Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hi, everyone, and welcome to Climate Proofers, the show all about those on the front lines of climate adaptation and resilience. 0:13 I'm Louis Woodall, editor of the Climate Proof newsletter, which you can read at climateproof.news. Today, I have a real treat for you. 0:20 You'll get to hear from not one, not two, but four climate proofers on closing the capital gap. 0:26 Earlier this year, I moderated a panel at the inaugural Adapt Unbound Summit in New York, a conference all about scaling solutions and unlocking capital for adaptation and resilience. 0:35 Today, you'll get to hear a recording of that panel. We discuss the adaptation finance shortfall, what sectors are attracting the most investment, the climate tech landscape, and much more. 0:46 The Adapt Unbound Summit will be returning to New York in twenty twenty-five. Check out adaptunboundsusa.com for more information. 0:53 Before we get started, a reminder that Climate Proofers and the Climate Proof newsletter are subscriber-supported productions. 0:59 Listeners like you can help support my coverage of the burgeoning adaptation and resilience space by heading over to climateproof.news/upgrade and becoming premium subscribers. Thank you for the support. 1:10 Okay, in a minute, the Adapt Unbound panel. But first, let's round up some of last week's adaptation and resilience stories. 1:17 [swish] In finance, COP29 host Azerbaijan launched the Climate Finance Action Fund, which aims to raise one billion dollars to help countries recover from climate-driven natural disasters, meet their climate action plans, and bolster mitigation and adaptation projects. 1:33 Officials say the fund will be capitalized by voluntary contributions from fossil fuel-producing countries and companies, with Azerbaijan itself taking the lead. 1:41 Although the country has yet to say how much it will chip in. 1:44 Twenty percent of the fund's investment returns will be earmarked for a rapid response funding facility, which will dole out grants and cheap capital to help climate-vulnerable countries deal with natural disasters. 1:56 However, climate activists criticized the fund, saying that the voluntary nature of the contribution and the fact that climate polluting companies would have decision-making powers over its investments made it an exercise in greenwashing. 2:07 [swish] In policy, the London Climate Resilience Review released its final report on how to harden the UK capital from escalating climate shocks. 2:16 The independent review, set up by Mayor Sadiq Khan following the extreme heatwaves that rocked the city in twenty twenty-two, found that while there are good examples of climate adaptation in London, governments and businesses are ill-prepared for the cascade of disruptions that could be triggered by overlapping extreme weather events. 2:33 The one hundred and sixty-eight-page report contains fifty recommendations on avoiding the costs of being underprepared and capturing opportunities to improve the living standards of working people and deliver robust infrastructure. 2:45 Mayor Khan said he accepted the report's recommendations and would work to take them forward over the coming months. 2:51 [swish] And in tech, well, sort of tech, the government of Canada has tested a new rapid extreme weather event attribution system, which it used to determine how much human influence on the climate increased the likelihood of June's heatwaves. 3:04 The new system released its analysis of last month's extreme weather events and concluded that they were made two to ten times more likely by human-caused climate change. 3:13 The system uses a series of climate models to simulate both the climate of the eighteen hundreds and the climate of today. 3:20 After heatwaves occur, scientists compare the number of similar events in the model-generated climates. 3:26 The purpose of the system is to better prepare Canada for the dramatic changes in the weather expected as climate change worsens. [swish] Okay, that's all for the news this week. Now onto the Adapt Unbound panel. 3:38 [upbeat music] So we're here to talk about the capital gap, and we have a star-studded panel with which to do that. I'm gonna ask them to introduce themselves, starting here with Mailys. Hi, everyone. I'm Mailys Carraro. 3:52 I'm the managing partner of the Catalyst Fund. We are an early-stage venture capital fund focused on climate adaptation in Africa. We... 4:01 I founded it about two years ago, and so far we've made twenty investments in climate adaptation ventures across the continent in eight markets. Hi, I'm Emily Mata Curti. I am co-founder and managing partner of Tailwind. 4:13 We are an investment fund as well as an ecosystem builder focused on early-stage adaptation and resilience tech. And yes, you have half the markets [chuckles] in here on this panel pretty much. 4:24 There's not a lot of investors out there. Um, so we do early-stage investments. We also do thought leadership and, uh, other kind of activities to help the ecosystem build. 4:34 And so I wanna shout out to, uh, Oliver and the Adapt Unbound team because this is a great event, first of a kind, and we need more of those. Thank you. Hey, everyone. Uh, I'm Sonam Velani. 4:46 I am the co-founder and managing partner of Streetlife Ventures. We are an early-stage venture fund based here in New York City. Uh, we focus on the intersection of cities and climate. 4:56 Uh, half of humanity lives in cities, seventy percent of emissions come from cities, ninety percent of climate risk is in cities, and we gotta do something about all that, so that is why we exist. 5:04 And I'm sure we will get into more details as we go along. Hi, everyone. I'm Anish Patel. I'm CEO and managing director of Yamaha Motor Ventures. We have under three hundred million under assets under management. 5:18 We invest in a broader kind of array of climate tech-related technologies across the world. Wonderful. Thank you all for being here. So we hear a lot about the adaptation finance shortfall. Here are some stats. 5:31 The UN claims there is an adaptation financing gap of one hundred and ninety-four to three hundred and sixty-six billion per year worldwide, and the Climate Policy Initiative warned in a report last year that global adaptation finance is just five percent of climate finance between twenty twenty-one and twenty twenty-two, and that's actually down from seven percent between twenty nineteen and twenty twenty. 5:53 And on the urban front, Sonam's specialty, a report from the Cities Climate Finance Leadership Alliance claims only nine percent of global urban climate finance goes towards adaptation. 6:04 So there is a, a serious shortfall here, and I'd like to ask the panel, like, how we can address this. And, um, Emily, actually, first of all ask you about the climate finance shortfall and how we can address it. 6:15 All right. So I brought my stats too, which is to say generally ten percent of climate finance goes to adaptation specifically, and that's mostly looking at public money. 6:23 If you look at VC, it's about one percent of VC money going into adaptation, which is not enough and-What I want to say is there's a capital gap because there's a market gap, and there's a market gap in that we need more innovation, but mostly we need people to want to buy and be ready to spend money on adaptation and resilience solutions. 6:44 And from where we sit, this is where the biggest gap is, is the lack of maturity from, uh, the ability to articulate what the buyers really need in terms of solutions and performance, uh, requirements, really be specific about what problems they're trying to solve how, and then having budget. 7:03 And so when we look at cities and local governments and utilities and agencies, but also corporates, there's a lot of potential demand. There's a lot of need, but it hasn't translated yet in a demand signal. 7:15 And so I think one of the ways we're gonna solve the capital gap is by working with corporations and with local governments so that they are able to articulate what they need and to find it. 7:26 Maelis, perhaps you could talk about the adaptation finance shortfall in the African context since that's where you're active. Absolutely. 7:32 If you think that, you know, globally the stats are depressing at best, and when you look at emerging markets, it's even worse. 7:40 Um, so in Africa alone, so just that continent, there's a gap estimated by also the Climate Policy Initiative at two hundred and fifty billion per year between twenty twenty and twenty thirty. 7:51 And, um, when you look at the contribution of the private sector, it's only fourteen percent of that total. In twenty twenty, the total that went to climate adaptation was just thirty billion. 8:01 So we are very far from meeting the need, and yet it's actually a huge opportunity. 8:08 So I think, you know, shifting sort of from the need and how we address it, like how we address it is actually looking at it from an opportunity perspective. 8:18 Like the narrative certainly is that this is the continent most vulnerable to climate impacts and the one that contributed the least to the problem. Only four percent of global emissions come from Africa. 8:29 And yet it has all the assets to actually do something about it and be a leader in climate action. 8:34 Abundant renewable energy resources, natural resources, and actually carbon sinks, when you think of like Great Lakes, for example. 8:43 Uh, a youth that is like ready to take action and actually a, a tech scene that has been booming over the past decade. 8:49 And all of these ingredients together make it a very promising, at least we believe, um, space for innovation to actually grow and find the solutions that are locally relevant, but also glo-- that can scale at a global, at a global level. 9:06 So that's what we are trying to do on our very, very small scale, but it's also the narrative that I'm seeing across governments, across the private sector, across investors, uh, happening in terms of mindset shift from yes, a need to fill, but also a huge opportunity. 9:21 That's a very polished pitch. Yeah, take my note, money now. [laughs] Uh, Sonam, I'd like to, to turn to you and talk about, uh, adaptation finance shortfall in the city urban context. Yeah. 9:31 So, so since we are sitting in Lower Manhattan, the, you know, financial capital of the world, I'm going to ask you all a question. 9:38 How much do you think the value of the property in Lower Manhattan is at risk due to climate change, um, today versus by twenty fifty? Wild guess. I, I know you are all very smart, so come on. 9:53 [laughs] Is it in, in percentage terms or in- Sorry? In percentage terms? What percentage of properties- Uh, uh, value, total dollar value. Total dollar value. Oh, goodness. Nobody in real estate here? This is Manhattan. 10:06 [laughs] I just moved to Battery Park, and I don't know. The-- Your property is at risk. No, no. [laughs] Yes, I know that. [laughs] No, Battery Park, we're actually doing something, uh, with coastal resilience there. 10:16 It's a hundred billion dollars, right? So by twenty fifty, a hundred billion dollars of property just in Lower Manhattan is at risk due to climate change. That is in, uh, you know, just about thirty years, right? 10:29 A little less than thirty years. And I think the-- one of the challenges with climate risk, and Emily, you touched on this, is actually putting a value to that risk. It's quantifying that risk. 10:39 And I think that is something that we do not do well, right? Because climate change happens, you know, your streets flood or, uh, the water jumps over the, the banks, right? 10:47 And then, uh, you know, two or three days later, we deal with it, thanks to DEP, uh, and we move on. But these risks are so, uh, you know, they're continuing to grow, and the value of that risk is continuing to grow. 11:02 And that's something that we focus a lot on, is not only, you know, what is the risk, what is the value of that risk, and understanding that risk, and then what are the actual solutions to that risk. 11:12 So, um, that's something just to keep in perspective, right? A hundred billion dollars just in one part of the city. 11:19 Uh, the city of New York, the total budget, annual budget of a place like the city of New York is a hundred billion dollars a year, right? 11:25 So we don't actually have all that amount of cash sitting around trying to address this risk, right? 11:31 And governments alone certainly cannot and should not do it because these are all private assets, um, that, that we need to think about, um, and put money into. Yeah. 11:40 So it's a big sticker price, but also kind of highlights the opportunity. 11:43 And Nish, maybe I can turn to you and ask about how you consider the adaptation finance gap and kind of bouncing off what Maelis said about opportunity, how do you see opportunities in this space? Yeah. 11:54 From, from our standpoint, our, our opportunities in this space are, are pretty broad, right? 11:59 We're, we're looking at things related to obviously water tech and emissions reductions, uh, and, and ready to write substantial checks off of our balance sheet because our products are used, uh, in a variety of ways that can be kind of in some ways detrimental to the environment. 12:16 And so we're looking straight across the board at a number of these types of technologies, especially as it relates to emissions and kind of recyclability of our products. 12:25 That's kind of first and foremost for us right now. Okay. Next question is how we can unblock-Uh, private capital, uh, so that it can flow into adaptation and resilience. 12:36 There are multiple tools and technologies that can be used. Uh, and I wanna turn to Emily because I believe that you actually recently came out with something useful for driving capital into this space. 12:45 Would you like to tell us more about it? Thanks. Well, we'll-- we hope it's useful. So we just released a taxonomy for adaptation and resilience investment opportunities. 12:53 It's online at, uh, [chuckles] tailwindclimate.com/taxonomy. And what it does is that it breaks down the opportunity around a set of core sectors and themes. 13:03 So there's eight themes that are really tied to basic human needs, essentially. We're looking at food and water and shelter and health. 13:10 And in-- under each of those, we look at the economic sectors where there might be opportunity. 13:15 So the way we're gonna bring in, um, investments in adaptation from our standpoint is first by breaking it down into investable sectors and, uh, technologies. 13:25 So if you think about health, there are medical equipment, there are medication, there are diagnosis technologies. 13:31 There's gonna be a lot of opportunities that go beyond what people typically think of when they think climate. And each of those can have markets more or less mature, a lot of opportunities at different stage. 13:43 They may have existing ecosystem where the investors may not be thinking climate. So again, going back to health, but also agriculture. There's a lot going on there. 13:51 We haven't talked about ag tech to- much today because of the focus on, uh, the built environment, but that's also a key sector. 13:57 So really breaking it down into sectors, breaking it down into examples of digital technologies, uh, hard tech, products and services. 14:06 There's a lot of innovation around services that can support adaptation and resilience. And in each of those, it's an opportunity to dig deeper and find where the opportunities are. Wonderful. 14:16 Yes, I encourage you all to check out that taxonomy. Uh, Sonam, we were talking in the, 14:21 in the call to prepare for this about, uh, different players in the adaptation financing space, and you were saying that, uh, government has, is taking the r- big role on, but it's not all government. 14:29 So I was wondering if you could talk about, uh, other players in the space. Yeah. Uh, frankly, it shouldn't be all government, right? 14:34 [laughs] I just told you the budget of the city of New York cer- you know, c- certainly is, uh, you know, cannot handle something like this, right? 14:40 And that, uh, in New York City, the budget of the city of New York is equivalent to the budgets of, frankly, most countries, right? Hundred billion dollars is a lot of money. 14:47 So I think one of the things coming back to this is actually how can the private sector actually put money into this, right? And to be able to put money into this, there are lots of different tools at play. 14:58 Um, oftentimes, you know, when in, when we say the word investors, people kind of automatically assume sort of venture capital, right? And many of the folks sitting on this, uh, on this stage are, um, RVCs. 15:09 But the reality is that you need a multiple different types of, uh, fin- sources of capital to actually address this risk. 15:16 Uh, we look a lot, uh, particularly when we work with early stage founders, um, at, uh, grant dollars, right? 15:24 Uh, there's a lot of, quote-unquote, "free money" in climate, particularly from the IRA, the infrastructure bill, uh, philanthropic, uh, foundations putting money into this. 15:34 So how can you actually leverage some of those grant dollars, particularly for your early stage product development? Um, that reduces your need for venture capital. It reduces dilution, um, for you as a founder. 15:46 It relu- reduces dilution for us as early stage investors and the like. Um, there's also, uh, revenue-based financing, asset-based financing, particularly for hardware related startups. 15:58 Uh, there are often private lines of credit from family offices that are willing to give you a lower cost of debt to actually build your product, right? To bui- build that physical hardware. 16:07 Um, and so much of thinking about this stuff from an early stage startup's perspective is what is the right type of capital for the right part of my business and going out and leveraging those resources. 16:19 Um, and ultimately, that is what actually helps you get to the, you know, three trillion dollars of ci- finance, y- financing solutions sort of sitting on the sidelines looking for the investable opportunities that, you know, Emily was talking about. 16:32 Yes. It seems to me that there are piles of money around, but actually linking them to the right people and activities is, is the challenge here. 16:38 Um, and Nishu, we were talking earlier about some of the, the war stories you've had from, uh, climate tech one point O. 16:44 So I was wondering if you could talk about your experiences and sort of the, the, the model of the, a climate tech investor in the adaptation space today, and what lessons you've learned from previous experience. Yeah. 16:53 I think from our standpoint, we're looking at deep tech investments in this space, but we're also looking at helping these companies scale and providing engineering resources from our standpoint too. 17:03 We can't just provide them with capital and walk away. 17:06 So we do make sure that when we invest in a lot of our portfolio companies, we have the engineering resources, whether it be on the manufacturing side or any other external resources we can provide to help these companies really understand on how to scale their business and also attract other capital in the later stages. 17:26 Can I ask, are you choosing your spots more carefully with adaptation than you would with mitigation and, um, other decarbonization technologies? Is it, do you have to do more due diligence, et cetera? Yeah. 17:36 We, we bring in external resources to do more technical due diligence, whether they're, um, you know, industry experts in a particular area. 17:45 We hire these resources not only to help the startup to help, but also to help our due diligence and really understand is this technology actually needed in the market, and will people actually use it, as well as other corporates, not just Yama. 17:59 Wonderful. Thank you. Okay, I wanna talk about different channels of, of finance into the adaptation space. 18:06 Um, we talked a little bit about public-private money, so I wanna turn to actually Melis first and ask about different financial instruments that could be used to catalyze, [chuckles] catalyst capital, catalyze adaptation investments in Africa and elsewhere. 18:19 Sure. 18:19 Um, one of the, I guess, approaches that I think has really developed over the past five, well, decade or so is blended finance, which is often thrown around as a, you know, sort of blanket term for a lot of things. 18:34 But in essence, how do you combine public and private sector fundingIn financial instruments so that you unlock more capital by providing a de-risking mechanism within a fund itself to invest in either frontier markets that are therefore more risky or sectors that are more risky, um, uh, or, you know, nascent, frankly, innovation, right, that actually require more patience and more years to actually develop. 19:01 So for example, our fund, you know, ourselves, Catalyst Fund, is a blended finance structure. 19:05 We have three tiers, and we have a first loss tranche that allows us to offer to senior investors or private sector players a downward risk protection mechanism. 19:18 And so with that, we can say, look, thirty percent of our fund is covered by a development finance institution. Their mandate is to catalyze more private sector capital. 19:29 Therefore, if things go badly, there's protection, you're gonna get your money back first with a certain return. And then if things go well, everybody participates in the upside, and we're all happy. 19:39 But that has really helped us unlock private sector capital from either foundations, family offices, even high net worth individuals, ex tech founders, because of the mechanism. 19:50 And there's many other examples in Africa and elsewhere with similar structures. 19:54 Uh, say for example, the, um, uh, some, some of the Acumen funds that have funding from the, the Green Climate Fund, for example, which does this a lot at a global level, or the Terra Fund that does this to invest in very early stage SMEs for land restoration in Africa. 20:10 So typically an area that, you know, has not yielded a lot of returns or in the agriculture space where there's also a preconceived conception that there will be no returns. I, I disagree, but that's the reality. 20:22 And, um, and others even in, in real estate actually in Africa, like Acorn, Acorn for example, where they've actually leveraged, uh, bonds, like new kind of climate bonds issued by governments to finance some of the risk of investing in resilient urban infrastructure across Africa. 20:40 So that I think is super interesting. The other piece is, um, local capital markets. Like in Africa, local capital markets are quite undeveloped or, or nascent. 20:50 Um, you know, i-if you would look at the past ten years, there's actually been only ten exits in the whole climate tech space in Africa. All of them were energy companies, no IPOs. 21:02 So how do we mobilize pension funds, sovereign wealth funds? There's actually billions of assets sitting there. And how do we actually build that market in ways that we can unlock that financing is an interesting one. 21:14 And thirdly, I would say non-traditional financing mechanisms, so beyond public and private sector funding, but in finance and, and local markets, uh, what we're seeing is very innovative ways to think about carbon credit or carbon revenue for adaptation projects that actually have mitigation benefits. 21:34 So nearly half of our portfolio is now getting certified so that they can sell carbon credits, uh, either for, you know, uh, for example, uh, food waste avoidance or actual sort of carbon storage or land restoration type solutions, uh, in, in Morocco, for example, in the desert. 21:53 And all of that is new and unproven, but w-we're seeing that it's unlocking quite significant financing. 22:00 In some cases, one of our companies already has unlocked a million dollar in revenue in pre-purchase credit in Kenya. So yeah, I, I'm feel encouraged by these, these innovations. 22:11 Just to stay with you for one more second. 22:13 Um, I'm interested when you're out raising to public and private finance instit-institutions, do you have to change the story depending on your audience, or do you find the, the story you told about opportunities attracting both sides of the, of the coin there? 22:28 It does. I think, again, human brains are wired to think about opportunity and upside more so than we want to think about risk and losses. 22:38 But of course, you know, if you talk to a development finance institution, you would emphasize more the 22:45 development benefits, and of course, adaptation and development or economic growth are extremely intertwined, so the two go hand in hand. 22:53 And you-- when you talk to a private sector player, you would talk more about the opportunity for the technology scalability or, you know, the innovation with large as well as the benefits, right? 23:02 But I haven't seen the need to really alter the narrative depending on who I talk to. That's interesting. I just wondered, yes, if there were different stories being told. 23:10 Um, Sonam, I wanna talk about capital stack or capital Jenga tower, like where do you pick your spots and, and what's kind of missing in the capital stack at the moment? Yeah. 23:19 Um, in terms of where we sort of pick our, pick our battles and find our favorites, um, we look at sort of three things when we're evaluating companies. We look at, uh, feasibility, viability, and desirability. 23:31 So on the feasibility side is, you know, what is the technical risk of this product? Um, oftentimes we have very many founders who come to us with three pages on a deck. We are not your investor [laughs]. 23:42 There are tons of fantastic non-dilutive incubators and accelerators out there where you can actually go, um, and build your product, right? 23:52 And I very much so encourage folks who are founders in this room or starting to think about start-- or thinking about starting companies to access folks like Venture for Climate, Scale for Climate, Activate, you know, several others, um, around the ecosystem. 24:06 Uh, the second thing that we look at is viability, right? 24:09 So it's the unit economics, and I fundamentally believe that, you know, we live in a world where money matters, um, and if these companies are not wildly profitable, they're not gonna have the climate impact that we need, right? 24:22 They're frankly just not going to scale. And how do you become, uh, you know, wildly profitable? 24:27 You use a lot of these different sources of financing that Maylis was talking about, um, and that I was talking about earlier, right, in terms of grants, non-dilutive capital, uh, whatnot, right, to actually reduce your risk as a company at those earliest stages so that you can scale effectively. 24:43 Um, and then the third thing that we look at is desirability, right? Are there other human beings in the world who actually wanna pay for whatever it is that you're building? [laughs] Right? 24:50 And, um, and the answer to that needs to be a resounding yes, right? And we look for-Um, different types of, of, of folks, right? 25:01 In your go-to-market strategy, be they, uh, the private sector and/or a combination of, of government buyers. 25:07 Um, what is it that you are selling to them, um, and why do they want to buy your product versus the person next to you, right? 25:13 And I think the aspect of storytelling, it actually goes hand in hand with great product development. Um, and it's something that I think sometimes founders forget [laughs] um, because they're busy building. 25:25 Uh, but those are sort of the three things that we look at, right? And then combining all of that with a creative capital stack, uh, to help you scale and grow. 25:33 Um, one thing that we also do is we work-- uh, we partner with cities, with real estate developers, and with infrastructure groups, and that's sort of a hallmark of us, uh, at Streetlife. 25:43 So for example, we have a partnership with the Brooklyn Navy Yard here in New York. 25:48 Um, I don't know if any of you have been there, but it's a three hundred acre former shipbuilding facility that has turned into an advanced manufacturing hub, um, and one of the country's largest climate hubs. 25:59 And we work with them to test buildings and transportation and water-related technologies because they're kind of like a mini city in and of itself. 26:07 Um, they're an asset holder, so they themselves need to purchase a lot of these tools, but then they also are, uh, you know, a quasi-governmental agency. It's called a local development corporation. 26:18 Um, so they have very flexible procurement, and they can test a lot of these solutions, um, at the pre-commercial stage, make them viable for the broader private sector market to then, you know, come on and, and purchase these products, right? 26:33 They de-- they help de-risk those solutions and sort of we very much so play a big part in that. 26:38 So I think it's both the capital, but then a lot of it is also these willing players who are will-- you know, who are there to support the startups in those earliest phases of development, um, both on the software and testing the hardware. 26:52 Wonderful. Emily, do you wanna weigh in there? Yeah, briefly because, uh, Sonam and MeiLee's both covered a lot of ground, but I wanna double-click on two things. 26:59 Um, one thing is with all the grant money and government money that's available out there, almost none of it will be labeled adaptation and resilience, except for the FEMA stuff. 27:08 But otherwise, you have to be looking for the hook inside different sectors, and that's true of SBIR and other research money for small businesses. 27:16 There are things that are relevant out there, but you have to go look for them because they're not gonna be [laughs] labeled adaptation, and they're not gonna be necessarily where you expect them. 27:26 Um, the other thing, going back on what MeiLee said, and I wanna flag one of the key development in the market, what's gonna bring capital is the work that the Climate Bonds Initiative is doing, and Ujala is here in the room, where they are really setting up the standards to help cities and corporates issue bonds that are dedicated to adaptation and resilience investments. 27:45 And so the use of proceeds from those bonds is gonna be the money that's gonna buy the adaptation and resilience solutions. 27:52 And so we've seen how successful green bonds have been for climate mitigation and for sustainability. And so now we're gonna see that same growth when that, um, when those certification comes out at the end of the year. 28:04 Hi, Ujala [laughs]. That's gonna help unlock a lot of money that's eventually gonna, uh, come through, and that's the best kind of money. That's revenues. 28:14 Yes, there seems to be standards and processes in place for like institutional investors, but we kind of still need that pipeline of, of deals and products to actually finance in the first place to get to that mature stage, right? 28:23 Because we have two VC firms here, three V-VC firms here starting the early stage, but I feel like there's a missing middle. Uh, I'm not sure if that's right. Maybe the audience can correct me. 28:31 But Anish, ha-- I want to come to you and ask about how you see the capital stack and how it compares and contrasts with the climate mitigation ta- stack. 28:38 Yeah, I, I think we would be a middle investor of somebody in pro-- less on the early stage, more on the middle side. We want to see prototypes or systems built that we can test and validate. 28:50 We're less likely to invest in early stage kinda PowerPoint solutions or, or research papers. 28:56 So we actually wanna see something that's built and something we can actually help with from our standpoint and using our resources, not just, um, you know, really early where we have to help build out the management teams. 29:08 While that's great, uh, we like doing that, but, you know, we don't think in the, in the climate tech space that's probably a good use of our resources. 29:16 We're mostly focused on helping them fix issues with their systems or their prototypes 'cause we have such a broad array of suppliers that can also help us. Excellent. Okay, I have one last pre-planned question. 29:28 I do wanna throw questions out to the audience, so if you have any questions you'd like to ask the panel, get thinking. I-I'll get to you in, in just a minute. 29:36 But I hoped we could mix things up a bit here and talk about where there may be sectors in the adapt-adaptation and resilience world that are kind of not receiving enough investment and those areas that are receiving, receiving too much investment perhaps. 29:48 We had Tom and his team up here talking about, uh, water as a, as a focus, and I've definitely heard about water as a big focus, but I'm wondering if certain sectors are pulling focus away from others. 29:57 So Emily, actually, I'm gonna come to you again and ask about your thoughts here. Yeah. So I've talked about health. 30:01 I'm gonna come back to health because again, this is not a sector that we talk about a lot when we talk climate, and when it comes to adaptation, it is a very critical sector. It's a healthy ecosystem. 30:12 Health tech investors are not necessarily thinking about climate. That's a mild understatement. So there's a big gap, which means it's a big opportunity, and there's gonna be a lot of needs. 30:20 We've covered some of those in the, in the panels this morning around heat, around, uh, wildfire smoke and asthma, around vector-borne diseases, and this is where there's, uh, a sort of a mature industry that isn't seeing a problem. 30:34 Uh, another example, changing tack, is thinking about consumer wearables, uh, and that could be electronics, that could be textile, that could be things that help us deal with extreme heat. 30:44 And, and again, those are sectors where there's very healthy, active industries and investment communities and buyers and exits, but there's a customer need that is emerging and that hasn't necessarily been localized, and I know there's some wearable companies in the room. 30:59 Um, and then the built environment. We've talked about that. That's a nice one because you have a lot of co-benefits with mitigation, and of course, that means access to a lot more capital. 31:08 Uh, but as we saw this morning with Metalmark, there's some really great adaptation benefit that can come, and if we're not leveraging the mitigation money that's going right now into the built environment for adaptation, uh, benefits, then we're completely missing the mark.You three have seen the deal flow in different geographies, and I'm wondering, yes, maybe Sonam, you can tell me, are you seeing too much tech and data, not enough, like, hard wear? 31:30 Is that what, is that an issue? Um, the favorite top-topic of mine. So I think about sort of adaptation in three categories, right? One is understanding the risk, right? And a lot of that is so- is software, right? 31:41 It is, uh, where is the water going? Where is the highest risk, uh, risk of wildfire, et cetera, et cetera. Um, uh, companies that I really like in this space, Rhizome is one of our portfolio companies. 31:53 I'm gonna give a shout-out to them. Uh, they are a climate risk platform. They help, uh, utilities understand their risk and then optimize their infrastructure investments to address that risk. 32:04 Utilities, you know, every two to three years have to go to a public service commission. Uh, they have to get approval for their rate hikes, right? They have to get approval for their budgets. 32:14 That process takes a really long time because utilities have to hire consultants at, you know, two or three million dollars a pop to create a PDF report that somebody reads, what, you know, every two to three years and then gets put on the bookshelf. 32:26 Um, s- dynamic modeling tools like Rhizome and several others, um, in this space actually create products that utilities can use on a day-to-day basis to actually help drive those investments. 32:39 And just today, utilities are investing fifty billion dollars per year in infrastructure investments, right? 32:45 It's a huge amount of money, and that mon- and that number is only going to continue to grow because climate risks will continue to grow. Um, so that's, that's sort of f- the first category. 32:56 Um, that said, like, I don't need another software tool to tell me where it's gonna flood in New York City [laughs] right? 33:01 The w- the water has-- goes to the same places that it has gone to for the past three hundred years. It goes into the watershed. 33:09 Um, uh, I live in a neighborhood called Park Slope, and I live almost at the bottom of the slope, right? So, um, the one end of the street is just fine. And Tom's my neighbor [laughs]. 33:20 The other end of the street, uh, is, is flooded almost every single time it rains, right? And that's just how New York City was built. 33:29 What I do need is I need hardware so that actually I can do something about that, right? So that the water doesn't end up in people's basements. 33:37 Um, and I think that's where a huge amount of innovation is needed, uh, things like porous concrete solutions, right? And this is where both public and private sectors' dollars comes to play. 33:48 Uh, one of my favorite examples, there is a partnership, uh, with a nonprofit called The Trust for, uh, Public Lands, right? 33:55 And they actually work with the DEP to, uh, retrofit a lot of the New York City playgrounds and put c- porous concrete into those playgrounds so that the water can seep down into the groundwater resources. 34:07 Um, another example there is, uh, yeah, just a number of different porous concrete solutions that nowadays I actually see a lot of real estate developers using in their developments because they actually wanna protect their physical places-- spaces, right? 34:22 Uh, because that also demands higher values, um, for their property. And then the third piece of it is like, well, we're not solving any of this tomorrow, unfortunately, so what do we do in the here and now? 34:33 Um, and that is where I see solutions that help both, um, the general public, governments, private sector as, um, uh, players to actually address that, uh, that risk and create tools, um, to think about that. 34:48 So Julia, I See Change is, is a favorite of ours, right? 34:51 So peer-to-peer, um, programs where, you know, something is happening in my neighborhood, I can put that information down into the app, um, and a ping goes to the DEP so that they can actually address these issues, right? 35:05 So understanding the root cause of the, of the climate, um, risk at hand. Uh, there are a number of insurance platforms that we really like. Kettle, I don't know if Alex is in the room. 35:16 Uh, Floodbase we heard from earlier, helping folks, uh, sort of address the, the financial challenges and create financial resilience, um, around this problem. You seem to know everyone in the room, Sonam [laughs]. 35:29 A lot of friends. But I've, I've, uh, but, you know, I think many of us are probably veterans in this space- [laughs]... and it's frankly awesome to see so many more people coming- Mm... into this sector, right? 35:37 Because it's sorely needed. Mm-hmm. Mel, does Sonam's kind of categorization make sense to you, and how is it different in Africa? 35:44 Where, where's the investments going to, and, and where do you think, which areas do you think are underserviced at the moment? Yeah, it definitely makes sense and resonates, although the, the context is different. 35:53 So we, we think about climate adaptation solutions in three buckets as well, managing risks, adapting livelihoods in the short and medium term, and then building long-term resilience. And so we categorize the landscape. 36:05 We invest across sectors because we do believe there's opportunity across all sectors, even though they don't self-identify as climate adaptation, as you were saying. 36:13 And so we're seeing solutions, for example, in climate insurance, um, in early warning systems a little bit, a lot actually in climate-smart agriculture or agritech in all its forms, whether it's precision agriculture or data solutions for agriculture, uh, hardware solutions for agriculture, like soil sensors, for example, but also marketplaces that promote, um, regenerative agricultural practices, like amongst farmers, l- a bit of land restoration, and then on the, and then on the essential services bucket, we look at access to water, waste management in urban environments. 36:48 Think of, of the mega cities like Lagos, like Nairobi, like Cairo, and, and the impact that, you know, climate will have, or climate change will have in those contexts. 36:57 Uh, cooling and cold chain, um, and also health, because it's critical to think about health as a climate adaptation solution, especially in a place where vector-borne diseases, extreme heat are gonna have a huge impact, uh, on, on really the basic health of pretty much everybody. 37:14 So the-- we, we take this broad approach. That said, 37:18 most of the dollars, seventy-five percent of the dollars are going to energy and a little bit into water, and twenty-five percent into everything else [laughs].So now things are changing and, and we're seeing a bit more in cold chain. 37:30 We recently invested in a company in Kenya called Keep It Cool that provides, um, cold chain storage solutions for poultry and fish farmers to basically increase the shelf life of this produce to then go to market and, and, uh, to restaurants in Nairobi, 37:44 uh, where I spend most of my time. And, uh [laughs] so I know them very well because I go to their restaurants, yes. [laughs] Where they-- that they service. 37:52 And, uh, or a company in Morocco called Centagreen that's using low-cost modular desalination machines and agroforestry, so actually ancestral methodologies to turn deserts into arable land. 38:06 And so what, what's interesting is that, uh, a lot of them again had to do work to identify as climate adaptation. There's an opportunity for us at the early stage to deepen that angle with them 38:18 and, uh, to widen the array of innovations, you know, across all these sectors. Like, it's still very concentrated. I think we, we have to do more, like, to, to look beyond. 38:28 Um, but it's promising already to see that that's, that's increasing. That's fascinating. Seventy-five percent in water and- And energy... and energy. Wow. Okay. Yeah, we need to even that up a bit, little bit. 38:39 Okay, we have around five or so minutes left. I- I'm sure all of us put the drinks on ice, right? Great. So until then, any questions from the audience? I, I will, I will pick on people if they have... Ah, excellent. 38:50 We have one over there. And please introduce- Hello. Ah. Yes, there we go. Please introduce yourself as well. Yes. Hi. Um, Sadie from Anez. Thank-- I know some of you. Um, thank you so much for your work. Great panel. 39:05 Um, I just have a question about framing. So we are a, a early-stage startup that does climate risk in supply chains, and so we talk to climate... We talk to people in supply chains, and we're like, "Hey, we do climate." 39:17 And they're like, "Great, we love ammonia. We love green shipping quarters." And we're like, "No, we do physical risks and adaptation." And they blink at us, and they say, "What are you talking about?" 39:25 And we say, "Well, the Panama Canal is shutting down, and you're having to go all the way around, you know, the globe, and your carbon costs are skyrocketing, and your insurance premiums are going up." 39:32 And they're like, "Oh yeah, that's a huge problem for us. We'd love to talk more." Um, so you know, Emily, you mentioned framing around, like, the word adaptation, sure, but there's all these sectoral opportunities. 39:44 It's really a cross-cutting issue. Everyone across the entire world is going to have to deal with these issues. 39:49 So thoughts on when to frame as adaptation, the use of words like physical risk when you're early stage and trying to bring people in to change the investing paradigm, and just any thoughts on sort of like how, how we tell our story without over-indexing on our words as, like, climate people. 40:07 Yeah. So [laughs] thanks for the question and, uh, having run a climate data company before where I militantly kept saying it's climate even if you don't want me to call it that. I will say weather works pretty well too. 40:18 And so if you say weather risk to supply chain people, they're gonna go, "Oh my God." When if you say climate, they're like, "Oh, it's long term, and it's greening my supply chain," right? 40:26 So it can be very small framing changes, and it can be like in this audience, it's great to talk about adaptation and resilience and sort of put it in your back pocket and, and wear the [laughs] do as Romans do wherever you are, right? 40:39 It's like you have to fit in with the right terminology so that people will see you as one of them. And then you get-- you can get in as a, as a provider or as an investee. Any from the panel to add to that, by the way? 40:52 I, I would say just quickly that I've been analyzing investor calls for the big public traded companies, and it's interesting, very few use the words adapt, resilience. 40:59 A lot of them use like words like harden, strengthen, and they do talk about individual weather risks, right? So I do think there is this kind of like silo of, of, of hazards that's going on right now. Any questions? 41:10 We have one over here, the gentleman over here. Fantastic. Please, uh, let us know who you are and where you're coming from. Thank you. My name is Greg Pugli. I work for the United Nations. 41:23 I head the climate team in the office that coordinates disaster, uh, humanitarian response to disasters. 41:29 Um, and I just wanna pick up on this point about the gap in adaptation finance and ask about a particular group of countries which are at the very extreme end of that gap where humanitarian actors are working and normally working at quite large scale for a long time. 41:45 I mean context of fragility and conflict and, and violence, the Sudans, the Myanmars, the Afghanistans, the Yemens of the world. These are the places where people are most vulnerable to climate impacts. 41:56 They've contributed the least to the problem, uh, and where, as I mentioned, we often have had billions and billions of dollars of humanitarian assistance year over year. 42:06 So and these places receive the least climate adaptation finance. I'm speaking of the public sphere now. This is a problem we've identified in the climate finance architecture. These contexts are really at the tail end. 42:18 We were quite encouraged at COP28 last year that we started to recognize this as a problem. 42:24 There were a lot of commitments from public finance actors to find ways to overcome the obstacles to investing more into these contexts, and of course, we humanitarian actors can help with that. 42:34 But I wanna ask you about private capital, um, into these most difficult contexts. In Africa, uh, Myla, you mentioned Kenya and, uh, Nigeria and others, but what about the Sudans? What about the Somalias? 42:45 Can we do more to unlock private investments into these? Uh, Myla, do you wanna try and take that one actually? Yeah, absolutely. So I mean, you're right. There's certainly a public finance gap in those countries. 42:57 There's certainly a bigger private capital gap. Most funds, even those that are s- call themselves Pan-African funds, still concentrate in four major countries, Kenya, Nigeria, Egypt, and South Africa. 43:13 They've received the bulk of dollars. 43:15 And if you actually look at the total private sector financing that went to Africa in twenty twenty-three was three billion dollars, not even, two point eight billion dollars, whereas in the US in twenty twenty-three, the lowest year of VC financing on record-Was over three hundred and fifty billion dollars. 43:32 So, and then if we look at Sudan's or, you know, and other really fragile states, even Congo, you have zero point zero zero zero percent that goes there. 43:43 So I think, you know, one, one, uh, way of unlocking more private capital is for development finance institutions or, you know, agencies like the UN and others to foster these collaborations, I think, with the private sector and provide that de-risking mechanism for private sector players to go in and say, and actually, you know, think about, for example, how to facilitate exits. 44:07 Because I think that's, that's, for example, the issue with equity capital in some of these countries is that if, if this is gonna be a loss-making investment, there's too much risk, and so that min- you know, that risk factor prevents the investment from coming in. 44:19 So h- thinking about which structures can incentivize capital to go in, and then the other is actually try to work on local actors, like how do you develop, as I was saying earlier, the local, uh, investor base, local angel networks. 44:36 That's happening a little bit, uh, in Sudan, for example. I know of a few, uh, small scale accelerators that are starting or incubators, some angel communities, but it's still tiny. 44:47 So how do we actually use public dollars to finance those local, uh, private sector initiatives and, and build the private sector market so that then in the future there's less reliance also on external, um, external players. 45:03 Yes, there's a true need for capacity building. Uh, we do need all hands to the pump, or everybody needs to jump into the pool. Uh, thank you for your question. 45:10 I believe we are at time, and I pride myself on my punctuality, so I'd like to invite our audience to say thank you to our wonderful panel. [clapping] Climate Proofers is a Climate Proof media production. 45:24 It is produced and presented by me, Louis Woodall. 45:27 Subscribe to the Climate Proof newsletter by going to climateproof.news/subscribe, and to learn more about the publication, feel free to reach out directly using our LinkedIn page. Goodbye for now. [outro music]