor, your lawmakers have also been working hard on trying to find ways to make the state more hardened to climate risks. 12:14 So I wanna know like what role the office of the insurance commissioner has in supporting these efforts. Well, it's not a, a prominent role, that's for sure. 12:24 You know, the state climate resilience strategy is more under the governor's purview, uh, and it's focused on energy rather than, like, property mitigation. 12:35 And, you know, we're a separate elected office, like the governor and like the other nine separate state agencies are. 12:42 And we've been critical in allowing insurance companies to provide risk mitigation goods and services, forming disaster resilient work groups that focus on natural hazards, and getting a high-level chief resilience officer placed in our emergency management d-division to coordinate state resilience work. 13:03 I personally will be working directly with the commissioner of DNR. 13:07 In fact, this work group that we're working on, they will co-chair that with us as we work toward how do we maintain healthy communities and how do we work to reduce the exposure to wildfire risk. 13:20 So we coordinate regularly with other state agencies to discuss resilience and natural hazard perils, and I don't see that ending anytime soon. 13:30 I think, you know, for my, uh, from my perspective, climate change and mitigation for natural catastrophes is gonna be a primary focus, and it will be for quite some time. 13:42 And I think we ignore it at our own peril, and we all have to be on the same page, and that requires us to share information, share resources, share data in particular, and, and that hasn't always been happening, and I think we're gonna see that change as we go forward. 13:59 I was just gonna ask what are the blockers to a joined up resilience strategy at the state and, and national level, right? 14:06 Because I hear from those folks I interview that you have to have this kind of cross-sector, cross-department approach to resilience because building resilience is not just something for one department. 14:16 It's something that has to happen across the government and across society. 14:20 And you have histories in certain state governments of people operating in silos and being kind of jealously holding onto their data and their information. And then just ways of doing business that need to change, right? 14:31 And that's why I think you've seen chief resilience officers appointed in certain counties and states to kind of be that convening force. 14:38 So I'm interested to know how those roles are important to actually getting stuff done at Washington State, and what blockers, if any, are you coming up against when it comes to trying to build a coherent climate resilience strategy? 14:49 Yeah. Well, I think the number one blocker to that, quite frankly, is the legislative process. I was a former senator and representative for about a decade, and the process is not designed to pass legislation. 15:05 It actually is designed to not pass it, and that makes it really challenging, especially when you're trying to do something substantial to address a critical need like addressing climate change. 15:18 And you run up against large moneyed interests, and that's always an obstacle when it comes to the legislative process. But I do think that, you know, it's also how you approach the problems. 15:33 And as I said, I'm very preventative based, so my goal here is it's not just to regulate the industry and work on a risk mitigation program, it's also to educate consumers, give them information on what they can be doing right here, right now to help maintain their insurability. 15:52 And I think that that's really critical. In fact, the legislature is still in session here through the end of the week, and after the session is over, we're going to go and travel the state again. 16:03 I've al- I've already done that on my own as a candidate. Now we'll be going as insurance commissioner in the Insurance Commissioner's office. 16:10 We will be doing a lot of outreach to people and talking to them about their insurance issues in their communities and giving them information on what they can do to reduce their risk. 16:22 The other thing I think when you talk about siloing information, it's not just within governmental agencies, it's also within the insurance industry itself. You know, they guard that. 16:33 So last year we passed a bill of mine that would protect their proprietary information that was submitted to the Office of the Insurance Commissioner, and I think that is really an important bill because we have one of the broadest public records law in the country, if not the broadest, and I think it was a valid concern that they had that if they submitted certain data to us that it could be used by their competitors against them. 16:57 So we did pass that bill and now we'll be able to collect that data, which will give us better information in order to give, you know, generalized instructions and help to consumers on how they can reduce their risk. 17:09 That's fantastic, that law about protecting proprietary information because I think this has come up on the national level as well when it comes to collecting data and sharing data. 17:17 There's concerns that insurers will lose their competitive edge or information will leak to other players if we do these data calls, and what is an insurance company except a big pot of money and some very sophisticated risk models and, and data, right? 17:31 So I can understand their concern, but we need to break down some of these silos so that we can build nationwide resilience because there's no other way to do it. 17:39 We can't do it in penny packets spread out across the country. So I wanna turn to the national level now. 17:46 We had the gathering of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners in Indiana in March, and I noticed that the association did not include the phrase climate risk or climate change in its recent list of federal policy priorities. 17:59 It did do so last year. 18:02 But despite the kind of change in rhetoric, I understand work is still ongoing on collecting climate risk data from insurers and updating the models used for risk-based capital requirements to account for worsening climate hazards. 18:13 So there seems to be work going on maybe behind the scenes on climate risk.And I'd like to ask you what you make of the NAIC's efforts to promote climate resilience to date, and what takeaways you got from the recent meeting on the future direction of climate risk management in the red-blue space. 18:27 Yeah. 18:28 So you have to take into account I'm brand new and haven't had many opportunities to be exposed to NAIC, but I will say that in terms of the name and everything, climate risk and climate change, they don't care about semantics or terminology. 18:44 Certain politicians will claim that they don't believe in climate change, but as I've told people, you know, you know who does? Your insurance company. They believe in it. 18:54 And, and if we want to effectively regulate an industry, we need to be able to study it inside and out. 19:01 If we're doing that, you can't ignore the fact that the industry is absolutely accounting for climate change and adjusting accordingly, and it's also showing up in their premiums. 19:15 So this is hitting people in their pocketbooks. 19:18 And, you know, it's, it's no surprise that the NAIC doesn't list climate change and insurance as a subject of discussion, um, given the current federal government, um, since our traditional contacts in the federal government on climate insurance have been pretty quiet since January. 19:37 But that doesn't mean that we're gonna stop working on it, and it certainly doesn't mean we're gonna stop emphasizing it here in Washington State. 19:44 And in the United States, of course, it, it's the state insurance regulators, not the feds, who have jurisdiction over the industry. 19:53 And, you know, given the absence of the federal government, our work is even more important than ever. In fact, I made the comment last November that state government just got a whole lot more important. 20:06 I think that is bearing out to be true given the wholesale dismantling of some very important agencies that we see at the federal level. But as I just mentioned, building resiliency is a all of government affair. 20:20 We need all levels of society, all rungs of the legislative and executive branch to be involved. And I wonder, do you see a federal role for insurance climate risk management? 20:31 Traditionally, the Federal Insurance Office is a part of the U.S. Treasury, has had a role in trying to convene insurance regulators and, and try and nudge insurance regulators in certain directions, I understand. 20:41 And of course, 'cause the FIO is currently operating under the Trump administration, its role is severely curtailed, if not to be eliminated entirely. 20:50 But I do wonder, do you see a federal role, maybe not through the FIO, but through other agencies like NOAA or the Commerce Department to support climate resilience by insurers and to support commissioners like yourself? 21:03 Well, I definitely see a role, um, especially for NOAA. I mean, the insurance industry uses their data that they collect. 21:10 I look at NOAA as actually having public safety aspects to what they do, and I think it's really, um, shortsighted and, and, you know, 21:21 extremely unfortunate to say the least, that we're seeing it under attack and being gutted. The same with FEMA. 21:29 We can do everything in our power to reduce our risk exposure, but that doesn't mean we're not still going to have natural catastrophes. Of course, we are. 21:40 And to, to dismantle an organization whose job it was to come in after a natural catastrophe and to help people right away on the ground, I think is really stupid, quite frankly. 21:54 You know, I don't understand why you would want to leave your, your own citizens helpless like that and vulnerable like that. 22:01 And, you know, it's going to be left to the states to pick up the cost, and that's gonna be really, really hard. 22:09 And, you know, I think we-- like I said, we can invest all we want in mitigation strategies, but we still are going to need to work together when there is a natural catastrophe. 22:20 And that's where I think there should be more of a partnership. You know, I hear people talk a lot about waste, fraud, and abuse in government, but yet when, you know... 22:30 I, I don't really see a lot of research and data to back up that it's, you know, across the board, you know, um, happening. 22:39 And when you are looking at programs that are desperately needed and you are cutting them, all you're doing is hurting your citizens. And I just don't understand that. 22:51 So, you know, we're, we're already working on our list of what we're gonna say to our federal delegation when we go out there, and one of them is to save FEMA and to save NOAA, uh, for those reasons. 23:02 So those agencies are of vital importance to insurers and the policy holders they insure. But you believe that the state-based insurance regulatory system is the best way to 23:13 enact regulations to protect your constituents? I definitely do at this moment in history. [chuckles] Good answer. Okay. 23:21 Finally, I wanna talk about the intersection of insurers and property developers and homeowners, because there's been some interesting laws written at the state level trying to incentivize homeowners to harden their own properties, and the little carrot they use is insurance premium discounts. 23:38 So the idea is that the state gives some money to a homeowner, they invest in building their house up to a certain resilient standard. 23:45 The insurer accepts, appreciates that standard, gets the certification approval and says, "Okay, good. We're gonna charge you a lower premium." 23:52 But I'm interested to know, like, what else could happen to bring these two worlds closer together, right? 23:58 The kind of property owner, property development space, and the insurance space, because this seems to be a big problem. We have natural disasters that affect whole cities, whole towns, and rebuilding happens. 24:10 People rebuild back in the same place. They rebuild the same building code. They don't harden their properties. That is definitely something that needs to change. 24:17 So on that intersection, I'd be interested in your thoughts.Well, I definitely think that we need to be... When, when a catastrophe hits, I think we need to learn from it, right? 24:29 Just like Pacific Palisades in California, we saw that there were some homes that withstood the fire. They were one-offs, right? Because they were homes that invested in wildfire risk mitigation strategies. 24:42 They may have gotten a, a discount for it, I don't know, but they're still going back to devastation, and no one wants to go back and live in that. 24:48 So the lesson to take from that is that you can't just do a one-off home here and a one-off home there when you're in an area that is subject to climate change. 24:58 You have to do whole communities, and you have to be thinking about the building codes and the materials that are being used, and, you know, there's the, um, IBHS. 25:09 I think adopting their standards and requiring that insurers give homeowners credit, uh, when they do u- adopt those standards, I think is really an important part of the consumer's role in maintaining their insurability and the insurance company's acknowledgement of that. 25:25 And I also think that it's incumbent upon the states, like I said, we're looking at a grant program here, and I am definitely supportive of that to help whole communities invest in things that they can do to reduce wildfire risk exposure. 25:42 And I'll give you an example. I mean, so we have, you know, we have parts of the state that are high wind areas, and we've got high wires running through those high wind areas. 25:54 And if we were to utilize some of the grant funds and bury those wires in those areas, then we have less likely... We have... We reduce the potential of one of those wires sparking a wildfire, right? 26:06 I mean, it's things like that that I think we can be doing. Yes, I know it costs a lot of money to do it, but how much is it gonna cost to clean up Pacific Palisades? And how long will it take to do that? 26:16 And how many years will it take before it ever even comes back to looking like it used to? 26:21 Uh, I think the cost of not doing these things far outweighs the cost of investing, uh, money upfront and w- you know, using what I consider some common sense approaches to reducing the risk. 26:35 It's quite the mindset shift though, right? 26:37 From individual policyholders taking individual policies based on their risk to promoting community resilience, and the question is about free riders, who pays, you know, behavioral kind of changes that need to be made, right? 26:49 So I wonder if this comes back to what you were saying earlier about your role kind of educating the public and trying to make the case with data, with evidence like we have seen recently in LA. 26:58 So do you see that there is a need to kind of, first of all, engage people more in insurance, then maybe change their mind about what insurance really is? 27:05 It's not just about me and my risk, it's about how I'm affected by our community's risk and how I can help harden the community as one element in it. Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, we're all in this together, right? 27:17 And I do think that what we do impacts others, and I think we need to be looking at it that way. But it, it also involves changing the way that we build, the materials that we use. 27:28 Um, you know, here in Washington, there was a bill to adopt the wildlife, um, uh, urban interface building code, which would reduce the potential for building in an area where a wildfire might occur. 27:41 And that unfortunately did not get over the finish line this year, but it was a bill that the OIC did support. Um, things like that that I think we could be looking at. 27:51 If you have an area that floods every single t- year and you keep building in the same area, I mean, uh, that doesn't make any sense without making any other modifications. 28:03 I mean, you look at what New Orleans has done, right? I mean, they've had to build pretty high levies, right? 28:08 There are ways, there is technology, and there are things that can be done to mitigate the unknown risk that might be happening if you're choosing to build there. 28:18 But that again, I mean, if you're choosing to build in an area that is subject to flooding, maybe there should be increased cost to insure there, I would think. And you might e- not even have insurance. 28:30 Of course, we have the National Flood Insurance Program for now, but I understand. I know, cross your fingers. [laughs] I hear that might be on the chopping block too. Excellent. 28:41 And finally then, yeah, you're new to the office. I wanted to know what's in your diary for the next few months and what you hope to achieve by the end of your first year in office. 28:52 Well, I have a lot of travel in the books and, um, you know, right now we're trying to get through session. We had four agency request bills in the legislature. Two have passed, and we're waiting on the third. 29:06 One has not made it over the finish line. But that work will continue and looking for ways to collaborate with the legislature on other insurance related issues. 29:18 And also, like I said, we're gonna be going around the state and we're gonna be, um, helping to, uh, educate consumers on, uh, insurance and insurance related issues. 29:29 And the goal for the first year is that by the end of the first year, I would like consumers of Washington, when they have an insurance related issue, that their first thought is to call me. That's what I want 29:45 because I want to be able to assist them any way that we can. We're here as a consumer advocacy group. It, um... an office. 29:54 It is in the statute that we act in the public interest, and I take that responsibility very seriously. Yes. Yeah. 30:02 It's a good example of that the government should be here for you, and in this case, your insurance commissioner should be here for you. You're not there for the insurance industry per se. 30:09 You're there for the policy holders, for the public. Exactly. Well, thank you so much for sharing your insights and perspectives with me, Commissioner. Have a wonderful rest of your week. Thank you. You too. Take care. 30:21 Climate Proofer's is a Climate Proof media production. It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe. 30:31 And to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [outro music]